In re E.C. CA2/1

CourtListener 10799833Calctapp24.02.2026

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 2/24/26 In re E.C. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

In re E.C., a Person Coming B345544
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 24CCJP04058)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

C.C.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from the jurisdictional and dispositional orders
of the Superior Court of Los Angeles County, Debra L. Losnick,
Judge. Affirmed.
Liana Serobian, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Jacklyn K. Louie, Principal
Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________

C.C. (mother) appeals from the juvenile court’s orders
asserting jurisdiction over her child E.C. and removing E.C. from
mother’s care. Mother argues the rulings violated the federal
Violence Against Women Act (VAWA), and were not supported by
substantial evidence. Mother forfeits her VAWA argument for
lack of legal citations. Substantial evidence of domestic violence
between mother and father M.B., as well as mother’s unresolved
mental health issues, justified jurisdiction and removal.
Accordingly, we affirm.

BACKGROUND

1. Prior child welfare history
In 2015, before E.C. was born, the juvenile court asserted
jurisdiction over E.C.’s two siblings based on sustained
allegations of domestic violence between mother and father,
including mother attacking father, and mother’s and father’s
history of illicit drug use. In 2017, the juvenile court sustained
an additional petition alleging a history of illicit drug use and
current drug use by mother. Mother’s and father’s parental
rights to E.C.’s two siblings were terminated in 2018.
In July 2024, shortly after E.C.’s birth, the Los Angeles
County Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS)
received a referral of general neglect. Mother had tested positive

2
for methamphetamine during prenatal care, although she was
negative at birth, as was E.C. DCFS investigated and deemed
the referral inconclusive.
On November 2, 2024, DCFS received a referral regarding
E.C. alleging emotional abuse and caretaker absence/incapacity.
The caller reported mother had called law enforcement and told
them she had a newborn in her care and needed help. Mother
said she was suicidal and had drunk a gallon of vodka to kill
herself. When police arrived mother was uncooperative and was
heavily intoxicated, screaming and yelling, throwing objects, and
spitting in the caller’s face. E.C. was on the couch. Police found
a pipe for methamphetamine in the home as well as empty vodka
bottles. Mother was arrested for battery on a police officer and
child endangerment.
DCFS investigated and concluded the situation had
stabilized. The home visit presented no concerns, and mother
had a support system and service providers in place. DCFS
deemed the allegations of emotional abuse unfounded, and the
allegations of caretaker absence inconclusive.

2. Current referral and investigation
On December 7, 2024, DCFS received a referral regarding
E.C., now five months old. According to the referral, mother’s
neighbor had called the police because mother was destroying
property. Father reported that mother was struggling with post-
partum depression. Maternal grandmother said father was a
drug addict and homeless. Maternal grandmother further
reported mother earlier that day was intoxicated and had said
she wanted to kill herself.
DCFS began an investigation. Paternal grandfather told
social workers that father had been drug free for four or five

3
years. He said mother had mental health issues but no drug use
of which he was aware.
Mother’s apartment manager, Maria, said mother had been
causing trouble in the four days leading up to the referral. Maria
said mother had a mental health crisis, vandalized items in the
apartment building, and kicked the window of a neighbor’s house.
Maria said mother had threatened and terrorized neighbors.
Maria showed social workers a video of mother screaming and
kicking the neighbor’s window. Maria said neighbors had told
her they had heard mother say she was going to kill the baby.
Maria said mother and father often engaged in domestic violence,
but a week later would be back together again.
The next day, Maria and her supervisor opened the door to
mother’s apartment when mother did not answer. A social
worker observed the home was damaged and in disarray with
belongings scattered and broken.
A few days later, social workers met with mother at
mother’s apartment, which had now been cleaned up. Mother
said she had not had a mental breakdown the day of the referral.
She said father and paternal grandfather had taken E.C. to a
tree-lighting ceremony, and mother remained at home with a
friend. Mother and her friend became intoxicated and the friend
started throwing and breaking things. Mother got into a physical
altercation with the friend and police arrived. The front door was
stuck for some reason so mother was unable to open it to let the
police in. When the police left the friend jumped out the window.
Mother said she planned not to drink anymore. The social
workers did not observe any marks or bruises on E.C. other than
minor diaper rash.

