Bauer v. Bauer CA2/6

CourtListener 10773299Calctapp12.01.2026

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 1/12/26 Bauer v. Bauer CA2/6

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SIX

JENNIFER BAUER, 2d Civ. No. B341078
(Cons. with B343541)
Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. D396761)
(Ventura County)
v.

KEVIN BAUER,

Appellant.

Appellant Kevin Bauer and respondent Jennifer Bauer
signed a stipulated judgment of dissolution in 2021. They agreed
Kevin would pay fixed monthly child and spousal support to
Jennifer, supplemented by a pre-agreed percentage of his bonus
compensation calculated using an Ostler-Smith table attached to
the judgment. In 2024 a dispute arose over Kevin’s Ostler-Smith
payments. This appeal follows two post-judgment orders
awarding Jennifer arrears and modifying Kevin’s prospective
spousal and child support obligations.
We will reverse the orders in part. The family court erred
by including post-judgment increases to Kevin’s base salary when
calculating his Ostler-Smith arrears. Any order regarding his
prospective spousal and child support obligations should confirm
this income is not subject to division. We will remand the case
with directions to reduce the arrears award and to recalculate
Kevin’s support obligations consistently with this opinion.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Kevin and Jennifer1 separated in 2019 after nearly 20
years of marriage. They have one minor daughter. Kevin works
in the facilities department of a large pharmaceutical company.
Jennifer is a school teacher.
The family court entered a stipulated judgment in October
of 2021 (judgment) dividing the couple’s marital assets. This
included, among other things, the proceeds from the sale of their
house (about $426,000), their employment retirement accounts,
corporate stocks, as well as several IRAs and investment
accounts totaling about $400,000. The judgment set Kevin’s
monthly child support at $366 and spousal support at $400.
These figures were derived from an attached DissoMaster report
titled “DissoMaster Report 2021 Monthly” that included their
wages and salary, custodial time share, and other financial
information etc. used to calculate support.2

1 We refer to the parties by their first names for ease of

reference.
2 “DissoMaster is a computer software program widely used

by courts to set child support and temporary spousal support.”
(Namikas v. Miller (2014) 225 Cal.App.4th 1574, 1578, fn. 4.)

2
The judgment included a variable Ostler-Smith3 component
requiring Kevin to pay additional spousal and child support as
follows: “[Kevin] shall pay to [Jennifer] a percentage of his
compensation in excess of [Kevin’s] base salary of $12,989 per
month and shall be paid . . . within seven (7) business days of
receipt and shall be accompanied by all paystubs or other
documentation evidencing such additional compensation. The
percentage payable shall be pursuant to the DissoMaster report
attached hereto as EXHIBIT ‘A’ and incorporated herein by
reference labelled for reference only as ‘Kevin Annual Bonus
Wages Report’. The spousal support set forth herein is based
upon all of the financial circumstances set forth in each party’s
Schedule of Assets and Debts, their respective incomes and the
financial circumstances set forth in the DissoMaster report
attached hereto, including the payment of child support by
[Kevin] to [Jennifer].”
The child support provision was almost identical: “As
additional child support, [Kevin] shall pay to [Jennifer] a
percentage of his compensation in excess of [Kevin’s] base salary
of $12,989 per month, payable within seven (7) business days of
his receipt of same. The child support set forth and the
percentage of additional child support is pursuant to the financial
circumstances and bonus table set forth in the DissoMaster

3 In re Marriage of Ostler & Smith (1990) 223 Cal.App.3d

33 (Ostler-Smith), held that spousal and child support awards
may include both a percentage of the supporting spouse’s wages
and a percentage of the income he or she receives in the form of
bonuses, dividends and other types of discretionary
compensation.

