CourtListener 10858312•Glickman v. Newmeyer & Dillion CA4/3
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 5/13/26 Glickman v. Newmeyer & Dillion CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
WILLIAM GLICKMAN,
Plaintiff and Respondent, G065111
v. (Super. Ct. Case No. 30-2019-
01049771)
NEWMEYER & DILLION LLP,
OPINION
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Theodore R. Howard, Judge. Reversed in part, affirmed in part. Motion for
Partial Dismissal of Appeal. Denied. Motion to Take Additional Evidence.
Denied.
Hinshaw & Culbertson, Desmond Hinds, Linda Streeter, and
David T. Hayek, for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Annigian Ryan, James T. Ryan and Nicholas A. Kurtz, for
Defendant and Respondent.
* * *
Newmeyer & Dillion (N&D) appeals from a discovery order
awarding $16,000 in monetary sanctions to respondent William Glickman.
N&D contends the monetary sanctions are based on two other discovery
orders: (1) an issue sanctions order finding N&D had failed to preserve
evidence; and (2) an order compelling further responses. N&D argues there
was insufficient evidence to support the issue sanctions order. We agree.
However, we disagree with N&D’s claim that the trial court abused its
discretion in granting the motion to compel further responses. Because there
remains an independent basis for the monetary sanctions, there was no abuse
of discretion in imposing monetary sanctions. Accordingly, we reverse the
issue sanctions order and affirm the order compelling further responses and
the monetary sanctions.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
I.
COMPLAINT AND EVIDENCE PRESERVATION LETTER
On February 6, 2019, Glickman filed a malpractice complaint
against Attorney Charles Krolikowski and N&D, alleging causes of action
arising from their representation of him in an Orange County Superior Court
case number 30-2018-00964856 lawsuit entitled Glickman v. Meston (the
“Meston Action”) He filed a second amended complaint, the operative
complaint in this matter, on May 4, 2023. As relevant to this case, Glickman
alleged he was persuaded to pursue a litigation strategy that Attorney
Krolikowski and N&D Attorney Jason Caruso knew or should have known
would not result in achieving his objectives. For example, he had a limited
2
budget and only filed a lawsuit against his neighbors to remove an adjoining
wall because he had been told he could recover attorney fees if he prevailed.
In actuality, however, he would not have recovered attorney fees even if he
had prevailed. The complaint alleged that when this and other adverse facts
became known, in late August 2018, he emailed Attorney Krolikowski, asking
him for a return call. He then spoke with Attorney Krolikowski and offered
not to sue N&D if they represented him for free in the Meston Action until it
was resolved. Attorney Krolikowski informed Glickman he would discuss the
matter with his managing partner, Greg Dillion. Ultimately, however, N&D
refused to help him unless he paid, which resulted in him having to represent
himself.
On May 20, 2019, Glickman’s attorney sent an electronically
stored information (ESI) preservation letter (ESI Preservation Letter) to
N&D. The ESI Preservation Letter provided notice to N&D to “immediately
take all steps necessary to prevent the destruction, loss, concealment, or
alteration of,” among other things, potentially relevant ESI on computers or
storage media, including “smart phones,” “cell phones,” and “laptop
computers.” It specifically noted: “Adequate preservation of ESI requires
more than simply refraining from efforts to destroy or dispose of such
evidence. N&D must also intervene to prevent loss due to routine operations
and employ proper techniques to safeguard all such evidence.” N&D also was
requested to modify or suspend features and operations that could cause the
loss of ESI, including, “reassigning, re-imaging or disposing of systems,
devices, or media.”
On January 11, 2023, Glickman served his second set of special
interrogatories on N&D. The special interrogatories asked N&D to describe
its efforts to search for relevant documents, to identify each devices searched,
3
and to “Describe any actions YOU took in response to the ESI [P]reservation
[L]etter from Tracy L. Anielski dated May 20, 2019, including without
limitation what, if anything, was done, who did it and when.”
