CourtListener 10705187•People v. Mauldin CA2/8
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 10/16/25 P. v. Mauldin CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION EIGHT
THE PEOPLE, B333751
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. MA084797-01)
v.
ERIN VINCENT MAULDIN,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County. Emily J. Cole, Judge. Reversed and remanded
with instructions.
Jared G. Coleman, by appointment of the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Noah P. Hill and Deepti Vaadyala, Deputy
Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_________________________
On appeal defendant Erin Vincent Mauldin contends the
jury did not find true both prior strike allegations alleged against
him and for which he was sentenced. He argues the verdict form
shows the jury found true only one prior strike. We agree and
reverse and remand the matter with instructions to find the
second strike allegation untrue and to hold a new sentencing
hearing.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
By Information filed March 22, 2023, the People charged
appellant Erin Vincent Mauldin with the attempted
premeditated murder of Dominique Beverly in violation of Penal
Code sections 664 and 187, subdivision (a)1 while personally
inflicting great bodily injury and using a firearm within the
meaning of sections 12022.7, subdivision (a) and 12022.5,
subdivision (a); assault with a semiautomatic firearm on Earl
McConnell in violation of section 245, subdivision (b); kidnapping
Ariyah W., a victim under 14 years old, in violation of section
207, subdivision (a) while personally using a semiautomatic
firearm with the meaning of sections 12022.5, subdivisions (a),
(d); and assault with a semiautomatic firearm on Ariyah W. in
violation of section 245, subdivision (b). The Information also
alleged Mauldin suffered two prior strike convictions within the
meaning of the Three Strikes Law (§ 667, subds. (d)), which also
constituted prior serious felony convictions within the meaning of
section 667, subdivision (a)(1). Finally, the Information alleged
aggravating circumstances within the meaning of California
Rules of Court, rules 4.421(a), (b).
1 Undesignated statutory sections are to the Penal Code.
2
The jury convicted Mauldin on all counts. He elected to
have the jury decide the truth of the enhancements, including the
two prior strike allegations. The People presented evidence that
Mauldin had sustained two prior felony robbery convictions in
the same case, that is, case No. MA035322. The trial court read
the allegations from the Information to the jury. The trial court
stated: “[I]t’s further alleged that with all of the counts, the
defendant has been convicted of the following serious or violent
felonies, and there are two counts under [case No.] MA035322.
Both counts are violations of Penal Code section 211, which is
robbery, and that conviction date was for both counts, September
11th of 2007.”
The prosecutor presented the People’s evidence of the prior
convictions and, in closing, told the jury: “Does Mr. Mauldin have
prior convictions? The only evidence that you can consider in
determining whether or not he has prior convictions is this
[section 969, subdivision (b)] packet. You all will be going back to
deliberate one more time. You’ll be able to take this packet with
you and thumb through it and look at all of the information that
Ms. Chavez just testified to. It is a certified record from the
Department of Corrections indicating when Mr. Mauldin was
convicted; what he was convicted of; where he went to prison; his
movement within the prison system; and, ultimately, when he
was paroled. [¶] I’ll draw your attention specifically to that
abstract of judgment. I know it’s pretty difficult to see up on the
screen, but this particular page of the document is going to tell
you specifically about his convictions. Again, I know it’s hard to
see, but the case number that the judge read to you that will be
contained on the verdict form is towards the top of the abstract of
judgment. It gives you the date of the hearing as well as the date
3
of conviction, which is September 11, 2007, and then what his
two convictions are for. Now, it’s the same count with the same
case number, but it’s two different counts; so it counts as two
different convictions. [¶] You’ll also be able to see that he pled to
these counts for the primary counts, 211, which are robberies.”
The trial court then instructed the jury with CALCRIM
No. 3101 [Prior Convictions]: “The People have alleged that the
defendant was previously convicted of other crimes. It has
already been determined that the defendant is the person named
in exhibit 969(B) packet. You must decide whether the evidence
proves that the defendant was convicted of the alleged crimes. [¶]
The People allege that the defendant has been convicted of: [¶]
1. A violation of Penal Code 211, for which judgment was entered
on September 11, 2007, in . . . Los Angeles, in Case Number
MA035322; [¶] 2. A violation of Penal Code 211, for which
judgment was entered on September 11, 2007, in . . . Los Angeles,
in Case Number MA035322. [¶] In deciding whether the People
have proved this allegation, consider only the evidence presented
in this proceeding. Do not consider your verdict or any evidence
from the earlier part of the trial. [¶] You may not return a finding
that any alleged conviction has or has not been proved unless all
12 of you agree on that finding.”
