CourtListener 10775571•Greer v. Carlson CA2/5
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 1/16/26 Greer v. Carlson CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
STEVEN GREER, B343596
Plaintiff and Appellant, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 23SMCV02036)
TUCKER CARLSON,
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Lisa K. Sepe-Wiesenfeld, Judge. Affirmed.
Steven E. Greer, pro. per., for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Dhillon Law Group and Mark P. Meuser for Defendant and
Respondent.
________________________
Plaintiff and appellant Steven Greer appeals from a
judgment of dismissal following an order sustaining a demurrer
without leave to amend in favor of defendant and respondent
Tucker Carlson in this action arising out of unsolicited ideas for
news stories. The trial court concluded that: (1) Greer’s claims
were precluded by prior federal litigation, (2) many of Greer’s
contract claims were barred by the two-year statute of limitations
for implied-in-fact contract, (3) the complaint failed to state a
claim for breach of an implied-in-fact contract, and (4) Greer’s
claim for violation of Business and Professions Code section
17200 depended on his contract claim, so he failed to state a
claim under that statute as well. On appeal, we agree that the
complaint fails to state a claim for breach of an implied-in-fact
contract, and the claim under Business and Professions Code
section 17200 was derivative of the contract claim. Therefore, we
affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Lawsuit in Federal Court in New York
On July 14, 2020, Greer, acting in propria persona, filed an
action in federal court in New York against multiple defendants,
including Fox News Media and Tucker Carlson. Among other
causes of action, the complaint alleged claims for unfair
competition in violation of California Business and Professions
Code section 17200, misappropriation of “hot news,” unjust
enrichment, and tortious interference with contractual relations.
The federal court dismissed the complaint on jurisdictional
grounds because Greer and Carlson were both domiciled in
2
Florida, but the court granted leave to file an amended
complaint.
In March 2021, Greer filed a second amended complaint in
federal court against several defendants, including Fox News
Media, but omitting Carlson, arising out of the same allegations
about the theft of Greer’s ideas. The federal court ultimately
dismissed the complaint without leave to amend. The court
found the Copyright Act preempted Greer’s unfair competition
claims. The court concluded Greer waived his claim for breach of
an implied-in-fact contract by failing to allege it in the complaint,
but even if not waived, Greer failed to plead the essential terms
of an implied contract. Greer appealed. On March 29, 2023, the
federal appellate court affirmed. Among other findings, the
appellate court concluded leave to amend to allege an implied-in-
fact contract was futile on the merits because Greer failed to
allege mutual assent between him and the defendants to
compensate or credit Greer for his news tips.
B. Lawsuit in California
On May 9, 2023, Greer, acting in propria persona, filed the
instant action against Carlson in California court. The trial court
sustained a demurrer filed by Carlson with leave to amend. In
February 2024, Greer filed the operative amended complaint
against Carlson for breach of implied-in-fact contract and unfair
competition in violation of Business and Professions Code section
17200 as follows.
Greer, a Florida resident, is a medical doctor who regularly
writes essays and provides expert interviews on healthcare and
other topics. He “blasts” emails about his blog essays as idea
3
pitches to an address list that includes members of the media,
including Carlson. In 2017, he added Carlson and Carlson’s
producers at Fox News to his list of email recipients.
It is the industry standard to pay for ideas. Greer’s emails
were standard industry pitches with the expectation of payment
if they were used. Payment by Carlson was implied. Carlson’s
show did not create original content, which was fine with Greer
as long as credit was given to the original sources, but Carlson
was not compensating Greer or providing recognition. Greer
began warning Carlson in 2019 that he expected payment and he
has continued to issue notices of violation to the present.
