In re Sheila M. CA2/8

CourtListener 10676366Calctapp23.09.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 9/23/25 In re Sheila M. CA2/8
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION EIGHT

In re Sheila M., a Person Coming B337772
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
______________________________ Los Angeles County
LOS ANGELES COUNTY Super. Ct. No. 23CCJP04267A
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Appellant,

STELLA E.,

Objector and Appellant,

v.

CHARLES M.,

Defendant and Respondent.

APPEAL from findings and order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Gabriela H. Shapiro, Juvenile Court
Referee. Affirmed.
Gina Zaragoza, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Objector and Appellant.
Dawyn Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy, Assistant
County Counsel, and Kimberly Roura, Deputy County Counsel,
for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Christopher Blake, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Respondent.
_________________________

INTRODUCTION
Mother and the Los Angeles County Department of
Children and Family Services (DCFS) appeal from the juvenile
court’s jurisdictional findings and order as to the minor child.
Mother and DCFS contend the juvenile court should have
sustained the petition as originally pleaded. More specifically,
they argue the juvenile court’s amended language of count b-1
and dismissal of count d-1 was error as Father’s actions
constitute sexual abuse under Welfare and Institutions Code1
section 300, subdivision (d). Father disagrees and argues the
trial court’s decision to amend count b-1 and dismiss count d-1
“was an appropriate exercise of its fact-finding authority and
must be sustained.”
We affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Referral and Investigation
On November 3, 2023, DCFS received a 5-day referral
alleging sexual abuse of 14-year-old Ryan.2 Per the reporting

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2 Ryan’s birth name is Sheila M. Ryan uses he/him/his
pronouns.

2
party, Ryan disclosed that “the trigger” leading to his
hospitalization was an incident where he felt Father’s erect penis
after Father climbed on top of him.
On November 9, 2023, a DCFS children’s social worker
(CSW) arrived at Mother’s home and interviewed Mother and
Ryan. Mother recounted that while she and Ryan were at Ryan’s
doctor’s office for a check-up on October 30, 2023, she noticed
Ryan hesitate in answering a question about “being touched
inappropriately” on the routine medical paperwork and
questionnaire he was completing. Mother asked Ryan about it
and Ryan confided in her that there have been incidents where
Father “laid on top of him and wouldn’t get off” while Ryan was
laying on the bed or couch, making Ryan feel “gross” and
“uncomfortable.” Ryan said he felt Father’s erect penis and that
Father had “grab[bed] his hip hard” on prior occasions. During
this disclosure, Ryan avoided Mother’s eye contact and kept
apologizing as if “it was his fault.”
Ryan then discussed the incidents with his doctor, Kaiser’s
social worker, and the school counselor. Per Mother, “after Ryan
spoke to everyone, it brought up a lot of emotion and Ryan came
to her on 11/1/23 about thoughts of suicide,” leading to his
hospitalization from November 1 through 7, 2023.3

3 This was Ryan’s third hospitalization. He was first
hospitalized after Thanksgiving 2022 because he “fe[lt] like he
can’t do anything right.” His second hospitalization was in
February/March 2023 because he was “bullied for having red
hair.”

3
Mother stated Father’s visits with Ryan were “sporadic”—
“maybe twice a month.”4 Father provides $400 a month in child
support “but does not help with anything else.” Mother has not
spoken with Father since discovering this information and
blocked his phone number on Ryan’s cell.
Ryan told the CSW he “doesn’t want [Father] to go to jail.”
Ryan “does not feel safe with dad” and is “scared” of him because
Father always yells at him. Ryan has been diagnosed with major
depressive disorder, anxiety, ADHD, and gender dysphoria.
B. Forensic Interview
On November 21, 2023, Ryan’s forensic interview was
conducted at the Children’s Advocacy Center.
When the forensic interviewer asked Ryan, “tell me
everything about your dad,” Ryan’s first shared piece of
information was that Father cheated on Mother while Mother
was pregnant with Ryan. He next shared that Father “yelled at
[Ryan] every day . . . for nearly eight years of [his] life.” Ryan
said he “was scared” of Father and, at times, thought Father “was
gonna hurt [him] or something.”
The forensic interviewer asked Ryan to explain what he
previously reported to the CSW.
Ryan described the first instance, which happened when he
was 13 years old. He stated that sometime during the previous
year (2022), while he was laying down on his stomach on the
living room couch in Father’s home, with Father sitting across
from him on a chair, Ryan and Father “were like joking around

4 Mother reported that she and Father were in a relationship
at the time Ryan was conceived; they have not been together
since the year 2020.

