CourtListener 10860842•In re T.P. CA2/8
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 5/18/26 In re T.P. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
In re T.P. et al., Persons Coming B347386
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
______________________________ Los Angeles County
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Super. Ct. No. 23CCJP01612
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
D.M.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Lucia J. Murillo, Juvenile Court Referee.
Conditionally reversed with directions.
Jesse Frederic Rodriguez, under appointment by the Court
of Appeal, and Giselle Marie Achecar for Defendant and
Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Peter Ferrera, Principal Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
______________________________________
INTRODUCTION
Mother D.M. raises two issues on appeal. First, she
contends the juvenile court erred in terminating parental rights
to two of her three children because the court should have
invoked the beneficial parental relationship exception to
termination to keep her family together. We conclude substantial
evidence supports terminating Mother’s parental rights and the
juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in doing so.
Mother’s second issue is that the juvenile court erred when
it found no reason to believe the children had Indian heritage.
The Los Angeles Department of Children and Family Services
(DCFS) concedes this issue. We agree with the parties and
conditionally reverse and remand the matter to the juvenile court
to complete the inquiry into the children’s possible Cherokee
heritage.
BACKGROUND
Mother has three children: son T.P., born 2015; daughter
L.P., born 2016; and son N.P., born 2018. Father is deceased.
On May 10, 2023, Mother was placed on a Welfare and
Institutions Code1 section 5150 hold after she came to the
children’s school, asking for law enforcement to be called. The
principal described Mother as frantic. Mother told a responding
police officer she was “[o]n the run for her life” from Chicago
because a hitman was after her and she was now homeless.
(Italics omitted.) The responding police officer described Mother
as “very paranoid, anxious and all over the place and had to be
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2
redirected.” The shelter where Mother and the children had been
living confirmed it had asked Mother to leave because she was
delusional, having altercations with staff and residents, accusing
staff of tampering with her food, and putting soap in the
children’s milk to see who would drink the milk. The children
were in tears.
DCFS was contacted because no one could provide for the
children. The children themselves appeared well-cared for, well-
fed, clean, well-dressed and healthy, according to school officials.
L.P. reported they ate well, had clean clothes to wear every day
and bathed daily.
DCFS interviewed mother at the hospital. She said she
had an argument at the shelter where she lived with the
children. She said a resident with whom she argued was also
from Chicago and knew all of Mother’s personal information.
Mother acknowledged putting soap in the milk because she
wanted to stop others who were stealing her food. Mother said
the children did not drink the milk; she had to throw away their
food which is why the children had not eaten. She told the
shelter’s manger she was being “framed and followed.” Mother
noted that others had tried to kill her before and she accused her
deceased husband’s family of trying to get her. She believed she
was on a 5150 hold because she had been crying at the children’s
school.
On May 12, 2023, DCFS filed a petition alleging the
children were at substantial risk of serious physical harm
because Mother’s mental and emotional problems, which included
paranoia, delusions, anxiety, and aggression, rendered her
incapable of providing regular care and appropriate supervision
of the children.
3
On May 15, 2023, the juvenile court detained the minors
from Mother’s custody and ordered monitored visitation for
Mother two times per week for two hours each visit. The court
designated the three children a sibling set.
The children were placed in a foster home with caregivers
Mr. and Ms. S. The children remained together in that
placement through termination of Mother’s parental rights two
years later in June 2025. The juvenile court eventually
designated the caregivers as prospective adoptive parents for all
three children.
Between the filing of the petition and the September 6,
2023, adjudication hearing, Mother told DCFS she previously
lived in Chicago but moved to California in January 2023 because
of fear for her safety and that of her children. She and the
children had lived in shelters since arriving in California. She
worried about regaining custody of her children because of her
mental health problems and because she feared the children
would start to resent her. In July 2023 Mother denied being
paranoid and delusional and stated she never harmed her
children. She insisted a woman at the shelter had been
tampering with her food and the staff did nothing when she
reported it. She said after the woman was removed from the
shelter, a new resident started eating her food. Mother said she
knew the names of the people and the organization that were
trying to harm her family. Mother confirmed the children’s
deceased father committed domestic violence and sexual assault
against her.
In preparation for the adjudication hearing, DCFS advised
the court that Mother had to be redirected not to speak to the
children about the case or about returning home. Otherwise, she
4
regularly visited the children, matched their energy, and
redirected their behaviors appropriately. She complied with her
medication and followed through with her mental health
treatment. She had “excellent visitation” with her children and
nurtured and redirected them when appropriate.
At the adjudication hearing on September 6, 2023, Mother
pled no contest to the petition as interlineated by the court. The
court found that Mother’s mental and emotional problems
included posttraumatic stress disorder which limited her ability
to provide regular care and appropriate supervision for the
children. The court found by clear and convincing evidence there
was a substantial danger to the children’s physical and emotional
well-being if they were not removed from Mother’s custody and
control. The court maintained the same monitored visitation
order for Mother and ordered a case plan which included
parenting classes, individual counseling and compliance with
prescribed medication management.
Between the adjudication hearing on September 6, 2023,
and the permanency and planning hearing on June 6, 2025, the
children reported feeling happy and safe together at the home of
Mr. and Ms. S. The children also individually reported they
wanted the monitor present during their visits with Mother.
During that 21-month period, Mother made little progress
in handling her mental health issues appropriately so she could
be a parent to her children. The general consensus among her
service providers was that Mother was unpredictably violent,
caustic towards her children, then loving and sometimes
compliant. Mother resided at a home for single mothers but
continued to disrupt staff and other residents by her erratic
behavior. The director reported that “ ‘we cannot work with her.
5
She does not follow the rules nor does she think she needs to
meet with her life coach weekly, which is part of the program.
Mother continues to demonstrate odd behavior that is alarming
as one minute she is cool, calm and collect[ed], and the next you
don’t know what is going on because you are getting yelled at and
blamed for mothers own efforts. . . . We have told her a number of
times that her only responsibility is to find a job and housing,
and that in doing so she is to keep track of her efforts so that we
can assist if need be and or verify that [M]other is doing what is
expected of her. [¶] Things with [Mother] have gotten so bad that
we even took the job searching off her list of things to work on so
she can secure housing.’ ” The director of the program did not
want Mother to visit with the children at the home because she
feared Mother was “going to just take off with the children.”
Mother enrolled in treatment programs but was removed due to
her aggressive behavior towards class facilitators or other
participants. She delayed participating in a psychiatric
assessment.
DCFS reported Mother’s behavior raised concerns about
the children’s safety if they were left unattended in her care. She
visited N.P. at the school fence where she spoke to him privately.
