CourtListener 10853329•Jeffers v. Perez CA2/1
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 5/5/26 Jeffers v. Perez CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not
been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
SUSAN JEFFERS et al., B339129
Plaintiffs and Appellants, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 23SMCV01522)
v.
GERONIMO PEREZ et al.,
Defendants and Respondents.
Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Lisa K. Sepe-Wiesenfeld, Judge. Affirmed in part, reversed
in part, and remanded with directions.
Martorell Law, Eduardo Martorell, and JoAnn Victor for
Plaintiffs and Appellants Susan Jeffers and 2444 Fourth Street,
LLC.
Rosing Pott & Strohbehn, Heather L. Rosing, and Amy P.
Chambers for Defendants and Respondents Geronimo Perez and
Daniels, Fine, Israel, Schonbuch & Lebovits, LLP.
The Maloney Firm, Gregory M. Smith, Patrick M. Maloney,
and Susan M. Freedman for Defendant and Respondent Larry
Moore.
______________________________
This appeal arises out of a decade-long dispute over a
residential unit in a previously rent-controlled, 10-unit building in
Santa Monica, California.
Respondent Larry Moore (Moore) began subleasing unit 5
in the 2444 Fourth Street building in 1991. Shortly after Moore
moved in, the building’s owner filed an application to convert the
building’s units into condominiums, pursuant to Santa Monica’s
Tenant Ownership Rights Charter Amendment (TORCA). “Under
TORCA, a conversion could be accomplished without a removal
permit if the tenants were offered an opportunity to purchase
their units, and two-thirds of the tenants supported the conversion
application.” (Bohbot v. Santa Monica Rent Control Bd. (2005) 133
Cal.App.4th 456, 460.) The TORCA purchase price for unit 5 was
$170,000.
Moore tried unsuccessfully to purchase unit 5 pursuant to
TORCA, eventually filing two lawsuits (in 2013 and 2018) seeking
to force the sale. The trial court consolidated Moore’s actions and,
following a bench trial, ruled against him. The court found that,
as a subtenant, Moore did not qualify as a “participating tenant”
entitled to compel a TORCA purchase. The court further found
that, although Moore’s sublessors had validly assigned him their
“participating tenant” status, the sublessors’ TORCA purchase
rights had expired prior to the assignment.
In 2022, respondent Geronimo Perez—an attorney and
Moore’s neighbor in the 2444 Fourth Street building—agreed to
2
represent Moore in filing a third lawsuit asserting the right to
purchase the unit at the $170,000 TORCA price. In this third
suit, Moore alleged that the March 2022 issuance of a new final
subdivision report for the building had triggered an additional
two-year TORCA purchase period, pursuant to certain conditions
enumerated in the City of Santa Monica’s approval of the building’s
TORCA application. Appellant 2444 Fourth Street LLC (the LLC),
which owned the unit, successfully demurred to the complaint. The
court dismissed Moore’s action with prejudice and awarded the LLC
attorney fees and costs.
The LLC then sued Moore, Perez, and Perez’s law firm for
malicious prosecution. In the same complaint, appellant Susan
Jeffers (Jeffers), the sole member of the LLC, asserted a claim
for financial elder abuse against Moore based on his attempts to
acquire unit 5. Jeffers also asserted claims for breach of fiduciary
duty and attempted extortion against Perez and his firm. Jeffers
alleged that Perez—who previously had represented Jeffers in a
probate action—had violated his duty of loyalty by representing
Moore, and that Perez had made extortionate statements in a
declaration and a meet-and-confer letter in Moore’s third lawsuit.
Moore, Perez, and Perez’s law firm filed “anti-SLAPP”1
special motions to strike the complaint, pursuant to Code of Civil
Procedure section 425.16.2 The trial court granted the motions in
full and dismissed the complaint with prejudice.
1 “ ‘SLAPP stands for “Strategic Lawsuit Against Public
Participation.” ’ ” (Lee v. Kim (2019) 41 Cal.App.5th 705, 710, fn. 1
(Lee), quoting Lam v. Ngo (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th 832, 835, fn. 1.)
2 Unspecified statutory references are to the Code of Civil
Procedure.
3
Jeffers and the LLC now ask us to reverse the order granting
the special motions to strike. Jeffers argues her claims for extortion
and breach of fiduciary duty do not arise from activity protected
by the anti-SLAPP statute. And both Jeffers and the LLC contend
they have demonstrated a probability of prevailing on their claims.
We agree with Jeffers that Perez’s statements in his
declaration and letter amount to extortion as a matter of law
and thus fall outside the ambit of section 425.16’s protection. But
we conclude that Jeffers’s and the LLC’s remaining claims arise
from protected activity. We further conclude that Jeffers has
demonstrated the requisite probability of success on her breach
of fiduciary duty claim, but that she and the LLC have failed to
make an adequate showing with respect to their remaining claims:
Jeffers fails to allege a “taking” sufficient to support her financial
elder abuse claim. And the LLC fails to demonstrate that Moore’s
third lawsuit was so completely lacking in merit that it supports a
claim for malicious prosecution.
Accordingly, we reverse the portion of the court’s order
striking Jeffers’s claims for extortion and breach of fiduciary duty.
We otherwise affirm.
FACTUAL SUMMARY AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY
We summarize only the facts and procedural history relevant
to our resolution of this appeal. Consistent with the applicable
standard of review, we draw our summary from “ ‘the pleadings
and the factual material submitted in connection with the
special motion[s] to strike.’ ” (Optional Capital, Inc. v. Akin
Gump Strauss, Hauser & Feld LLP (2017) 18 Cal.App.5th 95, 111
(Optional Capital).)
4
A. Jeffers’s Father Initiates the TORCA Conversion
Process for the 2444 Fourth Street Building
In 1991, Jeffers’s father—then the owner of the 2444 Fourth
Street building through his trust—filed an application pursuant to
TORCA to convert the building’s units into condominiums. In
1992, the City of Santa Monica approved the application, subject
to certain conditions enumerated in a “consent to conditions
agreement.” (Capitalization omitted.) Jeffers’s father executed
the agreement.
As relevant here, condition 1 of the agreement affords
“any participating tenant . . . the right to specific enforcement
of [the consent to conditions] agreement in addition to any other
remedies provided by law.” (Capitalization omitted.) Condition 2
of the agreement, in turn, provides: “The owner shall offer and
continue to offer the exclusive right to purchase each rental unit in
the building to the participating tenant thereof upon the terms set
forth in the application, without change, for a period of not less
than two (2) years from the date of final approval by the California
Department of Real Estate or the date the first unit in the building
is offered for sale, if approval by the California Department of Real
Estate is not required.” (Capitalization omitted.)
