In re D.T. CA4/2

CourtListener 9509472Calctapp31.05.2024

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 5/31/24 In re D.T. CA4/2

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

In re D.T. et al., Persons Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.

SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY
CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES, E082126

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super.Ct.Nos. J292608, J292609,
J292610)
v.
OPINION
S.T.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from the Superior Court of San Bernardino County. Annemarie G.

Pace, Judge. Affirmed.

Jack A. Love, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and

Appellant.

Tom Bunton, County Counsel and Landon Villavaso, Deputy County Counsel, for

Plaintiff and Respondent.

1
I. INTRODUCTION

Defendant and appellant S.T. (Father) appeals August 30, 2023 orders denying

Father reunification services for his three children, S.T., J.T., and D.T., pursuant to

Welfare and Institutions Code section 361.5, subdivisions (b)(3) and (b)(7).1 Father

claims that even if these bypass provisions apply, and authorized the court to bypass or

deny services for Father, the court erred in denying services for Father because it was in

the children’s best interests to reunify with Father. (§ 361.5, subd. (c)(2).) We conclude

1) the bypass provisions apply, and 2) the court did not abuse its discretion in concluding

it would not be in the best interest of the children to reunify with Father, and therefore, to

deny Father reunification services. Thus, we affirm the orders bypassing Father’s

services.

II. FACTS AND PROCEDURE

A. Background

Father and A.G. (the mother) are the parents of S.T., a boy born 2011, J.T., a girl

born in 2015, and D.T., a boy born in 2017. In March 2022, the mother and children

were living with the mother’s boyfriend, M.F. The mother and children had not seen

Father since September 2021 when Father was arrested and jailed for violating a 2019

domestic violence restraining order in favor of the mother. Father was released from

custody on March 6, 2022.

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.

2
On March 21, 2022, D.T., then age four, was taken to a hospital emergency room

and found to have severe physical injuries consistent with nonaccidental trauma: two

spinal fractures, six rib fractures in an “L” shape on his left side, a third degree burn on

his left leg, a cut in a “Y” shape on his left hand, bruises on his body and head in different

stages of healing, including bruising on his penis and on the inside of his lower lip. The

incident was referred to plaintiff and respondent, San Bernardino County Children and

Family Services (CFS).

When a social worker questioned D.T. about his injuries at the hospital, D.T. said

M.F. had been “hurting him” by pouring hot water on him and by putting M.F.’s hand on

D.T.’s mouth so that D.T. could not breathe. When asked whether he wanted to see MF.,

D.T. said, “no because he [is] mean. He make[s] me bleed.” When asked whether he

wanted to see his mother, D.T. said, “no, she’s not gonna pick me up anymore.” When

asked whether he wanted to see Father, D.T. said, “no, [Father] [s]creamed at me. Made

me cry at my normal house.”

The mother gave inconsistent versions of how D.T. sustained his injuries. Mother

reported she was married to Father but had had no contact with Father since September

2021, when Father was arrested for violating a domestic violence restraining order

granted in favor of the mother. The mother said she lived with the children and that her

boyfriend, M.F., only “randomly” spent the night. The mother worked full time, and

M.F.’s mother watched D.T. while the mother was at work and S.T. and D.T. were at

school. M.F. watched S.T. and D.T., but not J.T., when the mother would “go on a quick

errand.” S.T. and J.T. denied knowing how D.T. was injured. After speaking with the

3
mother and children, CFS took the children into protective custody. Given the ongoing

police investigation of D.T.’s injuries, CFS was unable to speak with M.F.

CFS attempted to locate Father and found no address but discovered Father was

arrested for domestic violence on September 2, 2021 and released from custody on March

6, 2022. On March 23, 2022, Father called CFS after the maternal grandmother told

Father the children were in protective custody. Father confirmed he had been released

from custody around two weeks earlier and said he had not seen the children “in months”

due to the restraining order against him. Father said he would like the children in his

care, and he was in the process of submitting “paperwork” in the family court to obtain

custody of the children.

