CourtListener 10851339•In re I.V. CA4/3
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 4/30/26 In re I.V. CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re I.V., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL G066212
SERVICES AGENCY,
(Super. Ct. No. 24DP0946)
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. OPINION
A.A.,
Defendant and Appellant.
Appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Robert Goodkin, Judge. Affirmed.
Catherine L. W. Markel, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Leon J. Page, County Counsel, Debbie Torrez and Aurelio Torre,
Deputy County Counsels, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
No appearance for Minor.
* * *
Mother A.A. (mother) appeals from the juvenile court’s order
terminating her parental rights to minor child I.V. (minor) following a
1
Welfare and Institutions Code section 366.26 hearing (section .26 hearing).
Mother contends the court erred by failing to sua sponte appoint her a
guardian ad litem. We disagree and affirm.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
On August 3, 2024, Senior Social Worker Heather Collins (SSW
Collins) sought a protective custody warrant for minor, who was born in May
2024, from mother and alleged father due to concerns about the parents’
unresolved mental health issues and mother’s present failure to provide
medical care for minor. It was reported mother had Tourette’s syndrome,
bipolar disorder, and schizophrenia. However, she denied having any mental
health issues and was unwilling to participate in mental health services.
Mother had taken minor to Children’s Hospital of Orange County (CHOC)
the prior night. After minor was diagnosed with failure to thrive because his
weight had dropped from the 20th percentile to the 1.25 percentile, mother
removed minor from CHOC against medical advice. CHOC Doctor Thiessen
advised SSW Collins minor’s condition could become “life-threatening” if he
was not readmitted. SSW Collins spoke with the alleged father over the
telephone. He stated he has a criminal history and an unresolved mental
1
All further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code, unless otherwise stated.
2
health condition for which he was receiving services. He could not care for
minor because he was living at a sober living facility with many roommates.
That night, SSW Collins spoke with mother at her residence. Mother made
statements about people “‘hurting’” her and referred to her residence as
“‘dangerous.’” In response to SSW Collins’s queries, mother stated she would
not take minor to CHOC or to a different hospital. The request for a
protective custody warrant was granted, and minor placed with his maternal
aunt.
On August 6, SSA filed a section 300 petition as to minor, which
included allegations of failure to protect, failure to provide and inability to
provide regular care due to the parents’ mental illness.
The next day, at the detention hearing, the juvenile court
appointed the public defender to represent mother. The court found SSA
made a prima facie case and ordered minor detained from mother’s custody
pending further proceedings. During the hearing, mother asked and
answered several questions, and was admonished for interjecting several
times.
In its September 12, 2024 report for the jurisdiction and
disposition hearing, SSA recommended the juvenile court sustain the section
300 petition and declare minor a dependent of the court. SSA reported
mother denied the allegations of the petition that she failed to ensure minor
receive basic needs including medical care. For reunification services, SSA
recommended mother participate in random drug testing, substance abuse
treatment, self-help meetings, parenting classes, individual counseling, and
mental health services. Mother indicated she was willing to participate in
services.
3
SSA reported that during its investigation, mother made various
concerning remarks, including referring to medical staff as “‘good guys’ and
‘bad guys,’” and stating she takes minor to a different doctor each month as to
not “‘play favorites.”” It also was reported that in 2021, mother caused a
disturbance at a gas station based on a hallucination she had overpaid the
cashier by $100. In May 2023, she was hospitalized after claiming she was
struck in the ribs with a baseball bat, although there was no medical proof.
In January 2024, she was placed on a mental health hold after she reported
“seeing people hanging by their necks on the walls of her family’s home and
claimed there were snipers in the vents and peering through the blinds of
their balcony.” The alleged father and maternal aunt reported mother had
mental health issues and was resistant or noncompliant with her
medications. Mother, however, denied any mental health issues, stating, “it is
all a setup against me.” She also expressed skepticism about psychiatric
medications, believing they cause harm rather than help. She denied ever
experiencing hallucinations or delusions.
