CourtListener 10874444•People v. Williams CA1/5
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 6/12/26 P. v. Williams CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
THE PEOPLE,
A171962
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Alameda County
Super. Ct. No. 22-CR-010803)
DEVIN WILLIAMS, JR.,
Defendant and Appellant.
Devin Williams, Jr. (appellant), appeals from his convictions, following
a jury trial, for the first degree murders of Maria Tran and Benison Tran.1
We reject his evidentiary challenges and affirm.
BACKGROUND
In 2022, Maria and Benison were married and lived in a two-story
house with their teenage son and Maria’s cousin. Appellant was a deputy
sheriff. In February, Maria and appellant began dating. Between February
and September, they exchanged about 50,000 text messages. These text
messages indicate that Maria initially told appellant she was divorced and no
1 Because the victims share a last name, we refer to them by their first
names. No disrespect is intended.
1
longer living with her ex-husband. By the end of May, she admitted to
appellant that she was still married but told him her husband lived in a
separate house.
About 3:30 a.m. one morning in early August 2022, officers were
dispatched to Maria and Benison’s house. Appellant was outside their front
door and told the responding officers that he found out his girlfriend might be
married and came to her house to find out if she was cheating on him.2
Maria initially told the officers that she did not know appellant, then
subsequently acknowledged that appellant was her boyfriend but said she did
not want her husband to hear.
At some point during their relationship, Maria gave appellant a
password enabling him to look at all of her text messages, previous and
current. In texts from early September 2022, appellant indicated to Maria
that he was going through her old text messages. Maria and Benison had
exchanged numerous text messages in July and August 2022 saying they
loved each other and calling each other “honey” and “babe.”
On September 6, 2022, Maria’s mother and brother were visiting and
staying with Maria and Benison. Maria and appellant texted numerous
times between 9:00 p.m. and 11:40 p.m. that evening. During this time,
appellant texted Maria, “ ‘I’m extremely scared about your ex-husband,’ ”
later explaining, “ ‘I’m scared for three reasons. One, you going back to him.
Two, you cheating on me with him. Three, your love being divided between
us. Do you send your ex-husband emojis like kissing face, heart eyes,
multiple heart face?’ ” Appellant asked, “ ‘If I let you talk to him however you
want, other than sexual, then you won’t do any intimate things with him, no
2 Excerpts from the officers’ body camera footage from this incident
were admitted into evidence.
2
kissing like this or sex or anything intimate that satisfies him. Could that be
acceptable?’ ” A little later, Maria told appellant that she was going to
change her passwords so he would no longer have access to her accounts.
Appellant said that she should trust him and that he would not go through
her information without asking. Appellant told Maria he needed her to
comfort him, and said he was about to “ ‘snap’ ” and “ ‘explode.’ ”
Around 11:20 p.m., appellant arrived outside Maria and Benison’s
house. During the next 20 minutes, he called Maria 20 times. By midnight,
everyone in the house but Benison had gone upstairs to go to bed. Around
12:15 a.m., appellant walked up the driveway carrying a phone and with
what appears to be a pistol grip sticking out of his pants pocket.3 At 12:21
a.m., appellant called Maria and they spoke for a little over 15 minutes. At
12:37 a.m., appellant walked to the front door, which was open, and entered
the house.
Maria’s cousin, mother, and brother all heard Maria and Benison
calling for Maria’s brother, and came out of their bedrooms. Appellant was in
Maria and Benison’s bedroom with a gun in his hand. Appellant told Maria
she was cheating on him, and Maria told appellant she never wanted to see
him again. Appellant was visibly upset and Maria’s mother tried to calm him
down. Benison told appellant to leave or he would call the police, and walked
downstairs to get his phone. Appellant told Maria, “ ‘If he’s calling the cops,
I’m gone.’ ” Benison began walking back up the stairs, talking to a 911
operator on speakerphone. When Benison was in the middle of the staircase,
appellant shot him. Benison fell down the stairs and Maria and her brother
ran after him. Maria hugged Benison as he lay on the ground, and appellant
3 Video clips from Maria and Benison’s security cameras were admitted
into evidence.
3
came down the stairs and shot both of them in the head. Appellant then ran
out of the house. Later that day, appellant turned himself in. Maria and
Benison died from their injuries.4
In closing arguments, defense counsel did not dispute that appellant
killed Maria and Benison, but argued he did so in the heat of passion after
discovering that Maria was still in a romantic relationship with Benison.
The jury convicted appellant of the first degree murders of Maria and
Benison. The trial court sentenced appellant to an aggregate term of 50
years to life.
DISCUSSION
I. Photographs
Appellant argues the trial court erred in admitting certain
photographs. We reject the challenges.
