CourtListener 9507152•In re D.S. CA2/1
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 5/24/24 In re D.S. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
In re D.S. et al., B326179
Persons Coming Under the (Los Angeles County
Juvenile Court Law. Super. Ct. No. 21CCJP04400)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
STACEY R.,
Defendant and Appellant;
JONATHAN S.,
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEALS from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, D. Brett Bianco, Judge. Affirmed.
John L. Dodd, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant Stacey R.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Aileen Wong, Deputy County Counsel,
for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Liana Serobian, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Respondent Jonathan S.
___________________________
Appellant Stacey R. (Mother) asserts the juvenile court
erred in awarding Jonathan S. (Father) sole legal custody over
their three children—D.S. (born 2016), R.S. (born 2018), and I.S.
(born 2019)—when it terminated dependency jurisdiction through
what is commonly referred to as an exit order. Mother asserts
she did not receive proper notice before the hearing where the
court made its legal custody decision, and alternatively that
substantial evidence does not support the court’s award of sole
legal custody to Father. We disagree and affirm the legal custody
order.
During the dependency proceedings involving D.S., R.S.,
and I.S., Mother gave birth to a fourth child, K.R. (born 2022),
who has a different father. The juvenile court asserted
jurisdiction over K.R., and those proceedings remain pending.
Mother separately appeals the jurisdictional findings as to K.R.
We find substantial evidence supports the findings, and affirm
the juvenile court’s exercise of jurisdiction over K.R.
2
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND1
A. Prior Dependency History
In May 2017, the juvenile court sustained a Welfare and
Institutions Code2 section 300 petition alleging D.S. was at risk
based on Mother’s substance abuse and domestic violence. The
court declared D.S. a dependent, removed him from Mother, and
ordered a home-of-parent-father placement. During the
reunification period, Mother did not participate in any court-
ordered treatment programs, which had included a drug and
alcohol treatment program, drug and alcohol testing, therapy,
and a 52-week domestic violence program. The juvenile court
terminated jurisdiction in 2018 through an exit order giving the
parents joint legal custody, Father sole physical custody, and
Mother monitored visitation.
A referral in March 2020 alleged Mother and Father
emotionally abused D.S., R.S., and I.S. When the referral was
investigated, Mother claimed she was the victim of domestic
violence by Father. Father claimed Mother assaulted him while
Mother was intoxicated. The referral was closed as inconclusive.
A little over one year later, in April 2021, the Los Angeles
County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS)
received a referral alleging Mother and Father emotionally
abused and generally neglected the three children. The reporting
party stated Mother was not observing, and Father was not
enforcing, an active domestic violence restraining order against
1 We limit our factual and procedural summary to that
which is relevant to the issues presented by these appeals.
2 All unspecified statutory references are to the Welfare
and Institutions Code.
3
Mother and that the parents engaged in frequent domestic
violence. The reporting party also alleged that the parents used
drugs in the children’s presence, including blowing marijuana
smoke into the children’s faces. DCFS closed the referral as
inconclusive.
B. The Dependency Proceedings at Issue in These
Appeals
1. Initial Referral and Subsequent DCFS Investigation
On July 17, 2021, police arrested Mother for committing
domestic violence against Father. The altercation occurred in the
presence of D.S., R.S., and I.S., and led to a referral to DCFS. On
July 27, 2021, DCFS received a second referral, alleging that
Mother was using drugs and alcohol with Father in the children’s
presence. The referral further discussed the July 17, 2021
domestic violence incident. It stated Mother and Father had
argued. As Mother was leaving their home, she stuffed
something in her purse and then struck Father with the purse,
causing him to fall to the floor unconscious.
Investigation by DCFS showed the following. Mother’s
criminal history included a July 2016 conviction for using or
being under the influence of a controlled substance. Maternal
grandmother expressed concern about Mother and Father’s use of
marijuana and nitrous oxide. Maternal grandmother stated the
parents used nitrous oxide once with a friend inside an
automobile which led to a car crash; the parents did not contact
the police right after the crash because they were high. A
maternal aunt expressed concern about Mother and believed she
needed therapy and other work.
Father reported that Mother smoked marijuana and drank
alcohol. Sometimes Mother was intoxicated while caring for the
4
children. Paternal grandmother reported Mother smoked
marijuana and drank alcohol; paternal grandmother did not
know if Mother used any other substances. Paternal
grandmother stated Mother was drunk and high during a
domestic violence incident between the parents, and that Mother
would inhale nitrous oxide to get high. Mother once got upset
and hit a window with her hand because Father would not give
her marijuana.
