CourtListener 9546403•Alers v. Kossuth CA2/5
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 6/13/24 Alers v. Kossuth CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
HAZEL ALERS, Individually and B322634
as Successor in Interest, etc. et al.,
(Los Angeles County Super.
Plaintiffs and Appellants, Ct. No. 20STCV36943)
v.
SARA R. KOSSUTH et al.,
Defendants and Respondents.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Gary Y. Tanaka, Judge. Affirmed.
Hazel Alers and Alejandro Alers, Jr., in pro. per., for
Plaintiffs and Appellants.
Schmid & Voiles, Denise H. Greer, Patrick W. Mayer and
David J. Masutani for Defendant and Respondent Sara R.
Kossuth, D.O.
Kelly, Trotter & Franzen, Brenda Ligorsky, Kristina A.
Hoban and David P. Pruett for Defendants and Respondents
HealthCare Partners Affiliates Medical Group, Mary Jean
Lockard, N.P., N. Isabel Kiefer, M.D., Hogop Sarkissian, M.D.
and Kelly Winer, S.W.
Beach Law Group, Paul D. Singer and Darryl C. Hottinger
for Defendant and Respondent Windsor Terrace HealthCare.
___________________________
Following the death of the 98-year-old Alejandro Alers, Sr.
(decedent), his wife, Hazel Alers, and son, Alejandro Alers, Jr.,
brought suit against a number of individuals and entities
involved in his care. The defendants all prevailed in pretrial
motions and judgment was entered in their favor. Plaintiffs
appealed. Previously, we granted multiple defendants’ motion to
dismiss the appeal as against them, on procedural grounds. In
addition, while this action was pending, another defendant
Windsor Terrace Healthcare Center filed a petition for
bankruptcy, and the appeal is stayed as to that party. We now
address plaintiffs’ appeal as to the remaining defendants.
Plaintiffs, who are proceeding in propria persona, have submitted
briefs and an appellate record that are largely inadequate to
enable review. To the limited extent their arguments are
cognizable, they are meritless. We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
1. Underlying Facts
We set forth the facts as alleged in the operative, second
amended, complaint. We limit our factual discussion to a brief
overview, with detailed attention paid to the allegations against
2
the one defendant doctor who successfully demurred on the basis
of failure to state a claim.
A. Treatment at the Hospital and Allegations
Against Dr. Sara Kossuth
On March 23, 2019, decedent, then 97, was found by wife to
be slumped over in a chair and non-responsive. Wife called 911
and decedent was rushed to Olympia Medical Center (Hospital),
where he was diagnosed as suffering from a heart attack and
pneumonia. He was admitted to Hospital.
Plaintiffs allege decedent suffered malpractice at the
Hospital, which ultimately led to his death. However, plaintiffs’
appeal has been dismissed as to all Hospital-related defendants
but one, Dr. Kossuth, whose involvement in his treatment was
minimal.
During his hospitalization, nurses – on the orders of a
different doctor – attempted to insert a urinary catheter in
decedent. After several painful attempts, the catheter was
inserted, only for decedent to rip it out. Nurses reinserted the
catheter and the decedent remained in pain. He continued to
pull at the catheter tube. Dr. Kossuth ordered that decedent be
placed in hand restraints to prevent him from pulling at the tube.
Dr. Kossuth also called a urologist to consult. That
urologist concluded the catheter had been inserted incorrectly.
He removed it, and ultimately successfully placed a different type
of catheter. Following this process, Dr. Kossuth made a comment
which, according to plaintiffs, implied that all of decedent’s pain
was attributable to his act of pulling out the catheter –
intentionally concealing that the catheter had, in fact, been
incorrectly placed by the nurses.
3
Plaintiffs’ allegations against Dr. Kossuth in the operative
complaint are limited to her ordering hand restraints and her
comment allegedly placing blame on decedent for his catheter-
related pain.
