CourtListener 10795195•In re K.L. CA3
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 2/17/26 In re K.L. CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Shasta)
----
In re K.L., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile Court C103216
Law.
SHASTA COUNTY HEALTH AND HUMAN (Super. Ct. No. 22JV3228901)
SERVICES AGENCY,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
J.M.,
Defendant and Appellant.
Appellant J.M., mother of the minor K.L., appeals from the juvenile court’s orders
denying her petition for modification, terminating parental rights, and freeing the minor
for adoption. (Welf. & Inst. Code, §§ 366.26, 388, 395.)1 Mother claims the juvenile
court abused its discretion when it denied her petition for modification and erred by
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
1
finding the beneficial parental relationship exception to adoption did not apply. We will
affirm the juvenile court’s orders.
BACKGROUND
Original Petition
The minor (then two years old) was initially removed from the custody of mother
and father B.L. (father) in May 2022 due to the parents’ alcohol abuse and acts of
domestic violence in the minor’s presence. The Shasta County Health and Human
Services Agency (Agency) filed a dependency petition pursuant to section 300,
subdivisions (b) and (g), describing a particular incident during which mother was
intoxicated while driving and father was reaching into the car attempting to turn off the
ignition. Mother dragged father approximately 50 feet while he was holding the minor in
his arms until father, fearing he would drop her, threw the minor into the car. Mother was
arrested. However, the following day, she declined to drug test and claimed not to know
the minor’s whereabouts. Law enforcement officers eventually found the minor with the
maternal grandmother, who was hiding with the child in the bathroom. The petition also
alleged father was briefly incarcerated at the county jail after becoming heavily
intoxicated, purposely crashing his car in an attempt to kill himself and then shooting at
responding officers. The juvenile court ordered the minor detained.
The combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing took place over many months.
During that time, the juvenile court allowed for liberal overnight visitation and the minor
spent the majority of her time in the parents’ home. The court eventually took
jurisdiction over the minor in January 2024—over a year and a half after the minor’s
detention. Later that month, the court ordered the minor returned to the parents’ custody
with family maintenance services, including a 52-week batterer’s program.
Supplemental Petition (Section 387)
On March 4, 2024, the Agency filed a supplemental petition pursuant to section
387 alleging the parents had regressed in their behaviors in that they were unwilling to
2
maintain physical boundaries, amicable co-parenting, or a domestic violence-free
environment for the minor. The supplemental petition alleged mother stole father’s house
key without permission, “trashed” his apartment, strung his belongings throughout the
home, cut his router cables after father spoke with mother’s boyfriend, loaned a vehicle to
father and then reported it stolen, and refused to turn the minor over to father at an
agreed-upon time. Father slashed mother’s tires because she refused to reconcile with
him even though she allowed him to sleep on her couch while he waited for a new
apartment.
The parents continued to demonstrate the same behaviors leading to the minor’s
initial detention and the domestic violence continued to escalate despite the array of
services offered, placing the minor at risk of emotional and physical harm. Mother was
evading the social worker, limiting the Agency’s ability to adequately assess the minor’s
safety and causing concern that mother would hide the minor from the Agency and law
enforcement. The Agency recommended the minor be removed from parental custody.
On March 5, 2024, the juvenile court ordered the minor detained with supervised
visitation and reunification services for the parents, including the 52-week batterer’s
program previously ordered along with random drug testing, individual counseling, and
psychological evaluations for both parents. The minor was placed with the paternal
grandparents.
Section 387 Jurisdiction and Disposition Report
In its section 387 jurisdiction and disposition report, the Agency reported that
mother tested negative for all substances on March 5, 2024, and completed the
recommended classes and an alcohol and other drug assessment. Mother stopped seeing
her therapist and informed the social worker she would not complete the co-parenting
counseling because she had “misused the tools she had learned in the course” when she
invited father to stay at her home. Visitation reportedly went well. When visits ended,
the minor told the social worker she wanted to go home with mother. However, the
3
Agency expressed its “grave concerns” regarding the increasing domestic violence
between the parents. The Agency recommended the court set the matter for a section
366.26 hearing.