DCFS was unable to obtain from Mother detailed
information regarding the July 17, 2021 physical altercation with
Father because Mother made irrational statements and appeared
paranoid. Despite her prior conviction, on at least one occasion
Mother denied being arrested for using or being under the
influence of illegal substances. She admitted smoking marijuana,
but denied using any other drugs and claimed to have stopped
using marijuana in 2021. Mother stated that she drank alcohol,
but not often.
Mother agreed to drug test. She tested negative for drugs
three times between October and December 2021. Mother failed
to test five times from September through December 2021.
2. DCFS Files a Petition as to D.S., R.S., and I.S.
On September 17, 2021, DCFS filed a section 300 petition
on behalf of D.S., R.S., and I.S., alleging Mother and Father had
a history of engaging in violent altercations and that Father had
a history of substance abuse. An amended petition filed
November 18, 2021 additionally alleged substance abuse by both
parents. At a disposition hearing held December 3, 2021, the
juvenile court declared the children dependents of the court and
ordered family reunification services which included for Mother a
full drug and alcohol program with aftercare, weekly random or
5
on-demand drug and alcohol testing, a 12-step program, a 52-
week domestic violence program, parenting education, individual
counseling, compliance with any active restraining or stay away
order, and monitored visits.
A February 24, 2022 last minute information filed with the
court reported that Mother had not yet enrolled in a full drug
program, a 12-step program, a domestic violence program, a
parenting program, or individual counseling. The last minute
information and other reports showed Mother tested negative for
drugs nine times from January 5, 2022 through March 1, 2022.
Mother’s visitation with the children was inconsistent, and she
had difficulty redirecting them when she did visit.
In April 2022, R.S.’s foster parent reported R.S. was
touching herself. R.S. disclosed she witnessed Mother
masturbating in front of her.
A June 8, 2022 status review report reported Mother
continued to be in minimal compliance with her court-ordered
case plan. Mother was drug testing but had not enrolled in any
programs. Mother further tested negative 12 times from
March 11 through May 25, 2022. Her visits with the children
continued to be inconsistent. DCFS had difficulty contacting
Mother, as she rarely responded to calls or texts.
On June 22, 2022, the juvenile court made a home-of-
parent-father order and ordered enhancement services for
Mother. The court further set the matter for a section 364 review
hearing on December 28, 2022, and ordered DCFS to notice all
appropriate parties.
Mother tested negative for drugs when she appeared for
testing, but she missed six drug tests from July 13 to August 19,
2022. During this period, K.R. was born. Mother blamed the
6
missed tests on having to isolate because she had COVID-19 and
needed to recover from K.R.’s birth. Mother tested negative on
August 22 and 29, 2022. Mother failed to test on September 8,
2022. Mother continued to deny any substance abuse problems.
As of September 22, 2022, Mother had not completed any
court-ordered programs; Mother blamed this failure on DCFS not
giving her referrals and not contacting her. Mother had recently
enrolled in drug counseling, parenting classes, and a domestic
violence program. On October 18, 2022, Mother reported that she
still had not enrolled in a substance abuse program or individual
counseling.
Mother tested negative eight times from September 16
through November 1, 2022.
On December 6, 2022, Mother stated she did not have time
to participate in family reunification services and refused those
services. DCFS reported on December 28, 2022 that Mother
continued to minimize the issues that brought D.S., R.S., and I.S.
before the dependency court. Mother took no responsibility for
the children being removed from her care and blamed the
dependency case on Father. Mother further blamed DCFS for her
lack of compliance with the court-ordered case plan.
3. Section 364 Hearing for D.S., R.S., and I.S.
Before the section 364 hearing scheduled for December 28,
2022, DCFS provided notice as ordered to Mother as well as other
parties. The notice stated that DCFS would recommend at the
hearing that the court continue dependency jurisdiction, and that
DCFS continue to provide services to the parents and children.
In a December 28, 2022 status review report, DCFS
reported that Mother had not visited D.S., R.S. or I.S. since June
2022. Mother had not enrolled in or participated in a 12-step
7
program. Mother had taken steps towards completing a domestic
violence and parenting program, and participated in an intake
appointment for individual counseling.