B. Treatment at the Skilled Nursing Facility and
Allegations Against HealthCare Partners
Decedent’s health problems were in no way limited to
urinary ones, although plaintiffs allege the improper catheter
placement was causal. Decedent had stopped eating and
drinking; wife and son requested placement of a gastrostomy
tube, which was successfully performed. After decedent’s
condition had stabilized, he was transferred to Windsor Terrace
Healthcare Center (Skilled Nursing Facility), which is a
contracted facility of HealthCare Partners Affiliated Medical
Group. Skilled Nursing Facility is presently in bankruptcy; we
have stayed the appeal against it. (11 U.S.C. § 362.) Plaintiffs’
appeal is still pending against HealthCare Partners and a
number of individuals associated with HealthCare Partners – Dr.
N. Isabel Kiefer, Dr. Hagop Sarkissian, nurse practitioner Mary
Jean Lockard, and social worker Kelly Winer. As these five
defendants and respondents presented a unified defense at trial
and on appeal, we use “HealthCare Partners” to refer to them
collectively.
The specific factual allegations against HealthCare
Partners are unnecessary to the resolution of this appeal.
Broadly speaking, plaintiffs allege that HealthCare Partners
forced them to agree to transfer decedent to Skilled Nursing
Facility; and then, once he was there, promised to transfer him
home with 24-hour nursing care and all necessary rehabilitation
4
resources, when instead they dumped him into home hospice care
with palliative treatment only.
C. Home Hospice Care and Death
When decedent was discharged from Skilled Nursing
Facility, his care was transferred to Seasons Hospice & Palliative
Care of California (Hospice). Plaintiffs’ appeal of the judgment in
favor of Hospice and individuals associated with it has been
dismissed; decedent’s treatment by Hospice is therefore not at
issue in this appeal. In sum, plaintiffs alleged that, despite what
they had been promised, Hospice provided only routine palliative
care, and decedent died within a week. Decedent died on
April 30, 2019.
2. Commencement of the Action
On September 28, 2020, plaintiffs, representing
themselves, filed their complaint, alleging some 23 causes of
action against myriad defendants. There were three purported
plaintiffs: wife, son, and decedent’s estate. This would
ultimately give rise to the legal issue of whether the estate could
proceed in propria persona.
On January 19, 2021, plaintiffs filed their first amended
complaint, which was brought by the same three plaintiffs,
including the estate, and now alleged 24 causes of action.
Plaintiffs’ first amended complaint was accompanied by a
declaration of son “in support of admission into evidence of the
plaintiffs’ exhibits,” and a stack of exhibits (which mostly, but not
exclusively, consisted of decedent’s medical records).1
1 The record is not clear as to the official status of these
exhibits. Although they were submitted along with the first
amended complaint, they were not technically exhibits to it; it
therefore does not appear that they were impacted when the first
5
3. Dismissal of the Estate’s Action
On February 11, 2021, HealthCare Partners demurred to
the first amended complaint on the basis that all causes of action
alleged against it were alleged by decedent’s estate, which could
not proceed against it in propria persona.2 Plaintiffs opposed the
demurrer, and subsequently filed a supplemental opposition.
On November 5, 2021, the trial court sustained the
demurrer with leave to amend, concluding that the estate could
not, in fact, proceed in propria persona.3 The court set the matter
for an order to show cause regarding the status of representation
of the estate.
On November 23, 2021, plaintiffs filed their operative,
second amended complaint. Nominally, plaintiffs had removed
the estate as a plaintiff. Factually, however, they had not.
Instead of purporting to allege causes of action on behalf of the
estate, wife simply alleged those same causes of action “as
amended complaint was later superseded by the second amended
complaint. But taken as an independent filing, the exhibits were
not submitted in connection with any hearing; son provided a
declaration in support of admitting them into evidence, but there
was no trial where evidence was taken, and there is no indication
that the court ever ruled on their admissibility. Under the
circumstances, we think it best to treat the exhibits as simply
lodged with the trial court.
2 Plaintiffs have not chosen to include the points and
authorities in support of the demurrer in their record on appeal.
3 The record on appeal contains the trial court’s tentative
ruling, not the court’s final ruling. However, it is clear from later
events that the court adopted its tentative.