4
and then he like, just got up suddenly and then he . . . laid on top
of me . . . . And he wouldn’t get up, even when I told him to [sic].
Not just that, . . . Dad’s a pretty big guy so I like couldn’t breathe
with him on top of me. . . . I felt like I was gonna pass out.”
Father’s stomach was on Ryan’s back, and Father had his legs
“spread over” Ryan’s legs. Ryan at first started “awkward[ly]
laughing” and then “was telling him to get off” but he did not.
When asked whether Father said anything in response, Ryan
said, “I don’t really remember what he said. He either said no or
he was just like laughing.” After about two minutes of Father
“just laying still on” Ryan, Father “finally” got off and went
outside to the porch area to smoke.
The forensic interviewer asked more questions about the
first instance, and Ryan provided the following information: Ryan
felt “something was poking” him “right below [his] butt” and
heard Father breathing “really heavily” and “shaky.” The
interviewer clarified, “Ok, just breathing heavily, he’s on top of
you, and you said you could feel it. And you said that he wasn’t
moving. So he’s just laying on top of you, right?” Ryan replied, “I
think his legs were moving.” “Like a little bit” and were
“shift[ing] around.”
Ryan described the second instance: Sometime in December
2022 or January 2023, Father “did it again except I was on my
back in the bedroom, and he got on top of me with, I had my legs
open . . . and he like laid on top of me . . . and he wouldn’t get off
when I told him to [sic].” Ryan didn’t “know if it was just
[Father’s] pants or something ‘cause he had jeans on . . . but
there was like something poking me.” After “a while,” Father got
up because Ryan was “gasping for air ‘cause [he] couldn’t

5
breathe.” Father “just like left the room” and Ryan did not see
him for “another hour.”
The forensic interviewer asked clarifying questions about
the second instance. Ryan said he was 14 years old during the
second incident and that it took place “definitely right after
Spring.” While he was sprawled out on the bed, he was “messing”
around with Father and “being annoying as a child does,” and
Father got up from his chair, walked over, and “plopped on top” of
Ryan. Ryan’s face was in Father’s shoulder and neck area, and
Father’s legs were in between Ryan’s legs. The interviewer asked
what Father did on top of Ryan, and Ryan answered, “He didn’t
really do anything.” A few minutes later, when asked what
Father’s legs were doing, Ryan answered, “they were moving
more than the last time” and “were just like shifting around a
lot.” Ryan felt “something . . . really hard [¶] . . . [¶] . . . like a
really heavy water bottle” pressed against Ryan’s pelvic area.
Father stopped when “either Grandma called him . . . or he had to
go to the restroom”—Ryan didn’t remember which it was. Ryan
“felt really gross” and “wrapped [himself] in a blanket.”
When asked whether there were any incidents other than
the two described, Ryan stated, “I think its actually happened a
few more times but, I don’t really remember if I like imagined
that . . . or something. And he used to always like put his hand
on my thighs [pats upper thigh near pelvic area]. Not just like
right here [puts hand on leg], that’s just like a pat, he was just
like right here [puts hand higher on thighs].” When Ryan first
turned 14, Father “started making more inappropriate jokes
around me” and made Ryan feel “really uncomfortable [because]
you’re my dad, you shouldn’t be talking about this girl stuff with
me. It’s something Mom should be talking about, not you.”

6
C. Continued Investigation
On November 22, 2023, the CSW received a call from a
therapist from Aurora Charter Oak, Victor Peraza, who said this
was his first interaction with this family. Mr. Peraza said Ryan
was “hospitalized for endangerment to themselves” and that the
“trigger was due to the father.” To Mr. Peraza’s understanding,
“it may have been from playing around but rose to concern when
Ryan felt an erection.”
On December 4, 2023, the CSW interviewed Father at his
home. Father said his method of discipline “used to be to spank,
but he hasn’t spanked since Ryan was four or five years old . . .
now he tries not to yell and calmly talks to Ryan.” Father is
unsure whether Ryan has been medically diagnosed with
anything but knows Ryan “has gender dysphoria” and “had a
difficult time for the past couple years regarding [M]other and
[F]ather’s separation.” Father knew Ryan was hospitalized last
year and this year “for wanting to harm himself.”
The CSW asked Father about the reported sexual abuse
allegations of Father laying on top of Ryan with an erection.
Father said “nothing like that ever happened” and that he did
“not recall anything like that at all.” Father said he was “abused
as a child” by his own father and that he would “never do
anything like that to his child.” The CSW asked about Father
having grabbed Ryan around the upper thigh area. Father said
Ryan “is ticklish in that area” and that he would “tickle Ryan
when goofing but not grab.” Father told the CSW he “finds it
interesting these allegations are coming up now” when there is a
pending child support matter.