4
When social workers spoke to father he denied drug use or
any involvement in domestic violence. In a later conversation, he
said mother had mental health issues but did not elaborate.
On December 19, 2024, apartment manager Maria sent the
social workers a video of mother and father arguing as they
carried E.C. into the apartment. According to the social workers’
description of the video, mother and father could be heard
arguing inside, although they could not be seen on the video at
that point. The “commotion sounded violent and aggressive in
nature” but it was unclear if mother and father were hitting one
another. (Boldface omitted.)
On December 22, 2024, DCFS received information that
father had gone to mother’s apartment to drop off “custodial
paperwork” regarding E.C. He and mother argued, then father
“strangled” mother for 30 seconds. E.C. was asleep in another
room. No drugs or alcohol appeared to be involved. Mother had
since moved into a shelter for victims of domestic violence.
Mother told DCFS father had come to the apartment to
deliver E.C.’s birth certificate and medical records at mother’s
request. Mother and father argued, and mother called him a
“bitch.” Father accused her of filming him and then choked her.
Mother had bruises on her neck and arm, of which a social
worker took pictures. Mother said apart from this incident,
father had not hit mother and their last episode of domestic
violence had been seven years earlier.
On January 13, 2025, the shelter reported to DCFS that
mother had left with E.C. “against program advice.” Mother had
told the shelter she had to go to Long Beach because her uncle
had been shot. The shelter informed her if she left, she would be
expelled from the program. Mother then said she wanted to leave

5
because she was afraid of the wildfires. Mother became
“increasingly irritable and aggressive.” At one point she swung
the stroller containing E.C. so hard that it tipped, and E.C. would
have fallen out had she not been strapped in.
When mother left, shelter staff looked in mother’s room and
found two empty tequila bottles, one empty whiskey bottle, and
four empty beer cans. Shelter staff reported that during mother’s
stay, she displayed fluctuations of aggressive behavior, and was
often rude to, and defensive with, staff.
Apartment manager Maria told DCFS mother had been
texting her with threats of harm, blaming Maria for DCFS’s
involvement.

3. Detention
On December 31, 2024, DCFS filed a petition under
Welfare and Institutions Code1 section 300 seeking to detain E.C.
Under section 300, subdivisions (a), (b)(1), and (j), the petition
alleged mother and father had a history of violent altercations in
the presence of E.C., including the incident in which father had
choked mother and mother had sustained bruises on her neck
and arms. The petition alleged on prior occasions mother and
father argued in E.C.’s presence. The petition noted mother and
father had lost parental rights over E.C.’s siblings because of
domestic violence.
Also under section 300, subdivision (b)(1), the petition
alleged mother had “a history of mental and emotional problems
including homicidal ideation and exhibiting aggressive
behaviors.” The petition alleged mother had been heard saying

1 Unspecified statutory citations are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.

6
she was going to kill E.C., that mother had vandalized items in
the home and kicked a neighbor’s window, and had threatened
other neighbors.
At the detention hearing on January 15, 2025, mother
presented letters confirming mother’s participation in mental
health services. She testified the shelter had not given her useful
referrals and would not answer her questions about a wildfire
safety plan. She did not know why alcohol bottles were in her
room at the shelter. She denied vandalizing her apartment or
threatening to kill E.C. She reported receiving therapy, was in
recovery maintenance for her sobriety, and was taking Lexapro
and Wellbutrin.
A social worker testified mother never indicated she was
afraid at the shelter, and told the social worker she was doing
well and felt connected with the community there. Mother had
not told DCFS she was leaving the shelter. The social worker
said mother was unable to control her aggression, and displayed
outbursts of depression and aggression every few days. DCFS
could not rely on her to be in communication with them, because
it all depended on how she felt on a given day.
The juvenile court said it did not wish to separate E.C. from
mother at such a critical point in E.C.’s life, but wanted
commitments from mother. The court ordered mother to avoid
alcohol and cooperate with DCFS and E.C.’s counsel. The
juvenile court ordered E.C. detained from father and released to
home of mother.

4. Jurisdiction report
The jurisdiction report, filed February 13, 2025, indicated
that since mother had left the shelter she had had unstable