In response, on February 15, 2023, N&D stated that searches
were conducted “at different times as the instant [a]ction developed” by
attorneys Krolikowski, Caruso, and Polyakov in his capacity as general
counsel. These searches included “hard drives of the work laptop computers
used by [attorneys] Krolikowski and Caruso during the time at issue. . . . The
search of the hard drive of [Attorney] Krolikowski’[]s work laptop was
conducted by [Attorney] Krolikowski.” In response to the interrogatory about
the ESI Preservation Letter, N&D stated it “reviewed the ESI [Preservation
L]etter when it was received and acted in accordance therewith. Pursuant to
the reasonable search and diligent inquiry of [N&D], [it] is not aware of any
of its files regarding the [Meston Action] being destroyed. Discovery is
continuing. [N&D] reserves the right to amend this response.”
On June 27, 2023, N&D served supplemental responses,
providing a range of dates for when the searches were conducted of “iManage
and Mimecase.” Its response to the ESI special interrogatory was not
changed.
II.
MOTIONS TO COMPEL FURTHER RESPONSES
On July 31, 2023, Glickman filed a motion to compel further
responses to his second set of special interrogatories and for monetary
sanctions in the amount of $6,430. The discovery referee (Retired Judge
David R. Chaffee) recommended overruling all objections to special
interrogatories 71 through 76, granting the motion to compel further
4
responses, and awarding $2,500 in sanctions. Later, the trial court adopted
the referee’s recommendations.
On November 30, 2023, N&D served its second supplemental
responses, which asserted that, aside from its iManage system, Mimecast
system, paper files and hard drives of personal work laptops assigned to
attorneys Krolikowski and Caruso, it “is unaware of any other locations
where [responsive documents] could have ever existed.” As to the ESI
Preservation Letter, N&D stated: “To [N&D]’s best recollection, [its] general
counsel, Leonard Polyakov reviewed the ESI [Preservation L]etter when it
was received and, on or about that same day, reviewed the letter with
[Attorney] Krolikowski. To the best of [N&D]’s recollection, [Attorney]
Polyakov, on behalf of [N&D], and [Attorney] Krolikowski, on behalf of
himself, confirmed to one another that both [N&D] and [Attorney]
Krolikowski would abide by the directives of the [ESI Preservation L]etter.
[Attorney] Polyakov further confirmed that Mimecast system does not allow
documents to be deleted and that by the time the [ESI Preservation L]etter
was received the file had been transferred to [Glickman]’s new counsel.”
On December 28, 2023, Glickman filed his second motion to
compel further responses to his second set of special interrogatories, this time
requesting monetary sanctions in the amount of $6,430. The discovery referee
recommended granting the motion to compel further response to the second
set of special interrogatories and awarding $6,000 in sanctions.
On February 13, 2024, N&D served its third supplemental
responses. The responses provided further details about the searches,
including that “records specific to documenting search dates were not
created.” For the first time, N&D also stated the cellular phones of attorneys
Krolikowski and Caruso were searched. Its response to the ESI special
5
interrogatory added additional qualifiers such as stating that Attorney
Polyakov reviewed and “discussed” the ESI Preservation Letter with
Attorney Krolikowski and that the Mimecast system does not allow emails to
be “modified” or deleted.
On March 27, 2024, Glickman filed a third motion to compel
further responses and requested $7,332.50 in monetary sanctions. The
discovery referee recommended granting Glickman’s third motion to compel
further responses and awarding $2,500 in sanctions.
After retaining new counsel, on May 2, 2024, N&D served its
fourth supplemental responses. These responses contained specific details
about searches, including names, dates, search terms and serial numbers of
devices. For the first time, N&D disclosed that the cellular phones that were
searched had replaced other prior phones. Specifically as to Attorney Caruso,
N&D stated that “[e]ach time he got a new phone[, Attorney] Caruso utilized
the Samsung/Google feature which transfers call history, texts, etc. over to
the new phone.” N&D also disclosed the laptops and computers searched had
been placed into service in 2022, and that ESI stored in its iManage had been
“migrated” to the current version of iManage. Its response to the ESI special
interrogatory was substantively the same, except with additional details
about conversations relating to compliance with the ESI Preservation Letter.