The verdict form, presented to and signed by the jury, as to
the strike allegations stated: “We, the Jury in the above-entitled
action, find that defendant, ERIN MAULDIN, suffered a prior
felony conviction on or about September 11, 2007 in case number
MA035322[,] a violation of Penal Code section 211 in the Los
Angeles Superior Court to be TRUE.” The jury made no other
findings related to the prior strike allegations.
4
Before the case went to the jury, the trial court invited
comment about and objections to the jury instructions. The trial
court asked if there were any corrections or additions that were
needed or being requested. The record does not reflect that the
trial court’s invitation to comment extended to the verdict forms.
There are no objections in the record to the form of the verdict.
In a sentencing memorandum to the court, defense counsel
noted for the court that the jury had found true one prior strike
conviction. Counsel also noted that the probation report included
two prior strike convictions from case number MA035322.
Counsel asked the court to strike a prior conviction along with
the gun enhancements.
At sentencing, the trial court noted, “[T]he two strikes the
defendant has [are] under case MA035322. The defendant’s true
strikes are from the same case, the same incident, but are from
separate victims. The defendant and a codefendant entered a
store and pointed rifles at multiple people in that store and
ordered everyone into the restroom, stole money and cell phones,
and one of the victims had the gun pointed at their head.” The
trial court sentenced Mauldin to a total of 85 years to life plus 12
years in prison. The aggregate term included a “third strike”
sentence of 25 years to life. This appeal followed.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
In August 2022, Dominique Beverly and her four children
returned home between 9:00 p.m. and 10:00 p.m. after a day
spent with family in Apple Valley. Beverly took the children
inside the apartment and then took their dog outside. When she
returned to her front door, she heard someone running up behind
her. It was Mauldin. He was extremely agitated and asked to
come inside her apartment because he said he was being chased.
5
Beverly tried to enter the apartment without him, but Mauldin
kept trying to force his way in. Eventually Mauldin asked if he
could use the phone; he promised to stand by the front door.
Beverly told him to wait. She headed towards her bedroom to
find a weapon to protect herself. She also called her fiancé. Just
as she connected with her fiancé, Mauldin attacked her from
behind with a hammer. She ran into the living room before
Mauldin attacked her again.
Beverly and Mauldin scuffled as she tried to grab the gun
she now saw in his hand. Mauldin shot her in the face. Beverly
called out to her 12-year-old daughter Ariyah to call the police.
She then saw Mauldin holding the gun to Ariyah’s head. Beverly,
bleeding and choking on her blood, begged him not to shoot
Ariyah. She began to crawl out of the apartment to find help.
Eventually Beverly’s fiancé arrived. He saw Mauldin
holding Ariyah in a chokehold and pointing a gun at her.
Followed and observed by Beverly’s fiancé, Mauldin walked to a
house across the street and kicked open the wooden gate that led
to the front yard. He told Ariyah he was doing all this because
people were chasing him. He also told her, as he kept his arm
around her neck, that she would be the first to die. Ariyah saw
Mauldin with two guns.
At around 10:30 p.m. police arrived and found Mauldin
holding Ariyah at gunpoint. Mauldin released her upon the
officer’s command to do so and he was then detained. Beverly
suffered severe facial injuries, including the loss of her right eye,
several skull fractures, recurring pain, and permanent swelling
and nerve damage.
6
DISCUSSION
I. Standard of Review
Review of an unauthorized sentence presents a question of
law which we review de novo. (People v. Smith (2001) 24 Cal.4th
849, 852; People v. Cromer (2001) 24 Cal.4th 889, 894.) A
sentence that exceeds statutory limits is unauthorized and
voidable at any time. (People v. Bell (1971) 17 Cal.App.3d 949,
955. No objection in the trial court is required to preserve the
issue. (People v. Scott (1994) 9 Cal.4th 331, 354.)
II. Applicable Law
Under California’s Three Strikes Law, a sentence of
25 years to life may be imposed only if the trier of fact expressly
finds that the defendant has suffered two or more prior strike
convictions. (§ 1170.12, subd. (c)(2)(A); see also § 1170.1, subd. (e)
[allegations must be found to be true by the trier of fact].)
