D.C. No. 3:15-md-02670- JLS-MDD ORDER -- 1 of 7 -- 2 OLEAN WHOLESALE GROCERY COOP.… v. -- 5 of 7 -- 6 OLEAN WHOLESALE GROCERY COOP. V. BUMBLE BEE FOODS BUMBLE BEE FOODS LLC

FOR PUBLICATION
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
OLEAN W HOLESALE GROCERY
COOPERATIVE , I NC.; BEVERLY
YOUNGBLOOD ; PACIFIC GROSERVICE ,
I NC., DBA Pitco Foods; CAPITOL
HILL SUPERMARKET ; LOUISE ANN
DAVIS M ATTHEWS ; J AMES W ALNUM ;
COLIN M OORE ; J ENNIFER A. NELSON;
ELIZABETH DAVIS -BERG; LAURA
CHILDS ; NANCY STILLER; BONNIE
VANDERLAAN ; KRISTIN M ILLICAN ;
TREPCO I MPORTS AND
DISTRIBUTION, LTD.; J INKYOUNG
M OON; COREY NORRIS ; CLARISSA
SIMON; AMBER SARTORI ; NIGEL
W ARREN; A MY J OSEPH; M ICHAEL
J UETTEN; CARLA LOWN ; TRUYEN
TON -VUONG , AKA David Ton; A-1
DINER; DWAYNE KENNEDY ; RICK
M USGRAVE ; DUTCH VILLAGE
RESTAURANT ; LISA BURR; LARRY
DEMONACO; M ICHAEL BUFF ; ELLEN
PINTO ; ROBBY REED; BLAIR HYSNI ;
DENNIS YELVINGTON ; K ATHY
DURAND G ORE ; THOMAS E.
W ILLOUGHBY III; ROBERT FRAGOSO ;
SAMUEL SEIDENBURG; J ANELLE
ALBARELLO; M ICHAEL COFFEY;
J ASON W ILSON; J ADE CANTERBURY;
NAY ALIDAD; GALYNA
No. 19-56514
D.C. No.
3:15-md-02670-
JLS-MDD
ORDER

-- 1 of 7 --

2 O LEAN W HOLESALE G ROCERY COOP. V. BUMBLE BEE F OODS
ANDRUSYSHYN ; ROBERT BENJAMIN ;
BARBARA B UENNING ; D ANIELLE
GREENBERG ; SHERYL HALEY; LISA
HALL ; TYA HUGHES ; M ARISSA
J ACOBUS ; G ABRIELLE KURDT ; ERICA
PRUESS ; SETH SALENGER ; HAROLD
STAFFORD; CARL LESHER; SARAH
M ETIVIER SCHADT ; GREG STEARNS ;
KARREN FABIAN; M ELISSA
BOWMAN ; VIVEK DRAVID ; J ODY
COOPER; DANIELLE J OHNSON ;
HERBERT H. KLIEGERMAN; BETH
M ILLINER; LIZA M ILLINER; J EFFREY
POTVIN ; STEPHANIE GIPSON;
BARBARA L YBARGER; SCOTT A.
CALDWELL ; RAMON RUIZ ; THYME
CAFE & MARKET , INC.; HARVESTERS
ENTERPRISES , LLC; AFFILIATED
FOODS , I NC.; PIGGLY W IGGLY
ALABAMA D ISTRIBUTING CO., I NC.;
ELIZABETH TWITCHELL ; TINA
GRANT ; J OHN TRENT ; BRIAN LEVY;
LOUISE ADAMS ; M ARC BLUMSTEIN;
J ESSICA BREITBACH; SALLY
CRNKOVICH ; PAUL BERGER;
STERLING KING; EVELYN OLIVE ;
BARBARA B LUMSTEIN; M ARY
HUDSON; DIANA M EY; ASSOCIATED
GROCERS OF NEW ENGLAND , I NC.;
NORTH CENTRAL DISTRIBUTORS ,
LLC; CASHWA DISTRIBUTING CO. OF
KEARNEY, I NC.; URM S TORES , I NC.;
W ESTERN FAMILY FOODS , I NC.;
ASSOCIATED FOOD STORES , I NC.;

-- 2 of 7 --

O LEAN W HOLESALE G ROCERY COOP. V. BUMBLE BEE F OODS 3
GIANT EAGLE , I NC.; M CLANE
COMPANY , I NC.; M EADOWBROOK
M EAT COMPANY , I NC.; A SSOCIATED
GROCERS , I NC.; BILO HOLDING, LLC;
W INNDIXIE STORES , I NC .; J ANEY
M ACHIN ; DEBRA L. DAMSKE ; KEN
DUNLAP ; BARBARA E. O LSON ; J OHN
PEYCHAL ; VIRGINIA RAKIPI ; ADAM
BUEHRENS ; CASEY CHRISTENSEN;
SCOTT DENNIS ; BRIAN
DEPPERSCHMIDT ; AMY E.
W ATERMAN ; CENTRAL GROCERS ,
I NC.; ASSOCIATED GROCERS OF
FLORIDA, I NC.; BENJAMIN FOODS
LLC; ALBERTSONS COMPANIES LLC;
H.E. BUTT GROCERY C OMPANY ;
HYVEE , I NC.; THE KROGER CO.;
LESGO PERSONAL CHEF LLC; KATHY
VANGEMERT ; EDY YEE ; SUNDE
DANIELS ; CHRISTOPHER TODD;
PUBLIX SUPER M ARKETS , I NC.;
W AKEFERN FOOD C ORP .; ROBERT
SKAFF ; W EGMANS FOOD M ARKETS ,
I NC.; J ULIE W IESE ; M EIJER
DISTRIBUTION, I NC.; DANIEL
ZWIRLEIN ; M EIJER, I NC.; SUPERVALU
I NC.; J OHN GROSS & COMPANY;
SUPER STORE I NDUSTRIES ; W. LEE
FLOWERS & CO. I NC.; FAMILY
DOLLAR SERVICES , LLC; AMY
J ACKSON ; FAMILY DOLLAR STORES ,
I NC.; KATHERINE M CM AHON ;
DOLLAR TREE DISTRIBUTION , I NC.;
J ONATHAN RIZZO; GREENBRIER