III.
MOTION FOR ADDITIONAL DISCOVERY SANCTIONS
On August 2, 2024, Glickman filed a motion for issue and
evidentiary sanctions, or in the alternative, an order compelling further
responses, and a request for monetary sanctions in the amount of $16,545. As
to the issue sanctions, Glickman requested the trial court order the following
facts as established, including: “That N&D knowingly and willfully failed to
6
conduct adequate searches for documents in response to [Glickman]’s
requests to hide the fact that it had hidden and/or destroyed documents that
would have adversely affected its defense”; “That N&D knowingly, willfully
and repeatedly provided evasive responses in discovery regarding its searches
for documents to try to avoid disclosing facts that would have adversely
affected its defense”; “That [Glickman] advised [Attorney] Polyakov [on] or
about August 2018 that he intended to sue N&D”; “That one of [Glickman]’s
attorneys, Tracy L. Anielski, sent N&D . . .[the ESI Preservation Letter]”;
“The ESI Preservation Letter required N&D to preserve all relevant
information, documents and devices, including cell phones, computers and
computer systems”; “That N&D knowingly and willfully failed to comply with
the ESI Preservation Letter by failing to preserve relevant information,
documents and devices, including cell phones, computers and computer
systems”; “That N&D knowingly and willfully failed to preserve relevant
information, documents and devices, including cell phones, computers and
computer systems, to avoid making disclosures that would have adversely
affected its defense.”
Glickman sought evidentiary sanctions prohibiting N&D from
adducing any evidence or argument at trial as to the factual findings above.
In the alternative, Glickman sought a recommendation compelling N&D to
provide a code-compliant further response. He also sought a recommendation
shifting all of the discovery referee’s fees to N&D.
In his memorandum in support of the sanctions motion,
Glickman argued that, “if, as it appears, N&D failed to preserve relevant
information, documents and/or [sic], [Glickman] is entitled to a spoliation of
evidence instruction at trial.” He cited Williams v. Russ (2008) 167
Cal.App.4th 1215 (Williams) for the definition of spoliation of evidence and
7
the available discovery sanctions for spoliation, including issue, evidence and
terminating sanctions. He also identified what he asserted were deficiencies
in the fourth supplemental responses, including N&D declining to search the
cellular phone of Attorney Dillion.
N&D opposed the sanctions motion. Among other things, it
argued issue and evidentiary sanctions were not appropriate because no prior
court order had been violated and the alterative remedy of an order
compelling discovery would not be futile. Citing Williams, it also argued that
Glickman had not shown that any evidence allegedly destroyed is probative
or relevant. (See Williams, supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p. 1227 [“[A] party
moving for discovery sanctions based on the spoliation of evidence must make
an initial prima facie showing that the responding party in fact destroyed
evidence that had a substantial probability of damaging the moving party's
ability to establish an essential element of his claim or
1
defense”].)
In reply, Glickman argued that discovery sanctions could be
imposed without violation of a prior court order, and citing Williams, supra,
167 Cal.App.4th 1215 asserted that “N&D’s failure to preserve the relevant
devices after receiving [ESI Preservation Letter] also is a misuse of the
discovery process that, standing alone, justifies the imposition of issue and
evidence sanctions.” Glickman further argued the discovery referee “should
1
In its opposition to specific issue sanctions, N&D argued there
was no evidence Glickman spoke with Attorney Polyakov in August 2018.
8
order N&D to serve further code-complaint supplemental response[s] no
2
matter how he rules on the subject of issue and evidence sanctions.”
IV.