She would try to fit all three children into one bathroom during
monitored visits so she could speak to them privately, despite
being informed not to do so. She spoke about case-related issues
in front of the children despite being redirected not to do so. The
children’s therapist thought Mother was trying to undermine the
foster parents. Mother’s therapist, who saw her only virtually,
expressed concern about Mother’s stability and her ability to be
consistent in her parenting behaviors.
6
Things soon began to go downhill for reunification after the
adjudication hearing. Not three months into the reunification
period, on December 1, 2023, Ms. S. (the children’s foster parent)
called DCFS to report that Mother showed up at the children’s
school and was seen talking to N.P. through the fence. Mother
had been told she was not allowed to be at the school, but she
continued to go. Mother became upset when DCFS asked her not
to go to the school. She denied she was doing anything other
than walking on a public sidewalk.
Also in December Ms. S. reported the children came home
from visits upset, stating Mother did not have any money. The
children also told her they did not have to listen to their foster
parents.
Ms. S. reported she was concerned about the children’s
attitude after they returned from visiting their mother. Ms. S.
reported that the youngest, N.P., came home upset from a visit,
said he hated Ms. S., and did not make his usual request for a
hug. L.P. then started to tell Ms. S. why N.P. was upset and T.P.
hit L.P. to stop her from talking. L.P. also told Ms. S. Mother
said Ms. S. is the one preventing them from returning to her.
Mother kept asking the children if Ms. S. was mean and wanted
to know if Ms. S. was hitting them.
On January 15, 2024, Ms. S. stated the children seemed to
know too much about the court case; after one visit, T.P. reported
he would be returned to Mother at the upcoming March court
date.
On January 17, 2024, Mother’s treatment provider
disclosed that Mother was terminated from her program. Mother
had “been extremely disruptive in class and at times had
challenges with properly managing her emotions that resulted in
7
confrontations with facilitators and other program participants.”
Another provider noted: “ ‘I have a lot of concerns with Mother
and her uncertainties with her behavior. Mother goes from 0-100
with staff and others in the home and what happened if the
children do not do what [they’re] told is she going to display that
same behavior with them.’ ”
That same month the social worker monitoring visitation
reported mother was “spiraling”—she did not remember certain
things and would resend things she previously communicated.
The monitor reported Mother again tried to get all three children
together into the bathroom and was upset when told not to do so.
The monitor observed Mother “is not always present in the
moment during visits. Sometimes you have to redirect her and
she continues to talk about the case despite being redirected. It
is almost like you have different personalities where she can’t
remember what was just said and done then she goes back to
being happy and like nothing bothers her.”
On January 29, 2024, Mother’s life coach, Jayda, reported:
“ ‘I have a lot of concerns with [M]other and her behavior. One
minute she is fine and the next she is not. I do not think she
should be around her children, if one gets a bad grade she might
flip. Mother does not follow rules, causes issues daily with staff
and other residents, [and has] aggressive, random behaviors and
mood swings, not caring, only aggressive, and not stable. One
minute she will be calm and collect[ed] then the next she is
aggressive out of nowhere and nobody will even had to say or do
anything to initiate her behavior. One minute she is acting polite
and professional and then the next she is completely different.
We have not made any progress with her.’ ”
8
In February 2024, Mother was still speaking about the case
in front of the children. Mother questioned why she needed a
mental health assessment, stating the children had been
removed from her because she did not have housing.
On February 26, 2024, DCFS received a call from the
director of Mother’s program to report that Mother was being
terminated from the program. The director stated that after
Mother “received her court report [for an upcoming hearing,] she
was upset and aggressive towards staff and other house mates.
. . . Mother wouldn’t stop yelling and she was screaming telling
us that we were the reason she doesn’t have her children and all
of this took place in front of other children in the home.” Mother
was non-compliant with house rules and went from being calm to
screaming and yelling, which caused other tenants to not feel
safe. The director sent Mother an email informing her that her
contract was terminated effective March 7, 2024 because of
concerns about her attitude, performance, and non-compliance
with program requirements. The letter documented two
incidents where mother’s aggression raised safety concerns for
staff.
In light of Mother’s continued aggressive and unpredictable
behavior, DCFS recommended she undergo an evaluation to
determine the potential future safety risks she might pose to the
safety of the children. In April 2024, one of Mother’s facilitators
reported Mother had recently started to yell and scream at her.
By June 2024, Mother was living in a new shelter.
Mother’s psychiatrist had diagnosed her with bipolar disorder.
Her treatment team advised the court Mother was compliant
with all appointments and medication and was engaged in
psychiatric services. Yet she continued to speak to the children
9
about the case and case-related issues during her visits with
them.
In July 2024, the social worker arrived with the children at
the park for visitation and Mother instantly started to speak
about court matters in front of them. The social worker asked
her to stop talking about court issues in front of them. Mother
then did not engage with the children, which made them
uncomfortable. Mother told the children, “DCFS is your parents.”
During a virtual visit later that month, Mother told the children
how a stalker brought her flowers and ice cream at work, she did
not like the man, and now she was scared because he set fire to a
gas station. The caregiver reported the children were worried
and scared for her life.
In June 2024, DCFS advised the court that the children
reported feeling loved and safe with Ms. S. Mother was still
speaking about case issues with the children despite being told
not to. The children displayed negative behavior at their
placement after the visits. Minors’ counsel told the court the
children all wanted to return to their mother’s care and custody.
Adopting the recommendations of DCFS, on July 16, 2024,
the juvenile court ordered continued family reunification services
and maintained all prior orders.
Nine days later, on July 25, 2024, Ms. S. voiced her concern
that the children are reporting “mother is saying bad words and
they were scared of mom when she was yelling and saying mean
things.” In August 2024, Mother called the social worker
screaming that she wanted more hours of visitation. She
complained that DCFS criticized her discipline of T.P.: “ ‘How did
[T.P.] feel when I was discipline them? They were fine[.] I’m
allowed to talk to them as I want[.] I am not physically hitting
10
them[.] I’m telling [T.P.] that he isn’t a man and that he can’t do
what he did. I am his mother I am allowed to talk to him in a
stern voice and if he wants to cry that is his fault because he is
messed up. They ain’t scared.’ ” That month Mother enrolled in
a new parenting class but completed only two of 12 classes.
During an August 2024 video call with the children, which
Mother took at her place of employment, Mother engaged in a
verbal argument with an unknown woman on her end of the
video in front of the children. The social worker intervened.
Mother became upset and the children sat with shocked looks on
their faces. N.P. did not engage during the entire video. In
another August 2024 visit, Mother told the children she was
going to change their names. The monitor later reported Mother
would say things under her breath that he could not catch but the
children could hear.
