People v. Meeks CA4/1

CourtListener 10796315Calctapp19.02.2026

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 2/19/26 P. v. Meeks CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

THE PEOPLE, D084296

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. RIF2100469)
v.

CHRISTIAN SCOTT MEEKS,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Riverside County,
Valerie A. Navarro, Judge. Affirmed as modified.
Jennifer A. Gambale, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney
General, Arlene A. Sevidal, Andrew S. Mestman and Randall D. Einhorn,
Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
A jury convicted Christian Scott Meeks on various charges related to
human trafficking, pimping, pandering, assault, and dissuading a witness.
Meeks asserts there was insufficient evidence to support four of the nine
convictions; that his trial counsel provided ineffective assistance by failing to
object to certain testimony offered by an expert witness on the commercial
sex industry; and that the trial court erred during sentencing. We modify the
judgment to stay the punishment on two of the counts, pursuant to Penal

Code section 654,1 and otherwise affirm the judgment.
I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Between 2018 and 2021, Meeks recruited, or attempted to recruit,
several women, including one undercover police officer, to work for him as
commercial sex workers. In 2021, the People charged Meeks with:
Count 1—human trafficking, victim V.B. (§ 236.1, subd. (b));
Count 2—human trafficking, victim M.S. (§ 236.1, subd. (b));
Count 3—pimping, victim M.S. (§ 266h);
Count 4—pandering, victim M.S. (§ 266i);
Count 5—assault by means likely to produce great bodily
injury, victim M.S. (§ 245, subd. (a)(4));
Count 6—assault by means likely to produce great bodily
injury, victim J.L. (§ 245, subd. (a)(4));
Count 7—dissuading a witness, victim J.L. (§ 136.1, subd. (b));
Count 8— pandering, victim J.L. (§ 266i); and
Count 9—pandering, undercover officer (U.C.) (§ 266i).
A. Evidence Presented at Trial
The primary victim, M.S., did not testify at trial. The prosecution
presented its case through the testimony of several Riverside County Sheriff’s
Officers, including an investigator that testified as an expert witness,
deputies that contacted Meeks and M.S. at various times, a deputy that acted
as the U.C. officer identified in count 9, and two other alleged victims, V.B.
and J.L.

1 Further unspecified statutory references are to the Penal Code.

2
1. Expert Testimony About the Commercial Sex Industry
At the outset of the case, Riverside County Sheriff’s Investigator
Bridgette Recksiek provided some general information to the jury regarding

the commercial sex industry.2
Recksiek explained that “commercial sex work is basically workers who
advertise themselves for sex in exchange for anything of value or money,” and
that a “pimp” is a person that maintains control over commercial sex workers
for their own financial benefit. A given pimp may use one or more common
tactics to maintain such control. For example, a pimp may make women feel
like they are in a traditional relationship with him and then use that
relationship to manipulate or control them, while another may use more
direct and forceful physical or mental control. Some may use a combination
of tactics, or transition from one type of tactic to another as the relationship
progresses.
“The life” refers to the subculture of the commercial sex industry, in
which a pimp will generally set certain house rules that female sex workers
must follow in exchange for promises of protection and being taken care of.
The rules may include a quota, or amount that a female sex worker must
make each day, and additional rules regarding the female’s relationship with
the pimp and others, such as “do not speak unless spoken to” and “do not
make eye contact with a male that is not their pimp.” There may also be
punishment associated with breaking these rules.
Female sex workers often refer to their pimp as “Daddy.” The female
sex worker that has been working for a pimp for the longest, or that is most
trusted by the pimp, may be referred to as the “bottom girl.” The group of

2 Recksiek testified several times throughout the trial. We discuss
additional testimony, post, but focus here on the background she provided.

3
women working under a pimp is generally referred to as his “stable.” The
bottom girl may recruit and train other women in the stable, making sure
that they know the rules. The pimp may also recruit girls directly, either
online or in areas where they commonly work.
Female sex workers generally advertise online, either on websites or
using social media. They typically use acronyms or terms that do not directly
refer to sexual services but are generally known in the industry. The pimp
may assist with making these ads. Pimps often give the women in their
stable nicknames, which the women then use in the ads. They may also have
the women get a tattoo that correlates to their moniker, symbolizing their
relationship. Tattoos of crowns are commonly utilized to designate that a
particular female belongs to, or is controlled by, a pimp.
Pimps will move around, from one motel to another. They may share a
room with a female sex worker or may have multiple rooms. Typically, the
pimp will be nearby, readily accessible to protect their female workers. When
the woman goes on a “date,” the pimp will keep most or all the cash she
receives. The pimp may treat her by paying to get her hair or nails done and
will also typically provide food or a minimal amount of money meant for food.
This keeps the women dependent on the pimp.
Although a female sex worker could theoretically walk away in most
instances, many feel pressured to stay for security, or because of threats
against themselves or their family members. For these same reasons, female
sex workers are rarely willing to talk to police or testify against their pimps.
2. V.B.
V.B. met Meeks in 2018. V.B. was struggling with homelessness and
had recently lost custody of her two children. A friend told V.B. that she had
been making money by posting ads for sexual services, so V.B. decided to post
an ad herself. Around the end of November or early December, she began