-- 3 of 7 --

4 O LEAN W HOLESALE G ROCERY COOP. V. BUMBLE BEE F OODS
I NTERNATIONAL , I NC.; JOELYNA A.
SAN AGUSTIN ; ALEX LEE, I NC.;
REBECCA LEE SIMOENS ; BIG Y
FOODS , I NC.; DAVID TON ; KVAT
FOOD STORES , I NC., DBA FOOD
CITY; AFFILIATED FOODS M IDWEST
COOPERATIVE , I NC.; M ERCHANTS
DISTRIBUTORS , LLC; BROOKSHIRE
BROTHERS , I NC.; SCHNUCK
M ARKETS , I NC.; BROOKSHIRE
GROCERY C OMPANY ; K MART
CORPORATION ; CERTCO , I NC.;
RUSHIN G OLD , LLC, DBA The Gold
Rush; UNIFIED GROCERS , I NC.;
TARGET CORPORATION; SIMON-
HINDI , LLC; FAREWAY STORES , I NC.;
M ORAN F OODS , LLC, DBA Save-A-
Lot; W OODMAN ’ S FOOD M ARKET ,
I NC.; DOLLAR GENERAL
CORPORATION ; SAM ’ S EAST , I NC.;
DOLGENCORP , LLC; SAM ’ S W EST ,
I NC.; KRASDALE FOODS , I NC.;
W ALMART STORES EAST , LLC; CVS
PHARMACY , I NC.; W ALMART STORES
EAST , LP; BASHAS ’ I NC.; W AL -M ART
STORES TEXAS , LLC; M ARC
GLASSMAN , I NC.; W AL -M ART
STORES , I NC .; 99 CENTS ONLY
STORES ; J ESSICA BARTLING; AHOLD
U.S.A., I NC.; GAY BIRNBAUM ;
DELHAIZE AMERICA, LLC; SALLY
BREDBERG; ASSOCIATED
W HOLESALE GROCERS , I NC.; KIM
CRAIG; M AQUOKETA CARE CENTER;

-- 4 of 7 --

O LEAN W HOLESALE G ROCERY COOP. V. BUMBLE BEE F OODS 5
GLORIA EMERY; ERBERT &
GERBERT ’ S , I NC.; ANA G ABRIELA
FELIX GARCIA; J ANET MACHEN ;
J OHN FRICK; PAINTED PLATE
CATERING ; KATHLEEN GARNER;
ROBERT ETTEN; ANDREW GORMAN;
GROUCHO’ S DELI OF FIVE POINTS ,
LLC; EDGARDO G UTIERREZ ;
GROUCHO’ S DELI OF RALEIGH;
ZENDA J OHNSTON ; SANDEE ’ S
CATERING ; STEVEN KRATKY ;
CONFETTI ’ S I CE CREAM SHOPPE ;
KATHY LINGNOFSKI ; END PAYER
PLAINTIFFS ; LAURA M ONTOYA ;
KIRSTEN PECK; J OHN PELS ; VALERIE
PETERS ; ELIZABETH PERRON; AUDRA
RICKMAN; ERICA C. R ODRIGUEZ ,
Plaintiffs-Appellees,
and
J ESSICA DECKER; J OSEPH A.
LANGSTON ; SANDRA POWERS ;
GRAND SUPERCENTER, I NC.; THE
CHEROKEE NATION ; US FOODS , I NC.;
SYSCO CORPORATION ; G LADYS ,
LLC; SPARTANNASH COMPANY;
BRYAN ANTHONY REO,
Plaintiffs,
v.

-- 5 of 7 --

6 O LEAN W HOLESALE G ROCERY COOP. V. BUMBLE BEE F OODS
BUMBLE BEE FOODS LLC; STARKIST
CO.; DONGWON I NDUSTRIES CO.,
LTD.,
Defendants-Appellants,
and
KING OSCAR , I NC.; THAI UNION
FROZEN PRODUCTS PCL; DEL
M ONTE FOODS COMPANY ; TRI
M ARINE I NTERNATIONAL , I NC.;
DONGWON ENTERPRISES ; DEL
M ONTE CORP .; CHRISTOPHER D.
LISCHEWSKI ; LION CAPITAL
(AMERICAS ), I NC.; BIG CATCH
CAYMAN LP, AKA Lion/Big Catch
Cayman LP; FRANCIS T.
ENTERPRISES ; GLOWFISCH
HOSPITALITY; THAI UNION NORTH
AMERICA, I NC.,
Defendants.
Filed August 3, 2021
ORDER
THOMAS, Chief Judge:
Upon the vote of a majority of nonrecused active judges,
it is ordered that this case be reheard en banc pursuant to
Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 35(a) and Circuit
Rule 35-3. The three-judge panel opinion is vacated.

-- 6 of 7 --

O LEAN W HOLESALE G ROCERY COOP. V. BUMBLE BEE F OODS 7
Judges McKeown, Wardlaw, Berzon, Owens, Miller,
Collins, Bress, and Forrest did not participate in the
deliberations or vote in this case.

-- 7 of 7 --