In September 2024, Mother was unable to discuss with the
social worker the topics covered in the parenting class and
Mother questioned why she needed to attend. She stated, “ ‘I
don’t know why I am doing the parenting class if mental health is
the concern you have. I am taking the medication and I’m
reporting I’m okay my progress letter states I am fine so I don’t
know why you guys are concerned.’ ” In September 2024, Mother
reported she was taking her medication as prescribed. She had
earlier refused a plan to take her medication by injection, stating
the plan had since been cancelled, an untrue statement. She
continued to speak to the children about the case, also blaming
them for her behavior, which caused a shift in their emotional
state. The monitor reported the children commented to him
about Mother’s behavior.
11
In October 2024, Mother was evaluated for bipolar disorder
and schizophrenia. The social worker did not believe Mother was
taking her medication as prescribed as she became dysregulated
when under stress. The providers were recommending injectable
medication.
That same month, DCFS reported that in August, the
visitation monitor noted a lack of emotional connection between
Mother and the children. Mother was often just spending money
on the children but not engaging and spending quality time with
them. The caregivers reported the children’s behavior “degraded”
after their visits with mother. Specifically Mother continued to
visit regularly, but she spoke with the children about the case
and “inappropriate issues” and was frequently dysregulated in
her own behavior. When redirected, Mother became closed off,
disengaged with the children, and turned to her cell phone.
Mother minimized her mental health issues and blamed DCFS
for the children’s removal. She told her virtual therapist that she
was “doing enough” and did not need medication. She declined to
take medication by injection as recommended by her doctor. She
used profanity in front of the children, which prompted them to
cover their eyes and ears. She also discussed with the children
getting them passports as well as changing their names. DCFS
was concerned that she might flee with the children if they were
left unattended with her.
During an October 2024 visit, Mother completely
disengaged from the children during the last 30 minutes of the
visit, walking away without saying goodbye to them. The
children just stared at her as she made her way across the park
without them. Another October 2024 visit ended early due to
Mother’s “gaslighting” behavior. During an October 28, 2024
12
visit, Mother, using an aggressive and forceful tone, asked N.P.
why he had not spoken to her during a recent virtual visit. The
children had been happy to see the monitor when the visit
started, but the moment Mother arrived, the children’s demeanor
shifted and they became uncomfortable talking to the monitor.
In October 2024, DCFS recommended terminating family
reunification services and proceeding with a permanent plan of
adoption. DCFS wrote: “During this period of supervision,
[M]other has made minimal efforts in maintaining productive
and healthy visits.” “[M]other has not been able to meet her case
plan’s service objectives. Mother has not been able to establish
appropriate boundaries with herself and the children, fails to
show an understanding of the children’s emotional needs, [has
been] unable to demonstrate appropriate parenting skills, and
has not stabilized her mental health.”
At a hearing on November 12, 2024, the juvenile court
ordered Mother not to discuss the case with the children during
future visitation, which continued to be monitored.
An 18-month review hearing was set for January 14, 2025.
The juvenile court received into evidence DCFS reports and took
testimony in chambers from T.P. and L.P. T.P. testified he felt
safe with Mother; became upset when his brother N.P. refused to
talk to Mother; and relayed messages from Mother to N.P. A few
months earlier, Mother had told him he was not a man. T.P. was
unsure he would still want to return to Mother if his siblings
remained in foster care.
L.P. stated she would not feel as safe at her visits with
Mother if the social worker or other adults were not present; in
her opinion Mother was not ready to care for her in the way she
needed. Both L.P. and T.P. stated they wanted to return home to
13
Mother. N.P. stated he did not want to return to Mother’s
custody.
Mother testified she had been in therapy about a year; she
had been diagnosed with PTSD, anxiety, depression and bipolar
disorder; she had learned a multitude of coping skills and a lot of
parenting skills; she was taking Abilify by injection and felt
calmer, coherent and clear; she had an apartment and a job
working as a cashier at a gas station; she and the children felt
uncomfortable visiting in the presence of the monitor because he
has threatened to cancel their visits several times if they were too
loud during the visits. Mother denied coaching the children.
DCFS argued that after 18 months of services, Mother was
still “unable to regulate” and had not made significant and
consistent progress. DCFS characterized the case as one where
Mother “has repeatedly struggled to follow recommendations by
her service providers, had difficulty signing releases of
information for the department to discuss the case-related issues
with her service providers and ultimately has really spent a lot of
time focusing on the wrong issues in the beginning of the case
and not really taking accountability for her behavior.”
The juvenile court terminated family reunification services
and scheduled a section 366.36 hearing for May 2025 to select
and implement a permanent plan for the children. The court
stated: “And the evidence points toward a number of concerning
facts for the court. I think they’re mostly summed up in a
statement by [licensed] psychiatric social worker, Mr. Astrachan,
at the bottom of page 20 opining regarding the state of mother’s
mental health, that he does not think that mother thinks that
she’s mentally ill. That doctors are still working to diagnose—to
evaluate mother to diagnose her particular illnesses; and he
14
believed bipolar and schizophrenia were likely. [¶] He said that
every time we talk, she is fine and considerate but there’s
something wrong with the client that we’re unable to figure out,
that one doctor is leaning towards bipolar, few thought
schizophrenia. This statement’s made in early October. That
was prior to the time that mother began the Abilify injections
that had been recommended for some time prior to that. [¶] But
one thing that stands out to the court today in the testimony is
that there was precious little testimony regarding mother’s
mental health. She testified to what she believed she’d been
diagnosed with and there was some testimony on the treatment
for that, specifically the medications that had been prescribed
and less . . . evidence as far as the steps that she had taken had
nothing to do with parenting classes than treatment of the
symptoms of an underlying issue raised by the mental illness
that go to, in large part, the communications between her and the
children that were the subject of the monitors stepping in on
multiple occasions and mother becoming dysregulated as a result
of that. [¶] And ultimately that causes the court serious concern
for mother’s credibility, whether it’s her perception of what is
being observed or that she is simply misstating facts as they are
alleged by the social workers, the monitors in this case, of her
conduct at hearings—or at the visits that led to the department
not liberalizing her visits with the children over a significant
period of time, 18 months. [¶] And I think the children, to their
credit, testified as might be expected, confirming a number of
statements made in the reports, statements that they had
previously made to the caregivers or social workers but walking
some of those back. And I don’t know that any of those is
dispositive, but it does paint a broader picture of the continued
15
risk of returning the children to their mother. [¶] The mother was
ordered to participate in programs and services as set forth in the
case plan, and I find that she is currently in substantial
compliance. [¶] I do find by clear and convincing evidence that
DCFS did comply with the case plan by making reasonable
efforts to return the children to a safe home and to complete steps
that are necessary to finalize the children’s permanent
placement. [¶] The court finds by a preponderance of the evidence
that return of the children to the physical custody of their mother
would create a substantial risk of detriment to their— to the
children, creating a continued necessity for and appropriateness
of the current placement. [¶] Reunification services are
terminated for mother because she does not meet the
requirements under section 366.22[, subdivision] (b) to permit the
court to continue reunification services.” The court set a
permanency planning hearing for May 29, 2025.
