CourtListener 9999246•In re D. CA2/4
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 7/10/24 In re D. CA2/4
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR
In re D. et al., Persons Coming B327900
Under the Juvenile Court
Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. Nos.
20LJJP00624
20LJJP00624 B, C)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and
Respondent,
v.
B.B.,
Defendant and
Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Donald A. Buddle, Jr., Judge. Affirmed.
David M. Yorton, Jr., under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Avedis Koutoujian, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
INTRODUCTION
Appellant Brittany B. (mother) appeals from a juvenile
court order terminating her parental rights to two of her
children, A. and D. The children were removed from mother’s
care in October 2020, shortly after A.’s birth; D. was 23 months
old. At the termination of rights hearing under Welfare and
Institutions Code section 366.261 in February 2023, the juvenile
court held that that mother failed to demonstrate that the
parental-benefit exception to adoption under section 366.26,
subdivision (c)(1)(B)(i) applied. Mother appealed.
We affirm. Mother did not meet her burden to demonstrate
that termination would be detrimental to the children under the
parental-benefit exception. Mother’s visitation with the children
was inconsistent and she did not show that the children would
benefit from continuing the relationship.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Detention
The children came to the attention of the Los Angeles
County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) in
September 2020, when mother tested positive for opiates and
1 All further undesignated statutory references are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.
2
amphetamines at the time of A.’s birth. Mother said she had
used cocaine (but not amphetamines) the day before A. was born,
and she took a Norco prescribed to someone else for back pain on
the day A. was born. Mother told hospital staff she did not know
she was pregnant, and she received no prenatal care. Mother
told staff A. was her first baby, and that she was unable to care
for her. A second referral stated that mother’s eight-year-old
daughter, H., who is not at issue in this appeal, reported seeing
mother smoking something with “a piece of glass,” and seeing
mother and A. and D.’s father (father) hitting and pushing each
other.2
Mother checked out of the hospital against medical advice
and she initially gave an incorrect name and address. When the
children’s social worker (CSW) was able to locate mother at her
home, mother gave a false name for D., 23 months old, and said
she was caring for D. because D.’s mother had a drug problem
and was living in Las Vegas. Mother also said H. was her niece.
Mother said she and father were no longer in a relationship.
The CSW learned mother’s and D.’s names when she called
mother’s acquaintance, who also told her that H. “mainly” lived
with her father, N.G. Another acquaintance told the CSW that
mother had known she was pregnant since about two months into
the pregnancy. The CSW visited H. and N.G. at N.G.’s home.
N.G. said he had observed mother showing signs of drug use
including weight loss, paranoia, and grinding her teeth. N.G.
also said mother had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder. H.
reported that she heard mother talking about being pregnant. H.
2 Mother initially refused to provide any information about
A.’s father, and father initially asserted that A. was not his child.
A DNA test later confirmed father’s paternity.
3
had also observed mother smoking out of a pipe and drinking
alcohol. H. said mother yells at her every day, and she had
observed mother and father hitting and throwing things at each
other.
Father told the CSW he knew mother was pregnant, but he
did not think the baby was his. After a 2019 arrest for domestic
violence, mother had a criminal restraining order against father;
father said mother was the aggressor. He also said mother had
stalked him and taken over his social media accounts. Father
said he occasionally cared for D. DCFS history showed reports of
domestic violence between mother and father in May, June, and
July 2020.
A. remained in the hospital due to medical complications.
Mother threatened to take A. from the hospital against medical
advice, and a hospital hold was placed on her. D. was also
removed from mother’s care on October 1, 2020. D. was placed
with a paternal aunt, N.H. (aunt); A. was placed with aunt when
she was discharged from the hospital a few days later.
On October 5, 2020, DCFS filed a petition under section
300, subdivisions (a), (b), and (j). Counts a-1 and b-3 alleged that
mother and father had a history of engaging in violent
altercations, including while mother was pregnant and while
father was living with mother despite the restraining order.
Counts b-1 and j-1 alleged that mother used illicit drugs while
caring for the children and while pregnant. Counts b-2 and j-2
alleged that father abused illicit drugs, and mother failed to
protect the children by allowing father to have unlimited access
to the children. Count b-4 alleged that mother had a history of
bipolar disorder and failed to take her prescribed medications.
