Taewoo Kim v. Jump Trading, LLC

In the
United States Court of Appeals
For the Seventh Circuit
MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR
$@R69O5=:8R


A7*7"@AR
" $* )6&&"")AR
,2R

AAR#R AR
$$*)6&&""$*)@R
MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR
333 33 3333
3 33(33'3
'3$%3
3$&$#323
('3
MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR
54A646:Q 57A646:R
MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMR
$'R

ARAR#R
A7 (+ *7
+)@R

A7 (+ *7
+@R''RE''FR#R R
,'R '.%)$*''#(R $#R )R ''R !$ #AR ,R ,(R
"#R.R''$'"R(ARR#%$'#R$"%#.@R#! R
R # AR ,R "#)#(R #)'!/R '$'(R $R %$()$'(JR
!#(ARR!$ #R"%!$.(RR#)'!/R#),$' R$R
*('(R)$R+'.RR)'#()$#@R R,(RR)')$#!R'.%O
)$*''#.AR"*R! R)$#AR,$(R+!*R1*)*)R(R
$#R(*%%!.R#R"#@R''AR.R$#)'()AR,(R(*%%$(R)$R
RR()!$#AR,$(R+!*R,(R!# R)$R($"R$)'R(()Q

6R $@R69O5=:8R
$'R''AR)R@@R$!!'@RR''R$#R,(R(*%%$(R)$RR
,$')R>5@
$()R()!$#(R'!.R$#RR'('+R$R#$)'R(()R)$R"#O
)#R)'R+!*@RR$#R(RR!"R)$R>5R#R)R'('+(AR($R
)R()!$#R($*!RR,$')R>5@RE)R(AR)R($*!RR'O
"!R$'R>5R#R(()(AR(*R(R%$()(R)RR# @FR''AR
$,+'AR*(R#R')'R"#("R)$R"#)#R)(R+!*@R
#R!$')"R!!$,R$!'(R)$R$#+')RR''R$#R#)$R
R$!!'J(R,$')R$R R#R+R+'(@RE)'R)#R!O
))R)R-#R$R''R$'R AR)R!$')"R,$' R
.R()'$.#RR''R$#R#R"#)#R R)$R'%!R)R$'R
.R()'$.#R R#R"#)#RR''@FR#ARR)R"'O
)R%'R$R''R!#R!$,R>5AR')'*'(R$*!R*.R
)AR$#+')R)R''R#)$RR$!!'R$R AR#R(!!R)R AR
%'$0)#R'$"R)R(%'@R$R!$#R(R)(R(%'R,(R')'R
)#R)R$()R$R)'#AR#+()$'(R,$*!R*.R''R#R$#O
+')R)R)$R R$'R$#+')R''R).R!'.R$,#@R#R%'#O
%!AR)(R,$*!R'()$'R''J(R%'R)$R>5@
''$'"J(R')'R"#("R),R!R)$R %R)(R
+!*R)R>5@R$)R)"(AR''J(R%'R!#AR#R,!R#O
+()$'(R$!#R''R$*!R$#+')R)R)$R AR$'R+'$*(R
'($#(R)(R"R*#('!@R''$'"R,(R!R)$R($!+R
)R0'()R!#AR#R6465AR.R%'(*#R *"%R'#R)$R*.R
"!!$#(R$R''R$#(R#R-#R$'R$%)$#(R)$R*.R R
%!.@R *"%J(R%*'(R'()$'R)R%'R$R''R)$R>5@R*)R
#()R$R%'$!"#R *"%J(R'$!AR''$'"R%')#R))R
)R')'R"#("RR'()$'R''J(R%'@R$'O
#R)$R)R$"%!#)AR)R,(R)#R))R#+()$'(Q*#,'R$R
*"%J(R'$!R*'#R)R0'()R'((Q$*)R''AR)'*()#R)R
')'R"#("@R#R)R!R#AR#R6466AR''J(R
%'R$!!%(@R(R)"R *"%R#J)R#)'+#@R''$'"R
!)R!!R)'#R#R0!R$'R# '*%).@R$*)R>84R!!$#R
#R#$"#!R+!*R+#(@

