In Ne.L. CA6

CourtListener 10736039Calctapp13.11.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 11/13/25 In Ne.L. CA6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

In re Ne.L. et al., Persons Coming Under H053000
the Juvenile Court Law. (Santa Cruz County
Super. Ct. Nos. 23JU00145,
23JU00146, 23JU00147)

SANTA CRUZ COUNTY HUMAN
SERVICES DEPARTMENT,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

N.L.,

Defendant and Appellant.

Appellant N.L. (Mother) challenges the juvenile court’s 12-month status review
orders extending reunification services. Mother contends that the juvenile court erred in
finding she made minimal progress in her case plan and that returning her youngest child,
Na.L., would create a substantial risk of detriment.1 We affirm.

Although Mother’s notice of appeal identified all three children’s orders, she
1

clarified in her opening brief that she challenges only the order concerning the youngest
sibling, Na.L. Mother raises no arguments regarding the other children. Accordingly, we
dismiss as abandoned the appeal from the orders concerning Ne.L. and No.L. (See In re
Sade C. (1996) 13 Cal.4th 952, 994.)
I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND2
The juvenile court ordered Mother’s three children, Ne.L. (born 2009), No.L.
(born 2010), and Na.L. (born 2015), detained and placed with maternal grandmother after
Ne.L. was found with bruising to her eyes and a hematoma on her head. Respondent
Santa Cruz County Human Services Department (the Department) had received referrals
about the impact of Mother’s mental health on the children. Mother also had a history of
methamphetamine use. At the jurisdiction and disposition hearing, the juvenile court
ordered family reunification services for Mother. The court also ordered Mother to
participate in the Department’s case plan, which included a psychological evaluation, a
substance use disorder assessment, counseling, and random drug testing. In appeal
number H052009, Mother appealed the jurisdictional and disposition orders regarding
Na.L., which we affirmed.
Mother completed the psychological evaluation and was diagnosed with
generalized anxiety disorder. Her responses in the evaluation demonstrated
characteristics such as grandiosity, defensiveness, and difficulty with emotional
regulation but also showed that she was able to think about complex issues. The juvenile
court granted the Department’s request to add the doctor’s recommendations to the case
plan. The updated case plan required Mother to complete individual and family therapy,
attend parenting classes, and obtain housing support and substance use treatment. Mother
obtained housing in San Mateo County. At the contested six-month review hearing, the

2
Our unpublished opinions in Mother’s prior appeals of the jurisdiction and
disposition orders and six-month status review orders provide additional background of
the proceedings in this dependency matter. (In re Ne.L. et al.; Santa Cruz County HSD v.
N.L. (Dec. 11, 2024, H052009) [nonpub. opn.]; In re N.C. et al.; Santa Cruz County HSD
v. N.L. (Aug. 12, 2025, H052794) [nonpub. opn.].) We take judicial notice of those
unpublished opinions. (See ZF Micro Devices, Inc. v. TAT Capital Partners, Ltd. (2016)
5 Cal.App.5th 69, 73, fn. 3 [appellate court may take judicial notice of its prior
unpublished decision].) We recite where necessary information from our earlier opinions
to resolve this appeal.

2
juvenile court found that Mother made minimal progress toward alleviating or mitigating
the causes necessitating the children’s placement with maternal grandmother. The
juvenile court also determined by a preponderance of the evidence that returning the
children to Mother would create a substantial risk of detriment to their safety and well-
being. The court ordered family reunification services be continued. In appeal number
H052794, Mother appealed the six-month review order concerning Na.L., which we
affirmed.
A. Progress Before the 12-Month Review Hearing
1. Mother’s Counseling
According to the Department’s 12-month review report, Mother told the
Department that she worked with a Kaiser Permanente counselor and a life coach. She
began individual therapy with a therapist over two months before the Department’s
report. The Department had difficulty assessing therapy’s impact on Mother and her
goals because as of the report, Mother had not provided a release of information for any
provider about her child welfare therapeutic goals. Despite Mother’s participation in
therapy, the Department did not observe a behavioral change that suggested she could
safely parent her children without oversight. It characterized Mother’s interactions with the
Department as “combative” with “frequent disagreement.”
2. Relationship with Children
The Department reported that Mother faced challenges parenting her children.
Mother blamed her eldest child, Ne.L., for the family’s circumstances. During a family
meeting, Ne.L. stated that she did not want to attend family therapy with Mother. The
assigned social worker commended Ne.L. for speaking her mind. After the meeting,
Mother called the social worker and expressed anger that the social worker supported
Ne.L. at the meeting. Mother also told the social worker that Ne.L., whose physical
injuries had caused the children to be removed from Mother, lied about her. Mother
described maternal grandmother and Ne.L. as enemies conspiring against her. An

