CourtListener 10687909•In re C.H. CA2/3
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 10/2/25 In re C.H. CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
B341674
In re C.H., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
(Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. 22CCJP01908A)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
C.H.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Los Angeles
County, Gabriela H. Shapiro, Juvenile Court Referee. Affirmed.
Law Offices of Vincent W. Davis & Associates and Vincent
W. Davis for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, Melania Vartanian, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗‗
Appellant C.H. (father) appeals from a juvenile court order
denying his petition to change a previous order pursuant to
Welfare and Institutions Code section 388 without a hearing.1
We affirm the order.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
I. Prior dependency history.
In February 2021, the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (DCFS) received a report that
father and mother2 emotionally abused and neglected minor child
C.H. Jr. According to the caller, mother left the home following a
verbal fight with father, and father followed her in his car,
leaving nine-month-old C.H. Jr. alone in the family home. The
caller further reported that father forced mother into his car and
then slapped her. Mother later told a detective that father had
not physically harmed her, and that paternal grandmother was
with C.H. Jr. in the home. The referral was closed as
inconclusive.
In March 2022, DCFS received a referral indicating that
father grabbed mother, causing redness, in C.H. Jr.’s presence.
Mother also reported that father had held a knife against her
1 All further undesignated statutory references are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.
2 Mother is not a party to this appeal.
2
throat a few days earlier. Mother obtained an emergency
protective order against father. DCFS noted that C.H. Jr. was
“safe and well cared for” and the report was closed as
inconclusive.
II. Current section 300 petition.
On May 13, 2022, father contacted law enforcement to
report that mother was using methamphetamines in the family
bathroom, and that mother hit father several times when he
confronted her about her drug use. Mother separately contacted
law enforcement and reported that father broke down the
bathroom door and struck her several times. The responding
officer observed scratch marks on father’s neck and redness on
mother, and discovered a “ ‘freshly used’ ” pipe in the bathroom.
The officer arrested father and mother.
A DCFS social worker visited the home later that day and
observed that C.H. Jr., who was then two years old, had no marks
or bruises. Paternal grandmother was caring for the child. She
reported that father and mother frequently argued, but denied
that either parent ever harmed C.H. Jr. DCFS detained the child
“due to caretaker absence, and [ongoing] domestic violence in the
home.”
Later that day, the social worker interviewed mother.
Mother reported that father hit her every day. She denied using
drugs and claimed father owned the pipe that was discovered in
the home. The social worker also interviewed father, who again
reported that he discovered mother using methamphetamines.
Father denied hitting mother that day and denied that he had
ever struck her in the past. The social worker obtained police call
logs which reflected that officers had been called to the family
home 10 times between February 2021 and May 2022 to respond
3
to reports of disturbances, domestic violence, battery, and
vandalism.
On May 16, 2022, father contacted the DCFS social worker
and reported that he had been released, and that he had
separated from mother and no longer lived with her. He said he
wanted to get custody of C.H. Jr. Father reported that he was
enrolled in a domestic violence program and provided an
enrollment letter dated March 29, 2022.
On May 17, 2022, DCFS filed a section 300 petition as to
C.H. Jr. The petition alleged that mother and father had a
history of engaging in violent fights in the child’s presence, that
this violent conduct endangered the child’s physical health and
safety and put him at risk of serious physical harm, damage, and
danger, and that both parents failed to protect C.H. Jr. from this
violence. The petition specifically alleged that father broke down
a door and repeatedly struck mother on May 13, 2022, and that
mother then pushed, scratched, and struck father. It further
alleged mother used methamphetamines on May 13, 2022, and
that mother’s history of drug use and father’s failure to protect
C.H. Jr. from that drug use also endangered the child.
At the May 18, 2022 detention hearing, the court ordered
C.H. Jr. detained and placed in DCFS custody pending
disposition of the section 300 petition. The child was placed with
maternal grandmother.
A DCFS investigator interviewed father on June 1, 2022.
Father admitted to arguing with mother but denied that their
fights ever became physical. He stated he was willing to move
out of the family home if C.H. Jr. could be placed with mother.
Father tested negative for drugs on May 18, 2022, and June 3,
2022.