$@R69O5=:8R7R
,$$R
"R$,#R''R$#(R,#R)'R+!*R%!*"O
")R#R6466@R
"R#RR%'$%$(R!((R$R#+()$'(R#R''R
(*R *"%R*#'R)R$""$)(R-#R)R#R)(R(O
($)R'*!)$#(AR(R,!!R(R*#'R)R$""$#R!,R$R*#O
*()R#'"#)@R
"R!!(R))R *"%R$#(%'R,)R'O
'$'"R )$R "#%*!)R )R %'R $R ''AR #AR #R ($R $#AR
$$!R"R#)$R)# #R))R''$'"J(R')'R"O
#("R!$#R$*!R"#)#R)(R&*+!#R,)R)R@@R$!O
!'@
"R$*!#J)R+R(*R''$'"R*(R)R#$.(R')(R
*#'R #R ')')$#R '"#)R ))R
"R (#R ,#R R
$#R)RK#$'R'$)$$!LQR%'$'"R))R!!$,R$!O
'(R$R''R)$R)'R)'R$#(R#R!#R)"R)$R$)'R*('(@R
R'"#)R%'$+(R))R
+,!3 33 !333333331
(3 3 (3 3 !3 3 3 3
.3 (3!33(33!33 3
333 3!3!3 3333(31
3)333*3!3 33 !3331
!3)/0*(333333"!33!31
3333 333333
33333)/30*'
*"%R'*(R))R
"R#J)R(*R)R)'R*(R)AR)$$AR#O
0)(R'$"R)R'"#)@R)R"$+R#R)R()')R$*')R)$R$"O
%!R')')$#@R)'R)RR($R*#'R=R@@@RN8R$'RN64:R(R
*#!'CR)R"$)$#R"#)$#(R#)'@R *"%R(.(R))R=@@@R
N646R$+'#(R)R')')$#R'"#)R),#R
"R#R'O
'$'"AR($R,R,!!R((*"R))RN64:R%%!(@R#R)R()')R
$*')R#R *"%J(R'&*()AR(R6469R@@R()@R
R<<<=<R
E @@R!!@R.R=AR6469FAR)R%%!R*#'R=R@@@RN5:EF@R
*"%R #$,!(R))R)R(R#$)RR%').R)$R)R'"#)R
),#R
"R#R''$'"@R#()AR)R(.(R))R)R$)'#R
$R&*)!R()$%%!R'&*'(R
"R)$R')')AR(#R
"R(R
(*#R *"%R $'R $#*)R #R ,R ''$'"R ,(R R $O$#O
(%')$'@R #R *"%J(R +,AR R !,(*)R #()R )R ,$*!R #.R

8R $@R69O5=:8R
''$'"R )R #0)R $R )R ')')$#R '"#)R *(R
*"%R".R(*R''$'"R$'R$#)'*)$#@R#R))R,$*!R
$'R ''$'"R )$R !))AR ')'R )#R ')')AR &*()$#(R
$*)R)(R"($#*)@R)R''$'"R#R)(R(*(($'R#R# O
'*%).R+R#)'R#)'+#R#$'R0!R#R"*(R'R)$R
(*%%$')R *"%Q*#'()#!.R($@RR'R)R$'R!"(R#R
)R# '*%).R(R%((AR#R''$'"J(R'"##R(()(R
'R!R#RR!&*)#R)'*()R'$"R,R *"%R##$)R#O
0)@R)R" (RR(*)R.R *"%R#()R''$'"R*#! !.@7
*"%R#$#)!((R$#)#(R))R#R')')$'AR')'R)#R
R$*')AR($*!RR)R((*R$R&*)!R()$%%!@R)R'(R
)R %$')$#R $R )R '"#)R '&*'#R ')')$#R $R K#.R
!"R$'R$#)'$+'(.R(R)$R')'!).LR)$R"#R))R,#O
+'R)'R(RR(%*)R,)'RR)'R%').R#R#$'R)R
'"#)AR))R(%*)R"*()RR')')@R#R)R%$#)(R)$R
!#*R'$"R)R*%'"R$*')J(R($#R#R%-)#7 ,27
$7 0(7.$%")37 $2AR97;R@@R;=RE6446FAR#R$*'R$,#R#R