Hearing on Jurisdiction, Disposition, and Change of Placement
At the March 21, 2024 hearing on jurisdiction and disposition for the amended
section 387 petition and request for change of placement, the juvenile court found the
previous family maintenance services had not been effective. The domestic violence
between the parents continued to place the minor at substantial risk of harm as evidenced
by the facts alleged in the supplemental petition and the parents filing opposing requests
for domestic violence restraining orders. The court took judicial notice of the related
domestic violence cases, heard testimony from both parents, and continued the hearing to
April 11, 2024.
April 2024 Addendum Report
In an addendum report filed April 24, 2024, the Agency provided the results of
mother’s psychological evaluation. The evaluator, Dr. Lea Tate, recommended mother
restart individual therapy to discuss, among other things, how domestic violence affected
her and the minor; restart posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) treatment; participate in
medication management and comply with any recommended medication regimen;
participate in domestic violence education; and maintain the restraining order against
father.
Continued Hearing on Jurisdiction, Disposition, and Change of Placement
The hearing on jurisdiction, disposition, and change of placement continued over a
number of days in April and May 2024. On May 3, 2024, the juvenile court sustained the
allegations in the amended supplemental petition and found that while mother made some
progress toward alleviating or mitigating the causes necessitating the minor’s placement,
she had not been able to demonstrate the skills necessary to safely co-parent, had not
shown she benefitted or learned from her case plan services, did not abide by the agreed-
4
upon safety plan, and continued to engage in domestic violence with father. The court
ordered the minor removed from the parents’ custody and terminated mother’s services,
finding she completed the majority of the case plan but was unable to show a benefit
from those services, she failed to abide by the agreed-upon safety plan, she had not been
able to demonstrate the skills necessary to safely co-parent the minor, she had reached the
maximum allowable reunification time, and there was a low probability of return of the
minor to her care. The court also set a section 366.26 hearing.
Section 366.26 Report
The Agency’s section 366.26 report stated mother’s visits with the minor initially
went well. Prior to the filing of the section 387 supplemental petition, mother was
compliant with supervised visitation and progressed to unsupervised visits in her home.
The minor visited on weekday evenings and all day on Sundays, with one to two weekly
overnight visits. Mother was engaged and appropriate during visits. The minor willingly
went to mother at the start of each visit and fussed when she had to say goodbye,
although she willingly reached for Agency staff when it was time to leave. However, at
some point, the paternal grandparents reported that the minor had begun using “colorful
language,” including saying “Mommy hates you” and screaming “NO!” following visits
with mother. The minor also repeatedly told others “scary Mommy” and “Mommy hits
on the face.” Mother reported not knowing where the minor got that from, stating she
suspected the paternal grandparents planted those thoughts in the minor’s head.
Prior to the minor’s detention on the section 387 supplemental petition, the parents
continued to have domestic violence incidents in front of the minor. Since detention, the
minor had been displaying signs of stress such as bed wetting, stuttering, moodiness,
angry outbursts, and crying before and after visits. The paternal grandparents reported
the minor was “mean, sassy, and defiant” after visits with mother and she continued to
have toileting issues at night. The minor was, however, doing well in her placement with
the paternal grandparents, who provided her with “excellent care” and were meeting all
5
her needs. The minor appeared secure in their care and sought them out for comfort and
affection. Mother’s monitored visitation at the child welfare office was reduced in
August 2024 to just once a month. The Agency recommended termination of parental
rights with a permanent plan of adoption.
Mother’s Petition to Modify Court Order (Section 388)
On August 15, 2024, mother filed a petition to modify the juvenile court’s order
terminating her reunification services, seeking return of the minor to her custody or
reinstatement of reunification services and unmonitored visits with an increase in
frequency and duration. Mother argued she successfully completed a domestic violence
program in September 2022, completed a psychological evaluation by Dr. Tate after
which Dr. Tate recommended further services but concluded mother’s “diagnosis” did not
prevent her from caring for and having custody of the minor, and successfully completed
a parenting program. Mother further argued that, at the time the minor was detained
pursuant to the original petition, mother was arrested for driving under the influence but
not for any of the acts alleged in the petition or the Agency’s reports. She argued she
secured a job as a registered nurse, which allowed her to financially provide for the
minor, and she had been granted a permanent restraining order against father in June
2024, allowing her to protect herself and the minor from father’s continued display of
violence against her. Mother also argued the requested change was in the minor’s best
interests because the minor was deeply bonded to her and would benefit emotionally
from what mother learned in her various counseling programs by being parented and
having extended contact with mother.