On October 9, 2020, the juvenile court found a prima facie basis
4
for jurisdiction under section 300, found father to be the alleged
father of A., ordered the children detained, and ordered that
mother’s visits be monitored.3
B. Jurisdiction and disposition
According to the jurisdiction/disposition report filed on
November 4, 2020, D. and A. remained with aunt and her family,
and H. remained with her father, N.G. The bases for jurisdiction
are not challenged in this appeal, so we do not discuss them in
depth.
Mother initially refused to be interviewed by the
dependency investigator. H. reiterated her earlier statements
about seeing and hearing violent altercations between mother
and father, and seeing mother smoke using glass pipes. Father
confirmed arguments with mother and some physical
altercations, but he said mother was the aggressor. N.G. and
father both confirmed that mother said she had been diagnosed
with bipolar disorder; father said mother did not like to take her
medication because it made her drowsy. DCFS found a high
potential for future risk of abuse and neglect.
D. and A. were adjusting well in aunt’s home. A hospital
report stated that A. tested positive for amphetamine and
methamphetamine at birth; after her seven-day hospital stay, she
was discharged in good health. Mother was visiting D. and A.
once per week for three hours. Although mother was entitled to
additional visits, DCFS had difficulty finding monitors for
3 The court also ordered monitored visits for father. The
court later sustained the petition as to father and ordered
reunification services, but father did not participate. His
parental rights were also terminated; he does not challenge that
ruling.
5
mother’s visits. Mother also requested separate visitation days
for each child.
A supplemental report filed November 18, 2020 stated that
the dependency investigator interviewed mother by phone.
Mother confirmed some of the domestic violence allegations with
father. She denied any drug abuse, saying that she used cocaine
shortly before giving birth because she did not know she was
pregnant, but she did not use any other drugs. Mother denied
that H. saw her smoking from a glass pipe. Mother also
confirmed that she had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder, but
said she did not take or need medication. Mother tested negative
for drugs on November 3, 2020.
A last-minute information (LMI) filed December 15, 2020
stated that mother continued to have weekly visitation with the
children. The LMI stated that aunt was not comfortable
monitoring mother’s visits because “mother gets upset easily,
uses foul language, and has displayed disrespectful behaviors
toward [aunt].” The LMI also stated that “mother often
references her attorney as a reason to not comply, or come to an
agreement, with the Department. As a result, servicing the
mother’s case has been difficult for [the CSW] and the
Department overall. [The CSW] explained that the mother often
times ‘texts bizarre things’ raising additional concerns for
mother’s mental health status. [The CSW] is unable to have a
meaningful conversation with the mother as the mother speaks
over [the] CSW while talking and becomes irate.”
A drug test on December 2, 2020 was negative. However,
the CSW received information that mother had purchased clean
urine to use for her drug test, and that mother was a daily
methamphetamine user. An LMI filed on January 13, 2021
6
stated that mother was having two monitored visits with the
children per week. No concerns were noted.
At the jurisdiction hearing on January 15, 2021, the
juvenile court found true counts b-1 and j-1 (relating to mother’s
drug abuse), b-3 (domestic violence), b-4 (mother’s bipolar
disorder), and j-2 (father’s drug abuse). The court dismissed
counts a-1 (serious physical harm due to domestic violence) and
b-2 (father’s drug abuse).
At the disposition hearing on February 26, 2021, the
juvenile court released H. to N.G. and terminated jurisdiction as
to H. The court ordered that D. and A. remain detained from
mother and father, and ordered nine hours of monitored
visitation for mother per week.
C. Reunification period
A status review report filed August 25, 2021 stated that D.
and A. remained with aunt and her family; D. and A. were “well
adjusted in the home and have formed bonds with the caregiver’s
biological children.” DCFS noted, “The children are to be referred
to Regional Center Services however the mother has not signed
the appropriate consent forms in order to evaluate the
children. . . . The mother has stated that her children are
developmentally well and not in need of services.”
Mother was “consistent with her monitored visits” three
times per week, and the visits were “reported to go well with
recommendations for improvement.” One visit per week was
monitored by the CSW, one was monitored by a human services
aid (HSA), and one was monitored by a professional monitor. The
HSA had “provided mother with advice as how to be more
interactive and more alert with both children in the visits.” The
CSW observed that “it is difficult for the mother to balance a two-
7
year-old and a 11-month year old during visits, but the mother
tries and continues to attempt to provide equal attention to
them.”