At the combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing on
September 26, 2024, mother’s counsel moved to continue the hearing date
because mother was not present. The juvenile court denied mother’s request.
Counsel objected to SSA’s recommendations and requested minor’s return to
mother’s care. The court sustained the petition, declared minor a dependent
of the court, adopted the proposed case and visitation plan, and granted
mother reunification services. It set the six-month status review hearing for
February 27, 2025.
In its report for the six-month status review hearing, SSA
recommended terminating mother’s reunification services and the
rescheduling of a section .26 hearing. Mother had not maintained consistent
4
contact with SSA, and continued to reside with maternal relatives. She also
was inconsistent with visitation. Mother continued to deny any mental health
issue, and it was unknown whether she was taking any of her prescribed
medications. Her progress with reunification services was minimal, and she
refused to review and sign the case plan.
At the six-month status review hearing on February 27, 2025,
mother’s counsel noted mother was not present but had authorized counsel to
proceed. Because a paternity test indicated the alleged father was not the
biological father and he was not married to mother, the juvenile court
excluded him from further proceedings. The hearing was continued to April
24.
At the April 24 hearing, mother’s counsel moved to continue the
hearing based on mother’s absence. The juvenile court denied the
continuance motion as lacking good cause. Over counsel’s objection, it
terminated mother’s reunification services and set a section .26 hearing for
August 20, 2025. Subsequently, the section .26 hearing was continued to
September 22, 2025.
In its section .26 report, SSA recommended terminating mother’s
parental rights over I.A and selecting adoption as the permanent plan. SSA
noted minor had been removed from maternal aunt’s care in July 2025, and
placed with a caregiver who was willing to adopt. When minor was in the
maternal aunt’s care, mother did not visit consistently. For example, in
March 2025, mother only visited minor twice, with each visit being about 30
minutes. After minor’s placement changed, mother did not visit, contact
minor on his birthday or call to check in on minor. Mother also did not return
phone calls or text messages from SSA about scheduling visits.
5
In an addendum report, SSA noted that on August 14, 2025,
mother texted SSA asking how she could get minor back and if she could
have visitation at an SSA office, but mother did not reply to SSA’s responsive
communications. On August 29, 2025, the maternal grandmother informed
SSA mother was hospitalized, but declined to provide the name and address
of the hospital.
At the section .26 hearing on September 22, 2025, mother’s
counsel moved for a continuance to attempt to contact mother and secure her
presence, but acknowledged there was “no assurance that [counsel] would be
able to secure her presence.” The juvenile court denied the motion because a
continuance would not be in the best interest of minor. It found minor to be
adoptable, terminated parental rights, and selected adoption as minor’s
permanent plan.
Mother timely appealed.
DISCUSSION
Mother’s sole contention on appeal is the juvenile court
committed reversible error by failing to appoint a guardian ad litem (GAL)
for her. We disagree.
Code of Civil Procedure section 372, subdivision (a)(2)(A)
provides: “A guardian ad litem may be appointed in any case when it is
deemed by the court in which the action or proceeding is prosecuted, or by a
judge thereof, expedient to appoint a guardian ad litem to represent the
minor, person who lacks legal capacity to make decisions, or person for whom
a conservator has been appointed, notwithstanding that the person may have
a guardian or conservator of the estate and may have appeared by the
guardian or conservator of the estate.” The guardian ad litem “shall have
power, with the approval of the court in which the action or proceeding is
6
pending, to compromise the same, to agree to the order or judgment to be
entered therein for or against the [party], and to satisfy any judgment or
order in favor of the [party] or release or discharge any claim of the [party]
pursuant to that compromise.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 372, subd. (a)(3).) A court
may on its own motion appoint a guardian ad litem for a party. (Code Civ.
Proc., § 373.)
“In a dependency case, a parent who is mentally incompetent
must appear by a guardian ad litem appointed by the court. [Citations.] The
test is whether the parent has the capacity to understand the nature or
consequences of the proceeding and to assist counsel in preparing the case.
