CourtListener 10796319•Pay Up Jr v. Rechnitz CA2/8
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 2/19/26 Pay Up Jr v. Rechnitz CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
PAY UP JR, LLC, B332788
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 20SMCV00216)
v.
JONA RECHNITZ et al.,
Defendants and Appellants.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County. Mark Epstein, Judge. Affirmed.
Robert W. Hirsh & Associates and Robert W. Hirsh for
Defendants and Appellants.
Frandzel Robins Bloom & Csato, Michael Gerard Fletcher,
and Hal D. Goldflam for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________________
INTRODUCTION
Defendants Jona Rechnitz and Jadelle Jewelry &
Diamonds, LLC (Jadelle Jewelry) appeal from the trial court’s
judgment entered in favor of plaintiff Victor Franco Noval1 after
a bench trial. Defendants contend insufficient evidence supports
several of the court’s findings, and that the court abused its
discretion in admitting certain pieces of evidence. Due to serious
defects in their appellate briefs, defendants have forfeited all the
claims of error that they raise on appeal. Accordingly, we affirm.
BACKGROUND
1. The loans
In 2019, Noval loaned about $6 million, through a series of
installments, to Jadelle Jewelry. Before Noval advanced each
installment of the loan to Jadelle Jewelry, Rechnitz pledged some
jewelry as collateral for the loan. Rechnitz assured Noval that
the total value of the jewelry was higher than the total value of
the loan.
In March 2019, Noval and Jadelle Jewelry executed a
document entitled, “DEBT ACKNOWLEDGMENT,
PROMISSORY NOTE AND SECURITY AGREEMENT”
(Promissory Note). The Promissory Note memorializes a portion
of the loan, specifically four installments totaling $2.85 million
that Noval advanced to Jadelle Jewelry between January and
March 2019. The Promissory Note sets forth the terms of
repayment for those installments, including the maturity date for
1 After the judgment was entered, Noval assigned his
interest in the judgment to Pay Up Jr, LLC (Pay Up). We
granted Pay Up’s application to substitute itself as the real party
in interest for Noval.
2
each installment and the monthly interest payments Jadelle
Jewelry was required to make on each installment. The
Promissory Note also includes a guaranty, which states that
Jadelle Jewelry’s payment obligations are secured by, among
other things, the jewelry that the company pledged as collateral.
Around December 2019, Rechnitz asked Noval to return the
jewelry that he was holding as collateral because Rechnitz
wanted to display it at a show in Los Angeles. Rechnitz told
Noval that he would use the money he obtained from any sales at
the show to pay off the money that Noval loaned to Jadelle
Jewelry. Rechnitz promised to return to Noval any unsold
jewelry the day after the show. Noval agreed to allow Rechnitz to
display the jewelry at the show. Rechnitz did not sell any jewelry
at the show.
The day after the show, Rechnitz asked if he could keep the
jewelry while he tried to sell it to a potential buyer. Noval
allowed Rechnitz to hold the jewelry. Over the next several
weeks, Rechnitz repeatedly told Noval that he would return the
jewelry or pay off the money that Noval lent to him.
In January 2020, Rechnitz gave Noval three checks, one for
$1.3 million, one for $2.5 million, and one for $4.5 million, which
were intended to repay Noval’s loan to Jadelle Jewelry. Noval
was not able to cash any of the checks. Jadelle Jewelry never
repaid Noval’s loan, and Rechnitz never returned the jewelry that
he pledged as collateral to secure the loan.
2. The lawsuit
In February 2020, Noval sued Rechnitz, Rechnitz’s wife,
Jadelle Jewelry, and a company called “Jadelle Inc.” Noval’s
operative first amended complaint asserted claims for fraud, civil
3
theft, breach of contract, and conspiracy to commit theft, fraud,
and fraud by concealment.
In February 2023, the trial court held a bench trial on
Noval’s claims. Noval and his brother were the only witnesses
who testified. Rechnitz and his wife did not testify because they
invoked their Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination.
