Javidzad v. Adler Construction CA2/1

CourtListener 10797822Calctapp23.02.2026

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 2/23/26 Javidzad v. Adler Construction CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STEVE JAVIDZAD et al., B345765

Plaintiffs, Cross- (Los Angeles County
Defendants, and Appellants, Super. Ct. No. 22STCV28104)

v.

ADLER CONSTRUCTION et al.,

Defendants, Cross-
Complainants, and
Respondents.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Tony L. Richardson, Judge. Affirmed.
CGG Law Offices and Charles Gaitan Gomez for Plaintiffs,
Cross-Defendants, and Appellants.
Lewitt, Hackman, Shapiro, Marshall & Harlan and
Nicholas S. Kanter for Defendants, Cross-Complainants, and
Respondents.
__________________________________
In the proceedings below, the trial court granted a motion
for terminating sanctions filed by respondents Adler Ventures,
Inc. and Eric Adler, finding appellants Steve Javidzad and Laleh
Javidzad violated multiple discovery orders.1 The Javidzads filed
no opposition to the motion and did not appear at the hearing. In
granting the motion, the court dismissed the Javidzads’
complaint with prejudice and struck Steve’s answer to Adler
Ventures’s cross-complaint. Adler Venture subsequently
obtained a default judgment.
Almost six months later, the Javidzads moved for relief
under Code of Civil Procedure section 473, subdivision (b)
(Section 473(b)), arguing they failed to oppose the sanctions
motion because their attorney did not receive it and did not know
it had been filed. The court denied the motion, finding the
Javidzads failed to demonstrate the court granted the sanctions
motion due to their attorney’s mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or
neglect.
On appeal, the Javidzads contend the trial court erred
because their attorney admitted to his negligence, making relief
mandatory. We affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. The Complaints

1. The Javidzads’ Complaints
In August 2022, Steve and Laleh filed a complaint against
Adler Construction, Adler Ventures, and Eric Adler, alleging

1 Because appellants share a surname, we refer to them by

their first name.

2
that, in March 2014, Steve entered into a written lease with
Adler Construction to occupy a home in Beverly Hills at a
monthly rent of $12,500. Thereafter, on September 2, 2021,
while Steve was in lawful possession of the property as his
residence, the defendants wrongfully entered the property and
changed the locks, thereby preventing Steve from entering. They
also “exercised wrongful dominion over and converted Steve and
Laleh’s personal property, furnishings, and other items seized by
Defendants.” Based on these facts, Steve and Laleh alleged
causes of action for: (1) wrongful eviction; (2) breach of written
contract; (3) breach of covenant of quiet enjoyment;
(4) negligence; (5) claim and delivery; and (6) conversion. In
August 2023, the Javidzads filed an amended complaint, listing
the personal property they contend the defendants wrongfully
took.

2. Adler Ventures’s Cross-Complaint
In January 2023, Adler Ventures filed a cross-complaint
against Steve. Adler Ventures alleged it was formerly known as
Adler Construction and, in March 2014, entered into a written
lease with Steve to occupy a home in Beverly Hills at a monthly
rent of $12,500. Adler Ventures claimed that, starting in
December 2019, Steve stopped making full rental payments.
Sometime thereafter, he claimed he could not pay rent because of
COVID-19 and “signed a COVID-19 declaration under penalty of
perjury, stating he could not pay rent due to: Loss of income
caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, increased out-of-pocket
expenses directly related to performing essential work during the
COVID-19 pandemic, and other circumstances related to the
COVID-19 pandemic that have reduced his income or increased
his expenses.” Adler Ventures contended this claim of inability to