RECOMMENDATIONS AND RULINGS ON SANCTIONS MOTION
On October 19, 2024, the discovery referee signed, and on October
22, 2024, filed his written “Report and Recommendations” on the sanctions
motion. The report stated:
“Despite the significant efforts of new counsel for . . . N&D,
[Glickman] properly points out that there is an incurable defect underlying
all of [N&D]’s responses to the subject special interrogatories. This action
was filed February 6, 2019, and an ESI [P]reservation [L]etter was delivered
to N&D on or about May 20, 2019. Subsequent to the dates of filing and
service of the original complaint, and subsequent to the date of service of the
ESI [P]reservation [L]etter, virtually all of [N&D]’s electronics including cell
phone and computers were replaced or upgraded to new systems. While N&D
claims that all [the] messages and information contained on the old cell
phones and computers were downloaded to the replacement devices or
systems, there is no proper way to prove that to be the case.
“From the information provided by both sides it appears that
since May, 2019, the cell phones of the key lawyers at . . . N&D have been
replaced multiple times. None of the cell phones extant in 2019 were
preserved with contents contained intact; nor were the contents of those cell
phones transferred or downloaded to the replacement cell phones by any
2
The reply referenced paragraphs 180–186 of the second
amended complaint to support Glickman’s claim that he raised the prospect
of suing N&D in 2018. Those paragraphs, however, alleged that Glickman
spoke with Attorney Krolikowski, not Attorney Polyakov.
9
disinterested third party who could competently testify that all content was
downloaded without deletion or omission. Similarly, laptop computers and
other computers were either replaced or new systems installed allegedly with
all old content downloaded onto the new computers or onto the newly
installed computer systems. Again, all of these downloads were accomplished
in house without preservation of the old computers or computer systems and
without the work having been accomplished by any disinterested third party
who could competently testify that all content was downloaded without
deletion or omission.
“To compound the problem, with each new edition of further
responses have come new information or new documents that serve to belie
the claim that complete and thorough searches and responses have been
provided. Each new tranche of material tends to prove [Glickman]’s claims
that facts, records and documents were either not subject to proper search or
are being hidden by . . . N&D, and that more information may have been
deleted from [N&D]’s electronic equipment to obstruct the production of
damaging documents and records.
“[I]t appears that no real effort was made to preserve the records
contained on [N&D]’s electronic devices other than that of the
representations of the individuals within [N&D] who allegedly downloaded or
transferred content from one older device to the next replacement. Under
these circumstances it is virtually impossible to verify that all records or
content from the cell phones or the computers was downloaded without
deletion or modification.”
The discovery referee also addressed the motion for further
responses to the special interrogatories, and discussed five areas of concerns,
which are summarized and addressed in his recommendations.
10
The referee made five recommendations. First, to grant the
“Motion Requiring Further Responses to Special Interrogatories as follows:
“1. Order that a new search for records and documents that are
the subject of these special interrogatories be conducted by an independent
third party not under the control or direction of [N&D].
“2. Order that [Attorney] Dillion’s cell phone and office
computer(s) be subject to the search conducted by the independent third
party.
“3. Order that all responses that indicate that they are ‘subject to
attorney-client or work product objections’ contain or attach a fully completed
privilege log of all such documents, records, or information.
“4. Order that any response that indicates that some
document(s), records or information will be supplied shall be accompanied
concurrently with those items.
“5. Order that all verifications based on ‘information and belief’
must be accompanied by a report by the verifier explaining his or her
capacity with respect to participation in the underlying lawsuit, who had
principal responsibility for doing the work subject to the particular
interrogatory, and who had supervisory responsibility for that particular
portion of the work.”(Boldface omitted.)
He also recommended granting the motion for issue sanctions by
finding as follows:
“1. That [Glickman] advised [Attorney] Polyakov [on] or about
August 2018 that he intended to sue N&D;
“2. That one of [Glickman]’s attorneys, Tracy L. Anielski, sent
N&D [an ESI Preservation Letter] on May 20, 2019;
11
“3. The ESI Preservation Letter required N&D to preserve all
relevant information, documents and devices, including cell phones,
computers and computer systems;
“4. That N&D failed to comply with the ESI Preservation Letter
by failing to preserve relevant information, documents and devices, including
cell phones, computers and computer systems;
“5. That N&D failed to preserve relevant information, documents
and devices, including cell phones, computers and computer systems.”
