CourtListener 10763090•In re A.H. CA2/8
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 12/22/25 In re A.H. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
In re A.H. et al., Persons Coming B343091
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
______________________________ Los Angeles County
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Super. Ct. No. 24CCJP03469
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
J.H.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Marguerite D. Downing, Judge. Affirmed.
Benjamin Ekenes, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Courtney Fisher, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________
The juvenile court ordered two young children removed
from their parents’ custody. Only the father appeals, arguing the
Los Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services
failed to prove by clear and convincing evidence that allowing the
children to relocate with him to Wisconsin “would not be a
reasonable alternative to the last resort of removing the children
from father’s custody.” We affirm. Undesignated statutory
citations refer to the Welfare and Institutions Code.
I
The children in this case are A.H. (born April 2019) and
M.H. (born May 2021).
The Department received its first referral about A.H. and
M.H. in July 2024. According to the caller, the children’s mother
and A.H. have autism diagnoses and receive welfare benefits.
The mother is divorced from the children’s father, who lived in
Wisconsin. The mother and children were living with relatives,
but she planned to move out to her own place. The caller was
concerned for the children’s safety because the mother would hit
both children on the head and face and curse at them when she
became upset. This referral was deemed “inconclusive.”
In October 2024, the Department received a referral
alleging A.H. had come to school with a “fresh” looking black eye.
At first, A.H. said a fall caused his black eye, but after more
questioning, A.H. said “my mom told me I was not allowed to tell
anyone so I just fell.”
2
Within thirty minutes of receiving the referral, a
Department social worker went to A.H.’s school to investigate.
The social worker interviewed A.H., who knew the social worker
had come because of his black eye. When the social worker asked
what happened to his eye, A.H. again said “oh I fell.” But after
the social worker questioned him more, A.H. admitted “don’t tell
my mother that [I] said it, she hit me with the phone.” A.H. said
he was “not sure” why his mother hit him but also said his
mother “smacks” him if he does not behave.
Later that same day, the social worker interviewed the
mother. The mother appeared “extremely nervous” and denied
hitting A.H., saying he fell from the couch to the trampoline and
hit his eye on the TV stand. The mother also said her children
are extremely active and often fall and hit themselves. She
stated she did not use any objects to discipline her children and
denied leaving marks or bruises on them.
The social worker then visited the family’s home, where she
spoke to the father. He insisted on their conversation taking
place a block away from the home because he was worried the
mother would hear. The social worker did not believe the father
was being honest because he was constantly looking back
towards the house and still believed the mother might somehow
overhear their conversation.
Eventually, the father told the social worker he had come
from Wisconsin to stay at the mother’s home because he was
worried about their children. The father became emotional and
said the mother forced him to sign divorce papers giving her full
custody of their children. He claimed to not understand what he
was doing when he signed them and that he loved his children.
3
The father also said that during their relationship and
marriage, the mother physically assaulted him, but no one would
believe him if he said anything. He said he had recorded many
videos of the mother yelling at the children and cursing, but he
was scared to share the videos because the mother would know
he was showing them. The father showed the videos to the social
worker, but refused to send them to her because he was scared of
the mother. In one video, the mother was coaching A.H. on what
to say at school about falling and hitting his eye, as she put on
his shoes.
In another video, the mother was lying on the ground while
talking and yelling at the children. The father said “she does
random stuff like that.” He has encouraged the mother to get
help for her mental health, but she has not listened to him. The
family’s sole source of income to pay for rent and living expenses
was from welfare benefits for the children. The father said he
had health issues from a car accident and had been unable to find
work since he moved from Wisconsin. He depended on the
mother for shelter and transportation.
The father’s family lives in Wisconsin and he said he was
willing to take the children to Wisconsin if necessary. However,
he also noted he has no custody rights since signing the divorce
settlement.
When the social worker encouraged the father to report
domestic violence to law enforcement, the father expressed fear.
In the words of the Department’s report: “It appears [that] the
father claimed he is here to protect [the] children, but he is
unable to protect them when mother gets upset and loud.”
While she was at the family’s home, the social worker also
assessed M.H., who appeared to be healthy and well-groomed.
4
There were no marks or bruises on M.H.’s body. M.H. was too
young to say anything meaningful to the social worker.
Later that same day, the social worker called the children's
maternal grandmother Gloria A. Gloria A. said the mother has
used physical force on the children before. She also said she
would be willing to help take care of the children if necessary.
The social worker did not believe she could leave the
children alone with the parents and devised a 7-day safety plan,
according to which the children would stay with Gloria A. The
parents agreed to the safety plan. That night, Gloria A. picked
up the children.