B. The Section 300 Petitions and Detention Hearing (March 2022)

On March 24, 2022, CFS filed petitions alleging the children were described in

section 300, subdivisions (a), (b)(1), (c), (d), (e), (g), and (i). The petitions alleged D.T.

suffered non-accidental, serious, and repeated physical harm while in the care of his

mother; the mother failed to protect D.T. from serious physical harm, serious emotional

damage, and sexual abuse; the parents engaged in domestic violence with each other in

the presence of the children; all of this conduct placed all three children at risk. On

March 25, the children were ordered detained outside parental custody. Father was

granted supervised visitation, but the mother was ordered to have no contact with the

children. Father waived his trial rights on the allegations and agreed to participate in

predispositional reunification services, including on-demand drug testing and domestic

violence classes.

4
C. Further Investigation of the Section 300 Allegations (March 2022 to June 2022)

1. M.F.’s Abuse of D.T.

M.F. admitted to police he “lost it” and physically abused D.T. after D.T. “acted

out’ at a theme park on March 9. M.F. grabbed and pulled D.T. by the arm, causing

D.T.’s arm to swell. In a second incident on March 19, apparently at mother’s home with

the children, M.F. took D.T. to the “restroom,” sat D.T. on the toilet, and, when asked

whether he had peed, D.T. said “no, not yet.” M.F. then grabbed D.T.’s arm and pulled

on D.T. to get up, then “punched” D.T. four times on D.T.’s back while D.T. was seated

on the toilet. M.F. then grabbed D.T. “from each side of his torso, lifted him and

slammed [him] down to the floor with force,” then squeezed D.T’s torso with both hands

after D.T. “landed on the tile floor.” D.T. continued to cry, so M.F. slapped D.T. across

the face. M.F. reported the Mother, S.T. and J.T. were “in the bedroom” when the March

19 incident occurred. M.F. denied causing injury to D.T.’s penis. The mother provided

several versions of how D.T. was injured, changed her statements several times, and had

no explanation for some of D.T’s injuries. The mother did not seek medical attention for

D.T. until March 21, 2022 because M.F. “begged” the mother not to.

2. The Children’s April 25 Forensic Interviews

In a forensic interview on April 25 2022, D.T. said M.F. made him scared and he

did not want to live with his mother and M.F. D.T. said his mother burned his foot

because “she hates me”, and M.F. broke his hand, poked his eyes with his fingers, and hit

D.T. on multiple occasions. In separate forensic interviews, S.T. and J.T. said M.F.

5
would hit D.T. on his buttocks, arms, legs, and chest with a belt, flip-flop/slipper and

hands resulting in bruising and red marks.”

3. The Parents’ History of Domestic Violence

Regarding the parents’ history of domestic violence, CFS obtained police reports

from November 9, 2019, October 3, 2020, and September 1, 2021. The November 9

report showed Father was arrested for domestic violence with the mother on November 9,

2019 “after an argument turned physical.” The mother reported Father punched the

mother in the nose, causing the mother’s nose to bleed. S.T. told officers his parents

were arguing because Father “did not want to pay bills anymore.” Based on the

November 2019 incident, the mother obtained a domestic violence restraining order

against Father.

On October 3, 2020, Father was arrested for violating the restraining order after he

entered the mother’s home in violation of the order, and the mother locked herself and

J.T. in a bathroom. On September 1, 2021, Father was again arrested for violating the

restraining order. At that time, the mother said the children told the mother that Father

had been “yelling at” the children and “putting them down” “throughout the day.” The

mother saw that Father was “acting strange.” Father “disclosed methamphetamine use”

to police. For violating the restraining order, Father was in jail from September 1, 2021

until March 6, 2022.

