In re Alex A. CA2/3

CourtListener 10708170Calctapp21.10.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 10/21/25 In re Alex A. CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule
8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

In re Alex A., et. al., Persons Coming B341553
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
_____________________________________
LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN AND Super. Ct. No. 24CCJP02216A-
FAMILY SERVICES, D)

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

A.A.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Debra Losnick, Judge. Affirmed.
David M. Yorton, Jr., under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Jane Kwon, Principal Deputy
County Counsel for Plaintiff and Respondent.

‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗

Father challenges the juvenile court’s jurisdictional
findings and dispositional orders as to his four children. Father
argues that the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings based on
his drug use and domestic violence were not supported by
substantial evidence. He contends the juvenile court abused its
discretion by ordering him to undergo weekly drug testing and a
full drug program with individual therapy as part of its
dispositional orders. Father also challenges the removal of the
children from his care. We affirm on all grounds.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
The parents began dating in 2010 and had their first child
in 2012. The family consists of mother, father, and their four
children: Alex (born in March 2012), Anajulia (born in May
2014), Antonio (born in November 2022), and Estella (born in
March 2024). The family has child welfare history from 2023,
which we discuss below. At the time of the present dependency
proceedings, father had recently moved out of the family home
and the maternal grandparents shared a two-bedroom apartment
with mother and the four children.
I. Child Welfare History
In November 2023, the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (DCFS) received a referral alleging

2
that in the presence of their children,1 the parents argued,
mother poured jugs of milk on father, and father hit mother five
to six times in the face with a closed fist. Father was arrested for
domestic violence as police determined he was the dominant
aggressor. DCFS investigated and the two older children
confirmed these events, except the children indicated father
pushed, not punched, mother. The parents verified the children’s
account. They declined to pursue a restraining order or family
law order, and father continued visiting the children in mother’s
home with no issues.
During the investigation, father reported smoking
marijuana weekly for sleep. In December 2023, father had one
no-show for drug testing and one positive drug test for
marijuana. DCFS referred mother for services and closed the
investigation, finding no risk of harm to the children.
II. DCFS’s Present Investigation
On July 6, 2024, mother called father, who had recently
moved out of the family home, and threatened to hang herself,
showing father a rope via FaceTime. The younger children, an
infant and toddler, were at home with mother during her suicide
threat. When police arrived, mother admitted to having several
prior suicide attempts and having postpartum depression. Police
placed mother on an involuntary psychiatric hold and left the
children in father’s custody
Three days later, on July 9, 2024, mother called the police,
claiming that burglars were in her home. Police responded and
found mother in the midst of a panic attack, pacing in the kitchen
with a knife in hand and breathing heavily. The infant and

1 Estella was not yet born.

3
toddler were again home with mother. Mother said she was
stressed and overwhelmed because father had not been helping
her with the children. Mother’s legs were covered in flea bites,
she had not bathed in several days, and the home was filthy.
Police placed mother on another psychiatric hold due to her
paranoia and delusions.
DCFS received referrals for these events and investigated
on July 10, 2024. DCFS inspected the family’s apartment,
finding all four children with mother. Mother told the DCFS
social worker that she was overwhelmed, anxious, and stressed
because father did not help her with their children. Mother
confirmed that the two younger children were in the home and
asleep during the knife incident. When she was discharged from
the hospital, mother picked up the children from father. Mother
informed DCFS that father was changing his work schedule so he
could have the children from noon to 4:00 p.m. to give her
assistance. She said father also needed services, but had no
concerns about the children being with father.
Mother confirmed that they had engaged in domestic
violence in November 2023 (the milk incident). Mother denied
that father pushed her; she said he threw tissue at her and she
fell. She and father separated shortly after father’s arrest.
When speaking with the social worker, father denied the
children were present for mother’s second mental health incident
involving the knife. He stated he was unaware of mother’s
postpartum mental health issues at the time but explained that
he had since adjusted his work schedule to provide her additional
support. Father admitted to using marijuana but denied any
other substance use. He also denied any history of domestic
violence with mother, stating there had been a “small incident,”

