People v. Atkinson CA4/1

CourtListener 10848636Calctapp27.04.2026

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 4/27/26 P. v. Atkinson CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

THE PEOPLE, D087443

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. RIF1904874)

v.

ALSON ATKINSON,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Riverside County,
Johnnetta Anderson, Judge. Judgment modified; remanded for resentencing.
Brad J. Poore, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Arlene A. Sevidal, Assistant Attorney General,
Daniel Rogers and Amanda Lloyd, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff
and Respondent.
A jury found Alson Atkinson guilty of one count of felony failure to

provide necessities to a minor child (Pen. Code, § 270).1 The jury also found
true allegations that Atkinson committed the crime against a particularly
vulnerable victim and that he took advantage of a position of trust. At
sentencing, the trial court placed Atkinson on formal probation for two years
and sentenced him to 120 days in jail, which the court stated Atkinson could
serve in a work release program.
On appeal, Atkinson claims that there is insufficient evidence to
support his conviction for failing to provide necessities to a minor child.
Atkinson also claims that the conviction must be reduced from a felony to a
misdemeanor. The People contend that there is sufficient evidence to support
Atkinson’s conviction for a violation of section 270 but concede in a
supplemental brief that the conviction should be reduced to a misdemeanor.
We conclude that there is substantial evidence to support Atkinson’s
conviction for failing to provide necessities to a minor child. We further
accept the People’s concession that the conviction must be reduced from a
felony to a misdemeanor. Accordingly, we modify the judgment to reflect that
Atkinson stands convicted of a misdemeanor violation of section 270 and we
remand for resentencing.
PROCEDURAL AND FACTUAL BACKGROUND
A. Procedural background
The People charged Atkinson with nine felony offenses: three counts
of willful harm or injury to a child (§ 273a, subd. (a); counts 1, 2, 4); three
counts of failure to provide for a minor child (§ 270; counts 3, 7, 9); two

1 Unless otherwise specified, all subsequent statutory references are to
the Penal Code.

2
counts of cruel or inhumane corporal punishment or injury of child resulting
in a traumatic condition (§ 273d; counts 5 and 8); and one count of false
imprisonment (§ 236; count 6). The information named three children whom
Atkinson had adopted as victims: D.A. (counts 1-3), L.A. (counts 4-7), and
O.A. (counts 8 and 9). The information further alleged two aggravating facts
— that each of the victims were particularly vulnerable (Cal. Rules of Court,
rule 4.421(a)(3)) and that Atkinson took advantage of a position of trust and
confidence to commit the crimes (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 4.421(a)(11)).
A jury found Atkinson guilty of count 7, failure to provide necessities to
L.A., and found both aggravating circumstances to be true as to that count.
The jury found Atkinson not guilty of counts 2, 4, 5, 8, and 9. The jury could
not reach a verdict on the remaining counts, which the trial court
subsequently dismissed in the interest of justice.

B. Factual background2
1. The People’s evidence
At trial, as detailed in our sufficiency of evidence discussion below, the
People presented evidence that Atkinson had failed to present food and
clothing for L.A.
2. Defense evidence
Atkinson began working as a social worker in 2003. He testified he had
“witnessed children who ha[d] been severely abused and neglected and that’s
what drove [him] to wanting to work with protecting children.” Atkinson
stated that he ensured that his children had balanced meals and that he did

2 We refer here only to some of the evidence pertaining to the single
count on which the jury found Atkinson guilty, count 7 for failing to provide
necessities to victim L.A.

3
not believe it was ever appropriate to withhold food as a punishment.
Atkinson also said that he provided L.A. with appropriately fitting clothes,
but that L.A. would destroy his clothing and shoes.
Atkinson also testified that L.A. and D.A. had significant behavioral
issues. According to Atkinson, L.A. would eat food off of the ground, hide
food, defecate on himself, steal, and lie. Atkinson also said that D.A. had
acted violently and been hospitalized for mental health reasons after acting
violently toward Atkinson, and that D.A. had threatened to destroy
Atkinson’s life.
Atkinson also said that L.A. and D.A. had both admitted to him that
they had made false accusations against him.
DISCUSSION
A. There is substantial evidence to support Atkinson’s conviction for failing to
provide necessities to a minor child
Atkinson claims that there is insufficient evidence to support his
conviction for failure to provide necessities to a minor child under section
270.
1. Standard of review
“ ‘When considering a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence to
support a conviction, we review the entire record in the light most favorable
to the judgment to determine whether it contains substantial evidence —
that is, evidence that is reasonable, credible, and of solid value — from which
a reasonable trier of fact could find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable
doubt.’ [Citation.] We determine ‘whether, after viewing the evidence in the
light most favorable to the prosecution, any rational trier of fact could have
found the essential elements of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt.’
[Citation.] This determination ‘presumes in support of the judgment the

