People v. Wells CA2/1

CourtListener 10869056Calctapp01.06.2026

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 6/1/26 P. v. Wells CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

THE PEOPLE, B341609

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BA516033)
v.

JOHNNIE JABAAR WELLS,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Craig Richman, Judge. Affirmed and
remanded; sentence vacated.
Victor J. Morse, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, and Michael C. Keller and Viet H. Nguyen,
Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Johnnie Jabaar Wells appeals from his judgment of conviction
for murder and related firearm offenses. He argues the court erred
when it refused to permit Wells to testify as a gang expert, and
that this testimony would have supported the self-defense theory
he presented at trial. Regardless of whether Wells could have
qualified as an expert witness, the proposed testimony is irrelevant.
The court correctly excluded it.
We, however, agree with both Wells and respondent that the
court erred by imposing the high term for certain enhancements.
Because the court did so based on aggravating circumstances not
found by the jury and to which Well did not stipulate, it violated
Penal Code section 1170.1 and Wells’s Sixth Amendment rights.1
Accordingly, we vacate the sentence and remand for resentencing in
a manner consistent with section 1170.1. In all other respects, we
affirm the judgment.

SELECTED FACTUAL AND
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Trial
The People charged Wells with first degree murder
(§§ 187, subd. (a), 189, subd. (a)), possession of a firearm by a
felon (§ 29800, subd. (a)(1)), and assault with a firearm (§ 245,
subd. (a)(2)), all based on allegations that Wells shot Jeremiah
Turner and fatally shot Charles Brown. The People also alleged
several enhancements.2

1 Unless otherwise indicated, all further statutory
references are to the Penal Code.
2 As to the assault and murder counts, the People alleged
Wells personally used a handgun (§ 12022.5, subd. (a)). As to the

2
1. Prosecution’s Case
At trial, the prosecution presented evidence establishing
the following:
On May 20, 2024, Wells met his friend Rickie Yarbrough
and his ex-girlfriend, Lepreshia Tucker, at the Defiant
Motorcycle Club (Defiant). Wells and Yarbrough were
both members of the 11 Deuce Neighborhood Crips gang.
The Hoovers, a rival gang of the Neighborhood Crips,
control some areas around Defiant. The Neighborhood Crips
control other areas around Defiant. Gang members care about
controlling their gang’s territory and excluding members of
other gangs. Motorcycle clubs, however, are open to people from
different gangs as long as they “leave [their] gang membership at
the door.” It is possible for members of rival gangs to get along at
these clubs.
Surveillance video from Defiant shows that, at 1:29 a.m.,
Wells, Yarbrough, and Tucker were talking while on the sidewalk
in front of the club. Brown and Turner walked close to the group,
but did not interact with any of them. Brown was a relatively
junior member of the Eight-Tray Hoovers gang. Neither Wells
nor Yarbrough had any interactions with Brown or Turner at
Defiant. Later video footage shows Brown and Turner leaving
Defiant together.
After Tucker observed “something happen[ing]” between
Yarbrough and a Hoover gang member named “Hoover T,” she

assault count, the People alleged Wells inflicted great bodily
injury on Turner (§ 12022.7, subd. (a)). Additionally, as to all the
counts, the People alleged Wells suffered two prior convictions
for robbery within the meaning of the “Three Strikes” law
(§§ 667, subds. (b)–(i), 1170.12, subds. (a)–(d)).

3
sensed “tension.” Hoover T appears in surveillance footage,
but police were unable to identify him. Another Hoover gang
member known as “Smacc” who was also at Defiant spoke with
Yarbrough and Wells.
Later that night, Wells, Yarbrough, and Tucker went to LA
Riders, a motorcycle club a few miles from Defiant. Smacc was
there as well, as were Brown and Turner. Neither Wells nor
Yarbrough had any interactions with Brown or Turner inside LA
Riders.
A man named James Nelson recorded a video inside the
club “to show the atmosphere,” which he immediately posted on
Instagram. The video included images of Wells. Nelson denied
any gang affiliation. Text messages sent and received from
Wells’s phone the night of the shooting discuss this video. Wells’s
cell phone received a text message attaching the video and
stating, “Cuz was on y’all the [w]hole time.” The user of Wells’s
phone responded: “There’s a lot going on with the Snoovas and
Troubles passing my picture around they have been plotting
on us since they seen us . . . they were recording and sending
pictures around to they homies. The homey from Brims.”
Surveillance video depicts Smacc engaged in a shoving
match with an unnamed man on the sidewalk in front of LA
Riders. While Wells was watching the fight, Brown and Turner
walked in front of Wells but did not look at him. Immediately
before Brown and Turner walked by, Wells turned towards
Yarbrough and shrugged his shoulders.
Soon thereafter, around 4:15 or 4:20 a.m., Wells shot at
Turner and Brown. Turner ran southbound; Brown fled in the
opposite direction. Wells ran after Brown, firing multiple shots
at his back. Brown fell to the ground, his body writhing. Wells