4
The DCFS investigator interviewed mother again on June
2, 2022. Mother reported that on May 13, 2022, she and father
argued, and father left the home. When father returned, mother
was in the bathroom. Father “tore down the door,” “grabbed her
off the toilet,” and “tried to push” her. Mother reported that
father “does get aggressive when he is drunk.”
Three DCFS social workers interviewed maternal
grandmother on June 2, 2022. Maternal grandmother reported
seeing redness and bruises around mother’s neck, but she did not
know whether father caused the injuries. The next day, two
DCFS social workers interviewed paternal grandmother, who
stated that father and mother “often” argued verbally, but denied
ever witnessing physical violence. Paternal grandmother
reported that father became very happy and “pull[ed] himself
together” after he started a relationship with mother and after
C.H. Jr. was born.
DCFS filed a jurisdiction and disposition report on June 9,
2022. Among other things, the report described an August 2021
police report in which mother claimed that father broke her cell
phone and carried her inside the family home against her will.
Father told officers he had been arguing with mother but
asserted that the fight never turned physical. The officers
arrested father.
According to the June 2022 DCFS report, mother asserted
that father became violent around the time she became pregnant
with C.H. Jr. Mother reported that she sometimes became
jealous about father’s interactions with other women and “would
scream at him,” and in response father “would smack and push
her.” The report stated that father denied any recent arrests
aside from the May 2022 arrest that led to the section 300
5
petition in this case. He also denied any physical violence
between himself and mother. The report asserted that father and
mother both minimized their domestic violence.
At the June 24, 2022 disposition hearing, the juvenile court
sustained amended allegations that mother and father had a
history of domestic violence and that they engaged in a violent
altercation on May 13, 2022, while C.H. Jr. was in the home, that
this violence endangered the child, and that both parents failed
to protect the child from their domestic violence. The court
struck allegations specifically describing the May 13 incident,
reasoning that it would not “benefit anyone to have all of the
details in the counts.” The court found that DCFS had not
proved by a preponderance of the evidence that mother’s drug use
harmed C.H. Jr. and struck both counts based on that allegation.
The court sustained the petition as amended, declared C.H. Jr. a
dependent of the court, and removed him from mother and
father.
The juvenile court ordered reunification services for both
parents. It ordered father to complete a 26-week domestic
violence program; individual counseling to address anger
management, self-esteem, how domestic violence affects young
children, and parenting and co-parenting; six consecutive random
or on demand drug tests; and, if father reconciled with mother in
the future, couples counseling. The court ordered unmonitored
visitation for both parents.
III. Six-month review hearing.
On July 27, 2022, a Multidisciplinary Assessment Child
Family Team (CFT) meeting was conducted as to father. Father
asserted he wished to reunify with C.H. Jr. and that he was
focused on completing the programs required by his case plan.
6
He reported that he was interested in reconciling with mother,
but he also acknowledged that their communication methods
were not healthy and asked for relevant referrals.
In September 2022, the court ordered that father could
have overnight visits with C.H. Jr. at paternal grandmother’s
home, conditioned on her presence.
DCFS conducted another CFT meeting for father on
December 8, 2022. The meeting focused on whether C.H. Jr.
should be released to father. A DCFS social worker asked father
if any new issues had arisen between him and mother, and father
did not report anything.
A December 8, 2022 DCFS status review report asserted
father had made “great progress” with his case plan. Specifically,
by July 21, 2022, father had completed six required on-demand
drug tests, each with a negative result. He attended weekly
individual therapy from September 26, 2022, to November 8,
2022. And as of November 3, 2022, father had attended
16 sessions of parent education, domestic violence, and anger
management program. DCFS recommended that C.H. Jr. be
released to father with family maintenance services.
DCFS soon changed its recommendation. On December 16,
2022, mother informed DCFS that father came to her home on
November 30, 2022. He took her phone and found a photograph
of mother with another man, became angry, and hit mother in
the face. Mother reported that father had continued to
emotionally abuse her, and that she finally decided to call law
enforcement after father’s abuse became violent. Mother
obtained an emergency protective order against father. Mother
also reported that she found father’s old phone and discovered
messages on his Instagram account suggesting he had been
7
selling and using drugs. She speculated that father’s angry
behavior could indicate he was using methamphetamines.