The next day Ms. S. reported Mother was seen after the
hearing at the courthouse screaming and hitting the elevator
door. Mother gave the caregiver an “evil” look and then ran to
the children, telling them the court had taken them away from
her. T.P. became emotional, L.P. ignored Mother and resumed
looking at her tablet, and N.P. grabbed onto the caregiver for
protection.
In March 2025 Ms. S. reported T.P. and N.P. fought after
every visit with Mother. During the March 5, 2025 visit, Mother
appeared disengaged and possibly under the influence as the
monitor observed her eyes to be barely open and continuously
blinking. She smiled at times that did not align with the
conversation. At another March visit, Mother repeatedly
encouraged T.P. to push another boy off the play structure after
16
the boy pushed T.P. The monitor had to intervene,
complimenting T.P. for not pushing back and urging him to tell
an adult if it happened again. That month, Mother gave T.P. her
telephone number and told him to call her. T.P. denied having
the phone number, although the caregiver later found it. T.P.’s
behavior and lying had worsened, according to the caregiver.
L.P. simply stated Mother was “tripping” at a recent visit.
By April 2025, Ms. S. reported the children generally
struggled to deescalate after visits with Mother. Their behaviors
seemed to be directly influenced by Mother’s mood during their
time together. DCFS suspected Mother used bathroom breaks to
communicate privately with the children as “evidenced” by the
children’s questions when they returned to their placement. The
children’s therapist noted a regression in the children’s
willingness to discuss their feelings after visits with Mother.
DCFS advised the court that Mother “failed to demonstrate an
understanding of how her mental health and her subsequent
behaviors negatively affect the children.” Ms. S. reported Mother
continued to tell the children they would be going home with her
at the next hearing, causing behavioral issues.
At a visit in May 2025, Mother had the children write down
her name, telling them it was so they could find her when they
were older. During a visit on May 24, 2024, Mother watched
without comment as the children acted out in a restaurant by
banging utensils and kicking each other. When N.P. fell and hurt
his knee at the park, Mother did not comfort him; she told him to
stop crying. On the way back from the visit, the social worker
twice asked the children how they liked the visit. They remained
silent and looked at one another.
17
The permanency planning hearing began on May 29, 2025.
The children’s testimony revealed their distressing positions
“between a rock and a hard place,” as the saying goes.
A. T.P.
T.P. was eight years old when the case was filed. After the
initial incident at his school on May 10, 2023, he said his mother
had been crying because his father’s family was out to get them.
Mother had told him his father had left him a lot of money and
the paternal family was now out to get it. T.P. told DCFS that
when the family lived in Chicago, they lived hotel to hotel and his
father’s family was after them. T.P. said he witnessed domestic
violence between his parents. T.P. said Mother would get angry
and often get scared. He denied being afraid of Mother. He said
he was scared for his life because Mother was scared.
Before the adjudication hearing in September 2023, T.P.
told DCFS he became sad, lonely and worried when separated
from Mother. He said he found it hard to adjust to his foster
home but reported he had fun and participated in several
activities there. Mother reported T.P. would become tearful
about leaving her side after scheduled visits. She also reported
T.P would try to protect her when there was domestic violence in
their former home. He was observed to be overprotective of his
brother and sister and jealous when others played with his
siblings. He was sure there were “bad people in Chicago trying to
hurt his mom.”
In November 2023, T.P. reported he enjoyed meeting with
his therapist and he would like to see the caregivers and go to
church with them even if he returned to his mother’s custody. He
was observed to be more outgoing and comfortable with stating
how he felt. T.P.’s therapist believed T.P. was parentified and
18
hesitant. During a video call in April 2024, Ms. S. overheard N.P.
asking Mother about passports and the plan to leave. T.P. then
hit N.P.
In July 2024, T.P. reported it was hard to tell Mother “no.”
He noted Mother got upset and then he was afraid to tell her
things. He was also worried that he would not go back to her and
the family would not be together again. T.P. stated he was the
most comfortable at visits with his Mother when the monitor was
present. He appeared well bonded with the S.’s and continued to
report feeling safe and loved by his caregivers. T.P.’s therapist
indicated he was working with T.P. to make him recognize he
needed to be a child and it was not his responsibility to be a
father to his siblings. The therapist opined Mother had such a
psychological hold over T.P. that he felt he had to do everything
to get his siblings to behave in the way he thought Mother
wanted them to behave. T.P. had not been able to get N.P. and
L.P. in line and Mother was now telling him he was not a man.
The therapist was concerned about how this was affecting T.P.
emotionally.
By October 2024, T.P.’s therapist opined he had become a
different child, becoming more reserved and cold. T.P. had taken
on the role of Mother’s protector and had a shift in his demeanor
after it was reported Mother told him he is not a man. The
therapist believed T.P. felt like he had failed Mother as he had
been unable to control his siblings’ engagement with her.
Conjoint therapy was out of the question because the therapist
believed T.P. would feel unable and uncomfortable expressing
himself to Mother and Mother would control the conversation.
T.P.’s therapist noted the “continuous spiral pattern of behavior”
by the children that followed Mother’s visits. T.P. said he liked to
19
have the monitor present during video calls and visits with
Mother. As much as he liked seeing and visiting Mother, he did
not like it when Mother yelled and did not listen to the monitor.
In December 2024, the caregiver reported T.P. was mean
towards his siblings, punching L.P. in the stomach. They had
argued earlier that day about returning to Mother.
In April 2025, DCFS reported T.P. was “strongly bonded”
with Mother, but he is not comfortable with unmonitored contact
during visitation. T.P. defended everything Mother did. He
sometimes told Mother to compose herself during visits to
prevent a visit from being canceled. T.P.’s relationship with
Mother had adversely affected his academic performance as he
had difficulty staying focused in class and needed assistance
completing assignments.
That same month, the caregiver reported that it had been a
difficult weekend due to T.P.’s acting out. During a recent visit,
the monitor had gone to the restroom, and Mother told the
children they had to fight for her in court or they would be
adopted. The caregiver reported that T.P. said “ ‘I just want to be
a kid, and I have too much stuff on my shoulders and that mom
wants me to lie for her and I can’t do it.’ ” The caregiver reported
T.P. stated he was disappointed in Mother and felt guilty both if
he told the truth and if he lied to her.