3
pay was false, alleging Steve “is the CEO and Founder of L&S
Enterprises, a private real estate equity firm with $20 million of
assets under management” and “on or about June 29, 2021, Steve
closed escrow on a 4-bedroom, 5-bathroom, 4,921 square foot
home in Bel-Air for $3.8 million.”
Because Steve conducted unauthorized renovations to the
floor of the leased home, “in November 2020, Adler served Steve
with a Three Day Notice to Perform or Quit, demanding that
Steve return the floor to its original condition, or vacate the
Premises.” After Steve refused to comply, Adler Ventures filed
an unlawful detainer complaint.
In February 2021, Adler Ventures notified Steve the
current lease expired on April 4, 2021, and Adler Ventures would
not renew it. Nevertheless, Steve did not leave after the lease
expired. Instead, he asked Eric Adler to meet him at the house to
“coordinate” his moveout. “However, during the meeting on April
6, 2021, rather than coordinate his move from the Premises,
Steve demanded that [Adler Ventures] pay him $400,000 to
vacate the Premises.” Adler Ventures alleged “the fair market
rental value for the Premises from April 5, 2021 – August 31,
2021 was at least $35,340.75 per month.”
In late August 2021, a few days before Adler Ventures’s
summary judgment motion in the unlawful detainer action was
set for hearing, Steve vacated the property and moved into his
new Bel Air home. Adler Ventures thereafter “obtained
possession” and “secured the Premises.”2
Based on these allegations, Adler Ventures brought causes
of action for: (1) breach of written contract; (2) trespass;

2 The record does not disclose how the unlawful detainer

action was resolved.

4
(3) intentional misrepresentation; and (4) civil extortion. Steve
answered the cross-complaint in March 2023.

B. Discovery

1. Adler Ventures Files Several Motions to
Compel

(a) First Set of Requests for Production
to Steve
In February 2023, Adler Ventures served on Steve a first
set of Requests for Production, consisting of seven requests,
seeking documents relating to his claim he was unable to pay
rent during the pandemic, the purchase of his new home in Bel
Air, and the unauthorized floor renovation. Steve responded to
the first six requests with “Production, inspection, and copying
will be allowed, and all documents or things in this category in
responding party’s possession, custody, or control will be included
in production.” He did not respond to the seventh request.
In April 2023, Adler Ventures sent Steve a meet-and-confer
letter, contending these responses were “evasive and incomplete”
in that “they do not identify any documents whatsoever” and did
“not specif[y] a date when the responsive documents will be
produced.” The letter also pointed out the failure to respond to
the seventh request for production. Steve’s attorney agreed to
review the responses and “supplement where necessary by May
12.”
On May 12, 2023, Steve’s attorney stated Steve had been
hospitalized and requested a further extension, which was
granted. One month later, Adler Ventures’s attorney informed
Steve’s attorney that Eric Adler had seen Steve walking around

5
town and requested he provide the promised supplemental
responses; Steve’s attorney stated he would provide them by June
23, 2023.
On June 23, 2023, Steve’s attorney stated he was
“collecting and will send all responsive documents to Request for
Production in the next 10 days with identification of documents
to corresponding requests.” Instead, Steve supplemented by
responding to the seventh request with: “Production, inspection,
and copying will be allowed, and all documents or things in this
category in responding party’s possession, custody, or control will
be included in production.”
On July 5, 2023, Adler Ventures sent another meet-and-
confer letter, repeating that the responses to the Requests for
Production were not code-compliant. Adler Ventures received no
further responses. On July 12, 2023, it filed a motion to compel
further responses and documents in response to its first set of
Requests for Production.

(b) Form Interrogatories to Steve
In February 2023, Adler Ventures served on Steve a set of
Form Interrogatories and a set of Requests for Admission.
Among the Form Interrogatories posed was No. 17.1, asking
Steve to state all facts and identify all witnesses and documents
relating to any requests for admission he denied. In April 2023,
Steve served responses.
Ten days later, Adler Ventures sent a meet-and-confer
letter regarding Steve’s response to Form Interrogatory No. 17.1,
contending he “completely failed to provide a response for RFA
27, and the remainder of his responses consisted of one-line
sentences which do not amount to a sufficient factual statement
under the code. Furthermore, Plaintiff failed to identify

6
witnesses and documents for each of the RFA’s under this
interrogatory.”
On June 23, 2023, Steve served supplemental responses to
Form Interrogatory No. 17.1. On July 5, 2023, Adler Ventures
sent another meet-and-confer letter, explaining why the
supplemental responses were still not code-compliant, and
requesting further responses be provided by July 11, 2023. Adler
Ventures received no further responses. On July 14, 2023, it filed
a motion to compel further responses to Form Interrogatory No.
17.1.