7
housing, moving to at least five different motels and changing her
telephone number four times.
According to the report, a DCFS dependency investigator
met with mother and E.C. on February 6, 2025. The investigator
observed no signs of abuse or neglect on E.C. Mother was alert
and attentive to E.C.
Mother now denied father had been physically violent with
her. She said she had argued with father, but he had never
choked her. Mother denied drug abuse. She said she had anxiety
and depression and took medication to treat those conditions.
She had posttraumatic stress disorder and was seeing a
therapist, but she denied being suicidal or homicidal. Mother
said she had been sober from methamphetamine for years,
although she could not remember the beginning date of her
sobriety.
Mother explained she broke her neighbor’s window by
accident. She got drunk with a friend, and she “maybe did
blackout.” She could not remember everything that happened,
but was not destroying her apartment.
Father did not make himself available to the dependency
investigator. Father would call the social worker at random
times and aggressively express his disappointment with DCFS,
but when DCFS attempted to address his concerns, father would
hang up.
Maternal aunt (misidentified in the jurisdiction report as
maternal grandmother) said she saw father hit mother years
earlier, when maternal aunt was a teenager. In the past few
years, she had seen marks and bruises on mother’s neck, and
knew father left those bruises. She said father was controlling
and manipulative. She believed father ruined things when

8
mother was getting back on track, but mother was now doing
well. She confirmed mother had anxiety and depression for
which she took medication and saw a therapist. Maternal aunt
denied mother was suicidal or would ever hurt E.C.
Maternal aunt said on one occasion, she went to mother’s
apartment when mother was not there and found father there
when he was not supposed to be. He left his backpack which
contained methamphetamine.
DCFS reported mother presented with visible anxiety
signs, including shaking, sweating, heavy breathing, pacing,
asking multiple questions and making multiple statements at the
same time, and deflecting questions directed to her. DCFS
did not believe the symptoms were caused by substance abuse,
but by mental health issues.
DCFS “applaud[ed]” mother for keeping DCFS informed of
her and E.C.’s whereabouts, and acknowledged that E.C.
appeared healthy, clean, and free from marks and bruises. DCFS
nonetheless recommended E.C. remain under juvenile court
supervision “as [mother] addresses her emotional and mental
health needs.”

5. Request for change of order and subsequent reports
On February 19, 2025, DCFS filed a request for a change of
order under section 385 seeking to detain E.C. from mother.
According to the request, mother had been arrested for petty
theft of baby formula and was in police custody. Mother had left
E.C. with paternal grandfather before committing the theft.2

2 The last minute information further states DCFS
suspected that mother and father were still romantically involved
as of February 2025. It is not clear from the record how DCFS

9
A last minute information filed February 26, 2025, stated
that according to booking records, mother had been released from
custody on February 21, but was taken back into custody on
February 23. The last minute information noted mother had two
active criminal cases, one for battery and child endangerment,
and one for theft with a prior theft conviction.
An interim review report filed March 20, 2025 stated DCFS
had placed E.C. with paternal grandfather. DCFS had been able
to interview father, who denied engaging in domestic violence
and said mother would get emotional and lie to the police about
him. He denied choking mother, and said at that time, she was
“buzzed” and having an emotional breakdown.
The report indicated mother had pleaded no contest to the
petty theft charge and received a suspended three-year sentence.
Mother’s drug tests were a mix of negatives and no-shows.
Father had one positive test for marijuana, and the other tests
were negative or no-shows.
DCFS expressed continued concern about mother’s mental
health, and referred to extreme mood swings, defensiveness,
extreme rationalization of her actions, being unfocused, and
being verbally confrontational. Mother had told DCFS she
wanted to stop taking her medication and try a homeopathic
approach, but it was unclear her psychiatrist had approved this
treatment.
A last minute information filed April 2, 2025 reported
mother had another negative drug test followed by a no-show.
Mother said she missed the test because of transportation issues,

reached that conclusion, and we do not consider that conclusion
for purposes of this appeal.

10
but DCFS noted she had not had transportation issues getting to
appointments before. Mother also missed a required
appointment to obtain funding from the county.
Mother informed DCFS she was living in a domestic
violence shelter and was able to take E.C. back, but she declined
to give DCFS an agency name or contact person to verify this.
Mother had been visiting E.C. at a DCFS office, with no concerns
for abuse or neglect reported.

6. Adjudication and disposition
The juvenile court adjudicated the section 300 petition on
April 2, 2025. The court found apartment manager Maria’s
statements credible. The court noted the video of mother and
father fighting, mother’s arrest,3 and mother’s statement that
father had choked her while E.C. was nearby. The court
sustained all allegations.
As for disposition, the court declined to release E.C. to
mother or father. The court cited the “ongoing domestic violence
between the parents.” The court ordered reunification services
for mother and father and granted monitored visitation.
Given the juvenile court’s order removing E.C. from both
mother and father, the court took DCFS’s section 385 request for
a change of order off calendar.