Father admitted having a history of domestic violence with the mother in the

presence of the children. Father reported the mother was “very jealous” and a “big

woman” who was “aggressive” and “violent” toward Father. The mother once held

6
Father against a wall, hid Father’s car keys and shoes, and slapped Father. After Father

tired of the mother’s behavior and began hitting her back, Father was arrested in 2019,

and the restraining order was issued against Father. Father claimed the order was

modified in 2020 to a peaceful contact order, but he and the mother lived in the same

property, and the mother continued to call law enforcement. Father claimed he no longer

used alcohol or any controlled substances including methamphetamine. Father was

referred for counseling, domestic violence, parenting, and drug testing services.

The mother claimed that, sometime before September 2021, the mother and Father

used drugs together (cocaine and methamphetamine) for six months. The mother said

Father “would pick fights with her when he was coming down from drugs and he would

yell more,” and was under the influence of drugs when he was arrested in September

2021 for violating the restraining order.

4. Additional Evidence

On April 2, 2022, a paternal cousin said the paternal grandmother (PGM) had

raised the children since birth. The PGM lived with both parents, then the mother, until

February 2022 when the mother moved away with the children and cut off all contact

with the paternal family. According to the paternal cousin, the parents had marital issues

due to the mother cheating on the Father. In December 2021, the paternal family learned

the mother had been seeing M.F.

The PGM reported the mother was “aggressive” toward all of the children with a

belt and hands, and the PGM and Father would intervene to protect the children from the

7
mother when the parents, children, and PGM lived together. The PGM said she was

“more of a mother figure” for the children and the mother was “rarely home.”

On April 26, 2022, the maternal grandmother (MGM) reported she had been

caring for the children while the mother was at work, before the mother moved away with

the children in February 2022. At that point, M.F. would not allow the mother to answer

her phone or have contact with the maternal family, and the MGM did not know where

the mother and children were living. The MGM later disclosed she saw bruising on

D.T.’s cheeks, butt, and legs, in February 2002 and questioned the mother about the

bruises. The mother, S.T., and J.T. told the MGM that D.T. hurt himself while playing

on a bunk bed. The MGM also said Father had a substance abuse issue which caused the

mother to have to work two jobs.

In April and May 2022, Father tested negative for controlled substances, and he

was participating in services, including domestic violence classes and counseling. CFS

reported Father was “very communicative” and had been “nothing less than cooperative”

with CFS. Father was also “very mindful” of D.T.’s medical needs. A paternal aunt

reported Father was working six to seven days per week, attending church, and going to

the gym. In therapy, Father was presenting with posttraumatic stress symptoms due to

M.F.’s severe physical abuse of D.T., and Father was “learning to use coping

mechanisms (deep breathing, stretching,

walking away) to deal with stressors and anxiety.”

8
D. Father’s Initial Visits with the Children

On March 30, 2022. Father had his first supervised visit with S.T. and J.T. Father,

S.T., and J.T. were laughing and playing together, and J.T. went to Father for comfort

when she heard screaming from another room. Father had his first visit with D.T. on

April 2. D.T. was still unable to walk due to his injuries but was comfortable engaging

with Father, smiled at and reached for father, and cried for Father at the end of the visit.

Father was always appropriate with the children during his weekly supervised visits;

Father came prepared with games and activities and engaged well with the children. On

several occasions, the children asked about returning to father’s care.

On May 10, 2022, Father’s visits were liberalized to unsupervised. On June 18,

J.T. reported Father yelled at her and her siblings during an unsupervised visit. J.T.

denied she was fearful of Father and explained Father became upset at the children and

told them they need to respect Father.

On July 5, 2022, a maternal cousin called CFS to report that Father was no longer

living in her home with D.T. Father left the home with D.T. on July 5, the day after the

cousin and Father had a disagreement. The cousin said Father was “upset” due to

“stressors such as work,” CFS’s involvement in his life, and the fact S.T. and J.T. were

not in his care. On July 7, S.T. and J.T. reported Father yelled at them and kicked a trash

can during an unsupervised visit on July 6. S.T. and J.T. said Father had been “upset

lately.”