7
On December 6, 2023, Mother told the CSW Ryan is
attending group therapy twice a week and meeting with his
therapist every other week and his psychiatrist once a month.
D. Petition and Detention
On December 12, 2023, DCFS filed a section 300 petition on
14-year-old Ryan’s behalf. It alleged:
• Counts b-1, d-1: Father “sexually abused” the child on
prior occasions. In 2022, Father’s “legs and hips were
moving while [he] laid on top of the child, causing
[Father’s] penis to poke below the child’s buttocks,
causing the child difficulty breathing.” In 2023, Father
“laid on top of the child, causing the child’s face to be in
[Father’s] shoulder and neck area. [Father’s] legs were
in between the child’s legs, resulting in [Father’s] body
pressing on the child’s vagina. The child had difficulty
breathing.” On prior occasions, Father placed his hands
on the child’s thighs. The child “felt uncomfortable” due
to Father’s conduct. “Such sexual abuse of the child by
[Father] endangers the child’s physical health and
safety and places the child at risk of serious physical
harm, damage, danger, and sexual abuse.”
At the December 27, 2023 detention hearing, the juvenile
court found a prima facie case exists and that “continuance in the
home of Father is contrary to the child’s welfare.” The juvenile
court ordered Ryan detained from Father and released to
Mother’s home and care. Mother was deemed “non-offending.”
Minor’s counsel informed the court that Ryan “shared he was not
ready to have visits with Father” and discussed whether he
“would have the right to decline” visits. The court ordered no

8
visitation for Father for three weeks as a “cooling off period.”
Father may then have monitored visits with Ryan, once a week
for one hour. The court stressed that Ryan “is not to be forced to
attend visits”; the court “certainly d[id]n’t want to create trauma
for . . . Ryan.” DCFS was ordered to document if Ryan did not
wish to participate in visits.
E. Developments during Dependency Proceedings
On January 10, 2024, DCFS interviewed Ryan, who “did
not wish to discuss the details of the allegations.” DCFS
summarized the allegations and Ryan confirmed the allegations
were “correct and true” as summarized. Ryan said, “Who does
that to their daughter? Why would you get on her anyway?”
Ryan expressed he is not interested in reunifying with or seeing
Father. He stated that Father is “kind of a dick. He gaslights me
a lot. He treats me like I’m stupid. He does that to my mom too.
. . . I just don’t like him. He convinced me for a while that he
was a good guy, until last year. That is when I stopped liking
him. It was the day mom told me that he [had] cheated on her. I
started thinking everything over and I realized he’s not a nice
guy.” Ryan was asked if he came to this realization before or
after the sexual abuse occurred. Ryan answered, “On[e] incident
was before, the other was after.”
On January 25, 2024, the juvenile court ordered the
production of the DVD of Ryan’s November 21, 2023, forensic
interview.
F. Adjudication
The jurisdictional and dispositional hearing took place
March 28, 2024. Mother and DCFS both requested that the court
sustain the petition as pleaded. Father requested that the

9
petition be dismissed in its entirety or, in the alternative, dismiss
count d-1 and sustain an amended count b-1.
After hearing argument, the juvenile court made lengthy
findings: “I recognize the standard is a preponderance of the
evidence and I think it is very important to consider all of the
factors and the people involved and the statements that were
made by Ryan. Ryan, through the forensic interview, comes
across as a child very bonded and devoted to his Mother and
internalizes a lot of the mother’s emotions and feelings with
regards to the father.”
The court did “not believe that Ryan made things up.
Ryan’s demeanor during the forensic interview became very
emotional and his voice dropped to almost a whisper when he was
expressing the two incidents that he alleges occurred between
him and the father and acknowledges that there was an incident
that occurred when the two of them—meaning the father and
Ryan—were joking around, and that Dad suddenly got on top of
Ryan and wouldn’t get off. And then there was another incident
again in December and Ryan was laying on his back and there is
a description of the father getting on top of Ryan and how Ryan
believed he was overreacting because it was his dad. And there
was a lot of discussion by Ryan about Mom being [a] very sweet
person and Dad being a person who yells and is tough and is a
big person and that that is what made Ryan not be able to
breathe, and the inappropriate jokes.”
The court “can’t help but think that part of the interaction
between the father and Ryan has something to do with Ryan’s
gender dysphoria and that some of the relationship started to
change when that became evident. And . . . there is a definite
possibility—that the father may have made jokes or made