3
printout attached hereto as Exhibit ‘A’ and incorporated herein
by reference.”
The “Kevin Annual Bonus Wages Report 2021 Yearly”
(bonus table) includes a two-page worksheet with several
columns. The first column is titled “Kevin’s Gross Bonus” and
runs downward in $1,000 increments from $1,000 to $60,000.
The table includes additional columns the parties use to calculate
how much of the bonus Kevin must pay toward child and spousal
support that year. On the low end (a $1,000 bonus), Kevin must
pay 8.02 percent (i.e., $80) toward child support and 21.29
percent (i.e., $213) toward spousal support. On the high end (a
$60,000 bonus), he must pay 7.19 percent ($4,315) toward child
support and 20.50 percent ($12,298) toward spousal support. The
table includes additional columns that specify the total support
due from Kevin when combined with his “fixed” or regular
monthly payment.
Two years after signing the stipulated judgment, Jennifer
learned Kevin’s income had increased to about $19,700 per
month. She retained a new attorney. The attorney sent a letter
expressing concern that Kevin’s actual income was “not
accurately represented in [the] Judgment.” The letter asserted
Jennifer was entitled to a percentage of any compensation above
$12,989 per month. It directed Kevin to “make a fee contribution
to my firm in the sum of $10,000” and to provide various wage
and salary information for the prior three years.
Kevin responded that the judgment accurately reflected his
2021 base salary ($155,866, i.e., $12,989 per month). He had
since received two base salary increases: to $161,633 in 2022,
and to $204,212 in 2023 when he received a promotion. Kevin
explained the figure of $19,700 included bonus income. He sent

4
documents showing he made Ostler-Smith payments on his bonus
income to Jennifer in 2022 and 2023. He also sent his paystubs
for 2021, 2022, and 2023.
Jennifer filed a request for order (RFO) increasing spousal
and child support in January of 2024. She did not serve the RFO
on Kevin or disclose she had filed it. The supporting documents
did not refer to arrears for past due support.
Jennifer served the RFO in April of 2024 along with a
supporting declaration. She acknowledged Kevin was current on
the fixed component of spousal support (i.e., $400 per month) and
child support (i.e., $366 per month) but argued he had underpaid
the Ostler-Smith payments in 2022 and 2023 by omitting from
the calculation base salary increases and parts of his gross pay.
Jennifer filed the declaration of a forensic accountant who
calculated Kevin’s arrears as exceeding $50,000. The accountant
cited the judgment’s directive that Kevin pay “a percentage of his
compensation in excess of [his] base salary of $12,989 per month,”
which she interpreted as the difference between $155,868 (i.e.,
$12,989 annualized) and the gross wages reflected on his W-2
forms for 2022 and 2023 ($235,029 and $326,494, respectively).
Jennifer requested the court modify spousal and guideline child
support based upon Kevin’s current income. She sought arrears
for 2022 and 2023.
Kevin consented to a guideline modification of child support
but opposed increasing spousal support. He requested the family
court terminate spousal support because Jennifer could now
support herself financially. He objected to the court deciding the
issue of arrears because Jennifer did not request or itemize them
on the required judicial council form.

5
The parties appeared before the family court on June 18,
2024. After argument, the court found as follows: “There’s a
long-term marriage. There was a negotiated settlement. So
spousal support remains as previously set. With regards to a
request to increase spousal support, that request is [also]
respectfully denied.” The court increased the fixed component of
child support from $400 to $591 based on a guideline calculation
reflecting both parties’ higher salaries. It stated the following on
the variable Ostler-Smith component for both spousal and child
support: “Now, the parties negotiated a settlement that had a
specific base salary in the judgment. But the reality is his base
pay has gone up, and so the Ostler-Smith shall apply to anything
above his normal base salary. And now that’s $17,655.”
The court denied Jennifer’s request for attorney’s fees as
“excessive” and “unjustified.” It deferred ruling on the issue of
arrears so Jennifer could properly plead the issue.
The court’s written order, filed July 29, 2024, ordered
Kevin to pay child support of $591 per month “subject to an
Ostler-Smith table for anything above [Kevin’s] normal base
salary of $17,655 per month and referred to an attached
DissoMaster Report. The order stated that Jennifer’s request to
modify spousal support was denied, but then it stated “[s]pousal
support remains as previously ordered and is subject to an Ostler-
Smith table for anything above [Kevin’s] normal base salary of
$17,655 per month.” (July 29 order).
Jennifer filed a second RFO seeking: (1) $10,774 plus
interest for child and spousal support arrears in 2022; (2) $37,750
plus interest for child and spousal support arrears in 2023;
(3) $25,000 in attorney’s fees; and (4) $10,000 paid to her forensic
accountant, though she attested to only having paid $5,000 to