On July 11, 2022, CFS held a meeting to address Father’s behavior. Father told

CFS he was having a difficult time because S.T. and J.T. were not in his care, and he felt

9
sad and depressed because he was on a budget and unable to buy the children things.

CFS stressed the importance of Father using his coping skills and support network. S.T.

and J.T. participated in the meeting and said that even though Father yelled at them

during their past two visits, they looked forward to visiting Father and wanted to live with

Father. D.T. reported feeling happy and safe in Father’s care. D.T. was described as

“extremely bonded” to Father.

E. The Original Jurisdiction and Disposition Orders (July 2022)

On July 28, 2022, at the combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing on the

section 300 petitions, the court dismissed the subdivision (g) allegations (that the mother

left the children with no provision for support) and found the other allegations true. The

court denied reunification services for the mother (§ 361.5, subds. (b)(5), (b)(6)), found

Father was the children’s presumed father, returned D.T. to Father’s care with family

maintenance services, and granted Father reunification services for S.T. and J.T. who

remained in foster care.

On January 23, 2023, CFS reported D.T. was doing well in Father’s care. Father

was taking D.T. to his medical appointments and D.T.’s injuries had mostly healed. D.T.

was meeting his developmental milestones but he was referred to a neurologist for his eye

injury and for mental health services. Father was still participating in services; he had

completed a parenting program, 35 of 52 domestic violence classes, and he was attending

10
individual counseling.2 Father reported he had learned coping skills in counseling.

Father was renting a three-bedroom, three-bath home for himself and all three children in

anticipation of having J.T. and S.T. returned to his care. On January 30, 2023, the court

continued D.T. in Father’s care and returned S.T. and J.T. to Father’s care, with family

maintenance services for all the children.

F. The Section 342 and 387 Petitions (May 2023)

On May 1, 2023, three months after J.T. and S.T. were returned to Father’s care,

CFS filed subsequent and supplemental petitions for the children pursuant to sections 342

and 387. The petitions alleged that on four occasions between February 24, 2023 and

April 24, 2023, Father physically abused 11-year old S.T. by punching and slapping S.T.

on the face very hard, multiple times, and Father’s conduct placed all three children at

risk of similar abuse.

1. Background

On February 24, 2023, J.T. disclosed that Father yelled at her and her siblings for

no reason, and that one day Father “walked out of the kitchen and hit [S.T.] across the

face really hard.” J.T. said Father said J.T. and the children were “not supposed to say

anything and not cause any trouble” and J.T. was scared to go home to Father. CFS

concluded the referral would not be substantiated because the discipline Father used did

not rise to the level of abuse.

2 The domestic violence classes were a condition of Father’s probation for
violating the 2019 restraining order. Father was in compliance with the conditions of his
probation.

11
On March 7, 2023, S.T. disclosed Father hit him on his face very hard. CFS found

this referral, too, would not be substantiated, but referred Father to counseling and

advised him to use other forms of discipline. On March 16, S.T. disclosed Father

“socked him on the jaw” two weeks earlier, and that on March 15, Father again “socked

him on the jaw and slapped his face with an open hand.” S.T. said he did not want to be

around Father and feared returning home; Father would get angry and tell S.T. he does

not like his attitude, then Father would hit S.T. S.T. had no observable marks or bruises.

CFS concluded the March 15 incident would also be unsubstantiated. On April 24,

another referral was made alleging Father’s physical and emotional abuse of S.T. CFS

decided to file the section 342 and 387 petitions while still investigating the April 24

referral.