Mother had “completed domestic violence, mental health
assessment, individual counseling, and parenting,” but “has yet
to complete a full substance abuse program with after care.”
Mother had missed seven drug tests. DCFS noted that it was
“concerned [about] the mother’s unwillingness to participate and
accept services pertaining to the issues that brought her to
attention of DCFS. Her reluctance and ability to fabricate
information continues to be a barrier for her reunification.
Mother refuses to accept how her past issues of substance abuse
lead [sic] to her involvement with DCFS.” DCFS assessed that
the risk of potential for negligence with mother remained high,
and recommended that the court terminate reunification services.
An LMI filed on September 16, 2021 stated that aunt was
“frustrated” with mother’s visitation “because the mother
sometimes does not confirm on time, visit is changed, or
canceled.” Mother still had not enrolled in a drug program.
Visit notes by the CSW from March 4, May 20, June 3, July
19, and August 9, 2021 noted no concerns with mother’s visits,
and said mother interacted with the children appropriately.
However, a note from August 10, 2021 stated that the HSA found
that mother’s visits involved “no immediate concerns but . . . the
mother needs improvement in her visits. The mother sometimes
doesn’t watch the children and HSA feels like she is watching the
children.” On one occasion when D. fell at a play area, mother
neither saw the fall nor checked on D. afterward. Mother also
“just leaves [A.] in the stroller. The child walks and [the HSA]
would have never known she walks until the caregiver told her.”
8
The HSA noted that there was “no doubt [mother] loves her kids
and her kids love her but she needs improvement in the quality of
her visits.”
At the status review hearing on August 26, 2021, the
juvenile court denied DCFS’s request to terminate reunification
services for mother. The court found that mother was in partial
compliance with her case plan, and that she made efforts to
comply with the remaining parts of the case plan.
A status review report filed December 14, 2021 stated that
mother had enrolled in a drug program and was attending
consistently. In November 2021, mother had asked that DCFS
liberalize her visitation to be unmonitored. DCFS denied the
request, stating that mother had only been in her drug program
for a month, and mother was not in compliance with other parts
of her case plan. DCFS again recommended that reunification
services be terminated.
An Evidence Code section 730 psychological evaluation for
mother was filed December 9, 2021. The clinical/diagnostic
impressions were bipolar I disorder with rapid cycling, mild;
stimulant use disorder, severe; and relationship distress with
intimate partner. The psychologist noted, “Overall, [mother’s]
profile is not considered in the clinical range. She tended to deny
most symptoms.” The psychologist recommended continued
jurisdiction while mother completed her case plan.
An LMI filed January 13, 2022 noted that mother’s recent
drug tests were negative. However, DCFS had “received some
concerns regarding the mother’s behavior,” including an
allegation that mother was “neglecting her elderly grandfather.
It was further observed in the conversations that the mother left
the grandfather for a week and traveled outside of the state to
9
meet a man and it was alleged that she was using illicit drugs.”
Mother denied the allegations.
A service log filed as an exhibit on January 25, 2022
included notes about mother’s visits by the CSW and HSA who
monitored mother’s visits. A visit note by the CSW from October
6, 2021 noted no concerns. A visit note by the CSW from
December 1, 2021 stated that D. did not want to leave home for
the visit with mother. At the visit she was whiny, and said, “I
miss mommy,” referring to aunt. Aunt told the CSW that mother
set up a visit for 10:00 a.m. on Thanksgiving, but did not show up
and did not text again until 5:45 p.m. Aunt “expressed her
frustration of how she tries to accommodate visits on special
holidays and occasions and the mother doesn’t show up and she
always has an excuse.” Mother was supposed to attend a dental
visit for the children on December 16, 2021; mother did not
attend and did not text aunt.
A visit note by the CSW from January 5, 2022 stated that
D. cried and did not want to go to the visit. The CSW noted that
during the visit mother “struggle[d] in attending to both
children,” but stated that it was understandable because both
children were under the age of three. The note stated, “The
children are observed to have a bond with mother; however the
children don’t seem to not want to stay [sic]. The children don’t
cry or don’t say that they don’t want to leave at the end of the
visit.”
On January 13, 2022, the HSA told the CSW that “she
continues to have concerns about the mother. [The HSA] says
that the mother has no patience for the children, and . . . favors
one child more than the other. The mother tends to favor the
child [D.] who is three rather than the child [A.] who is [one].