[Citations.] The effect of the guardian ad litem’s appointment is to transfer
direction and control of the litigation from the parent to the guardian ad
litem, who may waive the parent’s right to a contested hearing.” (In re James
F. (2008) 42 Cal.4th 901, 910.) “[W]hen the trial court already has knowledge
of the [party’s] incompetency, the trial court has an obligation to appoint a
guardian ad litem sua sponte.” (In re Lisa M. (1986) 177 Cal.App.3d 915,
919.) Any “error in the process used for appointment of a guardian ad litem
for a parent in a dependency proceeding is a form of trial error that is
amenable to harmless error analysis.” (In re James F., at p. 919, fn. omitted.)
“[T]he juvenile court’s error may be deemed harmless if the outcome of the
review hearings and the termination hearing were not affected by the
violation.” (In re Esmeralda S. (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 84, 93.)
Here, although mother has documented mental illnesses and
recently suffered from delusions and paranoia, the record does not establish
that mother lacked capacity to understand the nature or consequences of the
dependency proceedings or to assist her counsel. Her interactions with SSA,
as reflected in the reports, show she understood the allegations against her
7
and her later communications evidenced she was aware she lost custody of
minor and had to take remedial steps to reunify. Mother’s interactions at the
detention hearing also show she was aware of the nature and consequences of
the proceedings. Although she interrupted the court and counsel, her
interruptions were related to the topics being discussed. For example, she
sought to defend her actions by stating she took minor to every appointment
and had everything ready for him. She asserted, “I did everything right.”
Additionally, there is no evidence mother lacked capacity to assist her
attorney. Appointed counsel never stated mother could not assist. Rather, the
limited record indicates mother offered her opinion on legal issues, including
her opinion that the paternity test was incorrect. In sum, the juvenile court
reasonably concluded an appointment of a guardian ad litem was not
required. (Cf. In re Ronell A. (1996) 44 Cal.App.4th 1352, 1368 [“the trial
court did not abuse its discretion in failing to exercise its express power
under section 373 of the Code of Civil Procedure to act sua sponte to appoint
a guardian ad litem for father” where “[it is clear father understood the
nature of the proceedings against him, was able to participate meaningfully
in such proceedings and cooperate with his counsel in representing his
interests”]; In re R. S. (1985) 167 Cal.App.3d 946, 979–980 [finding no abuse
of discretion for juvenile court’s failure to sua sponte appoint guardian ad
litem for mother because “[n]otwithstanding [mother’s] documented mild
[intellectual disability] and her dependent personality disorder, the record
here establishes that [mother] did understand the nature of the proceedings
against her and was able to meaningfully participate in those proceedings
and to cooperate with her trial counsel in representing her interest”].)
8
Moreover, mother has not shown the failure to appoint a
guardian ad litem would affect the “outcome of the review hearings and the
termination hearing.” (In re Esmeralda S., supra, 165 Cal.App.4th at p. 93.)
Mother argues a guardian ad litem would have been a better advocate
because the guardian ad litem “would have requested a psychological
evaluation,” “directed [m]other’s counsel to subpoena [m]other’s mental
health records,” and “could advocate for [m]other to take or be forced to take
medication that she so desperately needed.” Here, mother came to the
attention of SSA because she refused to provide medical care for minor based
on her paranoid delusions. Her denial of suffering from any mental illness
and noncompliance with taking psychiatric medication resulted in the loss of
custody and ultimately termination of parental rights. It is clear the outcome
of the review hearings and termination hearing would not change without, at
a minimum, mother’s compliance with mental illness treatment. The record
indicates that her family, boyfriend, and social workers all encouraged her to
address her mental illnesses. We are not convinced that a guardian ad litem,
likely a stranger whose powers are expressly limited to legal choices related
to the dependency proceedings, would be more persuasive to mother about
accepting her mental illness diagnoses and complying with treatment for her
mental illnesses. In sum, any error in failing to appoint a guardian ad litem
was harmless.
9
DISPOSITION
The order terminating parental rights is affirmed.
DELANEY, J.
WE CONCUR:
MOTOIKE, ACTING P. J.
SANCHEZ, J.
10
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.