4
which he characterized as isolated. He stated they were no
longer in a relationship.
The eldest child, Alex (then twelve years old), confirmed
the two younger children were with mother during her July 6
suicide threat. When police were at their home, he and his
siblings went to a paternal relative’s home. However, all four
children returned to mother’s care within two days. Alex denied
ever seeing the parents use drugs or alcohol, and denied
witnessing domestic violence between the parents. Alex was not
afraid of either parent, but was concerned about mother.
Then-ten-year-old Anajulia stated she was in the car with
father on July 6 and heard mother threaten suicide over the
phone. Ever since, Anajulia had a stomachache and difficulty
eating. Anajulia reported that father drank “one drink once a
week,” which he got from the liquor store. Father was not
aggressive or incoherent after drinking; instead, he would just
sleep. Anajulia denied seeing domestic violence between the
parents.
The maternal grandmother stated she had no concerns
regarding mother’s mental health or the children’s wellbeing.
However, she expressed concern about father, stating that he was
very aggressive. The maternal grandmother wanted mother to
have protection from him. Father called mother a derogatory
name and frequently cursed at her. The maternal grandmother
believed father, who frequently threatened to take the children
away from mother, caused mother’s anxiety and stress. The
maternal grandmother disliked and feared father due to his
treatment of mother. She said father had broken into her home
and went into mother’s room, damaging doors and making a
mess.

5
III. Petition and Detention
On July 15, 2024, the juvenile court authorized DCFS to
detain the children from the parents. The two older siblings,
Alex and Anajulia, were placed with paternal relatives. The
younger two, Antonio and Estella, were placed with a foster
parent.
On July 17, 2024, DCFS filed a Welfare and Institutions
Code2 section 300 petition alleging Alex, Anajulia, Antonio, and
Estella were at serious risk of harm due to mother’s mental and
emotional problems and father’s failure to protect them from such
problems. On July 18, 2024, the parents entered denial pleas and
father was deemed the presumed father of the children. The
court detained the children from mother, and over DCFS’s
objections, released them to father on the condition that he reside
with a paternal relative. The court ordered monitored visits for
mother and that father was not to monitor mother’s visits.
IV. Further Investigation
In July, August, and September 2024, DCFS continued to
investigate and discovered the following.
Mother’s Mental Health Issues. Alex told DCFS that
mother would send the children to father “ ‘and hurt herself.’ ”
One time, mother tried to take a lot of pills when father and the
children were present. Father slapped the pills out of mother’s
hand and then monitored mother so that she did not try to hurt
herself. The incident gave Alex anxiety. Out of fear, Alex would
stay with mother to prevent her from harming herself. Anajulia
stated that mother was hospitalized twice for wanting to strangle

2 All undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare
and Institutions Code.

6
herself. Anajulia told father she did not want to stay with
mother because she was scared mother would hurt them.
Father admitted that after mother’s suicide threat
involving the rope, the police officer told father he could not leave
the children with mother. Despite this, father left the children in
mother’s care because her nineteen-year-old niece was present in
the home. Father also confirmed that the two younger children
were with mother during her paranoid episode involving a knife.
Following the knife incident, father took the children from
mother’s home, but he returned the children to mother’s care
days later.
Mother also confirmed that the children returned to her
care after both psychiatric hospitalizations. Mother stated, “ ‘I
did tell [father] that maybe [the children] shouldn’t be with me
because I’m under the effects of medication. But he said he had
to go to work.’ ” When mother told father she needed help, he
responded she had the maternal grandmother. Mother also said
father would “ ‘verbally bring me down.’ ”
Parental Drug Use. In 2016, father was arrested for
possession of marijuana and had to register as a controlled
substance offender. When asked about his 2016 arrest for
possession, father said, “ ‘It was for personal use.’ ” He stated he
had to register as a Controlled Substance Offender after being
arrested for possession of marijuana, but his case was “thrown
out” when “a Proposition passed.”
In July 2024, father tested positive for marijuana and
cocaine. When asked about his July 19, 2024, positive cocaine
test result, father explained that the day before the drug test, he
smoked a joint, which, unbeknownst to him, was laced with