The children were interviewed separately at school on April 25, 2023. D.T. said

he had heard S.T. crying from Father smacking S.T., but D.T. did not remember the day

he heard the smacking. J.T. said she saw Father put his hand on S.T.’s face, but it was

“not hard.” S.T. said he left home on April 24, after he talked to the social worker, and

he went to the home of his prior foster parents, because Father looked like Father was

going to hit S.T. When asked to explain, S.T. said Father clenched his fist, appeared

angry, and told S.T. to “stop bothering him.” S.T. was very frightened, held his hands up

to block his face, and repeatedly apologized to Father. S.T. said Father was “imagining”

that the children were “intentionally trying to agitate him when they do something on

accident.” S.T. confirmed that the prior referrals of Father hitting S.T. were true. S.T.

wanted to live with the PGM.

12
When interviewed on April 26, 2022, Father said he was unsure why S.T. was

alleging Father was physically and emotionally abusive toward S.T., and S.T. had no

reason to feel threatened. Father said S.T. would try to find ways to make Father angry,

but Father would try to ignore S.T.’s behavior. The children were taken into protective

custody.

2. Detention

At a detention hearing on May 2, 2022, the court detained the children from Father

and allowed Father weekly, two-hour supervised visits. On May 25, CFS interviewed

each child about the allegations of Father’s physical

abuse. Father declined to discuss the allegations with CFS.

3. The Children’s Further Interviews

In his May 25 interview, S.T. recalled the February 24 referral was made because

Father slapped S.T. hard on his cheek “for no reason” when S.T., J.T., and D.T. were

sitting on the living room couch watching television. S.T. recalled that Father told S.T.

that S.T. was bothering Father and to stop it.

S.T. explained that the March 7 referral occurred after S.T. asked his former foster

brother, who attended S.T.’s school, to tell S.T.’s former foster father to notify S.T.’s

social worker that Father was hitting S.T. By that time, Father had been hitting S.T. more

frequently, “every few days,” by slapping S.T. with his open hand. The slapping

incidents did not cause any marks or bruises, but one of the slaps made S.T.’s face hurt

for a few days. When asked why Father was slapping him, S.T. said Father would

13
complain that S.T. was “bothering” Father, but S.T. would not be doing anything to

bother Father.

S.T. described the March 16 referral as Father “sock[ing]” S.T. on the jaw with a

closed fist, which hurt for a while. S.T. sometimes feared going home because he felt

Father would hit him. S.T. said the April 24 referral occurred because Father asked S.T.

to take out the trash, and S.T. told Father he would do so after he ate. Father raised his

hand as if he was going to hit S.T., but S.T. apologized, pleaded with Father not to hit

him, and Father did not hit him. S.T. ate, took the trash out, then went to his prior foster

home and reported the incident. Following the incident, Father asked S.T. why S.T. “acts

out,” and S.T. told Father he acted out because he wanted to live with the PGM. S.T. felt

he did not misbehave with Father and said Father was always angry at him and his

siblings for no reason.

S.T. reported he and Father had a good relationship when S.T. was younger.

Father never hit him and was a good provider to the family. S.T. recalled the family lived

in Washington when S.T. was younger, but returned to California because they did not

have enough money. They moved into the MGM’s garage, then Father went to jail. S.T.

said Father’s “mindset is different” now because Father was very worried about what the

mother and M.F. had done to D.T. S.T. confirmed he did not want to live with Father

because he did not believe he would be safe with Father even if Father were to get help,

but he wanted to visit Father.

J.T. said Father had never hit her, but she felt scared when Father yelled at her and

her brothers and when he would say bad words in Spanish. Father would accuse J.T. and

14
S.T. of saying bad words to Father, but J.T. said Father was “hearing things” and had

falsely accused S.T. of saying “F. . . you” to Father. Father would tell J.T. and S.T. that

they had “ruined his life” and his life would be “different” if they were not at home with

him. J.T. recalled a time when Father “skipped” into the living room, slapped S.T., then

“skipped” back to the kitchen. Father appeared “happy” for having slapped S.T., but J.T.

saw tears on S.T.’s face. Another time, J.T. heard S.T., who was cooking in the kitchen,

“crying and screaming” telling Father to stop hitting him when S.T. was not doing

anything wrong. J.T. wanted to live with the PGM. In his May 25 interview, D.T. said

Father was “mean” to S.T. and J.T., and D.T. recalled hearing Father smack S.T. multiple

times.