In 2009, the California Department of Real Estate
issued a final subdivision public report (the 2009 report) for
the building authorizing the TORCA conversion. The 2009 report
expired by its own terms on January 16, 2014.
B. Perez Represents Jeffers in the Probate Action
Through Which She Obtains Rights to Unit 5
In 2004, Jeffers’s father died. Jeffers’s brothers then sued
Jeffers in probate court, in her capacity as former trustee of their
father’s trust. Jeffers retained Perez to represent her in the probate
5
litigation. At the time, Perez was an attorney with the law firm of
Wong Fleming, P.C.
In October 2014, Perez negotiated a settlement in the probate
action. Pursuant to the terms of the settlement, Jeffers received
the sole membership interest in the LLC, which owned unit 5.
Seven months later, in May 2015, Perez withdrew as Jeffers’s
counsel in the probate action. Perez attests he withdrew because
Jeffers disregarded his advice that she must file a notice of change
of ownership with the county concerning unit 5. He further attests
that he believes Jeffers refused to file the change of ownership to
avoid paying increased property taxes on the unit.
Jeffers failed to pay Perez’s legal fees in full. Perez’s law firm
assigned Perez its rights to recover legal fees and expenses against
Jeffers incurred in the probate action. Perez later sued Jeffers and
the LLC to recover the unpaid attorney fees (see post).
C. Moore Files Two Lawsuits Asserting the Right to
Purchase Unit 5 at Its TORCA Price
About a year before the probate action settlement, in 2013,
Moore filed a complaint against the LLC asserting the right to
purchase unit 5 at its $170,000 TORCA price. (See Moore v. 2444
Fourth Street LLC (Super. Ct. L.A. County, No. SC121224).) In this
first action, Moore alleged that he qualified as a “participating
tenant” under TORCA and the consent to conditions agreement.
In 2017—while the 2013 action still was pending—the
Bullucks (Moore’s sublessors) assigned to Moore their rights
as “participating tenants.” Moore then filed a second lawsuit in
January 2018 (Moore v. 2444 Fourth Street LLC (Super. Ct. L.A.
County, No. SC128726)), alleging he was entitled to buy unit 5 for
$170,000 as an “assignee” of a “participating tenant.”
The trial court consolidated the 2013 and 2018 actions and
held a bench trial. The court found that Moore did not qualify
6
as a participating tenant because TORCA “require[s] that a
subtenant . . . be in possession [of a unit] for at least six months as
of the filing of the [TORCA conversion application] to be eligible for
participating tenant status,” and “Moore was not in possession of
unit 5 for six months” prior to the application’s submission.
(Capitalization omitted.) The court further found that the Bullucks’
assignment of their “participating tenant” status to Moore was
“valid,” but that the Bullucks’ right to purchase the unit at the
TORCA price had expired prior to the date of the assignment. The
court therefore concluded Moore was not entitled to purchase the
unit at the $170,000 TORCA price and entered judgment in favor
of the LLC on July 24, 2020. Moore did not appeal the judgment.
D. Perez Settles His Suit Against Jeffers Seeking
Unpaid Attorney Fees from the Probate Action
As set forth, ante, in June 2018, Perez sued Jeffers to
recover allegedly unpaid attorney fees incurred in the probate
action. In June 2021, with the assistance of a settlement judge,
Jeffers (represented by new counsel) reached a settlement with
Perez.
Pursuant to the settlement agreement, Jeffers provided
Perez with two promissory notes secured by deeds of trust against
the unit. One promissory note, in the amount of $40,184.76,
corresponded to the allegedly unpaid attorney fees. The other, in
the amount of $35,053.51, corresponded to homeowners’ association
fees Perez had paid on Jeffers’s behalf.
The settlement agreement afforded Jeffers until March 31,
2022 (i.e., nine months) to pay off the notes. If Jeffers failed to
make the payments on time, the deeds of trust entitled Perez to
foreclose on unit 5 to collect the amounts owed to him. In addition,
the deeds of trust included the right to assignment of rent due on
the unit.
7
E. The Department of Real Estate Issues a New
Final Subdivision Report for the Building
On March 9, 2022, the California Department of Real Estate
issued a new final subdivision public report (the March 2022 report)
for the 2444 Fourth Street building. Perez attests that, based on
his understanding of the TORCA statute and process, the issuance
of the March 2022 report triggered a new two-year period in which
“participating tenants” could purchase a unit in the building at the
TORCA price.
F. Jeffers Fails to Pay, and Perez Assigns the
Promissory Notes and Deeds of Trust to Moore
On March 23, 2022, Perez emailed Jeffers’s then-counsel,
Harry Floyd, informing him that the notes were “due and payable
on March 31, 2022.” Floyd responded that same day, informing
Perez:
“I understand that the LLC is ready to sell to [Moore] and
will satisfy the obligations from the proceeds of that sale, which
is awaiting reinstatement of the LLC by the Secretary of State,
to which all necessary documents and payments have been
submitted.”
Jeffers, however, failed to sell the unit to Moore or to pay
the amounts owed as the March 31, 2022 deadline approached.
Perez attests “[he] could not wait any longer than the nine months
provided to [Jeffers] to issue the settlement payment” because “[he]
was still obligated to pay [his former law] firm back a portion of the
fees.” He therefore “decided to sell the [notes and deeds of trust]
to the first buyer willing to pay full value rather than pursue a
judicial foreclosure sale.” Perez further attests that he reached out
to Moore’s then-attorney to see whether Moore might be interested
in purchasing the notes and deeds of trust for the notes’ full price,
8
plus interest. Perez attests that Moore agreed and wired the
necessary funds to complete the transaction.
On March 31, 2022, Perez again emailed Jeffers’s counsel
to inform him of the assignment of the notes and deeds of trust
to Moore. Perez’s email further provided: “[Moore] will proceed to
foreclose and collect on the attached accordingly.”
G. Moore—Now Represented By Perez—Files a
Third Lawsuit Asserting the Right to Purchase
Unit 5 at the TORCA Price
In late March 2022—around the time Perez negotiated the
assignment of the notes and deeds of trust to Moore—Perez agreed
to represent Moore in attempting to purchase unit 5 pursuant to
the new March 2022 report. By this time, Perez was a partner with
the law firm of Daniels, Fine, Israel, Schonbuch & Lebovits, LLC.