3 It is not clear if the juvenile court was referring to
mother’s November 2024 arrest for battery against a police officer
and child endangerment, mother’s February 2025 arrest for petty
theft, or both.

11
Mother timely appealed from the jurisdictional and
dispositional orders.4

DISCUSSION
Mother challenges the jurisdictional findings against her as
well as the dispositional order removing E.C. from her care.

A. Substantial Evidence Supported Assertion of
Jurisdiction
The juvenile court asserted jurisdiction under section 300,
subdivisions (a), (b)(1), and (j).
Section 300, subdivision (a) requires a showing that “[t]he
child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the child will
suffer, serious physical harm inflicted nonaccidentally upon the
child by the child’s parent or guardian.”
Section 300, subdivision (b)(1) requires a showing that
“[t]he child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the
child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness, as a result of”
one or more enumerated circumstances, including “[t]he failure or
inability of the child’s parent or guardian to adequately supervise
or protect the child”; “[t]he willful or negligent failure of the
child’s parent or guardian to adequately supervise or protect the
child from the conduct of the custodian with whom the child has
been left”; or “[t]he inability of the parent or guardian to provide
regular care for the child due to the parent’s or guardian’s mental
illness, developmental disability, or substance abuse.” (§ 300,
subd. (b)(1)(A), (B), (D).)

4We dismissed father’s separate appeal pursuant to In re
Phoenix H. (2009) 47 Cal.4th 835, 838.

12
Section 300, subdivision (j) requires a showing that “[t]he
child’s sibling has been abused or neglected, . . . and there is a
substantial risk that the child will be abused or neglected . . . .”
“ ‘In reviewing the jurisdictional findings . . . , we look to
see if substantial evidence, contradicted or uncontradicted,
supports them. [Citation.] In making this determination, we
draw all reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the
findings and orders of the dependency court; we review the record
in the light most favorable to the court’s determinations; and we
note that issues of fact and credibility are the province of the trial
court.’ [Citations.]” (In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th 622, 633.)
As an initial matter, DCFS contends mother’s challenge to
jurisdiction is nonjusticiable because the sustained counts
against father are uncontested. (In re J.C. (2014)
233 Cal.App.4th 1, 3 [“Because the juvenile court assumes
jurisdiction of the child, not the parents, jurisdiction may exist
based on the conduct of one parent only. In those situations an
appellate court need not consider jurisdictional findings based on
the other parent’s conduct.”].) We nonetheless exercise our
discretion to reach the merits of mother’s challenge to
jurisdiction, because “the jurisdictional finding serves as the
basis for dispositional orders that are also challenged on appeal.”
(Id. at p. 4.)
Mother argues the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings
violated VAWA, because she was “a victim of domestic violence
and took appropriate measures to remove E.C. from being
exposed to violence by entering a shelter and separating from
father.” Mother does not cite any provisions of VAWA or case law
interpreting VAWA to support her position, and therefore forfeits
the argument. (In re Tobacco Cases II (2015) 240 Cal.App.4th

13
779, 808 [“ ‘a party’s failure to perform its duty to provide . . .
legal authority in support of a contention may be treated as a
waiver of the issue’ ”].)
Mother also argues the jurisdictional findings are not
supported by substantial evidence. She contends the findings
regarding domestic violence are unsupported by the record,
because the sole recent episode of domestic violence was
perpetrated by father, and mother took appropriate steps in
response including calling the police and moving into a domestic
violence shelter with E.C. Mother asserts the other episodes of
violence happened back in 2015 when the juvenile court took
jurisdiction over E.C.’s siblings, and nothing in the record
indicates domestic violence between that time and father
attacking her in December 2024.
Mother also contends there is no substantial evidence her
mental health issues posed a risk to E.C. Mother cites case law
holding a court cannot presume risk to a child from a parent’s
mental illness or cognitive impairment. (See Tracy J. v. Superior
Court (2012) 202 Cal.App.4th 1415, 1424.) Mother asserts the
record shows she has acknowledged her mental health issues and
has sought help for them.
There was substantial evidence domestic violence was an
ongoing problem for mother and father. In addition to the
December 22, 2024 incident when father choked mother, mother’s
apartment manager reported mother and father often engaged in
domestic violence but then got back together. DCFS saw the
apartment manager’s video from December 19, 2024 in which
mother and father argued, and although the social workers
could not see mother and father on the video, the social workers
described hearing a “commotion [that] sounded violent and