4. CFS’s Recommendations

In a June 1, 2023 jurisdiction/disposition report, CFS recommended the court

sustain the allegations of the sections 342 and 387 petitions and deny Father reunification

services for the children pursuant to section 361.5, subdivisions (b)(3) and (b)(7). CFS

concluded Father’s prognosis for reunifying with the children was poor. Father’s

supervised visits with the children were going well, however, and CFS had no concerns

about the visits. A June 6 hearing on the section 342 and 387 petitions was continued for

further assessments.

5. The August 30, 2023 Findings and Orders Denying Father Services

At the August 30, 2023 contested hearing, the court sustained the allegations of

the petitions. Father’s counsel argued section 361.5, subdivisions (b)(3) and (b)(7) did

not apply to Father, and even if the statutes applied, the court should order reunification

15
services for Father because Father could reunify with the children within the next six

months. The court found that the bypass provisions applied and that granting Father

services would not serve the best interest of the children. Father timely appealed.

III. DISCUSSION

Father claims that even if section 361.5, subdivisions (b)(3) and (b)(7) applied and

authorized the court to deny Father services, the court erroneously denied Father services

because reunifying with Father was in the children’s best interest. (§ 361.5, subd. (c)(2).)

We conclude that section 361.5, subdivisions (b)(3) and (b)(7) applied. We also conclude

the court did not abuse its discretion in denying Father services, because substantial

evidence shows the court reasonably determined that reunifying with Father was not in

the children’s best interest. Thus, we find no error in the August 30, 2023 orders.

A. Section 361.5, Subdivisions (b)(3) and (b)(7) Apply

When a child is removed from a parent’s custody, the parent is generally entitled

to reunification services for the child under section 361.5, subdivision (a), unless an

exception set forth in subdivision (b) of the statute applies. “Section 361.5, subdivision

(b) provides exceptions to the general entitlement to reunification services set forth in

section 361.5, subdivision (a).” (In re A.G. (2012) 207 Cal.App.4th 276, 280.)

Under subdivision (b), reunification services “need not be provided” to a parent

when the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that an exception set forth in

section 361.5, subdivision (b) applies. (In re S.B. (2013) 222 Cal.App.4th 612, 622.)

These exceptions allow the court to “bypass” services for the parent and reflect our

16
Legislature’s intent to provide services to parents “only where those services will

facilitate the return of children to parental custody.” (Ibid.)

“Consonant with the general presumption in favor of mandatory reunification

services, the bypass provisions are ‘narrow in scope’ and reach situations where ‘ “the

likelihood of reunification” ’ is ‘ “so slim” ’ due to a parent’s past failures that

‘expend[ing]’ the Department’s ‘ “scarce” ’ resources on reunification services is likely

to be ‘fruitless,’ or when ‘attempts to facilitate reunification’ would otherwise not ‘serve

and protect the child’s interest.’ [Citations.] By making the grant of reunification

services discretionary in these situations, the bypass provisions aim to

‘focus reunification efforts’ and resources on the cases ‘most likely to succeed’

with reunification. [Citation.]” (In re Jayden M. (2023) 93 Cal.App.5th 1261, 1271.)

As relevant, section 361.5, subdivision (b) provides: “(b) “Reunification services

need not be provided to a parent . . . when the court finds, by clear and convincing

evidence . . . [¶] . . . [¶] (3) That the child or a sibling of the child has been previously

adjudicated a dependent pursuant to any subdivision of Section 300 as a result of physical

or sexual abuse, that following that adjudication the child had been removed from the

custody of the child’s parent or guardian pursuant to Section 361, that the child has been

returned to the custody of the parent or guardian from whom the child had been taken

originally, and that the child is being removed pursuant to Section 361, due to additional

physical or sexual abuse. [¶] . . . [¶] (7) That the parent is not receiving reunification

services for a sibling . . . of the child pursuant to paragraph (3). . . .”

