People v. Potter CA2/8

CourtListener 9999875Calctapp11.07.2024

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 7/11/24 P. v. Potter CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

THE PEOPLE, B319107

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. MA077627)
v.

CHRISTOPHER POTTER,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County. Daviann L. Mitchell, Judge. Affirmed in
part, reversed in part, and remanded with directions.
William P. Melcher, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan S. Pithey, Assistant Attorney
General, Shezad H. Thakor, Jason Tran, and Kristen J. Inberg,
Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________________
Christopher Arland Potter appeals from his judgment of
conviction for count 1, conspiracy to commit murder (Pen. Code,1
§§ 187, subd. (a), 182), and count 2, first degree attempted
murder (§§ 187, subd. (a), 664). The jury also found true each
count was committed to benefit, promote, further, and assist a
criminal street gang (§ 186.22, subd. (b)(1)(C)) and the offenses
were committed in state prison (§ 1170.1, subd. (c)).
Potter makes various challenges to his conviction. First,
Potter asserts the trial court improperly limited his cross-
examination and impeachment of the prosecution’s primary gang
expert and investigator regarding a complaint lodged by the gang
leader against the expert. Second, he argues the trial court
erroneously admitted a hearsay statement that the gang’s leader
ordered the murder of a former member of the gang. Third, he
argues the trial court improperly limited his cross-examination of
that former member’s motivation for participating in another
murder, specifically, whether the attack was financially
motivated and conducted for reasons unrelated to the gang,
which resulted in the former member’s expulsion from the gang.
Fourth, Potter argues the evidence was insufficient to support the
jury’s true finding on the gang enhancement because the
predicate offenses no longer met the amended requirements
under Assembly Bill No. 333 (2021–2022 Reg. Sess.) (AB 333).
Fifth, he argues the trial court improperly erred in applying a 10-
year enhancement for the gang enhancement under section
186.22, subdivision (b)(1).

1 All further undesignated statutory references are to the
Penal Code.

2
On his first two challenges, we find any error was harmless
beyond a reasonable doubt as the evidence of Potter’s guilt was
overwhelming. With respect to his third argument—whether the
trial court erred in limiting his cross-examination of the former
gang member—we find the trial court properly exercised its
discretion as Potter’s counsel lacked a good faith belief to further
question him about any alternative motivation for attacking
another inmate. Regarding his fourth and fifth challenges to the
sufficiency of the evidence in support of the jury’s true finding on
the gang allegations, we agree with Potter.
For these reasons, we affirm in part and reverse in part the
judgment, and remand with directions.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Prosecution evidence
A. The Northern Riders
Maurice Vasquez founded the Northern Riders in 1999 and
is the gang’s current leader. “Northern” has since been dropped
from the gang’s name, and the gang is now known as the
“Riders.” While the Riders primarily operate in facilities within
the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation
(CDCR) system, they are considered a street gang. The Riders’
primary criminal activities are pimping, illegal drug sales,
robbery, assault, and battery. Members identify themselves
using the terms “Compa,” “Compadre,” “Riders,” and “Rider” and
have adopted the Playboy Bunny logo as a symbol.
Vasquez is known as the “Playboy President.” He
established the Riders by breaking from the Nuestra Familia,
a Northern California Hispanic street gang, operating within
CDCR’s general population. Vasquez recruited other individuals,

3
who no longer wanted to be governed by the rules and regulations
established by the Nuestra Familia.
CDCR segregates Riders from its general population
inmates by placing them on sensitive needs yards (SNY’s), which
are used to segregate individuals who have dropped out of
general population gangs. Although SNY’s are not supposed to
contain active gang members, SNY gangs, such as the Riders, are
eventually formed with general population gang dropouts.
A “Riders compound” is a CDCR facility that houses Riders, and
conforms to the Riders’ rules and regulations.
Vasquez drafted a document known as the “Compadre
Concepts and Objectives” (CCO’s), which describes the Riders’
history, structure, and rules. The CCO’s prohibit any kind of
split within the Riders, stating “ ‘at no time will there ever be a
divide within the Rider movement.’ ” Indeed, forming a splinter
faction is considered a blatant violation of the CCO’s and
punishment for doing so includes murder.
Alexander “Scrappy” Diaz, a former Rider and the victim in
this case, formed such a splinter faction known as the Nuestra
Compas. The Nuestra Compas is now known as the Nuestra
Cosas. It was well known amongst Riders and within Riders
compounds that Diaz betrayed Vasquez in forming the Nuestra
Cosas.
Various documents related to the Riders were found in
Vasquez’s cell. One document titled, “A Missive Concerning
Current [E]xisting Issues On The Compounds,” and signed
“[L]oyally Committed To The Prosperity Of The Rider Movement,
The Playboy President,” was entered into evidence and it
contained the following excerpts.

4
“There will never be a divide within the Rider movement.
We have a zero tolerance policy towards actions concerning
subsets, subgroups or offsets of our movement. Recently in [Kern
Valley State Prison] there was some nonsense transpiring where
compas were identifying themselves as FAS, going as far as
tattooing it on them. I sent a personal emphasis to them to cease
such controversial behavior and provide one warning for them to
cover any tattoos of that crap or it would be fucken cut off of
them. The compas delivering the warning were committed to
executing extreme violence upon any individual who chose to
disregard the compadres commands to terminate such
contradictory behavior. The compas who were involved in the
shenanigans all immediately obliged. We shall never condone,
tolerate, accept, nor support contrary behavior.”
“If any entity puts us in a position where we feel
challenged, we declare war, plan, prepare and execute the attack
wherein we will slaughter our target. That’s the Rider way of
warfare.”
Another document was titled “An Epistle Pertaining To The
Prosperity of The R.I.D.E.R. Movement” dated December 31,
2016, and was signed by Vasquez as “ ‘The Playboy President.’ ”
The following excerpts were read to the jury.
“The infestation of imposters running around like a bunch
of lowlife, lawless hooligans were practicing and promoting false
propaganda. They were convincing the imposters to believe—to
believe we’re the Northern Riders. Yet, [were] just some made-up
gibberish that was falsely fabricated and filtered by [the] lawless
little homosexual snitch named Alexander Diaz. . . . [¶] . . . [¶] —
who also goes by the several aliases such as Scrappy Diaz, Tiny,
Shorty, and Midget. The little jailhouse schmuck first came to

5
[CDCR] in 2011 from [the California Youth Authority] and was in
Tehachapi in IYP . . . until he turned 18 and was sent to
[CDCR]’s first SNY in Mule Creek in 2001. [¶] He paroled in
2003, and shortly after was charged with murder of a 15-year-old
kid wherein he testified against all his co-defendants from Varrio
Meadow Fair in San Jose. [¶] The little faggot has never stepped
foot on the mainline and has absolutely nothing to do with
founding the Rider movement. What he is responsible for,
however, is promoting contradictory behavior under the shield
. . . [¶] . . . [¶] —of the glorious Rider movement. He is
responsible for all the contrary conduct that was occurring in the
PC yards from 2001–2003. While the certified compadres were
on the mainlines of [Pleasant Valley State Prison] . . . a yard,
Susanville-Lassen yard, Corcoran 3B, and [High Desert State
Prison] . . . D yard. [¶] . . . [¶] Guarding and protecting our
territory at the time.”
“Now mind you, the reason for CDCR’s attempt to validate
the Rider movement as a prison gang was not . . . as a result of
what [Vasquez] and his playboys were doing in 2004, but due to
the secret code word . . . . [¶] . . . [¶] Malicious malarkey that
faggot Scrappy and her homosexual homegirls were doing on the
PC yards. Safe out of . . . harm’s way. The first and only time
[Vasquez] ever encountered this little prison punk was in Ad Seg
law library wherein he instructed . . . [Diaz] to sign off his SNY
chrono so he could transfer to High Desert.”
“That little queer Scrappy went to Tehachapi where he
infiltrated as a buster and got his dumb-ass validated as a
structure associate which is why he had to debrief in the
[Transitional Housing Unit] in [Kern Valley State Prison].
[¶] . . . [¶] Unbeknownst to [Vasquez], he was never going to