$ R,27+)*(7& *"7%(&2AR:59R@7R;79RE;)R'@R6454FAR))R
)R)# (R$"%!(R)(R$#!*($#@R$)'AR)(R'*"#)(R
%'(#)R),$R&*()$#(BR0'()AR,$R(Q)R$*')R$'R#R'O
)')$'Q)R"')(R$R *"%J(R&*)!R()$%%!R'*"#)DR
#R($#ARRR$*')R(AR(R *"%R#))!R)$R')')R
#()R
"D7
')')$#R(R$#)')*!CRR$*')R#R$"%!R)R$#!.RR)R
%')(R +R 'R )$R ')')@R17 $%"% )37 $27 ,27
%##+$ * %$)7 %(!()AR8;9R@@R:87AR:8<P8=RE5=<:F@R')(R
#R'R)$R')')R(%*)(R$*)R')'!).AR,R( R
,)'R R (*()#)+R (%*)R ($*!R R ')')R $'R !)O
)@R
"R#R''$'"R'R)$R$R))R#R)R)'"(R$R
('+@R$'R-"%!AR).R,$*!R#R)$R')')RR(%*)R
$*)R,)'R
"J(R!"(RE)R($*'R$R)R(*()#)+R!O
!R(%*)FRK'(GHR$*)R$R$'R'!)GHR)$LR)R)'"(Q#ARR
).RAR
"R,$*!R#R)$R')')R)"@R *"%R(.(R))R

$@R69O5=:8R9R
#R')')$'R!($R"*()RR,)'R&*)!R()$%%!R'O
&*'(R
"R)$R')')R(R(*()#)+R!!R!"(R#()R)@R
)J(R*(AR#R)(R+,AR *"%J(R&*)!R)$'.R%'(#)(R
RK!"R$'R$#)'$+'(.R(R)$R')'!).L@RR%-)#AR97;R
@@R)R<8CR
$ AR:59R@7R)R;87@R
*)R$'R#R,)'R&*)!R()$%%!R(RR&*(O
)$#R$R')'!).AR,R"*()RR,)'R
"R#R *"%R
+R'R)$R')')R$.R&*()$#(@R')')$#R(RK()')!.R
R"3'R$R$#(#)ALR% $)37 $27,27+)! AR:46R@@R587AR58<R
E6468FRE))$#R$"3FARKR,.R)$R'($!+R)$(R(%*)(Q
*)R$#!.R)$(R(%*)(Q))R)R%')(R+R'R)$R(*O
")R)$R')')$#@LR @RE&*$)#R ()*7&* %$)7%7 %37 $27
,27 &"$AR958R@@R=7<AR=87RE5==9FF@RK$#(&*#)!.AR)R0'()R
&*()$#R#R#.R')')$#R(%*)R"*()RBR)R+R*)7
&(* )R'R)$DL7 @RE"%((RF@R
"R#R *"%RO
+#J)R'R)$R')')@R
"R#R''$'"R+AR($R *"%J(R
()R$%R$R')')#R)R((*R$R&*)!R()$%%!R,$*!R
R(RR)'O%').R#0'.R$R)'R'"#)@RR %(")6
%)7 ,27 +"*+("7 (37 $2AR 585R @8)R 745AR 74=P54R E5()R '@R
6469F@R)R)R$(R#$)R$#)#R))R)R()(0(R)R'&*'"#)(R
$R)(R$)'#@R
$R(R,)'R *"%R(R')(R*#'R))R'O
"#)DR)R"*()RRR$*')@R(R)R*%'"R$*')R-%!#R#R
$*66$*(37 )*37 $2R,27
!)%$AR 9:5R @@R :7AR ;5R E6454FAR
$*')(RR#$)R$#!.R,)'R%')(R+R'R)$R!O
)R &*()$#(R $R ')'!).R )$R #R ')')$'AR *)R !($R
,)'R#R.R,$"R#R'"#)R!)#R)(R&*(O
)$#(R#RR#$'@R#R$*66$*(R$#R$R)R%')(R'O
*R))R#R'"#)R)$R')')R(*()#)+R(%*)(R,(R
+$@RR *()(R!R))R#R')')$'R,$*!R#R)$RR
,)'R))R,(R)'*AR(#R)R%')(RR'R)$R'O
)')R&*()$#(R$R')'!).@R*)R)R,$*!R+R!!#R)$RR
$*')AR#$)R#R')')$'AR)$RR,)'R)R'"#)R)$R