17
“If the court finds by clear and convincing evidence that a bypass provision

applies, it must deny services unless the parent proves that services would be in the

child’s best interests. (§ 361.5, subd. (c).) While the parent bears the burden of proof on

that issue, the department bears the burden of proving the threshold issue of whether a

bypass provision applies. [Citation.]” (In re T.R. (2023) 87 Cal.App.5th 1140, 1148.)

We review a juvenile court’s determination that a bypass provision applies for substantial

evidence. (Cheryl P. v. Superior Court (2006) 139 Cal.App.4th 87, 96 & fn. 6.)

Here, the court relied on subdivision (b)(3) of section 361.5, in denying Father

reunification services for S.T. and J.T., and relied on subdivision (b)(7) of the statute in

denying Father services for D.T. Substantial evidence supports the court’s

determinations that these bypass provisions applied.

First, S.T. and J.T. are children described in subdivision (b)(3) of section 361.5.

They are (1) siblings of D.T., a child previously adjudicated a dependent pursuant to

section 300 as a result of physical or sexual abuse; (2) following “that adjudication,” S.T.

and J.T. were removed from the custody of the mother, from whom D.T. was “originally”

taken in the section 300 adjudication for D.T.; (3) S.T. and D.T. were later returned to

Father’s custody; and (4) S.T. and J.T. were later removed from Father’s custody due to

“additional physical abuse” of S.T.

Second, D.T. is a child described in subdivision (b)(7) of section 361.5. That is,

D.T. has a sibling—two siblings, S.T. and J..T.—for whom “the parent,” Father, was not

receiving services pursuant to subdivision (b)(3). (§ 361.5, subd. (b)(7).)

18
Father does not seriously argue section 361.5, subdivisions (b)(3) and (b)(7), do

not apply.3 Rather, Father’s opening brief states, “Father’s position is that even if the

section 361.5, subdivisions (b)(3) and (b)(7) applied, it was in the best interests of the

children for their father to receive reunification services under section 361.5, subdivision

(c)(2).” We turn to this question.

B. The Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion in Concluding Reunification with Father Was

Not in the Children’s Best Interest, and Bypassing Services for Father

Section 361.5, subdivision (c)(2), states: “The court shall not order reunification

for a parent or guardian described in paragraph (3), (4), (6), (7), (8), (9), (10), (11), (12),

(13), (14), (15), (16), or (17) of subdivision (b) unless the court finds, by clear and

convincing evidence, that reunification is in the best interest of the child.”

A juvenile court may consider several factors in determining whether reunification

would be in a child’s best interest, including 1) the parent’s current efforts, fitness, and

history, 2) the gravity of the problem that led to the dependency; 3) the strength of the

3 As Father concedes, section 361.5, subdivision (b)(3) has been interpreted as
applying to a child who was subsequently physically abused even if that child was not the
child who was abused in the prior adjudication. (In re D.F. (2009) 172 Cal.App.4th 538,
545.) That is, the statute does not require the child for whom services “need not be
provided” to be the child who was originally abused; rather, the child for whom services
“need not be provided” may be a sibling of the child who was originally abused. (Ibid.)
Put yet another way, section 361.5, subdivision (b)(3) applies when, as here, the
“additional” or subsequent abuse is to the sibling of the child originally abused. (S.V. v.
Superior Court (2018) 28 Cal.App.5th 671, 676.) This interpretation is in keeping with
the apparent purpose of the statute, which is “to protect children against recidivist abusive
parents.” (Ibid.) Further, the plain language of the statute does not require the parent for
whom services “need not be provided” to be the perpetrator of the original abuse.
(§ 361.5, subd. (b).)