6
date. Kevin filed a separate RFO asking the court to reconsider
and clarify his support obligations—specifically, whether
increases to his base salary were included in the Ostler-Smith
calculation. He understood it would apply only to his annual
bonuses and that he did not intend to allow Jennifer’s spousal
support to automatically increase without considering her own
pay increases.
The family court held a hearing in September of 2024. It
awarded Jennifer the arrears sought, as well as $10,000 in
attorney’s fees and $7,500 in costs pursuant to Family Code
sections 271 and 2030.4 It reasoned: “[Kevin] signed off on a
judgment that stated that anything above said base salary, and
then it included what that base salary was. It says what it says.
It was negotiated and signed off on. People are free to enter into
crappy agreements or poorly drafted agreements or agreements
that they later find were not as good as they might have
preferred. This is the agreement your client signed off on. It
might not even be the agreement that the Court would have said
is a good agreement, but it says what it says. It says anything
above a specific amount is subject to an Ostler-Smith. It says
what it says. There is nothing ambiguous about it, which I think
the Court said last time, and the Court has said it again.” The
family court entered a written order on October 23, 2024 (October
23 order).5

4 Undesignated statutory references are to the Family

Code.

5 Kevin first appealed the July 29 written order and the

September 4 oral ruling (no. B341078). He later appealed the
October 23 order (no. B343541). We consolidated the appeals for
briefing, oral argument, and disposition pursuant to stipulation.

7
DISCUSSION
Kevin contends the family court misinterpreted the
judgment by treating post-judgment increases to his base salary
as Ostler-Smith income subject to division with Jennifer. He
requests we reduce the spousal and child support arrears award,
remand for an evidentiary hearing to determine his 2022 and
2023 income, and clarify that prospective Ostler-Smith
calculations will not include base salary increases nor unvested
stock compensation. He also challenges the retroactive date of
the family court’s child support modification and the awarding of
expert costs to Jennifer that are not yet incurred.
Kevin’s Base Salary Increases Are Not Subject
To Division Under Ostler-Smith
We interpret the terms of a marital settlement agreement
incorporated into a stipulated judgment under the general rules
governing the interpretation of contracts. (In re Marriage of Schu
(2014) 231 Cal.App.4th 394, 399.) “Where no extrinsic evidence is
introduced, or the extrinsic evidence is not in conflict, we
independently construe the agreement. [Citation.]” (Ibid.) We
construe the contract as a whole, interpreting all provisions
together to give effect to all, if reasonably possible or practicable.
(City of Atascadero v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith, Inc.
(1998) 68 Cal.App.4th 445, 473.) “A contract must, if possible, be
given a reasonable rather than an unreasonable construction.”
(Broome v. Broome (1951) 104 Cal.App.2d 148, 157.)
We agree the family court misinterpreted the judgment. It
focused on just one phrase: “Respondent shall pay to Petitioner a
percentage of his compensation in excess of Respondent’s base
salary of $12,989 per month . . . .” Placing this phrase in context,
however, shows the parties intended “Exhibit ‘A’” to apply only to