10
comments that appeared inappropriate to Ryan but that perhaps
a father wouldn’t think is inappropriate to say to a son, even
though—I’m not trying to reach for anything, but I’m trying to
understand the relationship and the dynamics with the family—
and that could be definitely taking things too far. I don’t think it
is appropriate to make inappropriate jokes or sexual comments
depending on the child’s gender.”
The court continued: “What I cannot believe, even by a
preponderance of the evidence, is that any of the behaviors that
Ryan attributes to the father were done for sexual gratification
such that the elements in . . . Penal Code section 11165.1 [are
met]. I don’t think that even the description of the potential
erection that was discussed even meets that level, and I think
that, if anything, the court can sustain a b-1 count with relation
to sexual boundaries being crossed and that it was inappropriate
behavior. And I think a lot of it stems from the gender dysphoria
and lack of knowledge and information, and I think that the
intensely emotional experience that Ryan has undergone because
of the custody disputes and all of it has sort of blended together,
and so I think that Ryan was credible but I think that it is a
reach to sustain a ‘D’ [count] in this case.” With regards to count
b-1, the court found Father’s conduct was not sexual abuse but
rather “crossed sexual boundaries and resulted in inappropriate
contact” with Ryan.
The court dismissed count d-1 and amended count b-1 of
the section 300 petition by interlineation:
• Count b-1: On prior occasions, Father “crossed
appropriate sexual boundaries which caused the child to
have difficulty breathing and to feel uncomfortable.” On
a prior occasion in 2023, Father “laid on top of the child

11
and placed [his] hands on the child’s thighs, causing the
child’s face to be in [Father’s] shoulder and neck area.
Such conduct . . . caused the child to feel uncomfortable,
placing the child at risk of serious physical harm and
damage.”
The juvenile court proceeded to disposition and found clear
and convincing evidence of a substantial risk of detriment to
Ryan’s safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being
without his removal from Father’s home and care. The court
ordered Ryan released to home of Mother and ordered monitored
visitation for Father, one hour once a week, to take place in a
therapeutic setting. DCFS was given discretion to liberalize.
The court-ordered case plan for Father included parenting
classes, sex abuse awareness counseling,5 conjoint counseling
with Ryan when appropriate, and individual counseling to
address case issues including sexual abuse, co-parenting, and
Father’s “relationship with Ryan as it relates to child’s gender
dysphoria.” Mother was ordered not to discuss with Ryan any
interpersonal issues she has with Father.
Mother and DCFS filed notices of appeal.

5 The court explained: “I’m not ordering sex abuse for
perpetrators [counseling], but I’m ordering sex abuse awareness
counseling because I believe that the father needs to understand
the appropriate sexual boundaries.”

12
G. Post-Disposition Events6
On March 27, 2025, while Mother’s appeal was pending,
the juvenile court found the conditions that justified the initial
assumption of dependency jurisdiction no longer exist and are not
likely to exist if supervision is withdrawn. The court terminated
jurisdiction with a custody order awarding Mother and Father
joint legal custody and awarding Mother sole physical custody of
Ryan. The juvenile court stayed the termination of jurisdiction
pending its receipt of the custody order on April 7, 2025.
DISCUSSION
Mother and DCFS argue on appeal that the juvenile court
should have sustained the section 300 petition as originally
pleaded. They contend Father’s actions qualify as sexual abuse
and fall within conduct described by section 300, subdivision (d).
Father disagrees and argues the juvenile court’s “orders
dismissing the (d) allegations and amending the (b) allegations
must be upheld under the general principles of appellate review of
substantiality of the evidence.”

6 We grant Father’s request for judicial notice filed March
28, 2025 as to exhibit B only—the minute order dated March 27,
2025. (Evid. Code, § 452, subds. (c), (d).)

We also grant Mother’s request for judicial notice filed
April 14, 2025 as to attachments A, B, and C—i.e., the minute
order issued April 7, 2025, the custody exit orders filed April 7,
2025, and Mother’s notice of appeal filed April 7, 2025. (Evid.
Code, § 452, subds. (c), (d).)