When the social worker checked in with Gloria A. a few
days later, she learned both children had diaper rashes, the
mother had ignored Gloria A.’s request for more diapers and the
children’s shoes, and that neither parent called about the
children over the weekend. Gloria A. also mentioned A.H.
admitted the mother hit him with her phone because he and M.H
would not go to sleep, which made her angry.
As for the father, Gloria A. said he came to live with the
mother because of “her financial stability and housing situation.”
She also said she was worried he might drive recklessly with the
children in the car.
The Department’s investigation continued with a call to
Emily A., the children’s maternal aunt. Emily A. told the social
worker the history of the parents’ tumultuous relationship. They
met online and after two in-person meetings, the mother moved
to Wisconsin to be with the father in June 2018. Then she
became pregnant with A.H. and she married the father shortly
after A.H.’s birth.
5
At first, the mother and father lived alone, but then the
father’s parents and siblings moved in with them. The mother
had difficulty adjusting to this change and invited Emily A. to
visit. Emily A. observed conflict between the mother and father.
After one of their arguments, the mother decided to move back to
California with the children in August 2021. However, after she
moved, the parents reconciled and the father would buy plane
tickets for the mother to visit him in Chicago. Nevertheless, the
mother eventually filed for divorce.
At some point after moving back, the mother and the
children lived with Emily A. Emily A. observed multiple
incidents of the mother using physical force on the children. For
instance, the mother hit A.H. multiple times while they were
waiting in line for a Monster Jam show in January 2024. Emily
A. said the mother would hit the children when she is frustrated
with them or wants to get away from them.
Emily A. shared some photos from June 2024 of the
children’s injuries. One photo showed A.H. with a bruise on his
thigh and calf. A.H. told Emily A. that the mother had dragged
him at the mall when no other relatives were present. In another
photo, M.H. had a scratch on his nose from the mother hitting
him. A third photo showed a bruise on M.H.’s back. A.H. said
that the bruise was caused by the mother pulling M.H. down
from the top of the bunk bed.
Regarding the father, Emily A. reported he had “emotional
issues,” such as crying and expressing feelings of being disliked.
Emily A. described the father as weak and unable to protect the
children. Like Gloria A., Emily A. believed the father’s
relationship with the mother was for his own financial gain,
6
because he did not contribute anything and relied on the mother’s
resources.
After speaking with Emily A., the social worker received
the report from a forensic medical exam of A.H. When the nurse
conducting the exam asked A.H. why he had come, he replied “my
mom threw a phone at me. Do you see the blue mark?” The
nurse noted A.H.’s injury was consistent with his description of
what happened.
Based on this information, the Department applied for and
received a removal order from the juvenile court about a week
after the October 2024 referral call.
II
In November 2024, the Department filed a section 300
petition on behalf of A.H. and M.H., alleging the mother inflicted
serious physical harm on them, and that the father knew of this
physical abuse but failed to protect the children. Both parents
denied the allegations.
At the initial hearing, the Department recommended the
court detain the children. In response, the father asked the court
to release the children to him, arguing the Department did not
provide any evidence that he, by himself, was a danger to the
children. The father said he lived in Wisconsin and was just
visiting during the Department’s investigation, and asked the
court to allow him to take the children back to Wisconsin. If the
court would not allow him to take the children to Wisconsin, the
father said he would live with the children in a hotel. The father
argued his proposal was a reasonable alternative to removal.
The mother joined the father’s request.
The children, through counsel, joined the Department’s
request and opposed the father’s. Counsel pointed out the
7
mother had physically assaulted the father, he seemed scared of
her, and did not seem able to protect the children.
The court followed the Department’s recommendation and
ordered the children removed from the parents, but also
scheduled a pre-release investigation hearing to assess the
possibility of releasing the children to their father.
After the hearing, a Department social worker began the
pre-release investigation by interviewing the father. He told the
social worker “I’ve been caring for my kids a lot. I love my kids.
I’ve always been, you know, providing for them even the times
that I was not physically with them I was still sending them
financial support. Since I got here, I have been cooking for them
. . . I think that I can be responsible in taking care of my
children.”
The social worker asked about the father’s living situation,
and he provided the address of an apartment in Chatsworth, but
also pointed out that his “original home” is in Wisconsin. When
the social worker asked if the mother also lived at this address,
the father said: “I have no idea. She left this morning. I’m not
too sure where she went.” At first, the father seemed unsure of
whether he was on the lease for the apartment, but then said he
was “100% sure” he was on the lease.
The social worker explained that even if the court released
the children to him, the father would still be responsible for
making sure the mother did not return to their home or have
unlimited access to the children. The father said he understood
and was “trying to work with you guys and get this the best way
possible.”