At the section 364 hearing, the juvenile court informed
counsel and the parties that its tentative ruling was to terminate
jurisdiction over D.S., R.S. and I.S. Father’s counsel agreed with
the tentative. Mother’s counsel submitted on the tentative, and
requested the exit order include joint legal custody. Minors’
counsel objected to joint legal custody because of the parties’
contentious relationship and Mother being non-responsive and
“impossible to reach.” She requested instead that Father have
sole legal custody given his track record with the children.
The court ordered dependency jurisdiction terminated upon
entry of an exit order awarding Father sole legal and physical
custody, and Mother monitored visitation, explaining it was
making that order “for the reasons outlined by [minors’ counsel]
particularly this being a [domestic violence] case with Mother
being the aggressor and being difficult and being a contentious
situation.” Mother’s visits were to be monitored because she had
not completed her case plan.
4. DCFS Files a Petition as to K.R.
On November 7, 2022, DCFS filed a section 300 petition on
K.R.’s behalf. The petition alleged Mother had a history of
substance abuse (counts b-1, j-1).3 On November 22, 2022, the
juvenile court found a prima facie case for K.R. and ordered him
3 The petition further alleged Mother had a history of
domestic violence (counts a-1, b-2, and j-2). The court dismissed
these domestic violence counts, and we do not discuss them
further.
8
released to Mother on conditions including that Mother
participate in the court-ordered case plan for K.R.’s siblings,
reside with the maternal grandmother or a DCFS-approved
location, cooperate with DCFS, participate in family preservation
services, test clean with no unexcused drug tests, and make K.R.
available for visits by DCFS.
At the December 28, 2022 adjudication hearing, counsel for
DCFS argued that Mother had a history of substance abuse,
including inhaling nitrous oxide, that was found to be true in the
case of K.R.’s siblings. Counsel also highlighted that Mother
failed to participate regularly in her court-ordered case plan and
minimized her substance abuse history, demonstrating that her
substance abuse issues remained unresolved. K.R.’s counsel
requested the substance abuse allegations against Mother be
sustained, and expressed concern that Mother was drinking and
had a serious issue with nitrous oxide. Mother’s counsel argued
she was enrolled in treatment and her recent drug tests were
negative such that K.R. was not at risk remaining in Mother’s
custody.
The juvenile court sustained counts b-1 and j-1 based on
Mother’s substance abuse. The court declared K.R. a dependent,
found there were services available to prevent removal, made a
home-of-parent-mother order, ordered family reunification
services for Mother, and set the matter for future proceedings.
9
DISCUSSION
A. The Juvenile Court Did Not Err in Awarding Father
Sole Legal Custody Over D.S., R.S., and I.S.
1. Mother Was Not Denied Proper Notice
Mother argues we should reverse the legal custody order as
to D.S., R.S., and I.S. because she was not provided proper notice
beforehand. “ ‘We review procedural due process claims de novo
because “the ultimate determination of procedural fairness
amounts to a question of law.” [Citation.]’ [Citation.]” (In re
L.W. (2020) 44 Cal.App.5th 44, 49.)
Mother first claims that section 292, subdivision (d)
entitled her to pre-hearing notice that the court might award
Father sole legal custody because it provides that “[f]or a section
364 hearing, the [advance] notice must include a statement of
‘any change in the custody or status of the child.’ ” Mother
argues the notice sent to her before the section 364 hearing did
not comply with section 292, subdivision (d) because it did not
state the court might make a change and award Father sole legal
custody.
Mother’s selective quotation of section 292 is misleading, as
is her attempt to isolate that section from the rest of the
statutory scheme. Adding back in what Mother’s quotation
omits, section 292 states in pertinent part: “The social worker . . .
shall give notice of the review hearing held pursuant to [s]ection
364 in the following manner: [¶] . . . [¶] (d) The notice shall
contain a statement regarding the nature of the hearing to be
held and any change in the custody or status of the child being
recommended by the supervising agency.” (§ 292, subd. (d), italics
added.) Section 364, subdivision (c) requires that the juvenile
court terminate jurisdiction at the section 364 hearing “unless
10
the social worker or his or her department establishes by a
preponderance of evidence that the conditions still exist”
justifying continued jurisdiction. (Ibid.) “When the juvenile
court terminates its jurisdiction over a dependent child, section
362.4 authorizes it to make custody and visitation orders . . . .”