(c) Second Set of Requests for
Production to Steve
In May 2023, Adler Ventures served on Steve a second set
of Requests for Production, consisting of three requests seeking
his tax returns for 2019, 2020, and 2021. Steve did not respond.
On July 5, 2023, Adler Ventures sent a meet-and-confer letter,
requesting responses be provided by July 11, 2023. When Adler
Ventures still received no responses, it filed a motion to compel
responses and documents in response to its second set of
Requests for Production.
In September 2023, Steve asked for the motion to compel to
be taken off-calendar because he had “served fully compliant”
responses to the second set of requests for production. A copy of
the responses was attached. To the requests for tax returns for
2019 and 2020, Steve stated: “Production, inspection, and copying
will be allowed, and all documents or things in this category in
responding party’s possession, custody, or control will be included
in production.” To the request for his 2021 tax return, Steve said:
“Unable to comply after diligent search and reasonable inquiry in
an effort to comply because particular item or category has never

7
been in responding party’s possession, custody, or control.” The
verification page was dated June 26, 2023.
In its reply, Adler Ventures asserted the responses were
not served until the date of the opposition (i.e., September 20,
2023), the responses were not code-compliant, and Steve had yet
to produce any documents.

(d) Second Set of Special Interrogatories
to Steve
On July 24, 2023, Adler Ventures served on Steve its
second set of Special Interrogatories. Steve did not respond and,
on September 28, 2023, Adler Ventures filed a motion to compel
further responses to its second set of Special Interrogatories.

(e) Discovery to Laleh
On August 23, 2023, Adler Ventures served on Laleh
Special Interrogatories, Form Interrogatories, and Requests for
Production of Documents. Laleh did not respond and, on
September 28, 2023, Adler Ventures filed three motions to
compel, one for each set of discovery.

2. The First Motion to Compel Hearing
On October 3, 2023, with both counsel present
telephonically, the court denied as moot Adler Ventures’s motion
to compel responses to its second set of Requests for Production
but ordered Steve “to produce all responsive documents within
thirty (30) days.” The court expressly warned Steve that if he
failed to do so, “Defendant Adler Ventures may file a motion for
monetary, issue, evidentiary, and terminating sanctions.” The
court also ordered Steve to pay monetary sanctions of $1,667.60.
The court additionally ordered all remaining motion to compel

8
hearings continued to November 1, 2023, and ordered the parties
to meet and confer about them by the next day. Thereafter, by
October 16, 2023, the parties were to submit a joint statement
informing the court of what issues were resolved and what issues
remained for the court to decide. Adler Ventures gave notice of
the court’s order the next day.

3. The “Joint” Statement
On October 16, 2023, Adler Ventures submitted a
statement outlining what it and the Javidzads agreed on in their
meet-and-confer. Essentially, the Javidzads agreed to serve code-
compliant responses without objection and produce documents as
to all the discovery requests at issue in the motions to compel, by
October 13, 2023. However, they did not. Adler Ventures further
informed the court that, on October 16, it had sent the Javidzads
a draft statement for them to “fill in their portion” in time for it to
be filed with the court that day, but their counsel was “out of
office” and suggested the parties file the statement a day later,
which suggestion Adler Ventures declined.

4. The Javidzads Serve Some Responses and
Oppose All Motions to Compel
On October 22, 2023, Laleh served responses to the
discovery propounded on her. Additionally, Steve served
responses to Adler Ventures’s second set of Special
Interrogatories. Steve served no supplemental responses, and
neither Steve nor Laleh produced any documents.
The next day, the Javidzads opposed all remaining motions
to compel, contending either that they had already served
responses, or that their original responses were code-compliant.