On March 26, 2022, Moore sent Jeffers a letter purporting
to “accept” his right to purchase the unit pursuant to TORCA and
the March 2022 report. On April 7, 2022, Perez emailed the letter
to Floyd. That same day, Floyd sent the following response:
“I have previously informed you that I do not currently
represent . . . Jeffers, and that also applies to [the LLC]. However,
with respect to your claim [that] Larry Moore has a right to
purchase unit 5 at the TORCA purchase price of $170,000.00 as
a participating tenant, as Mr. Moore well knows, he has no such
right, with his alleged status in that regard having been determined
against him in a judgment which I have attached for your review.
You and Mr. Moore should therefore govern yourselves accordingly.”
On April 11, 2022, Perez filed suit on behalf of Moore
against the LLC (hereafter, the third Moore lawsuit), asserting
causes of action for (1) third-party beneficiary breach of written
contract, and (2) breach of written contract. The complaint alleged
that, under the terms of the consent to conditions agreement,
9
issuance of the March 2022 report triggered a new two-year period
in which Moore, as a participating tenant or an assignee of a
participating tenant, could purchase unit 5 at the TORCA price of
$170,000. The complaint further alleged that, by refusing to sell
the unit to Moore, the LLC had breached the consent to conditions
agreement. Among other remedies, Moore sought specific
performance of the agreement—i.e., that the LLC allow him to
purchase the unit for $170,000.
On April 12, 2022, Perez filed a notice of lis pendens
identifying the unit as the subject of the dispute in the third Moore
lawsuit. In addition, Moore recorded a notice of default and election
to sell the unit pursuant to the deeds of trust. Finally, pursuant
to the assignment of rents provision in the deeds of trust, Moore
stopped paying rent on the unit.
Jeffers alleges that Perez’s and Moore’s actions impeded
her ability to refinance the unit in order to pay off the notes and
avoid foreclosure. She further alleges that, “fortuitously, [she was]
able to refinance the unit through the beneficence of a private
lender and thereby was able to pay the promissory notes and
avoid[ ] a foreclosure sale.” (Capitalization omitted.)
H. The LLC Secures a Dismissal of the Third Moore
Lawsuit with Prejudice and Recovers Its
Attorney Fees and Costs
On July 26, 2022, the LLC’s new attorney, Bruce Lorman,
wrote a meet-and-confer letter to Perez advising that the LLC
intended to file a demurrer to the complaint in the third Moore
lawsuit. The letter further provided, in pertinent part:
“Please be advised that if this action is not voluntarily
dismissed, this is to put you on notice that you are exposing yourself
and your firm to substantial liability for malicious prosecution. . . .
[¶] In addition to the demurrer and motion to strike, this is to
10
advise you that we are reviewing your prior representation of
[the LLC] and now your representation of [Moore] against your
former client. Such conduct potentially breaches your fiduciary
and professional duties to your former client. I am interested [in]
hearing from you why you believe you can sue your own former
client.”
Moore did not dismiss the suit, and the LLC filed its
demurrer. The LLC argued the doctrine of issue preclusion barred
Moore’s claims because the court in Moore’s prior consolidated
actions had determined that Moore did not qualify as a
participating tenant entitled to purchase the unit at the TORCA
price.
In response, Moore argued the court in the prior actions
had made its determinations relying on the 2009 report, which
expired in 2014, and that the March 2022 report rendered the
prior findings as to his “participating tenant” status “overripe,
non-justiciable, . . . moot[,] and . . . void.” (Italics omitted.) He
further argued that issuance of the March 2022 report triggered a
new two-year period during which he could purchase unit 5 at its
TORCA price because (1) the trial court in the prior consolidated
actions found the Bullucks’ assignment of their “participating
tenant” rights to Moore was “valid,” but that the Bullucks’ rights
as participating tenants to purchase the property at the TORCA
price had expired prior to the assignment, (2) the express terms
of the consent to conditions agreement require the building owner
“to offer the . . . right to purchase [the] unit” at the TORCA price
“for a period of not less than two . . . years from the date of final
approval by the California Department of Real Estate,” and
(3) after the 2009 report expired, the March 2022 report constituted
the relevant “final approval” under Business and Professions Code
11
sections 11018 and 11018.2, thereby reviving the previously expired
“participating tenant” TORCA purchase rights.3
At the October 17, 2022 hearing on the demurrer, Perez
argued on Moore’s behalf: “[E]ven if the underlying actions are
not moot and even if the underlying actions are determinative
of the ruling on the 2009 public report, . . . then [the court] has
to accept the [prior] finding . . . that says that the assignment
[of participating tenant rights] from the Bullucks to Mr. Moore is
valid. [¶] And the reason that is significant is because defendants
obtained a public report in 2022. From that springs the right to
purchase . . . at the TORCA price. Every time a public report
is issued, you have to offer the right to the participating tenant
to purchase. . . . [¶] So whether the court finds that it’s moot
or whether it finds that it’s not moot, Mr. Moore still has . . .
standing to pursue his breach of contract claims under the 2022
final subdivision public report.”
At the conclusion of the hearing, Perez emphasized the
case involved “an issue of first impression.” The judge stated she
would “take a second look based on [Perez’s] arguments” and took
the matter under submission. Later that day, the court issued a
3 Section 11018 of the Business and Professions Code
provides, in pertinent part: “The Real Estate Commission shall
make an examination of any subdivision, and shall, unless there
are grounds for denial, issue to the subdivider a public report
authorizing the sale or lease in this state of the lots or parcels
within the subdivision.” (Bus. & Prof. Code, § 11018, italics added.)
Section 11018.2, in turn, provides in relevant part: “No person
shall sell or lease, or offer for sale or lease in this state any lots or
parcels in a subdivision without first obtaining a public report from
the Real Estate Commissioner.” (Id., § 11018.2.)
12
written ruling sustaining the LLC’s demurrer. The court reasoned,
in pertinent part:
“[The LLC] argues the doctrine of issue preclusion bars
[Moore] from relitigating [his “participating tenant” status] in
this action as a court already adjudicated these issues adversely
to [Moore] in prior litigation. The court agrees.
“[¶] . . . [¶]
“ . . . If [Moore] truly believed the issue of his status as a
participating tenant under TORCA was mooted by the expiration
of the 2009 . . . report, he would not have filed a second action
in 2018 seeking to force [the LLC] to sell him the unit at the
TORCA purchase price. . . . Having specifically sought a judicial
determination of [his] rights to purchase under TORCA after the
expiration of the 2009 . . . report, [Moore] cannot now show his
request was moot by the expiration of that report.
“[Moore] has also not demonstrated the expiration of
the 2009 . . . report had any bearing on his status as a TORCA
participating tenant, either by virtue of his subtenancy or
assignment of the Bullucks’ TORCA rights.” (Capitalization
omitted.)