7
cocaine. Father denied a history of cocaine use and denied using
any other drugs.
In August and September 2024, father had five positive
drug tests for marijuana; he never tested negative. Father
nonetheless denied having a history of substance abuse. He
stated in mid-August 2024, “ ‘They have on record that I smoke
weed, but I stopped.’ ” However, the next day, father tested
positive for marijuana with a high concentration of the drug
(1500 ng/mL).3 In September 2024, father told DCFS that he was
trying to stop using marijuana, but he had “been smoking for
years, so going cold turkey is hard. I’m trying to do the right
thing.” Several days later, father tested positive for marijuana,
again at a high concentration (1480 ng/mL).
Mother stated she did not know if father used marijuana
and explained that father had used cocaine years ago, but was
not presently using cocaine. Mother confirmed father became a
Registered Controlled Substance Offender in 2016.
Alex told DCFS that he had not seen father use marijuana.
However, Anajulia said mother and father “ ‘used to’ ” use drugs.
She reported that she and Alex had found “ ‘a bag that had a
plant on it’ ” filled with white circular pills in the medicine
cabinet. Anajulia said that on a phone she shared with mother,
she saw text messages between the parents indicating that father
had stopped doing drugs “ ‘a while back but my mom didn’t want
to.’ ” Anajulia stated that father’s eyes were “ ‘red most of the
time.’ ”

3 Father’s other positive marijuana tests reflected smaller
concentrations of the drug at values of 600, 427, 1112, 426, and
671 ng/mL.

8
The paternal aunt reported that the parents smoke
marijuana but not in the children’s presence. She denied that
father used any other drugs.
In August 2024, mother tested positive for marijuana, and
in September, she tested positive for methamphetamine and
amphetamine.
Mother Supplied Alex with THC Vape Pens. Father
informed DCFS that mother was providing Alex with vape pens
containing THC. Father learned about the vaping when he read
text messages between Alex and mother, but denied knowing
anything else about it.
When interviewed about the vape pens, Alex told DCFS
that he had tried a THC vape pen with his cousins in December
2023 and then with a girl at school. When Alex told mother that
he had tried vaping, mother was not upset with him and instead
she began sharing THC vape pens with Alex, who at the time was
11 and 12 years old. Alex reported that mother had supplied him
approximately 15 THC vape pens over an eight- or nine-month
period. Alex stated that father was upset mother was supplying
him with vape pens but he did not know whether or not father
addressed the issue with mother.
Domestic Violence. Father and mother had been together
for 14 years, but due to relationship problems, father had
recently moved out of the family home. Mother’s mental health
incidents happened about two months after he left the home.
Father denied the existence of domestic violence in their
relationship, with the exception of the 2023 milk incident.
At times, mother felt concerned about the children in
father’s care “ ‘because he’s short-tempered sometimes.’ ”
Although the children had not complained recently, they had

9
previously called her and said, “ ‘Dad’s mad.’ ” Mother denied
domestic violence in their relationship but indicated there was a
lot of verbal abuse. Mother said their relationship was rough, but
they were trying to co-parent.
Anajulia told the social worker that she did not always feel
safe in the home with father and the paternal relatives.
Although father did not yell at them or physically discipline them
when angry, Anajulia stated that father’s face was angry and he
had “ ‘angriness every day.’ ”
In August 2024, father enrolled in a Nurturing
Fathers/Thriving Dads program and completed three of 20 Anger
Management classes. Father was then dropped from the
program “ ‘due to childcare challenges’ ” and scheduled to restart
a 12-week parenting course at the end of August.
Violations of the Visitation Order and Additional
Domestic Violence. Mother told DCFS that on August 21, 2024,
she attended Alex’s soccer game, where father was also present
with three of the children. Because she did not want to carry her
purse with her, mother stored it in father’s car. Alex forgot his
cleats at home so father left with Estella to get Alex’s cleats.
Alex went onto the soccer field with his team and mother was left
alone with Antonio in violation of the juvenile court’s July 2024
order that mother’s visits be monitored.
When father and Estella returned, father became upset
after discovering messages from other men on mother’s phone,
which she had left in her purse inside his car. He stated to
mother, “ ‘If you want to work things out with me, then you need
to unlock your phone and let me read all of your messages.’ ”
When mother unlocked her phone, father saw messages and
photos she had sent to her male friends. Upset, father threw and