6
finally pulverize this little pussy as he has been eagerly
anticipating due to Scrappy having his 812.[2] [¶] . . . [¶]
[Vasquez] was made aware of this while in [Kern Valley State
Prison] Ad Seg for demolishing some pcs on D yard with some of
his compadres. The reason I’m even elaborating on this . . . is
due it to being essentially to defining a . . . line of clarification by
emphasizing that anyone who has been . . . deceived to believe
this little rat was in any way whatsoever involved in any of what
transpired during the tremendous tenacity it took to conquer and
surmount the arduous obstacles that were constantly
encountered during the introduction of the Rider movement to
the prison system. You have your calculation profoundly
miscalculated.”
Another document found in Vasquez’s cell was a purported
“hit list.” The list contained the names of numerous inmates,
their location, and inmate number. Diaz was on the list.
B. Potter
Potter is a member of the Riders and is one of Vasquez’s 18
“disciples.” Potter is known as “Blanco” and is considered the
“son” or “godson” of Vasquez. Potter was the only known Rider
who could countermand Vasquez’s orders.
C. The conspiracy to murder Diaz
On April 2, 2019, Diaz was transferred to Corcoran State
Prison (Corcoran). At the time, Potter was housed at Corcoran
with other Riders, including Michael Kons, Andres Cordova,

2 An “812” is a CDCR form that is filled out by inmates to
notify prison officials when another prisoner is their enemy. If an
inmate lists another inmate on an 812 form, those inmates are
not supposed to be housed together.

7
Anthony Bojorquez, and Witness Number Five. Witness Number
Five later testified under an immunity agreement with the
prosecution.
When Diaz arrived at Corcoran, Potter received a “wila” or
“one-time,” from another inmate, who delivered it on behalf of
Diaz. A “wila” or a “one-time” is an inmate-authored note that is
delivered from prison to prison. The note contained a money
order from Vasquez to Diaz and a phone number for Potter to call
to make sure Diaz was approved to be on the Corcoran yard with
the Riders.
On April 10, 2019, Potter called Michelle Bravo, Vasquez’s
“secretary.” Gangs operating within a CDCR facility may use a
“female facilitator” or “secretary” to assist them in conducting
criminal activity and to communicate with inmates at other
CDCR facilities. The call was recorded and played for the jury.
The conversation proceeded as follows:
“Potter: Alright. I’m good. Have you talked to [Vasquez]?
“Bravo: I’m waiting on his call . . . it should be kinda [sic]
between now and the week.
“Potter: Ok. And you got everything that I told you last
time down?
“Bravo: Yeah. Yeah I did. S[o] um, do you have any word
on [Diaz]?
“Potter: He’s right here.
“Bravo: Okay, so what’s goin [sic] on with that?
“Potter: That’s what I need to know. Ok. Listen, I got a
one-time and that’s how I got your number so all that got
squashed. It’s all good for him from what I know. That’s why
I’ve been waiting. You know what I’m saying? [¶] . . . [¶] So,
whoever, so, but it’s, that’s all squashed. It’s a stand down. And

8
uh, he’s right here. He’s on orientation. He came with a couple
things for me. That’s, you know what I’m saying?
“Bravo: Yeah. So it’s proved then?
“Potter: Huh?
“Bravo: It’s been proven? It’s been proven then that he’s.
“Potter: Absolutely. I know, I know, I know his writing.
Right? [Vasquez]? I know his writing. And it’s his. It even had
something in there for me. Had this number. Every other, every
other thing that I had. Yeah, and it’s . . . . And, a lot of other
people were like ‘Ok’ but I had to tell them that’s it. That he did
that. That’s it. There’s no . . . you can’t, you can’t, there’s
nothing else you can do about it, you know what I’m saying?
“Bravo: Ok. So is everybody getting on board with that?
Because I spoke to. . . .
“Potter: It doesn’t matter. That doesn’t matter though.
That doesn’t matter. He did that.
“Bravo: No, I mean, do they know? Do they know?
Because he’s asking if they know?
“Potter: Right here? Right here?
“Bravo: Yeah.
“Potter: Everybody, a couple of people at first like
ehhh . . . but everybody’s on board, and uh, it’s alright.
Everything’s good. You know what I’m saying? There isn’t
really, there isn’t really nothing that nobody can say. Because
when he said he had something for . . . when he had said . . . from
him. I said let me see it? And I already knew the writing. And
it’s like . . . and then it had something for me in there. And
that’s . . . you know what I’m saying?”
On May 8, 2019, Vasquez called Bravo from Lancaster
State Prison. During the call, Bravo informed Vasquez she had

9
spoken to Potter, who had confirmed his receipt of the note from
[Diaz]. Bravo told Vasquez, “Everybody is kinda [sic]upset
because I’m like [Diaz] is good, [Diaz] is saying he’s good. [¶] . . .
[¶] And so is [Potter]. [Potter] is saying yeah, he said I’m here on
the yard with him right now, he’s with me, it’s good.” Vasquez
responded, “No, not at all . . . . Tell them that they need to
understand to disregard that, disregard that. Tell them if it’s not
coming from me directly, disregard that. Tell them what the fuck
are they thinking?”
Vasquez then asked Bravo to call Potter’s secretary, Abigail
“Chula” Valencia while he remained on the phone. The following
colloquy took place:
“Vasquez: Tell them I said, they should know better.
“Bravo: Ok.
“Vasquez: Don’t you ever assume that, that would ever
happen.
“Bravo: Ok.
“Vasquez: Tell them that would never happen. Ok?
“Bravo: What would never happen?
“Vasquez: That bitch Alexis, that bitch Alexis being ok.[3]
“Bravo: Ok, ok.
“Vasquez: She is not cool.
“Bravo: Ok.
“Vasquez: She’s in the exact same predicament as she’s
always been.
“Bravo: Ok perfect, perfect.
“Vasquez: Ok listen to me that was all nonsense. They
need to disregard any of that. Let look it listen to me, let Chula’s

3 Alexis refers to Diaz.

10
dude know, this is very important baby. Let Chula’s dude know,
let Chula’s dude know that his Pops, his Pops said.
“Bravo: Yes?
“Vasquez: His Pops said that, that chick Alexis.
“Bravo: Yeah.
“Vasquez: That bitch has, that bitch has a stay away
order.”
“Vasquez: Hey Chula.
“Bravo: She’s on the phone.
“Vasquez: Very very low, . . . speak up Chula. I can’t even
fuckin hear her.
“Bravo: Chula can you speak up?
“Valencia: I can hear him.
“Bravo: Ok what do you want me to tell her?
“Vasquez: Ok tell her that her dudes dad.
“Bravo: Ok her dude’s dad, yeah.
“Vasquez: Tell her, . . . her dude’s dad said that that
[fuckin’] chick Alexis cannot be on the fuckin property. She can’t
be on the property.
“Bravo: Did you hear that Chula?
“Vasquez: Did she hear me?
“Valencia: No.
“Bravo: Ok he’s saying that, that chick Alexis cannot be on
the same property as your dude. Could you tell him that?
“Valencia: Ok, he’s [on] C Status right now.
“Vasquez: Ok listen to me.
“Bravo: He’s on C Status.
“Vasquez: What?
“Bravo: He’s on C status right now.
“Vasquez: Ok well, does he call her?