But the court did not address Moore’s theory that the
Bullucks had validly assigned him their “participating tenant”
status and expired TORCA purchase rights, and that issuance of
the March 2022 report had revived those previously expired rights.
The court dismissed the third Moore lawsuit with prejudice,
and the LLC then moved for $47,880 in costs and attorney fees.
In his declaration in support of the fee request, the LLC’s attorney
attested that defense of the third Moore lawsuit “involved complex
legal and factual issues relating to[, inter alia,] [Perez’s] . . .
apparent violation of his fiduciary duties of loyalty.” The
13
declaration also quoted from the July 26 meet-and-confer letter
accusing Perez of possible breaches of his fiduciary duties.
In response, on March 1, 2023, Perez filed his own declaration
in which he attested, in pertinent part:
“[The LLC’s] supporting declaration . . . conveniently ignores
and fails to mention that [the LLC’s] manager, . . . Jeffers, and her
accountant . . . conspired and used . . . Jeffers’s prior probate case
and the court system to intentionally perpetrate multiple crimes
against the County of Los Angeles, the State of California, and the
United States, which continue to this day and which resulted in the
termination of the attorney-client relationship in her probate case.”
In addition, on March 22, 2023, Perez sent a letter to
the LLC’s attorney accusing Jeffers of “intentionally committing
tax fraud” by “intentionally failing to disclose the transfer of
100 [percent] membership interest in” the LLC from her father’s
trust to her individually, pursuant to the probate action settlement.
(Underscoring omitted.) The letter described Jeffers’s allegedly
criminal conduct in considerable detail and included images of
Jeffers’s (presumptively privileged) attorney-client communications
with Perez from 2015.
Perez contends that his purpose in filing the March 1
declaration and sending the March 22 letter “was to point out that
Jeffers’s unclean hands precluded her from successfully pursuing
the threatened malicious prosecution and breach of fiduciary
duty claims based on Perez’s prior representation of Jeffers in her
capacity as a trustee.”
On March 27, 2023, the court granted the LLC’s motion for
attorney fees and costs. The court, however, reduced the award to
$39,780 based on its determination that the originally requested
amount included fees for time spent on work “which was not
14
necessary for the defense of this action or unrelated to the subject
matter of this lawsuit.”
I. Jeffers and the LLC File Suit Against Moore,
Perez, and Perez’s Law Firm
Less than two weeks later, on April 7, 2023, Jeffers and
the LLC filed a joint complaint against Moore, Perez, and Perez’s
law firm. Jeffers asserted causes of action for (1) attempted
extortion against Perez and his law firm (collectively, the attorney
respondents), (2) breach of fiduciary duty against the attorney
respondents, and (3) financial elder abuse against Moore. The LLC
asserted a cause of action for malicious prosecution against all three
defendants. Finally, both Jeffers and the LLC asserted a negligence
cause of action against all the defendants.
The crux of the complaint’s allegations was that Perez and
Moore filed the third Moore lawsuit for the improper purpose of
putting financial pressure on Jeffers through the recording of the
lis pendens. Jeffers alleged the lis pendens “created a cloud on title
to the unit and substantially interfered with [her] ability to obtain
the funds needed to pay off ” the promissory notes to avoid
foreclosure. (Capitalization omitted.) She further alleged this was
part of an overarching strategy by Perez and Moore “to assist the
foreclosure sale of the unit in order to attempt to acquire [it] at a
substantial discount.” (Capitalization omitted.)
J. The Trial Court Grants the Anti-SLAPP Special
Motions to Strike Filed By Moore and the
Attorney Respondents
The attorney respondents and Moore each filed an anti-
SLAPP special motion to strike the causes of the action in the
complaint. Jeffers and the LLC opposed the motions, offering
15
declarations from Jeffers and Jeffers’s mortgage broker, Dan Spitz,
in support of the oppositions.
On May 8, 2024, the trial court granted the motions in full.
The court concluded that all the claims arose from protected activity
because they were based on Moore’s and the attorney respondents’
litigation of the third Moore lawsuit against the LLC. The
court further concluded that Jeffers and the LLC had failed to
demonstrate a probability of prevailing on any of the claims. It
found, in pertinent part, that (1) the litigation privilege barred the
extortion claim, (2) Jeffers had failed to offer sufficient evidence in
support of the breach of fiduciary duty claim, (3) Jeffers had failed
to adequately allege the financial elder abuse claim, and (4) the
LLC had failed to make a sufficient showing that Moore and Perez
initiated the third Moore lawsuit “with malice,” as required to
support the claim for malicious prosecution. The court therefore
dismissed the claims with prejudice and awarded the attorney
respondents and Moore their reasonable attorney fees and costs.
Jeffers and the LLC timely appealed. On appeal, Jeffers and
the LLC have abandoned their cause of action for negligence, and
we therefore do not further discuss that claim.
DISCUSSION
A. Law Governing Anti-SLAPP Motions and
Standard of Review
“The anti-SLAPP statute is ‘designed to protect defendants
from meritless lawsuits that might chill the exercise of their rights
to speak and petition on matters of public concern. [Citations.] To
that end, the statute authorizes a special motion to strike a claim
“arising from any act of that person in furtherance of the person’s
right of petition or free speech under the United States Constitution
or the California Constitution in connection with a public issue.”
16
[Citation.]’ [Citation.]” (Bonni v. St. Joseph Health System (2021)
11 Cal.5th 995, 1008–1009 (Bonni).)
“Litigation of an anti-SLAPP motion involves a two-step
process. First, ‘the moving defendant bears the burden of
establishing that the challenged allegations or claims “aris[e] from”
protected activity in which the defendant has engaged.’ [Citation.]”
(Bonni, supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 1009.) “A defendant’s burden
on the first prong is not an onerous one. A defendant need only
make a prima facie showing that plaintiff ’s claims arise from the
defendant’s constitutionally protected free speech or petition rights.
[Citation.]” (Optional Capital, supra, 18 Cal.App.5th at p. 112.)
A defendant makes the required showing “ ‘by demonstrating
that the act underlying the . . . cause [of action] fits one of the
categories spelled out in section 425.16, subdivision (e).’ [Citation.]”
(Navellier v. Sletten (2002) 29 Cal.4th 82, 88 (Navellier).) As
relevant here, two such categories are: “(1) any written or oral
statement . . . made before a . . . judicial proceeding,” and “(2) any
written or oral statement or writing made in connection with
an issue under consideration or review by a . . . judicial body.”
(§ 425.16, subd. (e)(1)–(2).)