13
In light of the juvenile court’s subsequent order
terminating jurisdiction on March 27, 2025, pending receipt of its
custody exit orders issued April 7, 2025, Father argues this appeal
should be dismissed as moot. He contends “[no] relief can be
afforded to appellants” because “[r]einstating the subdivision (d)
allegations will not change” anything since Ryan “is no longer
subject to the jurisdiction of the Juvenile Court.” Mother urges us
to address the appeal because the juvenile court’s findings and
orders have “infected the outcome of subsequent proceedings,”
which Mother has appealed from via her notice of appeal filed
April 7, 2025.
We address these contentions below.
A. Mother’s and DCFS’s Pending Appeal is Justiciable
1. Applicable Law
“As a general rule, an order terminating juvenile court
jurisdiction renders an appeal from a previous order in the
dependency proceedings moot.” (In re C.C. (2009)
172 Cal.App.4th 1481, 1488.) “ ‘[A]n appeal presenting only
abstract or academic questions is subject to dismissal as moot.’ ”
(In re Jody R. (1990) 218 Cal.App.3d 1615, 1621.) An important
requirement for justiciability is the availability of effective relief.
(In re I.A. (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 1484, 1489.)
A reviewing court may nonetheless exercise its discretion to
reach the merits of the parent’s arguments when “(1) the
jurisdictional finding serves as the basis for dispositional orders
that are also challenged on appeal; (2) the findings could be
prejudicial to the appellant or could impact the current or any
future dependency proceedings; and (3) the finding could have
consequences for the appellant beyond jurisdiction.” (In re A.R.
(2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 1146, 1150.)

14
“We decide on a case-by-case basis whether subsequent
events in a juvenile dependency matter make a case moot and
whether our decision would affect the outcome in a subsequent
proceeding.” (In re Yvonne W. (2008) 165 Cal.App.4th 1394, 1404;
see In re Kristin B. (1986) 187 Cal.App.3d 596, 605.)
2. Analysis
When Father filed his respondent’s brief on March 28, 2025
arguing that the appeal should be dismissed as moot as a result
of the juvenile court’s March 27, 2025 order terminating
jurisdiction, Mother had not yet filed her notice of appeal.
Mother waited until the juvenile court’s April 7, 2025 issuance of
custody exit orders; in fact, she filed her notice of appeal that
same date. This supports Mother’s argument on appeal that the
juvenile court’s findings and order further prejudice her with
respect to subsequent custody orders pertaining Ryan—orders
she has since appealed.
We consider the merits of Mother’s appeal. Ryan will
remain a minor until January 20, 2027; it is possible there may
be future actions regarding him, either in the family law context
or the dependency context (besides Mother’s other pending
appeal), until he reaches the age of majority. It is also plausible
Father or the family law court may rely on the juvenile court’s
findings in making future, modified custody or visitation orders;
thus, prejudice in subsequent family law proceedings is possible,
rendering Mother’s appeal justiciable.

15
B. Substantial Evidence Supports the Juvenile Court’s
Jurisdictional Findings
1. Standard of Review
In reviewing a challenge to the sufficiency of the evidence
supporting jurisdictional findings and related dispositional
orders, we “consider the entire record to determine whether
substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s findings.” (In
re T.V. (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 126, 133; accord, In re I.J. (2013)
56 Cal.4th 766, 773.) “Substantial evidence is evidence that is
‘reasonable, credible, and of solid value’; such that a reasonable
trier of fact could make such findings.” (In re Sheila B. (1993)
19 Cal.App.4th 187, 199.) In making our determination, we draw
all reasonable inferences from the evidence to support the
findings and orders of the dependency court; we review the record
in the light most favorable to the court’s determinations and we
note that issues of fact and credibility are within the province of
the trial court. (In re I.J., at p. 773.) “ ‘ “We do not reweigh the
evidence or exercise independent judgment, but merely
determine if there are sufficient facts to support the findings of
the trial court.” ’ ” (Ibid.) We uphold the juvenile court’s findings
unless they are “ ‘ “so lacking in evidentiary support as to render
them unreasonable.” ’ ” (Jamieson v. City Council of the City of
Carpinteria (2012) 204 Cal.App.4th 755, 763.)
2. Applicable Law
Under section 300, subdivision (b)(1), a juvenile court may
assert jurisdiction over a child if “[t]he child has suffered, or there
is a substantial risk that the child will suffer, serious physical
harm or illness as a result of . . . [¶] (A) The failure or inability of