In July 2019, Greer emailed a tip to several individuals,
including Carlson and his producer, that Jeffrey Epstein’s wealth
was derived solely from Les Wexner. The following Monday, this
story was a prominent topic of Carlson’s episode, and Carlson
interviewed an individual who repeated the text of Greer’s tip
nearly verbatim. The following day, Greer sent a text message to
Carlson and received as a response, “This is [Fox producer] Chris
Wallace. Please stop sending me right wing propaganda.” Greer
believes Carlson wrote the text message himself to cover up using
Greer’s idea. On July 29, 2019, Greer sent a “cease and desist”
letter to the legal department for Fox News, which was received
and read, but Greer received no reply. Based on these
allegations, Greer asserted the existence of an implied-in-fact
contract because Greer created the idea, disclosed the idea for
sale, use of the idea was “clearly conditioned on the obligation to
pay,” Carlson used the idea on his show, and the idea had value.
In early 2019, Greer created the term “Demplosion,” which
he used on his website BatteryPark.TV (BPTV) and in essays.
On July 30, 2019, one day after receiving the “cease and desist”
4
letter, Carlson used the term “Demimplosion” in a graphic.
Carlson’s monologue mirrored Greer’s essays about the
Democratic party making mistakes that would cause them to lose
badly in the next elections.
Greer promptly posted a story on his website that day with
the title, “Tucker Carlson rips off BPTV again,” which he sent to
his email blast list. Greer received no reply. Carlson used the
term again in February 2020.
In April 2020, Greer wrote an essay entitled, “Coronavirus
is a New York problem, not a national problem,” stating that the
mainstream media was clustered in Manhattan, the high death
rate was simply generated from hot spots in Queens and other
outer boroughs where Third World conditions have existed, and
the country was not in a national pandemic worth shutting down
the global economy.
On April 24, 2020, Carlson’s monologue on his show stated
that the virus was concentrated in a small number of places in
and around New York City, and it was possibly because these are
where most national media figures live that the pandemic often
seems like a nationwide disaster.
On May 1, 2020, Greer emailed Carlson and Fox News
staff, “Please have your lawyers contact me. You are a serial
plagiarist. I am forced to memorialize my innovative content by
sending it to you as a copyright notice.” Fox News did not
respond.
Instead, Carlson used Greer’s April 2020 idea again on
June 11, 2020, in a story about hospital deaths. Greer sent a
“cease and desist” email to Carlson that stated, “I saw your
segment tonight with the insider nurse exposing how egregiously
incompetent care at Elmhurt Hospital directly led to infections
5
and death. You even discussed the concept of medical advocacy
by family, which is in my book the Medical Advocate. [¶] As you
well know, I was the first person months ago to say in the
national media and on my own website that the high death rates
were due to incompetent care at these hospitals. I even called the
CEO of Elmhurst and spoke with him. I gave you his contact. [¶]
I’m glad you are covering this. Unfortunately for you, you have a
legal obligation to mention that this was my story. It is also basic
journalistic ethics.”
In September 2021, Greer sent an email to Carlson with an
exclusive tip about the restriction of oral therapeutics for COVID,
including hydroxychloroquine and ivermectin, at large
pharmacies in California. Ten days later, Carlson spoke on his
show about this idea. Greer sent a message to Carlson and Fox
News staff with the subject line “Violation,” and stated, “Tucker
is covering my ivermectin story verbatim tonight. He even
mentioned the same pharmacies that are not dispensing the
drug. His source? ‘We are hearing[.]’ ”
On September 20, 2022, Greer was an invited speaker
before the State Board of Education for Ohio about harm caused
by gender reassignment surgery. The complaint alleges Carlson
received Greer’s email blast with links to that story, which
Carlson read. On September 22, 2022, Carlson began his show
with comments very similar to Greer’s statements. Greer sent a
notice to Carlson and his attorneys stating, “Tucker Carlson’s
opening segment last night was lifted straight from my
discussion at the Ohio Department of education this week . . . .”
In December 2022, Greer wrote in his “Greer Report” that
“The November jobs number of 223,000 seemed to be bogus . . . .”
In another post, he wrote, “The White House is putting out
6
fraudulent jobs numbers. Now, the GDP number seems inflated.”
Greer sent blast emails to Carlson that included links to Greer’s
stories.