Second, “[i]f the defendant makes the required showing, the
burden shifts to the plaintiff to demonstrate the merit of the claim
by establishing a probability of success.” (Baral v. Schnitt (2016)
1 Cal.5th 376, 384.) “The plaintiff must do so with admissible
evidence.” (Optional Capital, supra, 18 Cal.App.5th at p. 112.)
“The Supreme Court has ‘described this second step as a “summary-
judgment-like procedure.” [Citation.] The court does not weigh
evidence or resolve conflicting factual claims. Its inquiry is
limited to whether the plaintiff has stated a legally sufficient claim
and made a prima facie factual showing sufficient to sustain a
favorable judgment. It accepts the plaintiff ’s evidence as true, and
17
evaluates the defendant’s showing only to determine if it defeats
the plaintiff ’s claim as a matter of law. [Citation.] “[C]laims
with the requisite minimal merit may proceed.” ’ [Citation.]” (Lee,
supra, 41 Cal.App.5th at p. 719.) “If the plaintiff cannot make this
showing, the court will strike the claim.” (Bonni, supra, 11 Cal.5th
at p. 1009.)
We review an order granting a special motion to strike
de novo. (See Lee, supra, 41 Cal.App.5th at p. 719.)
B. With the Exception of Jeffers’s Extortion Cause of
Action, the Claims Arise from Protected Activity
Jeffers contends the trial court incorrectly concluded that her
claims for attempted extortion and breach of fiduciary duty arise
from protected activity.4 We agree with Jeffers with respect to
her claim for extortion, but reject her contention as to the breach
of fiduciary duty cause of action.
We first consider Jeffers’s extortion claim. “Extortion
includes ‘the obtaining of property or other consideration from
another, with his . . . consent . . . , induced by a wrongful use of
force or fear . . . .’ [Citation.] What constitutes a wrongful use of
force or fear for these purposes is defined in Penal Code section 519
[citation], and includes ‘a threat . . . [¶] . . . [t]o expose, or to impute
to [the person threatened a] disgrace, or crime. . . .’ [Citation.]”
(Flickinger v. Finwall (2022) 85 Cal.App.5th 822, 833; see People v.
Baker (1978) 88 Cal.App.3d 115, 119 [for purposes of extortion,
“property” includes “ ‘a right to recover money or other personal
property by a judicial proceeding’ ”].)
“ ‘No precise or particular form of words is necessary in order
to constitute a threat under the circumstances. Threats can be
4 Jeffers and the LLC do not dispute that their remaining
claims arise from activity protected by the anti-SLAPP statute.
18
made by innuendo and the circumstances under which the threat
is uttered and the relations between [the defendant] and the
[target of the threats] may be taken into consideration in making a
determination of the question involved.’ [Citations.]” (Stenehjem v.
Sareen (2014) 226 Cal.App.4th 1405, 1424 (Stenehjem).) “The
absence of either an express threat or a demand for a specific sum
of money . . . does not negate [a communication’s] fundamental
nature as an extortionate writing.” (Ibid.) Indeed, “[a]s our high
court explained nearly 100 years ago: ‘The more vague and general
the terms of the accusation the better it would subserve the purpose
of the accuser in magnifying the fears of his victim, and the better
also it would serve to protect him in the event of the failure to
accomplish his extortion and of a prosecution for his attempted
crime. [Citations.]’ ” (Ibid., quoting People v. Sanders (1922) 188
Cal. 744, 749–750.)
In the complaint, Jeffers alleges Perez committed attempted
extortion by (1) filing the March 1, 2023 declaration in the third
Moore lawsuit accusing her of unspecified crimes, and (2) sending
the March 22, 2023 meet-and-confer letter to Jeffers’s then-attorney
accusing Jeffers of tax fraud. Jeffers further alleges the accusations
were made as threats “to intimidate and instill fear in [her] so
that [she] would not bring [the instant] action.” Although, on
their face, these activities “fit . . . the categories spelled out” in
subdivisions (e)(1) and (e)(2) of section 425.16 (Optional Capital,
supra, 18 Cal.App.5th at p. 110), Jeffers contends the activities
nonetheless are excluded from anti-SLAPP protection pursuant to
Flatley v. Mauro (2006) 39 Cal.4th 299 (Flatley). We agree.
In Flatley, D. Dean Mauro, an attorney, sent a demand
letter on behalf of his client, Tyna Marie Robertson, to well-known
entertainer Michael Flatley. (Flatley, supra, 39 Cal.4th at p. 305.)
The letter claimed that Flatley had raped Robertson and demanded
19
a seven-figure payment to settle Robertson’s claims. (Ibid.) Mauro
repeated the demands in subsequent phone calls. (Ibid.) And he
threatened to “ ‘go public’ ” with the allegations if Flatley failed to
pay. (Id. at p. 311.) Flatley did not pay (ibid.); instead, he sued
Mauro for civil extortion. (Id. at p. 305.) The trial court denied
Mauro’s special motion to strike Flatley’s complaint under the anti-
SLAPP statute, and the appellate court affirmed the denial. (Ibid.)
Our high court likewise affirmed, concluding that “where
a defendant brings a motion to strike under section 425.16 . . .
but either the defendant concedes, or the evidence conclusively
establishes, that the assertedly protected speech or petition activity
was illegal as a matter of law, the defendant is precluded from
using the anti-SLAPP statute to strike the plaintiff ’s action.”
(Flatley, supra, 39 Cal.4th at p. 320.) The court “emphasize[d]
that [its] conclusion . . . [was] based on the specific and extreme
circumstances of [the] case” (id. at p. 332, fn. 16), which included
threats to report criminal activities “entirely unrelated” to
Robertson’s claims against Flatley. (Id. at p. 330.)
As in Flatley, the extreme circumstances of this case bring
Perez’s communications outside the protection of the anti-SLAPP
statute. Taken together, Perez’s March 1 declaration and March 22
letter amounted to extortion as a matter of law. In the publicly
filed declaration, Perez made oblique references to unspecified
criminal conduct by Jeffers. In the subsequent letter sent only to
Jeffers’s counsel, Perez described in rich detail the alleged tax fraud
he impliedly threatened to expose if Jeffers filed suit against him.
And the criminal conduct Perez impliedly threatened to publicly
disclose was entirely unrelated to any alleged injury suffered by
Moore or by Perez himself. (See Flatley, supra, 39 Cal.4th at
pp. 330–331 [“the threat to disclose criminal activity entirely
unrelated to any alleged injury suffered by [the] client ‘exceed[s]
20
the limits of respondent’s representation of his client’ and is itself
evidence of extortion”].)