6
surviving spouse” of decedent, under statutes providing for
survival of a cause of action. (E.g., Code Civ. Proc., § 377.30.)
On December 9, 2021, the court held a hearing on the order
to show cause regarding representation of the estate. By this
time, there was still no attorney representing the estate, and the
court ordered the estate dismissed without prejudice. On
December 9, 2021, the court signed a form order of dismissal
without prejudice of the estate’s complaint. The next day, the
court signed a counsel-prepared order, specifically dismissing (by
number), each cause of action in the second amended complaint
brought by the estate – or, more accurately, each cause of action
brought by wife as decedent’s surviving spouse. HealthCare
Partners served notice of entry of the order of dismissal on
December 16, 2021.
While this order disposed of all of the causes of action
alleged by the estate, it did not resolve the entirety of the action
against HealthCare Partners. The second amended complaint
had added a cause of action for wrongful death, pursued by wife
on her own behalf.
Following the filing of the second amended complaint and
the dismissal of the estate, both Dr. Kossuth and HealthCare
Partners ultimately obtained judgment. Although the relevant
proceedings overlapped chronologically, we discuss the
defendants separately.
4. Dr. Kossuth Ultimately Prevails on Demurrer
Dr. Kossuth had not been successfully served with
plaintiffs’ first amended complaint. She was not served until
February 4, 2022, after the second amended complaint had been
filed.
7
Dr. Kossuth was named in three causes of action in the
second amended complaint: two causes of action brought by wife
as surviving spouse (intentional misrepresentation and
concealment) and wrongful death brought by wife herself.
On March 24, 2022, Dr. Kossuth demurred to the complaint
on the basis that it failed to state facts sufficient to state a cause
of action against her. As to the causes of action brought by wife
as surviving spouse, Dr. Kossuth argued that they had already
been dismissed. As to the wrongful death cause of action, Dr.
Kossuth argued that the allegations of the complaint did not
actually allege any tortious act or omission on the part of Dr.
Kossuth that caused decedent’s death.4
The court found the demurrer was moot as to the two
survival causes of action, as they had already been dismissed. As
to the wrongful death cause of action, the court sustained the
demurrer with 20 days leave to amend.5 Plaintiffs did not amend
4 Factually, this was correct. The wrongful death cause of
action alleged decedent’s death was caused by another doctor’s
order for catheter placement and the nurses’ improperly insertion
of it. Even considering previous allegations incorporated by
references, plaintiffs allege only that Dr. Kossuth ordered hand
restraints; they do not allege that the hand restraints caused
death.
5 The court ruled on Dr. Kossuth’s demurrer at the same
time as demurrers brought by Hospital and Hospice. At least one
of those defendants successfully relied on the statute of
limitations as a defense. Although Dr. Kossuth had not raised
the statute of limitations in her demurrer, the court offered it as
an additional basis for sustaining her demurrer to the wrongful
death cause of action. In her respondent’s brief on appeal, Dr.
8
during that time and, on Dr. Kossuth’s ex parte motion, the court
dismissed the action against her. Judgment was entered in Dr.
Kossuth’s favor on July 11, 2022. Plaintiffs filed their notice of
appeal on August 5, 2022.
5. HealthCare Partners Ultimately Prevails on
Summary Judgment
A. Deemed Admitted Order
HealthCare Partners had submitted requests for admission
to wife. Wife did not answer those requests for admission.
HealthCare Partners moved to deem the matters admitted.6
Wife’s response to this critical motion consisted of a single page of
argument plus another page of conclusion. She argued that:
(1) the “definitions” section of the requests for admission referred
to legal theories, but failed to define them in layperson’s terms;
(2) the requests for admission were “not related to any facts as
alleged” in the operative complaint; and (3) the requests for
admission improperly sought admissions related to legal theories,
not facts.7
Kossuth does not rely on the statute of limitations, and we
therefore do not address it.