3
incident with Mother occurred about a month prior to the Department’s 12-month review
report. Mother visited the children at maternal grandmother’s home. Maternal
grandmother asked her to leave because it was the children’s bedtime. Mother refused to
leave and became upset. Maternal grandmother told the Department that Mother blamed
Ne.L. and accused Ne.L. of lying to social workers. Ne.L. called law enforcement. After
law enforcement arrived, Mother left the home. Ne.L. told the Department that she and
her brothers must remain with maternal grandmother.
The middle child, No.L., informed the Department that he enjoyed some visits
with Mother. Mother was a strong advocate for No.L.’s educational needs and attended
his individualized education plan meetings. However, he occasionally refused to see
Mother because she was “too emotional.” He also felt she favored Na.L., the subject of
this appeal. No.L. told the Department that Mother’s behavior had not changed and she
was still emotionally volatile.
Na.L. enjoyed being with Mother and hoped to live with her again. The
Department reported that Mother and Na.L. had positive visits. When visiting Na.L. and
No.L., she incorporated enjoyable activities, such as outdoor outings. Na.L. also
expressed concern that Mother would prevent him from seeing maternal grandmother as
she did before. He feared Mother would become angry if he stated his desire to see his
paternal relatives. Ne.L. informed the Department that Na.L. would become angry in
maternal grandmother’s home because Mother told Na.L. that he would live with her
again and did not have to listen to maternal grandmother’s rules. Family members also
told the Department that Mother’s comments caused Na.L. emotional distress.
The Department reported that Mother did not provide evidence that she completed
parenting classes. Mother inquired about sessions with a parenting coach but did not
provide verification that sessions had commenced.
The Department concluded that the risk of returning the children to Mother’s care
was high. It noted that Mother did not always comply with her case plan’s objectives.

4
She continued behaving in ways that brought her to the juvenile court’s attention and
minimized the severity of the concerns that led to the children’s removal. Mother also
exhibited limited insight into how her behavior impacted her children. She attributed the
issues with her older children primarily to their adolescence. The Department opined that
Mother rarely acknowledged the impact of other significant factors, including incidents
the children experienced while living with her. The Department reported that Mother
attempted to manipulate the siblings by favoring Na.L. and creating division among the
children. Mother continued exhibiting heightened anxiety, especially with Na.L., which
escalated family tensions.
The Department recognized Mother’s periods of improvement, noting that she
started therapy and maintained her sobriety. Mother also expressed that she wanted her
children to be happy. With consistent therapy and self-reflection into the causes of the
dependency proceedings, the Department opined that Mother could reunify with her
children within the next six months. The Department also noted that “[Mother]
believe[d] she need[ed] six more months of reunification and to [receive] services in her
county of residence in order to successfully reunify.”
3. Substance Use
The Department reported that Mother made some progress with her case plan’s
substance use objective. Mother completed a substance abuse disorder assessment and
did not meet the criteria for a disorder. She did not require treatment, and she reported
that she was not using illegal substances. However, Mother did not consistently complete
mandated drug tests. Of the tests she completed, she tested negative for substances other
than marijuana. She also did not complete an ordered hair follicle test.
B. 12-Month Review Hearing
Mother’s counsel submitted on the Department’s 12-month review report and a
letter from Mother. Mother stated in her letter that she wanted the court to continue
maintenance services until an 18-month review hearing. Mother’s counsel also said that