Agency’s Opposition to Mother’s Section 388 Petition
The juvenile court ordered a hearing on mother’s section 388 petition. The
Agency opposed the petition, arguing that despite completion of her interim case plan
services, the court found mother did not benefit from those services and continued to
“lack the insight into the significance of her conduct and the profound effect such
6
violence has upon the well[-]being of her children.” The Agency argued there remained
concerns that mother did not benefit from the domestic violence program she completed
in September 2022 due to her persistent involvement in domestic violence events with
father that continued to increase in severity. The Agency argued mother’s reference to
her psychological evaluation and Dr. Tate’s assessment that mother could safely parent
the minor failed to include a key caveat: that mother could only do so “within 9-12
months if she is compliant with the following recommendations,” which included
individual therapy, PTSD treatment, medication management, domestic violence
education, and maintenance of the restraining order against father. As of the writing of
the opposition, there was no indication mother had complied with any of Dr. Tate’s
recommendations.
November 2024 Addendum Report
In an addendum report filed November 27, 2024, the Agency reported the minor
was hitting other children at school. When the teacher corrected her, the minor said,
“Mommy hit [d]addy in the face and he got blood.” The minor told her teacher she had
seen mother throw a trash can at father’s car while she (the minor) was in the car, and that
she did not want to visit mother because mother poured water on her head and was mean.
The teacher reported the minor used the school’s “safe space” often and required a lot of
reassurance. When the minor became upset, she reportedly asked for father and was
given permission to speak with him on the phone. The minor’s caregiver reported the
minor had several occurrences of enuresis and encopresis after visiting with mother. The
clinician providing case management services to the family expressed concern that visits
with mother appeared to cause the minor significant distress as evidenced by emotional
dysregulation and enuresis.
Bonding Assessment Report
Therapist Linda Lafferty completed a bonding study in November 2024 between
mother and the minor. Lafferty concluded that mother was consistent with visitation and
7
“it has been witnessed that a bond is intact and it would be beneficial continuing the
parent/child relationship and would be detrimental to terminate [mother’s] parental
rights.” Lafferty further concluded that the minor would need “support from her paternal
and maternal grandparents to promote healing while this process is implemented, for the
best interest of [the minor].”
January and February 2025 Addendum Reports
In January 2025, the Agency reported the minor was again exhibiting behavioral
issues. The minor hit a child in the face at school, fought with her cousin, and spit in a
child’s face on the bus. When the caregiver spoke with the minor about these incidents,
the minor said, “Mommy said it’s okay to hit if we don’t like someone.” The caregiver
reported that the minor cried when told she would have to visit with mother after school.
The minor had reportedly been telling her attorney and the caregiver that she did not want
any more visits with mother. After one visit, the minor became so emotionally distraught
that the caregiver called father, who came over to calm the minor (who had soiled her
pants).
Following a January 2025 visit, the minor told the caregiver (her paternal
grandmother) that “Mommy hates you.” The minor was so dysregulated after the visit
that she needed to talk with father so he could soothe her before bedtime. After another
visit with mother, the minor was unusually sassy toward her grandmother, rolling her
eyes, speaking in a condescending and “snotty” manner.
On January 28, 2025, over mother’s objection, the juvenile court ordered mother’s
visits with the minor reduced to one visit per month.
In February 2025, the Agency reported that during a visit while mother and the
minor were tickling each other, the minor bit mother on the shoulder. When mother told
the minor it hurt and encouraged her to apologize, the minor refused and began to cry.
Mother later denied the incident ever happened.
8
Hearing on Mother’s Section 388 Petition and Section 366.26 Hearing
The hearing on mother’s section 388 petition and the section 366.26 hearing
commenced on February 11 and 14, 2025. Mother testified that, after the juvenile court
terminated her reunification services in May 2024, she continued services by completing
49 of the 52 batterer’s treatment classes and taking her anxiety medication. She testified
she learned communication tactics, how to identify abuse, how to set and maintain
boundaries, and how to keep positive people around her. She started weekly individual
counseling with therapist Judy Tarkington in June 2024. Mother further testified she had
no relationship with father. She acknowledged there was significant domestic violence in
their relationship, which had an impact on the minor. She testified she exposed the minor
to domestic violence by arguing with father and creating animosity in the house.