:R $@R69O5=:8R
')')R&*()$#(R$R')'!).R,(R#$'!RR)R%'O
)(RR!!#R)RE')'R)#R)R'"#)R)$R')')R
(*()#)+R(%*)(F@R
*()R($R'@R
"R".R+R'R)$R')')R)R&*(O
)$#R,)'R)'R%')(R#R#$'R(R(*()#)+R')'O
)$#R '"#)R ,)R ''$'"@R *)R R $*')R "*()R R
,R )'R %')(R #R #$'R )R '"#)R )$R ')')R
K!"G(HR$'R$#)'$+'(G(HR(R)$R')'!).L@R)',(AR#O
.$#R$*!R#0)R'$"RR()'#'J(R'"#)R)$R')')R
)(R&*()$#(R,)$*)R+'R#RR%').R)$R)QR'(*!)R))R
)R$'#'.R!,R$R$#)')(R$(R#$)R!!$,@R#R)R'!R
')')$#R )R $(R #$)R K!+)R G'"#)(R )$R ')')R
&*()$#(R$R')'!).HR$+'R$)'R$'"(R$R$#)')@LR$*6
6$*(AR9:5R@@R)R;5@R
(R "#(R ))R *(AR #$)R #R ')')$'AR "*()R R
,)'R)R'"#)R),#R
"R#R''$'"R)$R'O
)')R')'!).R+(R')(R)$R *"%@R *"%R(.(R))R!#O
*R'&*'#R
"R)$R')')R!"(R(R$#R''$'"J(R
"($#*)Q$'R(R$#RK)(R$'R$"(($#(R$'R,R.$*R
G
"HR ".R $#)#R ))R ,R G''$'"HR 'R !!LQ+(R
')(R)$R$O$#(%')$'(R#R))R"($#*)AR*)R)R)-)R$"O
%!(R )R $%%$()R $#!*($#BR ))R
"R 'R )$R ')')R
,)R''$'"R$#!.@RR $7(7+*%#%* ,7(*)7$* *(+)*7 * 6
* %$AR=95R@7R7;;AR7<9RE:)R'@R6464FRE'$R($%R$R(O
%*)(R$+'R.R!)'!R')')$#R'"#)RR#$)R*(O
).R%%!.#R'"#)R)$R')')R')'!).R)$R)'R%'O
)(FCR(#(7,27%.%*7 %*%(7%(&2AR;49R@7R5566AR556;P6<RE=)R
'@R6457F@RR$#('R!($R)R*!)R'*!R#R())R!,R))RKR
#G#$)HR!"R')(R*#'RR$#)')R))R(R$#!.RR#RR
(R%')(@LR7 $*"" $*7 %"+* %$)7 $27 ,27 (*"7 $2AR7:R
@8)R;65AR;68RE;)R'@R6466FCR %(")6%)AR585R@8)R)R74=P
54@RR$#J)R(R#.)#R#R)R)-)R))R!)'(R)(R*!)@R
$R R *"%R #R
"R ! R #R '"#)R )$R ')')R