(Boldface omitted.)
The referee recommended an “Order that the following
instruction be given to the jury prior to the commencement of deliberations:
“If you find that [N&D] willfully suppressed the file of
[Glickman], you may draw an inference that there was something damaging
to [N&D]’s case contained in that file. Such an inference may be regarded by
you as reflecting [N&D]'s recognition of the strength of [Glickman]’s case
generally and/or the weakness of its own case. The weight to be given such
circumstance is a matter for your determination.” (Boldface omitted.)
He also recommended his fees be paid entirely by N&D.
Finally, he recommended: “In view of the foregoing[,] monetary
sanctions are required. Recommend sanctions in the amount of $16,000.00 be
awarded against [N&D] and in favor of [Glickman].”
On December 4, 2024, after independently considering the
referee’s findings, N&D’s objections, and Glickman’s responses, the trial court
adopted the report and recommendations without changes.
12
V.
NOTICE OF APPEAL AND MOTION FOR PARTIAL DISMISSAL OF APPEAL
On January 17, 2025, N&D filed its notice of appeal. In that
notice it stated it was appealing from: the “12/4/2024 Order adopting the
Discovery Referee’s Recommendations (awarding monetary sanctions over
$5,000 and issue and evidentiary sanctions inextricably intertwined
therewith).”
On March 21, 2025, Glickman moved for dismissal of the appeal
of the issue and evidentiary sanctions. He argued that, because N&D did not
appeal from the order requiring further responses and instead complied with
3
the order by providing supplemental responses, N&D conceded monetary
sanctions are warranted and thus the only remaining issue is whether N&D
acted with substantial justification.
N&D opposed the motion for partial dismissal, arguing that its
appeal of the monetary sanctions necessarily encompassed the order
compelling further responses, the issue sanctions, and the order on the jury
instruction because those orders are inextricably intertwined with and form
the basis for the monetary sanctions sought, as Glickman did not allocate the
attorney fees and costs to any particular order. We address the motion for
partial dismissal of the appeal below.
3
The evidence N&D complied is presented in the concurrently
filed motion to take additional evidence. N&D opposed this motion on the
ground that no legal authority supports such augmentation, and that even if
subject to judicial notice, this court cannot accept the truth of the information
in the augmented documents. We will deny the motion to take additional
evidence, as it is not necessary or helpful to our resolution of this appeal.
13
DISCUSSION
I.
SCOPE OF APPEAL
As a preliminary matter, we must determine the scope of this
appeal. “This court generally lacks jurisdiction to review interlocutory orders
pertaining to discovery; appellate review must await entry of a final
judgment.” (Glickman v. Krolikowski (2025) 109 Cal.App.5th 527, 530.)
However, a discovery order imposing monetary sanctions of $5,000 or more is
appealable under Code of Civil Procedure section 904.1, subdivision (a)(1).
(Ibid.) A limited exception has been recognized to permit review of a
nonmonetary discovery sanction where the monetary sanctions and the
nonmonetary sanctions are based on the same conduct and “the two are
inextricably intertwined.” (Mileikowsky v. Tenet Healthsystem (2005) 128
Cal.App.4th 262, 276 (Mileikowsky), disapproved on another ground in
Mileikowsky v. West Hills Hospital & Medical Center (2009) 45 Cal.4th 1259,
4
1273.)
In Mileikowsky, the appellate court determined an order granting
terminating sanctions and an order awarding monetary sanction were
inextricably intertwined because the monetary sanctions order was based on
the fees and costs incurred in opposing the motion for terminating sanctions.
(Id., 128 Cal.App.4th at pp. 276, 280.) As a panel of this court explained,
“[t]he propriety of both the terminating sanctions and the monetary sanctions
therefore depended on whether the trial court erred by granting the motion
4
The fact that N&D did not reference all of the discovery orders
in its notice of appeal is not material because those orders can be reviewed if
they are inextricably intertwined with the order awarding monetary
sanctions.