8
fluctuating bonus-type income received by Kevin and not to
increases to his base salary.
Both parties refer to the bonus table as an “Ostler-Smith”
schedule. The purpose of an Ostler-Smith calculation “is to
capture fluctuations in the supporting spouse’s income that are
not included in a flat rate amount of support.” (In re Marriage of
Minkin (2017) 11 Cal.App.5th 939, 949 (Minkin); see Hogoboom
& King, Cal. Practice Guide: Family Law (The Rutter Group
2025) § 6:187.1 [“There also is a ‘Bonus Schedule’ in
[DissoMaster] that can assure an accurate support calculation
when a party has irregular or fluctuating income (e.g., bonuses,
overtime, stock options, etc.)”].) “Case law justifies an [Ostler-
Smith] award ‘on the ground that future bonuses are not
guaranteed, and it would be unfair to require the obligor to file
motions for modification every time a bonus is reduced [or
denied].’” (Minkin, at p. 949.)
The stipulated judgment contemplates a one-time, annual
calculation of Kevin’s additional child and spousal support
obligation added to the fixed monthly support obligations. The
additional obligations are based on the DissoMaster report
attached to the judgment as “Exhibit ‘A.’” The report clearly
differentiates between salary and bonus income. Page one is
titled “DissoMaster Report 2021 Monthly” and lists both parties’
“Wages + salary.” It sets monthly guideline child support of $366
and spousal support of $400. The attached bonus table, in
contrast, is titled “Kevin Annual Bonus Wages Report 2021
Yearly.” (Italics added.) It defines support as percentages of
“[b]onus paid as additional . . . [s]upport.” This shows the parties
“intended the annual bonus phrase to refer to a fluctuating,
discretionary payment [Kevin] received from his employer based

9
on performance, not more broadly to all payments he received
above base salary.” (Minkin, supra, 11 Cal.App.5th at p. 949.)
Conflating monthly “salary” with yearly “bonus wages” ignores
the plain text of the report.
In addition, the judgment requires Kevin to pay his Ostler-
Smith obligation “within seven (7) business days” of receiving
bonus wages. Treating base salary increases as bonus wages, it
follows, will require Kevin to re-calculate his support obligations
after receiving every paycheck. Jennifer’s RFO and the family
court orders all ignored this peculiar outcome. Jennifer
calculated arrears and interest based on a single, annual Ostler-
Smith payment due on January 1—not multiple payments
throughout the year. As Jennifer conceded in oral argument, the
court’s interpretation incentivizes Kevin to seek modification
whenever his base salary increases so he can reduce the amount
of pay subject to the Ostler-Smith table.6
The parties negotiated Kevin’s support obligations based on
their financial circumstances at the time of settlement. The
judgment states, “[t]he spousal support set forth herein is based
upon all of the financial circumstances set forth in each party’s
Schedule of Assets and Debts, their respective incomes and the
financial circumstances set forth in the DissoMaster [Report]
attached hereto . . . .” (Italics added.) It similarly states, “[t]he
child support set forth and the percentage of additional child
support is pursuant to the financial circumstances and bonus

6 This is, in fact, what the family court did after the June

18 hearing. Although the court said it denied Jennifer’s request
to modify spousal support, its July 29 order reflected Kevin’s base
pay increase (i.e., $17,655) and ordered him to pay an Ostler-
Smith percentage on “anything above” that amount.

10
table set forth in the DissoMaster [Report] attached hereto . . . .”
(Italics added.) Considering Kevin’s base salary increases but not
Jennifer’s would run afoul of the judgment’s admonition to
interpret its terms “simply and fairly, and not strictly for or
against either of the parties.” The court’s interpretation
incentivizing future modification requests would contradict the
judgment’s stated intent “to resolve all rights and obligations
relating to spousal support.” It would also build perpetual
nonguideline child support into the judgment—an issue we
discuss in more detail below.
Support Arrears Award
As we have stated, the family court misinterpreted the
judgment when calculating child and spousal support arrears by
applying an Ostler-Smith to Kevin’s regular salary increases.
Accordingly, it must reverse the order and recalculate arrears for
2022 and 2023 on remand. The court must also determine what
should be included in Kevin’s compensation. Kevin acknowledges
the judgment’s Ostler-Smith provision applies to vested stock
options and other forms of non-salary compensation available to
pay support. He argues it does not apply to “phantom” W-2
income like non-vested stock options. We leave the family court
to resolve what compensation was available to Kevin to pay
support in those years. (See In re Marriage of Macilwaine (2018)
26 Cal.App.5th 514, 518 (Macilwaine) [section 4058, subdivision
(a)(1) “must be construed to include all compensation that has
been conferred upon and is available to the employee”].)
Prospective Child Support
Jennifer contends the July 29 child support order is
guideline but also argues the court was required to follow the
parties’ non-guideline method of calculating of support, i.e., by