4
stood over Brown briefly, raising one arm, then walked back
towards the club. He walked past an unidentified man who was
holding a gun in each hand and Wells shrugged his shoulders.
Tucker drove Wells back to Defiant, where Wells’s car was
parked.
Forensic investigation revealed Brown suffered multiple
gunshot wounds, two of which proved fatal. Turner sustained a
gunshot wound to the chest but survived.
The day after the shooting, Wells called Tucker and told
her, “Don’t say nothing.” He also stated, “I fucked up, I fucked
up. Man I fucked up.” He did not say anything about being
concerned for his safety at the time of the shooting. Wells also
did not say anything to this effect when he spoke with Yarbrough
after the shooting, nor when interviewed by police.

2. Yarbrough’s Testimony
Yarbrough denied any involvement in the shooting.
Hoover T “spooked” Yarbrough at Defiant by being “aggressive”
about the Yankees hat and jacket Yarbrough was wearing, which
could be interpreted as affiliated with the Neighborhood Crips.
Yarbrough became fearful and tried to get a gun to protect
himself but was unsuccessful. After that, Yarbrough told Wells
and Tucker that the “incident” between Yarbrough and Hoover T
was “over.”
Yarbrough was not concerned about Wells’s safety during
the fight in front of LA Riders. He believed that there was “no
need for [Wells] to [be] . . . scared.”

3. Wells’s Testimony
Wells testified that he shot Turner and Brown because he
“fear[ed] for his life,” and that Yarbrough was not involved in

5
any way. Wells regularly carried a gun for protection, including
on the night in question. He had been shot in the past and “just
[knew] how it [was] out there in [L.A.]”
While at Defiant, Yarbrough confessed to Wells that he had
been talking about gang activity with Hoover T, in violation of
club rules. Smacc assured Wells everything had been resolved
and no one should worry. Wells did not believe this but remained
at the club because everything seemed peaceful. He did not
“notice . . . [¶] . . . [¶] . . . or pay attention to” Brown or Turner at
Defiant.
While inside LA Riders later that evening, Wells did not
notice any tension or animosity towards him. When Wells and
Yarbrough arrived there, they talked briefly with Smacc and
saw other people who had been at Defiant earlier. Wells did not
notice Brown or Turner.
Wells believed the fight between Smacc and another
Hoover in front of LA Riders resulted from Smacc having been
“confrontational with Hoover T” earlier. While watching the
fight, Wells saw Brown and Turner further up the sidewalk.
He heard someone say, “Knock the nigga S dome off his head.
Go right there. Get that nigga, groove.” Wells believed that
the term “S dome” was a reference to the Seattle Mariners hat
Wells was wearing. These hats are popular with Rolling 60’s
Crips gang members, but they are not always associated with
the Crips, and rival gangs also wear them. Nevertheless,
wearing such a hat could offend Hoovers gang members.
Wells believed that whoever made the “S dome” comment
was referring to him, and that he was in “mortal danger.”
He therefore opened fire on Turner and Brown. According to
Wells, “when that comment came out of nowhere, like, what I do