4
existence of every fact the trier could reasonably deduce from the evidence.’ ”
(People v. Cardenas (2025) 18 Cal.5th 797, 821.)
2. Governing law
Section 270 makes it unlawful for the parent of a minor child to
“willfully omit[], without lawful excuse, to furnish necessary clothing, food,

shelter or medical attendance, or other remedial care for his or her child.”3
The parties do not dispute that CALCRIM No. 2981 properly outlines
the elements of a violation of section 270 and specifies that the People are
required to prove the following in order to establish a violation of the statute:
(1) the defendant was the parent of a child; (2) the child was a minor; (3) the
defendant failed to provide necessities for the child; and (4) the failure to
provide necessities was willful and without lawful excuse. In addition, the
parties agree that, as defined in CALCRIM No. 2981, “[n]ecessities are

3 Section 270 provides in relevant part, “If a parent of a minor child
willfully omits, without lawful excuse, to furnish necessary clothing, food,
shelter or medical attendance, or other remedial care for his or her child, he
or she is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding two
thousand dollars ($2,000), or by imprisonment in the county jail not
exceeding one year, or by both such fine and imprisonment. If a court of
competent jurisdiction has made a final adjudication in either a civil or a
criminal action that a person is the parent of a minor child and the person
has notice of such adjudication and he or she then willfully omits, without
lawful excuse, to furnish necessary clothing, food, shelter, medical attendance
or other remedial care for his or her child, this conduct is punishable by
imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding one year or in a state prison for
a determinate term of one year and one day, or by a fine not exceeding two
thousand dollars ($2,000), or by both such fine and imprisonment.”

5
necessary clothing, food, shelter, [and] medical care[, or other remedial care]

for a minor child.”4
3. Application
Atkinson contends that there is insufficient evidence in the record to
demonstrate that he willfully failed to provide clothing or food for L.A. While
the evidence was disputed and far from overwhelming, we conclude the
following evidence, viewed in light most favorable to the jury’s verdict,
constitutes substantial evidence to support that verdict.
With respect to clothing, a health technician, who served as an
assistant to the nurse at L.A.’s school, testified. She stated that L.A.’s
teacher would send him to the health office because “he would smell, or his
shoes would be ripped or his clothing didn’t fit, or he wasn’t feeling well.”
The health technician estimated that she would see L.A. “maybe every other
day.”
The health technician testified, “He could come to the health office
when his shoes were broken and he couldn’t walk, or when it was raining, his
shoes would be very wet, his clothes would be wet, the clothes wouldn’t fit
him. And it was more for like the shoes, it [sic] would be broken. He would
be walking with broken shoes. We can’t have that at school because of safety
issues.”
The health technician stated that L.A.’s shoes “looked horrible,” and
that “when he [would] walk, his shoes would make noise because they were
broken from the front.” L.A. wore these same shoes every time he came to
the health office. The health technician called Atkinson “maybe five times at

4 The trial court instructed the jury under CALCRIM No. 2981.

6
the most,” to tell him that L.A. had broken shoes. Atkinson would be “upset,”
would “raise his voice” at the health technician and would say that L.A.
“would have to learn to deal with that.” According to the heath technician,
Atkinson “didn’t want to come bring him shoes.” L.A.’s shoes “got to a point
where [the health technician] had to use tape to wrap his shoes so it didn’t
flop when he walked.”
The health technician explained that eventually, after she had duct-
taped L.A.’s shoes together, the shoes had so many holes that L.A. could no
longer walk. The health technician called Atkinson and told him that L.A.
needed to have shoes brought to him. Although Atkinson brought L.A. shoes
to the school, the technician said that Atkinson was “very angry” and that he
threw the shoes at L.A. This was the only time that Atkinson ever came to
the school in response to the health technician’s phone calls. On every other
occasion, according to the health technician, Atkinson would refuse to come to
the school.
The health technician also explained that “[a]lmost every day” she
would see L.A. wearing clothes that did not fit him. For example, L.A. would
wear jeans that either were too small and with holes or they “would be baggy
and he didn’t have a belt.” L.A. appeared to be uncomfortable. On a couple of
occasions, after the health technician told L.A. that she would call “home for
a belt,” L.A. responded, “No, my dad won’t bring it, so I’ll use a rope,” and the
health technician would use a rope to hold up his pants.
L.A.’s second-grade teacher also testified that there were at least three
instances in which L.A. wore either dirty clothes or clothes that he had worn
the previous day to school. In addition, the teacher “would see [L.A.] walking
to school with no jacket early in the morning” when “it was cold outside or
raining.”