10
broke the phone in Antonio’s and Estella’s presence. Father
confirmed that he broke mother’s phone but asserted the children
were not present.
Subsequently, father sent mother threatening text
messages. Father texted, “[W]atch what you say,” “Speak up
watch how I show the cocaine shit and your drug test from blue
star,” “Try me in court,” and “Yup fuck wit me.”
It also came to DCFS’s attention that father was leaving
the children at maternal grandmother’s home where mother
resided, without a proper monitor for mother’s visitation.
Unexplained Injury to Antonio. In early September
2024, during mother’s monitored visitation, a social worker
observed that one-year-old Antonio had a two- to three-inch white
patch on his right arm that appeared to be a burn. When asked
about it, mother and the maternal grandmother said they had
first noticed the injury on August 20, 2024, and had taken a
photo of it that day. The August 20 photo showed the wound
already beginning to scab.
Father later told the social worker that Antonio had burned
his arm just one week earlier, which was inconsistent with the
photograph produced by the maternal grandmother showing the
injury two weeks earlier. Father explained that it was hot
outside and the child had brushed against something metal in the
backyard. However, when the social worker interviewed the
paternal aunt, she said father had told her he did not know how
the injury occurred because Antonio never cried or complained.
She stated that father repeated his lack of knowledge even when
she asked him where he had been when it happened.

11
V. Amended Petitions
In August and September 2024, DCFS amended the section
300 petition three times to include allegations that the children
were placed at risk of serious harm from: (1) father’s substance
abuse, (2) the parents’ domestic violence in the children’s
presence with father as the dominant aggressor, (3) mother
providing Alex with marijuana, and (4) mother’s mental and
emotional problems and father’s failure to protect the children
from such problems.
Also in September 2024, the juvenile court detained the
children from parental custody, and ordered monitored visitation
for the parents.
VI. Jurisdiction and Disposition Hearing
On October 10, 2024, the juvenile court held the combined
jurisdiction and disposition hearing and received into evidence
DCFS’s reports and an August 2024 letter indicating father
participated in three of 20 anger management classes.
DCFS asked the court to sustain the petition as pled.
Counsel for the children joined in DCFS’s request, citing
“concerns for the well-being of the children” and expressing alarm
that additional problematic behavior had surfaced during the
dependency case. Counsel emphasized mother’s undisputed
mental health issues, the parents’ volatile relationship, mother
furnishing the eldest child with a vape pen, and the parents’
repeated violations of the court’s visitation order. Counsel also
pointed out that the toddler and baby were “very young and
unable to protect themselves.”
Mother’s counsel argued there was no present risk of harm
to the children because mother acknowledged it was wrong to
give the vape pen to Alex and she now has insight not to do it

12
again, the parents were no longer in a relationship and thus
domestic violence would not recur, mother was not currently
using substances, and mother had not had any other mental
health episodes since her hospitalization. Father’s counsel urged
the court to dismiss his substance abuse count because there was
no nexus between father’s marijuana use and his ability to
provide the children regular care. Counsel argued the court
should amend the domestic violence count, asserting the
allegation did not properly reflect his role in those conflicts.
Counsel argued father acted in self-defense during the milk
incident and that throwing mother’s phone in proximity to the
children was an inappropriate act of frustration. Father
submitted on the allegation that he failed to protect the children
from the dangers posed by mother’s mental health issues.
In rebuttal, DCFS pointed out that father not only tested
positive for marijuana, but also for cocaine.
After hearing argument, the juvenile court sustained the
counts alleging that mother supplied Alex with a vape pen and
that mother’s mental and emotional problems placed the children
at substantial risk of harm, from which father failed to protect
the children. As pertinent to this appeal, the court also sustained
the following counts as pled:
“(a-1) . . . [Mother and father] have a history of engaging in
violent altercations in the presence of the children. On or about
11/25/2023, when the mother was pregnant with Estella, the
mother poured milk on the father and the father pushed the
mother, causing her to fall, in the presence of the children. On or
about 8/21/2024, the father became upset with the mother and
threw and broke her phone in the presence of the children.
. . . The violent conduct by the father against the mother, and the