5
Mother would continue participating in the case plan and was “hopeful . . . [for]
reunification soon in her other county [of] residence.” The day before the hearing,
Mother submitted verification of her enrollment in a 12-week parent education and
family stabilization course. Mother expressed gratitude for the case plan. Adopting the
Department’s recommendations for continued reunification services, the juvenile court
found that Mother’s progress towards alleviating or mitigating the causes necessitating
placement in foster care was minimal but acknowledged her efforts. The juvenile court
also determined by a preponderance of the evidence that returning the children to Mother
would create a substantial risk of detriment to their safety, protection, or physical or
emotional well-being.
Mother timely appealed.
II. DISCUSSION
Mother contends the juvenile court erred in finding that Mother made minimal
progress in her case plan and that returning Na.L. to her care would create a substantial
risk of detriment. The Department asserts Mother forfeited her arguments by submitting
on the Department’s recommendation. The Department also maintains that substantial
evidence supports the juvenile court’s findings. Although we determine that Mother has
not forfeited her arguments, our review of the record does not support Mother’s
contentions.
A. Mother Has Not Forfeited Her Arguments
“As a general rule, a party is precluded from urging on appeal any point not raised
in the trial court.” (In re Richard K. (1994) 25 Cal.App.4th 580, 590.) “Dependency
matters are not exempt from this rule. [Citations.]” (In re S.B. (2004) 32 Cal.4th 1287,
1293, superseded by statute on another ground as stated in In re S.J. (2008)
167 Cal.App.4th 953, 962.) However, “a parent who submits on the reports in evidence
does not forfeit the right to appeal the juvenile court’s orders. . . . Only when a parent
submits on a social worker’s recommendation does he or she forfeit the right to contest

6
the juvenile court’s decision if it coincides with that recommendation. [Citation.]” (In re
T.V. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 126, 136.)
We hold that Mother has not forfeited her arguments. At the review hearing,
Mother and counsel made statements suggesting both Mother’s acquiescence to
reunification services and hope for family maintenance services. In its 12-month review
report, the Department reported that “[Mother] believe[d] she need[ed] six more months
of reunification and to [receive] services in her county of residence in order to
successfully reunify.” At the hearing, Mother did not contest this statement. However, in
her letter to the juvenile court, she wrote that “[f]urther accomplishment [would be] a
ruling of continued services to [an] 18[-]month review hearing, family maintenance with
continued services for [Na.L.].” (Emphasis added.) This suggests Mother desired family
maintenance services with Na.L. rather than family reunification services. At the 12-
month review hearing, Mother’s counsel stated that Mother was submitting on the
Department’s report. However, counsel also stated that “[Mother was] hopeful . . . [for]
reunification soon in her other county [of] residence.” (Emphasis added.)
In Steve J. v. Superior Court (1995) 35 Cal.App.4th 798, 813, the appellate court
found that “[b]ecause of [the appellant’s] counsel’s mixed message” of submitting on the
department recommendation but taking “exception [with] the court’s finding of
reasonable services,” the appellant did not forfeit her arguments. As in Steve J., Mother’s
counsel here presented a “mixed message” by stating that Mother submitted on the report
recommending reunification services but also that Mother was hoping to reunify with the
children soon. (Ibid.) Although Mother expressed gratitude for her case plan at the
hearing, she did not retract her written statement that she desired family maintenance
services for Na.L. Considering Mother’s letter and her counsel’s conflicting statements,

7
we conclude that Mother has not forfeited her challenges to the 12-month review order.
(Ibid.)
B. No Error in the Juvenile Court’s Minimal Progress Finding
Mother asserts the juvenile court erred in its minimal progress finding because she
completed a substance abuse and psychological assessment, participated in parenting
education, worked with a parenting coach, visited with her children as allowed by court
order, enrolled in individual counseling, and secured housing in San Mateo County. We
review the juvenile court’s minimal progress finding for substantial evidence. (See J.H.
v. Superior Court (2018) 20 Cal.App.5th 530, 535 (J.H.).) Evidence is substantial if it is
“ ‘reasonable, credible and of solid value. [Citation.]’ [Citation.]” (Tracy J. v. Superior
Court (2012) 202 Cal.App.4th 1415, 1424.) “We resolve all conflicts in favor of the
court’s determinations, and indulge all legitimate inferences to uphold its findings.
[Citation.]” (J.H., at p. 535.) It is the appellant’s burden to establish the evidence is
insufficient to support the juvenile court’s findings. (See In re A.G. (2017)
12 Cal.App.5th 994, 1001.)
Mother’s case plan required her participation in psychological and substance use
disorder assessments, drug testing, individual and family therapy, and parenting classes.
She was also required to obtain housing support and substance use treatment. Substantial
evidence supports the juvenile court’s minimal progress finding. We acknowledge that
Mother completed the psychological and substance use disorder assessments and
obtained housing in San Mateo County. Mother also did not require substance use
treatment because she was not diagnosed with a substance use disorder.
However, Mother did not complete all portions of her case plan, particularly those
aspects of the plan designed to protect the children from her substance use and unstable
mental health. These were the bases for the children’s removal. Despite her history of
methamphetamine abuse, she did not fully comply with her drug testing requirements
during the 12-month period. The record does not support her assertion that she was no