T.P. confirmed to the social worker that Mother told the
children to fight for her because she did not want them to be
adopted. T.P. said he felt he was in a tug of war between Mother
and Ms. S. and he felt like he had to lie because of Mother but he
was sad doing so because of Ms. S. T.P. said he wanted to go
home with Mother or at least have overnight visitation with her.
20
Against this backdrop T.P. testified on May 29, 2025 at the
permanency planning hearing. He stated he did not want to be
adopted if it meant he would not be able to see Mother anymore.
He thought “of happiness” when he thought of Mother. She was
one of the people he felt closest to and he did not want to lose
another parent after losing his father. T.P. testified Mother told
him “You have to fight for me” which meant trying to stay with
her, trying to get back. He felt both mother and Ms. S. wanted
him to say what they wanted to hear. T.P. acknowledged he
would be alright staying with Mr. and Ms. S. as long as he could
still talk to Mother. He did not want to be adopted if it meant he
could not see Mother.
B. L.P.
L.P. is Mother’s seven-year-old daughter. After the initial
May 10 incident at school, L.P. said people at the shelter were
messing with the family’s food. She acknowledged Mother put
soap in their milk to stop other people from drinking it. She
shared Mother had been crying and said unspecified people
wanted to kill them and take the children away.
L.P. reported that when she was separated from Mother’s
care, she became sad, lonely and worried. She had trouble
initially adjusting to the placement, but stated she enjoys living
there because they have fun and participate in several activities.
She reported feeling safe at the foster home. She was happy
when visiting with Mother because they did fun activities. She
stated, however, she wanted the monitor to stay with them at the
visits.
In July 2023, L.P. stated she had witnessed her father
dragging her mother by the hair to the bathtub.
21
In November 2023, L.P. was described as “always happy
and friendly.” “[S]he is pretty quiet but she is usually always
happy unless her brothers start to annoy her. [She] is very
honest and loves to dress up and dance.” L.P. reported that she
wanted to continue to go to church on Sundays and her social
worker observed she was well bonded with her caregivers and is
comfortable telling them her needs or wants. She excelled in
mental health services. L.P. reported she feels happy when she is
at visits with Mother, but she still wanted a monitor to be with
them at visits.
By July 2024, L.P. was still reporting she liked the fun
things she does with Mother during visits, but it was hard to tell
Mother how she felt because she was worried Mother would “get
mad” at her. At one visit Mother made the children take a nap.
L.P. did not want to do that, but she did not want to tell Mother
because she did not want to upset her. L.P. said she liked the
visitation monitor because the monitor watches them. DCFS
noted L.P. tended to “get quiet and closed off when discussing
mother.” L.P. also told Ms. S. that Mother was “ ‘ruining our
lives.’ ”
At a visit in September 2024, L.P. tried to hug Mother, who
pushed L.P. away.
By November 2024, L.P. had reported she did not like it
when Mother yelled, did not listen to the social worker, and
pushed L.P. away when L.P. tried to hug her. She did not like it
when Mother whispered things in her ear because what Mother
said saddened and upset her. DCFS reported L.P., “became
closed off” when asked about the things Mother said to her. L.P.
liked that visitation was monitored. She remained consistent
22
that she wanted to have contact with her mother but felt most
safe and happy when monitors were present.
Against this backdrop, L.P. testified at the permanency
planning hearing. She stated she liked visiting with Mother and
also felt “good” about the caregivers. She did not want to be
adopted by Ms. S. but wanted to stay with them until Mother
could get her back. She felt safe when alone with Mother and felt
Mother was not ready for her to go home now. L.P. testified she
still sometimes felt most safe when there was a monitor present
at her visits with Mother. She loved the S.’s and Mother. Mother
told L.P. to fight for her, but L.P. said she did not know what
Mother meant by that.2
Mother also testified at the permanency planning hearing.
The children were now seven, nine and ten years old. She had
regular visits with them where they played games, talked about
school, and read books. She felt the children were happy and
loving during the visits and never expressed discomfort at seeing
her.
Counsel for T.P. and L.P. argued that the juvenile court
should apply the beneficial parental relationship exception to
termination of parental rights.
On June 6, 2025, the juvenile court made extensive
findings about the two years Mother and the children had been
before the court. The juvenile court declined to apply the
beneficial parental relationship exception, terminated Mother’s
parental rights, and ordered adoption as the permanent plan for
all three children. In doing so, the court concluded: “The court
2 Mother has not challenged the termination order as to N.P.
so we do not recite his testimony at the hearing.
23
reviewed the evidence and considered the testimony of everyone,
and the 2021 case In re Caden C. as set forth in the minute order.
[¶] . . . In order to meet the Caden C. standard, [Mother] is
required to prove by preponderance of evidence that she
maintains regular, consistent contact with the children, taking
into account the extent of visitation permitted that the children
have a substantial, positive, emotional attachment to her and
that terminating the attachment would be detrimental to the
children when balanced against the countervailing benefit of a
new adoptive home. [¶] . . . [Mother] has maintained regular and
consistent contact with the children. . . . [¶] The children have
resided in their current placement since they were removed from
[Mother] in May 2023. In order to make a determination
regarding whether there’s a substantial, positive, emotional
attachment, the court has considered the reports for the relevant
information regard[ing] the children’s relationship with [Mother].
[¶] When the children were taken into custody by D.C.F.S., the
children described having to move around a lot while in mother’s
care. They described mother’s paranoid, delusional behavior they
thought people were out to kill them, which is why they had to
move around so much, which is why they left Chicago and ended
up in California. They obviously love their mother when they
were removed from the department, she was their only caregiver
when they were detained. [¶] When the court examined the
evidence in the [six month status review] report dated March 6,
2024, the children had been in case for ten months. [¶] The report
notes [T.P] has gone from being closed off and reserved to more
outgoing and comfortable with stating how he’s feeling. [T.P.]
has been [seen] during in-person monthly visits as well bond[ed]
with the caregivers and stated he enjoys being there and stated
24
even though he goes back to mom, he still wants to see Ms. [S.]