9
Two days later, Adler Ventures replied to all the
oppositions, pointing out both the discovery responses and the
oppositions were untimely, explaining why many of the responses
were not code-compliant, and asserting that the Javidzads still
had not produced any documents.

5. The Court Mostly Grants the Remaining
Motions to Compel
On November 1, 2023, the court mostly granted the
remaining motions to compel. Specifically:
As to the discovery propounded on Laleh and the second set
of Special Interrogatories propounded on Steve, the court ordered
“verified responses without objections shall be served within
thirty (30) days if they have not been served already” and warned
“[i]f Plaintiffs fail to do so, Defendants may file a motion for
monetary, issue, evidentiary, and terminating sanctions.” The
court also ordered Steve to pay monetary sanctions in the amount
of $1,661.65 within thirty days.
As to the first set of Requests for Production propounded on
Steve, the court ordered him to “produce all responsive
documents within thirty (30) days and . . . provide a code-
compliant response within thirty (30) days making clear that he
has done so.” The court also found “his failure to comply with his
discovery obligations under these circumstances constitutes an
abuse of the discovery process warranting sanctions” and ordered
him “to pay Defendants, by and through counsel, the amount of
$2,061.65 within thirty (30) days.”
As to Form Interrogatory No. 17.1 propounded on Steve,
the court ordered him to “provide code-compliant responses
without objections within thirty (30) days” to portions of the
interrogatory.

10
Adler Ventures gave notice of the court’s order a week
later.

C. Motion for Terminating Sanctions
On December 22, 2023, respondents moved for terminating
sanctions. They contended:
Steve violated the court’s October 3, 2023 order because he
“did not produce his tax returns by the Court’s deadline.” After
Adler Ventures contacted Steve’s counsel to request the tax
returns and gave him several more days to produce them, Steve
“produced partial 2020 tax returns, but did not produce the 2019
tax returns, only a tax transcript for 2019.” Steve refused to
produce the 2019 tax return and failed to pay the ordered
monetary sanctions.
Steve also violated the court’s November 1, 2023 order
because, as regards to Form Interrogatory No. 17.1 and Adler
Ventures’s first set of Requests for Production, he “has not
produced any responsive documents, served code-compliant
responses, or paid monetary sanctions.”
Laleh also violated the court’s November 1, 2023 order
because she “failed to serve compliant responses” and “failed to
produce any documents.”
The Javidzads did not oppose the motion.
On February 8, 2024, the court granted the motion. The
court found: “As of the date of the motion, Plaintiffs have not
produced any responsive documents or served code-compliant
responses. [Citation.] Plaintiffs have not opposed the motion,
and the record reflects no good cause for Plaintiffs’ failure to
comply with their discovery obligations. The Court has
considered whether lesser sanctions would facilitate Plaintiffs’
compliance with their discovery obligations. However, the Court

11
previously imposed monetary sanctions on two occasions, to no
avail, and evidentiary and issue sanctions would not remedy the
prejudice caused by Defendants failure to obtain necessary
discovery.” Based on these findings, the court dismissed the
Javidzads’ complaint with prejudice and struck the answer to the
cross-complaint. That same day, the court served on the
Javidzads’ attorney an order of dismissal indicating the court had
dismissed their action with prejudice.
Five days later, Adler Ventures served notice of the ruling.
On February 20, 2024, at the request of Adler Ventures, the court
clerk entered Steve’s default. On February 28, 2024, Adler
Ventures filed and served documents seeking a default judgment
against Steve. On March 4, 2024, the court entered judgment in
favor of Adler Ventures and against Steve for $707,914.02. Later
in March 2024, Adler Ventures requested a writ of execution and
an abstract of judgment, both of which were served on the
Javidzads’ counsel.