11
including all Kevin’s base salary increases but not her’s. We need
not reconcile these seemingly contradictory assertions. Jennifer
forfeited any claim to non-guideline support when she consented
to guideline support in the family court. Moreover, no language
in the judgment suggests the parties intended child support (or
future modifications to support) to be non-guideline.
Jennifer’s first RFO sought guideline child support based
on their current financial information. Kevin consented to this.
A modification to child support that considered Kevin’s base
salary increases but not Jennifer’s would not be guideline. A
court deviating from guideline child support must “state, in
writing or on the record” the reasons for the deviation and why
the ordered support is “consistent with the best interests of the
children.” (§ 4056, subd. (a), (a)(2) & (3).) The family court made
no such findings here. The July 29 order set a base amount of
child support and ordered Kevin to pay additional support
“subject to an Ostler-Smith table for anything above [Kevin’s]
normal base salary of $17,655 per month.” An updated
DissoMaster report is attached to the order. The report
calculates monthly child support as $591 based on both Kevin’s
and Jennifer’s current monthly base salaries. An updated bonus
table (titled “Kevin Annual Bonus Wages Report 2024 Yearly”) is
attached as well. We affirm this part of the order as “adher[ing]
to the statewide uniform guideline.” (§ 4052.) As with spousal
support, we leave the family court to resolve any disputes over
what types of non-salary compensation to include in future
Ostler-Smith calculations.
Retroactive Child Support Award
Kevin does not challenge the order increasing his monthly
child support payment from $400 to $591 but contends the family

12
court erred by dating the increase retroactively to February 1,
2024. He argues the appropriate date is when Jennifer served
her RFO seeking the increase, i.e., April 19, 2024. (§ 3653, subd.
(a).) Jennifer concedes the issue. We will reverse the order in
this respect and direct the family court to modify the retroactive
date on remand.
Costs Award
Kevin contends the family court abused its discretion when
it awarded Jennifer $7,500 in costs because her supporting
documents showed she incurred only $5,000 in costs. Kevin
forfeited the issue by not raising it below. (See In re Marriage of
Whealon (1997) 53 Cal.App.4th 132, 144 [“errors must be brought
to the trial court’s attention at the trial level while the error can
still be expeditiously corrected”].)
DISPOSITION
The July 29 and October 23 orders after judgment are
vacated. We direct the court to re-calculate Kevin’s child and
spousal support arrears for 2022 and 2023 on remand. It shall
omit Kevin’s post-judgment base salary increases from bonus
income when calculating his Ostler-Smith arrears, but may
include other forms of non-salary compensation, e.g., vested stock
options, consistent with Macilwaine.
The family court shall order spousal support consistent
with the parties’ stipulated judgment and shall order prospective
guideline child support. For both spousal and child support it
shall omit Kevin’s post-judgment base salary increases from
bonus income subject to the Ostler-Smith table but it may include
other forms of non-salary compensation consistent with
Macilwaine.

13
It shall modify the retroactive date of its prior award of
guideline child support to April 19, 2024.
Either party may request a hearing on remand to present
evidence and argument as to these issues. The orders are
otherwise affirmed. Appellant shall recover his costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

CODY, J.

We concur:

YEGAN, Acting P. J.

BALTODANO, J.

14
Michael S. Lief, Judge
Superior Court County of Ventura
_______________________________

Ferguson Case Orr Paterson, Wendy C. Lascher and John
A. Hribar, for Appellant.
Taub & Taub, Richard F. Taub, for Respondent.

15

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.