10
The HSA stated that both of them were acting up and [D.] didn’t
get in trouble but [A.] was put in the car seat as punishment.”
The HSA also noted that D. “cries when she has to go to the
visit,” and “is always crying that she does not want to go.” The
HSA observed that mother “loves her children but she lacks
parental insight” and is “moody” at visits.
An LMI filed on February 8, 2022 stated that mother had
missed three appointments to take a hair follicle drug test.
Mother claimed that she missed one test because she was in the
emergency room, but when the CSW called the hospital to verify,
the hospital said mother had not been there since 2015. The
CSW reported that on February 7, 2022, she had “received text
messages from an anonymous source claiming that mother had
plans to tamper with the hair follicle test and further indicated
that mother has been falsifying urine tests and continues to use
illicit substances.” DCFS continued to recommend that
reunification services be terminated.
An LMI filed on March 8, 2022 noted that mother had
become more inconsistent in her visitation. Mother had cancelled
visits on February 3, 10, and 24, and March 3, and she was so
late to the February 23 and March 2 visits that the visits were
cancelled. The CSW set up a meeting with mother and a
supervisor to address the missed visits, but mother canceled the
meeting. In addition, mother had missed two additional
appointments for a hair follicle test.
An LMI filed March 15, 2022 stated that the meeting with
mother occurred on March 9 by phone. Mother was told that she
needed to confirm with the monitors an hour before each visit
that she was at the visit location, and once confirmed, the
11
monitors would go to pick up the children. DCFS recommended
that mother’s visits be reduced to one three-hour visit per month.
At a review hearing on March 16, 2022, the juvenile court
terminated reunification services. The court found that mother
failed to make substantial progress, and the children would not
be returned to her care by the 18-month mark, which would occur
within weeks of the hearing. The court set a hearing under
section 366.26 regarding termination of mother’s parental rights.
The court also rejected DCFS’s request that mother be ordered to
confirm her visits one hour beforehand, and instead adopted
mother’s request that she confirm only a half hour before each
visit.
Mother filed a motion requesting a bonding study. After a
hearing, the juvenile court denied the motion. This court
affirmed that ruling. (In re D.B. (Aug. 31, 2023, B320301)
[nonpub. opn].)
D. Termination of parental rights
A section 366.26 report filed June 28, 2022 stated that D.
and A. remained in the care of aunt and her family. The report
noted that DCFS tried to serve mother notice of the section
366.26 hearing at a visit, but was unable to because mother did
not show up to several visits in a row. The permanency plan for
the children was adoption by aunt and her husband. DCFS
requested additional time to do an adoptive home study.
Mother was having two visits with the children per week:
on Wednesdays, monitored by the CSW, and on Thursdays,
monitored by the HSA. DCFS noted that “mother has a pattern
of inconsistently arriving on time to visits or not showing to the
visits after confirming.” The HSA observed that mother “has no
patience for the children” and is “moody” at visits. The HSA also
12
observed that D. “cries when she has to go to the visit and often
has to be bribed to attend visits.” The report continued, “It is the
HSA’s observation[ ] that there is no bond between the mother
and children.”
The CSW noted that on April 6, 2022, mother met the CSW
and children at the library. Mother interacted with the children,
but “mother’s demeanor demonstrated that she did not want to be
there.” Mother kept A. in her stroller for the entire visit, rather
than letting her walk or run around. On May 11, 2022, the CSW
noted that “mother has more of a bond with [D.] than [A.]. The
mother payed [sic] more attention to [D.] by carrying her and
leaving [A.] in the car seat.” Mother had a visit with D. on June
1, 2022; A. was ill. No concerns were noted. Mother did not have
any additional visits with the children in June, because “mother
does not confirm the visit or she confirms and is a no show.”
A supplemental report filed August 25, 2022 stated that the
children were likely to be adopted by aunt’s family, and
recommended termination of mother’s parental rights. A status
review report filed on September 7, 2022 stated, “Mother’s visits
are inconsistent. The court ordered the mother to be at the
location 30 minutes early prior to the visit starting. The mother
does not show up on time and visits continue to be canceled. The
mother has not showed for the Thursday visits with [the HSA] in
over two months. The mother confirms her visits but does not
call thirty minutes before and does not show up to the visits.”
In October 2022, mother filed a request to make up visits
that were missed while the CSW was on leave for two months.