4
speaking with an individual named “Rico,” whom she subsequently identified
as Meeks, on a social media application called Tagged. Meeks wanted V.B. to
work for him.
V.B. agreed to meet Meeks in person. She thought that Meeks could
help her make more money, but also wanted to get to know him as a person
before agreeing to any such arrangement.
A couple days before Christmas Eve, Meeks picked V.B. up at a house
in Lancaster where she was staying with relatives. His friend was driving,
and the friend’s girlfriend was also in the car. V.B. knew that Meeks was
from Moreno Valley, but she understood that they would just be hanging out
near Lancaster. After a while, V.B. realized that they were getting on the
freeway. She asked Meeks where they were going, and he said they were
going to Morena Valley to get a room. V.B. said she could not leave
Lancaster and had things she needed to take care of at home. Meeks said he
would take her home the next day.
The driver left Meeks and V.B. at a motel. They were alone in the
room. After about an hour, Meeks started talking to V.B. about “how the
game works,” meaning how to post ads, and how to respond to men that
responded to her ads. He suggested that she put more nudity in her
photographs. V.B. felt like she was stuck in the room. She tried to tell
Meeks that she wanted to leave and raised her voice to attract attention, but
he continued to talk about the ads. Meeks took additional pictures of V.B.
and posted an ad on a website for the Inland Empire area. V.B. tried to
delete the ad but Meeks would not let her.
V.B. received an inquiry on the ad. Meeks told her how to respond and
what to charge. Eventually, V.B. agreed to meet the man in the parking lot.
She did not want to do it and felt like she was being forced. When the man

5
arrived, she went out to the car and Meeks watched from inside the motel
room. V.B. had agreed to perform a sex act for $60 but she told the man that
she really did not want to and they just talked.
The man gave V.B. the agreed upon $60. Meeks took it as soon as V.B.
returned to the motel room. Meeks said he would save it until she made
more, and then he would help her buy more clothes and things. At that
point, V.B. got “really upset.” She asked for the money back and they started
to argue. At some point, V.B. left the motel room and they continued to argue
in the corridor just outside. V.B. said she was going to call the police and
Meeks said she “wasn’t going to do that.” He then took V.B.’s iPad, smashed
it against the railing of the stairs, and used it to hit V.B. in the face. Meeks
ran off and V.B. called 911. The People played a recording of the 911 call for
the jury.
3. J.L.
J.L. was living at a motel in Moreno Valley for about three months in
early 2020. Meeks and M.S. lived in the motel room next door to her. J.L.
knew Meeks as “Rico” or “Active.” J.L. believed that Meeks was physically
assaulting M.S. On one occasion, she heard screaming, someone being
slammed against the wall, and M.S. yelling for help. After, M.S. appeared in
the doorway with a black eye and asked J.L. to call the police. The police
came and talked to M.S.
J.L. was aware that there was prostitution going on in the room, in
part because M.S. asked J.L. to join her “plenty of other times.” M.S. referred
to Meeks as “Daddy,” a common term for a pimp. Meeks tried to give J.L.
flowers. She refused them and said that she had a boyfriend. J.L. believed
the gesture was an effort by Meeks to get her to work for him.
By March 22, 2020, J.L. had moved to another motel down the street.
J.L. walked across the street to the liquor store around noon, and

6
encountered Meeks and M.S. As she walked into the store, she got into “a
physical argument” with Meeks. Meeks said she was going to get her “ass
whooped” and that she “already [knew] what time it was.” J.L. finished her
shopping and walked out of the store with some items in her hands. Meeks
told her to drop her stuff. She took that to mean there was going to be a
fight, so she threw her items into the grass. Meeks called her a snitch and
other derogatory terms. J.L. said that she was pregnant and Meeks said that
he did not care.
M.S. and J.L. “squared up” in the grass, but Meeks was upset that M.S.
was not really fighting or hitting J.L. so he “jumped in, grabbed [J.L] by [her]
hair, and dragged [her] all the way to the door.” He started kicking J.L. and
“throwing [her] everywhere.” J.L. was eventually able to get away and run
across the street back to the motel. As she was leaving, Meeks said “that’s
what [you] get. That’s what [you] need.” J.L. was taken to the hospital and
had injuries including bruises and bite marks.
J.L. testified that she did not want to come to court to testify because
she was afraid of Meeks and everything that had happened. She was
wearing an ankle monitor and explained that it was so the People could track
her location leading up trial.
4. Undercover Deputy (U.C.)
U.C. had previously been assigned to the Riverside County Anti-
Human Trafficking Task Force. In January 2021, U.C. assisted the task
force by going undercover to contact Meeks on Snapchat, a social media
platform with direct messaging. U.C. spoke with Meeks on Snapchat, and at
some point, the conversation moved to direct text messages and conversations
over the phone. Meeks asked U.C. to video call with him but she made
excuses as to why she could not.

7
Meeks told U.C. that his name was Rico. When U.C. asked Meeks
what he did for a living, Meeks said that he “motivates, inspires people to get
it.” He also told her that “everyone needs a little guidance and unconditional
loyalty.” This was significant because this language was typical examples of
grooming used by pimps.
After talking for a while, U.C. told Meeks that she was thinking of
going back to stripping, and that her goal was to make money to get an
apartment and a car. Meeks told her that he wanted to meet in person to
“interview” her, which U.C. understood to mean that he wanted to find out
what she was willing to do. Meeks also said that he was “setting things up
for you as we speak.” U.C. said she was thinking of starting an OnlyFans
page, another social media platform where account holders often post
sexually explicit content for money, and Meeks told her that she was “on the
right track.”
When they spoke on the phone, Meeks talked to U.C. about “setting up
some dates,” which she took to mean prostitution. Meeks said “The sky is the
limit. It’s up to you and your work ethic.” Meeks did not ever offer U.C.
information about a stripping job, or any other legal form of employment.
When U.C. asked Meeks to be more specific about what they were going
to do, Meeks told her to call, and also asked her to prove that she was not a
cop by sending a video saying, “I’m not a cop” and showing her nipples.
Eventually, Meeks told U.C. that they needed to meet in person. He said, “It
seems like you want to talk about prices and money and cuts. I will not do
that here. I don’t trust it.” The conversation began to trail off at that point.
U.C. did not agree to meet Meeks in person and she believed he suspected
that she was an undercover police officer.