and go to church with them. [¶] . . . [¶] [L.P.] reports how happy
she was with Ms. [S.] and likes going to church on Sunday. [¶] ‘I
really like being here because Ms. [S.] is nice. She gives me toys,
dresses, and she does my hair. I love going to church. My mom
said I can see her when we go back with mom.’ [¶] In the
beginning of this case the department’s characterization of
[Mother’s] visits with the children was very good; in fact, they
said visits were excellent; but subsequently there was [a] decline
in the quality and nature of the visits. The Department
described in subsequent reports that [Mother] spent some time
unable to focus on the children during visits. She would argue
with the social workers. She was unable to engage with all three
children at once. [¶] [T.P. and N.P.] reported feeling not in terms
of jealousy but that [Mother] spent more time with the other
children and that it hurt their feelings. The children have been
in therapy while in the [caregivers’] care. [¶] In the [six-month
status review] report the therapist indicated in-person monthly
visits she had seen [L.P.] well bonded with the caregivers . . . and
reports [L.P.] is comfortable telling them what her needs and
wants are. [Her] therapist reports that [L.P.] is a role model
client and has [excelled] in mental health services. She enjoys
meeting with her therapist once a week. [L.P.] expressed she felt
happy when visiting her mom because of the fun activities they
do, but she would like C.S.W. Jenkins to stay with them during
visits. [¶] . . . [¶] The therapist for the children commented that
working with [T.P.] has been going well but that [T.P.] is more
parentified and hesitant. [¶] Mr. Davis reports he’s worried that
Mother was doing what she can to undermine the foster parent,
which can cause disruption with the children . . . . [¶] . . . There
25
were several notes of [Mother] having inappropriate discussions
with the kids, telling them their caregivers are the reason they
cannot go home, telling them they are going home at the next
court hearing. [¶] [In] the report dated July 10, 2024, the children
had been in care for 14 months. [¶] [T.P.] reported, ‘It is hard to
tell my mom no. Sometimes I’m scared and worried. Sometimes
mom gets upset, and I’m scared to tell her some things, but I am
also worried that I will not go back to mom and be together’. [¶]
[T.P.] reported he’s happy and loves Ms. [S.] but still likes seeing
his mom; that at visits he feels the most comfortable when C.S.W.
Jenkins is present. [T.P.] appears well bonded with the
caregivers and continues to report being safe and loved from the
caregivers. [¶] [L.P.] reports, ‘Sometimes it is hard to tell mom
how I feel because I’m worried she’ll get mad at me. Mom made
us take a nap last time, and I did not like it. I don’t know why
she made us do that. I did not want to tell her no because I did
not want to upset her.’ [¶] [L.P.] tends to be closed off and
reserved when discussing how she would feel if monitor C.S.W.
Jenkins was not present. [L.P.] reported she likes Mr. Jenkins
there because he watches them. . . . [¶] . . . [¶] At the 18 month
review hearing, the November 12, 2024 report indicated that the
children, during monthly visits with the social worker, have an
appropriate bond with caregivers and continue to report they feel
happy and safe with Mr. and Mrs. [S]. They report they enjoy
church every Sunday with the caregivers as well as feeling loved
and safe with the [S.’s]. [¶] [T.P.] turns into physical aggression
against [N.P.] when [N.P.] refuses to participate in phone calls
and visits with [Mother]. The children’s therapist at that time
expressed extreme concern about [T.P.’s] emotional state and
asked whether it was possible not to have the children visit their
26
mother. The therapist reported concerns with the children’s
emotional state as he expressed a significant shift in their
behaviors. [¶] Mr. Davis [the therapist] reports [T.P.] is becoming
a completely different kid, becoming more reserved. He asked
the social worker if there is a way to not have visits between
mother and the children or reduce the visits. [¶] Mr. Davis
reported visits were detrimental to the children at this time and
stated, ‘I met with [T.P.], and it is like he’s a different kid. He
was not the happy, smiling kid I am used to see[ing], but I can
tell something was going on because he was just cold and not
present. I have to feel [T.P.] has taken on the role as the
protector of mom, and there’s been a shift in his demeanor after
the report of mother telling him he’s not a man.’ [¶] Mr. Davis
reported concerns that [T.P.] during that time felt like he had
failed his mother as he had not been able to control his siblings
and their engagement with mom and then having mom tell him
over and over that he’s not the man. Mr. Davis voiced concerns
about the psychological effect Mother’s involvement with them
plays on the children. [¶] Mr. Davis reported there was fear that
the rapport he buil[t] with [T.P.] would be eliminated if [Mother]
continued to be in the picture. Mr. Davis reported there is a
continuing spiral pattern of behavior following Mother’s visits. [¶]
A concern was raised that [Mother] was discussing her financial
situation with the children and asked [T.P.] to help her. Money
had come up missing in the caregivers’ home. [T.P.] had asked to
bring money back to mom to help her. The caregivers spoke with
[T.P.] and reminded [him] he’s not responsible for his mom’s
financial needs. [¶] [T.P. and L.P.] both described enjoying visits
with [Mother], as long as the social worker is there, that they do
not like it when she uses the rest room in front of them or argues
27
or yells at social workers. [¶] [L.P.] shared she doesn’t like it
when [Mother] whispers bad things in her ears. It makes her
upset. . . . [¶] . . . [¶] [Mother] frequently becomes dysregulated
during visits to the extent that monitors are unable to redirect
them, which has led to some visits being terminated early. [¶] . . .
[A]fter the 18 month review hearing on January 14, 2025, when
the court terminated [Mother’s] reunification services, she had a
dramatic breakdown in front of the kids in the courthouse where
she cried, screamed, and banged on the elevator door. [¶] [T.P.]
became emotional, [L.P.] shut down, and [N.P.] immediately went
to his caregiver for protection. The children have witnessed
firsthand how [Mother] is affected by this case, and their
testimony on May 29[, 2025] was the result of it leading up to the
permanency planning hearing. [¶] [T.P.] told the social worker,
. . . ‘I feel like I’m a rope. I would love staying here. I just want
to talk to my mom.’ He said he did not want to be adopted and
. . . that he would feel sad if he could not see her anymore during
testimony. [¶] [L.P.] testified that mom told the children if they
love her, they need to fight for her. She then stated [if] she were
adopted, she would feel calm; however, when she testified, she
said she doesn’t want to be adopted but wants to continue living
there until mom gets them back. [¶] For the first time in the life
of this case, she said she feels safe with her mom, despite
repeatedly telling her social workers that she wants them present
when she visits her mom. [¶] . . . [¶] It is clear [the children] love
their mother. They want to protect her and do not want to make
her unhappy. It is clear they are safer and happier where they
are, but they are conflicted about those feelings. They have seen
how upset she was after the [18-month review] hearing, and they
do not want to be the cause of upsetting [her] more. [¶] Given all
28
the evidence, I can’t find that [Mother] has shown by
preponderance of evidence that her relationship is a substantial
positive emotional attachment. I can’t find that terminating that
attachment would be detrimental to the children when balanced
against the countervailing benefit against a new adoptive home.
[¶] The children will struggle with this court’s decision. I know
they will be sad, but I have seen from the evidence they recognize
they have a healthy, stable home, and they want to stay there; so
I am finding that the permanence to be achieved by adoption
outweighs the attachment they have to their mom. [¶] . . . [¶] The
court finds by clear and convincing evidence that the children are
adoptable, and there are no legal impediments to adoption.” The
juvenile court went on to designate the current caregivers as the
children’s prospective adoptive parents.