13
mother’s failure to protect the children, endangers the children’s
physical health and safety, creates a detrimental home
environment, and places the children at risk of physical harm,
damage, danger and failure to protect.”
“(b-3) . . . [Father] has a history of substance abuse,
including marijuana and cocaine, and is a current abuser of
marijuana and cocaine, which renders the father incapable of
providing regular care and supervision of the children. On
7/19/2024, the father had a positive toxicology screen for cocaine.
On 12/19/2023, 7/17/2024, 8/15/2024, 8/22/2024, and 8/26/2024,
the father had positive toxicology screens for marijuana while the
children were in his care. Further, the father is a Registered
Controlled Substance Offender. The children, Antonio and
Estella are of such a young age requiring constant care and
supervision and the father’s substance abuse interferes with
providing regular care and supervision of the children. . . . The
father’s substance abuse and the mother’s failure to protect the
children endangers the children’s physical health and safety,
creates a detrimental home environment, and places the children
at risk of serious physical harm, damage, danger, and failure to
protect.”
For disposition, the juvenile court ordered the children
removed from parental custody, and ordered family reunification
services for the parents with monitored visits. The court
highlighted that neither parent followed the court’s orders and
father continued to drug test positive after the court released the
children to him.
Regarding father’s case plan, father’s counsel agreed to
individual counseling and parenting, but did not believe a full
drug program was necessary because his positive drug tests for

14
marijuana were for similar quantities throughout the case.
Counsel proposed father undergo weekly testing and only enroll
in a full program if he tested positive for another substance.
Counsel also stated that father had already attended six anger
management classes.
Over father’s counsel’s objections, the court ordered father
to participate in a full substance abuse treatment program with
aftercare, weekly random and on-demand drug/alcohol testing,
and a 12-step program, as well as a parenting program and
individual counseling with a licensed therapist to address case
issues, including substance abuse, domestic violence, and anger
management.
Father appealed.
VII. The Children Returned to Father’s Custody
While this appeal was pending, on April 10, 2025, the
juvenile court ordered the children released to father’s custody,
on the condition that he reside with the paternal aunt or in
another DCFS-approved housing arrangement, and abide by all
court orders.
DISCUSSION
Father argues that substantial evidence did not support the
juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings under count (a-1)
regarding the parents’ domestic violence and count (b-3), dealing
with father’s substance abuse. He also contends the court abused
its discretion by ordering father to submit to drug and alcohol
testing and participate in a substance abuse program, 12-step
program, and therapy. Father further challenges the removal of
the children from his custody.

15
I. Substantial Evidence Supported Jurisdiction
a. Father’s Challenge to the Substance Abuse
Finding is Not Moot
Father argues that substantial evidence did not support
two of the five bases for jurisdiction. “When a dependency
petition alleges multiple grounds for its assertion that a minor
comes within the dependency court’s jurisdiction, a reviewing
court can affirm the juvenile court’s finding of jurisdiction over
the minor if any one of the statutory bases for jurisdiction that
are enumerated in the petition is supported by substantial
evidence. In such a case, the reviewing court need not consider
whether any or all of the other alleged statutory grounds for
jurisdiction are supported by the evidence.” (In re Alexis E.
(2009) 171 Cal.App.4th 438, 451.) However, as father points out,
in In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 283 (D.P.), the Supreme
Court clarified that “where a jurisdictional finding ‘serves as the
basis for dispositional orders that are also challenged on appeal’
[citation], the appeal is not moot.”
Here, father challenges the jurisdictional findings under
count (a-1), alleging domestic violence between the parents, and
count (b-3), alleging father’s substance abuse. He contests only
the dispositional orders requiring him to participate in drug
testing and substance abuse treatment. Accordingly, we address
the challenge to count (b-3), which directly supports the disputed
dispositional orders, and decline to reach count (a-1), which does
not relate to the challenged dispositional orders.
b. Applicable Law
The juvenile court may exercise jurisdiction over a child if
DCFS establishes by a preponderance of the evidence that the
allegations made pursuant to section 300 are true. (In re I.J.