In May 2023, the court issued a final statement of decision.
The court found Rechnitz and Jadelle Jewelry liable for fraud and
civil theft, and Jadelle Jewelry liable for breach of contract.
The court found Noval suffered $5.9 million in actual damages
with respect to his civil theft cause of action, which tripled to
$17.7 million under Penal Code section 496, subdivision (c).
Although the court found Noval also suffered nearly $6 million in
damages for each of his fraud and breach of contract causes of
action, it found those damages were duplicative of the damages
he suffered for his civil theft cause of action. The court found in
favor of Rechnitz’s wife and Jadelle Inc. on all of Noval’s causes of
action.
In June 2023, the court entered judgment in Noval’s favor
against defendants for $17.7 million, plus prejudgment and
postjudgment interests, costs, and attorney fees. The court later
denied defendants’ motions for a new trial and to vacate the
judgment.
Defendants appeal.
DISCUSSION
At the outset, we highlight some serious defects in
defendants’ appellate briefs. These defects include a failure to
cite and discuss relevant evidence that was presented at trial,
and a failure to provide reasoned legal argument supported by
factual analysis and citations to relevant authority. As we
4
explain, these defects undermine all the arguments that
defendants raise on appeal.
It is a fundamental rule of appellate review that the
challenged judgment or order is presumed to be correct and that
the appellant carries the burden to affirmatively demonstrate
error. (Dietz v. Meisenheimer & Herron (2009) 177 Cal.App.4th
771, 799 (Dietz).) To overcome this burden, the appellant must,
among other things, tailor each argument raised in its appeal to
the applicable standard of review (Sonic Mfg. Technologies, Inc. v.
AAE Systems, Inc. (2011) 196 Cal.App.4th 456, 465); support each
claim with “reasoned argument and citations to authority” (Dietz,
at p. 799); and set forth, discuss, and analyze all the evidence,
both favorable and unfavorable to the appellant’s position, that
supports the trial court’s factual findings that are challenged on
appeal (Doe v. Roman Catholic Archbishop of Cashel & Emly
(2009) 177 Cal.App.4th 209, 218 (Roman Catholic Archbishop)).
An appellant’s failure to comply with any of these requirements
may result in a waiver of the appellant’s claims on appeal. (See
Maria P. v. Riles (1987) 43 Cal.3d 1281, 1295–1296; Sonic Mfg.,
at p. 465; Dietz, at p. 799; Roman Catholic Archbishop, at p. 218.)
As a threshold matter, we note that at oral argument,
defendants withdrew the argument raised in their opening brief
challenging the trial court’s decision to admit into evidence the
Promissory Note, because it was not authenticated and contained
hearsay statements. Because defendants have withdrawn this
argument, we need not address it.
The next defect—defendants’ failure to discuss Noval’s
testimony—undermines defendants’ remaining arguments. An
appellant challenging the “sufficiency of the evidence to support a
finding must set forth, discuss, and analyze all the evidence on
5
that point, both favorable and unfavorable.” (Roman Catholic
Archbishop, supra, 177 Cal.App.4th at p. 218.) If the appellant
fails to discuss and analyze evidence that is relevant to the
court’s challenged finding, the appellant waives any claim that
the finding is not supported by substantial evidence. (Ibid.)
Defendants argue the record does not support the following
findings made by the trial court: (1) Noval was Jadelle Jewelry’s
lender and creditor; (2) the jewelry that Jadelle Jewelry pledged
as collateral to secure Noval’s loan was worth more than the total
value of the loan; (3) defendants acted with the requisite criminal
intent for civil theft; and (4) Noval and Jadelle Jewelry entered
into an enforceable written contract. Because these findings are
not supported by the evidence, defendants claim the court erred
in finding them liable for fraud, civil theft, and breach of
contract. As we explain, Noval’s testimony is relevant to each of
these findings.