6 Although plaintiffs have included in the record on appeal
some discovery-related documents, most of those documents do
not relate to HealthCare Partners’ motion to deem admitted their
unanswered requests for admission to wife. Plaintiffs have
included in the appellate record wife’s opposition to that motion;
but not the motion, the discovery request itself, or, in fact, the
court’s ruling on the motion.
7 Here, wife quoted a single request for admission: “Admit
that these requesting Defendants did not commit PHYSICAL
ABUSE on decedent.” She argued that physical abuse is a legal
9
In December 2021, the trial court ordered the matters
deemed admitted, on the basis that wife had failed to serve
timely responses to the requests.8
B. Summary Judgment
The deemed-admitted order was devastating to wife’s
remaining wrongful death cause of action against HealthCare
Partners. HealthCare Partners obtained summary judgment on
the basis that, as part of that order, wife was deemed to have
admitted that the care and treatment HealthCare Partners
rendered was at all times appropriate and that no act or omission
on their part had caused decedent’s death.9
Summary judgment was granted in favor of HealthCare
Partners on April 1, 2022. Wife immediately moved for
reconsideration, on the basis that her answers to HealthCare
Partners’ interrogatories raised a triable issue of fact.10 The court
theory, not a fact. As the requests for admission are not part of
the record on appeal, we do not know how the capitalized phrase
“PHYSICAL ABUSE” was defined by HealthCare Partners for
the purpose of the requests for admission.
8 We know this ruling from the court’s tentative, which wife
subsequently attached as an exhibit to a later motion, as well as
other filings referring to it.
9 The appellate record provided by plaintiffs contains neither
the motion for summary judgment nor any of the briefing on it.
Plaintiffs limit their record to the trial court’s tentative order
granting the motion. (Although the respondents’ appendix
submitted by HealthCare Partners contains, as an exhibit to
another document, the motion for summary judgment itself, it
does not include the supporting documents or points and
authorities.)
10
entered judgment for HealthCare Partners on May 31, 2022. On
July 27, 2022, the court denied reconsideration on the basis that
it lacked jurisdiction, but indicated that the reconsideration
motion would not have changed the result. As noted above,
plaintiffs filed their notice of appeal on August 5, 2022.
6. Briefing on Appeal
As we have discussed, Hospital and Hospice have been
dismissed from the appeal (and the appeal has been stayed as to
Skilled Nursing Facility). However, the dismissals and stay did
not occur until after plaintiffs, still proceeding without counsel,
had filed their opening brief.11 That brief does not separate out
arguments by defendant, and instead takes a holistic approach to
showing error, mainly arguing that (1) the allegations of the
complaint and lodged exhibits support claims for relief; and
(2) the trial court exhibited bias and unfairness against them.
10 Wife’s answers to the interrogatories were quite superficial,
and simply referred to the allegations of the complaint and the
exhibits lodged by son.
11 At no point before the trial court or on appeal did son argue
that he was proceeding as anything but a propria persona
litigant. However, the proofs of service plaintiffs submitted with
their appellate briefs indicate service was made by son, with the
state bar No. 240532, of the “Law Office of Alex Alers.” We take
judicial notice of the information on the California State Bar’s
website pertaining that bar number. Those records indicate that
son was, at one time, licensed to practice law. He was ordered
inactive prior to the filing of the complaint in this matter, and
was disbarred shortly thereafter, on October 31, 2020.
<https://apps.calbar.ca.gov/attorney/Licensee/Detail/240532> [as
of June 11, 2024] archived at <https://perma.cc/YBU9-SYQK>.
We caution son against further representations that he is
licensed to practice, whether intentional or inadvertent.
11
Only in the course of these arguments and in their conclusion do
they argue the court erred in the key rulings at issue in the
appeal: (3) the demurrer ruling barring the estate from litigating
in propria persona; (4) the dismissal in favor of Dr. Kossuth;
(5) the order deeming admitted HealthCare Partners’ requests for
admission against wife (erroneously described as the court
“order[ing] judicial notice” of the requests); and (6) the grant of
HealthCare Partners’ motion for summary judgment.
