People v. Toscano CA1/1

CourtListener 10846770Calctapp22.04.2026

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 4/22/26 P. v. Toscano CA1/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
A172182
v.
BENJAMIN KAUKUKALA (Contra Costa County
TOSCANO, Super. Ct. No. 05009211517)
Defendant and Appellant.

In 1992, defendant Benjamin Toscano pled guilty to second degree
murder for a killing he committed when he was 17 years old. After being
found unsuitable for commitment to a juvenile facility, he was sentenced to
15 years to life in prison.
Nearly 30 years later, Toscano filed a petition for resentencing under
Penal Code1 former section 1170.95, now section 1172.6, based on changes to
the law of murder made by Senate Bill No. 1437 (2017–2018 Reg. Sess.). (See
People v. Hin (2025) 17 Cal.5th 401, 441.) After an evidentiary hearing, the
trial court denied the petition, finding that Toscano was still guilty of murder
under current law as “the actual killer.” (§§ 189, subd. (e)(1), 1172.6,
subd. (d)(3).)

1 All further statutory references are to the Penal Code.
Toscano appealed from the denial of his resentencing petition. His
appointed appellate counsel filed a brief under People v. Delgadillo (2022)
14 Cal.5th 216, 221–222 (Delgadillo) stating that there are no arguable
issues. Under Delgadillo, we gave Toscano notice that he had a right to file a
supplemental brief or his appeal could be dismissed. (See id. at pp. 231–232.)
Toscano filed a supplemental brief raising numerous claims, including
various evidentiary issues and ineffective assistance of counsel. We reject all
of his claims and affirm.
I.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL
BACKGROUND
The underlying facts are drawn primarily from the challenged order’s
summary of the evidence presented at the evidentiary hearing on the
resentencing petition. On December 15, 1991, Toscano, 22-year old Harold
Spiller, and two other acquaintances, all of whom were affiliated with the
Norteño street gang, were in a car together in Richmond. Spiller was driving,
and he and the other two men agreed that Toscano was sitting in the car’s
right rear passenger’s seat. As the car approached a liquor store, several
members of the rival Sureño street gang “exchange[d] . . . words” with the
car’s occupants. Toscano produced a shotgun and fired it toward the other
group, killing the victim, Alejandro Cervantes. Toscano then fled the scene.
Before the police arrived, the three men remaining in the car “agreed to
cover for Toscano by blaming the shooting on an ‘[a]lbino’ who was . . . with
them.” During their police interviews, all three initially reported that an
albino or white man was the shooter, but all three ultimately independently
admitted that it was actually Toscano. Another eyewitness, who also knew
Toscano, testified at the evidentiary hearing that he could not see anything
because he was hiding. Soon after the killing, however, this witness told the

2
police that Toscano was the shooter, having seen him in the car’s back seat
holding a shotgun when the shots were fired.
A Richmond police officer, Terry Hudson, happened to be at the scene
when the shooting occurred. He saw “a long gun that was protruding from
the left rear passenger window of the car and was discharged once or twice.”
After observing someone flee from the right rear passenger seat, Officer
Hudson “broadcast on his radio to other officers that the fleeing suspect was a
black man” (Toscano is not Black). The officer did not pursue the person
running, testifying that “he was trying to focus his attention on the three
persons who remained in the car.” Upon investigation, Officer Hudson found
a shotgun in the car’s rear seat that “was positioned . . . with its muzzle
pointing toward the left rear window.”
In April 1992, Toscano was charged with murder, and it was alleged
that he intentionally caused death by discharging a firearm from a vehicle
and committed the crime with the intent to benefit a street gang.2 Toscano
pled guilty to second degree murder and admitted the gang enhancement.
That November, the trial court struck the gang enhancement and sentenced
him to 15 years to life in prison.
Toscano filed a petition for resentencing under former section 1170.95
in January 2022. On a form, he checked boxes indicating that he met all the
statutory requirements for relief, including that he “could not presently be
convicted of murder . . . because of changes made to . . . [sections] 188 and
189, effective January 1, 2019.” (See § 1172.6, subd. (a).) The prosecution

2 The murder was charged under section 187, the firearm enhancement

was alleged under former section 12022.55, and the gang enhancement was
alleged under former section 186.22, subdivision (b)(1). Spiller was sentenced
to five years in prison for his involvement after he pled guilty to being an
accessory after the fact under section 32 and admitted a gang enhancement.