11
“Bravo: Does he call you?
“Valencia: No he don’t, but he has people call me.
“Bravo: No he has people call her.
“Vasquez: Ok listen to me, who does he have call her?
“Bravo: Ok, who does he have call you?
“Valencia: I don’t know he has cellies.
“Bravo: His celly? Does he give you a name?
“Vasquez: Ok well listen, whenever he, whoever calls him,
whoever calls her, needs to understand that bitch Alexis cannot
be [¶] . . . [¶] on that property.
“Bravo: Ok could you tell him that Chula?
“Valencia: Yeah I can.
“Bravo: Ok thank you.
“Vasquez: Look it, at all, tell him he should [fuckin’] know
that.
“Bravo: Ok.
“Vasquez: Tell him he should know that. Tell her to tell
him she should fuckin know that.
“Bravo: Shit ok so I’m going to call.
“Vasquez: He should know that.
“Bravo: Primo so you could tell him that.
“Vasquez: Ok listen.
“Bravo: Yeah.
“Vasquez: Do you have Primo’s [girl’s] number?
“Bravo: No but I have.
“Vasquez: Huh babe?”
Bravo then called Joshua “Primo” Simmons while Vasquez
remained on the line.4

4 Simmons was an active member of the Riders at the time.

12
“Bravo: I have his hold on, can you hear anything is the
phone ringing?
“Vasquez: Who’s this? Yeah who is this?
“Bravo: I’m calling Primo. Ok.
“Vasquez: Where’s Primo at, same area?
“Simmons: Hello?
“Vasquez: Same area?
“Bravo: Primo’s right here can you hear him?
“Vasquez: Hey Primo. Primo?
“Simmons: Hey who’s this?
“Vasquez: Hey what’s up playboy? Ok listen to me this is
very important I only got a couple minutes nigga. Listen to me.
“Simmons: Who is this?
“Vasquez: Playboy.
“Simmons: Who is this?
“Bravo: The author, the author.
“Vasquez: Nigga you know who this is nigga, listen to me
playboy listen to me nigga. Mother fuckers cannot be that damn
goofy to believe that that bitch Alexis is allowed to be stepping on
the mother fucking property nigga. Are mother fuckers really
that stupid? Are mother fuckers really that stupid?
“Simmons: Well look it, look it I already know that ok but I
was told something different ok.
“Vasquez: I know but listen to me.
“Simmons: Wait a second.
“Vasquez: Ok listen never, never, never, never. Listen you
know Blanco’s dad right?
“Simmons: Right.
“Vasquez: Blanco’s pops, you know Blanco’s pops? Blanco’s
pops?

13
“Simmons: Yeah.
“Vasquez: Ok Blanco’s pops said to disregard everything
that that [h]o is talking about. That bitch can’t be over there
working at the club bruh. Aren’t mother fuckers smarter than
that? That bitch can’t go over there with no recommendation to
work at the club nigga. That’s all game that was all game
playboy. Mother fuckers are out of their minds. Don’t they
realize that that was all game nigga? You got to be kidding me.
That bitch can’t work there. Every nigga, listen to me that club
will, listen to me this is very important that club will lose their
license if that bitch is anywhere on that property bruh.
“Simmons: I’m already knowing. I’m already knowing. I’ll
take care of it.
“Vasquez: You know what’s crazy?
“Simmons: I’ll make sure it’s taken care of by the end of.
“Vasquez: Ok look it.
“Bravo: It’ll be taken care of.
“Vasquez: In the thing, in that book listen to me nigga in
that book it says that her circumstances are still the same. Her
circumstances have not changed nigga. Mother fuckers got to get
their shit together, niggas are out of their fuckin mind playboy,
[they’re] out of their mind.
“Bravo: But.
“Vasquez: [They’re] out of their mind.
“Bravo: The son.
“Vasquez: Tell them niggas I said step their fucking game
up. Step their fucking game up.”
On May 8, 2019, Potter, Witness Number Five, and
Bojorquez called Vasquez with a contraband cell phone from
Potter’s cell. Vasquez told Witness Number Five, “ ‘It’s time to

14
shine and time to take care of business and see how loyal you are
to me.’ ” Witness Number Five responded, “ ‘Okay. I will do what
I got to do’ ” and “ ‘I’m always loyal to you, compadre.’ ” Witness
Number Five understood Vasquez’s statement as an order to
attack Diaz.
On May 9, 2019, Potter, Kons, Witness Number Five, and
Cordova met in the yard for a “Compadre Committee.” Potter led
the others in a discussion of how they would attack Diaz.
Bojorquez and Cordova were assigned to help Witness Number
Five assault Diaz on the yard. Witness Number Five’s
instructions were to “stomp [Diaz] out and kill him” or at least
cause great bodily injury if possible.
D. The attempted murder
On May 10, 2019, the day of the attack, Witness Number
Five was working out with Diaz on the yard. Diaz showed
Witness Number Five an inmate-manufactured wood knife that
Diaz secreted on his person.
After working out with Diaz, Witness Number Five went
back to his cell. About 45 minutes later, Bojorquez came to
Witness Number Five’s cell and said Potter wanted him back on
the yard. Witness Number Five went back outside to the yard
where he met with Potter, Kons, Bojorquez, Cordova, and two
other Riders. Potter said it was time to assault Diaz. The group
discussed how they were going to attack Diaz, somebody was
going to stab him and the others would “finish him.” Although it
was originally planned that Witness Number Five would stab
Diaz, Bojorquez volunteered to stab Diaz, stating “ ‘I’ll do it,’ ”
and “ ‘I stab him, and you guys assault him after I’m done.’ ”
The group then went their separate ways with Witness Number

15
Five and Bojorquez moving closer to Diaz, who was still on the
yard working out.
After two other inmates started fighting, Potter gave
Witness Number Five the “ ‘go ahead’ ” signal to attack Diaz.
As Diaz was looking towards the direction of the fight, Bojorquez
approached him from behind and stabbed Diaz in the back and at
the base of his skull and neck. After Bojorquez stabbed Diaz,
Witness Number Five started fighting with Diaz. As they fought,
Witness Number Five fell to the ground and Diaz stabbed him
three times in the back. Diaz said, “fuck Riders,” “fuck Snoop,”
“I’m an N.C.,” and “I’m going to kill you.” Cordova joined the
fight to help Witness Number Five. Kons then ran towards the
fight from across the yard and punched Diaz, dropping Diaz to
the ground. Witness Number Five, Kons, and Cordova proceeded
to kick Diaz while he was down. The fight continued until Potter,
who was lying prone nearby, told them to “get down.”
Correctional Sergeant Jose Garcia witnessed the attack on
Diaz. He testified that two inmates began fighting in another
area of the yard just before the attack on Diaz. Cordova ran to
assist the inmate fighting Diaz and began punching Diaz. Kons
then ran across the yard and began attacking Diaz as well. Diaz
fell to the ground and the other inmates continued to punch him.
CDCR investigators responded to the scene. When they
arrived, Diaz’s attackers were handcuffed and lying prone on the
ground. The investigators found a wood knife underneath
Cordova that was consistent with the wounds sustained by
Witness Number Five, Cordova, and Kons. As Diaz was being
treated for stab wounds, the investigators noted his injuries were
different in nature from those suffered by his attackers and were
consistent with a thin metal weapon like an icepick. Based on