However, she denied ever attacking or committing physical violence against anyone and
she specifically denied dragging father while he tried to turn off the car ignition (as
alleged in the original petition). She denied ever telling the minor it was “okay to hit if
we don’t like someone.” She also denied ever telling the minor she hated the paternal
grandmother. Mother testified both she and father abided by the restraining order despite
communicating via a talking parents app.
Therapist Linda Lafferty testified regarding her bonding assessment of mother and
the minor. Lafferty spent four hours in September 2024 observing mother and the minor
together. During the first two-hour visit, mother and the minor interacted well. Mother
brought snacks, clothes, and toys and the two played together and snuggled. The minor
was connected to mother and said goodbye when they parted. The second two-hour visit
went well. Mother brought soup and she and the minor did various activities together.
The two were affectionate toward each other. Lafferty testified that the paternal
grandmother brought the minor to the second visit and was very frustrated with mother
and had very little positive to say about her. Lafferty’s review of the visitation logs gave
her the overall impression that visits went favorably. She noted the minor once told her,
9
“grandma does not like mommy.” When Lafferty asked about father liking mother, the
minor said, “No one likes mommy.”
Therapist Lafferty opined that the minor had been exposed to domestic violence
between mother and father but there was a bond between the minor and mother, the
minor had a positive emotional attachment to mother, the bond was beneficial to the
minor, and continuing the parental relationship was in the minor’s best interest. When
asked whether the minor’s trauma from being exposed to domestic violence outweighed
her emotional attachment and bond with mother, Lafferty stated the minor was confused
due to disruptions in her life such as domestic violence and out-of-home placements but it
was in the minor’s best interest to strengthen her bond with mother “[i]f everyone got
therapy and realigned themselves with health and healing.” Lafferty testified that
termination of mother’s parental rights would be detrimental to the minor because the
minor is five years old, “knows her mom,” and “will always remember her mom and that
will cause some angst in her development as she goes through life.”
The minor’s counsel made an offer of proof that, over the past several months on
at least four occasions, the minor was very emotional and expressed frustration with visits
with mother. The minor told counsel she did not want to attend visits with mother
anymore or, at the very least, wanted visits to be shorter.
At the continued hearing on February 14, 2025, the juvenile court denied mother’s
section 388 petition, finding she did not meet her burden of showing changed
circumstances or that the requested change was in the minor’s best interest. Next, the
court found the minor was likely to be adopted. With respect to the applicability of the
beneficial parental relationship exception, the court considered the minor’s age, how long
she was exposed to the domestic violence, the portion of her life spent in her parents’
care, and the effects of the interaction between the minor and mother. The court found
mother demonstrated she consistently visited with the minor but did not demonstrate a
positive emotional attachment, termination of which would be detrimental to the minor.
10
The court balanced the severance of parental rights against the benefit of adoption and
found any benefit the minor received from her relationship with her parents did not
outweigh her need for permanency in a safe and secure adoptive home. The court
terminated parental rights and identified adoption as the permanent plan.
DISCUSSION
I
Denial of Section 388 Petition
Mother contends the juvenile court abused its discretion when it denied her section
388 petition. She claims the court failed to consider that she completed domestic
violence and parenting programs and a psychological evaluation and continued to attend
a batterer’s program and therapy after services were terminated; she gained significant
insight into her domestic violence relationships; and she abided by the restraining order.
She further claims the court failed to consider the minor was bonded to her and
continuing the relationship was in the minor’s best interest. We find no abuse of
discretion.
To petition to modify a juvenile court order under section 388, a party must
factually allege changed circumstances or new evidence to justify the requested order,
and that the requested order would serve the minor’s best interests. (In re Daijah T.
(2000) 83 Cal.App.4th 666, 672.) The petitioner has the burden of proof on both points
by a preponderance of the evidence. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.570(h)(1)(D).)