8
5. Police Contact with J.L., M.S. and Meeks
Deputy Ruiz made contact with J.L. at the motel in Moreno Valley on
January 23, 2020. J.L. expressed concerns that there was yelling as if
someone was getting beat up in the room next to hers.
Recksiek, Ruiz and Deputy Sheriff Rodriquez returned the next day.
Meeks exited the room that he and M.S. had been staying in as Rodriquez
approached. Meeks was sweaty and nervous, and his voice was shaking. The
door was open and Rodriquez could see M.S. inside. M.S. was emotional and
crying. There was bruising on her face near her eye and the eye itself was
red due to broken blood vessels. M.S. had a crown tattoo on her face near the
eye, which is indicative of prostitution subculture, and specifically of a
woman working for a man, or pimp. Rodriguez conducted a sweep of the
room and found a spiral notebook, assorted condoms, and a large can of
pepper spray. Both Recksiek and Rodriguez testified that those items were
consistent with prostitution occurring in the room.
Recksiek retrieved video surveillance from the motel. She noted that it
showed Meeks coming and going, at times with M.S. In one video, shown to
the jury, a car arrives, M.S. exits, goes around the car and opens the door for
Meeks, and then quickly walks away. She does not make eye contact with
any of the other men that are present. Recksiek testified M.S.’s behavior
suggested that she had been taught the rules, including how she was
supposed to show respect for Meeks.
Ruiz also spoke with J.L. in March 2020, after the incident outside the
liquor store. He took photographs of J.L.’s injuries and the People submitted
those photos to the jury.
6. Deputy Daniel Engels
Deputy Engels was part of the anti-human trafficking task force in
early 2020. He testified, consistent with Recksiek’s testimony, about some of

9
the general concepts and terminology. He discussed “the life” and the
dynamics between female sex workers, pimps, and “Johns,” or customers. He
also explained that female sex workers are often vulnerable in many ways.
They may be young, previously victimized, and lacking in love or support and
a stable family or homelife. Many have had experience with foster or group
homes.
Engels also discussed the different kinds of tactics used by pimps to
control women, as well as the “house rules” system. He noted that a female
sex worker may be physically assaulted if they break their pimp’s rules. He
explained that most women start in “the life” at a very young age, and are
vulnerable, making them easily swayed or exploited. Because they start so
young, they often don’t know anything else, which can make it difficult for
them to leave or get out of the lifestyle. The pimps generally keep most or all
of the money, making it difficult for the women to have the resources to leave.
The women may also fear physical violence or retaliation.
Engels made contact with M.S. at the motel on January 24, 2020. M.S.
was 19 years old at the time. Engels conducted a search and found several
ads for sexual services depicting M.S. and using the name Ruby Diamond.
In December 2020, Engels attempted to contact M.S. in an undercover
capacity, posing as a potential client while calling the phone number on one
of her ads. He arranged to meet M.S. for a car date. Before meeting, M.S.
asked for a picture of his face, his penis, and the $120 agreed upon for the
date. Engel sent the requested photos (not of himself) and M.S. provided an
address. Another deputy drove to the location and when M.S. came to the
vehicle, police detained her and obtained a download of her phone. The
People provided the jury with a transcript of the text messages and Engels
walked through the exchange, explaining what occurred.

10
Engels also assisted with a traffic stop involving Meeks on February 3,

2021.3 During the stop, deputies confiscated a phone from Meeks and
likewise obtained a download of data. The phone rang when Deputy Engels
called a number used by U.C. to contact Meeks.
7. Cellular Phones and Notebook Obtained From M.S. and
Meeks
Recksiek also testified about evidence obtained from M.S. and Meeks,
including data from their cellular phones and the notebook found in the motel
room.
The phone taken from M.S. was associated with the e-mail account
Redroseinc@gmail.com. This was significant because Red Rose
Entertainment was a label that Meeks used for the women working for him.
The police were able to capture data from the iCloud backup on the phone.
There were several pictures of M.S. and Meeks at various motels in the
region. One of the photos included an emoticon of a king wearing a crown
and the words, “what a life.” Recksiek testified that crowns are often a sign
of power and are also used to signify that someone is a pimp. There was
another photo of Meeks holding fanned out money in his hand.
There were also various ads offering sexual services from M.S. in the
iCloud account. Recksiek explained one of the ads, noting that there was an
emoticon of a car and a car plate that read $80. It also had wording,
including “serious inquires only, gentlemen,” that was suggestive of offering
sexual services to men. The words “QV for a hundred” appeared at the
bottom, and Recksiek testified that this meant “quick visit,” or about 15
minutes. There was at least one photo of M.S. performing a sexual act with a

3 Engels testified this stop occurred in February 2020, but elsewhere in
the record, it appears the stop occurred in 2021.

11
male. There was also a photo of M.S. from around January 20, 2020, in
which her face and lip appeared swollen. There was also a search from that
same day for “how to get rid of a bleeding eye.”
The phone taken from Meeks was associated with the e-mail account
Activeonshit@gmail.com. The search history on the phone revealed visits to
various websites known for posting advertisements for commercial sex. One
had a saved account belonging to “Rico Sevanni.” Another had an account
under the username Rubydiamond2000. Ruby was a nickname for M.S. The
password for the account was “304pgoforever.” Recksiek testified that 304
was a reference to “hoe” (based on the word spelled when the numbers are
upside down on, for example, a pager) and “pgo” was an acronym for “pimping
going on.”
Several of the pages included ads for M.S. There was also a history of
message exchanges indicating M.S. was meeting with men for sexual
services, and notifications from Cash App where Meeks received payments in
amounts often associated with sex work. Finally, the location of the phone
over time matched up with the ads and was consistent with Meeks and M.S.

traveling the prostitution circuit together.4
In another exchange, Meeks wrote “I need a fee to incorporate you to
where it’s really at. I have the proper guidance, knowledge, and energy to
give you to make sure you have the motivation you need.” Recksiek
explained that, in her experience, this was Meeks “trying to get someone to
come conduct commercial sex work for him.” Meeks went on to state, “I gotta

4 Recksiek explained that the “circuit” is a group of cities that prostitutes
frequently travel to for work. It includes the Inland Empire, Orange County,
San Diego, Los Angeles, and then it extends up through Northern California,
oftentimes into Las Vegas and Arizona.