Mother also requested that visits be in her home, instead of at
the library. The request said nothing of the missed visits with
the HSA.
13
At a hearing on November 7, 2022, DCFS asked again that
the court require mother to confirm appointments 60 minutes in
advance; otherwise, the monitors had to go to the children’s home
and get them ready to leave, only to find out that mother did not
confirm the visit, which was burdensome for the monitors and
confusing for the children. Counsel for the children agreed,
stating, “I would note that really all of the restrictions on
mother’s visits have been due to the mother’s lack of consistency
with visitation and canceling the visits on time and the
disruption this has caused for the caregivers and for the minors.”
Regarding whether visits could occur in mother’s home, DCFS
noted that mother said throughout the case that she was not
using drugs, but the results of a drug test taken on March 8,
2022, which were filed on November 7, 2022, showed that mother
tested positive for methamphetamine. DCFS noted that mother’s
use of drugs could expose the children to substances or
paraphernalia in her home, so for safety reasons the visits should
remain in a neutral location.
The court agreed that previous changes to mother’s
visitation “were due to her lackluster appearance at visitation,”
and ordered mother to confirm visits one hour beforehand. The
court also ordered DCFS to “provide an update that includes
Caden C.,[4] Parent’s [sic] progress, visitation and any changes in
recommendation.”
Also on November 7, 2022, mother filed a request to
reinstate reunification services. The court set a hearing to
4 We presume the court was referring to the elements
relevant to the parental-benefit exception, as discussed in In re
Caden C. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 614 (Caden C.). See the Discussion
section, infra.
14
determine whether to grant an evidentiary hearing. DCFS filed a
response to mother’s request on December 6, 2022.5 It stated
that an investigator scheduled a meeting with mother on
December 2, but mother did not show up. Mother returned the
investigator’s call later that day, and an interview was completed
by phone. Mother said she did not know how the March 8 drug
test was positive. Mother also said that her visits with the
children are good, and she had complied with her case plan.
Aunt said mother’s visits were sporadic, and since mother
had not been showing up for visits, the visits had been reduced to
one day per week. Mother had cancelled visits on November 3,
November 27, and December 1. Due to mother’s multiple
cancellations, the HSA was requiring mother to contact the HSA
by a video call to confirm she was at the visit location before the
HSA would go to pick up the children.
D. told the DCFS investigator that she likes to visit mother,
and she likes living with “mommy and daddy” (aunt and her
husband). A. also called the caregivers mommy and daddy. The
CSW handling the case told the investigator that mother was
“not consistent with her visits. [Mother’s] bond with the children
is not there. She dismisses the children’s feelings. [D.] would say
‘at mommy’s house’ (referring to the caregiver) and [mother]
would just tell her ‘she is not your mommy’ then [D.] would fight
back and say ‘I have two mommy’s’ [sic] and she will continue to
argue with the child and tell her No; completely dismissing her
feelings. There was a hair follicle test ordered when they
terminated reunification. The hair follicle test is paid for and all
5 Much of this information is repeated in DCFS’s LMI filed
on December 7, 2022, in response to the court’s request for
information relevant to the Caden C. considerations.
15
she has to do is go take it and she continues to refuse to take the
hair follicle test.”
The CSW added that sometimes the children do not want to
go to visits: “They often cry and cling on the caregiver stating
they do not want to go. Sometimes it takes some bribing from the
caregiver for them to go. Does [D.] love her mother, of course she
is able to recognize who her mother is, but detaches easily after
the visit is over. [D. does not] cry when visits end . . . . As far as
[A.] there is no bond as [A.] is not able to fully identify that it is
her mom, she was detained at birth and that bond was not fully
formed in the two years that the children have been detained
from her care.”
The HSA agreed that mother “is not consistent with
visitations. [Mother] confirms for her Thursday visit early in the
week but then, very often, is a no show to her visitations.
[Mother] has shown strange behavior, as in . . . calling me on a
Sunday evening, and texting to confirm her visit the day before
Thanksgiving[ ] after having been told the office would be closed
on the Thursday of Thanksgiving.” The HSA also stated that
mother “seems as though she has difficult time being aware of
both of her daughters,” because she pays attention to only one at
a time while ignoring the other. The HSA said that mother is
“affectionate with the girls making sure she tells them she loves
them at the end of visitations.”