First, Noval’s testimony supports the court’s finding that he
was Jadelle Jewelry’s creditor. Noval testified that he agreed to
loan money to Jadelle Jewelry, that he made each of the
payments advancing money to the company under that loan, and
that the company wrote unfunded checks to him in an effort to
repay him for the loan.
Second, Noval’s testimony supports the court’s finding that
the jewelry that Jadelle Jewelry pledged as collateral to secure
the loan was worth more than the total value of the loan. Noval
testified that before he advanced each installment of the loan to
Jadelle Jewelry, the company gave him jewelry as collateral to
secure each installment of the loan. According to Noval, he “was
sure to get more collateral and make sure that it was of a value
that would keep [him] safe in this loan.” Noval testified that
6
Rechnitz assured him that the total value of the jewelry that was
pledged as collateral was “more than sufficient to cover the value
of the loan.”
Third, Noval’s testimony could support a finding that
defendants acted with the criminal intent needed to establish
liability for civil theft under Penal Code section 496. Under
subdivision (c) of that statute, any person who is injured by a
violation of subdivision (a) “may bring an action for three times
the amount of actual damages . . . sustained by the plaintiff.”
(Pen. Code, § 496, subd. (c).) To establish a violation of
subdivision (a), the plaintiff must prove: (1) the property was
stolen; (2) the defendant knew the property was stolen; and
(3) the defendant had possession of the stolen property.
(Lacagnina v. Comprehend Systems, Inc. (2018) 25 Cal.App.5th
955, 970.)
To prove civil theft, “a plaintiff must establish criminal
intent on the part of the defendant beyond ‘mere proof of
nonperformance or actual falsity.’ ” (Siry Investment, L.P. v.
Farkhondehpour (2022) 13 Cal.5th 333, 361–362.) Evidence that
the defendants “acted not innocently or inadvertently, but with
careful planning and deliberation” will support a finding of
criminal intent. (Id. at p. 362.)
Noval testified in detail about how Rechnitz convinced him
to relinquish possession of the jewelry that Jadelle Jewelry had
pledged as collateral to secure the underlying loan. Noval also
testified about how defendants refused to return the jewelry,
despite Noval’s repeated requests for them to do so, and how
Rechnitz tried to prevent Noval from contacting law enforcement
to help recover the jewelry. Although defendants attempted to
address this evidence at oral argument, they made no effort to do
7
so in their opening brief. By failing to address Noval’s testimony
in their opening brief, defendants have forfeited any claim that it
does not support an inference that Rechnitz acted with the
requisite criminal intent. (See Collins v. Navistar, Inc. (2013)
214 Cal.App.4th 1486, 1508, fn. 8.)
Finally, the court expressly relied on Noval’s testimony
when it found there was an enforceable contract between himself
and Jadelle Jewelry. As the court explained, Noval “testified that
he made the payments at issue,” including writing the checks
through which the money was advanced to Jadelle Jewelry. The
court also explained that it found Noval’s testimony was credible
about the formation of the loan agreement with Jadelle Jewelry.
Our review of the record confirms that Noval’s testimony was
consistent with the court’s findings. To the extent defendants
argue that the court erred in finding Jadelle Jewelry liable for
breach of contract based on Noval’s testimony, they have forfeited
that argument by failing to develop it. (Dietz, supra,
177 Cal.App.4th at p. 799.)
In short, Noval’s testimony is relevant to each of the trial
court’s findings that defendants challenge on appeal. But
defendants do not discuss, let alone cite, any of Noval’s testimony
in their appellate briefs. By failing to discuss that testimony,
defendants have forfeited any claim of error related to the court’s
findings that they challenge on appeal. (Roman Catholic
Archbishop, supra, 177 Cal.App.4th at p. 218.)
8
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Pay Up shall recover its costs on
appeal.
VIRAMONTES, J.
WE CONCUR:
STRATTON, P. J.
SCHERB, J.
9
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.