On December 22, 2022, a DCFS social worker contacted
father about the November 30, 2022 altercation. Father
acknowledged an “incident” but asserted mother “was notorious
for calling the police when simple misunderstandings occurred.”
Father denied using drugs and agreed to complete drug tests.
The social worker explained that DCFS would be changing its
recommendation to continued reunification services out of
concern for C.H. Jr.’s safety. Father said he did not understand,
and he eventually ended the call.
DCFS filed a section 385 application on December 22, 2022,
seeking to change the recommendation made in its December 8,
2022 status review report. DCFS reported concerns that father
did not understand the significance of his domestic violence.
DCFS was particularly concerned that father failed to report the
November 30, 2022 altercation during his December 2022 CFS
meeting, and that he minimized the incident when DCFS asked
him about it. DCFS also expressed concern that father may be
using or selling drugs. DCFS therefore recommended that the
court order continued reunification services for father, and order
father to complete a full 52-week domestic violence program and
weekly drug tests. DCFS also recommended that the court order
monitored visitation for father.
At the December 23, 2022 six-month review hearing, the
court ordered monitored visitation for father and continued the
hearing as to other pending issues.
At some point after the December 23, 2022 hearing, DCFS
obtained the police report from the November 30, 2022 incident.
According to the police report, mother was at home sleeping when
8
she awoke and discovered father sitting on her bed and looking
through her cell phone. Father became angry about something
he saw, slapped mother in the face, and left. Mother told officers
there had been another domestic violence incident around
October 2022, but she could not recall further details.
A DCFS social worker interviewed father again on January
23, 2023. Father claimed that the phone mother identified as
father’s phone, which contained Instagram messages discussing
drug sales, belonged to someone else. Father denied that he had
ever sold drugs.
Between December 28, 2022, and January 19, 2023, father
completed four negative random drug tests. As of January 13,
2023, father continued to participate in therapy. By January 25,
2023, father had completed 23 sessions of his parent education,
domestic violence prevention, and anger management program.
At the January 31, 2023 six-month review hearing, the
juvenile court found that returning C.H. Jr. to father would be
detrimental to the child’s safety and ordered six additional
months of reunification services. The court acknowledged
father’s participation in classes and that he had expressed some
insight as to his faults. The court nonetheless found that father
only partially complied with his case plan. Specifically, the court
observed that “father’s compliance has been more technical
rather than substantive, even with the comments made by the
father that showed insight. The problem is that even with
ongoing domestic violence programs, [continued domestic
violence] incidents did occur.” The court also expressed “grave
concern” over father’s continued domestic violence, in part
because father had minimized the incident by describing it as a
“miscommunication.” It ordered father to complete a 52-week
9
domestic violence program, with credit for the 23 sessions he had
completed previously. The court also ordered father to complete
10 consecutive drug tests, and if each test was negative, further
testing would be required only upon reasonable suspicion.
IV. 12-month review hearing.
By April 4, 2023, father had completed 10 negative drug
tests.
A DCFS social worker spoke to mother’s therapist on May
3, 2023. The therapist reported that father and mother
continued to have “unhealthy communication.” When DCFS
raised this concern with father, he denied that he communicated
with mother in an unhealthy manner.
On May 9, 2023, father’s therapist told a DCFS social
worker that he was engaged in therapy and took responsibility
for his wrongful actions. As of June 28, 2023, father had
completed 42 sessions of his 52-week domestic violence program.
Despite father’s compliance with his case plan, DCFS
remained concerned that father “failed to demonstrate
understanding and growth from the case issues in particular with
his communication with” mother. On July 25, 2023, DCFS
assessed C.H. Jr. at high risk for future abuse or neglect if he
were returned to father’s care, and recommended continued
reunification services for father.
At the July 25, 2023 twelve-month review hearing, the
juvenile court found there was a substantial probability of
returning C.H. Jr. to the parents’ custody by the next court date
and extended reunification services a further six months. The
court also ordered unmonitored visits for father.
10
V. 18-month review hearing.
Father graduated from his therapy program on July 26,
2023, and his therapist reported he had made substantial
progress over 10 months of sessions. Father completed his 52-
week parent education, domestic violence, and anger
management program course on October 11, 2023.