16
the different injuries, investigators opined that the wood knife
belonged to Diaz.
Two days after the attack on Diaz, Potter told Witness
Number Five, “That bitch got what she got coming.”
On June 8, 2019, Bojorquez called Bravo. A recording of
the call was played for the jury. During the call, Bojorquez
relayed the following message from Potter to Vasquez: “[H]ello
it’s his son. I can’t call myself due to loss of phone, but I got a
very important message for him, and others who are part of the
Company. I got the message for Chula. He got the message from
Chula. Everything went absolutely perfect, Alexis got a ride out
of here in a helicopter.” Generally, in prison, when someone gets
a “ ‘ride out of here in a helicopter’ ” it indicates that person
suffered such severe or life-threatening injuries that they needed
to be transported to a medical facility via helicopter.
In a recorded call between Potter and Valencia, Potter
asked her if she spoke with Vasquez. When Valencia indicated
she had not, Potter said, “[J]ust let [Vasquez] know that guy is
taken care of. That old boy got flighted out in helicopter ok.”
During the trial, Cordova and Vasquez were in lockup
together. Cordova asked Vasquez for permission to lie to the
court and jury, explaining he would take the responsibility for the
crime to protect the Riders, specifically, Potter and Kons.
Vasquez responded: “Yes. Absolutely, playboy. Go in there. Let
them know the [C]ompas had nothing to do with it, that it was
you. You can’t be harmed anyway. You already took a deal. Let
them know that the knife that was found underneath you was not
yours. Make sure you let the jury know that. That was not
yours, playboy. Let them know that you asked for fingerprints.

17
Where’s the knife that was supposedly this bitch Alexis was
stabbed with? Where is it at? That wasn’t the knife.”
II. Defense Evidence
Vasquez testified for the defense. When Vasquez entered
prison in 1996, he was a member of the Norteños, a subgroup of
the Nuestra Familia. In 1999, after Vasquez was released from
custody, he formed the Riders as an alternative to prisons gangs.
There are several hundred Riders in CDCR custody while there
are several thousand in the streets. The Riders use the Playboy
Bunny as their symbol.
Vasquez is the “Playboy President,” and author of the
CCO’s. When someone wants to join the Riders, that individual
must go through an “embracement process.” Once the individual
is certified, the member becomes a “disciple.” Riders conduct
business by holding a “Playboy Committee,” composed of Riders
in good standing. A Riders motto is: “We never abandon our
fellow Compadre in time of battle.” This means, if a Riders
member is being overwhelmed in a fight, other Riders must assist
him in breaking up or joining the fight.
Vasquez met Diaz in 2004. Diaz was a Rider until he was
kicked out of the gang when it was discovered he killed a child
during a robbery. Diaz then formed the Nuestra Cosas. In May
2019, Diaz was in bad standing with the Riders.
Vasquez used Bravo to deliver messages. He admitted
telling her to relay the message to Potter that Diaz could not be
on the Corcoran yard.
While Vasquez had referred to Potter as his “son” in the
past, Potter was no longer a Rider as of May 2019.
Kons also testified for the defense. When Kons entered
prison in 2001, he was a member of the Northern Crips. Kons

18
joined the Riders in 2015 after he was transferred to a SNY.
Kons did not view Vasquez as the gang’s leader, but as a mentor,
who had a “strong voice” within the Riders.
Kons was transferred to Corcoran in 2016. Kons was
confused when Diaz arrived at Corcoran, seemingly with
Vasquez’s permission to be on the yard with the other Riders
because Kons knew that Diaz was from a different gang.
Although the Riders at Corcoran argued over whether the note
received by Potter was authentic, they ultimately decided the
note was from Vasquez, and Diaz would be left alone.
On the day of the attack, Kons saw Cordova running
toward a fight between Witness Number Five and Diaz. Upon
seeing that Witness Number Five was losing the fight, Kons ran
towards them to break it up. Kons thought Diaz might have a
knife because Cordova looked scared. After being stabbed by
Diaz several times, Kons “dropped” Diaz with a couple of
punches. Kons only saw a knife after the fight was over when the
investigators recovered the wood knife beneath Cordova.
Kons never knew Potter as a Rider because Potter was
“pushed out” of the gang “a long time ago.” Kons believed Potter
was forced out of the Riders after he was “jumped on in another
yard by Riders and told to keep the movement out of his mouth.”
Former Corrections Captain and Correctional Counselor
William Adams testified for the defense. Adams had investigated
numerous gang attacks and murders involving knives. Adams
testified it was common to see fist fights between inmates, and
that inmate fights are not necessarily planned. However,
typically when one gang member is involved in a fight, other
members of that gang are expected to assist.

19
If a prison gang conspires to murder an inmate, a common
scheme is to greet the victim by hugging him so that other gang
members can stab him with inmate-manufactured weapons.
This will generally occur in a “blind spot” on the yard where
prison staff have limited visibility.
Adams was familiar with the Riders and their conflicts
with general population gangs, as well as their presence on
SNY’s. Adams opined that at the time of the attack on Diaz,
Kons was an active member of the Riders, however, he was
unable to confirm whether Potter was an active member at the
time.
III. Jury Verdict and sentencing
An amended information charged Potter and Kons with
conspiracy to commit murder (count 1; §§ 182, subd. (a)(1), 187)
and attempted murder (count 2; §§ 187, subd. (a), 664).5
It further alleged both counts were committed in state prison
(§ 1170.1, subd. (c)), and were for the benefit of, at the direction
of, and in association with a criminal street gang (§ 186.22, subd.
(b)(1)(C)). The information alleged Potter suffered a prior strike
and serious felony conviction. (§§ 1170.12 and 667, subd. (a).)
A jury convicted Potter of conspiracy to commit murder,
and attempted willful, deliberate, premeditated murder, and
found the gang and prison allegations true. Kons was acquitted
on all charges. In a bifurcated proceeding, Potter admitted the
prior conviction allegation.
The trial court struck the prior serious felony
enhancement, but declined to strike the prior strike conviction or

5 The original information also charged Vasquez, Bravo,
Simmons, Cordova, Valencia, and others.

20
the gang enhancement. It sentenced Potter to 60 years to life on
count 1, composed of 25 years to life, doubled to 50 years to life
pursuant to the Three Strikes law, plus 10 years for the gang
allegation. On count 2, the trial court sentenced Potter to life
with a minimum parole eligibility date of 15 years under
section 186.22, subdivision (b)(5). The trial court stayed the
sentence on count 2 under section 654.
Potter appealed.
DISCUSSION
I. Whether the trial court improperly precluded
testimony regarding the prosecution’s gang expert’s
bias against Vasquez
Potter argues the trial court improperly limited his cross-
examination of Luis Chavez, the prosecution’s primary gang
expert and investigator, on whether Chavez’s opinions and
investigation of the Riders were motivated by animus towards
Vasquez. Potter argues this evidence was highly relevant as
Chavez’s testimony was integral to the prosecution’s case, and
the trial court’s limitation on his cross-examination violated
Potter’s Confrontation Clause rights and constituted prejudicial
error.
A. Additional background
As the prosecution’s primary gang expert and investigator,
Chavez offered various opinions on the Riders and assisted the
jury in interpreting the various documents and recorded phone
calls related to the Riders and the conspiracy to murder Diaz.
To impeach Chavez, Potter sought to cross-examine Chavez about
the circumstances of a complaint filed by Vasquez against Chavez
for violating CDCR policy.

