CourtListener 10807374•In re A.T. CA3
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 3/11/26 In re A.T. CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Yolo)
----
In re A.T., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile Court C103132
Law.
THE PEOPLE, (Super. Ct. No. JD2024-0117)
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
A.T.,
Defendant and Appellant.
A.T. appeals from the juvenile court’s order denying his petition for termination
from the sex offender registry. He argues the prosecution failed to meet its burden of
proving community safety would be significantly enhanced by requiring his continued
registration and the juvenile court abused its discretion in finding otherwise. We agree
and reverse the court’s order.
1
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I
Juvenile And Criminal History
In July 2002, the prosecution filed a wardship petition alleging A.T. (14 years old
at the time of the offenses) committed eight offenses related to the molestation of three
female victims, two of whom were four years old and one of whom was seven years old.1
The abuse occurred on multiple occasions between November 2001 and February 2002.
A.T. was subsequently adjudged a ward of the juvenile court for committing the
following offenses: (1) lewd and lascivious conduct with a child under the age of 14,
(2) misdemeanor sexual battery by restraint (two counts), (3) assault with a deadly
weapon by means likely to cause great bodily injury, and (4) misdemeanor assault. On
September 30, 2002, the juvenile court released A.T. into the custody of his parents,
placed him on probation, and ordered him to serve five days in juvenile hall. On
December 20, 2004, he was sent to the former California Youth Authority. He was
paroled from the California Youth Authority on October 10, 2008.
On August 14, 2008, A.T. (then 21 years old) was arrested for contributing to the
delinquency of a minor after he rented a motel room for a 16-year-old female coworker
who claimed she was being abused by her grandparents. The coworker told police
officers that she called A.T. because she did not want to return home. A.T. offered to get
her a motel room. He paid for the room then took one of the room keys and left; he said
he would be back later to check on her. The coworker told police that she and A.T. were
only friends and they never had sex.
1 There is no evidence of the victims’ ages in the appellate record, only statements
made by the prosecution in the juvenile court. A.T. did not, however, challenge the
statements in the juvenile court and does not challenge them on appeal.
2
Police officers found A.T. at his home and detained him. After initially
obfuscating, A.T. told the police that the coworker was at the motel. He also told them he
was on “[California Youth Authority] parole” and was a “290PC sex offender.” A.T.
knew this “look[ed] really bad” but he did not “see how this [was] a problem.” He met
the coworker five days earlier at work. He initially identified the coworker as his
girlfriend but later said they were only friends, and he was trying to help her. Because
she worked and did not go to school, he believed she was 18 years old. He told the
officers that he never had sex with her.
During a search of A.T.’s person, police officers found three condoms and a cell
phone. On A.T.’s cell phone, the officers found several calls between A.T. and the
coworker, photographs of “young females who appeared to be under or close to the age
of 18” in various stages of dress, and “several text messages from various females, some
of which described various sex acts.” A.T. was placed on a “parole violation” hold and
the California Youth Authority was contacted. Charges were never filed. He was
discharged from California Youth Authority parole several weeks later on October 10,
2008.
In January 2009, A.T. was arrested for domestic violence. The record contains no
further information regarding this arrest.
On December 16, 2023, police officers found A.T. drunk, sitting in a stranger’s
car. There was vomit on his pants and in the car. A.T. told officers he was in town with
friends “celebrating an ‘end of life.’ ” (Italics omitted.) He said the car belonged to one
of his friends and she put him in the car. The officers arrested A.T. for being drunk in
public.
II
Petition To Terminate Sex Offender Registration
On July 9, 2024, A.T. petitioned the juvenile court to terminate his sex offender
registration requirement. In his petition, A.T. indicated he was currently registered in
3
Yolo County as a “[t]ier 2 ([j]uvenile)” offender, he was not in custody, he was not being
supervised by law enforcement, and there were no charges pending against him. This
was his first petition. The court set the petition for a hearing.