On December 20, 2022, Carlson began his show by
explaining lies from the White House, including the economic jobs
report. Greer wrote a violation warning to Carlson and his
attorneys that stated, “I was the first person I know of to say that
the jobs numbers were cooked. . . . Tucker Carlson tonight [led
off his show] with the story about the jobs number being
concocted.”
In April 2023, Carlson’s employment with Fox News
terminated and he created a media company named Last
Country, Inc.
Greer had an idea that Covid mRNA vaccines were gene
therapies that must be removed from the market, which he
discussed on his video platform. Greer states that he sent an
email about this story to the President of Carlson’s company,
Last Nation, Inc. In January 2024, Carlson posted an interview
with Florida Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo, M.D., to discuss
this idea. Greer notified Carlson’s lawyer and demanded a
correction, stating in pertinent part, “This interview by Tucker
Carlson with Dr. Ladapo is based entirely on my ideas and
videos. Please issue a correction. Failure to do so will be willful
and malicious violations. [¶] This is the story that started the
idea of the Pfizer and Moderna shots being ‘gene therapies’ that
must be removed from the market. Before my story, people were
only exposing ‘DNA contamination’ and not demanding the shots
be removed. . . . [¶] . . . [¶] The Epoch Times covered the
interview. Ron DeSantis and Dr. Ladapo used it in subsequent
7
comments. Tucker Carlson watched the video last year when I
made it.”
With respect to each idea alleged in the complaint, Greer
stated that he created the idea, he disclosed the idea for sale to
Carlson, the use of the idea was clearly conditioned on the
obligation to pay, Carlson voluntarily accepted the idea disclosure
and used the idea on his show, and the idea had value.
Greer alleged in summary that Carlson is a serial
plagiarist whose career is based on repackaging other people’s
content into a live show, but Carlson does not give credit to the
original sources. Greer sought damages of $1 billion.
C. Demurrer and Trial Court Ruling
In March 2024, Carlson filed a demurrer to the amended
complaint. Carlson asserted the New York litigation precluded
the California action based on the doctrines of issue and claim
preclusion, formerly referred to as res judicata and collateral
estoppel, because Carlson was in privity with Fox News. Greer’s
cause of action for implied-in-fact contract was further barred by
the statute of limitations and Greer’s failure to allege mutual
assent, which was an essential element of an implied-in-fact
contract. The cause of action for violation of Business and
Professions Code section 17200 failed to state a claim because it
was duplicative of the claim for breach of implied-in-fact contract
and otherwise preempted under the Copyright Act. In addition,
the statute did not support recovery by a non-resident of
California, when the alleged misconduct and injuries did not
occur in California.
8
Greer opposed the demurrer. He argued that his claims
based on implied-in-fact contracts had not been asserted or
litigated previously. In addition, he argued Carlson was not in
privity with Fox News. He conceded that the claim under
Business and Professions Code section 17200 was derived from
the claim for breach of implied-in-fact contract, but asserted that
to the extent the claim was based on contract law, it was not
preempted by copyright law. He also argued that the continuing
violation doctrine brought all of the acts within the statute of
limitations.
A hearing was held on November 27, 2024. No reporter’s
transcript of the hearing has been incorporated in the appellate
record. On December 6, 2024, the trial court issued a minute
order sustaining the demurrer without leave to amend. The
court granted Carlson’s request to take judicial notice of 14 court
records from the federal action in New York. The court concluded
Carlson was in privity with his employer, Fox News, because he
had been sued in his capacity as a broadcaster on Fox News.
Greer previously alleged claims against Fox News and Carlson
for violation of Business and Professions Code section 17200 and
breach of an implied-in-fact contract, those claims were
adjudicated in favor of Fox News, and the judgment is final.
Although Greer had not pled a cause of action explicitly based on
implied-in-fact contract in the federal action, he asserted that an
implied-in-fact contract existed between him and Fox News, and
the federal court concluded Greer had no claim for an implied-in-
fact contract. Greer’s claims were barred by the doctrines of res
judicata and collateral estoppel, as he was clearly attempting to
relitigate claims decided against him in the prior federal
litigation.