(In re Roger S. (1992) 4 Cal.App.4th 25, 30.)
We reject Mother’s assertion that the pre-hearing notice
she received did not comply with the applicable statutes. DCFS
complied with section 292, subdivision (d) by providing Mother
with notice of its recommendation. DCFS did not recommend
sole legal custody or any other order in connection with
terminating jurisdiction; it instead recommended the juvenile
court continue to exercise jurisdiction over the children and order
further enhancement services.4 The juvenile court did not follow
DCFS’s recommendation, and instead independently determined
pursuant to section 364, subdivision (c) that jurisdiction should
be terminated, which necessitated the issuance of an exit order.
No violation of section 292, subdivision (d) occurred.
Mother also suggests making a legal custody order at the
section 364 hearing deprived her of due process distinct from any
statutory requirement. “[D]ue process guarantees apply to
dependency proceedings.” (In re J.P. (2014) 229 Cal.App.4th 108,
125.) “ ‘In juvenile dependency litigation, due process focuses on
the right to notice and the right to be heard.’ [Citation.]” (In re
Vanessa M. (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 1121, 1129.) “[D]ue process
4 As DCFS did not request either the termination of
jurisdiction or sole legal custody to Father, it takes no position on
Mother’s appeal as to the legal custody issue. Father argues we
should affirm the legal custody order.
11
requires ‘notice reasonably calculated, under all the
circumstances, to apprise interested parties of the pendency of
the action and afford them an opportunity to present their
objections.’ [Citation.]” (In re Melinda J. (1991) 234 Cal.App.3d
1413, 1418.)
Mother received notice consistent with these due process
guarantees. Mother was provided advance notice of the section
364 hearing. The statutory purpose of that hearing was for the
court to determine whether to continue exercising jurisdiction
over D.S., R.S., and I.S. As explained above, the governing
statutes further made clear that if the court determined
continued jurisdiction was unnecessary, the court would address
the terms of an exit order terminating jurisdiction. Mother thus
received advance notice that the December 28, 2022 hearing
would address whether the court would continue to exercise
dependency jurisdiction, and if the court decided continued
jurisdiction was unnecessary that it would address the terms
(including custody orders) under which the court would terminate
jurisdiction.
Contrary to Mother’s claim, she was hardly caught
unaware that legal custody might be discussed at the
December 28, 2022 section 364 hearing. Indeed, it was Mother’s
counsel—not anyone else—who first raised the issue of legal
custody at that hearing. Mother did not ask for more time to
address the issue or to present additional evidence on the topic;
she instead asked the court to rule at the hearing that joint legal
custody was appropriate. We find no procedural due process
violation in the court making a legal custody order in response to
Mother’s request.
12
2. Substantial Evidence Supports the Legal Custody
Order
Mother alternatively argues there was no evidentiary basis
for the court’s legal custody award. She argues an award of sole
legal custody is improper in the absence of substantial evidence
that the parents had prior difficulties in making medical or
educational decisions, and that the record contains no such
substantial evidence.
We review the juvenile court’s legal custody decision for
abuse of discretion. (In re J.M. (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th 95, 113.)
When applying this differential standard, “ ‘the trial court’s
findings of fact are reviewed for substantial evidence, its
conclusions of law are reviewed de novo, and its application of the
law to the facts is reversible only if arbitrary and capricious.’
[Citations.]” (In re C.B. (2010) 190 Cal.App.4th 102, 123.)
“Substantial evidence is relevant evidence which adequately
supports a conclusion; it is evidence which is reasonable in
nature, credible and of solid value.” (In re R.C. (2012) 210
Cal.App.4th 930, 941.) “We do not evaluate the credibility of
witnesses, reweigh the evidence, or resolve evidentiary conflicts.
Rather, we draw all reasonable inferences in support of the
findings, consider the record most favorably to the juvenile
court’s order, and affirm the order if supported by substantial
evidence even if other evidence supports a contrary conclusion.”
(In re L.Y.L. (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th 942, 947.)
At the section 364 hearing, after Mother requested joint
legal custody, counsel for D.S., R.S., and I.S. argued for Father
having sole legal custody. Minors’ counsel noted that the parents
had “a really bad relationship” as evidenced by repeated domestic
violence which showed the parents “don’t know how to get along.”
13
Counsel noted Mother was often non-responsive to DCFS, and
there was no reason to expect that if Mother failed to respond to
DCFS during the dependency proceedings she would respond to
Father on legal custody issues—especially because she blamed
Father for the dependency court’s involvement in her life.