In deciding whether a parent has met his or her burden under section 388, the
juvenile court must consider such factors as the seriousness of the problem that led to the
dependency, and the reasons for the continuation of the problem; the degree to which the
problem may be and has been removed or ameliorated; and the strength of the relative
bonds between the dependent child and the child’s parents or caretakers. (In re B.D.
(2008) 159 Cal.App.4th 1218, 1229.) However, this list is not exhaustive. (Ibid.)
11
The child’s best interests “are not to further delay permanency and stability in
favor of rewarding” the parent for his “hard work and efforts to reunify.” (In re J.C.
(2014) 226 Cal.App.4th 503, 527.) “A petition which alleges merely changing
circumstances and would mean delaying the selection of a permanent home for a child to
see if a parent, who has repeatedly failed to reunify with the child, might be able to
reunify at some future point, does not promote stability for the child or the child’s best
interests.” (In re Casey D. (1999) 70 Cal.App.4th 38, 47, disapproved on other grounds
in In re Caden C. (2021) 11 Cal.5th 614, 636, fn. 5.) We review the denial of a section
388 petition for abuse of discretion. (In re S.R. (2009) 173 Cal.App.4th 864, 870; In re
J.T. (2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 953, 965.)
Here, regarding evidence of a change in mother’s circumstances, mother
completed a domestic violence program in September 2022, four months after the minor
was initially removed from her (and father’s) custody. The minor was returned to the
parents’ custody in January 2024 with family maintenance services, including a 52-week
batterer’s program. Just two months later, the juvenile court again ordered the minor
detained due to the parents’ continued domestic violence. The parents were ordered to
complete reunification services including the previously ordered batterer’s program.
Mother completed a psychological evaluation but did not fully comply with Dr. Tate’s
recommendation that she engage (or re-engage) in individual therapy, PTSD treatment,
medication management, and domestic violence education, and maintenance of the
restraining order against father. Even five months after the minor was detained on the
section 387 petition, there had been no confirmation mother was engaging in individual
therapy, PTSD treatment, or medication management. She last attended the 52-week
batterer’s program class in late April 2024, yet thereafter continued to have contact with
father despite the active restraining order.
Mother testified she acknowledged her past behaviors, including arguing with
father and creating “animosity in the house,” and she gained insight into those behaviors
12
and was rehabilitated. At the same time, however, she denied she ever perpetrated any
physical violence on father, testimony that was directly contradicted, not only by the
minor’s repeated statements, but by evidence she dragged father approximately 50 feet
with her car (while father held the minor in his arms), threw a trash can at father’s car,
and vandalized father’s home. The court concluded mother had not done anything
significant to address the issues leading to the minor’s detention and found she did not
meet her burden of showing changed circumstances.
The juvenile court further found that, even assuming mother had shown changed
circumstances, she did not demonstrate the requested changes were in the minor’s best
interest. Contrary to mother’s assertion, the court considered and rejected her claim that
the minor was strongly bonded to her such that the minor would benefit emotionally from
the requested changes and from what mother learned in her counseling programs.
Therapist Linda Lafferty concluded there was a bond between mother and the minor but
failed to discuss the concerning reports about the minor experiencing significant distress,
including emotional dysregulation, enuresis, and encopresis, after visiting with mother.
The court focused on the then five-year-old minor’s need for permanency and safety, the
fact that the dependency had been ongoing since 2022 and the minor had been in the care
of someone other than the parents for over half her life, and the fact that the minor was in
a prospective adoptive placement. On that basis, the court found mother failed to
demonstrate the requested changes were in the minor’s best interest.
The juvenile court acted well within its discretion in denying mother’s section 388
petition for modification.
II
Beneficial Parental Relationship Exception
Mother contends the juvenile court erred when it found the beneficial parental
relationship exception to adoption did not apply. The claim lacks merit.
13
At the section 366.26 selection and implementation hearing, a juvenile court must
choose one of several “ ‘possible alternative permanent plans for a minor child. . . . The
permanent plan preferred by the Legislature is adoption. [Citation.]’ [Citations.] If the
court finds the child is adoptable, it must terminate parental rights absent circumstances
under which it would be detrimental to the child.” (In re Ronell A. (1996) 44 Cal.App.4th
1352, 1368.) There are limited circumstances permitting the court to find a “compelling
reason for determining that termination [of parental rights] would be detrimental to the
child.” (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B).) One such circumstance is the beneficial parental
relationship exception. (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i); In re Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at
pp. 625-626.)