21
The circumstances of the CDCR complaint involved the
seizure and search of a contraband cell phone in Vasquez’s
possession. According to defense counsel, after searching the cell
phone’s contents, Chavez found nude pictures of Vasquez’s wife
on the cell phone and made derogatory comments about her.
Chavez also found nude photos of his own girlfriend on the cell
phone. Nevertheless, after confiscating the cell phone, Chavez
offered Vasquez the use of a landline phone, which was a
violation of CDCR policy. Vasquez filed a formal complaint
against Chavez for the violation, as well as for the derogatory
comments regarding Vasquez’s wife. The complaint was not
sustained.
In seeking to question Chavez about the complaint, Potter
argued the testimony tended to show Chavez’s bias and motive to
lie about Vasquez and regarding the Riders more generally.
Potter’s counsel sought to question Chavez about when he began
investigating and working towards becoming an expert on the
Riders. According to defense counsel, if Chavez began
investigating the Riders after the complaint, it could show
Chavez was motivated to investigate the Riders for personal
reasons rather than his duties as a CDCR investigator. The
prosecutor argued Chavez’s motive to investigate the Riders was
not relevant to the veracity of his testimony or the evidence he
discovered.
The trial court excluded the matter under Evidence Code
section 352, finding the testimony tangential and speculative,
and requiring an undue consumption of time. The trial court
stated: “I find this tangential. It has to do with [Chavez’s]
relationship with Vasquez and not [Potter and Kons], and there
[were] no sustained complaints. He did not get disciplined; so

22
you can’t say he’s angry because he got disciplined. You don’t
know the details of it. And the fact that he’s having an affair
with another woman is irrelevant. If he had been disciplined and
you can argue that, you know, that will be a motive for him to lie.
[¶] But, frankly, it’s not about Vasquez. Vasquez is simply a
witness the defense has brought. It’s about [Potter and Kons],
and there’s no bias that appears to be . . . individual[ ] against
these two [defendants].” The trial court further explained, by
Potter’s counsel’s own admission, he had already thoroughly
impeached Chavez. Thus, the probative value of any further
impeachment did not greatly outweigh the prejudice.
B. Governing law and standard of review
Cross-examination may be used to elicit evidence of a
witness’s bias or prejudice. (People v. Carpenter (1999)
21 Cal.4th 1016, 1054.) “ ‘Cross-examination is the principal
means by which the believability of a witness and the truth of his
testimony are tested. Subject always to the broad discretion of a
trial judge to preclude repetitive and unduly harassing
interrogation, the cross-examiner is not only permitted to delve
into the witness’ story to test the witness’ perceptions and
memory, but the cross-examiner has traditionally been allowed to
impeach, i.e., discredit, the witness,’ including by ‘cross-
examination directed toward revealing possible biases,
prejudices, or ulterior motives of the witness.’ [Citation.] ‘The
partiality of a witness is subject to exploration at trial, and is
“always relevant as discrediting the witness and affecting the
weight of his testimony.” ’ ” (People v. Villa (2020) 55
Cal.App.5th 1042, 1050–1051, quoting Davis v. Alaska (1974)
415 U.S. 308, 316, italics omitted.)

23
“[A] criminal defendant states a violation of the
Confrontation Clause by showing that he was prohibited from
engaging in otherwise appropriate cross-examination designed to
show a prototypical form of bias on the part of the witness, and
thereby ‘to expose to the jury the facts from which
jurors . . . could appropriately draw inferences relating to the
reliability of the witness.’ ” (Delaware v. Van Arsdall (1986)
475 U.S. 673, 680 (Van Arsdall).)
“Trial judges retain ‘wide latitude insofar as the
Confrontation Clause is concerned to impose reasonable limits on
such cross-examination based on concerns about, among other
things, harassment, prejudice, confusion of the issues, the
witness’ safety, or interrogation that is repetitive or only
marginally relevant.’ [Citations.] A trial court’s ruling to admit
or exclude evidence offered for impeachment is reviewed for
abuse of discretion and will be upheld unless the trial court
‘exercised its discretion in an arbitrary, capricious, or patently
absurd manner that resulted in a manifest miscarriage of
justice.’ ” (People v. Ledesma (2006) 39 Cal.4th 641, 705.)
We review the trial court’s decision to admit or exclude
evidence for harmless error. (People v. Snow (2003) 30 Cal.4th
43, 90; People v. Watson (1956) 46 Cal.2d 818, 836 (Watson).)
We will only find an error prejudicial if, after an examination of
the entire record, we conclude it is “reasonably probable that a
result more favorable to the appealing party would have been
reached in the absence of the error.” (Watson, at p. 836.)
However, Confrontation Clause errors are subject to the higher
standard articulated in Chapman v. California (1967) 386 U.S.
18 (Chapman). “The correct inquiry is whether, assuming that
the damaging potential of the cross-examination were fully

24
realized, a reviewing court might nonetheless say that the error
was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. Whether such an error
is harmless in a particular case depends upon a host of factors,
all readily accessible to reviewing courts. These factors include
the importance of the witness’ testimony in the prosecution’s
case, whether the testimony was cumulative, the presence or
absence of evidence corroborating or contradicting the testimony
of the witness on material points, the extent of cross-examination
otherwise permitted, and . . . the overall strength of the
prosecution’s case.” (Van Arsdall, supra, 475 U.S. at p. 684,
citing Chapman, at p. 24.)
C. Analysis
Here, even assuming the trial court erred and abused its
discretion in limiting Potter’s cross-examination of Chavez, we
find the error harmless under the more demanding standard
articulated in Chapman. Even if Potter realized the full potential
of his cross-examination of Chavez, we are confident the error
was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt. (Chapman, supra,
386 U.S. at p. 24.)
While there is no question Chavez’s testimony was helpful
to the prosecution’s case, he was only one of several gang experts
called by the prosecution, each of whom testified extensively
regarding the Riders and Vasquez’s position and influence within
the gang. Nor was Chavez the only witness who testified as to
Potter’s position and authority within the gang, or his leadership
role in the conspiracy to murder Diaz.
For example, Witness Number Five was a former Riders
member and was directly involved in the conspiracy and
attempted murder. He explained that Vasquez was the leader of
the Riders and Potter was Vasquez’s “right-hand man.” He was