The father then said: “I was dealing with this, with her
violence, just to stay with the kids . . . it’s just the pressure that
8
she has [sole custody].” He explained that he stayed silent about
the mother’s abuse because he had signed the divorce agreement
and thought he would never see his children again if he reported
the mother. When the social worker asked why the father did not
take action sooner, he responded: “There were visitations as I
said and we were going through the divorce process. I was doing
my best to connect with her regardless of all the trauma.”
As for his plans for the children, the father said he would
take them to school, but that it was in his best interest to take
them to Wisconsin, where his family resides and would help him
financially. He was not planning to stay in California. Although
he had some health issues when he first came to California that
made it hard for him to find a job, he was now working full-time
as a rideshare driver.
The next day, the social worker called Gloria A. to speak
about the possibility of the children living with the father. Gloria
A. expressed concern because of the father’s lack of parenting
experience, inability to provide financially, and inability to
protect the children from their mother. According to Gloria A.,
the father was not involved with the children for at least two and
a half years when the mother moved back to California. Gloria A.
also pointed out the father had only been working as a rideshare
driver for a week, despite living in California for months, and had
fought with the mother about getting half of the children’s
welfare benefits. She was certain the father was aware of the
mother’s physical abuse of the children, but he was more focused
on protecting the mother instead of the children.
The social worker continued her investigation by speaking
with the children’s maternal great aunt Eva F., their maternal
aunts Kate A. and Emily A., and paternal uncle Basel H.
9
All three maternal relatives expressed concern about
releasing the children to the father. Eva F. said the father was
“overwhelmed,” “not the most motivated individual,” and mostly
focused on maximizing his potential settlement from car accident
lawsuits. Emily A. reported the father drives fast and recklessly,
did not have proper car seats for the children, and left razor
blades around and a hookah on the floor. Kate A. shared that
there was one instance when the parents gave A.H. “to some
random stranger” when the mother had to go to the hospital
when they lived in Wisconsin.
Basel H. was the only relative who did not report any
concerns about the father having custody over the children: “I
would be totally fine if [the father] actually had the kids. [He] is
actually more protective.” Basel H. also said he saw the mother
scream at the children in Wisconsin and that the father told him
that the mother physically abused them. When the social worker
asked what the father did to protect the children from the
mother’s abuse, Basel H. said the father contacted his family
because he was afraid to go to the police.
Based on its investigation, the Department recommended
against releasing the children to the father. In its report, the
Department found “the father clearly failed to protect the
children by allowing them to be in the mother’s care for a
prolonged period of time without taking any actions to ensure
that the children are safe. The father’s intense fear of retribution
by the mother is extremely concerning and shows that he had
clear knowledge of the mother’s abilities to attempt to or
successfully cause physical harm, yet has not taken the necessary
steps to protect the children.” The report also expressed doubt
that the father would be able to set boundaries with the mother
10
and keep the mother away from the children, “as evidenced by his
prior tendencies and fearfulness of the mother.” It noted the
father had been “overly vague” about his living situation. The
report concluded the children’s current placement with Gloria A.
was appropriate.
At the next hearing, the father objected to the
Department’s recommendation, arguing that at the time of the
report, the mother had not yet moved out and that she was no
longer at the residence. He reiterated that he was not a danger
to the children.
The children’s attorney responded that the report was
“extremely thorough about [the] father’s lack of protective
capacity with regard to the children.”
After hearing from all parties, the court stated: “based
upon the report, I agree with the Department, there is a concern
about protective capacity in the event the mother has to move in,
so at this time the children will remain where they are.” The
court then scheduled the disposition hearing for the following
month.
The Department’s December 2024 disposition report
recommended sustaining the allegations in the petition, removing
the children from physical custody of the parents, and ordering
family reunification services for the parents.
Attached to the report was a copy of the August 2024
dissolution judgment of the parents’ marriage and settlement
agreement. The settlement agreement gave the mother sole legal
and sole physical custody of the children and allowed the father
to have visitation with the children. According to the agreement,
the mother represented herself in the dissolution proceedings and
the father had counsel who approved the settlement.
11
At the disposition hearing, the court sustained the
allegations against both parents, over the father’s objections, and
ordered the children removed from the custody of the parents.
III
A juvenile court may not remove a child from a parent’s
physical custody “unless the juvenile court finds by clear and
convincing evidence . . . [that] there is or would be a substantial
danger to the physical health, safety, protection, or physical or
emotional well-being of the [child] if the [child] were returned
home, and there are no reasonable means by which the [child’s]
physical health can be protected without removing the [child]
from the [child’s] parent’s . . . physical custody.” (§ 361, subd.
(c)(1).)
The parties agree on the appropriate standard of review:
whether substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s
dispositional finding of clear and convincing evidence that it was
reasonable and necessary to remove the children from the father.