In November 2023, DCFS liberalized father’s visitation to
overnight visits.
As of January 23, 2024, DCFS recognized father had
completed his services and demonstrated some insight into case
issues. DCFS expressed continued concern about potential abuse
between father and mother, but ultimately assessed C.H. Jr. as
at moderate risk of future abuse or neglect if returned to father’s
custody. DCFS therefore recommended the child reunify with
father, so long as father and child resided with paternal
grandmother and participated in family preservation services.
Because mother continued to struggle with substance abuse,
DCFS recommended terminating her reunification services.
At the January 23, 2024 eighteen-month permanency
review hearing, the juvenile court was “very pleased” and
extended “special congratulations to the father.” The court found
father had made substantial progress and that returning C.H. Jr.
to father would not create a substantial risk to the child’s safety.
The court therefore ordered C.H. Jr. to father’s home, so long as
father resided with paternal grandmother or in a DCFS-approved
home, and ordered family preservation services for father. The
court converted mother’s services to enhancement services and
ordered a written visitation schedule for mother.
11
VI. Section 340 removal.
On April 29, 2024, DCFS received a report indicating that
father had recently physically assaulted mother. Mother
reported that she was out with friends early in the morning of
April 28, 2024. Father called her and offered to drive her home.
Mother was reluctant but eventually accepted. Father did not
immediately arrive, so mother began to walk home. Soon, father
drove up, exited his vehicle, and abruptly hit mother on the back
of the head so hard that she fell. Father continued to hit mother
until she felt “ ‘dazed.’ ” A bystander intervened, and father hit
mother one more time then fled.
A police report describing the incident indicates mother
“was unable to keep track of the events.” According to the report,
the bystander saw mother arguing with father while he slowly
drove around her in his vehicle. Mother entered the vehicle
briefly and then father tried to push her out. Mother got out of
the vehicle and they continued to argue. Father then exited the
vehicle, ran toward mother, and grabbed her head with one hand
while punching her with the other fist. Mother fell to the ground
and father made a kicking motion. The bystander heard mother
scream, “ ‘Just kill me!’ ” When the bystander announced she
was calling 911, she heard father yell, “ ‘Stay out of it bitch, I got
you marked!’ ” Father then got into his vehicle and drove away.
The bystander made a video of the incident, which DCFS later
obtained and provided to the juvenile court.
Mother told a DCFS social worker that father had also hit
her in the face around Easter, leaving her with a “ ‘black eye and
busted lip.’ ” Mother did not report that incident because father
begged her not to.
12
The social worker contacted father on May 1, 2024, and
informed him that DCFS had received reports of a recent
domestic violence incident between father and mother. Father
asserted any such reports were false. He claimed that his last
contact with mother was two weeks earlier. Father accused
mother of lying, claimed she “always causes drama,” and stated
he was worried about mother’s drug use.
On May 2, 2024, the DCFS social worker spoke to mother.
She reported that father called her angrily and demanded that
she “cover up for him so he does not lose” C.H. Jr. Father told
mother that if she did not “fix it he would tell [DCFS] the truth
about her.” Mother decided to press charges against father and
pursue a restraining order. On May 15, 2024, mother obtained a
criminal protective order against father, which will expire on
May 15, 2027.
The social worker also spoke to father on May 2, 2024.
Father claimed mother was “reporting lies” and “trying to ruin
his life.” He “shifted the blame” to mother and asserted mother’s
drug use was the source of the family’s problems.
On May 3, 2024, mother reported that father called her and
threatened to report her to Immigration and Customs
Enforcement. Mother hung up and blocked father’s phone
number.
On May 8, 2024, DCFS filed a section 340 application
seeking authorization to remove C.H. Jr. from father’s custody.
The juvenile court granted the application that day. C.H. Jr. was
again placed with maternal grandmother.
On May 9, 2024, a DCFS social worker spoke to father.
Father again denied that any domestic violence had occurred and
again accused mother of lying. He asserted that C.H. Jr. was not
13
present during the incident, “ ‘so what does it matter.’ ” The
social worker observed that father’s domestic violence was an
ongoing case issue and that father repeatedly failed to recognize
the potential risk to his child.