As an initial matter, with respect to six of the photographs challenged
by appellant on appeal—photographs of Maria’s brother taken at the crime
scene—appellant fails to establish that he objected to their admission below.5
“Generally, a ‘trial counsel’s failure to object to claimed evidentiary error on
the same ground asserted on appeal results in a forfeiture of the issue on
appeal.’ ” (People v. Guenther (2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 483, 525.) Appellant
4 We omit evidence submitted in appellant’s defense, which is not
relevant to our resolution of the issues on appeal.
5 In contending there was no forfeiture, appellant relies on a defense
counsel argument that in fact related to a photograph depicting an injury to
Maria’s arm, not to the photographs of her brother. The photographs of
Maria’s brother were not part of the group of photographs addressed at the in
limine hearing.
4
offers no explanation or basis for an exception to this general rule.
Accordingly, his challenge as to these photographs is forfeited.6
Appellant challenges the admission of three photographs of the victims,
arguing they are irrelevant and more prejudicial than probative.7 The
challenged photographs are a still image from the body camera of the first
responding officer showing Maria’s brother attempting to resuscitate
Benison, a photograph of the victims lying at the foot of the staircase, and a
photograph of Maria lying on a blue plastic sheet with blood on her face.
“ ‘Whether the trial court erred in admitting into evidence the
challenged photographs of the murder victims depends upon two factors: (1)
whether the photographs were relevant, and (2) whether the trial court
abused its discretion in determining that the probative value of each
photograph outweighed its prejudicial effect.’ [Citation.] We review the trial
court’s decision to admit the photographs for abuse of discretion. [Citation.]
‘ “The court’s exercise of that discretion will not be disturbed on appeal unless
the probative value of the photographs clearly is outweighed by their
prejudicial effect.” ’ ” (People v. Morales (2020) 10 Cal.5th 76, 103 (Morales).)
Appellant has not established an abuse of discretion.
Appellant argues the photographs were not relevant because he did not
dispute that he shot Maria and Benison, and did not contest the witnesses’
account of how the shooting occurred. Similar challenges to the admission of
crime scene photographs have been repeatedly rejected. “Defendant asserts
6 We need not decide whether, as the People contend, appellant’s
challenges to the other photographs are also forfeited.
7 Although appellant’s briefing identifies two additional photographs—
one of the crime scene and one from the autopsy—these photographs were not
admitted into evidence.
5
that the manner and cause of the victims’ deaths and the intent of the
perpetrator were not disputed at trial; rather, the only seriously contested
issue was the perpetrator’s identity, and the photographs were irrelevant to
that question. But defendant’s not guilty plea put in issue all of the elements
of the charged offenses, including the elements he conceded. [Citations.]
Thus, the prosecution was ‘still entitled to prove its case and especially to
prove a fact so central to the basic question of guilt as intent.’ [Citations.]
Defendant also contends that the manner of restraint and the cause of death
were amply described in oral testimony; therefore the photographs were
cumulative. But a prosecutor is not required to rely solely on oral testimony
when a visual image would enhance the jury’s understanding of the issues.”
(People v. Cowan (2010) 50 Cal.4th 401, 476; see also People v. Lewis (2001)
25 Cal.4th 610, 641 (Lewis) [“Although defendant contends the photographs
were inadmissible because they had no bearing on the only disputed question
at trial (his mental state), we have made clear that the absence of a defense
challenge to particular aspects of the prosecution’s case or its witnesses does
not render victim photographs irrelevant”]; Morales, supra, 10 Cal.5th at
p. 104 [“We have previously rejected the argument that ‘photographs are
irrelevant or inadmissible simply because they duplicate testimony, depict
uncontested facts, or trigger an offer to stipulate’ ”].)
Appellant also contends the challenged photographs are more
prejudicial than probative. “ ‘ “[V]ictim photographs and other graphic items
of evidence in murder cases always are disturbing.” ’ [Citation.] A trial court
may admit photographs of victims even when the photographs are ‘gruesome’
if ‘the charged offenses were gruesome’ and the photographs ‘[do] no more
than accurately portray the shocking nature of the crimes.’ [Citations.] ‘The
jury can, and must, be shielded from depictions that sensationalize an alleged
6
crime, or are unnecessarily gruesome, but the jury cannot be shielded from
an accurate depiction of the charged crimes that does not unnecessarily play
upon the emotions of the jurors.’ ” (Morales, supra, 10 Cal.5th at p. 104.) We
have reviewed the challenged photographs and find, as did the Lewis court,
that “[a]lthough the blood-splattered surroundings and the images of the
victims depicted in the photographs . . . are disturbing to view, as such
evidence always is [citation], none of these exhibits is unduly gruesome or
inflammatory.” (Lewis, supra, 25 Cal.4th at p. 642.)
