Mackel v. McDonough CA2/6

CourtListener 9507149Calctapp24.05.2024

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 5/24/24 Mackel v. McDonough CA2/6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SIX

VIRGINIA A. MACKEL, 2d Crim. No. B324520
(Super. Ct. No. 56-2021-00556620-
Plaintiff and Respondent, CU-WM-VTA)
(Ventura County)
v.

PAUL MCDONOUGH,

Defendant and Appellant.

Paul McDonough appeals a judgment entered after the trial
court granted a motion for a writ of mandate sought by Virginia
A. Mackel, the co-manager of four limited liability companies that
she and McDonough jointly manage. (Code Civ. Proc., § 1085;
Corp. Code, § 1603, subd. (a).)1 We affirm.
This appeal concerns an amended petition for writ of
mandate filed by a co-manager of four limited liability companies

We deny Mackel’s motion to dismiss McDonough’s appeal.
1

Although McDonough may have complied with the writ of
mandate following the judgment in favor of Mackel, that
compliance does not respond to all the issues he raises on appeal.
(collectively CVP Companies) seeking the production of company
books and records for inspection and copying, and the return of
the books and records to the principal business office. The CVP
Companies own and operate separate parcels of real estate that
comprise a Thousand Oaks shopping center, the “Conejo Valley
Shopping Center.” Mackel and McDonough’s father developed
the companies and, as part of his estate plan, transferred
ownership to them as co-managers. In June 2021, McDonough
unilaterally moved the CVP Companies’ books and records from
the longtime business office to his home, and then to a different
office. Despite Mackel’s repeated demands, McDonough refused
to return the books and records and allow Mackel to inspect and
copy them.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
The operating agreements for the CVP Companies state
that “[t]he business of the Company shall be managed by the
Manager (which term includes co-Managers),” and that the
“Manager shall be Paul J. McDonough and Virginia A. Mackel, or
any successor Manager elected as provided [herein].” The
operating agreements provide the co-managers with the “full,
exclusive and complete” power and authority to jointly manage
the CVP Companies. The operating agreements also require a
designated principal office in a location determined by the
co-managers. Three of the companies designated an office at
32123 Lindero Canyon Road and the fourth company designated
a principal office at 725 Lakefield Road. On January 1, 2012, the
co-managers entered into a written lease for the Lindero Canyon
Road office and moved the CVP Companies records to that office.
In June 2021, without notice to Mackel and without her
consent, McDonough removed the books and records of the CVP

2
Companies. Mackel repeatedly demanded that McDonough
return the books and records to the Lindero Canyon Road office
for her inspection and copying, but McDonough stated various
reasons for not doing so. In an e-mail to Mackel, McDonough
admitted that “[n]either of us can remove the records without the
other person[’]s prior written approval.”
McDonough initially moved the books and records to his
home and later to the office of Capital Real Estate Advisors
(CREA) located at 973 South Westlake Boulevard. CREA is a
property administrator employed by the CVP Companies to
collect rents and pay vendors, among other things.
Mackel was later granted access to the Westlake Boulevard
office by a CREA administrator. Mackel believed that some
records were missing. She also noticed that documents were
scattered and detached and some were in trash bags. Mackel had
difficulty gaining access to the office because it was frequently
closed and no one was available to provide access.
Prior to Mackel’s visit to the Westlake Boulevard office, she
filed a verified petition for writ of mandate concerning access to
the books and records and their return to the Lindero Canyon
Road office. McDonough contested the petition. Following oral
argument, the trial court granted Mackel’s motion for a writ of
mandate and ordered McDonough to produce all existing
company books and records for inspection and copying. The writ
also ordered McDonough to return all existing company books
and records to the Lindero Canyon Road office and maintain
them there as long as that office remained the business office of
the CVP companies. Finally, the order stated that Mackel was
the prevailing party “to the extent that she is entitled” to
attorney fees.