DCFS recommended that the court deny mother’s petition
to reinstate reunification services. It stated that although
mother had “worked towards addressing all the Court ordered
case services, she still has not demonstrated any significant
changes in her protective capacity or ability to care for” D. and A.
16
At the section 366.26 hearing on December 12, 2022, the
court denied mother’s request to reinstate reunification services,
finding no change in circumstances. Turning to section 366.26,
mother asserted a new claim that her family had Indian ancestry
warranting investigation by DCFS. The court therefore
continued the hearing.
An LMI filed on February 15, 2023 noted as a “Caden C.
factor” that D. and A. “can get a little clingy before family time
visits with their mother and sometimes will cry prior to the visits
when they do not want to go. [Aunt] said the last visit mother
did not show up to and visits tend to be inconsistent. . . . [Aunt]
worries that the inconsistency will cause more harm to the girls.”
Mother had missed visits on January 19 and 26 due to illness and
car problems, and was late on February 9. The CSW said
“mother’s visits continue to be inconsistent although she confirms
her visits and then is a no show.”
At the section 366.26 hearing on February 23, 2023, mother
testified that sometimes her visits get canceled if she is “one
minute late, two minutes late.” Mother said she visits with the
children once per week, monitored by the HSA. Mother testified,
“[D.] asks me, ‘Mommy, can I come home? Why can’t I go home
with you?’ And I tell her why. And I give [A.] a kiss. She gives
me a kiss and a hug.” Mother further testified, “[M]y kids have a
really close bond. And I really think it would be very detrimental
to them to not see me, because also the caregiver and I do not get
along. And I know that if I get terminated [sic], I will not see my
kids until they are 18. And it would be really, really . . .
upsetting to both parties, to me and my children.”
Mother’s counsel asked the court to apply the parental-
benefit exception to adoption, asserting that mother had
17
maintained regular visitation and the children would benefit
from maintaining a regular relationship with mother. The
children and DCFS argued that mother did not meet the
requirements for the parental-benefit exception, and asserted
that mother’s parental rights should be terminated.
The court said, “The court has read and considered the
reports. The court does note that . . . there was a much to-do [sic]
about the social workers and the department, but the [HSA] also
noted . . . that mother was not consistent with visits.” The court
continued, “The court finds by clear and convincing evidence that
the children are adoptable, and there are no legal impediments to
adoption. [¶] The court finds that the parents have not
maintained regular visitation with the children and have not
established a bond with the children. [¶] The court finds that any
benefit accruing to the children from the relationship with the
parents is outweighed by the physical and emotional benefit the
children will receive through the permanency and stability of
adoption and that adoption is in the best interest of the children.”
The court therefore terminated mother’s parental rights.
Mother timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
Mother asserts the trial court erred in finding that the
parental-benefit exception did not apply. We find no error.
A. Legal authority
Children have “compelling rights . . . to have a placement
that is stable, permanent, and that allows the caretaker to make
a full emotional commitment to the child.” (In re Marilyn H.
(1993) 5 Cal.4th 295, 306.) “The objective of the dependency
scheme is to protect abused or neglected children and those at
substantial risk thereof and to provide permanent, stable homes
18
if those children cannot be returned home within a prescribed
period of time.” (Id. at p. 307.) “[W]here possible, adoption is the
first choice. ‘Adoption is the Legislature’s first choice because it
gives the child the best chance at [a full] emotional commitment
from a responsible caretaker.” [Citation.] ‘Guardianship, while a
more stable placement than foster care, is not irrevocable and
thus falls short of the secure and permanent future the
Legislature had in mind for the dependent child.’” (In re Celine
R. (2003) 31 Cal.4th 45, 53.)
Thus, at a section 366.26 hearing, “the court shall
terminate parental rights unless” one of the statutory exceptions
applies. (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1).) “The statutory exceptions merely
permit the court, in exceptional circumstances [citation], to choose
an option other than the norm, which remains adoption.” (In re
Celine R., supra, 31 Cal.4th at p. 53 (emphasis in original).) One
of the statutory exceptions is the parental-benefit exception,
which applies when “[t]he court finds a compelling reason for
determining that termination would be detrimental to the child”
where “[t]he parents have maintained regular visitation and
contact with the child and the child would benefit from
continuing the relationship.” (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i).) “[T]he
exception applies in situations where a child cannot be in a
parent’s custody but where severing the child’s relationship with
the parent, even when balanced against the benefits of a new
adoptive home, would be harmful for the child.” (Caden C.,
supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 630.)