3
opposed the petition, arguing that Toscano was ineligible for relief because he
was the actual killer and was not convicted under a now-invalid theory of
murder. The trial court found that “a summary denial of the motion was not
possible without resorting to judicial fact-finding” and issued an order to
show cause. (See § 1172.6, subd. (c).)
An evidentiary hearing was held under section 1172.6, subdivision (d),
at which several witnesses testified, including Officer Hudson, Spiller, and
the other two men who were in the car. The trial court found that the
evidence established beyond a reasonable doubt that Toscano was the actual
killer of Cervantes and denied the resentencing petition. In doing so, the
court rejected Toscano’s attempts to undermine the credibility of the men
who were with him. The court also rejected Toscano’s “alternative theory”
that “some unknown African-American male” was the shooter, finding that
Officer Hudson’s broadcast description was “not very reliable” given the
officer’s limited opportunity to observe the suspect.
II.
DISCUSSION
In his supplemental brief, Toscano raises 13 points that he wishes us to
consider. For the most part, he fails to identify evidence in the record
supporting his claims or develop them sufficiently to demonstrate they have
legal merit. (See People v. Holford (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 155, 186 [claims
unsupported by “reasoned argument or citation to authority” are forfeited].)
We conclude that none of Toscano’s points entitle him to relief in this appeal.
We begin by addressing various claims that relate to a Sergeant Brown,
who was apparently the investigating officer and conducted at least some of
the witness interviews in the early 1990’s. Toscano contends that the
sergeant “fabricated his police report” because the report omitted statements
the sergeant made to witnesses that improperly suggested Toscano was the

4
shooter. As no police report was introduced into evidence, we are unable to
evaluate this contention.
Toscano also complains that his counsel below failed to call Sergeant
Brown as a witness or present certain articles about the sergeant’s
malfeasance that the defense investigation supposedly uncovered. But
Toscano does not attempt to demonstrate that the failure to call Sergeant
Brown amounted to ineffective assistance of counsel or explain why the
sergeant’s testimony might have affected the result, and the record fails to
demonstrate that counsel had access to other impeachment evidence she
failed to present. Similarly, the record does not support Toscano’s claim that
Sergeant Brown made mistakes and told lies involving the sergeant’s
interview of another witness, Magdalena B., who did not testify at the
hearing either. Indeed, Toscano does not specify what Magdalena B. said to
the police or otherwise explain why she had relevant information, meaning
we reject his claim that she likewise should have been called to testify.
Turning to another police officer, Toscano contends that Officer Hudson
“attempted to alter” the recording in which he stated that he saw a Black
male fleeing the car, exposing the officer to perjury charges and other
sanctions. There is no evidence in the record that Officer Hudson did what
Toscano claims, and in any event the trial court was aware of the officer’s
statement about the shooter’s race when it ruled. Although Toscano claims
the court “refused to address impeachment issues at the evidentiary
hearing,” the court’s order explicitly addressed several such issues, and he
fails to identify any particular evidence the court supposedly overlooked.
Toscano also complains about other aspects of the proceedings without
demonstrating that they entitle him to relief. For example, Toscano states
that despite evidence that Spiller was the shooter, the 1992 prosecution went

5
forward because Spiller was a witness for the original prosecutor and
Sergeant Brown in another case. Nothing in the record supports this claim.
Toscano also contends that the judge and attorneys below “were having secret
meetings/collusions about [his] case without [his] consent or knowledge,” but
he does not point to any evidence that this occurred or explain what relief he
seeks as a result. Similarly, Toscano objects that he never received his case
documents despite asking for them, but he does not provide any proof or
explain why his lack of access to records matters for purposes of this appeal.
Finally, Toscano makes vague claims about the performance of his
counsel in 1992 and during the current proceedings. He cursorily states that
his counsel in 1992 and his counsel below “provided ineffective assistance of
counsel.” But this appeal concerns only the denial of Toscano’s resentencing
petition, meaning his original counsel’s performance is not before us, and he
does not identify any supposedly deficient performance by his counsel below
beyond that we have already addressed.3 Toscano also claims that his
appellate counsel overlooked case law recognizing a section 1172.6
petitioner’s right to exculpatory evidence in police officer personnel files (see
People v. Nuno (2024) 105 Cal.App.5th 1030, 1038), but he does not explain
how such authority supports any claim he might now raise.
In short, none of the points that Toscano raises in his supplemental
brief suggest that the trial court erred in denying his resentencing petition on
the basis that he was the actual killer. As a result, we conclude he is not
entitled to relief. (See Delgadillo, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 232.)

3 After initiating this appeal, Toscano filed a petition for a writ of

habeas corpus based on ineffective assistance of the attorney who represented
him during the 1992 proceedings. (In re Benjamin Toscano (A175737).) This
division summarily denied the petition on April 16, 2026.

6
III.
DISPOSITION
The November 14, 2024 order denying Toscano’s petition for
resentencing is affirmed.

7
_________________________
Humes, P. J.

WE CONCUR:

_________________________
Langhorne Wilson, J.

_________________________
Smiley, J.

People v. Toscano A172182

8

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.