8
longer required to participate in any drug testing after the substance use disorder
assessment. She also did not complete a hair follicle test as requested. Although Mother
commenced therapy over two months prior to the 12-month review hearing, the
Department was unable to assess therapy’s impact on her goals because she did not
provide a waiver for any provider to share information. The Department did not observe
any behavioral change with Mother since she started therapy. Further, although she
inquired about parenting education, she did not provide the Department verification of
her attendance in a parenting program or work with a parenting coach. Mother filed a
certification of her enrollment in a parenting course only the day before the 12-month
review hearing. In short, she provided no consistent support for the court to conclude at
the time of the hearing that she was consistently sober, and sufficiently emotionally stable
to take custody of the children.
Mother contends that substantial evidence does not support the juvenile court’s
finding because she made progress on her case plan and demonstrated parental insight, in
contrast to the appellant in J.H., supra, 20 Cal.App.5th at pages 535-536. In J.H., the
appellate court found substantial evidence supported termination of reunification services
after the 12-month review hearing because the father was hostile toward social workers
and had a history of domestic violence but declined to participate in therapy. (Ibid.) The
father “neither made significant progress in resolving the problems that led to his
daughters’ removal from the home nor demonstrated his capacity to complete the
objectives of the case plan.” (Id. at p. 535.)
But here, as in J.H., the Department reported Mother exhibited combative
behavior towards social workers. Mother’s mental health and emotional regulation
issues—the cause of the dependency proceedings—were not resolved despite her
participation in therapy. No.L. reported to the Department that Mother was too
emotionally volatile to have custody of the children. Mother’s refusal to leave maternal
grandmother’s home until law enforcement arrived confirmed that assessment. Mother

9
also continued to blame Ne.L. for the dependency proceedings, and accused Ne.L. and
maternal grandmother of conspiring against her. Instead of acknowledging her parenting
role, Mother attributed her damaged relationship with the older children on their
adolescence. The Department reported that Mother minimized the incidents that arose
while the children lived with her and that resulted in their removal. On balance, although
the Department believed Mother could achieve reunification in six months given her
partial compliance with previous court orders, it noted that she had not yet completed
significant aspects of her case plan that were critical to the safety of the children.
For these reasons, we determine that substantial evidence supports the juvenile
court’s minimal progress finding.
C. No Error in the Juvenile Court’s Detriment Finding
Mother also asserts that substantial evidence does not support the juvenile court’s
detriment finding. A dependent child must be returned to their parent’s physical custody
at the 12-month status review hearing unless the juvenile court finds by a preponderance
of the evidence that return would create a substantial risk of detriment to the child’s
safety, protection, physical or emotional well-being. (Welf. & Inst. Code,
§ 366.21, subd. (f)(1).) We review the juvenile court’s detriment finding for substantial
evidence. (Angela S. v. Superior Court (1995) 36 Cal.App.4th 758, 763 (Angela S.).)
The substantial risk standard does not mean “ ‘the parent in question is less than ideal,
did not benefit from the reunification services as much as we might have hoped, or seems
less capable than an available foster parent or other family member.’ [Citation.]” (In re
Yvonne W. (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 1394, 1400 (Yvonne W.).) The standard requires a
more particular showing that “returning a child to parental custody represents some
danger to the child’s physical or emotional well-being. [Citations.]” (Ibid.)
The juvenile court based its detriment finding on the Department’s report that
Mother’s failure to fully address her mental health issues and lack of parental insight
were detrimental to Na.L. Mother contends that she demonstrated parental insight