25
with Potter when he received the note stating Diaz could be on
the yard with the Riders, spoke on the phone with Potter and
Vasquez when they discussed the planned attack on Diaz, and
was ordered by Vasquez and Potter to attack Diaz. He was also
present at the meeting where Potter and the other Riders
planned the attack, and where Potter stated Diaz “was no good,”
and “gots [sic]to go.” Then, on the day of the attack, Potter
instructed Witness Number Five how to assault Diaz, and
actually gave Witness Number Five the signal to attack.
Similarly, Terry Gonzales, Jr., an ex-Rider and Vasquez’s
former right-hand man, testified how he worked with Vasquez to
organize the gang by helping to create its rules and regulations.
He also described how he committed crimes at Vasquez’s
direction, including prior attempts to murder Diaz, and how
Riders members would receive orders from Vasquez via written
notes.
This additional testimony notwithstanding, there was also
evidence of the phone call in which Potter and his coconspirators
discussed the plan to murder Diaz on Vasquez’s orders. Potter
was also recorded on multiple phone calls discussing Diaz and
attempting to relay a message to Vasquez that the attack had
indeed occurred. In one recorded call after the attack, Potter
tried to relay the message to Vasquez that Diaz had been “taken
care of” and had suffered life-threatening injuries.
There was also ample documentary evidence for the jury to
infer Vasquez wanted Diaz murdered for forming the Nuestra
Cosas, including writings by Vasquez that splinter factions would
be dealt with using extreme violence and would be slaughtered.
There was also a hit list with Diaz’s name, and other documents

26
detailing Vasquez’s anger towards Diaz for forming a splinter
faction.
While Potter argues Chavez helped the jury interpret this
evidence making Chavez’s credibility relevant to Potter’s defense,
the recordings and documents spoke for themselves and would
have been admitted regardless of any limitations placed on
Chavez’s cross-examination. For example, the recorded calls
clearly show a plot, in which Potter played a vital role, to lure
Diaz to Corcoran to try to murder him. We find further
impeachment of Chavez would not have left the jury with a
different impression of the various recorded calls or documents
introduced as part of his testimony or their plain meaning.
Potter also argues Chavez’s testimony was critical to the
prosecution’s theory that the plan was to murder Diaz, rather
than merely assault him. While Chavez’s testimony supported
this inference, there was additional, arguably stronger evidence
to support that conclusion. This included the nature of the attack
and wounds sustained by Diaz, specifically, a stab wound to the
base of Diaz’s skull and neck with a metal ice pick. Moreover,
Witness Number Five testified his orders were to kill Diaz.
Thus, although Chavez played a prominent role in the
prosecution’s case, his contribution was not so significant that a
fully realized cross-examination or additional impeachment
would have altered the outcome. (Van Arsdall, supra, 475 U.S. at
p. 684.)
II. Whether the trial court erred in admitting a hearsay
statement that Vasquez ordered the murder of
another inmate
Potter next argues the trial court erred by allowing Terry
Gonzales, a former Rider, to testify regarding a hearsay

27
statement that Vasquez had ordered Gonzales’s murder. Potter
contends admission of the statement was severely prejudicial as
its only relevance was the truth that Vasquez had issued a kill
order similar to the order to kill Diaz here.
A. Additional background
Gonzales testified for the prosecution. Gonzales became a
Rider in 2003. As a Rider, Gonzales assaulted other inmates on
behalf of the gang, taught other members how to kill, and ordered
murders of the gang’s enemies. Gonzales was Vasquez’s “vice-
president” and “right-hand man,” and he admitted to attempting
to murder Diaz multiple times on Vasquez’s orders. Tired of gang
politics, Gonzales left the Riders in 2017 despite Vasquez’s
threats to murder him if he left the gang.
When asked if he had any indication he had been targeted
for murder, Gonzales testified a CDCR staff member had shown
him a note that said “ ‘[Vasquez] put an order to kill you.’ ”
Potter’s counsel objected to the statement on hearsay grounds.
The prosecutor explained the testimony was being offered for
Gonzales’s state of mind. The trial court overruled the objection
and instructed the jury that the statement was not being offered
for the truth of the matter but why Gonzales believed what he
believed.
Gonzales went on to testify that he was nearly stabbed to
death by two Riders in October 2020. In describing the
circumstances that led up to the stabbing, Gonzales testified
Witness Number Five came to his cell and appeared to have a
concealed weapon. Gonzales suspected Witness Number Five
was going to try to kill him based on the CDCR staff member’s
note and Witness Number Five’s strange behavior. Several days
later, the Riders attacked Gonzales while he was in the shower.

28
His attackers stabbed Gonzales numerous times while one of
them yelled out, “Riders, motherfucker.”
In addition, Witness Number Five testified Vasquez
ordered him to kill Gonzales because Gonzales was disloyal and
was a snitch. He also described his interaction with Gonzales.
B. Standard of review and governing law
“Hearsay may be briefly understood as an out-of-court
statement offered for the truth of its content. Evidence Code
section 1200, subdivision (a) formally defines hearsay as
‘evidence of a statement that was made other than by a witness
while testifying at the hearing and that is offered to prove the
truth of the matter stated.’ A ‘statement’ is ‘oral or written
verbal expression’ or the ‘nonverbal conduct of a person intended
by him as a substitute for oral or written verbal expression.’ ”
(People v. Sanchez (2016) 63 Cal.4th 665, 674.) “Hearsay is
generally inadmissible unless it falls under an exception.” (Ibid.;
Evid. Code, § 1200, subd. (b).)
Exceptions to the hearsay rule include when a statement is
offered to prove the declarant’s state of mind (People v. Cash
(2002) 28 Cal.4th 703, 727) or to show its effect on the listener
(People v. Ramirez (2022) 13 Cal.5th 997, 1115). However, even if
these exceptions apply, the offered statement must still be
relevant and not unduly prejudicial. (See People v. Ortiz (1995)
38 Cal.App.4th 377, 389.)
We review the trial court’s ruling on the admissibility of
evidence for abuse of discretion. (People v. Morales (2020)
10 Cal.5th 76, 97.) “A judgment may be reversed on appeal for
improper admission of evidence only if ‘it is reasonably probable
that a result more favorable to the [defendant] would have been
reached in the absence of the error.’ [Citations.] Reasonably

29
probable in this context ‘does not mean more likely than not, but
merely a reasonable chance, more than an abstract possibility.’
[Citation.] In assessing prejudice, we consider both the
magnitude of the error and the closeness of the case.” (People v.
Vasquez (2017) 14 Cal.App.5th 1019, 1041, italics omitted.)
C. Analysis
Here, even assuming the statement should have been
excluded as hearsay without exception and because it was
irrelevant to any issue in dispute, we find the error harmless as it
is not reasonably probable Potter would have achieved a more
favorable result absent the error. (Watson, supra, 46 Cal.2d at
pp. 836–837.)
As an initial matter, we note there is no indication the jury
used the evidence for an improper purpose. The trial court gave
a specific limiting instruction during Gonzales’s testimony
regarding the CDCR staff member’s note. The trial court
instructed the jury, “Ladies and gentlemen, with respect to the
statements that were made to this witness, they’re not being
offered for the truth of the matter but why this witness believes
what he believes.” We presume the jury followed this instruction.
(People v. Winbush (2017) 2 Cal.5th 402, 457.)
But even assuming the jury disregarded the limiting
instruction or that the instruction was incorrect, the hearsay
statement was only a fraction of the evidence that Vasquez and
the Riders targeted Gonzales for murder. This included
Vasquez’s threat to kill Gonzales if he left the gang. Further,
there was evidence of a letter authored by Vasquez, informing
other Riders that Gonzales had a “warrant for his arrest.”
Vasquez himself explained that this meant the person would be
assaulted “or worse.” Other witnesses also confirmed that “or