The prosecution opposed A.T.’s petition, claiming “[c]ommunity safety would be
significantly enhanced by the petitioner’s continued registration.” In support of its
opposition, the prosecution submitted five exhibits: (1) the 2002 through 2003 juvenile
court records related to A.T.’s wardship proceeding; (2) the 2002 police records of the
arrest that resulted in A.T.’s wardship proceeding; (3) the police records related to A.T.’s
2008 arrest for contributing to the delinquency of a minor; (4) the police records related
to A.T.’s 2023 arrest for being drunk in public; and (5) A.T.’s “[r]egister of [a]ctions . . .
card” from his juvenile record (the remainder of his juvenile files had already been
purged).
The Woodland Police Department submitted its own “petition check list,” which
included A.T.’s California law enforcement telecommunications system report, his
current sex offender registration, and the register of actions card from his juvenile record.
(Capitalization omitted.) A.T. was required to register for a minimum of 10 years and his
registration requirement was never extended due to a failure to register conviction. The
Woodland Police Department determined A.T. was eligible to have his registration
requirement terminated.
The prosecution argued A.T. continued to “represent a threat to the public safety.”
(Boldface and capitalization omitted.) Using the police reports of his registration offense,
the prosecution argued A.T.’s three victims were vulnerable family members who were
“extremely young.” The prosecution also argued that A.T.’s behavior in the years after
the registration offense (i.e., his arrests for domestic violence, contributing to the
delinquency of a minor, and being drunk in public) demonstrated a need for continued
registration. In particular, the prosecution argued, even while sober, A.T. harmed three of
his very young female relatives and an emotionally vulnerable 16-year-old girl. Thus,
4
given his most recent arrest for public drunkenness, the prosecution argued, “[I]t is not
[a] stretch to imagine a public safety concern when [A.T.] is so intoxicated that he is a
danger to himself and others.” In short, A.T.’s behavior “indicate[ed] the . . . petition
should be denied.”
At the hearing on A.T.’s petition, the juvenile court found A.T. met his initial
burden. As a result, the court’s task was to determine whether “community safety would
or would not be significantly enhanced by a continued registration.” To reach that
determination, the court explained, it would have to assess the risk that A.T. would
reoffend. The court noted that it did not have any evidence of a risk assessment or
information about A.T. from the California Youth Authority.
Despite finding the registration offense to be “horrendously egregious,” the
juvenile court noted that the registration offense alone was not sufficient to deny the
petition, although it “does weigh strongly.” The court found the passage of time (more
than 20 years since the registration offense) weighed in favor of granting A.T.’s petition.
The court characterized the circumstances surrounding A.T.’s 2008 arrest for contributing
to the delinquency of a minor to be “suspicious.”
Regarding A.T.’s 2023 arrest for being drunk in public, the juvenile court noted,
“It’s common sense that alcohol is disinhibiting.” The court continued: “[The incident]
does cause the [c]ourt concern because it’s so recent and so it undercuts to a pretty
significant degree the conclusion that everything is changed from how it was earlier for
him. Of course, it’s a much different character, I understand that, but it’s still a law
violation and causes concern to the [c]ourt.” The court concluded: “[T]he [prosecution]
ha[s] met [its] burden to show that community safety would be significantly enhanced by
continued registration.” Accordingly, the court denied the petition and set the period for
reapplication at two years.
A.T. appeals.
5
DISCUSSION
Defendant contends the juvenile court abused its discretion by denying his
petition. We agree.
I
Legal Principles And Standard Of Review
Penal Code section 290.008 sets forth the sex offender registration requirements
for juvenile offenders. (Ruelas v. Superior Court (2015) 235 Cal.App.4th 374, 380.)
Effective January 1, 2021, this statute in relevant part provides: “Any person who, on or
after January 1, 1986, is discharged or paroled from the Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation to the custody of which [he or she or they was] committed after having
been adjudicated a ward of the juvenile court pursuant to [s]ection 602 of the Welfare and
Institutions Code because of the commission or attempted commission of any offense
described in subdivision (c) shall register in accordance with the [Sex Offender
Registration] Act [(Pen. Code, § 290 et seq.)] unless the duty to register is terminated
pursuant to [Penal Code s]ection 290.5 or as otherwise provided by law.” (Pen. Code,
§ 290.008, subd. (a); see id., subd. (g).)