D. The Javidzads Ask the Court to Set Aside Its
Order Dismissing the Complaint and Its
Judgment Against Steve

1. Motion
On August 2, 2024, the Javidzads moved under Section
473(b) “for a mandatory order granting relief from the
February 8, 2024 Order, Dismissal of Complaint, Default on
Cross-Complaint, and Default Judgment on Cross-Complaint
entered on March 4, 2024 due to attorney fault resulting from
attorney’s mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or neglect for
counsel’s failure to timely receive the February 8, 2024 Motion for
Terminating Sanction before the hearing.” The Javidzads

12
claimed their attorney failed to oppose the motion for terminating
sanctions “because he never received and was aware of the
Motion until after the February 8, 2024 hearing [sic].”3 They
argued that “[d]ue to Plaintiffs’ counsel’s mistake, inadvertence,
surprise, or neglect preventing opposition, Plaintiffs did not
oppose the Motion, resulting in Dismissal of Plaintiffs’ Complaint
and Default Judgment on Defendants’ Cross-Complaint.” They
further argued the requested relief was mandatory. However,
they did not dispute they violated the court’s discovery orders
and provided no explanation as to why they had done so. Nor did
they attach any supplemental discovery responses to their
motion, or any evidence they had produced any documents.

2. Opposition
In January 2025, Adler Ventures opposed the Javidzads’
motion for relief, arguing: (1) “the order, default, and judgment
were not caused by [the Javidzads’ attorney] Mr. Gentino. The
Court dismissed Plaintiffs’ complaint and entered judgment for
Defendants/Cross-Complainants Eric Adler and Adler Ventures,
Inc. (‘Defendants’) because Plaintiffs engaged in a misuse of the
discovery process and violated multiple discovery”; (2) “the
motion was not made within a reasonable time, as required by
Code Civ. Proc. § 473”; and (3) “even if Mr. Gentino caused the
default, dismissal, or resulting judgment, the motion should be
denied because it is not in the proper form” in that “[i]n the
context of a terminating sanctions motion, a request for
mandatory relief under Code Civ. Proc. § 473(b) must be

3 Neither the Javidzads nor their attorney ever explain

when and how they became aware of the motion and the
subsequent orders, dismissals, and judgment.

13
‘accompanied by verified discovery responses in question’ ” and
the Javidzads’ motion was not so accompanied.

3. Reply
In their February 2025 reply, the Javidzads argued:
(1) “The Order, Dismissal, Default, and Default Judgment were
caused by Mr. Gentino, as stated in his moving Declaration”;
(2) “The motion was timely”; and (3) “Plaintiffs have provided all
verified discovery responses and produced all responsive
documents to Defendants.”
Specifically, the Javidzads newly claimed: (1) Steve had
produced his entire 2020 tax return and could not produce his
2019 tax return because he did not have it; (2) Laleh had served
verified responses without objection to the discovery propounded
on her; (3) Steve had served verified response without objection to
the second set of Special Interrogatories propounded on him;
(4) Steve’s original responses to the first set of Requests for
Production were not code-compliant because he had previously
said “Production, inspection, and copying will be allowed” but did
not indicate if production, inspection, and copying would be
allowed in whole or in part, and he had remedied this defect by
serving supplemental responses provided that “Production,
inspection, and copying will be allowed in whole”; (5) the
Javidzads’ attorney “has prepared an email to Defendants’
counsel with attached documents responsive to” their first set of
Requests for Production4; and (6) the Javidzads’ attorney “had

4 The Javidzads’ attorney stated he “accepts responsibility

for his failure to produce all responsive documents within 30 days
of the November 1, 2023 Order” without explaining why he was
responsible for this failure.

14
begun drafting, but had failed to finalize and serve a” further
supplemental response to Form Interrogatory No. 17.1, but
attached such a response to his declaration accompanying the
reply.5