$@R69O5=:8R;R
')'!).AR#RR *"%R$(#J)R+R')(R)$R#$'R'O
'$'"J(R'"#)R,)R
"AR)#RR$*')R"*()R'($!+R)(R
'*"#)R$*)R&*)!R()$%%!@R
+#RR))R)R()')R*R,(R')R)$R#!./R
*"%J(R&*)!R()$%%!R'*"#)AR')'R)#R!+R)R)$R
)R')')$'AR,R#$,R'+,R'R($#R$#R)R"')(@RR
()')R*R%%!R!!#$(J(R+'($#R$R&*)!R()$%%!AR
0##AR$'')!.R#R$*'R+,AR))R!!#$(R$*')(R$'!$(R(O
)$%%!R*#!((R)R)'R%').R(R'($#!.R'!R$#R)R$#O
)')R%'$+#R$'R')')$#@R(, $7,27%! 37 $2AR78=R!!@R%%@R
7R94<AR958P5:RE6448FCR(R!($R+$%7 $*($* %$"7 $27,27
$)+7
+$%7% "(7%237*2AR $@R69O6695RE;)R'@FRE((*R$#)"%$O
'#$*(!.F@R $R$#R(*()(R))R%%#R'@R
*)R,(R)R()')R*R$'')R)$R%%!.R!!#$(R!,DR
*"%R'*(R))R%)'R6R$R)R'!R')')$#R)AR=R
@@@RNNR645P4<Q,R"%!"#)(R)R$#+#)$#R$#R)R
$#)$#R#R#$'"#)R$R$'#R')'!R,'(RE)R
,R$' R$#+#)$#FQ%'$+(R)R%%!!R!,R$R&*O
)!R()$%%!@R%)'R6R(R(!#)R$*)R,)'R)'R%')(R
#R #$'R ')')$#R '"#)(@R )!!AR *"%R '*(R ))R
%)'R6R*)$'/(R'!R$*')(R)$R+!$%R)'R$,#R!,R
$R&*)!R()$%%!@R(R()#(R#R$#)'()R)$R%)'R5AR
,R*((R)R'*!(R$R&*)!R()$%%!R'$"R())R!,@R(6
*+(7$()$77,27(" )"AR99:R@@R:68AR:74P75RE644=F@R
R)R()')R*AR,R$*)R))R%)'R6R$+'#(R
)(R(%*)@R)R,$*!R$+'#RR(%*)R),#R
"R#R'O
'$'"R $*)R )R #$'!).R $R )'R '"#)R )$R 'O
)')AR$'R''$'"R(R#$)RR)/#R$R)R#)R))(RE!)O
$*R *"%R(F@RR=R@@@RN646@R*)R$'R)R("R'($#(R
,R())R)$R$%)R *"%J(R-%#(+R'#R$R)R,$'R
K')'!).LAR,R())R#$,R)$R(.R))R%)'R6R)'O
"#(R *"%J(R')(R(RR)'R%').@R#'R *"%J(R+,AR#.R

<R $@R69O5=:8R
##)AR("%!.R.R((')#R')(R)$R#$'R#R')')$#R
'"#)RK'(#R$*)R$RR!!R'!)$#(%LR),#RR)O
/#R$R)R#)R))(R#RR$'#R$#AR,$*!RR#))!R
)$R+R)R!,R$R%)'R6RR(R')(R)$R#$'R)R
'"#)R(RR)'R%').AR#$R"3'R$,R'"$)R)R!)#)R
(R'$"R)R$#)')R%'$+#R$'R')')$#@R *"%J(R'#R
,$*!R!!$,R#R#)).R)$R#0)R'$"R#R')')$#R'O
"#)J(R())*(R*#'R%)'R6R$'R#R,)'R)R(R
(*)R )$R ))R '"#)R )R !!@R )AR (R )R ()')R *R
%)!.R%*)R)AR,$*!R%*)R)R')R$'R)R$'(@R
R!($R+R('$*(R$*)(R$*)R *"%J(R(*()$#R))R
7 $(.7 %-(7 %$,() %$7 ($7 37 %(&27 ,27 +*%!+#&+7
* $"))737AR9=4R@@R876RE6464FAR%'")(R'!R$*')(R
)$R+!$%RR$""$#R!,R$R&*)!R()$%%!R,)R'(%)R
)$R$#)')(R$+'#R.R%)'R6@R'R)R *()(R!R
))R#$)#R#R)R())*)R%'+#)(R'!R$*')(R'$"R%%!.O
#R K$"()LR $)'#(R $R &*)!R ()$%%!R )$R ((R #O
+$!+#R)(R$#)')(@R#R)R#)R))(AR)R%'+!#R
K$"()LR$)'#(R$R&*)!R()$%%!R'R$*#R#R())R
!,@R(*+(7$()$7)!!(R*(R))R%)'R5R$R)R'!R'O
)')$#R)R $%(&%(*)7())R$)'#(R$R&*)!R()$%%!AR
$+)#R)R#R$'R'!R'*!(@R99:R@@R)R:74P75@RR7
$(.7)(R))R%)'R6R"#)(R)R%%!)$#R$R$O
"()R$)'#(R$R&*)!R()$%%!AR#R())R!,R%'$+(R
)$(R$)'#(Q#!*#R,)R'(%)R)$R')')$#R'O
"#)(Q)#R )'R ($*!#J)R R #.R #R )$R ')R '!R
$)'#(R$R&*)!R()$%%!@RR!($R)) ((7 ,27 .))$6
%($# )/7%""* %$7%+$* %$AR9=:R@@R54;AR55:P5;RE6466F@R
)R*(R%*)R)(RR2'#)R,.@R'!R$*')(R')R$O
)'#(R$R'!R!,R,#R#(('.R)$R($!+R(%*)(R'(#R
*#'R'!R())*)(@R$'R-"%!AR)R"%!$.R)'"#)R
#$"R*').R)REFR'&*'(R%!#(JR(%$#($'(R)$R %R
)R%'$"((R).R" R)$R,$' '(R#R,!'O#0)R%!#(@R