This finding must be express, not implied. Penal Code
section 1158 provides as follows: “Whenever the fact of a previous
conviction of another offense is charged in an accusatory
pleading, and the defendant is found guilty of the offense with
which he is charged, the jury, or the judge if a jury trial is
waived, must unless the answer of the defendant admits such
previous conviction, find whether or not he has suffered such
previous conviction. The verdict or finding upon the charge of
previous conviction may be: ‘We (or I) find the charge of previous
conviction true’ or ‘We (or I) find the charge of previous conviction
not true,’ according as the jury or the judge find that the
defendant has or has not suffered such conviction. If more than
one previous conviction is charged a separate finding must be
made as to each.” (§ 1158.)
7
III. Analysis
The record is clear that the jury found true only one prior
strike conviction, not two. We conclude, pursuant to the
reasoning of People v. Huffman (1967) 248 Cal.App.2d 260, that
the trier of fact’s failure to find true both strikes operates as an
acquittal of one of the two strike allegations. As Huffman
explains, “Since no finding was made by the court as to the
alleged prior conviction as required under Penal Code section
1158, the court’s silence operates as an acquittal of the charge of
the prior conviction. [Citations.] Thus the present conviction
must be treated as a conviction upon a first offense. [Citation.]”
(Huffman, at p. 261; see also People v. Bright (1970) 4 Cal.App.3d
926, 928 [failure of trier of fact to make finding on prior
conviction operates as acquittal of allegation].)
More salient is People v. Eppinger (1895) 109 Cal. 294.
There the jury was asked to find whether the defendant had
suffered a prior conviction for petty larceny. The jury returned a
verdict of guilty on the underlying charge, but “[failed to] find
specifically upon this issue as they were required to do by section
1158 of the Penal Code.” (Id. at p. 297.) The trial court
sentenced the defendant to the mandatory term of fourteen years
as if there had been a true finding on the prior petty larceny
conviction. Our Supreme Court held, “It was unquestionably
error for the jury to have failed to find upon the issue. The error
being shown, the injury will be presumed, unless the contrary is
clearly made to appear. [Citations.] In other words, it must be
presumed that the trial judge treated the general verdict as
including a finding in favor of the truth of the charge of prior
conviction and thus sentenced under section 667 of the Penal
Code. Had the sentence been for any less period than fourteen
8
years, the difficulty would have been obviated, for it would then
certainly have appeared that the court treated the verdict as
favorable to the defendant upon the charge of prior conviction.
Not having done so affords additional ground for the belief that it
felt compelled to sentence under section 667. But, in so doing,
the judge incorporated into the verdict a finding of fact which the
jury did not make, and sentenced the defendant under an issue
upon which the jury did not pass.” (Id. at pp. 297–298.) The
Supreme Court concluded: “The verdict rendered should be
treated as a finding against the defendant upon the crime
charged, and in favor of the defendant upon the question of prior
conviction. The judgment must therefore be reversed, with
directions to the trial judge to pronounce a judgment and
sentence upon defendant in the exercise of . . . discretion upon the
facts and circumstances of the case.” (Id. at p. 298; People v.
Gutierrez (1993) 14 Cal.App.4th 1425, 1440 [where no words are
used and the trier of fact fails to make a finding, the effect is the
same as a finding of “not true”].)
Citing People v. Jackson (2014) 58 Cal.4th 724, 750 and
People v. Ochoa (1998) 19 Cal.4th 353, 427, the People contend
we should treat the jury’s failure to make a factual finding as a
“technical” defect in the verdict form that may be disregarded.
The People also suggest that because the instructions were so
clear, the jury had no reason to believe that they were making a
finding as to a single strike only and therefore we should imply a
jury finding that both strike allegations were true. Finally, the
People argue that if we determine there must be a jury finding on
the second strike allegation, all we have to do is remand for a
retrial on the allegation pursuant to People v. Barragan (2004)
32 Cal.4th 236, 259.
9
We disagree with the People’s contentions. This was not a
verdict form that had the potential to confuse the jury, as
contended in Jackson and Ochoa. This was the complete absence
of a jury form, in violation of section 1158’s requirement of a
separate verdict form for each alleged prior conviction. The form
the jury did sign was neither unclear nor confusing. It plainly
asked for one finding on one prior conviction in the prior case in
which Mauldin had sustained two prior convictions. We can
speculate as to why the jury proceeded with the jury verdict form
that contradicted the instructions it had received, but to what
end. Over 100 years ago, People v. Eppinger set out the path we
must follow, which does not include a retrial of the allegation.
We do so now.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is reversed with directions to find the second
strike allegation untrue and to hold a new sentencing hearing.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
STRATTON, P. J.
We concur:
VIRAMONTES, J. RUBIN, J.*
* Retired Presiding Justice of the Court of Appeal, Second
Appellate District, assigned by the Chief Justice pursuant to
article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
10
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.