30
worse” meant murder. Witness Number Five also testified
Vasquez ordered him to kill Gonzales. In addition, Gonzales
detailed the attempt on his life, when he was stabbed in the
shower as an attacker yelled, “Riders,” which is more prejudicial
than the hearsay statement. The circumstances of the stabbing
combined with the other evidence of Vasquez’s position and
authority within the gang are sufficient to preclude Potter from
establishing prejudicial error.
Thus, we find it not reasonably probable the admission of
the hearsay statement had any material effect on the outcome of
the case. (Watson, supra, 46 Cal.2d at pp. 836–837.)
III. The trial court properly limited cross-examination
on the topic of Gonzales’s motivation for attacking
another inmate
Potter also argues the trial court erred by limiting his
cross-examination of Gonzales on whether an attack Gonzales
committed on another inmate was due to a financial dispute or
whether it was on behalf of the Riders and on Vasquez’s orders.
Potter argues the trial court should have allowed this line of
questioning over the prosecution’s Evidence Code section 352
objection. By limiting his cross-examination, Potter argues the
trial court violated his Confrontation Clause rights.
A. Additional background
On direct examination, Gonzales testified that he attacked
and tried to murder X-Raided, another inmate who published rap
music from prison. Gonzales explained that the attack on X-
Raided was carried out with other Riders and on Vasquez’s
orders. Potter’s counsel sought to cross-examine Gonzales on this
point, explaining he had a good faith belief Gonzales attacked X-
Raided over a financial dispute between Gonzales’s cell mate and

31
X-Raided over X-Raided’s music publishing business. Potter’s
counsel explained the testimony was relevant to one of the gang
enhancement predicates and to impeach Gonzales.
The prosecution objected to this line of questioning under
Evidence Code section 352. The prosecution argued Potter’s
counsel had the opportunity to explore this theory and did not
have a good faith basis to cross-examine Gonzales further after
Gonzales denied the attack was motivated by a financial dispute
unrelated to the Riders. The prosecutor further explained if
Potter’s counsel did not have a good faith basis to pursue this
theory, the questions would be improperly left before the jury
without any evidentiary support. In response, Potter’s counsel
offered Vasquez’s anticipated testimony that the Riders had
nothing to do with the attack on X-Raided and Gonzales had been
kicked out of the Riders for participating in the attack.
The trial court sustained the objection, finding Potter’s
counsel lacked a good faith belief to pose any questions regarding
his alternative theory for Gonzales’s motivation to attack X-
Raided after he denied the attack was financially motivated or
involved a dispute with Gonzales’s cell mate. The trial court also
noted that while Vasquez could testify that the attack was not
committed for the Riders, he would have no knowledge as to
whether the attack was carried out for some other reason.
Further, Potter’s counsel lacked a good faith belief that Gonzales
was kicked out of the Riders for the attack on X-Raided because
Gonzales left the gang years after the attack.
Later, when Vasquez testified for the defense, he claimed
the attack on X-Raided had nothing to do with the Riders, but
said that Gonzales was kicked out of the gang for being a snitch.

32
B. Standard of review and governing law
As we have already stated the standard and governing law
for reviewing Confrontation Clause errors, we do not restate
them here.
A defendant’s broad Confrontation Clause rights
notwithstanding, he or she must still have a good faith basis for
asking a question on cross-examination when attacking a
witness’s credibility. (People v. Pearson (2013) 56 Cal.4th 393,
433–434.) Thus, a trial court may properly preclude any
questions that lack a good faith basis and invite jury speculation
on claims that would not be given any evidentiary support.
(People v. Lomax (2010) 49 Cal.4th 530, 580.) In other words,
counsel “ ‘may not examine a witness solely to imply or insinuate
the truth of the facts about which questions are posed.’ ” (People
v. Young (2005) 34 Cal.4th 1149, 1186.)
We review a trial court’s limitation of cross-examination for
abuse of discretion. (People v. Royal (2019) 43 Cal.App.5th 121,
149; see People v. Ledesma, supra, 39 Cal.4th at p.705.) As stated
above, we review Confrontation Clause errors under Chapman.
(Van Arsdall, supra, 475 U.S. at p. 684.)
C. Analysis
Here, we find no abuse of discretion as the trial court
properly limited the cross-examination of Gonzales regarding
whether the attack on X-Raided was financially motivated or
whether Gonzales was kicked out of the Riders for participating
in the attack. After Gonzales denied the attack on X-Raided was
due to a financial dispute between Gonzales’s cell mate and X-
Raided, Potter’s counsel had no basis to inquire further as there
was no other evidence, either through Gonzales’s or Vasquez’s
testimony, of a financial motivation for the attack. This is

33
because, even if Vasquez testified that the attack was unrelated
to the Riders, Vasquez knew nothing regarding whether the
attack was financially motivated or related to Gonzales’s cell
mate. Thus, as the trial court correctly found, any further
questioning on the topic would have invited jury speculation on
claims that had no evidentiary support. (See People v. Lomax,
supra, 49 Cal.4th at pp. 578–580.) Likewise, there was no
evidence that Gonzales was pushed out of the Riders for
participating in the attack since he left the Riders years later.
Indeed, Vasquez testified Gonzales was pushed out of the gang
for snitching. Accordingly, the trial court did not abuse its
discretion in limiting the cross-examination of Gonzales.
IV. Whether the evidence was insufficient to support the
gang enhancements
Potter argues the evidence was insufficient to support the
gang allegations and the jury’s true finding should be reversed.
While the People agree the evidence was insufficient, they
contend that the prosecution should be given the opportunity to
retry the gang allegations. We agree with the People.
A. Additional background
The amended information alleged each count was
committed for the benefit of, at the direction of, or in association
with a criminal street gang, with the specific intent to promote,
further, or assist in criminal conduct by gang members.
(§ 186.22, subd. (b)(1)(C).) The three predicate acts offered to
support a pattern of gang activity were: (1) Gonzales’s 2010
attack on X-Raided; (2) a December 2017 fight between several
Riders and a rival gang member; and (3) a 2020 conspiracy to
attack and murder Gonzales.

34
The jury was instructed that a “criminal street gang” is:
“[A]ny ongoing, organized association or group of three or more
persons, whether formal or informal: [¶] 1. That has a common
name or common identifying sign or symbol; [¶] 2. That has, as
one or more or its primary activities, the commission of Assault
by Means Likely to Produce Great Bodily Injury . . . or
Conspiracy to Commit Murder . . . ; [¶] AND [¶] 3. Whose
members collectively engage in or have engaged in a pattern of
criminal gang activity.”
The jury was instructed that a “pattern of criminal gang
activity” is defined as: “1. The commission of, attempted
commission of, or conspiracy to commit: [¶] any combination or
two or more of the following crimes: Assault by Means Likely to
Produce Great Bodily Injury . . . or Conspiracy to Commit
Murder . . . ; [¶] 2. At least one of those crimes was committed
within three [years] of [the] prior offense; [¶] 3. The most recent
crime occurred within three years of the date the current offense
is alleged to have been committed; [¶] 4. The crimes were
committed on separate occasions, or by two or more members; [¶]
5. The offenses commonly benefitted a criminal street gang; [¶]
AND [¶] 6. The common benefit of the offenses is more than
reputational.”
B. Standard of review and governing law
To evaluate whether a section 186.22 enhancement was
supported by sufficient evidence, we review the entire record and
determine whether evidence is reasonable, credible, and of solid
value such that a reasonable trier of fact could find the defendant
guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. (People v. Albillar (2010)
51 Cal.4th 47, 59–60.)