14
for terminating sanctions. The terminating sanctions and the monetary
sanctions were inextricably intertwined because a decision on the appeal
from the monetary sanctions also resolved the appeal from the terminating
sanctions.” (Deck v. Developers Investment Co., Inc. (2023) 89 Cal.App.5th
808, 826 (Deck).)
In Deck, a panel of this court determined an order granting issue
sanctions and an order awarding monetary sanctions were not inextricably
intertwined. The panel first determined that the monetary sanctions were
warranted based on the appellant’s unsuccessful opposition to that discovery
motion, leaving only “whether the trial court should have found Defendants
acted with substantial justification or other circumstances would make
monetary sanctions unjust” as issues on appeal. (Deck, supra, 89 Cal.App.4th
at pp. 826–827.) In contrast, “[t]he propriety of the issue sanctions depends
on the resolution of issues and assessment of factors other than whether
Defendants acted with substantial justification or monetary sanctions
otherwise would be unjust.” (Id. at p. 827.)
Here, the trial court issued: (1) an order compelling further
responses; (2) an order imposing issue sanctions (finding spoliation of
evidence by N&D); (3) an order providing that the jury would be instructed on
spoliation of evidence, (4) an order allocating all of the discovery referee’s fees
to N&D, and (5) an order imposing monetary sanctions in the amount of
$16,000 based on the “foregoing” orders. As noted, the monetary sanctions
order is appealable, and the other four orders are appealable only if they
were inextricably intertwined with the monetary sanctions order. As to the
order on the allocation of the referee’s fees, N&D does not argue the order is
inextricably intertwined with the monetary sanctions order. Thus, the fee
order cannot be addressed in this appeal.
15
N&D argues the issue sanctions order, which is based on
spoliation of evidence, can independently support monetary sanctions.
Likewise, the order compelling further responses is appealable because it can
independently form the basis for monetary sanctions. Thus, N&D argues they
are inextricably intertwined with the order awarding monetary sanctions. We
agree. Resolution of the propriety of the monetary sanctions order depends on
the propriety of those orders. For example, if we conclude there is no
spoliation of evidence and that further responses are not required, there
would be no basis for the monetary sanctions. Accordingly, those orders are
reviewable. We therefore deny Glickman’s motion for partial dismissal of this
appeal.
As to the order concerning the jury instruction, we acknowledge
it is logically intertwined with the issue sanctions. Absent additional
evidence, if we reverse the issue sanctions, the record does not contain
sufficient evidence to support giving a spoliation of evidence instruction.
However, we are not aware of any limitation on Glickman producing
substantial evidence to support a spoliation of evidence instruction at a later
date. More important, the jury instruction is not inextricably intertwined
with the monetary sanctions order. The propriety of the jury instruction order
does not impact the monetary sanctions, that is, it does not support or
undermine the monetary sanctions for discovery violations. Accordingly, the
jury instruction order is not reviewable in this appeal.
II.
DISCOVERY ORDERS
“‘Orders regarding discovery are reviewed under the abuse of
discretion standard. [Citations.] The trial court has broad discretion in
deciding whether to impose sanctions and in setting the amount of monetary
16
sanctions.’” (Deck, supra, 89 Cal.App.5th at pp. 823–824.) “The test for abuse
of discretion is traditionally recited as whether the trial court’s decision
exceeded the bounds of reason. [Citation.] In more practical terms, the abuse
of discretion standard measures whether, in light of the evidence, the trial
court’s decision ‘“falls within the permissible range of options set by the legal
criteria.”’ [Citation.] The scope of the court’s discretion is limited by law
governing the subject of the action taken. [Citation.] An action that
transgresses the bounds of the applicable legal principles is deemed an abuse
of discretion. [Citation.] A trial court’s decision is an abuse of discretion if it is
based on an error of law.” (Id. at p. 824.)