14
aggressive in nature.” (Boldface omitted.) Although mother is
correct the findings of domestic violence leading to the removal of
E.C.’s siblings were a decade old, given the more recent incidents
those earlier findings further supported the juvenile court’s
finding mother and father have unresolved issues of domestic
violence between them.
Mother is correct she called law enforcement and moved
into a domestic violence shelter, all of which is laudable. It is
concerning, however, that in later DCFS reports, she changed her
story and said father had not in fact choked her, suggesting she
either was not being forthcoming, or still had not completely
acknowledged the severity of the issues between her and father.
As for mother’s mental health issues, there was substantial
evidence those issues posed a risk to E.C. The referral that led to
these proceedings concerned mother wrecking her apartment, in
what she herself acknowledged might have been an alcohol-
caused “blackout.” Her apartment manager stated this incident
followed several days in which mother had vandalized the
apartment building, kicked the window of a neighbor’s house, and
threatened her neighbors. Video taken by the apartment
manager corroborated mother had broken a neighbor’s window
and was screaming at that time. Social workers interacting with
mother reported her extreme mood swings, defensiveness, and
extreme rationalization of her actions, as well as mother being
verbally confrontational. The staff at mother’s shelter reported
mother’s aggressive behavior including swinging E.C.’s stroller so
violently E.C. would have fallen out had she not been strapped in.
The staff also found empty liquor bottles in mother’s room. This
all supported a finding that mother not only had unresolved

15
mental health issues, but also, that those issues manifested in
aggressive and destructive ways.
In sum, substantial evidence supported the juvenile court’s
jurisdictional findings.

B. Substantial Evidence Supported Removal of E.C.
From Mother
Section 361, subdivision (c) provides that “[a] dependent
child shall not be taken from the physical custody of their
parents . . . unless the juvenile court finds clear and convincing
evidence” that, inter alia, “[t]here is or would be a substantial
danger to the physical health, safety, protection, or physical or
emotional well-being of the minor if the minor were returned
home, and there are no reasonable means by which the minor’s
physical health can be protected without removing the minor
from the minor’s parent’s . . . physical custody.” (§ 361,
subd. (c)(1).)
Although we review the juvenile court’s dispositional orders
for substantial evidence, “ ‘appellate review of the sufficiency of
the evidence in support of a finding requiring clear and
convincing proof must account for the level of confidence this
standard demands. . . . [W]hen reviewing a finding that a fact
has been proved by clear and convincing evidence, the question
before the appellate court is whether the record as a whole
contains substantial evidence from which a reasonable fact finder
could have found it highly probable that the fact was true.
Consistent with well-established principles governing review for
sufficiency of the evidence, in making this assessment the
appellate court must view the record in the light most favorable
to the prevailing party below and give due deference to how the
trier of fact may have evaluated the credibility of witnesses,

16
resolved conflicts in the evidence, and drawn reasonable
inferences from the evidence.’ ” (In re V.L. (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th
147, 155, quoting Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989,
995–996.)
Mother notes the juvenile court released E.C. to her at the
detention hearing, and DCFS did not recommend removal until
mother was arrested for petty theft. Mother cites case law
holding that the mere fact of a parent’s incarceration does not
justify removal. (See In re J.N. (2021) 62 Cal.App.5th 767, 777–
778.) Mother further argues the juvenile court did not
“evaluate[ ] the section 361 factors or consider[ ] whether any
reasonable alternative to E.C.’s removal from mother existed,
such as an order for mother to continue in her shelter and/or
separate housing from father, while complying with the court’s
orders and cooperating with [DCFS], as she was previously
doing.”
The juvenile court’s stated reason for removing E.C. from
mother was not the arrest for petty theft, but the “ongoing
domestic violence between the parents.” As addressed in our
discussion of the court’s jurisdictional findings, ante, there was
substantial evidence of that violence, which similarly supported
the removal order even under the higher clear and convincing
standard. It is true the juvenile court did not order E.C. removed
at the detention hearing, but mother cites no authority that a
court cannot change its mind following further investigation. As
we have noted, after the detention hearing mother changed her
story and said father had not choked her, causing concern that
she was either not being forthcoming about the issues between
her and father or was failing to comprehend the gravity of those
issues.

17
Although not expressly cited by the juvenile court as a
basis for removal, the evidence of mother’s unresolved mental
health issues, in particular her aggressive and sometimes
destructive behavior and problems with alcohol, similarly
supported removal.

DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s jurisdictional and dispositional orders
are affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

BENDIX, J.

We concur:

ROTHSCHILD, P. J.

WEINGART, J.

18

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.