VII. Section 387 petition and subsequent section 342
petition; termination of reunification services.
On May 10, 2024, DCFS filed a section 387 petition seeking
a more restrictive placement and a subsequent removal petition
pursuant to section 342, both based on the April 28, 2024
altercation.
On May 13, 2024, the juvenile court determined there was
substantial danger to C.H. Jr.’s physical and emotional health
and that it would be detrimental for the child to remain in
father’s home. The court therefore removed C.H. Jr. from father.
On June 5, 2024, father spoke to a DCFS social worker and
again denied hitting mother in the head. When the social worker
told father that there was a video of the incident, father accused
mother of throwing a tequila bottle at him. The social worker
told father DCFS would be recommending that the court
terminate father’s reunification services.
On June 27, 2024, DCFS assessed that there was a very
high risk to C.H. Jr. if he remained in his parents’ care. DCFS
cited father’s ongoing domestic violence against mother, his
repeated denials that any violence had occurred, and his failure
to take responsibility for his actions. DCFS also noted that
mother continued to use methamphetamines, amphetamines, and
marijuana, and tested positive for drugs as recently as May 31,
2024. DCFS recommended that the court terminate family
reunification services for father and mother.
14
At the June 27, 2024 jurisdiction and disposition hearing,
father pleaded no contest and entered a settlement as to the
section 342 and section 387 petitions. Pursuant to the
settlement, the court sustained both petitions with amendments.
Specifically, the court sustained allegations that father and
mother had a history of violent alterations, that father struck
mother on the back of the head on April 28, 2024, and that father
struck mother in March 2024 causing a bruised eye and a cut lip.
The court described the video of the April 28, 2024 incident
as “very jarring” and “violent and aggressive.” It observed that
father had custody of C.H. Jr. at the time, and that even if the
child was not present during the incident, the parents’
relationship was “absolutely toxic” and could have harmed the
child. The court noted that DCFS “has been providing reasonable
services to the parents to help them reunify, and that we’re in the
same situation that we were in May of 2022.” The court therefore
determined reunification attempts had failed, terminated
reunification services for both parents, and set a section 366.26
permanency review hearing for October 22, 2024.
VIII. Father’s section 388 petition.
On October 9, 2024, father filed a section 388 petition
asking the court to amend its June 27, 2024 order of no
reunification services for father. The petition alleged that father
had attended additional individual counseling addressing
domestic violence, and it attached a letter from a counseling
center supporting that father had participated in eight weekly
counseling sessions between July and September 2024. The
sessions addressed “healthy coping skills, co-parenting,
strengthening family systems, improving conflict resolution,
psychoeducation on complex trauma, identifying abuse patterns,
15
communication, and clarification of individual roles and needs.”
Father also submitted records showing he completed eight
parenting classes between July and September 2024 and 10
sessions of anger management. His petition further alleged that
he had complied with the criminal protective order barring him
from contacting mother and that he would not reconcile with
mother. Father asked the court to order family reunification
services for father or to release C.H. Jr. to father and order
family maintenance services. The petition asserted it was in C.H.
Jr.’s best interests to reunify with father because father had a
bond with the child and consistently and appropriately visited
the child.
At the October 22, 2024 section 366.26 hearing, the juvenile
court denied father’s section 388 petition without an evidentiary
hearing. The court explained: “There has been no domestic
violence participation since removal. [¶] No discussion of the
domestic violence in individual counseling, as noted in the
father’s exhibits. [¶] And I don’t believe that it would be in [the
child’s] best interests, at this time.” The court continued the
section 366.26 permanency hearing to the following month.
Father timely appealed the juvenile court order denying his
section 388 petition.
16
DISCUSSION
Father argues that the juvenile court abused its discretion
by summarily denying his section 388 petition without a hearing.
For the reasons that follow, we find no abuse of discretion.3
I. Legal standards.
Section 388 allows a parent to petition the juvenile court to
modify a prior order based on changed circumstances. (§ 388,
subd. (a).) To obtain such a modification, the petitioner must
demonstrate by a preponderance of the evidence both a change of
circumstance and that the proposed change of order is in the
child’s best interests. (§ 388, subds. (a) & (d); Cal. Rules of Court,
rule 5.570(d); In re Alayah J. (2017) 9 Cal.App.5th 469, 478.)