The juvenile court agreed with the concerns expressed by
minors’ counsel, and substantial evidence supports the court’s
findings. Mother and Father had a contentious relationship.
Although there was no recent domestic violence between them as
they were no longer living together, Mother had not gotten very
far in programs ordered by the court to address her domestic
violence. Mother was unresponsive to DCFS during the
dependency proceedings, and it was reasonable to infer that she
would be similarly unresponsive to Father and thus prevent the
making of joint custody decisions with necessary dispatch.
Mother had opted not to visit D.S., R.S. or I.S. in the six months
before the section 364 hearing. Father, on the other hand, was
with the children daily. They were happy in his care; Father
participated in his case plan and was working to establish
routine and structure for the children. In light of this substantial
evidence, the juvenile court did not err in awarding Father sole
legal custody.
B. The Juvenile Court Did Not Err in Asserting
Jurisdiction over K.R.
1. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
The juvenile court asserted jurisdiction over K.R. pursuant
to subdivisions (b)(1) and (j) of section 300. As relevant here,
subdivision (b)(1) permits the exercise of jurisdiction where “[t]he
child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will
suffer, serious physical harm or illness as a result of” either “[t]he
14
failure or inability of the child’s parent . . . to adequately
supervise or protect the child” (§ 300, subd. (b)(1)(A)), or as a
result of “[t]he inability of the parent . . . to provide regular care
for the child due to the parent’s . . . substance abuse” (id., subd.
(b)(1)(D)). Subdivision (j) provides for dependency jurisdiction
where “[t]he child’s sibling has been abused or neglected, as
defined in subdivision (a), (b), (d), (e), or (i), and there is a
substantial risk that the child will be abused or neglected, as
defined in those subdivisions. . . .” (Id., subd. (j).) We review
jurisdictional findings under section 300 for substantial evidence.
(In re I.C. (2018) 4 Cal.5th 869, 892.)
2. Substantial Evidence Supports the Juvenile Court’s
Findings
Mother has a long history of substance abuse. In 2017,
before R.S. and I.S. were born, the juvenile court declared D.S. a
dependent based on Mother’s drug abuse. Mother did not
participate in court-ordered treatment and testing programs,
leading to her having only monitored visits with D.S. In 2021,
the juvenile court again declared D.S. a dependent due to
Mother’s substance abuse, and further named siblings R.S. and
I.S. as dependents. Mother was again ordered to participate in
drug treatment. She again failed to comply with her court-
ordered case plan, leading to her having monitored visitation
with all three children.
Once K.R. was born, Mother appears to have shown greater
dedication to addressing her substance abuse issues, and she
tested negative in the six weeks leading up to K.R.’s jurisdiction
hearing. We commend these efforts and hope Mother continues
such positive forward steps. But those six weeks of negative tests
must be weighed against the entire record, which contains
15
countervailing evidence that Mother was still struggling with
sobriety. Mother did not consistently test during either the
reunification period for K.R.’s siblings or during the investigation
related to K.R. himself and the juvenile court could fairly
consider her missed tests (regardless of Mother’s excuses for why
she did not appear) to be positive drug tests. (L.C. v. Superior
Court (2024) 98 Cal.App.5th 1021, 1036.) Mother denied ever
having a drug problem, and “[o]ne cannot correct a problem one
fails to acknowledge.” (In re Gabriel K. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th
188, 197.) Mother’s past drug use indicated that when
intoxicated she was prone to violent outbursts, including in front
of the children, that posed substantial risk to K.R. (In re N.R.
(2023) 15 Cal.5th 520, 559 [juvenile court may find an inability to
provide regular care and a substantial risk of serious harm “from
the evidence that has been introduced in a particular case,
including evidence relating to substance abuse, and the
reasonable inferences that can be drawn from this evidence”].)
In light of the above, we conclude substantial evidence
supports the juvenile court’s determination that, at the time of
the jurisdiction hearing, Mother had an unresolved substance
abuse problem that compromised her ability to care for K.R.,
justifying the assumption of dependency jurisdiction under
section 300, subdivisions (b)(1) and (j).
16
DISPOSITION
The legal custody order as to D.S., R.S., and I.S. and the
jurisdictional order as to K.R. are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
WEINGART, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
CHANEY, J.
17
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.