6
basically like, what’s going on? You know, and I reacted the way
I reacted because I didn’t know what was going on. [¶] I just
know when I heard that . . . they coming to get me. So I reacted.
I pulled my gun out, and I reacted the way I reacted.”
Wells explained he chased and continued firing at Brown
as Brown fled because Wells believed that, if he stopped firing,
Brown might draw a gun. Wells “didn’t know what was going
on” so he “[j]ust ke[pt] on shooting until [he could not] shoot no
more.” Afterwards, when he walked by the unidentified man
holding two guns, Wells shrugged his shoulders to indicate, “I
don’t know” and kept on walking away to avoid a confrontation.
Wells had no conflict with either Turner or Brown. The
“S dome” statement came from behind him where Turner, Brown,
and others were standing. Although he did not know who made
the statement and was not familiar with either man’s voice, he
had a “specific” fear of the person who made the “S dome”
statement and believed that he had no choice but to kill Brown.
Wells was afraid “generally,” not specifically afraid of Brown or
Turner. This “generalized fear” continued after he shot Turner
and led him to chase and continue shooting at Brown. Wells also
explained that his reaction was due in part to “life stressors,” his
previous experience in prison, and that he had previously been
shot.
Text messages from Wells’s phone earlier that evening
express concerns about being attacked by the Hoovers. One
message sent from Wells’s phone stated, “[T]hey just put a green
light on me and Bam.” Bam referred to Yarbrough. Wells’s
phone received a message responding, “I was thinking that but I
don’t think they’re but okay be still though stop moving it around
stay out of Bam’s car.” Wells’s phone also received a message

7
stating, “The boy that don’t bang his family from Hoova he not
I actually know him Ben Ten.” Ben Ten referred to Brown.

4. Efforts To Offer Testimony About
Hoover T’s Gang Status
Defense counsel attempted to elicit testimony from Wells
that, based on Hoover T’s actions in the surveillance footage,
Hoover T was a “high-ranking member” of the Hoovers capable
of ordering more junior members to kill someone. This opinion
was relevant, defense counsel argued, because it supported the
defense’s theory that Hoover T had masterminded a conspiracy to
kill Wells and/or Yarbrough after Yarbrough offended Hoover T.
This theory required Hoover T to have both authority and
motivation to direct other Hoovers to follow Wells and Yarbrough
from club to club, video-record them, and post the video on social
media as a means of encouraging other Hoovers to pursue
revenge for Yarbrough’s act of disrespect.3
Wells and his counsel confirmed that Wells did not believe
Hoover T was a high-ranking member of the Hoovers “at the
time” of the shooting and would instead be offering testimony
based on Wells’s analysis of the surveillance video. The People
objected based on lack of foundation, relevance, and Evidence
Code section 352. In response to these objections, defense counsel
clarified its intent to qualify Wells as a gang expert for purposes
of this testimony.

3 The People’s gang expert testified that a senior Hoovers
gang member could order a killing of someone wearing an
offensive Mariners hat. Stalking a person for wearing an
offensive hat, video recording that person, and posting images
on social media could function to encourage or green light killing
that person.

8
The court did not qualify Wells as a gang expert. It also did
not permit Wells to testify about the night of the shooting based
on anything except his experiences and observations that night
and the text messages to and from his phone that night. As a
result, Wells was not permitted to testify, either as an expert
or percipient witness, about Hoover T’s gang status.

5. Verdict and Sentencing
The jury found Wells guilty as charged. The court
sentenced Wells to 50 years to life on the murder count; 9 years
on the assault count; the upper term of 10 years on each of the
two firearm-use enhancements; and, to be served concurrently
with the other terms, two years on the firearm possession count.
Wells timely appealed.

DISCUSSION
Wells argues the court reversibly erred both at trial and at
sentencing. We address each argument in turn.

A. Testimony Regarding Hoover T’s Gang Status
To establish he acted in self-defense, a defendant must
show that (1) when committing the crime, he subjectively
feared for his life, and (2) his fear was objectively reasonable.
(See People v. Humphrey (1996) 13 Cal.4th 1073, 1082–1083
(Humphrey).) In assessing objective reasonableness, “a jury
must consider what ‘would appear to be necessary to a
reasonable person in a similar situation and with similar
knowledge.’ ” (Ibid., italics added; see id. at p. 1083 [jury “judges
reasonableness ‘from the point of view of a reasonable person
in the position of defendant’ ”].)