3
McDonough appeals and contends that the trial court erred
by: 1) ordering him to produce the books and records because he
never refused Mackel’s requests for inspection; 2) ordering him to
produce documents beyond the scope of Corporations Code
sections 17704.10 and 17701.13; and 3) finding the principal
office as Lindero Canyon Road rather than the location (El
Segundo) provided as a principal place of business to the
California Secretary of State.
DISCUSSION
I.
McDonough argues that Mackel was not denied an
opportunity to inspect the books and records, and asserts that she
did inspect and photocopy documents on many occasions at the
Westlake Boulevard office. He claims the issue is one of law
because a writ order cannot require performance of an action that
a person has not previously refused to perform.
The trial court found that McDonough provided some
documents for inspection to Mackel, but that he claimed the
production “should be limited in scope.” From this argument, the
court drew the reasonable inference that McDonough was
withholding documents. Mackel asserted that some documents
were missing when she inspected and copied the books and
records. She saw that documents were detached and others
placed into trash bags. Mackel provided two photographs of the
documents in disarray. The court found that McDonough refused
production of existing books and records at the Lindero Canyon
Road office. Viewing the evidence and drawing reasonable
inferences favorably to the judgment, substantial evidence
supports this factual finding. (Fowler v. Golden Pacific Bancorp,
Inc. (2022) 80 Cal.App.5th 205, 218 [substantial evidence

4
standard of review applies to trial court’s judgment granting
mandamus petition].)
II.
For the first time on appeal, McDonough asserts that the
writ order is overbroad because it orders the production of his
correspondence and personal e-mails, certain documents equally
available to Mackel, original books and records, and documents
without any time limitation.
We disagree with McDonough’s interpretation of the writ
order. The order compels the production and return of CVP
Companies’ existing books and records that McDonough took from
the Lindero Canyon Road office. A writ of mandate properly is
used to compel a party to return corporate books and records to
the principal place of business. (Liberal Catholic Church v.
Rogers (1944) 65 Cal.App.2d 196, 199-200.) The order does not
compel production of McDonough’s personal e-mails unrelated to
the CVP Companies; it is limited to “company books and records.”
“By analogy, Corporation Code section 1602, applicable to
corporations, states that corporate directors have the “absolute
right” at any reasonable time to inspect and copy all corporate
books, records, and documents of every kind.” (Tritek Telecom,
Inc. v. Superior Court (2009) 169 Cal.App.4th 1385, 1390.)
Corporations Code section 17701.13, subdivision (d) lists the
documents a limited liability company shall maintain at its
business office, including the books and records regarding
internal affairs for the current and prior four fiscal years. (Id.,
subd. (d)(7).) The writ order expressly refers to correspondence
and e-mails related to the CVP Companies’ activities from
January 1, 2021, to date.

5
Moreover, McDonough did not raise the specific
overbreadth arguments in the trial court. Thus, he has forfeited
the arguments here. As a general rule, theories not raised in the
trial court cannot be asserted for the first time on appeal. (Nellie
Gail Ranch Owners Assn. v. McMullin (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 982,
997.) This rule rests upon fairness to the trial court and to
opposing litigants. (Ibid.) “Bait and switch” on appeal subjects
the parties to additional expenses and overburdens the judicial
system. (Ibid.)
III.
McDonough argues that the trial court erred by finding
that the CVP Companies’ “principal office” was the Lindero
Canyon Road office, and not the El Segundo office of CREA.
In filings with the California Secretary of State in 2019, the
CVP Companies stated that the CREA office located at 222 N.
Pacific Coast Highway, El Segundo, California, was and had been
the principal office for the companies. McDonough adds that the
written lease for the Lindero Canyon Road office expired on June
30, 2021, prompting his removal of the books and records.
The trial court’s factual finding that the Lindero Canyon
Road office was the designated and principal office of the CVP
Companies is supported by substantial evidence. The operating
agreements of the four limited liability companies required
designation of a principal office. McDonough and Mackel chose
the Lindero Canyon Road office, maintained the books and
records there, and occupied the office pursuant to a 10-year
written lease. Following termination of the lease term, the
companies have occupied the office as holdover tenants on a
month-to-month basis. The court’s judgment indicates that the
books and records shall be maintained at the Lindero Canyon

6
Road office so long as that office remains the principal office of
the CVP Companies.
McDonough’s argument regarding the “principal place of
business” for the CVP Companies appears to concern matters of
venue. The argument is irrelevant here.
In sum, the trial court did not abuse its discretion by
issuing the writ of mandate here. (Richardson v. Franc (2015)
233 Cal.App.4th 744, 757 [trial court may exercise its broad
equitable discretion and fashion relief to fit the specific facts of
the case].)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Mackel shall recover costs.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

GILBERT, P. J.
We concur:

BALTODANO, J.

CODY, J.

7
Benjamin F. Coats, Judge

Superior Court County of Ventura

______________________________

Loeb & Loeb and Oleg Stolyar for Defendant and
Appellant.
Seltzer Caplan McMahon Vitek, Neal P. Panish and Jake
D. Sesti for Plaintiff and Respondent.

8

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.