$@R69O5=:8R=R
(R'*!R#RR#$'R$#!.R.R%%!.#R$)'#(R$R$#O
)')R !,Q,AR #R (#)R '$"R AR '!R $*')(R
"*()R$%)@R+#R)#AR$,+'AR)R'!R$)'#(R'RO
($'R'$"R())R!,R')'R)#R#R')R$*)R$R,$!R
!$)@RAR@@AR 17 %".#()7 37 7 ,27 !0AR9;8R@@R
86;RE6459F@RR!($R7 $+)*( "7227,27)AR9<7R@@R577AR
579P7:RE645<FRE%%!.#RK$'#'.R%'#%!(R$R$#)')R!,LR
)$R #)'%')R $!!)+O'##R '"#)(R $+'#R .R
'!R!$'R!,F@R%)'R6R$R)R'!R')')$#R)AR
,R$(R#$)R(.R$#R,$'R$*)R()$%%!AR$(R#$)R#R
$"%!)$#R)'$*R'!R$""$#R!,@R
)R%)'R6R$(R(.R(R))R%)'R5R$+'#(R,)R
'(%)R)$R!!R(*)(R#$)R$+'R#R%)'R6R$'R)R ,R
$' R$#+#)$#@R=R@@@RN64<@R()$%%!R(R$#R$R)$(R(*O
)(R $"3R '$"R %)'R 6Q*)AR %'R(*+(7 $()$AR (R
$+'R#R%)'R5R)'$*R)R#$'%$')$#R$R())R!,@R
)R$!!$,(R))R())R!,R$#)'$!(R(%*)(R$*)R()$%%!R*#O
'R%)'R6R(R,!!@R
R'$#/R))R$*'R'*)(R+R!R))R'!R$"O
"$#R!,R%'$+(R)R'*!R$R&*)!R()$%%!R$'R'O
"#)(R$+'#R.R%)'R6@R0.7,27( $ ,)7+$".7
AR7R@8)R55::RE=)R'@R6465FC7 $*($7 227 ,27 ( $AR788R
@7R578AR587P88RE5()R'@R6447FCR# *5$(%$7%$(* %$7 #6
*7 (*$() &37 $27 ,27 # *7 %$(* %$7 $*($* %$"37 $@AR
5=<R @7R <<AR =:R E6R '@R 5===FCR $*($* %$"7 &(7 %27 ,27
- ))$7 ) $$717$"$7 AR64:R@7R855AR85;R
#@8RE8)R'@R6444F@RR0)R$!(AR)$R)R$#)''.AR))R())R!,R
%%!(@R $*%$7 ,27 $ $7 (%(7 $)+($7 %@AR5:5R@8)R6<6AR
6<;P<<RE9)R'@R6469FAR%))$#R$'R')$''R%##AR $@R69P
57<7@R
R'R,)R $*%$R#RR))AR+#RR,R,'R)$R'O
)R R '!R '*!R $R &*)!R ()$%%!AR ,R ,$*!R )R )R