12
have the real, the loyalty, the trust,” and Recksiek explained that pimps often
use such language in recruiting because they want their sex workers to be
loyal only to them.
Recksiek also discussed the notebook found in the motel room Meeks
and M.S. had been staying in on January 24, 2020. The third page had a list
of goals: “Get 2 phones. Bank account. Car. Prescription. Glasses. Make
my way to O.C. Courthouse to pay on ticket, or call and arrange payment
plans, if possible, by the 19th. Pay wheels [or weelo] $500. Pay Brawn.” The
next page said “Ruby,” for M.C., and had a list of adult websites and
passwords. Page 12 had a similar list. It also said, “Five a day keeps the
haters away.” Recksiek explained that this appeared to be a quota indicating
five clients a day to make money. Page 14 said “Daddy loves Maia forever,”
and was signed, “Christian Meeks, Daddy.”
Page 19 was titled “R.R. House Rules,” and Recksiek testified R.R.
likely stood for Red Rose Entertainment. The rules listed included, “Respect
my game.” “Speak only when spoken to, aka, find time to express your
mind.” “Always be ready to put it in my hand only with smiles on demand.”
“Work with hard work and dedication, aka, no bitching and complaining.”
Recksiek testified that the third rule meant the girls should be willing to give
Meeks their money, and should do so with a smile. Recksiek also testified
that she had looked at other examples of Meeks’s handwriting and most of
the writing in the notebook appeared to be consistent with those examples.
Finally, in January 2021, Recksiek texted a phone number associated
with Meeks. She said her name was Shawna and that she was looking for
Rico. The two had a conversation over text and the People provided the
transcript to the jury.

13
B. Defense Case
Meeks did not testify or present any witnesses in support of his
defense. In closing argument, his counsel asserted the prosecution had not
met their burden to prove the charged offenses.
C. Verdict and Sentencing
The jury found Meeks guilty of the counts 1 through 7 and count 9.
They found Meeks not guilty on count 8 as charged, but guilty of a lesser
included offense of attempted pandering, as to J.L. The trial court sentenced
Meeks to a total aggregate term of 56 years, 8 months in prison.
Meeks filed a timely notice of appeal.
II. DISCUSSION
Meeks assert the judgment of conviction must be reversed because
there was insufficient evidence to support the convictions on counts 2, 5, 7,
and 8, and because his trial counsel provided ineffective assistance by failing
to object when Recksiek exceeded the scope of permissible opinion testimony.
In addition, he asserts the trial court erred in sentencing him on count 7 and
that the trial court should have stayed the sentences for counts 3 and 4
pursuant to section 654.
A. Substantial Evidence Supports Each of the Convictions
We begin with Meeks’s assertion that there is insufficient evidence to
support the convictions on counts 2, 5, 7, and 8.
“It is the prosecution’s burden in a criminal case to prove every element
of a crime beyond a reasonable doubt.” (People v. Cuevas (1995) 12 Cal.4th
252, 260.) “To determine whether the prosecution has introduced sufficient
evidence to meet this burden, courts apply the ‘substantial evidence’ test.”
(Ibid.)
“The standard is deferential: ‘When a trial court’s factual
determination is attacked on the ground that there is no substantial evidence

14
to sustain it, the power of an appellate court begins and ends with the
determination as to whether, on the entire record, there is substantial
evidence, contradicted or uncontradicted, which will support the
determination.’ ” (People v. Superior Court (Jones) (1998) 18 Cal.4th 667,
681.) “ ‘We do not reweigh evidence or reevaluate a witness’s credibility.’ ”
(People v. Houston (2012) 54 Cal.4th 1186, 1215 (Houston).) Instead, we
“presume in support of the judgment every fact the trier of fact reasonably
could infer from the evidence.” (People v. Guyton (2018) 20 Cal.App.5th 499,
506 (Guyton).)
1. Count 2
To prove human trafficking as alleged in count 2, the People had to
show that Meeks “deprive[d] or violate[d] the personal liberty of another with
the intent to effect or maintain a violation of” one of several enumerated
statutes associated with commercial sex work. (§ 236.1, subd. (b).)
“ ‘ “Deprivation or violation of the personal liberty of another” includes
substantial and sustained restriction of another’s liberty accomplished
through force, fear, fraud, deceit, coercion, violence, duress, menace, or threat
of unlawful injury to the victim or to another person, under circumstances
where the person receiving or apprehending the threat reasonably believes
that it is likely that the person making the threat would carry it out.’ ”
(People v. Oliver (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 1084, 1095 (Oliver).)
“When determining whether the victim’s liberty was deprived or
violated, and when determining whether a defendant used duress or coercion,
the jury must consider ‘[t]he total circumstances’ including a list of
nonexhaustive ‘factors’ such as the victim’s age, the relationship between the
victim and his or her trafficker or the trafficker’s agents, and any handicap or
disability of the victim.” (Oliver, supra, 54 Cal.App.5th at p. 1095, fn. 7.)
This “nonexhaustive definition of deprivation or violation of personal liberty