There are “three elements the parent must prove to
establish the [parental-benefit] exception: (1) regular visitation
and contact, and (2) a relationship, the continuation of which
would benefit the child such that (3) the termination of parental
19
rights would be detrimental to the child.” (Caden C., supra, 11
Cal.5th at p. 631 (emphasis in original).) In other words, “the
parent asserting the parental benefit exception must show, by a
preponderance of the evidence, three things. The parent must
show regular visitation and contact with the child, taking into
account the extent of visitation permitted. Moreover, the parent
must show that the child has a substantial, positive, emotional
attachment to the parent—the kind of attachment implying that
the child would benefit from continuing the relationship. And the
parent must show that terminating that attachment would be
detrimental to the child even when balanced against the
countervailing benefit of a new, adoptive home. When the parent
has met that burden, the parental-benefit exception applies such
that it would not be in the best interest of the child to terminate
parental rights, and the court should select a permanent plan
other than adoption.” (Id. at pp. 636-637.)
We review the court’s determination on the first two
elements for substantial evidence; the third element “is
discretionary and properly reviewed for abuse of discretion.”
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at pp. 639-640.) However, where, as
here, a parent contends the court erred in finding she did not
meet her burden of proof, we must determine whether “the
evidence compels a finding in favor of the appellant as a matter of
law. [Citations.] Specifically, the question becomes whether the
appellant’s evidence was (1) ‘uncontradicted and unimpeached’
and (2) ‘of such a character and weight as to leave no room for a
judicial determination that it was insufficient to support a
finding.’ [Citation.]” (In re I.W. (2009) 180 Cal.App.4th 1517,
1528, disapproved on another ground in Conservatorship of O.B.
(2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1003, fn. 4, 1010, fn. 7.)
20
B. Consistency of visitation
“The first element—regular visitation and contact—is
straightforward. The question is just whether ‘parents visit
consistently,’ taking into account ‘the extent permitted by court
orders.’” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 632.)
Mother asserts she “maintained regular visitation with her
children as best she could,” blaming missed visits on “obstacles
placed before her by DCFS” and the children’s caregiver. She
argues that based on the entire record, beginning in 2020, her
visits were consistent enough to meet the Caden C. standard.
We are not persuaded. Although mother’s visits were
consistent at the beginning of the case in 2020, her visits became
very inconsistent over time. Mother missed visits on February 3,
10, 23, and 24, and March 2 and 3, 2022. She only had a single
visit with the children in June 2022, despite being allowed two
visits per week. The status review report filed on September 7,
2022 stated that mother had not showed up for her Thursday
visits in more than two months. Additional visits were cancelled
on November 3, November 27, and December 1, 2022, and
January 19 and 26, 2023. The CSW, the HSA, and the children’s
caregivers each reported that mother’s visits were inconsistent.
Mother therefore did not meet this element. (See, e.g., In re C.F.
(2011) 193 Cal.App.4th 549, 554 [“Sporadic visitation is
insufficient to satisfy the first prong of the parent-child
relationship exception to adoption”].)
Mother argues that the juvenile court’s ruling was not clear
about whether she met this element, and therefore mother “is left
with not knowing what the juvenile court relied upon in making
its findings regarding” the first element. Mother points to no
legal authority requiring the court to specify in its order which
21
parts of the record demonstrate irregular visitation. Moreover,
the record here makes clear that mother’s visitation was
inconsistent, leaving no question as to whether this element was
met. Mother therefore has not demonstrated error with respect
to the first element.
C. Benefit of continuing the relationship
For the second element, “courts assess whether ‘the child
would benefit from continuing the relationship.’ (§ 366.26, subd.
(c)(1)(B)(i).) Again here, the focus is the child. And the
relationship may be shaped by a slew of factors, such as ‘[t]he age
of the child, the portion of the child’s life spent in the parent’s
custody, the “positive” or “negative” effect of interaction between
parent and child, and the child’s particular needs.’ [Citation.] [In
addition,] courts often consider how children feel about, interact
with, look to, or talk about their parents.” (Caden C., supra, 11
Cal.5th at p. 632.)
Mother asserts that D. and A. were bonded to her, citing
only a note by the CSW from January 5, 2022 and mother’s own
testimony. The record does not support mother’s contention.