9
In addition, each cause of action failed to state a claim upon
which relief may be granted. The statute of limitations for an
implied-in-fact contract is two years. The complaint was filed on
May 9, 2023, but many of the ideas at issue were sent and aired
before May 9, 2021, outside the statute of limitations. Each tip
that Greer alleged Carlson included in a broadcast was an
independently actionable wrong, not a continuing violation.
Therefore, many of the implied-in-fact contracts alleged in the
complaint were barred by the statute of limitations.
Moreover, Greer failed to state any cause of action for
breach of an implied-in-fact contract because he failed to allege
any facts showing an agreement by Carlson to compensate Greer
for his ideas, nor were there any facts showing mutual asset by
Carlson. Greer simply disseminated his ideas to Carlson and
brought this action based on similarities between the purported
tips that he sent and the content on Carlson’s television show.
This did not show the existence of an implied-in-fact contract.
Carlson’s purported use of Greer’s ideas, where Greer
unilaterally expected compensation, does not show mutual assent
because it is not mutual. The subjective belief of a single party is
not mutual assent. The cause of action for violation of Business
and Professions Code section 17200 was duplicative of the
contract claim, and otherwise preempted by copyright law. The
court sustained the demurrer without leave to amend.
On January 3, 2025, the trial court entered a judgment of
dismissal. Greer filed a timely notice of appeal.
10
DISCUSSION
A. Standard of Review
“In determining whether plaintiffs properly stated a claim
for relief, our standard of review is clear: ‘ “We treat the
demurrer as admitting all material facts properly pleaded, but
not contentions, deductions or conclusions of fact or law.
[Citation.] We also consider matters which may be judicially
noticed.” [Citation.] Further, we give the complaint a reasonable
interpretation, reading it as a whole and its parts in their
context. [Citation.] When a demurrer is sustained, we determine
whether the complaint states facts sufficient to constitute a cause
of action. [Citation.] . . . ’ (Blank v. Kirwan (1985) 39 Cal.3d 311,
318; see also McCall v. PacifiCare of Cal., Inc. (2001) 25 Cal.4th
412, 415 [noting that our review is de novo].)” (Zelig v. County of
Los Angeles (2002) 27 Cal.4th 1112, 1126.)
B. Implied-in-Fact Contract
Greer contends that the complaint states a cause of action
for implied-in-fact contract under California law. We disagree.
“An implied contract is one, the existence and terms of
which are manifested by conduct.” (Civ. Code, § 1621.) “A cause
of action for breach of implied contract has the same elements as
does a cause of action for breach of contract, except that the
promise is not expressed in words but is implied from the
promisor’s conduct.” (Yari v. Producers Guild of America, Inc.
(2008) 161 Cal.App.4th 172, 182.)
11
“ ‘Even though an idea is not property subject to exclusive
ownership, its disclosure may be of substantial benefit to the
person to whom it is disclosed. That disclosure may therefore be
consideration for a promise to pay[.]’ [Citations.]” (Desny v.
Wilder (1956) 46 Cal.2d 715, 733 (Desny).) “Usually the parties
will expressly contract for the performance of and payment for
such services, but, in the absence of an express contract, when
the service is requested and rendered the law does not hesitate to
infer or imply a promise to compensate for it. [Citations.] In
other words[,] the recovery may be based on contract either
express or implied. The person who can and does convey a
valuable idea to a producer who commercially solicits the service
or who voluntarily accepts it knowing that it is tendered for a
price should likewise be entitled to recover.” (Id. at pp. 733–734.)