15
leaves open the possibility that a victim may agree to have his or her freedom
of movement limited by a pimp, for example, to help facilitate and share in
the profits of a prostitution ring.” (Id. at p. 1097.) “[C]onsent is not an
element of the offense of human trafficking in violation of section 236.1(b),
and [lack of consent] is not an affirmative defense.” (Ibid.)
Meeks asserts there was insufficient evidence that he violated the
personal liberty of M.S. He argues there was no evidence of how M.S. and
Meeks met, the extent of their relationship, or that M.S. did not decide to join
him in the motel room to prostitute herself willingly and without force or
coercion. To the contrary, there was ample evidence of how Meeks operated,
including how he attempted to recruit V.B., J.L., and U.C., and, specifically—
how he used violence to intimidate both V.B. and J.L. In addition, J.L.
testified that M.S. called Meeks “Daddy” and tried to recruit her. From this
evidence, the jury could conclude that Meeks followed the same pattern with
M.S. as he did with the other female victims. If the jury found, as it did, that
Meeks committed the other charged offenses, it could conclude from that
evidence that Meeks was predisposed or inclined to commit the other charged
offenses, including the trafficking of M.S. (See People v. Villatoro (2012)
54 Cal.4th 1152, 1166–1168.)
Moreover, there was also evidence that Meeks used physical force and
other forms of coercion or control against M.S. When police arrived at the
motel after J.L. reported the violent incident, M.S. was emotional and crying
and had visible bruising on her face. During that same visit, the police
recovered a notebook that contained lists of websites and accounts where
M.S. was advertising prostitution and a list of “house rules.” Rules like
“speak only when spoken to” and that the women give any money they earn
to Meeks, were indicative of control, coercion, and duress. There was also

16
evidence that the rules did govern the relationship between Meeks and M.S.,
including evidence that Meeks received payments to his Cash App based on
commercial sex work performed by M.S., and M.S. opening the car door for
Meeks while being careful not to make eye contact with any of the other men.
When considered in totality, all this evidence supports an inference that
Meeks was restricting M.S.’s liberty through coercion, control, and/or
violence.
Meeks relies on Guyton—in which the court found there was sufficient
evidence of human trafficking—to assert the People did not present similar
evidence in this case that M.S. was afraid to leave, or that she was living in a
restricted environment that kept her dependent on Meeks. (See Guyton,
supra, 20 Cal.App.5th at p. 507 [court discussing “[t]he various restrictions
defendant placed on [the victim], such as isolating her, constantly monitoring
her, requiring her to stay in contact with him by phone, checking her phone,
requiring her to work so much she was exhausted, falsely promising he had
purchased a car for her and depriving her of the financial means to live”].)
But the People did not need to provide the same type of evidence here as was
provided in Guyton. Rather, the jury was to consider the totality of
circumstances, including, among other things, M.S.’s age (19), her
relationship with Meeks, and all the other evidence indicating Meeks’s
pattern of pimping through coercion and/or violence. (See Oliver, supra,
54 Cal.App.5th at pp. 1095–1097.)
Based on the foregoing we conclude there was sufficient evidence to
support the conviction in count 2 for human trafficking of M.S. in violation of
section 236.1, subdivision (b).
2. Count 5
To prove assault by means likely to produce great bodily injury as
alleged in count 5, the People had to show that Meeks “did an act that by its

17
nature would directly and probably result in the application of force to a
person” and that the “force used was likely to produce great bodily injury.”
(CALCRIM No. 875; § 245, subd. (a)(4).)
“ ‘The force likely to produce bodily injury can be found where the
attack is made by use of hands or fists. [Citation.] Whether a fist used in
striking a person would be likely to cause great bodily injury is to be
determined by the force of the impact, the manner in which it was used and
the circumstances under which the force was applied.’ [Citation.] A solitary
punch may violate section 245, subdivision (a)(4).” (People v. Medellin (2020)
45 Cal.App.5th 519, 528.)
J.L. testified that she called the police in January 2020 because M.S.
asked her to after J.L. heard M.S. yelling for help and then saw M.S. in the
doorway with a black eye. When police made contact with M.S. the next day,
she was emotional and crying and had injuries to her eye and face.
Meeks asserts that there was insufficient evidence to support the
conviction on count 5 because no one saw the assault and M.S. did not tell the
police or the jury what happened. Thus, he argues, there was no evidence
that he did any act or applied any force to cause M.S.’s bruised and bloody
eye. Although M.S. did not testify directly, and the officer did not testify as
to what she told him that day, J.L.’s testimony was circumstantial evidence
of an altercation between Meeks and M.S., there was no evidence anyone
other than Meeks and M.S. were present or involved, and there was no
suggestion that M.S.’s injuries occurred because of an accident. Rather,
M.S.’s request that J.L. call the police, and her emotional state when the
police arrived, provided additional circumstantial evidence from which the
jury could easily infer that Meeks applied force to M.S. by some mechanism

18
likely to produce great bodily injury, namely the bruise to her face and the
rupture of blood vessels in her eye.
Meeks does not provide, nor are we aware of, any authority suggesting
circumstantial evidence is not relevant or sufficient to prove assault by
means likely to produce great bodily injury. (Cf. People v. Kelly (2007)
42 Cal.4th 763, 788 [“same standard of review applies [for claims based on
the sufficiency of the evidence] when the evidence of guilt is circumstantial”].)
Accordingly, we conclude there was substantial evidence to support the
conviction on count 5.
3. Count 7
Count 7 alleged that Meeks violated section 136.1, subdivision (b) by
trying to dissuade J.L. from testifying.
Section 136.1, subdivision (b) provides:
“Except as provided in subdivision (c) [aggravated
dissuading], a person who attempts to prevent or dissuade
another person who has been the victim of a crime or who
is witness to a crime from doing any of the following is
guilty of a public offense and shall be punished by
imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year or
in the state prison:
(1) Making a report of that victimization to a peace officer,
a state or local law enforcement officer, a probation,
parole, or correctional officer, a prosecuting agency, or
a judge.
(2) Causing a complaint, indictment, information, or
probation or parole violation to be sought and
prosecuted, or assisting in the prosecution thereof.
(3) Arresting or causing or seeking the arrest of a person
in connection with that victimization.”
To prove that Meeks violated section 136.1, subdivision (b), the People
had to prove that Meeks (1) attempted to prevent or dissuade J.L., (2) who