“The change of circumstances or new evidence ‘must be of such
significant nature that it requires a setting aside or modification
of the challenged prior order.’ ” (In re Mickel O. (2011) 197
Cal.App.4th 586, 615.)
A section 388 petition “must be liberally construed in favor
of its sufficiency.” (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 5.570.) “If it appears
that the best interests of the child or the nonminor dependent
may be promoted by the proposed change of order . . . the court
shall order that a hearing be held” on the petition. (§ 388, subd.
(d).) However, if the petition fails to make a prima facie showing
3 Father’s opening brief also challenges certain juvenile court
orders entered in June 2024. These orders were not identified in
father’s notice of appeal. Moreover, because father’s appeal was
filed in October 2024, any challenge to the June 2024 orders was
untimely. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.406(a)(1).) We therefore
decline to consider father’s arguments as to the June 2024 orders.
17
of both required elements, the court need not hold a hearing. (In
re Zachary G. (1999) 77 Cal.App.4th 799, 806–807.)
“Whether [the petitioner] made a prima facie showing
entitling [the petitioner] to a hearing depends on the facts alleged
in [the] petition, as well as the facts established as without
dispute by the court’s own file . . . .” (In re Angel B. (2002) 97
Cal.App.4th 454, 461.) “The court may consider factors such as
the seriousness of the reason leading to the child’s removal, the
reason the problem was not resolved, the passage of time since
the child’s removal, the relative strength of the bonds with the
child, the nature of the change of circumstance, and the reason
the change was not made sooner. [Citation.] In assessing the best
interests of the child, ‘a primary consideration . . . is the goal of
assuring stability and continuity.’ ” (In re Mickel O., supra, 197
Cal.App.4th at p. 616.)
We review the juvenile court’s summary denial of a section
388 petition without a hearing for abuse of discretion. (In re B.C.
(2011) 192 Cal.App.4th 129, 141.) We will not disturb its ruling
“ ‘ “unless the trial court has exceeded the limits of legal
discretion by making an arbitrary, capricious, or patently absurd
determination [citations].” ’ ” (In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7
Cal.4th 295, 318.)
II. The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion.
Father asserts the trial court abused its discretion by
summarily denying his section 388 petition because the petition
made a prima facie showing necessary to obtain a hearing. On
appeal, father contends “[t]he changed circumstances were that
[father] completed his case plan.” However, father completed his
case plan in January 2024, five months before the June 2024
order that his section 388 petition sought to modify. Because this
18
completion predates the June 2024 order, it is not a change in
circumstance that could support a section 388 petition to modify
that order.
We focus instead on the changed circumstances identified
in father’s section 388 petition. The petition alleged that after
the June 2024 order was entered, father completed eight weekly
individual counseling sessions, eight sessions of a parenting
course, and 10 anger management sessions. Yet, none of these
programs directly addressed father’s domestic violence, which
was the problem that led to C.H. Jr.’s removal.4 Moreover, father
had already participated in similar programs extensively. Father
first enrolled in domestic violence courses more than two and a
half years before he filed his section 388 petition. After
completing 16 sessions, father entered mother’s home while she
was sleeping and hit her in the face. Father eventually
completed a 52-week parent education, domestic violence, and
anger management program; and he participated in 10 months of
individual therapy. Father nonetheless struck mother again in
March 2024, causing bruising and a cut lip; and in April 2024 he
violently hit her in the back of the head. In short, despite
4 Father’s petition alleged that his continued individual
counseling addressed domestic violence. However, as the juvenile
court correctly recognized, a letter from the counseling center
which father attached to his petition did not list domestic
violence as one of the topics addressed in father’s therapy. The
letter identified topics that conceivably could encompass domestic
violence: “improving conflict resolution” and “identifying abuse
patterns.” But even assuming the eight therapy sessions
addressed domestic violence, as we discuss, a few additional
sessions did not constitute a change in circumstances in the
overall context of this case.
19
receiving extensive reunification services, father continued to
engage in the same domestic violence that led to C.H. Jr.’s
removal. Father’s “recent completion of yet another program did
not constitute a material change in circumstances.” (In re N.F.