7
The teacher also explained that L.A. “had a pair of tennis shoes where
his toes were poking out the front.” She noted that it “was like the shoes had
a mouth,” and she observed that L.A.’s toes were exposed when he walked.
The teacher added that the shoes did not appear new, but rather “worn” and
“dirty.” L.A. wore this same pair of shoes throughout second grade.
In addition, the teacher stated that “sometimes [L.A.] had a foul odor,”
which she believed stemmed from L.A.’s inability to “wipe correctly or use the
facilities.” The teacher added, “[a]nd because there was a smell, I would

usually send him to the nurse.”5
With respect to food, D.A. testified that when he was 17 years old,

Atkinson started locking food in his bedroom, using a padlock.6 The
prosecutor also asked D.A., “How long did this go on for, [where] there wasn’t
really food in the fridge or the kitchen?” D.A. responded, “I don’t remember.
I know it was a good amount of time, though, because my friend’s mom was
buying me food.”
In addition, an investigator stated that D.A. had described he and his
brother’s limited access to food in Atkinson’s home as follows: “[D.A.] stated
there were no nutritional foods for the children within their ability to get it,
nothing in the kitchen that they could grab that had any nutritional value.
And he also stated that other foods were being kept locked in the room

5 An investigator testified that D.A. had told him that there was no toilet
paper in their house and that they had been told to use the restroom at
school.

6 A sheriff’s investigator searched Atkinson’s home and found a padlock
in Atkinson’s bedroom and a latch on the door that appeared to be usable
with the padlock.

8
belonging to Alson Atkinson.” The investigator stated that D.A. told him that
Atkinson had told the children that he had stopped buying food and toiletries
for the house because “they didn’t deserve it and that it wasn’t his
responsibility to do so.”
The People also presented evidence of a forensic interview conducted
with L.A. when he was nine years old. L.A. made several statements during
the interview regarding the limitations that Atkinson placed on L.A.’s access
to food. For example, the interviewer asked, “[I]f you’re hungry at the house,
are you able to get food?” L.A. responded, “No.” After L.A. explained that he
was required to ask Atkinson for food, the interviewer asked, “What happens
if you don’t ask for food?” L.A. responded, “[I]f I lie about it, um, he hits me
with wood.”
When the interviewer asked L.A., “Do you get like breakfast, lunch,
and dinner?” L.A. responded, “Sometimes.” L.A. elaborated that “there’s
been sometimes that only ate [sic] twice.” And, when the interviewer asked
whether there had “ever been a time when [L.A.] didn’t eat,” L.A. responded,
“When I don’t do the dishes.”
Atkinson’s arguments in support of his claim that such evidence is
insufficient are unpersuasive and depend on an improper reweighing of the
evidence and reassessment of the credibility of the witnesses. (See, e.g.,
People v. Oyler (2025) 17 Cal.5th 756, 820 [in considering a sufficiency
challenge, “[w]e do not reweigh evidence or reevaluate a witness’s
credibility”].) For example, with respect to clothing and shoes, Atkinson
argues that L.A. “elected to rip, cut, or tear it himself,” and he notes that L.A.
testified at trial that he wore his shoes in such a manner as to “mess them
up.” The jury was able to weigh L.A.’s trial testimony that he had lied
previously about Atkinson’s abuse and neglect in light of L.A.’s forensic

9
interview and his acknowledgment at trial that he loved his father and he did
not want anything bad to happen to Atkinson. With respect to the failure to
provide food, Atkinson points to L.A.’s trial testimony that there was always
food available, medical evidence that L.A. was “overweight,” and Atkinson’s
own testimony that his children would overeat. It was, however, up to the
jury to consider how to weigh this evidence against the evidence discussed
above upon which a reasonable jury could find that Atkinson had failed to
provide L.A. with adequate food.
Accordingly, we conclude there is substantial evidence to support
Atkinson’s conviction for failing to provide necessities to a minor child.
B. The felony conviction for violation for failing to provide necessities must be
reduced to a misdemeanor
In his opening brief on appeal, Atkinson argued that there was
insufficient evidence to sustain a felony conviction for a violation of section
270 and he contended that the conviction should be reduced to a
misdemeanor.
After the completion of briefing, we issued a supplemental briefing
order directing the parties to brief the following question, “Is this court
required to reduce the felony conviction on count 7 for a violation of Penal
Code section 270 to a misdemeanor conviction under the equal protection
clauses of the state and federal constitutions? (See People v. Gregori (1983)
144 Cal.App.3d 353, 356 [(Gregori)].)”
As noted in footnote 3 above, the violation of section 270 is a
misdemeanor unless “a court of competent jurisdiction has made a final
adjudication in either a civil or a criminal action that a person is the parent
of a minor child and the person has notice of such adjudication.” In Gregori,
supra, 144 Cal.App.3d 353, this court concluded that, while felony

10
punishment can be imposed constitutionally on persons previously found
guilty of a violation of section 270, the statute violates equal protection to the
extent felony “punishment [is] grounded solely on an earlier legal
determination of paternity.” (Gregori, at p. 359.)
In their supplemental letter brief, the People concede that, in light of
Gregori, “appellant’s felony conviction should be reduced to a misdemeanor
under the equal protection clause.”
We accept the People’s concession and reduce Atkinson’s conviction for
a violation of section 270 to a misdemeanor. In light of our reduction of
Atkinson’s felony conviction to a misdemeanor, the matter must be remanded
for resentencing.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is modified to reflect that Atkinson stands convicted on
count 7 of a misdemeanor violation of section 270. The matter is remanded
for resentencing.

BUCHANAN, J.

WE CONCUR:

O’ROURKE, Acting P. J.

DO, J.

11

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.