Thus, viewed in context, we conclude Perez’s statements
constituted extortion as a matter of law. The statements therefore
do not arise from protected activity, and we reverse the portion of
the court’s order granting the attorney respondents’ special motion
to strike Jeffers’s cause of action for extortion.
We reach the opposite conclusion with respect to Jeffers’s
breach of fiduciary duty claim. In the complaint, Jeffers alleges
that Perez breached his duties of loyalty and confidentiality
to her by (1) “actively represent[ing] . . . Moore,” whose interests
were adverse to those of Jeffers, in his efforts to “force a sale of
[unit 5],” (2) “rel[ying] on confidential information obtained while
representing . . . Jeffers [in the probate action] in formulating
[Perez’s] representation of . . . Moore against [the] LLC,” and
(3) “impliedly threaten[ing] to present criminal charges” against
Jeffers in the March 1 declaration and the March 22 letter,
in violation of rule 3.10 of the Rules of Professional Conduct.
Jeffers further alleges Perez’s law firm is liable for these breaches
because the firm “authorized, ratified and approved of ” Perez’s
actions.
There is some force to Jeffers’s argument that Perez’s
“alleged acts of representing [a] client[ ] with interests adverse to
his former client and using [Jeffers’s] confidential information in
the new representation do not constitute protected activity under
the anti-SLAPP law,” as the mere acts of agreeing to represent
or advising a client do not necessarily involve speech or petitioning
activity. (Wittenberg v. Bornstein (2020) 50 Cal.App.5th 303, 314
(Wittenberg), citing, inter alia, Benasra v. Mitchell Silberberg &
Knupp LLP (2004) 123 Cal.App.4th 1179 and Freeman v. Schack
(2007) 154 Cal.App.4th 719.) And as set forth, ante, we conclude
21
Perez’s statements in the March 1 declaration and March 22 letter
do not constitute protected activity.
But Perez’s representation of Moore also included conduct
falling squarely within section 425.16’s enumerated categories—
namely, the filing of the complaint in the third Moore lawsuit.
(See § 425.16, subd. (e)(1) & (2) [written statements made “before
a . . . judicial proceeding” or “in connection with an issue under
consideration . . . by a . . . judicial body” constitute protected
activity].) Jeffers nonetheless insists her breach of fiduciary
duty claim is not subject to the anti-SLAPP statute because the
“gravamen” of her claim is Perez’s breach of his duty of loyalty—
and not Perez’s speech or petitioning activity.
This argument fails because our high court expressly
has rejected the “gravamen” test that Jeffers urges us to apply.
(See Bonni, supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 1011; ibid. [“[i]f we were . . .
to adopt [the] proposed gravamen approach, we would . . . risk
saddling courts with an obligation to settle intractable, almost
metaphysical problems about the ‘essence’ of a cause of action that
encompasses multiple claims”].) Rather, “[w]hen relief is sought
based on allegations of both protected and unprotected activity,
the unprotected activity is disregarded at [the first step of the
anti-SLAPP analysis]. If the court determines that relief is sought
based on allegations arising from activity protected by the statute,
the second step is reached. There, the burden shifts to the plaintiff
to demonstrate that each challenged claim based on protected
activity is legally sufficient and factually substantiated.” (Baral,
supra, 1 Cal.5th at p. 396.)
We recognize that our high court also has “reaffirmed that
‘[a]ssertions that are “merely incidental” or “collateral” are not
subject to section 425.16. [Citations.] Allegations of protected
activity that merely provide context, without supporting a claim
22
for recovery, cannot be stricken under the anti-SLAPP statute.’
[Citation.]” (Bonni, supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 1012.) But this
does not aid Jeffers, because the complaint frames the filing of
the third Moore lawsuit as a central feature of Perez’s alleged
wrongdoing—and not merely as incidental background.
We therefore conclude that Jeffers’s breach of fiduciary
duty claim arises, at least in part, from protected activity. As
such, Jeffers bears the burden of demonstrating a probability of
prevailing on the claim. (See Baral, supra, 1 Cal.5th at p. 396;
Wittenberg, supra, 50 Cal.App.5th at p. 315 [“[b]ecause the . . .
causes of action seek relief based, in part, on . . . specific allegations
of [the defendant’s] litigation activity, the burden shifted to [the
plaintiff] to demonstrate the minimal merit of the challenged
causes of action to the extent they are based on protected litigation
conduct”].)
C. Jeffers Has Demonstrated the Requisite
Probability of Success on Her Breach of
Fiduciary Duty Claim
Jeffers contends that Perez, as her former counsel, breached
his fiduciary duties to her by representing Moore in his efforts to
acquire unit 5 and by using Jeffers’s confidential information in the
course of that representation. Jeffers further contends that Perez’s
current law firm is vicariously liable for Perez’s breaches. We agree
sufficient evidence demonstrates a probability of success on these
claims.
“The elements of a cause of action for breach of fiduciary
duty/duty of loyalty are: (1) the existence of a relationship giving
rise to a fiduciary duty/duty of loyalty; (2) one or more breaches
of that duty; and (3) damage proximately caused by that breach.
[Citation.]” (Wittenberg, supra, 50 Cal.App.5th at p. 312, fn. 7.)
23
As to the first element, Perez does not dispute that
he owes a fiduciary duty to Jeffers as his former client. (See
Styles v. Mumbert (2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 1163, 1167 [“an attorney
continues to owe a former client a fiduciary duty even after the
termination of the relationship”].) Further, it is undisputed that
Perez was a partner at his current law firm when he allegedly
breached his fiduciary duties to Jeffers, and “[a] law partnership,
as any partnership, is vicariously liable ‘for loss or injury caused
to a person, or for a penalty incurred, as a result of a wrongful act
or omission, or other actionable conduct, of a partner acting in the
ordinary course of business of the partnership or with authority of
the partnership.’ ” (PCO, Inc. v. Christensen, Miller, Fink, Jacobs,
Glaser, Weil & Shapiro LLP (2007) 150 Cal.App.4th 384, 391
[affirming dismissal of direct breach of fiduciary duty claim
by nonclient against law firm, but finding triable issues of fact
existed as to firm’s vicarious liability for firm partner’s alleged
wrongdoing]; see Corp. Code, § 16305, subd. (a).) Jeffers therefore
has made an adequate showing with respect to the first element
of her breach of fiduciary duty claim.
Turning to the second element, “[a]n attorney’s fiduciary
obligations to his or her client include the duties of loyalty and
confidentiality. ‘ “[T]he effective functioning of the fiduciary
relationship between attorney and client depends on the client’s
trust and confidence in counsel. [Citation.] . . . [C]ourts will protect
clients’ legitimate expectations of loyalty to preserve this essential
basis for trust and security in the attorney-client relationship.”