This appeal followed.
DISCUSSION
A. Beneficial Parental Relationship Exception to Adoption
Mother contends the juvenile court should have applied the
beneficial parental relationship exception to termination of
parental rights because she proved the three elements that
establish the exception. We disagree.
1. Applicable Law
At the permanency planning hearing, if the court finds that
the child is likely to be adopted and that “there has been a
previous determination that reunification services be terminated,
then the court shall terminate parental rights to allow for
adoption. [Citation.] But if the parent shows that termination
would be detrimental to the child for at least one specifically
enumerated reason, the court should decline to terminate
29
parental rights and select another permanent plan.” (In re Caden
C. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 614, 630–631 (Caden C.); see § 366.26,
subd. (c)(1)(B)(i)–(vi), (4)(A).)
One of the exceptions, the beneficial parental relationship
exception, applies when (1) “the parent has regularly visited with
the child”; (2) “the child would benefit from continuing the
relationship”; and (3) “terminating the relationship would be
detrimental to the child.” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 629;
see § 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i).) “The first element—regular
visitation and contact—is straightforward. The question is just
whether ‘parents visit consistently,’ taking into account ‘the
extent permitted by court orders.’ ” (Caden C., at p. 632.)
To establish the second element, that the child would
benefit from continuing the relationship, the parent must show
the child has a “substantial, positive, emotional attachment to
the parent—the kind of attachment implying that the child would
benefit from continuing the relationship.” (Caden C., supra,
11 Cal.5th at p. 636.) The “focus is the child,” and “the
relationship may be shaped by a slew of factors, such as ‘[t]he age
of the child, the portion of the child’s life spent in the parent’s
custody, the “positive” or “negative” effect of interaction between
parent and child, and the child’s particular needs.’ ” (Id. at
p. 632.)
“Concerning the third element—whether ‘termination
would be detrimental to the child due to’ the relationship—the
court must decide whether it would be harmful to the child to
sever the relationship and choose adoption.” (Caden C., supra,
11 Cal.5th at p. 633.) “When it weighs whether termination
would be detrimental, the court is not comparing the parent’s
attributes as custodial caregiver relative to those of any potential
30
adoptive parent(s). . . . Accordingly, courts should not look to
whether the parent can provide a home for the child.” (Id. at
p. 634.) “When the relationship with a parent is so important to
the child that the security and stability of a new home wouldn’t
outweigh its loss, termination would be ‘detrimental to the child
due to’ the child’s beneficial relationship with a parent.” (Id. at
pp. 633–634.)
The parent bears the burden to show the statutory
exception applies. (In re Derek W. (1999) 73 Cal.App.4th 823,
826.) When a parent meets that burden, it would not be in the
best interest of the child to terminate parental rights. In that
case the court must select a permanent plan other than adoption.
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at pp. 636–637.)
We review the court’s findings using a hybrid approach: for
the first two elements, which require factual findings (parental
visitation and the child’s emotional attachment), we apply the
substantial evidence standard of review; and for the court’s
weighing of the relative harms and benefits of terminating
parental rights, we use the abuse of discretion standard. (Caden
C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at pp. 639–640.) However, when the party
with the burden of proof did not carry the burden, “the question
for a reviewing court becomes whether the evidence compels a
finding in favor of the appellant as a matter of law. [Citations.]
Specifically, the question becomes whether the appellant’s
evidence was (1) ‘uncontradicted and unimpeached’ and (2) ‘of
such a character and weight as to leave no room for a judicial
determination that it was insufficient to support a finding.’ ” (In
re I.W. (2009) 180 Cal.App.4th 1517, 1528, disapproved on other
grounds by Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1010,
fn. 7.)
31
2. Analysis
As set out above, the juvenile court found that Mother had
failed to show by a preponderance of the evidence that the benefit
of maintaining a relationship with her outweighed the benefits to
T.P. and L.P. of permanency through adoption. Put another way,
Mother failed to show that it would be more harmful to each child
to sever the relationship with her than to give each of them an
adoptive family. (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 633 [would a
new stable home, on balance, alleviate the emotional instability
and preoccupation that may result from the loss of a parent].)
Mother does not challenge the facts that support adoption.
She simply argues they are not sufficient. We disagree and
conclude the facts do support rejecting the parental benefit
exception to adoption. The facts speak for themselves. In
summary, the children spent two full years subject to Mother’s
volatile and unpredictable behavior, unkind comments, and, at
times, outright rejection of their presence in her life. Their love
for her belied the chronic distress she subjected them to while
acting as their parent. The evidence substantially supported the
juvenile court’s conclusion that there was no positive, emotional
attachment between Mother and her children and that, as a
result, the children would not benefit from maintaining their
emotional relationship with her.
The juvenile court also did not abuse its discretion in
finding that the balance of facts favored adoption. Mother had
18 months of reunification services and, despite some periods of
relative calm, she was as erratic and volatile at the end of the
period as she was at the beginning of the case. The juvenile court
keenly observed the cycle of volatility that the children and
Mother endured during the two-year life of this case. T.P. and
32
L.P. were riding an emotional roller coaster as their Mother
repeatedly lost her focus, denied her mental health issues, and
ladled aggression, anger, and blame on them, the caregivers, and
those providing her support services and housing. Mother’s
repeated inability to regulate her emotions, resulting in
termination of several shelter opportunities and service
programs, did not inspire trust that she could act as the lone
responsible “adult in the room” with her children. It is telling
that in 18 months, she had no unmonitored visitation with her
children. It is more telling that the children welcomed the
monitoring. The children’s interactions with Mother caused them
stress, fear, and discomfort. The court’s decision was difficult
because the children were old enough to feel conflicted, feelings
the juvenile court acknowledged. Nevertheless, after 18 months
of services that seemed to make no dent in Mother’s
unpredictable volatility and negative impact on her children, it
was time for the court to give them what they needed most—a
safe, secure, predictable home. The juvenile court did not abuse
its discretion in doing so.
B. Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 (ICWA)
Here DCFS sent notices to the Cherokee tribes after
learning late in the game that maternal great grandfather may
have Cherokee heritage. There is no record that DCFS ever filed
its notices or any responses it may have received as a result of its
inquiries. Nor does the record reflect whether DCFS attempted
to learn whether the maternal great grandfather was available to
be questioned about his ancestry. The juvenile court ultimately
did not compel DCFS to complete its inquiry and it found that it
had no reason to know that the children had Indian heritage.