16
(2013) 56 Cal.4th 766, 773.) Section 300, subdivision (b)(1)
provides that a child is within the juvenile court’s jurisdiction if,
“[t]he child has suffered, or there is a substantial risk that the
child will suffer, serious physical harm or illness, as a result of
. . . [¶] (A) [t]he failure or inability of the child’s parent or
guardian to adequately supervise or protect the child” or “(D)
[t]he inability of the parent or guardian to provide regular care
for the child due to the parent’s or guardian’s . . . substance
abuse.”
“Thus, to obtain a jurisdictional determination under
section 300, subdivision (b)(1), [DCFS] must ‘prove three
elements: (1) the parent's or guardian’s neglectful conduct or
failure or inability to protect the child; (2) causation; and (3)
serious physical harm or illness or a substantial risk of serious
physical harm or illness.’ ” (In re S.F. (2023) 91 Cal.App.5th 696,
712.) “For jurisdiction under section 300, subdivision (b)(1)(D),
the child protective agency must prove that substance abuse
makes the parent or guardian unable to provide regular care for a
child and that this inability caused the child to suffer serious
physical harm or illness or creates a substantial risk of such
harm or illness.” (In re Gilberto G. (2024) 105 Cal.App.5th 52,
62.)
“ ‘A parent’s “ ‘[p]ast conduct may be probative of current
conditions’ if there is reason to believe that the conduct will
continue.” ’ ” (In re J.A. (2020) 47 Cal.App.5th 1036, 1048.) In
addition, “a child’s youth and maturity level can bear upon the
care that the child may require and whether a parent’s . . .
substance abuse places the child at substantial risk of serious
physical harm. Courts can properly take these facts regarding a
child into account, together with all other relevant evidence, in

17
deciding whether the government has met its burden at the
jurisdictional stage. But courts may not shortcut the inquiry
envisioned by the Legislature by regarding substance abuse as
constituting prima facie evidence of an inability to provide
regular care to a young child and a substantial risk of serious
physical harm to that child, and then look to the parent or
guardian to rebut this presumption.” (In re N.R. (2023) 15
Cal.5th 520, 559–560 (N.R.).)
We review the juvenile court’s jurisdictional findings for
substantial evidence. “Substantial evidence is ‘evidence that is
reasonable, credible, and of solid value—from which a reasonable
trier of fact could have made the requisite finding under the
governing standard of proof.’ (In re Jerry M. (1997) 59
Cal.App.4th 289, 298.) Under this standard ‘we review the record
in the light most favorable to the court’s determinations and
draw all reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the
findings and orders.’ (Kevin R. v. Superior Court (2010) 191
Cal.App.4th 676, 688–689.) ‘We do not reweigh the evidence or
exercise independent judgment, but merely determine if there are
sufficient facts to support the findings of the trial court.’ (In re
Matthew S. (1988) 201 Cal.App.3d 315, 321.) ‘[T]he trial court’s
ruling must be upheld if there is any basis in the record to
sustain it.’ (People v. Marquez (1992) 1 Cal.4th 553, 578.)” (In re
J.E. (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 309, 313–314.)
c. Substantial Evidence Supported the Court’s
Substance Abuse Jurisdictional Findings
The evidence established that father’s substance abuse was
long-standing, unmitigated, and continued throughout these
proceedings, including while the children were in his care.
Father had been using marijuana at least since his 2016 arrest

18
for possession, which he admitted was for his personal use. In
December 2023 and July through September 2024, father tested
positive for marijuana on every drug test administered. Even
after telling the dependency investigator in mid-August 2024
(when the children were in his care), that he had stopped using
marijuana, father tested positive with a high concentration of
marijuana (1500 ng/mL) the next day. On September 23, 2024,
father told DCFS that he was trying to stop using marijuana, but
he had “ ‘been smoking for years, so going cold turkey is hard.
I’m trying to do the right thing.’ ” Then, four days later, father
tested positive for marijuana again with a high concentration of
the drug (1480 ng/mL).
Father’s substance abuse went beyond marijuana. In July
2024, he tested positive for cocaine. Although father claimed the
result was from smoking a joint laced with cocaine without
realizing it, the court could reasonably infer that the use was
intentional given that mother reported father had a history of
cocaine use. Alcohol use was also an issue. Anajulia reported
father drank something from the liquor store once a week that
caused him to sleep. She further observed that father’s eyes were
“ ‘red most of the time’ ” and that he was angry every day.
The evidence also showed that father’s ongoing substance
abuse directly impaired his ability to supervise and care for the
children, placing them at substantial risk of harm. First, the
court could infer that it impaired his judgment as father
repeatedly returned the children to mother after the suicide
attempt and mental health episode, and then allowed them to
visit mother without a monitor in violation of court orders. In
addition, while in father’s care in August 2024, one-year-old
Antonio sustained a sizeable burn on his arm. When DCFS