After Dr. Kossuth and HealthCare Partners filed their
respective respondent’s briefs focusing on the dispositive rulings,
plaintiffs filed a reply. The reply brief, however, does not address
the merits. Instead, plaintiffs have used their reply brief to:
(7) seek reconsideration of our order dismissing their appeal as to
Hospital and Hospice; (8) contend that no timely respondent’s
briefs were actually filed; and (9) argue that Skilled Nursing
Facility’s bankruptcy filing constituted an admission of the
merits of this action which should result in an immediate
judgment against Skilled Nursing Facility (and, through
conspiracy allegations, also be binding against Health Care
Partners). This final argument prompted Skilled Nursing
Facility to file a motion to strike the reply brief and request for
sanctions, for violating the automatic bankruptcy stay. We
decline to impose sanctions but disregard this improper
argument.
DISCUSSION
1. Plaintiffs’ Argument as to the Merits of their
Complaint Is Irrelevant
The majority of plaintiffs’ opening brief is devoted to a
rehash of the allegations of their complaint and an argument
12
that, factually, they have made sufficient allegations to support
each cause of action alleged.
But, with the exception of the order sustaining Dr.
Kossuth’s demurrer to wife’s wrongful death cause of action,
which we discuss below, none of the rulings at issue on this
appeal implicate the sufficiency of plaintiffs’ allegations. This
argument is therefore irrelevant.
2. Plaintiffs’ Argument as to Judicial Bias Is
Unsupported by the Record
“ ‘[I]t is a fundamental principle of appellate procedure that
a trial court judgment is ordinarily presumed to be correct and
the burden is on the appellant to demonstrate, on the basis of the
record presented to the appellate court, that the trial court
committed an error that justifies reversal of the judgment.
[Citations.]’ [Citation.] ‘This means that an appellant must do
more than assert error and leave it to the appellate court to
search the record and the law books to test his claim. The
appellant must present an adequate argument including citations
to supporting authorities and to relevant portions of the record.’ ”
(L.O. v. Kilrain (2023) 96 Cal.App.5th 616, 619-620.) If a party
fails to support an argument with necessary citations to the
record, the argument is deemed to have been waived. (Id. at
p. 620.) This rule applies equally to parties represented by
counsel and self-represented parties. (Ibid.)
In plaintiffs’ brief, they argue that the trial court was
biased against them, based on any number of statements the trial
court allegedly made.12 There is no citation to the record for any
12 For example, plaintiffs represent that the trial judge
“stated at the multiple discovery hearings that he had over 700
cases before his Court. He did not have the time to read nor
13
of these statements and our review of the record reveals no
evidence of them. With no evidence to support this argument, it
is considered waived.
3. The Estate Could Not Proceed In Propria Persona
The vast bulk of the causes of action in plaintiffs’ first
amended complaint were not brought directly by wife and/or son,
but were pursued on behalf of the estate. When the trial court
concluded that plaintiffs could not litigate in propria persona on
behalf of the estate, plaintiffs amended their complaint to
reassert the same causes of action, but replace the estate plaintiff
with wife as decedent’s “surviving spouse.” The trial court
concluded this recharacterization made no difference, and
dismissed those causes of action pursuant to its prior order.
The court’s initial ruling, that plaintiffs could not represent
the estate in propria persona, was correct. “[A] conservator,
executor, or personal representative of a decedent’s estate who is
unlicensed to practice law cannot appear in propria persona on
behalf of the estate in matters outside the probate proceedings.”
(Hansen v. Hansen (2003) 114 Cal.App.4th 618, 619.) While
unlicensed individuals can represent their own interests in legal
proceedings, they cannot represent the interests of others. (Id. at
p. 621.)
consider the Plaintiffs’ opposition papers. He was going to make
his decision regarding the Discovery issues based sole[l]y upon
the arguments of the Defendants. If the Defendants’ arguments
made logical sense, he planned to rule in the Defendant’s favor
and levy sanctions against the Plaintiffs for failure to answer the
Defendant’s interrogatories, also including but not limited to, the
Court’s finding of judicial notice of admissions of facts against the
Plaintiffs.”