19
was a victim or witness to a crime, (3) from making any report of the crime to
any peace officer or other designated officials. (See People v. Sherman (2022)
86 Cal.App.5th 402, 411.)
J.L. testified that, in March 2020, Meeks called her a snitch, assaulted
her while she was pregnant, and stated said “that’s what [you] get. That’s
what [you] need,” as he was leaving.
Meeks does not dispute that the assault occurred but asserts there was
insufficient evidence to support the conviction on this charge because it
happened two months after J.L. called the police to report the assault of M.S.
But the People did not argue that Meeks was trying to dissuade J.L. from
reporting the assault of M.S. J.L. lived next door to Meeks and M.S. for
months and also had information regarding the commercial sex work that
was occurring in and around the room. There was no indication in the record
that J.L. had spoken to the police about the prostitution, or that Meeks had
reason to believe that she had. As Meeks points out, the prosecutor asserted
J.L. “had additional information about what [Meeks] was doing next door”
and that Meeks’s intent was to “silence her further.” In other words, the
prosecution’s theory was that Meeks was trying to dissuade J.L. from talking
to the police about additional crimes, such as the subsequently charged
offenses of pimping, pandering, and human trafficking.
Meeks implicitly concedes that, at a minimum, the assault was in
retaliation for her calling the police regarding his prior assault of M.S. We
acknowledge that retaliation after a report is not the same as assault for the
purpose of dissuading a future report in all instances, but here, the evidence
established that J.L. had additional information about additional crimes that
she had not yet reported. Indeed, J.L. testified that she did not want to come
to court because she was afraid of Meeks and everything that had happened.

20
There is no dispute here that Meeks assaulted J.L. while his pimping
activities were ongoing, and before she reported any additional information
relevant to the present charges. (See, e.g., People v. Sherman (2022)
86 Cal.App.5th 402, 414 [“it will often be reasonable for a jury to conclude
that, by preventing a victim from contacting the police to seek help during an
ongoing crime, the defendant prevented the victim from reporting her
victimization”].)
There was substantial evidence from which the jury could infer that
Meeks was attempting to dissuade J.L. from reporting these additional
crimes, and thus, to support the conviction on count 7.
4. Count 8
As to count 8, the jury found Meeks guilty of the lesser included offense
of attempt to pander J.L. in violation of section 266i.
Section 266i, subdivision (a) states, in relevant part: “any person who
does any of the following is guilty of pandering, a felony, and shall be
punishable by imprisonment in the state prison for three, four, or six years:
(1) Procures another person for the purpose of prostitution. [¶] (2) By
promises, threats, violence, or by any device or scheme, causes, induces,
persuades, or encourages another person to become a prostitute.”
“Pandering is ‘the business of recruiting a prostitute, finding a place of
business for a prostitute, or soliciting customers for a prostitute.’ ” (People
v. Campbell (2020) 51 Cal.App.5th 463, 484.) Section 266i encompasses a
broad range of conduct, and the intent of the Legislature was “ ‘to deter
pimps or others from establishing new working relationships in the unlawful
prostitution trade.’ ” (Campbell, at p. 485.) “The crime of pandering does not
require that actual acts of prostitution take place.” (Id. at p. 488.)
Here, the trial court instructed the jury that Meeks was guilty of the
lesser included offense of attempted pandering if he “took a direct but

21
ineffective step toward committing pandering,” with the intent to commit
pandering. (See CALCRIM No. 460.) Meeks does not dispute the adequacy of
this instruction. Rather, he asserts that the evidence established only that
M.S. asked J.L. to join her in prostitution, and there was no evidence
establishing M.S. did so at Meeks’s request, or that Meeks himself took any
steps towards pandering J.L.
To the contrary, it was reasonable for the jury to infer that M.S. was
attempting to recruit J.L. for Meeks. J.L. said that she knew what was going
on in the motel room and was therefore at least somewhat familiar with the
commercial sex industry. She testified that Meeks would send M.S. her way
and that she believed Meeks was trying to get her to prostitute for him. The
People also provided expert testimony establishing that it was common for a
“bottom girl” to recruit other women on behalf of their pimp. And there was
additional evidence that Meeks sought to involve M.S. in the recruitment of
another potential victim, U.C.
Finally, J.L. testified that Meeks tried to give her flowers on one
occasion, which the jury could have interpreted as an act of grooming. To the
extent Meeks asserts these actions could have been interpreted differently,
he was free to argue that to the jury. We do not reweigh the evidence on
appeal. (Houston, supra, 54 Cal.4th at p. 1215.)
For these reasons, we conclude there was sufficient evidence to support
the conviction for attempted pandering in count 8.
B. Ineffective Assistance of Counsel: Expert Testimony
Meeks contends that Recksiek improperly offered her expert opinion on
the meaning of certain text messages, which the jury could have interpreted
on its own; that certain conversations were consistent with pimping and
pandering; and that certain text messages established that Meeks was a
pimp. He acknowledges that his trial counsel did not object to any of this