19
asked about the injury, father minimized it, saying Antonio
brushed against something metal on a hot day. But when the
paternal aunt pressed him on where he was when the injury
occurred, father repeatedly denied knowing. The juvenile court
could reasonably infer from father’s evasiveness and the
unexplained injury, that his drug abuse compromised his ability
to safely supervise the children.
In addition, Anajulia told DCFS about how she and her
sibling once found in the home’s medicine cabinet a bag “that had
a plant on it” containing “white circular pills.” Anajulia also
described father inebriating himself to the point of passing out.
The court could infer from the children’s access to drugs and
father’s weekly inebriation to the point of passing out that
father’s long standing drug use hampered his care of the children.
This was particularly true for the two younger children, a baby
and toddler, who needed constant supervision and who were most
vulnerable to harm. (See N.R., supra, 15 Cal.5th at p. 559 [“a
child’s youth and maturity level can bear upon the care that the
child may require and whether a parent’s . . . substance abuse
places the child at substantial risk of serious physical harm”].)
Even if, as father contends, the juvenile court’s reference to
father as a Registered Substance Abuse Offender was error, any
such error was harmless. The substantial evidence outlined
above independently and amply supported jurisdiction under
count (b-3).
II. No Abuse of Discretion in Ordering Substance Abuse
Testing and Programs
If a child is adjudged a dependent child of the juvenile
court, the court may make “any and all reasonable orders for the
care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of

20
the child.” (§ 362, subd. (a).) The juvenile court has “wide
latitude” in making such orders for the well-being of the child and
“is not limited to the content of the sustained petition when it
considers what dispositional orders would be in the best interests
of the children.” (In re Briana V. (2015) 236 Cal.App.4th 297,
311.) To the contrary, the court’s “broad discretion to determine
what would best serve and protect the child’s interest and to
fashion a dispositional order in accord with this discretion,
permits the court to formulate disposition orders to address
parental deficiencies when necessary to protect and promote the
child’s welfare.” (In re K.T. (2020) 49 Cal.App.5th 20, 25.) We
review dispositional orders for an abuse of discretion. (In re A.F.
(2024) 102 Cal.App.5th 778, 786; In re K.S. (2016) 244
Cal.App.4th 327, 340.)
Father contends that the trial court abused its discretion
when it ordered him to undergo weekly drug testing and engage
in a full substance abuse program with therapy because there
was “no evidence that marijuana or alcohol use by father has ever
impacted his ability to care for his children.” As described in our
jurisdictional analysis, the record contained ample evidence of
father’s ongoing substance abuse and its detrimental impact on
his ability to care for the children. Given this evidence, the court
could reasonably determine that addressing father’s substance
abuse was necessary to protect the children’s well-being. The
dispositional orders for drug testing and treatment with therapy
were therefore well within the court’s discretion.
III. Father’s Removal Challenge is Moot
Father contends the juvenile court erred when it removed
the children from his care. While the appeal was pending, the
children were returned to father’s care. DCFS asserts this issue

21
is moot as we can no longer provide father relief since he
currently has custody of the children. Father “acknowledges that
the children have been returned to his custody” and does not
argue the removal issue any further in reply.
We agree father’s removal challenge is moot as we cannot
offer him any relief. (See D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 276.) We
therefore do not address the merits of the children’s removal.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s orders are affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL
REPORTS

EDMON, P.J.

We concur:

ADAMS, J.

HANASONO, J.

22

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.