10
because she understood her children’s individual needs and worked on her case plan.
Mother also expressed concern with the weight the juvenile court gave to the
Department’s opinion that she lacked parental insight.
While Mother recognized her children’s individual needs, Mother’s inability to
resolve her issues harmed Na.L.’s emotional well-being. Family members explained that
Mother’s statements that Na.L. did not have to listen to maternal grandmother and would
live with Mother soon caused Na.L. to exhibit anger in maternal grandmother’s home.
Despite Mother’s positive visits with Na.L., Na.L. feared Mother would prevent him
from seeing maternal grandmother and worried about her reaction if he told her that he
wanted to see his paternal relatives.
The juvenile court properly weighed the Department’s opinion that Mother’s lack
of parental insight would create a substantial risk of detriment to Na.L. Mother’s reliance
on Georgeanne G. v. Superior Court (2020) 53 Cal.App.5th 856, 869 (Georgeanne G.) is
unpersuasive. In Georgeanne G., the Department expressed concern that the appellant’s
partner would harm the appellant or her child because he had a domestic violence
conviction with a different victim. (Id. at p. 868.) The appellate court found the
Department’s concern unsupported because the appellant’s partner never harmed the
appellant or her child, and the appellant completed a domestic violence program for
victims. (Id. at pp. 868-869.) The appellate court also determined that the Department’s
concern that the appellant would violate a no-contact order between her partner and child
was speculative. (Id. at p. 869.) The court noted that the appellant attested that she
would follow future orders and understood the importance of complying with court
orders restricting contact between her partner and child. (Id. at p. 870.) However,
although the appellate court found that the Department failed to present substantial
evidence that returning the appellant’s child would create a substantial risk of detriment,
the court also concluded that a parent’s lack of insight may be considered by the juvenile
court when assessing whether a child may be safely returned home. (Id. at pp. 865-868.)

11
Here, the Department did not speculate. Rather, the social workers’ interactions
with Mother, her children, and her relatives supported the Department’s opinion that
returning the children to Mother, including Na.L., would be detrimental to them. Further,
Mother submitted on the Department’s report. She did not dispute the Department’s
description of her conduct. No.L. observed that Mother’s emotional and behavioral state
had not changed. Mother showed favoritism towards Na.L. to the detriment of No.L.’s
emotional well-being. Mother blamed Ne.L. during the incident in maternal
grandmother’s home. Additionally, Mother expressed anger towards a social worker
because the social worker commended Ne.L. for stating her thoughts at a family meeting.
Mother’s failure to understand her actions’ impact on her children directly affected
Na.L.’s emotional safety. Mother’s statements to Na.L. undermining grandmother’s
authority and promising that he would live with Mother soon caused his behavioral issues
at maternal grandmother’s house. In short, the Department’s opinion was “not merely
written in a conclusory fashion” but was “corroborated by [Mother’s] specific acts of
conduct.” (Constance K. v. Superior Court (1998) 61 Cal.App.4th 689, 692.)
Mother’s failure to regularly participate in her case plan’s therapeutic goals to
address her mental health and emotional regulation further supported the juvenile court’s
detriment finding. (See Yvonne W., supra, 165 Cal.App.4th at p. 1400 [“In evaluating
detriment, the juvenile court must consider the extent to which the parent participated in
reunification services. [Citations.]”].) As stated ante, Mother’s case plan required her
participation in therapy and parenting classes. Although Mother maintains that she used
her service providers appropriately, she commenced therapy only a few months before
the 12-month review hearing, provided no means for the Department to confirm her
progress, and provided evidence of her enrollment in parenting classes the day before the
hearing. (See Angela S., supra, 36 Cal.App.4th at pp. 763-764 [finding in part that the
appellant’s failure “to meaningfully address the conditions that brought her children” to
the juvenile court’s attention and the appellant’s “projection of blame onto others”

12
supported the court’s detriment finding].) Mother’s failure “ ‘to comply with material
aspects of the service plan . . . [was] enough to support a finding of detriment.’ ” (M.G.
v. Superior Court (2020) 46 Cal.App.5th 646, 660.)
D. Conclusion
We acknowledge that Mother has made progress in addressing the challenges that
caused the removal of her children. Family preservation is a priority in juvenile
dependency proceedings, and Mother’s love for Na.L. is clear. But here our task is to
determine whether substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s order finding that
returning Na.L. to Mother would create a substantial risk of detriment to his emotional
safety or well-being at the 12-month status review. (See Angela S., supra, 36
Cal.App.4th at p. 763.) Based on our careful review of the record under the relevant
standard of appellate review, we are compelled to affirm the juvenile court’s order.
III. DISPOSITION
The January 30, 2025 order from the 12-month review hearing concerning Na.L.
(Case No. 23JU00147) is affirmed. The appeal from the orders regarding Ne.L. (Case
No. 23JU00145) and No.L. (Case No. 23JU00146) are dismissed as abandoned.

13
_______________________________
Greenwood, P. J.

WE CONCUR:

______________________________________
Danner, J.

______________________________________
Kulkarni, J.*

H053000 - In re Ne.L. et al.; Santa Cruz County HSD v. N.L.

_____________
* Judge of the Santa Clara County Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant
to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.