22
testimony but asserts, to the extent this court concludes the arguments are
therefore forfeited, that his trial counsel provided ineffective assistance of
counsel.
1. Forfeiture
As an initial matter, we agree that Meeks has forfeited these claims by
failing to object in a timely matter in the trial court. (See, e.g., People v.
Waidla (2000) 22 Cal.4th 690, 717 [“ ‘It is, of course, “the general rule” ’—
which we find applicable here—‘ “that questions relating to the admissibility
of evidence will not be reviewed on appeal in the absence of a specific and
timely objection in the trial court on the ground sought to be urged on
appeal.” ’ ”].) “A general objection to the admission or exclusion of evidence,
or one based on a different ground from that advanced at trial, does not
preserve the claim for appeal.” (People v. Marks (2003) 31 Cal.4th 197, 228;
see also Evid. Code § 353.) Here, the trial court made a ruling as to the scope
of Recksiek’s testimony in pretrial proceedings, but trial counsel still had to
object to any specific testimony he believed exceeded the permissible scope in
order to preserve the argument for appeal. In the absence of any such
objection, Meeks has forfeited the claim and must proceed, instead, on the
alternate theory of ineffective assistance of counsel.
2. Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
To prove ineffective assistance of counsel, Meeks must show his
attorney performed below the standard of reasonableness under prevailing
professional norms and that there is a reasonable probability the result
would have been more favorable to him but for that substandard
performance. (Strickland v. Washington (1984) 466 U.S. 668, 686–688;
People v. Mayfield (1993) 5 Cal.4th 142, 199.)
“Ineffective assistance of counsel claims are rarely cognizable on
appeal,” as we give deference to trial counsel’s tactical choices and the record

23
rarely provides information regarding trial counsel’s strategy. (People
v. Silvey (1997) 58 Cal.App.4th 1320, 1329; Strickland, supra, 466 U.S. at
pp. 690–691; People v. Wilson (1992) 3 Cal.4th 926, 936.) Where the record is
silent as to counsel’s motivation, the court must reject an ineffective
assistance of counsel claim “unless counsel was asked for and failed to
provide a satisfactory explanation, or there simply can be no satisfactory
explanation.” (People v. Scott (1997) 15 Cal.4th 1188, 1212.)
Meeks asserts Recksiek’s testimony exceeded the permissible scope of
expert testimony, and that there could be no tactical reason for his counsel’s
failure to object to that testimony. We disagree.
Expert witness testimony in the form of an opinion is admissible if it is
“[r]elated to a subject that is sufficiently beyond common experience that the
opinion of an expert would assist the trier of fact.” (Evid. Code § 801, subd.
(a).) “Like other evidence, expert testimony must be relevant and competent
on a material issue, subject to exclusion, however, if unduly prejudicial.”
(People v. Bowker (1988) 203 Cal.App.3d 385, 390.) Expert witnesses may not
express an opinion as to the defendant’s guilt, primarily because the jury, as
the trier fact, is equally competent to weight the evidence and draw a
conclusion as to the charged offenses. (People v. Torres (1995) 33 Cal.App.4th
37, 46–48.) However, “ ‘[t]here is no hard and fast rule that the expert cannot
be asked a question that coincides with the ultimate issue in the case.’ ”
(People v. Valdez (1997) 58 Cal.App.4th 494, 507.) The issue ultimately
comes down to whether the expert’s testimony presents matters beyond the
common experience of the jury. (Ibid.)
Meeks acknowledges that it was appropriate for Recksiek to testify
about the culture of pimping, prostitution, and human trafficking, but asserts
that she was prohibited from offering additional opinions about the meaning

24
of certain text messages, the nature of his relationship with M.S., and that he
was actually pimping, pandering, and/or involved in human trafficking. But
Meeks does not point to any testimony in which Recksiek directly stated that
he was guilty of any crime.
Rather, Meeks points, in many instances, to testimony in which
Recksiek provided her expert opinion on the meaning of certain language and

behaviors.5 For example, in one instance, the prosecutor presented Recksiek
with a transcript of text messages involving M.S. After reviewing some of the
terminology used therein, the prosecutor asked Recksiek “what does this
conversation mean to you?” Recksiek responded by explaining it appeared to
be M.S. agreeing to an “outcall.” In another instance, Recksiek explained
terms like “work ready” and “tap in” meant the female sex worker was ready
to conduct commercial sex work. These were terms, or practices, members of
the jury were not likely to be familiar with.
In a few instances, Recksiek’s testimony did come closer to the ultimate
issues in the case. For example, Recksiek testified that a certain
conversation showed that Meeks “is preparing [M.S.] for commercial sex
work,” and that Meeks “appears to be trying to get someone to work with him
and prostitute for him.” In another instance, Recksiek testified that M.S.’s
behavior suggested “she was obviously told how to respect him, how to treat
him, and it’s his way of being in charge.” Again, though, these opinions were
based on Recksiek’s expertise in human trafficking, including her knowledge

5 Meeks sets forth a great deal of specific testimony in the background
portion of his brief and then makes general arguments concerning that
testimony in the legal section. We have considered the totality of Recksiek’s
testimony in our analysis herein but note that, for the most part, Meeks does
not make specific arguments about specific testimony.