54R $@R69O5=:8R
'!R'*!R'$"R())R!,@R(R)R*%'"R$*')R!R#R
$ *7**)7,27 #""7%%)37 $2AR)R!,R$R)R$'*"R())R
(*%%!(R)R'!R'*!R*#!((R)'R(RR#R$'R*#$'").R
$'R%%!.#R())R!,R,$*!R'*()')R'!R#)'()(@R884R
@@R;59AR;6<P6=RE5=;=FCR(R!($R$ *7**)7,27(%-$7'+ &6
#$*7%(&2AR<:R@7R;44AR;4:P4;RE;)R'@R5==:FRE0##R'*!R$R
'!R$""$#R!,R$'R"(*'#R"(R)$R'!R%'$%O
').R.R''#R)$R$'*"R())J(R!,FCR)*7,27%+ ), ""7)717
"*( 7%2AR=95R@7R<6;AR<76RE;)R'@R6464FRE#)'%')#RO
'!R())*)R2)#R("#)(R.R!$$ #R)$R$'*"R())J(R
!,R$R%'$%').FCR5=R')AR!!'R?R$$%'AR("7(* 7
$7 (%+(RN895<RE7R@R646:FREKR*%'"R$*')R(R
%*)R#'(#R"%((R$#R)R#$)$#R))R,#R)'"##R
)R$#)#)R$R'!R$""$#R!,AR$'*"R())R!,R($*!RR
$%)R(R'!R!,R(#)R($"R$$R'($#R)$R(%!R
)LF@R
R(*+(7$()$7'&*'(R*(R)$R#$'R')')$#R'O
"#)(R*#'R%)'R5R$R)R'!R')')$#R)R! R#.R
$)'R$#)')BR$'#R)$R'*!(R$R())R!,@R)R$(R#$)R%'O
('R *#$'").@R .R ($*!R ,R )')R '"#)(R *#'R
%)'R6R2'#)!.DR%)'R6R$+'(R'"#)(R),#R
@@R#R$'#R)/#(AR*)R))R($*!#J)R" RR2'#@R
#)'#)$#!R')')$#R'"#)(R".R$#)#R$O$O
!,R!*((AR,R($*!RR$#$'AR*)R'*"#)(R'$"R
$*)(R)R)-)R$R#R'"#)RE(R *"%J(R(FR%'(*"%)+!.R
'()R$#R)R!,R$R)R$'*"R())@R%&)7,27%#&%7%" $)37
$2AR5:4R@8)R<59AR<68RE;)R'@R6469F@R))*)(R$'R)')(R".R
'&*'R#)$#!R*#$'").AR*)R *"%R$(R#$)R%$#)R)$R#.@R
R0.AR7R@8)R)R55:=P;:REAR @AR((#)#FRE)#R7$6
(.F@R
*%%$(R))R,R,'R)$R')RR*#$'"R'!R'*!R$R
&*)!R()$%%!@RR,$*!R()!!R#R)$R)'"#R,)'R
)R%%!(R$+'R'*!(R$R$)'R$*#)'(R))R+R(#R)R