14
The question next raised is whether wife could avoid this
prohibition by recasting the claims by the estate as claims
brought by “herself as the surviving spouse of the [e]state” and by
invoking the statutes governing survival of causes of action. She
cannot. Preliminarily, she has not alleged a sufficient basis to
pursue the causes of action under the survival statute. Code of
Civil Procedure section 377.30 provides, “A cause of action that
survives the death of the person entitled to commence an action
or proceeding passes to the decedent’s successor in interest
[subject to identified sections of the Probate Code] and an action
may be commenced by the decedent’s personal representative or,
if none, by the decedent’s successor in interest.”13 A “surviving
spouse” is not necessarily a successor in interest nor a personal
representative of the estate – she may be either, both, or neither.
Moreover, the survival doctrine alone cannot solve plaintiffs’
representation problem. If wife is purporting to pursue these
causes of action as the personal representative of the estate,
rather than for herself as a sole successor in interest, she would
still be representing others’ interests, and be barred from
proceeding in propria persona.
In short, plaintiffs’ amendment of their pleading did not
resolve the issue that they could not pursue causes of action on
behalf of the estate in propria persona, and the court did not err
in dismissing those claims.
13 Code of Civil Procedure section 377.32 requires that a
person who seeks to pursue a survival action under these
provisions, “shall execute and file an affidavit or a declaration
under penalty of perjury” setting forth the factual basis for their
right to pursue the action. There is no evidence in the record that
wife complied with this provision.
15
4. Wife Has Not Established Error in the Dismissal of
Dr. Kossuth
The discussion portion of plaintiffs’ brief does not contain
any express arguments against the dismissal in favor of Dr.
Kossuth; instead, those arguments are briefly made in the
conclusion section of their brief.14 These arguments violate the
Rules of Court, which require briefs to state each point under a
separate hearing and support it by argument and, if possible,
citation to authority. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.204(a)(1)(B).)
We consider these arguments as forfeited and decline to consider
them. (People v. Lombardo (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 553, 565, fn. 6.)
5. Wife Has Not Established Error in the Order Deeming
Matters Admitted
Wife suggests the trial court erred in granting HealthCare
Partners’ motion to deem admitted its requests for admission.
The record wife submitted on appeal does not contain the
requests for admission themselves or HealthCare Partners’
motion to deem them admitted; wife’s record on this issue
consists only of her opposition to the motion.
14 Specifically, plaintiffs raise a new issue, suggesting –
contrary to their representation in the case management
statement – that Dr. Kossuth was properly served with the first
amended complaint and plaintiffs were therefore entitled to
default judgment against her. Following that argument,
plaintiffs’ reply brief simply states, with no argument or citation
to authority, “Plaintiffs have stated sufficient facts in the [second
amended complaint] to constitute a valid cause of action, or in the
alternative, the Plaintiffs should be permitted to amend the
[second amended complaint].” But plaintiffs were, in fact,
granted leave to amend as to Dr. Kossuth, but failed to do so.
16
“It is the appellant’s affirmative duty to show error by an
adequate record. [Citation.] ‘A necessary corollary to this rule
[is] that a record is inadequate, and appellant defaults, if the
appellant predicates error only on the part of the record he
provides the trial court, but ignores or does not present to the
appellate court portions of the proceedings below which may
provide grounds upon which the decision of the trial court could
be affirmed.’ ” (Osgood v. Landon (2005) 127 Cal.App.4th 425,
435.) Wife has failed in her duty to provide an adequate record,
and has defaulted in her burden to establish error.
In any event, Code of Civil Procedure section 2033.280
provides that if a party fails to timely respond to requests for
admission, the requesting party may move for an order that the
truth of the matters be deemed admitted. “The court shall make
this order, unless it finds that the party to whom the requests for
admission have been directed has served, before the hearing on
the motion, a proposed response to the requests for admission
that is in substantial compliance” with statutory requirements.