Subdivision (d) of section 290.008 of the Penal Code2 provides for tiered periods
of registration. A tier one juvenile offender is subject to registration for a minimum of
five years; a tier two juvenile offender is subject to registration for a minimum of 10
years. (§ 290.008, subd. (d)(1), (2).)
Section 290.008, subdivision (d)(3) provides procedures for juvenile offenders to
petition the juvenile court to terminate their registration requirement “at the expiration of
their mandated minimum registration period, pursuant to [s]ection 290.5.” Section 290.5
provides the procedures for adult offenders to terminate their registration requirement; the
2 Further undesignated statutory references are to the Penal Code.
6
procedures are, therefore, the same, and the process begins by filing a petition for
termination and serving it on the district attorney. (§ 290.5, subd. (a)(1), (2).) Upon
receiving a petition, the district attorney may request a hearing and “present evidence
regarding whether community safety would be significantly enhanced by requiring
continued registration.” (§ 290.5, subd. (a)(2), (3).)
In ruling on the petition, the court “shall consider” the following seven factors:
(1) “the nature and facts of the registerable offense”; (2) “the age and number of victims”;
(3) “whether any victim was a stranger at the time of the offense (known to the offender
for less than 24 hours)”; (4) “criminal and relevant noncriminal behavior before and after
conviction for the registerable offense”; (5) “the time period during which the person has
not reoffended”; (6) “successful completion, if any, of a Sex Offender Management
Board-certified sex offender treatment program”; and (7) “the person’s current risk of
sexual or violent reoffense, including the person’s risk levels on [the State Authorized
Risk Assessment Tool for Sex Offenders] static, dynamic, and violence risk assessment
instruments, if available.” (§ 290.5, subd. (a)(3).) The court may base its determination
on “declarations, affidavits, police reports, or any other evidence submitted by the parties
[that] is reliable, material, and relevant.” (Ibid.) If the court denies the petition, it “shall
set the time period after which the person can repetition for termination, which shall be at
least one year from the date of the denial, but not to exceed five years.” (§ 290.5,
subd. (a)(4).)
When the prosecution requests a hearing on a petition, it is its burden to produce
evidence and to show “that requiring continued registration [will] appreciably increase[]
society’s safety” because the defendant is “currently likely to reoffend.” (People v. Thai
(2023) 90 Cal.App.5th 427, 432, 433 (Thai).) The trial court’s task when ruling on a
petition “is to assess whether the [prosecution] ha[s] carried [its] burden.” (People v.
Franco (2024) 99 Cal.App.5th 184, 192.)
7
“We evaluate a trial court’s decision whether to grant or deny a petition for
removal from the sex offender registry for an abuse of discretion, reviewing any
subsidiary factual findings based on disputed facts for substantial evidence and any
subsidiary legal findings—including questions of statutory construction—de novo.”
(People v. Franco, supra, 99 Cal.App.5th at p. 192.) “A trial court abuses its discretion
when its factual findings are not supported by the evidence, or its decision is based on an
incorrect legal standard.” (Thai, supra, 90 Cal.App.5th at p. 433.)
II
The Juvenile Court Abused Its Discretion
Mindful that it is the prosecution’s burden to demonstrate the defendant is
currently likely to reoffend, and not the defendant’s burden to establish he, she, or they is
not currently likely to reoffend (§ 290.5, subd. (a)(3)), we find the juvenile court abused
its discretion in denying A.T.’s petition.
In Thai, the defendant pled guilty to violating section 288, subdivision (a) after he
masturbated a 12-year-old boy who was not a stranger. (Thai, supra, 90 Cal.App.5th at
p. 430.) More than 23 years later, the defendant filed a section 290.5 petition; the
defendant argued he had participated in counseling and had no criminal history since the
registration offense. (Thai, at pp. 430-431.) The prosecution opposed the petition,
arguing the facts of the underlying crime were “ ‘particularly egregious,’ ” with the
defendant taking advantage of the 12-year-old victim and (despite the defendant’s guilty
plea) showing no remorse after the crime. (Id. at p. 430.) The defendant responded that
there was no evidence he was currently a danger; in other words, the prosecution failed to
meet its burden of proof. (Id. at p. 431.) The trial court denied the petition, reasoning the
crime was egregious and the defendant had taken advantage of a position of trust. (Id. at
pp. 431-432, 434.) The appellate court reversed. (Id. at p. 435.)