33
Mother contends substantial evidence does not support the
juvenile court’s conclusion that there is no reason to know that
the children may have Indian heritage. DCFS concedes the
juvenile court erred in this regard. We agree and conditionally
reverse so that the juvenile court can complete its ICWA review
and analysis properly.
1. Applicable Law
ICWA was enacted “ ‘to protect the best interests of Indian
children and to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes
and families by the establishment of minimum Federal standards
for the removal of Indian children from their families and the
placement of such children in foster or adoptive homes which will
reflect the unique values of Indian culture.’ ” (In re Dezi C. (2024)
16 Cal.5th 1112, 1128–1129 (Dezi C.), quoting 25 U.S.C. § 1902.)
Both ICWA and the Welfare and Institutions Code define an
“Indian child” as “any unmarried person who is under age
eighteen and is either (a) a member of an Indian tribe or (b) is
eligible for membership in an Indian tribe and is the biological
child of a member of an Indian tribe.” (25 U.S.C. § 1903(4);
§ 224.1, subds. (a), (b) [incorporating federal definitions].)
The juvenile court and DCFS are charged with “an
affirmative and continuing duty to inquire whether a child for
whom a petition under Section 300 . . . may be or has been filed,
is or may be an Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (a); see In re Isaiah
W. (2016) 1 Cal.5th 1, 9, 11–12.) The duty to inquire whether a
child is an Indian child begins with the initial contact, i.e., when
the referring party reports child abuse or neglect that triggers
DCFS’s investigation. (§ 224.2, subd. (b)(1), (2).) DCFS’s initial
duty to inquire includes asking the child, parents, legal guardian,
extended family members, and others who have an interest in the
34
child whether the child is, or may be, an Indian child. (Id.,
subd. (b)(2).) Extended family members include “a person who
has reached 18 years of age and who is the [child’s] grandparent,
aunt or uncle, brother or sister, brother-in-law or sister-in-law,
niece or nephew, first or second cousin, or stepparent.” (§ 224.1,
subd. (c)(1); 25 U.S.C. § 1903(2).)
“When the agency has ‘reason to believe’ that an Indian
child is involved, further inquiry regarding the possible Indian
status of the child is required.” (Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at
p. 1132.) There is “reason to believe” a child involved in a
proceeding is an Indian child whenever the court or social worker
“has information suggesting that either the parent of the child or
the child is a member or citizen, or may be eligible for
membership or citizenship, in an Indian tribe.” (§ 224.2,
subd. (e)(1).) Further inquiry may be conducted by, among other
things, interviewing the parents and extended family members,
and contacting any tribe that may reasonably be expected to have
information about the child’s membership, citizen status, or
eligibility. (Id., subd. (e)(2).)
If the inquiry establishes a “reason to know” an Indian
child is involved, notice of the proceedings must be provided to
the pertinent tribes. (Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at p. 1133; In re
Q.M. (2022) 79 Cal.App.5th 1068, 1079.) There is “reason to
know” a child is an Indian child if any one of six statutory criteria
is met—e.g., if the court is advised that the child “is an Indian
child,” the child’s or parent’s residence is on a reservation, the
child is or has been a ward of a tribal court, or either parent or
the child possess an identification card indicating membership or
citizenship in an Indian tribe. (§ 224.2, subd. (d).) Thereafter,
the court shall confirm that DCFS used due diligence to identify
35
and work with all of the tribes of which there is reason to know
the child may be a member, or eligible for membership, to verify
whether the child is in fact a member or whether a biological
parent is a member and the child is eligible for membership. (Id.,
subd. (g).) A determination by an Indian tribe that a child is or is
not a member of, or eligible for membership in, that tribe “shall
be conclusive.” (Id., subd. (h).)
If, instead, the juvenile court finds no reason to know the
child is an Indian child and finds “that an agency’s inquiry and
due diligence were ‘proper and adequate,’ ” the court may make a
finding that ICWA does not apply. (Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at
p. 1134, quoting § 224.2, subd. (i)(2).) A court may not find that
ICWA does not apply when the absence of evidence that a child is
an Indian child results from an inquiry that is not proper,
adequate, or demonstrative of due diligence. (In re Josiah T.
(2021) 71 Cal.App.5th 388, 408 (Josiah T.).)
2. Standard of Review
We review the juvenile court’s ICWA findings for
substantial evidence. (Josiah T., supra, 71 Cal.App.5th at p. 401;
In re S.R. (2021) 64 Cal.App.5th 303, 312; Dezi C., supra,
16 Cal.5th at p. 1134 [“The juvenile court’s factual finding that
ICWA does not apply is ‘subject to reversal based on sufficiency of
the evidence.’ ”].) If our review reveals error resulting in in
inadequate initial ICWA inquiry, then we must order “conditional
reversal with directions for the child welfare agency to comply
with the inquiry requirement of section 224.2, document its
inquiry in compliance with [California Rules of Court],
rule 5.481(a)(5), and when necessary, comply with the notice
provision of section 224.3.” (Dezi C., at p. 1136.)
36
3. Analysis
The trial court erred in not completing its inquiry into the
children’s possible Indian heritage. (§ 224.2, subd. (b); see In re
Y.W. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 542, 555 [juvenile court has a duty “to
ensure the Department adequately investigated the children’s
possible Indian ancestry through [Mother’s] side of the family”];
In re Rylei S. (2022) 81 Cal.App.5th 309, 320.) The juvenile court
should have followed up with DCFS as to its efforts to ascertain
whether the children had possible Cherokee heritage through
Mother’s side of the family. “[T]he court has a responsibility to
ascertain that the agency has conducted an adequate
investigation and cannot simply sign off on the notices as legally
adequate without doing so.” (In re K.R. (2018) 20 Cal.App.5th
701, 709.) Conditional reversal is required when error results in
an inadequate ICWA inquiry. (Dezi C., supra, 16 Cal.5th at
p. 1152.)
We note ICWA does not require DCFS to “cast about” for
investigative leads. (In re D.S. (2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 1041,
1053.) At this point DCFS’s obligation is to advise the court as to
any response it received from its notice to the Cherokee tribes
and the court’s obligation is to act upon that advisement.
37
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s termination order is conditionally
reversed. The matter is remanded for the limited purpose of
complying with the inquiry and notice provisions of ICWA and its
California implementing provisions. If the juvenile court
thereafter finds a further inquiry was proper and adequate, finds
due diligence has been conducted, and concludes ICWA does not
apply, it shall reinstate the termination order. If the juvenile
court concludes ICWA does apply, then it shall vacate the
underlying order and proceed in conformity with ICWA and
related California law. (25 U.S.C. § 1912(a); §§ 224.2, subd. (i)(1),
224.3 & 224.4.)
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
STRATTON, P. J.
We concur:
WILEY, J.
SCHERB, J.
38
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.