[Citations.] Accordingly, “an attorney is forbidden to do either of
two things after severing [the] relationship with a former client.
[The attorney] may not do anything which will injuriously affect
[the] former client in any matter in which [the attorney] formerly
represented [the client] nor may [the attorney] at any time use
24
against [the] former client knowledge or information acquired by
virtue of the previous relationship.” [Citations.]’ ” (Fremont
Reorganizing Corp. v. Faigin (2011) 198 Cal.App.4th 1153, 1174
(Fremont).) Further, the duties of loyalty and confidentiality
prohibit an attorney “from taking a former client’s confidences
significantly into account in acting in the attorney’s own interest
even if there is no second client and no confidences are disclosed.”
(Ibid.)
Perez insists there is “no evidence that [he] relied on
confidential information obtained while representing Jeffers in
formulating his representation of Moore.” But Perez’s March 1
declaration and March 22 letter constitute such prima facie
evidence: These documents support that Perez relied
on confidential information from the probate action—namely,
Perez’s privileged legal advice to Jeffers regarding certain tax
issues involving the unit and Jeffers’s purported failure to follow
that advice—to defend against Jeffers’s request for attorney fees
in the third Moore lawsuit and to dissuade Jeffers from filing the
instant suit against Moore, Perez, and his law firm.
Perez insists the information in his declaration and letter is
not confidential because, under the crime-fraud exception set forth
in Evidence Code section 956, “the attorney[-]client privilege does
not apply to when a client seeks an attorney’s help in committing a
crime or fraud.” Perez, however, fails to demonstrate that exception
applies here as a matter of law, and the exception therefore cannot
defeat Jeffers’s claim at this stage in the litigation. (See Fremont,
supra, 198 Cal.App.4th at p. 1166 [“[t]he defendant cannot defeat
the plaintiff ’s evidentiary showing [for purposes of opposing an
anti-SLAPP special motion to strike] by presenting evidence that
merely contradicts that evidence but does not establish as a matter
of law that the plaintiff cannot prevail”].) We likewise reject Perez’s
25
argument that the litigation privilege bars Jeffers’s breach of
fiduciary duty claim. (See Fremont, supra, 198 Cal.App.4th at
p. 1160 [“the litigation privilege is inapplicable in an action by
a former client against an attorney arising from breach of
professional duties”].)
Finally, as to the third element of damages, in Jeffers’s
declaration filed in opposition to the anti-SLAPP motions, she
attests in pertinent part: “Perez’[s] conduct represent[ing] Moore
injuriously affected me”; “I understood Perez’[s] accusations of
‘multiple crimes’ to be threats that he would report me for ‘multiple
crimes’ if I filed [suit against him]”; and “I have suffered and will
continue to suffer pain and suffering, and mental anguish and
emotional distress.” Taken together, these attestations constitute
prima facie evidence of damages for purposes of the anti-SLAPP
inquiry.5 (See Kaushansky v. Stonecroft Attorneys, APC (2025)
109 Cal.App.5th 788, 805–806 [“[e]motional distress damages
may be recoverable if directly caused by an attorney’s conduct in
breach of his fiduciary duties”].)
Accordingly, we conclude that Jeffers has established the
requisite probability of success on her breach of fiduciary duty
claim.
5 Before the trial court, Moore did not object to the
admissibility of these statements in Jeffers’s declaration. And
the court overruled the attorney respondents’ evidentiary objections
to the statements. No other portions of the declarations filed by
Jeffers or her mortgage broker, Spitz, are material to our analysis.
We therefore need not further address the attorney respondents’
argument that, on appeal, Jeffers and the LLC seek improperly to
rely on portions of the declarations the trial court ruled
inadmissible.
26
D. Jeffers and the LLC Fail to Demonstrate a
Probability of Success on Their Two Remaining
Claims
1. Financial Elder Abuse
“The Legislature enacted the [Elder Abuse and Dependent
Adult Civil Protection Act (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 15600 et seq.)]
to protect elders by providing enhanced remedies to encourage
private civil enforcement of laws against elder abuse and neglect.
[Citation.] . . . [Citation.] The proscribed conduct includes financial
abuse. The financial abuse provisions are, in part, premised on
the Legislature’s belief that in addition to being subject to the
general rules of contract, financial agreements entered into by
elders should be subject to special scrutiny.” (Bounds v. Superior
Court (2014) 229 Cal.App.4th 468, 478 (Bounds).)
The elements of financial elder abuse are: (1) “[t]ak[ing],
secret[ing], appropriat[ing], obtain[ing], or retain[ing]” or
“[a]ssist[ing] in taking, secreting, appropriating, obtaining,
or retaining,” (2) “real or personal property,” (3) “of an elder or
dependent adult,” and (4) “for a wrongful use or with intent to
defraud, or both.” (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 15610.30, subd. (a)(1)–(2).)
Jeffers alleges that Moore committed financial elder abuse
against her by (1) sending the March 26, 2022 “notice of acceptance”
to purchase the unit, (2) filing the third Moore lawsuit and
lis pendens, (3) withholding rent payments under the deeds
of trust, and (4) recording the notice of default against the unit.
(Capitalization omitted.) She concedes that none of these actions
caused her to lose possession of the unit, but urges they nonetheless
constituted a “taking” for purposes of the elder abuse statute.
In support, she relies on Bounds, where two individuals
and their associated business entities (the KMA parties) allegedly
exploited the deteriorating mental condition of Bounds, an
27
88-year-old widow with Alzheimer’s disease, to secure her signature
on escrow instructions authorizing the sale of real property held
by her trust. (Bounds, supra, 229 Cal.App.4th at p. 472.) When
Bounds’s attorney discovered the instructions, he terminated
the escrow on her behalf. (Id. at p. 475.) As a result, “the Trust
retain[ed] title to, and Bounds remain[ed] in possession of, the
property.” (Id. at p. 472.) Certain of the KMA parties then sued to
enforce their right to purchase the property. (Id. at p. 475.) Bounds
and her trust filed a cross-complaint alleging, inter alia, a cause
of action for elder abuse. (Ibid.) They argued the KMA parties’
conduct effected a “taking” of the property because “the existence of
the escrow instructions significantly impair[ed] [Bounds’s] right to
sell the property at fair market value or to use it to secure a loan on
favorable terms.” (Id. at p. 472.)