A. Issue Sanctions Based on Spoliation of Evidence
“Spoliation of evidence means the destruction or significant
alteration of evidence or the failure to preserve evidence for another’s use in
pending or future litigation. [Citation.] Such conduct is condemned because it
‘can destroy fairness and justice, for it increases the risk of an erroneous
decision on the merits of the underlying cause of action. Destroying evidence
can also increase the costs of litigation as parties attempt to reconstruct the
destroyed evidence or to develop other evidence, which may be less accessible,
less persuasive, or both.’ [Citation.] While there is no tort cause of action for
the intentional destruction of evidence after litigation has commenced, it is a
misuse of the discovery process that is subject to a broad range of
punishment, including monetary, issue, evidentiary, and terminating
sanctions.” (Williams, supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p. 1223.)
Under Evidence Code section 500, a party generally has the
burden of proof as to the existence or nonexistence of each fact that is
essential to their claim for relief. (Williams, supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p.
1225.) “On rare occasions, the courts have altered the normal allocation of the
17
burden of proof. [Citation] The shift in the burden of proof from the plaintiff
to the defendant rests on a policy judgment that there is a substantial
probability the defendant has engaged in wrongdoing and the defendant’s
wrongdoing makes it practically impossible for the plaintiff to prove the
wrongdoing.” (National Council Against Health Fraud, Inc. v. King Bio
Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (2003) 107 Cal.App.4th 1336, 1346.) The “rare
occasions” include spoliation of evidence cases. (Ibid.)
Thus, “a party moving for discovery sanctions based on the
spoliation of evidence must make an initial prima facie showing that the
responding party in fact destroyed [or failed to preserve] evidence that had a
substantial probability of damaging the moving party’s ability to establish an
essential element of his claim or defense.” (Williams, supra,167 Cal.App.4th
at p. 1227.) For example, a lawyer defending himself against a malpractice
claim obtained terminating sanctions by showing his former client destroyed
5
the client file containing “notes, research, and other work product.” Once the
5
Notably, the Williams defendant did not have to prove the
content of the destroyed work product in detail or show it would have
vindicated him at trial. (See Williams, supra,167 Cal.App.4th at p. 1220
[defense counsel explained “it was no longer possible to determine what was
kept or what had been destroyed”].) Secretly allowing the file to be destroyed
was itself sufficient to “raise[] an inference” the plaintiff had “cherry-pick[ed]
favorable new information from the file” and destroyed the rest “to prevent
[the defendant] from obtaining other documents from the file that were
unfavorable to” the plaintiff. (Id. at p. 1224.)
18
moving party makes its prima facie showing, the responding party bears “the
6
burden of disproving prejudice.” (Ibid.)
Here, substantial evidence does not support an implied finding
that Glickman made a prima facie case. While substantial evidence may
support an implied finding that N&D failed to preserve ESI, there is no
substantial evidence supporting an implied finding the unpreserved ESI had
a substantial probability of assisting Glickman in establishing an essential
element of his claims against N&D. Unlike in Williams, supra, 167 Cal. App.
4th at p. 1220, where a witness could verify the destroyed file at least
contained some kind of notes and work product, there is no evidence the cell
phones and computers actually contained any information that had not been
preserved, let alone the kind of information whose loss could damage
Glickman’s ability to prove his claims. Because Glickman failed to make a
prima facie case of spoliation of ESI, the trial court abused its discretion in
granting issue sanctions or monetary sanctions based on spoliation.
B. Motion Compelling Further Responses
Initially, Glickman sought as alternative relief, an order
compelling N&D to provide further responses, but later, asked for an order
compelling further responses regardless of whether the trial court granted or
denied the issue sanctions. Ultimately, the court granted this motion to
compel further responses.
6
At oral argument, Glickman argues N&D waived its claim that
he failed to make a prima facie case of spoliation. We disagree. N&D
referenced the issue in its opposition to the discovery sanctions motion, and
at the hearing on the sanctions motion, expressly raised Glickman’s failure to
make a prima facie case to the discovery referee.