$@R69O5=:8R55R
,R$' R$#+#)$#@R)R *"%R$(R#$)R(*((R)R!,R$R
#%$'AR''$'"J(R$"R#)$#AR)$*R)R,$*!R+R(R
')RR!"R(R$(R$""$#R!,R#R)R#)R))(@R $'R
$(R *"%R( R*(R)$R!$$ R)$R)R!,R$R)R*'$%#R#$#AR
#AR-$AR %#AR$'R$)'R)'#R%')#'(R#R$'"#R
R$.R$R$""$#R!,@R
R)'R,'R(*RR)#R(RR'!R$""$#R!,R*#'R
%)'R6AR,R,$*!R#R)$R0#R)(R$#)#)@R#R,R+R
#R)$R')R*#$'"R'*!(R#R)R%()Q(R#R((R#)'O
%')#R%!#(R*#'RQ,R+R+!$%R)"R'$"R
K$'#'.LR$'RK#'!LR%'#%!(R$R$#)')R!,@R 17%"6
.#()AR9;8R@@R)R879CR%!7,27%#&+*(7))% *)7 $*($* %$"37
$2AR69;R@7R;44AR;48P49RE;)R'@R6445F@R *"%J(R%'$%$(R'*!R
,$*!R!!$,R)'R%')(R)$R')')R!"(R))R!!R$#)R
"($#*)R.R)R#R)R(#)$'.R)$R#R')')$#R'O
"#)@RR 7"(7(, 7%(&27,27($!" $AR5;;R@7R=86AR=8;R
E55)R'@R5===F@R(R'*!R$(R#$)R("RK$'#'.LR)$R*(@R)R
,$*!R!!$,R)'R%')(R)$R( R#0)(R'$"RR$#)')R$'R
,R#)'R%').R#$))AR%'+#R
"R$R)R#0)R
$R(R'#R,)R''$'"@RR5
$'AR "" )*%$7 %$7 %$6
*(*)RN5B5RE8)R@R646:FREKR$!R$R$#)')R!,R(R)$R$!R
%')(R)$R)'R'"#)(R($R))R).R'+R)R#0)(R$R
)'R'#(@LF)R".R" R(#(R)$R%%!.R&*)!R()$%O
%!R,#RR%').R)$RR$#)')R$(R($")#R)$R" RR)'R
%').R)# RR(R$*#R)$R)Q$'R-"%!ARR
"R(*R *"%R
$'R'#R)R)'"(R$R('+@RR7$(.AR9=4R@@R)R
87;RE&*$)#R65
$'AR "" )*%$7%$7%$*(*)RN9;B5=R)R644RE8)R
@R645;FF@R*)R
"R(#J)R((')#RR$#)')*!R')R#()R
*"%R#AR(R'R(R,R#R)!!AR#+'RR#.)#R)$R" R
*"%R)# R)R,(R$*#R)$R)R)'"(@R$%)#R *"%J(R'*!R
")R!($R()*'R-()#R$""'!R'!)$#(CR%')(R)$RO
!)'!R')')$#R'"#)(R,$*!RR!)R,$#'#R,R
)'R%')(AR%$((!.R*# #$,#R)$R)"AR$*!R#$'R)'R

56R $@R69O5=:8R
')')$#R'"#)(R#()RR%$((!R!,(*)@RR #""7
%%)AR884R@@R)R;6<P6=@R
*"%R'!(R$#R$(-( *()7*7"%.4)7,27(%$+*7 $)+($7
%@AR944R@7R9;5RE;)R'@R644;FAR,R*(RR'*!R',#R'$"R
'!R !,R $+'R $#R '$"R !$'#R !,R ,#R #R
,)'RR"#R)$R')')R,(R)"!.@R)R($#R$(R
#$)R$#'#R()$%%!Q#R)R%'(R(*+(7$()$AR,R
)$!R*(R)$R)R'*!(R$R()$%%!R'$"R())R!,@RR%#!R'!R
$#RR(*%%$(R#R$'R#)$#!R*#$'").R))R)R*%'"R
$*')R')R),$R.'(R!)'@R*(R)R%')R(*+(7$6
()$AR)R%#!R#R(%$+*R!($RR#$)R$#('R)R2)R
$R=R@@@RN64<AR,R''(R R)$R%)'R5R)$R#!R*#O
%'$+O$'R((@R)+'R$'7(%$+*R".R+RR!"O
)R)$R)"#R&*()$#(AR)R##$)RR-)#R)$R*().R)R
')$#R$R'!R$""$#R!,R$*)R()$%%!@R
'R(#J)R#.R'!R#)'()R))R$"%!(R*(R)$R')R
'!R$""$#R!,@RR$"R$*')(R+R*()0R)'R#+#O
)$#R$R&*)!R()$%%!R$)'#(R(R#(('.R)$R"%!"#)R
R '!R #)'()R #R #$*'#R ')')$#@R AR @@AR 7
"(7 (, AR5;;R@7R)R=8;@R*)R %($7 ,27 +$$37 $2AR
9=:R@@R855AR85;P5=RE6466FAR)!!(R*(R)R$%%$()BR))R)'R
(#J)RR'!R#)'()R#R%'$"$)#R')')$#@RR$!R$R
)R'!R())*)R(R#$'"#)R$R$#)')(AR#$)#R"$'@R
(R!(R*(R R)$R!!#$(J(R$)'#R$R&*)!R()$%O
%!AR,R'&*'(R'($#!R'!#R.R)R%').R#+$ #R
)R')')$#R'"#)@R*(R *"%R$(#J)R$#)#R))R
)R'!R$#R'%'(#))$#(R.R
"AR)R##$)R*(R&*)!R(O
)$%%!R)$R#$'R)R')')$#R'"#)R#()R"@R$R
*"%R"*()R!))@R

R