25
of commonly used language, patterns, and prices for commercial sex services.
With this specialized knowledge, Recksiek was able to draw conclusions
about specific conversations or behaviors that a lay juror may not be as
familiar with. Such testimony may have been helpful to the jury, and
generally did not go so far as to suggest that Recksiek believed Meeks was
guilty of any specific offense.
In any event, the jury was able to read the text messages and view the
video footage themselves and were able to determine whether they agreed
with Recksiek. To the extent they believed they could understand what was
happening, or being discussed, without needing to rely on the explanations
offered by Recksiek, they were free to reach their own conclusions. Along
those same lines, the trial court instructed the jury with CALCRIM No. 322,
telling them that it was up to them to determine the meaning and importance
of any expert testimony, just like they would with any other witness. (See
People v. Leonard (2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 465, 493–494 [finding any error in
admitting expert testimony regarding type of pimp defendant was to be
harmless given a similar instruction].)
For these same reasons, it would have been a reasonable tactical
decision for Meeks’s trial counsel to withhold an objection. A decision on any
such objection would be left to the sound discretion of the trial court and
counsel reasonably could have believed that making an objection would look
obstructive or serve only to draw further attention to Recksiek’s testimony.
(See, e.g., People v. Huggins (2006) 38 Cal.4th 175, 206 [no ineffective
assistance of counsel where counsel’s failure to object could have been a
tactical decision not to draw attention]; People v. Prince (2007) 40 Cal.4th
1179, 1223 [courts permit a broad range of expert testimony in criminal

26
matters, notwithstanding the jury’s ability to examine “other evidence to
form their own commonsense conclusions”].)
In sum, we conclude Meeks has not established that his trial counsel
provided ineffective assistance by failing to object to any specific testimony
provided by Recksiek.
C. Sentencing
Meeks raises two independent arguments regarding sentencing. First,
he asserts the trial court erred by imposing a full consecutive term on count
7. Second, he asserts the matter must be remanded for resentencing because
the trial court should have stayed the sentences on counts 3 and 4 under
section 654. The People assert that the jury also made a true finding on an
allegation related to count 7 and, based on that allegation, the trial court did
not err. They concede the sentences on counts 3 and 4 should be stayed but
assert that this court can modify the judgment without the need for a full
resentencing. Meeks does not respond to these arguments in his reply brief.
1. The Trial Court Did Not Err in Sentencing Meeks on
Count 7
In the first amended information, count 7 alleged that Meeks violated
Penal Code section 136.1, subdivision (b) by dissuading J.L., but also alleged
that he committed that offense “knowingly and maliciously by means of force
and by an express or implied threat of force and violence . . . within the
meaning of [section] 136.1, subdivision (c)(1).” As noted in the amended
information, the latter carries a sentencing triad of 2, 3, or 4 years in prison.
(§ 136.1, subd. (c)(1).) The jury found Meeks guilty on count 7 and found the
additional allegation true.
In addition, Section 1170.15 provides that for a person convicted “of an
additional felony that is a violation of Section 136.1 or 137 and that was
committed against the victim of, or a witness or potential witness with

27
respect to, or a person who was about to give material information pertaining
to, the first felony . . . the subordinate term for each consecutive offense that
is a felony described in this section shall consist of the full middle term of
imprisonment for the felony for which a consecutive term of imprisonment is
imposed.”
At sentencing, the trial court explained, “Count 7, pursuant to Penal
Code section 1170.15, the subordinate term for each consecutive offense
consists of the full middle term of imprisonment, in this case three years,
which is doubled due to the strike prior for a total of six years to run
consecutive to Count 1.”
We find no error in the trial court’s sentencing on count 7.
2. The Sentences for Counts 3 and 4 Are Stayed
Section 654 subdivision (a) states: “An act or omission that is
punishable in different ways by different provisions of law may be punished
under either of such provisions, but in no case shall the act or omission be
punished under more than one provision.”
As our Supreme Court has explained: “Section 654 does not preclude
multiple convictions but only multiple punishments for a single act or
indivisible course of conduct. [Citation.] ‘The proscription against double
punishment . . . is applicable where there is a course of conduct which
violates more than one statute and comprises an indivisible transaction
punishable under more than one statute . . . . The divisibility of a course of
conduct depends upon the intent and objective of the actor.’ ” (People
v. Miller (1977) 18 Cal.3d 873, 885). “ ‘[I]f all the offenses are incident to one
objective, [then] the defendant may be punished for any one of them but not
for more than one.’ ” (Ibid.)
Here, Meeks was convicted in counts 2, 3, and 4 of human trafficking,
pimping, and pandering, each related to M.S. and each during the same

28
period from April 2019 to August 2020. The People concede, and we agree,
that, given the specific factual scenario presented here, including that all
three offenses were charged for the same period and that none relied on one
specific act, the pimping offense was incidental to the pandering offense, and
the intent to pander was an essential element of the human trafficking
charge. (See, e.g., People v. Deloach (1989) 207 Cal.App.3d 323, 337 [“as a
general rule, any acts of prostitution that follow directly or proximately from
the pandering are incident to a single objective and therefore constitute an
indivisible transaction with it; that is, the subsequent sex offenses are
incidental to the commission of the pandering, and are facilitated by it”];
People v. Dearborne (2019) 34 Cal.App.5th 250, 263 [“As charged under the
facts of this case, the human trafficking and [pandering] were part of the
same criminal ‘intent and objective’ [citation], and thus the court was
required to stay the sentence on the [pandering] count. The human
trafficking charge literally has an element of an intent to [pander].”].)
Accordingly, the trial court should have stayed the sentences on counts
3 and 4 pursuant to section 654. Meeks asks us to remand the matter for
resentencing based on this error, but we agree with the People that
resentencing is not necessary. Rather, we exercise our authority to modify
the judgment to reflect that the punishments on counts 3 and 4 are stayed
pursuant to section 654. (§ 1260 [appellate court may reverse, affirm, or
modify judgment]; People v. Alford (2010) 180 Cal.App.4th 1463, 1473, [court
may exercise its authority to modify a judgment based on an unauthorized
sentence under section 1260 in the context of section 654].)
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is modified to reflect that the punishments on counts 3
and 4 are stayed pursuant to section 654. The matter is remanded to the

29
trial court with directions to prepare an amended abstract of judgment and
forward to the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. In all other
respects, the judgment is affirmed.

KELETY, J.

WE CONCUR:

MCCONNELL, P. J.

CASTILLO, J.

30

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.