35
To prove a section 186.22 enhancement, the prosecution
must show: (1) the underlying felony must be committed for the
benefit of, at the direction of, or in association with any criminal
street gang; and (2) the felony must be committed with the
specific intent to promote, further, or assist in criminal conduct
by gang members. (§ 186.22, subd. (b)(1); People v. Perez (2017)
18 Cal.App.5th 598, 606–607.)
Effective January 1, 2022, AB 333 amended the elements
for establishing the existence of a “criminal street gang” and “a
pattern of criminal gang activity.” (Stats. 2021, ch. 699.) It
modified the definition of “criminal street gang” to “an ongoing,
organized association or group of three or more persons, whether
formal or informal,” whose members “collectively engage in, or
have engaged in, a pattern of criminal gang activity.” (§ 186.22,
subd. (f), as amended by Stats. 2021, ch. 699, § 3.) Under AB 333,
to demonstrate a pattern of criminal gang activity, a “pattern of
criminal gang activity” means “the commission of, attempted
commission of, conspiracy to commit, or solicitation of, sustained
juvenile petition for, or conviction of, two or more of the following
offenses, provided at least one of these offenses occurred after the
effective date of this chapter, and the last of those offenses
occurred within three years of the prior offense and within three
years of the date the current offense is alleged to have been
committed, the offenses were committed on separate occasions or
by two or more members, the offenses commonly benefited a
criminal street gang, and the common benefit from the offenses is
more than reputational.” (§ 186.22, subd. (e)(1).)
C. Analysis
AB 333 became effective January 1, 2022 (Stats. 2021,
ch. 699) and the amended information was filed two days later.

36
The amended information appeared to track the outdated
elements for gang enhancements in effect prior to AB 333.
Consequently, the three predicate acts offered to support a
pattern of gang activity were insufficient to support the gang
allegation under AB 333, which was in effect at the time of trial.
First, the 2010 attack is outside the section 186.22, subdivision
(e)(1)’s time limitations. Second, the conspiracy to murder
Gonzales occurred after the attack on Diaz. Offenses committed
after the charged offense cannot qualify as a predicate offense.
(People v. Duran (2002) 97 Cal.App.4th 1448, 1458.) The only
remaining predicate is a 2017 fight, which, on its own, is
insufficient to support the gang enhancement. Thus, the jury’s
true finding on the gang enhancement is reversed for insufficient
evidence.
Because we are reversing the gang enhancement, we must
decide whether retrial of the gang allegations is barred on
remand. On the one hand, Potter argues retrial is barred based
on double jeopardy principles because we are reversing for
insufficient evidence under the law as it was in effect at the time.
On the other hand, the Attorney General asserts double jeopardy
principles do not bar retrial because, even if Potter were
convicted on retrial, he would not be exposed to greater
punishment. As the Attorney General explains, since Potter is
already subject to a sentence of 50 years to life, a true finding on
the gang allegations would not expose him to a greater
punishment. While the disagreement appears to be merely
academic and a retrial would serve no practical purpose, we agree
with the Attorney General.
“The double jeopardy clauses of the Fifth Amendment to
the United States Constitution and article I, section 15 of the

37
California Constitution guarantee that a person may not be
placed twice ‘in jeopardy’ for the ‘same offense.’ [Citation.]
‘The double jeopardy bar protects against a second prosecution
for the same offense following an acquittal or conviction, and also
protects against multiple [punishments] for the same offense.’ ”
(People v. Seel (2004) 34 Cal.4th 535, 541–542 (Seel).)
“An ‘appellate court’s reversal for insufficiency of the
evidence is in effect a determination that the government’s case
against the defendant was so lacking that the trial court should
have entered a judgment of acquittal.’ [Citation.] Because
reversal for insufficiency of the evidence is equivalent to a
judgment of acquittal, such a reversal bars a retrial.” (McDaniel
v. Brown (2010) 558 U.S. 120, 131.)
Our own Supreme Court has held any factual allegation
that constitutes an element of the offense, including sentence
enhancement allegations, may not be retried following the
equivalent of an acquittal. (Seel, supra, 34 Cal.4th at pp. 548–
549.) However, our Supreme Court subsequently held that this
does not apply to a section 186.22 enhancement if the underlying
crime was for first degree murder, which is punishable by death,
imprisonment for life without the possibility of parole, or by a
prison term of 25 years to life. (People v. Nunez (2013) 57 Cal.4th
1, 39, fn. 6.) In that scenario, because the gang enhancement
subjects the defendant to a 15–year mandatory minimum parole
eligibility term, a section 186.22 enhancement will not increase
the punishment for the crime. (People v. Nunez, at p. 39, fn. 6.)
Since Potter is currently subject to a sentence of 50 years to
life, retrial of the gang allegations would not increase the
punishment for the offenses here. Therefore, although a

38
conviction on retrial would have no practical effect, the
prosecution is not barred from retrying the gang allegations.
The cases cited by Potter do not persuade us otherwise.
In each of those cases where the reviewing court remanded the
matter without giving the prosecution another opportunity to
retry the gang allegations, the defendants committed less serious
offenses and a conviction on the gang enhancements on retrial
would have increased the defendants’ sentences beyond the
statutory minimum or the statutory maximum. (See, e.g., People
v. Garcia (2014) 224 Cal.App.4th 519, 525–526 [gang
enhancement would add five years to defendant’s sentence for
shooting a firearm in a grossly negligent manner]; People v.
Renteria (2022) 13 Cal.5th 951, 970 [gang enhancement would
require an indeterminate sentence for shooting at an inhabited
dwelling].)
Accordingly, although retrial on the gang allegations would
serve little purpose as Potter has already been sentenced to
50 years to life, the prosecution is not barred from retrying the
allegations.
V. Whether the trial court erred in applying the 10-year
enhancement under section 186.22, subdivision (b)(1)
instead of the 15-year minimum parole date
enhancement
Although we are reversing the jury’s true finding on the
gang allegations for insufficient evidence, because we are giving
the prosecution the opportunity to retry those allegations on
remand, we find it necessary to address Potter’s final argument
that the trial court erred in imposing the 10-year enhancement
under section 186.22, subdivision, (b)(1)(C).

39
On count 1, the trial court sentenced Potter to a base term
of 25 years to life, doubled to 50 years to life pursuant to the
Three Strikes law, plus 10 years for the gang allegation. Where,
as here, gang allegations under section 186.22, subdivision (b),
are found true by the jury and the underlying felony already
carries a life sentence, “section 186.22, subdivision (b)(5) . . .
applies and imposes a minimum term of 15 years before the
defendant may be considered for parole.” (People v. Lopez (2005)
34 Cal.4th 1002, 1004.)
Accordingly, the additional 10 years imposed by the trial
court on count 1 was unauthorized. In the unlikely event Potter
is retried and the gang allegation is found true, the trial court
may only set the minimum parole eligibility date of 15 years
under section 186.22, subdivision (b)(5).

DISPOSITION
The gang enhancements are reversed and the matter is
remanded to the trial court to afford the prosecution an
opportunity to retry the gang allegations. Accordingly, the
additional 10 year sentence imposed under section 186.22 is also
reversed. In all other respects, the judgment is affirmed.

VIRAMONTES, J.

WE CONCUR:

STRATTON, P. J.

WILEY, J.

40

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.