(2021) 68 Cal.App.5th 112, 122; In re Mickel O., supra, 197
Cal.App.4th at p. 615 [change in circumstance supporting section
388 petition must be of a “ ‘significant nature’ ”]; but see In re
Hashem H. (1996) 45 Cal.App.4th 1791, 1799 [18 months of
therapy and therapist’s recommendation that child return to
parent’s custody was a meaningful change of circumstance].)
Nor did the juvenile court abuse its discretion in concluding
that resuming father’s reunification services would not be in C.H.
Jr.’s best interests. Father filed his petition less than two weeks
before the scheduled section 366.26 hearing. “At the point of
these proceedings—on the eve of the section 366.26 permanency
planning hearing—the child[]’s interest in stability was the
court’s foremost concern and outweighed any interest in
reunification.” (In re Edward H. (1996) 43 Cal.App.4th 584, 594.)
Indeed, after reunification services have been terminated, there
is a rebuttable presumption that a child’s “stability in an existing
placement is in the best interest of the child . . . . [Citation.] To
rebut that presumption, a parent must make some factual
showing that the best interests of the child would be served by
modification.” (In re Angel B., supra, 97 Cal.App.4th at p. 465.)
In assessing a child’s best interests, courts consider: “(1) The
seriousness of the problem which led to the dependency, and the
reason for any continuation of that problem; (2) the strength of
relative bonds between the dependent children to both parent
and caretakers; and (3) the degree to which the problem may be
easily removed or ameliorated, and the degree to which it
20
actually has been.” (In re Kimberly F. (1997) 56 Cal.App.4th 519,
532.)
Father argues resuming reunification services would be in
C.H. Jr.’s best interest because father has a strong bond with the
child and visited him consistently and safely. Yet, father fails to
meaningfully acknowledge—in his petition or on appeal—the
domestic violence that led to C.H. Jr.’s removal.5 As we have
discussed, that violence was serious. The juvenile court described
father’s actions as “very jarring,” “violent and aggressive,” and
“absolutely toxic.” Father also fails to acknowledge the difficulty
he faced in attempting to ameliorate his violent conduct. Even
after 52 weeks of domestic violence classes and 10 months of
individual therapy, father continued to engage in violent
altercations with mother. Father also repeatedly denied that any
violence occurred and minimized the significance of his actions,
suggesting he was unwilling or unable to ameliorate the problem.
(In re Gabriel K. (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 188, 197 [“One cannot
correct a problem one fails to acknowledge”].) The first and third
factors support that resuming father’s reunification services
would not be in C.H. Jr.’s best interests.
As for the second factor, the petition alleged that father had
a strong bond with the child. Indeed, as of October 2024, DCFS
reported that the two shared a “significant and positive bond.”
5 For example, father’s opening brief acknowledges that
mother accused father of attacking her in April 2024, but he
asserts there was “no proof of an assault.” Father’s briefing omits
any reference to the police report, witness account, and videotape
of the incident. He also omits that the juvenile court sustained
allegations of the assault pursuant to father’s own settlement
with DCFS.
21
But father fails to mention that, according to DCFS, the child
also had a strong bond with maternal grandmother. C.H. Jr.
lived with maternal grandmother for nearly two years during the
dependency proceedings, or about half of his young life. Thus,
even taking into account father’s bond with C.H. Jr., the child’s
interest in stability is paramount. (In re Edward H., supra, 43
Cal.App.4th at p. 594.) The second factor is at best neutral, and,
when viewed in the context of the entire record, it does not
establish it would be in C.H. Jr.’s best interests to resume
father’s reunification services. (In re Angel B., supra, 97
Cal.App.4th at p. 465 [mother’s assertion that she bonded with
child and participated in visits was insufficient to establish
modification was in child’s best interests where child also bonded
with foster parents who cared for child since birth; denial of
section 388 petition without a hearing affirmed].)
In sum, in the context of this case, father’s petition failed to
allege materially changed circumstances or that resuming
father’s reunification services would further C.H. Jr.’s best
interests. The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in
denying father’s section 388 petition without a hearing.
22
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court order denying father’s section 388
petition is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
HANASONO, J.
We concur:
EDMON, P. J.
EGERTON, J.
23
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.