19
N&D contends the court abused its discretion in granting the
motion to compel further responses because the discovery referee never made
an express finding that N&D’s responses did not comply with the discovery
requests. Although no express finding was made, it is clear the discovery
referee found N&D’s responses failed to comport with its discovery
obligations when the referee discussed its concerns about the responses and
then made recommendations addressing those concerns. Additionally,
substantial evidence supports that finding. For example, N&D’s responses
failed to include searches of Attorney Dillion’s cellular phone and work
computer, even though the second amended complaint alleges Attorney
Krolikowski discussed the case with him. Thus, there is a substantial
possibility that Attorney Dillion would have relevant information. The
responses also did not affirmatively disclose N&D’s failure to comply with the
ESI Preservation Letter.
N&D faults the specific recommendations as granting discovery
beyond that requested by the special interrogatories. We find no abuse of
discretion. Those specific discovery recommendations sought to address
shortcomings in N&D’s responses. The recommendation that new searches be
conducted by an independent third party sought to address the discovery
referee’s concerns about the accuracy and completeness of N&D’s searches.
This concern was well-founded based on the discovery referee’s experience
with the case, including his personal observation that, “with each new edition
of further responses, have come new information or new documents.” The
recommendation that Attorney Dillion’s electronic devices must be searched
did not exceed the scope of how the parties and the discovery referee have
interpreted the language of the special interrogatories. Stated differently,
N&D had performed searches of the electronic devices of attorneys
20
Krolikowski, Caruso, and Polyakov in response to the same special
interrogatories. The same reasoning applicable to those searches would apply
to the search of Attorney Dillion’s electronic devices.
Finally, N&D claims the remaining recommendations are
problematic because “what is recommended was already done.” If that is true,
there is no prejudice because N&D has complied with these
recommendations. To the extent the discovery referee did not believe N&D
already complied with the recommendations, N&D does not present any
persuasive evidence that the recommendations constituted an abuse of
discretion, i.e., that a finding it did not comply was erroneous. In sum, the
trial court properly granted the motion to compel further responses.
C. Monetary Sanctions
Code of Civil Procedure section 2023.030, subdivision (a)
provides: “The court may impose a monetary sanction ordering that one
engaging in the misuse of the discovery process, or any attorney advising that
conduct, or both pay the reasonable expenses, including attorney’s fees,
incurred by anyone as a result of that conduct. . . . If a monetary sanction is
authorized by any provision of this title, the court shall impose that sanction
unless it finds that the one subject to the sanction acted with substantial
justification or that other circumstances make the imposition of the sanction
unjust.” Thus, “[a] court shall impose a monetary sanction against ‘any party,
person, or attorney’ who unsuccessfully opposes a motion to compel a further
response to interrogatories, . . . ‘unless [the court] finds that the one subject
to the sanction acted with substantial justification or that other
circumstances make the imposition of the sanction unjust.’” (Deck, supra, 89
Cal.App.5th at p. 829.)
21
N&D does not argue it acted with substantial justification. Nor
does it argue imposition of the monetary sanctions is unjust under the
circumstances. Rather, it argues the order imposing monetary sanctions must
be reversed because it is based on the “entirety of Glickman’s [discovery]
motion.” Stated differently, Glickman sought $16,000 in monetary sanctions
for preparing the discovery motion and did not allocate the fees to any of the
specific relief requested. Thus, N&D contends, if this court finds any part of
the trial court’s order adopting the referee’s recommendations was in error,
the entirety of the monetary sanctions must be reversed. We disagree. N&D
cites no legal authority for striking monetary sanctions in their entirety
merely because one of the grounds for imposing sanctions is erroneous, and
we are aware of no such legal authority. Accordingly, we affirm the monetary
sanctions.
DISPOSITION
The order granting issue sanctions is reversed. The order
compelling further responses and the monetary sanctions are affirmed. The
parties are to bear their own costs on appeal.
DELANEY, ACTING P. J.
WE CONCUR:
GOODING, J.
SCOTT, J.
22
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.