D. was 23 months old when she was removed from mother,
and A. had been removed from mother since birth. The only
relationship the children had with mother after removal
consisted of a few hours of supervised visits per week. The
January 5 note mother relies upon did mention a bond between
mother and the children, but it also stated that D. cried because
she did not want to go to the visit and “[t]he children don’t cry or
don’t say that they don’t want to leave at the end of the visit.”
The visit notes for December 1, 2021 and January 13, 2022 also
stated that D. cried and did not want to go to the visit with
mother. The HSA observed in June 2022 that D. “cries when she
22
has to go to the visit and often has to be bribed to attend visits,”
while mother “has no patience for the children” and is “moody” at
visits. The HSA observed “no bond between the mother and
children.” In December 2022, the CSW observed again that the
children sometimes cry and say they do not want to go to visits
with mother, and “[s]ometimes it takes some bribing from the
caregiver for them to go.” D. continued to “detach[ ] easily after
the visit is over,” while A. had no bond at all, having been
detained from mother since birth.
Thus, although the children often enjoyed visiting mother,
the evidence does not demonstrate the existence of a relationship
between mother and the children that was beneficial to the
children.
D. Detriment of termination of parental rights
For the third element, the court considers whether the
termination of parental rights would be detrimental to the child.
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 631.) In determining whether
termination would be detrimental, “the question is . . . whether
losing the relationship with the parent would harm the child to
an extent not outweighed, on balance, by the security of a new,
adoptive home.” (Id. at p. 634.) “Because terminating parental
rights eliminates any legal basis for the parent or child to
maintain the relationship, courts must assume that terminating
parental rights terminates the relationship. [Citations.] What
courts need to determine, therefore, is how the child would be
affected by losing the parental relationship—in effect, what life
would be like for the child in an adoptive home without the
parent in the child’s life.” (Id. at p. 633.)
Mother asserts this element has been met, again asserting
that the children were bonded with her. The record does not
23
support this contention, and nothing in the record suggests D.
and A. would be detrimentally affected by having mother’s rights
terminated and being adopted by aunt’s family. The children
were well bonded to aunt’s family, they called aunt and her
husband mommy and daddy, and they bonded to aunt’s other
children. D. and A. were well-adjusted and thriving in aunt’s
home—the only home A. had ever known.
This case is not similar to In re D.M. (2021) 71 Cal.App.5th
261, one of the cases mother cites. In that case, without the
clarification the Supreme Court later provided in Caden C., the
juvenile court erroneously considered the extent to which father
played a parental role in the children’s lives. (Id. at pp. 270-271.)
The record there also showed that father visited his three
children consistently, and “the youngest child cried when visits
concluded. D.M. had lived with father for nearly eight years of
her young life, R.M. for nearly five years, and I.M. for nearly two
years, in an intact family where father was a breadwinner and
custodial parent.” (Id. at p. 271.) The Court of Appeal said it
could not “know how the court would have exercised its discretion
if it had the benefit of the Caden C. analysis when making its
ruling,” and therefore remanded the matter for a new section
366.26 hearing. (Ibid.)
Mother also relies on In re J.D. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 833,
a similar case in which the juvenile court’s decision pre-dated
Caden C. The Court of Appeal noted that the mother met the
first element regarding visitation, but regarding the second and
third elements, “the juvenile court’s ruling cannot be affirmed on
this record, because we cannot be certain the juvenile court did
not consider factors disapproved of in Caden C.” (Id. at p. 854.)
The Court of Appeal also discussed the “abundant evidence that
24
[the child’s] attachment to [his] mother continued throughout the
case,” even as their visits were limited due to the Covid-19
pandemic. (Id. at p. 855.) As in In re D.M., the Court of Appeal
remanded the matter for a new section 366.26 hearing. (Id. at p.
871.)
Here, by contrast, the juvenile court specifically considered
the Caden C. elements, and the record does not support a finding
that the children would be harmed by the loss of a relationship
with mother, or that such harm would outweigh the benefit the
children would receive from the security and stability of adoption.
Moreover, unlike the parents in In re D.M. and In re J.D., mother
did not meet the first element regarding consistent visitation.
Mother therefore has not demonstrated that the juvenile court
erred in finding that the parental-benefit exception does not
overcome the legislative preference for adoption.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
COLLINS, J.
We concur:
CURREY, P. J. MORI, J.
25
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.