4. Ruling
On February 26, 2025, the court denied the Javidzads’
motion. The court found the Javidzads failed to “demonstrate the
dismissal of Plaintiffs’ complaint resulted from Counsel’s
mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect.” Instead,
“the Court imposed terminating sanctions because Plaintiffs
disregarded this Court’s October 3 and November 1, 2023 orders,
in which the Court ordered Plaintiffs to provide discovery
responses. Counsel fails to address the reasons why Plaintiffs
failed to comply with those orders. As such, Counsel’s
explanation for his failure to oppose the motion for terminating
sanctions does not show the Court’s February 8, 2024 order
resulted from Counsel’s mistake, inadvertence, or excusable
neglect when that sanction was imposed because of Plaintiffs’
abuse of the discovery process.” The court also noted the
Javidzads failed to provide verified discovery responses with
their motion. The court concluded: “Given the history of this
action, in which Plaintiffs had ample opportunities to rectify the
issues which compelled this Court to impose a terminating
sanction and to make a case for setting aside the Court’s
February 8, 2024 order, Plaintiffs’ reply brief and Counsel’s

5 In his accompanying declaration, the Javidzads’ attorney

stated: “I had begun drafting, but had never finalized and served
a Further Supplemental Response to Form Interrogatories
(set#1), Number 17.1, and don’t know the reason why.”

15
declaration attached to it do not add much clarity to support the
notion the dismissal was Counsel’s fault. Thus, they are
insufficient to warrant granting Plaintiffs the relief they seek.
Accordingly, the motion is denied.”
The Javidzads timely appealed.

DISCUSSION
The Javidzads’ sole argument on appeal, without any
citation to the record, is that the trial court abused its discretion
in denying their motion for relief from default when their
attorney “admitted to engaging in acts of neglect that resulted in
multiple sanction orders, including, ultimately, terminating
sanctions,” and “[t]he neglect of counsel representing Appellants
before the trial court is evident even in the very 473(b) motion
Appellant’s [sic] former trial counsel filed to relieve his former
clients of the neglect that resulted in terminating sanctions.”
Under such circumstances, the Javidzads contend relief was
mandatory. We disagree.
The court granted the motion for terminating sanctions
because the Javidzads had “not produced any responsive
documents or served code-compliant responses,” and “the record
reflects no good cause for Plaintiffs’ failure to comply with their
discovery obligations.” In their motion to set aside the court’s
granting of the sanctions motion, the Javidzads entirely failed to
address why they had not produced responsive documents or
served code-compliant responses within the time limit set by the

16
court. Instead, they focused only on why their attorney had not
responded to the motion for terminating sanctions.6
Even were we to consider the belated arguments and
evidence the Javidzads presented in and with their reply brief,7
they still do not fully explain why the Javidzads were unable to
comply with their discovery obligations in a timely fashion. For
example, while some verified discovery responses were included
with the reply, the Javidzads did not explain why these responses
were not served until February 2025, why Steve was unable to
produce documents until February 2025, or why Laleh still had
not produced any documents. Without such explanations, the
Javidzads failed to meet their burden to demonstrate the
misconduct was solely their attorney’s fault. Relief under section

6 Even on that topic, their explanation was lacking. While
the Javidzads’ attorney stated he did not receive the December
2023 motion for terminating sanctions, he did not explain why—
as the attorney representing the plaintiffs—he never once
bothered to check what was happening in the case in the more
than eight months that passed between the filing of the sanctions
motion and the Javidzads’ request for relief. Nor did he ever
claim he had not received any of the other documents that would
have alerted him to the proceedings, such as the notice of ruling
regarding the sanctions motion, the notice of the court dismissing
with prejudice the Javidzads’ complaint, the default judgment
prove-up package submitted by Adler Ventures, the request for
writ of execution, and the abstract of judgment.

7 “ ‘The general rule of motion practice . . . is that new

evidence is not permitted with reply papers.’ ” (Maleti v. Wickers
(2022) 82 Cal.App.5th 181, 227.) This principle applies to new
arguments as well, “particularly where the circumstances giving
rise to the argument” were known when the motion was filed.
(Ibid.)

17
473(b) “is available only when the attorney is solely responsible
for the misconduct.” (Lang v. Hochman (2000) 77 Cal.App.4th
1225, 1228.) Therefore, the court did not abuse its discretion in
denying the Javidzads’ motion.

DISPOSITION
The court’s order is affirmed. Respondents shall recover
their costs on appeal.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

M. KIM, J.

We concur:

ROTHSCHILD, P. J.

WEINGART, J.

18

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.