The appellate court in Thai concluded the trial court abused its discretion because
the prosecution failed “to produce evidence establishing that terminating the registration
8
requirement considerably raised the threat to society because [the] 64-year-old
[defendant] was currently likely to reoffend.” (Thai, supra, 90 Cal.App.5th at p. 433.)
Assuming the underlying crime was egregious, “those facts alone do not demonstrate [the
defendant] was a risk to the community over 24 years later.” (Id. at p. 434.)
Here, the parties do not dispute the circumstances underlying A.T.’s registration
offense: A.T. sexually abused three of his younger female relatives when he was 14 years
old. The juvenile court considered the nature and facts of the registration offense,
including the age of the victims, and found the crime “horrendously egregious.” The
court also looked at A.T.’s subsequent criminal and noncriminal conduct, which included
two arrests nearly 20 years ago and a more recent arrest for public drunkenness.
(§ 290.5, subd. (a)(3).) This evidence alone does not support a finding that A.T. is
currently at risk of reoffending.
A.T. was 14 years old when he committed his registration offense, in contrast to
the defendant in Thai, who committed his qualifying offense when 39 years old. (Thai,
supra, 90 Cal.App.5th at p. 430.) In the more than 20 years since the registration offense,
A.T. has not been convicted of another offense. Almost immediately after he was
discharged from the California Youth Authority, he was arrested for contributing to the
delinquency of a minor, with no allegation of sexual abuse. But no charges were ever
filed, and he was discharged from California Youth Authority parole shortly thereafter.
There is evidence of an arrest for domestic violence in 2009, but there are no details
about the circumstances of that arrest, and it does not appear charges were ever filed.
Nearly 15 years later, in 2023, A.T. (now an adult) was arrested for being drunk in
public after vomiting in a stranger’s car. A single incident of public drunkenness after a
nearly 20-year conviction free period is not substantial evidence that A.T. is likely to
reoffend, especially considering defendant’s alcohol consumption did not appear to be a
chronic problem or linked to the commission of his qualifying offense.
9
Indeed, although it was its burden to prove A.T. was currently at risk of
reoffending, the prosecution presented no evidence that A.T.’s conduct demonstrated a
pattern of behavior that required continued registration to significantly enhance
community safety. The prosecution did not present a report from a Sex Offender
Management Board-certified sex offender treatment program discussing A.T.’s current
risk of sexual or violent reoffense, or risk levels on the State Authorized Risk Assessment
Tool for Sex Offenders static, dynamic, or violence risk assessment instruments.
(§ 290.5, subd. (a)(3).) Other than the details of the registration offense, the prosecution
offered only two police reports (with nearly 15 years between them) that do not allege
sexual abuse offenses, and its opinion that A.T., now 36 years old, is currently at risk of
reoffending.
Consistent with the legislation’s purpose to cull from the registration rolls low-risk
offenders so that resources could be concentrated on high-risk ones (Sen. 3d reading
analysis of Sen. Bill No. 384 (2017-2018 Reg. Sess.) as amended Sept. 8, 2017, pp. 12-
13), it was incumbent upon the prosecution to present “reasonable, credible, and solid
evidence” establishing a current risk of reoffense. (Thai, supra, 90 Cal.App.5th at p. 435;
see id. at p. 433.) It did not. Without evidence establishing such risk, the juvenile court
abused its discretion in determining that “ ‘community safety would be significantly
enhanced’ ” by continued registration. (Id. at p. 435.) Accordingly, the order of the
juvenile court must be reversed.
10
DISPOSITION
The order denying defendant’s section 290.5 petition is reversed.
/s/
ROBIE, Acting P. J.
We concur:
/s/
MAURO, J.
/s/
WISEMAN, J.*
* Retired Associate Justice of the Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District, assigned
by the Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
11
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.