(See Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, 1011–1012
[“When reviewing a finding that a fact has been proved by clear
and convincing evidence, the question before the appellate court
is whether the record as a whole contains substantial evidence
from which a reasonable factfinder could have found it highly
probable the fact was true”].) Under this standard, we view the
record in the light most favorable to the Department and defer to
how the juvenile court evaluated the credibility of witnesses,
resolved conflicts in the evidence, and drew reasonable inferences
from this evidence. (See id.)
On appeal, the father faults the Department for failing to
“adequately explore” the possibility of allowing him to relocate
with the children to Wisconsin as an alternative to the “last
12
resort” of removing them from his custody. He claims this failure
precludes the Department from proving by clear and convincing
evidence that there were no reasonable means to protect the
children without removing them from his custody. Additionally,
he argues the court could have continued the disposition hearing
to allow the Department to assess the suitability of his Wisconsin
home for the children.
Two cases form the foundation of the father’s argument on
appeal: In re M.V. (2022) 78 Cal.App.5th 944 (M.V.) and In re
John M. (2006) 141 Cal.App.4th 1564, 1567 (John M.). Like this
case, M.V. concerned allegations of a mother who was the
“domina[nt] aggressor” and a father who failed to protect. (See
M.V., 78 Cal.App.5th at p. 961.) In M.V., the appellate court
reversed a removal order for lack of substantial evidence when it
found the juvenile court did not “adequately consider” the option
of ordering the mother to leave the home as an alternative to
removal. (Id. at p. 964.) And in John M., the appellate court
found the juvenile court erred in denying a noncustodial father’s
request for a continuance of the dispositional hearing to allow the
agency to assess the suitability of a placement with the father in
Tennessee. (John M., supra, 141 Cal.App.4th at p. 1572.)
In response, the Department contends “[t]he record
contains ample evidence from which the juvenile court reasonably
determined under the heightened clear and convincing standard
that [A.H] and [M.H] would be at substantial risk of serious
physical harm if they were returned to the father, regardless of
whether they lived in California or Wisconsin.” The Department
also argues it was not necessary for its reports to address
specifically the father’s proposed move to Wisconsin, as this
13
Court must presume the juvenile court implicitly considered and
rejected this request in its dispositional finding.
The Department is right. The record is clear the juvenile
court duly considered whether it was safe to release A.H. and
M.H. to the father as an alternative to removal—it ordered the
Department to prepare a report and held a hearing on this very
issue. Although the Department’s report did not explicitly
address a potential move to Wisconsin, it did assess the father’s
ability to protect the children from the mother—the threshold
issue that governs, regardless of where the father lives.
According to the report, the father said the mother “forced” him
to sign paperwork giving her full custody of the children against
his wishes. And instead of intervening when the mother was
being violent or reporting it to law enforcement, the father
recorded videos of her behavior. The report explained that the
father’s fear of the mother prevented him from standing up to her
to protect the children, despite his awareness of her violent
tendencies.
The father’s failure to recognize the risks to which he
exposed M.H. and A.H. alone is substantial evidence supporting
the juvenile court’s decision to order removal of the children.
(See In re A.F. (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th 283, 293.) Nothing in the
record suggests the father is aware of his role in enabling the
mother to harm the children, which makes it unlikely that he can
protect them from her in the future, even if he moves out of state.
(See In re V.L. (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 147, 156–157.) Viewing this
evidence in the light most favorable to the Department, we reject
the father’s argument that the Department was required to
assess the option of allowing the father to take the children to
Wisconsin as an alternative to removal. (See ibid.)
14
The father’s reliance on M.V. is unavailing, for that case is
readily distinguishable. First, in M.V., the violence was between
the mother and father, not the mother and children. (M.V.,
supra, 78 Cal.App.5th at p. 951.) Second, the father in M.V.
demonstrated that he could protect his children; he called law
enforcement to report violence by the mother and a social worker
testified it was safe to place the children with him. (Id. at p.
961.) Third, in M.V., the social worker admitted the health and
human services agency never explored the option of removing the
mother from the home, even after the children’s counsel
requested this option. (Id. at p. 964.)
Turning to the father’s John M. argument that the court
should have continued the hearing to allow further assessment of
the proposed relocation to Wisconsin, the father never asked the
juvenile court for such a continuance. As the Department
correctly argued, the father forfeited this issue by failing to raise
it before the juvenile court. (In re Sofia M. (2018) 24 Cal.App.5th
1038, 1046.)
DISPOSITION
We affirm the juvenile court’s order.
WILEY, J.
We concur:
STRATTON, P. J. VIRAMONTES, J.
15
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.