Under Desny, to prevail on a claim for breach of an implied-
in-fact contract for idea submission, “plaintiffs must show (1)
they clearly conditioned the submission of their ideas on an
obligation to pay for any use of their ideas; (2) the defendants,
knowing this condition before the plaintiffs disclosed the ideas,
voluntarily accepted the submission of the ideas; and (3) the
defendants found the ideas valuable and actually used them—
that is, the defendants based their work substantially on the
plaintiffs’ ideas, rather than on their own ideas or ideas from
other sources.” (Spinner v. American Broadcasting Companies,
Inc. (2013) 215 Cal.App.4th 172, 184, emphasis omitted
(Spinner); Norman v. Ross (2024) 101 Cal.App.5th 617, 647–648
(Norman).)
A producer’s inferred or implied promise to compensate the
purveyor of an idea “must be based on circumstances which were
known to the producer at and preceding the time of disclosure of
12
the idea to him and he must voluntarily accept the disclosure,
knowing the conditions on which it is tendered. Section 1584 of
the Civil Code (‘[T]he acceptance of the consideration offered with
a proposal, is an acceptance of the proposal’) can have no
application unless the offeree has an opportunity to reject the
consideration -- the proffered conveyance of the idea -- before it is
conveyed. Unless the offeree has opportunity to reject[,] he
cannot be said to accept. [Citations.] The idea man who blurts
out his idea without having first made his bargain has no one but
himself to blame for the loss of his bargaining power. The law
will not in any event, from demands stated subsequent to the
unconditioned disclosure of an abstract idea, imply a promise to
pay for the idea, for its use, or for its previous disclosure. The
law will not imply a promise to pay for an idea from the mere
facts that the idea has been conveyed, is valuable, and has been
used for profit; this is true even though the conveyance has been
made with the hope or expectation that some obligation will
ensue.” (Desny, supra, 46 Cal.2d at p. 739.)
The complaint in this case does not state a cause of action
for implied-in-fact contract. There is no allegation that Carlson
solicited any of the ideas alleged in the complaint as the basis of
implied contract claims. Greer, on his own volition, added
Carlson’s contact information to a mass email list and provided
content that Carlson did not request from him. There is no
allegation that Greer clearly stated in advance of providing any
particular idea that he expected to be paid for use of that idea.
There is no allegation that Carlson, knowing this condition for
payment before Greer disclosed the ideas, voluntarily accepted
the submission of the ideas. (See Norman, supra, 101
Cal.App.5th at pp. 654–655.) In fact, there is no allegation that
13
Carlson had an opportunity to refuse the ideas offered by Greer
before they were offered. The allegations reveal that Greer
voluntarily provided content that he considered valuable and
then hoped or expected some obligation would ensue. His
unilateral expectation of payment or attribution does not satisfy
the requirement of mutual assent to a contract.
The circumstances alleged in the complaint further reveal
the lack of mutual assent to contract. After providing ideas to
Carlson in 2019 and 2020, well outside of the statute of
limitations in this case for a claim based on an implied contract,
Greer accused Carlson of plagiarism and filed a lawsuit against
him in federal court for misappropriation of Greer’s ideas.
Carlson was clearly not agreeing to pay for the use of Greer’s
unsolicited ideas. Without any change in their relationship,
Greer simply continued to send unsolicited ideas to Carlson. In
fact, in his reply brief, Greer admits that he continued to email
ideas to Carlson to prove in writing that his work predated
Carlson’s, because Greer anticipated theft of his ideas. The law
will not imply a promise to pay for an idea from demands stated
after the unconditioned disclosure of an abstract idea. (Norman,
supra, at p. 655.) The complaint fails to allege Carlson’s
agreement in advance to pay for Greer’s ideas or mutual assent to
contract.
Greer concedes that his cause of action for violation of
Business and Professions Code section 17200 is derived from his
assertion of a contract claim, and as we have explained, Greer
has failed to allege a contract claim. On appeal, Greer has not
requested leave to amend or suggested how he could successfully
amend to state a cause of action. The trial court properly
14
sustained the demurrer without leave to amend and entered
judgment in favor of Carlson.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Respondent Tucker Carlson is
awarded his costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
MOOR, J.
WE CONCUR:
BAKER, Acting P. J.
KIM (D.), J.
15
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.