The appellate court agreed, explaining in pertinent part:
“[I]n any sales or loan transaction concerning the property,
petitioners[, Bounds and the trust,] would be required to disclose
KMA’s claim that it has a legally enforceable right to acquire
the real property. [Citation.] This disclosure would, in turn,
impair petitioners’ ability to sell the real property for fair market
value or to use it as security to obtain a loan on reasonable and
commercially acceptable terms. The [operative cross-complaint]
thus alleges, in substance, that the existence of the escrow
instructions significantly interferes with petitioners’ rights to use
the realty as they see fit. These allegations regarding the adverse
financial impact of the escrow instructions are sufficient to allege
a ‘depriv[ation] of [a] property right . . . by means of an agreement’
[citation] because petitioners have been deprived of one of the
incidents of property ownership: the right to strike the best
bargain possible in either selling or encumbering the real property.”
(Bounds, supra, 229 Cal.App.4th at p. 480.)
28
The relevant facts here are unlike those in Bounds. The
March 26, 2022 notice of acceptance—signed only by Moore and not
made in response to any offer by Jeffers or the LLC—did not create
“a legally enforceable right to acquire the real property.” (Bounds,
supra, 229 Cal.App.4th at p. 480.) And although the complaint in
the third Moore lawsuit and the lis pendens purported to assert
such a right—and may have impaired Jeffers’s ability to use the
unit as security to obtain a loan—those filings fall within the scope
of the litigation privilege. (See Civ. Code, § 47, subd. (b)(1); id.,
subd. (b)(4) [a recorded lis pendens is a privileged publication if
it “identifies an action previously filed with a court of competent
jurisdiction which affects the title or right of possession of real
property”].) Finally, even if Moore’s decision to withhold rent
and record the notice of default impaired the unit’s value, Jeffers
fails to demonstrate these actions were “wrongful.” (Welf. & Inst.
Code, § 15610.30, subd. (a)(1) & (2).) The deeds of trust expressly
authorized Moore to take such actions, and Jeffers does not contend
otherwise. (See, e.g., Stebley v. Litton Loan Servicing, LLP (2011)
202 Cal.App.4th 522, 527–528 [exercise of legitimate, contractual
foreclosure rights did not constitute a “wrongful use” under the
elder abuse statutes].)
Accordingly, we conclude Jeffers fails to demonstrate a
reasonable probability of prevailing on her elder abuse claim.
In light of our conclusion, we need not address Moore’s contention
that Jeffers lacks standing to pursue the claim because the LLC
owns the unit at issue.
2. Malicious Prosecution
To establish a claim of malicious prosecution, the plaintiff
must demonstrate with respect to the prior action that it “(1) was
commenced by or at the direction of the defendant and was pursued
29
to a legal termination favorable to the plaintiff; (2) was brought
without probable cause; and (3) was initiated with malice.”
(Soukup v. Law Offices of Herbert Hafif (2006) 39 Cal.4th 260, 292.)
We conclude the LLC fails to demonstrate a reasonable probability
of prevailing on the “no probable cause” element of its malicious
prosecution claim.
“The question of probable cause is ‘whether as an objective
matter, the prior action was legally tenable or not.’ [Citation.]
‘A litigant will lack probable cause for his action either if he relies
upon facts which he has no reasonable cause to believe to be true,
or if he seeks recovery upon a legal theory which is untenable under
the facts known to him.’ [Citation.]” (Soukup, supra, 39 Cal.4th at
p. 292.)
“Reasonable lawyers can differ, some seeing as meritless suits
which others believe have merit, and some seeing as totally and
completely without merit suits which others see as only marginally
meritless. Suits which all reasonable lawyers agree totally lack
merit—that is, those which lack probable cause—are the least
meritorious of all meritless suits. Only this subgroup of meritless
suits presents no probable cause.” (Robert v. Sentry Life Insurance
(1999) 76 Cal.App.4th 375, 382.)
Here, we are not persuaded that all reasonable lawyers would
agree the third Moore lawsuit totally and completely lacked merit.
Moore’s strongest theory in support of his claims proceeded as
follows: (1) the trial court in Moore’s prior consolidated actions
found the Bullucks’ assignment of their “participating tenant”
rights to Moore was “valid,” but that the Bullucks’ rights as
participating tenants to purchase the property at the TORCA price
had expired prior to the assignment, (2) the express terms of the
consent to conditions agreement require the building owner “to offer
the . . . right to purchase [the] . . . unit” at the TORCA price “for a
30
period of not less than two . . . years from the date of final approval
by the California Department of Real Estate,” (3) because the
earlier subdivision report had expired, the March 2022 report
constituted that “final approval” under the pertinent Business
and Professions Code sections, and (4) issuance of the March 2022
report therefore triggered a new two-year period during which
Moore could purchase unit 5 at its TORCA price.
The LLC does not dispute that the findings in the
prior action and the plain language of the consent to conditions
agreement provide support for Moore’s theory. Nor does the LLC
contend that any published case squarely addresses and rejects
Moore’s theory in the context of a TORCA-related action. On this
record, we cannot conclude the third Moore lawsuit was so utterly
meritless that it “was brought without probable cause.” (Soukup,
supra, 39 Cal.4th at p. 292.) The LLC thus fails to demonstrate a
probability of prevailing on this element of its malicious prosecution
claim, and we need not address the parties’ contentions concerning
the remaining elements.
Accordingly, we conclude the trial court properly granted the
anti-SLAPP special motions to strike.
E. Attorney Fees
Finally, because we conclude the trial court erred in
striking Jeffers’s claims for (1) extortion and (2) breach of fiduciary
duty, we grant Jeffers’s request that we direct the court on remand
to revisit the portion of its order awarding the attorney respondents
“reasonable attorney fees and costs” in connection with their special
motion to strike those claims.
We deny the attorney respondents’ request for attorney fees
on appeal because we conclude they are not “prevailing” parties.
(See Maughan v. Google Technology, Inc. (2006) 143 Cal.App.4th
31
1242, 1253.) As to Moore’s request for attorney fees on appeal, “[he]
may request an award of attorney fees by a properly filed motion
with the trial court.” (Geragos v. Abelyan (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th
1005, 1033.)
DISPOSITION
The portions of the challenged order striking Jeffers’s
claims for extortion and breach of fiduciary duty are reversed.
On remand, we direct the trial court to reinstate those causes of
action. We further direct the trial court to reconsider its award
of prevailing party attorney fees to the attorney respondents in
connection with their anti-SLAPP special motion to strike, in light
of our reinstatement of two of Jeffers’s claims. In all other respects,
the order granting the special motions to strike is affirmed.
Moore is awarded his costs on appeal. Jeffers, the LLC, and
the attorney respondents shall bear their own costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
ROTHSCHILD, P. J.
We concur:
WEINGART, J.
M. KIM, J.
32
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.