9
Wells claims the court erred by not allowing him to present
testimony relevant to the objective reasonableness requirement:
namely, expert testimony that Hoover T was a high-ranking
member and “shot-caller” in the Hoovers gang. Wells argues
this testimony, and/or testimony about a hypothetical based on
Hoover T’s actions as depicted in the surveillance video footage,
could have helped the jury understand Hoover T had the power
to order more junior Hoovers like Brown and Turner to kill Wells
and/or Yarbrough in response to Yarbrough’s earlier show of
disrespect. Wells thus sought to use this testimony to argue
it was objectively reasonable for Wells to have interpreted the
“S dome” comment as a death threat on the night in question.
As the court correctly instructed the jury, however,
objective reasonableness depends on “the circumstances as
they were known to and appeared to the defendant” at the time
and “what a reasonable person in a similar situation with
similar knowledge would have believed.” (Italics added.) (See
Humphrey, supra, 13 Cal.4th at p. 1083.) Wells admits he did not
know Hoover T’s gang status on the night in question, nor was he
aware that night of the basis for the opinion he would later form
on this topic. Rather, he conceded below and does not dispute
on appeal that he formed his opinion about Hoover T’s status
entirely in hindsight based on reviewing surveillance videos
depicting Hoover T’s actions on the night of the shooting. Thus,
whether it was objectively reasonable to perceive an immediate
danger upon hearing the “S dome” comment, had Wells known of
Hoover T’s status on the night of the shooting, is irrelevant to his
claim of self-defense. Accordingly, even assuming Wells could
have qualified as a gang expert, the court correctly ruled the

10
proposed expert testimony is irrelevant to show Wells’s fear was
objectively reasonable at the time of the shooting. (See ibid.)
In arguing to the contrary, Wells cites cases that are
distinguishable. First, he relies on People v. Davis (1965) 63
Cal.2d 648, in which the defendant “testif[ied] as to specific acts
of violence on the part of [the] deceased which defendant had
witnessed or which had been reported to him” before the homicide.
(Id. at p. 656, italics added.) The defendant then sought “to
corroborate his testimony [with] the testimony of the victims [of
these prior acts of violence].” (Ibid.) Davis thus addressed the
admissibility of evidence corroborating circumstances of which
the defendant was aware at the time of the alleged self-defense.
Wells’s proposed testimony does not serve this purpose, because
he does not claim to have seen or experienced anything that night
suggesting Hoover T was a high-ranking gang member.
Wells also cites People v. DelRio (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 47.
In DelRio, the only living witness to a fatal shootout was the
defendant, who contended the victim began antagonizing him
without provocation and drew his gun first. (Id. at pp. 49–50.)
To corroborate the defendant’s description of the victim’s
behavior, defendant offered propensity evidence that the victim
had instigated other physical altercations in the past. (Id. at
p. 53.) This evidence was relevant to the defendant’s self-defense
argument even “[i]f [the victim’s violent character] was not
known [to the defendant]” at the time of the shooting, because the
defendant was not offering the evidence to prove the defendant’s
state of mind at the time of the shooting. (Id. at p. 55.) Rather,
the defendant was offering it to corroborate what defendant
claimed he saw the victim do. (See ibid.) Here, by contrast,
Wells’s theory of self-defense does not depend on what Brown and

11
Turner did before Wells shot them—it depends exclusively on
what Wells believed at that time. Testimony about facts of which
he was not aware in that moment is thus irrelevant, as the court
correctly determined.

B. Sentencing
Wells argues the court erred when it imposed the upper
term sentences on his firearm enhancements, because it did so
based on aggravating factors to which Wells did not stipulate and
that the jury did not find. Respondent agrees, as do we, that this
was error, and that a remand for resentencing is required.
“If an enhancement is punishable by one of three terms,
the court shall, in its sound discretion, order imposition of a
sentence not to exceed the middle term, except . . . [¶] . . .
when there are circumstances in aggravation that justify the
imposition of a term of imprisonment exceeding the middle
term, and the facts underlying those circumstances have been
stipulated to by the defendant, or have been found true beyond
a reasonable doubt at trial by the jury or by the judge in a
court trial.” (§ 1170.1, subd. (d)(1)–(2).) “[A] Sixth Amendment
violation occurs when the trial court relies on unproven
aggravating facts to impose an upper term sentence” and “is
prejudicial unless an appellate court can conclude beyond a
reasonable doubt that a jury would have found true all of the
aggravating facts relied upon by the trial court.” (See People v.
Lynch (2024) 16 Cal.5th 730, 768 (Lynch).)
Here, the jury did not find any aggravating circumstances,
nor did Wells stipulate to any. The court nevertheless concluded
“a significant number of aggravating factors in this matter”
supported imposing upper term sentences on the firearm
enhancements. But because the court did not specify which ones,

12
we cannot determine whether a jury necessarily would have
found these factors true. Accordingly, this error is prejudicial.
(See Lynch, supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 768.)

DISPOSITION
The sentence is vacated. Following remand, the trial court
shall resentence Wells consistent with the views expressed
herein.
In all other respects, the judgment is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
We concur:

BENDIX, J.

M. KIM, J.

13

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.