The party claiming the exception has the burden of establishing supporting
circumstances. (In re Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at pp. 636-637; In re Melvin A. (2000)
82 Cal.App.4th 1243, 1252; Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.725(d)(2).) The parent “must
show regular visitation and contact with the child, taking into account the extent of
visitation permitted. Moreover, the parent must show that the child has a substantial,
positive, emotional attachment to the parent—the kind of attachment implying that the
child would benefit from continuing the relationship. And the parent must show that
terminating that attachment would be detrimental to the child even when balanced against
the countervailing benefit of a new, adoptive home.” (In re Caden C., at p. 636.)
The beneficial parental relationship exception “must be examined on a case-by-
case basis, taking into account the many variables which affect a parent[-]child bond.
The age of the child, the portion of the child’s life spent in the parent’s custody, the
‘positive’ or ‘negative’ effect of interaction between parent and child, and the child’s
particular needs are some of the variables which logically affect a parent[-]child bond.”
(In re Autumn H. (1994) 27 Cal.App.4th 567, 575-576.) The factual predicate of the
exception must be supported by substantial evidence, but the juvenile court exercises its
discretion in weighing that evidence and determining detriment. (In re Caden C., supra,
14
11 Cal.5th at p. 630.) We do not substitute our judgment for that of the juvenile court as
to what is in the child’s best interests. (Id. at pp. 640-641.)
Here, the juvenile court determined, and the parties agree, that mother established
the first element of the beneficial parental relationship exception—regular visitation.
Therefore, we need not address that element further.
Regarding the second element—whether the minor had a “substantial, positive,
emotional attachment” to mother such that the minor “would benefit from continuing the
relationship” (In re Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 636; see In re Katherine J. (2022)
75 Cal.App.5th 303, 316-317; In re J.D. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 833, 852)—mother
argues she and the minor shared a substantial and positive bond as demonstrated by the
fact that mother met the minor’s physical and emotional needs during visits and the minor
said she loved mother and asked when she could “go back to my mommy’s house.”
However, mother ignores that, following the filing of the supplemental petition, the minor
displayed significant signs of stress before and after visits with mother. Even after
mother’s visits were reduced to once-weekly monitored visits, and later to one visit per
month, the minor exhibited behavioral problems following visits, including hitting and
spitting at other children at school. Additionally, the minor repeatedly told the caregiver
and her attorney that she did not want to visit mother anymore.
The juvenile court found, based on the evidence, that mother did not share a
positive emotional attachment with the minor, given the “chaos of the chronic domestic
violence in which the child was exposed.” The then five-year-old minor had spent half
her life in mother’s care being exposed to domestic violence, which the court accurately
characterized as “significant,” involving a vehicle on more than one occasion. Contrary
to mother’s assertion, the court did consider the bonding assessment but was not
persuaded. As previously noted, the bonding study failed to address the fact that the
minor was experiencing significant distress, emotional and physical dysregulation, and
was exhibiting behavioral issues, after visiting with mother.
15
Regarding the third element—whether the attachment was so significant that
terminating it would be detrimental to the minor even when balanced against the
countervailing benefit of a new, adoptive home (In re Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at
p. 636; In re Autumn H., supra, 27 Cal.App.4th at p. 575)—the juvenile court found that,
given the number and severity of domestic violence incidents and the parents’ continued
engagement in domestic violence acts in front of the minor despite being provided
services to address the issue, there was “minimal evidence of a beneficial parental
relationship” between the minor and mother (or father) and any existing relationship did
not outweigh the minor’s need for permanency. Based on the record as we have
recounted here, we find no abuse of discretion in the court’s finding.
We conclude the juvenile court did not err by finding the beneficial parental
relationship exception to adoption did not apply.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s orders are affirmed.
/s/
BOULWARE EURIE, J.
We concur:
/s/
ROBIE, Acting P. J.
/s/
RENNER, J.
16
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.