II. Evidence Regarding a Sound on Victims’ Security Video
Appellant challenges evidence relating to a sound heard on the victims’
security camera on the night of the shootings. We reject the challenges.
A. Additional Background
In one of the security camera videos played for the jury, a sound is
audible at about 12:27 a.m., during a time when appellant was outside Maria
and Benison’s house but not visible on the camera. Over appellant’s
objection, a peace officer opined that the sound was “a slide racking on a
handgun.” He testified the basis for his opinion was, “I’ve racked the slide
thousands of times, and it just has a very distinct sound to it.”8
The People also presented a video of the peace officer racking the same
type of gun used by appellant. This reenactment video was recorded by the
same security camera at the victims’ house. The officer testified he believed
the sounds on the two videos were the same. Defense counsel questioned the
officer about certain differences between the sounds, as well as differences in
the time of day and ambient noise levels of the two videos. Defense counsel
8 At a prior hearing, the trial court ruled this testimony was admissible
as lay opinion.
7
also established on cross-examination that none of the security videos from
the night of the shooting showed appellant with the gun in his hand.
During closing arguments, defense counsel argued the sound on the
original video was “completely different” than the sound on the reenactment
video, and played both videos three times. Counsel argued the sound was
instead possibly the opening and closing of a metal latch on a gate next to the
victims’ garage.
During deliberations, the jury asked for the original and reenactment
videos.
B. Reenactment Video
Appellant argues the reenactment video was unreliable because, as
established during the officer’s cross-examination, the officer did not know
appellant’s precise location, the weather conditions, the level of ambient
noise, or the condition of the camera microphone on the night of the shooting.
Appellant relies on a case discussing the Kelly/Frye standard,9 whereby,
“ ‘ “when faced with a novel method of [scientific] proof,” ’ our Supreme Court
requires ‘ “a preliminary showing of general acceptance of the new technique
in the relevant scientific community” before the scientific evidence may be
admitted at trial.’ ” (People v. Hardy (2021) 65 Cal.App.5th 312, 324.)
“Kelly/Frye ‘ “is intended to prevent lay jurors from being unduly influenced
by procedures which seem scientific and infallible, but which actually are
not.” ’ ” (Id. at p. 325.)
The reenactment video here was not a new scientific technique, but
simply capturing a known sound on a security camera in order to compare it
to an unknown sound captured on the same security camera. Defense
9 (People v. Kelly (1976) 17 Cal.3d 24; Frye v. United States (D.C. Cir.
1923) 293 Fed. 1013.)
8
counsel cross-examined the peace officer at length about the limitations of the
reenactment. “[T]here was no danger that the jury was swept away by the
presentation of a new scientific technique which it could not understand and,
therefore, would not challenge.” (People v. Hood (1997) 53 Cal.App.4th 965,
970 [holding computer animation of a shooting did not need to meet
Kelly/Frye requirements].)
C. Opinion Testimony
Appellant argues the peace officer’s testimony about the source of the
sound on the security video from the night of the shooting was speculative
and not a proper subject for lay opinion testimony. We need not decide
whether the admission of this testimony was error because any error was
harmless.
The original security video and reenactment video were played for the
jury multiple times—including by defense counsel during closing
arguments—and the jury was able to compare the two sounds and determine
for themselves whether they were the same. The jury was properly
instructed with respect to witnesses’ opinions that they were “not required to
accept those opinions as true or correct” and “may give the opinions whatever
weight you think appropriate.” (See CALCRIM No. 333.) Accordingly, any
error in the admission of the officer’s testimony opining as to the source of the
sound on the original security video was harmless. (See People v. Leon (2015)
61 Cal.4th 569, 601 [rejecting challenge to lay opinion testimony identifying
person on a security video as the defendant in part “because the surveillance
video was played for the jury, jurors could make up their own minds about
whether the person shown was defendant”]; People v. Larkins (2011) 199
Cal.App.4th 1059, 1068 [“the jurors were able to test the manager’s opinion
that defendant was the person in the 20 to 30 videos because they saw still
9
photos taken from some of the videos and they could test his ability to
correctly identify defendant in the three videos they were shown”].)10
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
SIMONS, Acting P. J.
We concur.
BURNS, J.
CHOU, J.
(A171962)
10 We reject appellant’s claim of cumulative error. As the only assumed
error we have found is the admission of the peace officer’s testimony about
the source of the sound on the original security video, there is no error to
cumulate.
10
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.