(§ 2033.280, subd. (c).) Even on the limited appellate record wife
provided, there is no indication that she ever served a proposed
response to the requests for admission. The court’s order
deeming the matters admitted was therefore mandatory.
6. Wife Has Not Established Error in the Grant of
Summary Judgment in Favor of HealthCare Partners
Following dismissal of the causes of action wife purported
to pursue on behalf of the estate, her only cause of action against
HealthCare Partners was for wrongful death. The court granted
summary judgment on this cause of action based on the requests
for admission it had deemed admitted against wife.
17
On appeal, wife contends this ruling was error. On appeal,
we review a summary judgment ruling de novo. (Jackson v. Lara
(2024) 100 Cal.App.5th 337, 343.) In practical effect, we assume
the role of the trial court and apply the same rules and standards
governing the trial court’s resolution of the motion. (Ibid.)
Again, we conclude the appellate record provided is
inadequate for this review. Wife provided only the trial court’s
tentative ruling granting the motion – a document that is
irrelevant to our de novo review. Even with the motion itself
having been provided by HealthCare Partners, our record still
lacks all supporting documents, points and authorities, and
briefing on the motion. We cannot review what we do not have.
That said, even on the skeletal summary judgment record
we have, it is apparent that the trial court did not err. “ ‘[A]
deemed admitted order establishes, by judicial fiat, that a
nonresponding party has responded to the requests by admitting
the truth of all matters contained therein.’ [Citation.] Any
matter deemed to have been admitted ‘is conclusively established
against the party making the admission’ . . . .” (Inzunza v.
Naranjo (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 736, 742.) It was thus
conclusively established that the care and treatment HealthCare
Partners rendered was at all times appropriate and that no act or
omission on their part caused decedent’s death. This justifies
judgment against wife on her wrongful death cause of action
against HealthCare Partners.
7. Plaintiffs’ Challenge to the Dismissal of Hospital and
Hospice Is Untimely
In their reply brief on appeal, plaintiffs argue that the
previous order dismissing their appeal against Hospital and
Hospice should be vacated. It is too late to raise that argument.
18
The motions to dismiss of Hospital and Hospice were granted on
August 28, 2023. A partial remittitur, indicating the order of
dismissal had become final, issued November 6, 2023. Three
months later, when we no longer have jurisdiction over the action
against Hospital and Hospice, plaintiffs attempt to seek
reconsideration of the dismissal. That portion of this matter is
simply no longer before us.
8. Plaintiffs’ Suggestion That No Timely Respondents’
Briefs Were Filed Is Belied by the Record
Finally, plaintiffs argue that neither Dr. Kossuth nor
HealthCare Partners filed a timely respondent’s brief. They
argue that this is so “according to the Court Clerk of Division
Five,” but provide no evidence supporting this assertion.
Our record contradicts plaintiffs’ assertion. Their opening
brief was filed on March 21, 2023. Respondents were therefore
required to file their briefs within 30 days, unless an extension
was granted by stipulation or the presiding justice. (Cal. Rules of
Court, rule 8.212.) On April 20, 2023, the 30th day, the presiding
justice granted Dr. Kossuth an extension to June 20, 2023. She
timely filed her respondent’s brief on June 13, 2023. HealthCare
Partners’ extension path was more convoluted, but no less valid.
If a party fails to timely file a respondent’s brief, the clerk must
notify the party and grant an additional 15 days, before any
sanction may follow. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.220(a).) At no
point did such a notice issue to HealthCare Partners, nor did
plaintiffs ever move to strike HealthCare Partners’ brief as
untimely filed. Their decision to disregard the brief, based solely
on their independent belief that it was untimely, is made at their
peril.
19
DISPOSITION
The judgment of dismissal in favor of Dr. Kossuth and the
summary judgment in favor of HealthCare Partners are affirmed.
Plaintiffs shall pay Dr. Kossuth’s and HealthCare Partners’ costs
on appeal.
LEE, J.*
WE CONCUR:
MOOR, Acting P. J.
KIM, J.
Judge of the San Bernardino County Superior Court,
assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of
the California Constitution.
20
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.