19
parent-child and parent-caretaker bonds; and, 4) the child’s need for stability and

continuity, which is of “paramount concern.” (In re D.F., supra, 172 Cal.App.4th at

p. 547; In re Ethan N. (2004) 122 Cal.App.4th 55, 66-68.) The burden is on the parent to

show that reunification would serve the best interest of the child. (In re A.G., supra, 207

Cal.App.4th 276, 281.) A best interest finding “also requires a likelihood that

reunification services will succeed. [Citation.] ‘In other words, there must be some

‘reasonable basis to conclude’ that reunification is possible before services are offered to

a parent who need not be provided them. [Citation].’ ” (Ibid.)

We review a juvenile court’s best interest finding under section 361.5, subdivision

(c)(2) for an abuse of discretion. (See Cheryl P. v. Superior Court, supra, 139

Cal.App.4th at p. 96, fn. 6.) We will find no abuse of discretion if substantial evidence

shows the court could have reasonably concluded that reunification with the parent who

may be denied reunification services was not in the child’s best interest. (See Ramsden v.

Peterson (2022) 76 Cal.App.5th 339, 345 [an abuse of discretion shown if the child

custody determination is not supported by substantial evidence].)

Father claims it was in the best interest of the children to reunify with Father; thus,

it was in the children’s best interest to offer reunification services to Father at the August

30, 2023 hearing. Father emphasizes that the bypass provisions of section 361.5,

subdivisions (b)(3) and (b)(7) applied only because D.T. suffered physical abuse in the

mother’s care. Father points out he was not living with the family when D.T. was

abused, and Father “was not part of any physical abuse” of D.T. Father also correctly

observes that he cooperated with CFS from the beginning of the case in March 2022, he

20
complied with his case plan, and the children enjoyed visiting Father and being with

Father.

Father also points out that there was no permanent plan for the children—at the

August 30, 2023 hearing, the court found by clear and convincing evidence that there was

a compelling reason not to set section 366.26 hearings for the children because 1)

adoption was not in the children’s best interest at the time, and 2) there was no adult

willing or able to be the children’s legal guardian.

Substantial evidence shows, however, that the court reasonably determined that

reunification with Father was not in the children’s best interest. (§ 361.5, subd. (c)(2).)

As the court noted, Father was aware from the beginning of the case that D.T. had been

“significant[ly]” physically abused, that S.T. and J.T. were removed “for the same risk,”

and that all of the children had experienced “significant trauma.” But Father’s physical

abuse of S.T. caused the children’s second removal in April 2023. As the court also

emphasized, the children feared going home and were told by Father “not to speak about

the abuse they were suffering” in Father’s care. The children also corroborated each

other’s accounts of the Father’s abuse.

As CFS argues, substantial evidence shows Father “had an extensive history of

violent and abusive behavior that was not ameliorated by his participation and completion

of reunification services.” Despite his participation in individual counseling, domestic

violence classes, and parenting classes, Father “continued to exhibit behavior that

evidenced aggression, violence, and a lack of impulse control throughout much of the

case. Indeed, Father yelled at the children during their unsupervised visit with Father in

21
July 2022. Moreover, Father continued to physically abuse S.T. despite referrals to

counseling. And when interviewed in May 2023, S.T. and J.T. said that they did not want

to live with Father because they would not feel safe in Father’s care, even if Father were

to get additional help.

In sum, the court reasonably determined that reunification was not in the

children’s best interest. Although we recognize and commend Father’s efforts at

reunification, the record shows there was no reasonable likelihood that reunification

would succeed. (In re A.G., supra, 207 Cal.App.4th at p. 281.) Thus, the court did not

abuse its discretion in denying reunification services for Father.

IV. DISPOSITION

The August 30, 2023 orders are affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

FIELDS
J.
We concur:

RAMIREZ
P. J.

MENETREZ
J.

22

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.