16
the child’s parent . . . to adequately supervise or protect the
child.” (§ 300, subd. (b)(1).)
Additionally, a juvenile court may assert jurisdiction over a
child under section 300, subdivision (d), if the child “has been
sexually abused, or there is a substantial risk that the child will
be sexually abused, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal
Code, by the child’s parent.” (§ 300, subd. (d).) Penal Code
section 11165.1, in turn, defines “sexual abuse” as “sexual assault
or sexual exploitation” and includes any act that violates Penal
Code section 288 (lewd or lascivious acts upon a child under the
age of 14) or Penal Code section 647.6 (annoying or molesting a
child). (Pen. Code, § 11165.1, subd. (a).)
Penal Code section 288 bars “any lewd or lascivious act . . .
upon or with the body, or any part or member thereof, of a child
who is under the age of 14 years, with the intent of arousing,
appealing to, or gratifying the lust, passions, or sexual desires of
that person or the child.” (Pen. Code, § 288, subd. (a).) Penal
Code section 288 “is violated by ‘any touching’ of an underage
child accomplished with the intent of arousing the sexual desires
of either the perpetrator or the child.” (People v. Martinez (1995)
11 Cal.4th 434, 452.)
Penal Code section 647.6, subdivision (a)(1) makes it a
crime to “annoy[ ] or molest[ ] any child under 18 years of age.”
(Pen. Code, § 647.6, subd. (a)(1).) Penal Code section 647.6 “does
not require a touching [citation] but does require (1) conduct a
‘ “normal person would unhesitatingly be irritated by” ’
[citations], and (2) conduct ‘ “motivated by an unnatural or
abnormal sexual interest” ’ in the victim.” (People v. Lopez (1998)
19 Cal.4th 282, 289.)

17
Penal Code section 11165.1 provides, “Conduct described as
‘sexual assault’ includes, but is not limited to” “[t]he intentional
touching of the genitals or intimate parts, including the breasts,
genital area, groin, inner thighs, and buttocks, or the clothing
covering them, of a child, or of the perpetrator of a child, for
purposes of sexual arousal or gratification.” (Pen. Code,
§ 11165.1, subd. (b)(4).) “The absence of physical evidence of
sexual abuse does not preclude a finding of sexual abuse.” (In re
L.O. (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 227, 241–242.)
“To determine whether a defendant acted with sexual
intent, all the circumstances are examined. Relevant factors
include the nature and manner of the touching, the defendant’s
extrajudicial statements, the relationship of the parties and ‘any
coercion, bribery or deceit used to obtain the victim’s cooperation
or avoid detection.’ [Citation.] The requisite intent ‘must be
inferred from all the circumstances . . . . A touching which might
appear sexual in context because of the identity of the
perpetrator, the nature of the touching, or the absence of an
innocent explanation, is more likely to produce a finding that the
act was indeed committed for a sexual purpose and constituted a
violation of the statute. On the other hand, if the trier of fact is
persuaded . . . from all the circumstances, that the touching of a
child was sexually motivated, nothing in the language, history, or
purpose of [Penal Code] section 288 indicates that the touching
should escape punishment simply because it might not be
considered a means of sexual gratification by members of the
mainstream population.’ ” (In re R.C. (2011) 196 Cal.App.4th
741, 750, italics omitted.)

18
3. Analysis
Mother, joined in by DCFS, asserts that the juvenile court
erred in amending the section 300 petition to remove the
allegation of sexual abuse, and in sustaining the petition as
amended by interlineation. Mother and DCFS ask that we
reverse the juvenile court’s ruling and remand the case with
directions to sustain the petition as originally pleaded.
We find that Mother and DCFS have not met the high
burden required for a reversal.
In the underlying proceedings, DCFS was required to prove
by a preponderance of the evidence that Ryan was a person
described by section 300. (§ 355, subd. (a).) Here, the juvenile
court found that DCFS failed to meet that burden under section
300, subdivision (d) (count d-1), and that it met the burden under
section 300, subdivision (b)(1) (count b-1) only when the language
in the petition was amended.
“[W]here the trier of fact has expressly or implicitly
concluded that the party with the burden of proof did not carry
the burden and that party appeals,” the “question for a reviewing
court becomes whether the evidence compels a finding in favor of
the appellant as a matter of law. [Citations.] Specifically, the
question becomes whether the appellants’ evidence was
(1) ‘uncontradicted and unimpeached’ and (2) ‘of such a character
and weight as to leave no room for a judicial determination that
it was insufficient to support a finding.’ ” (In re I.W. (2009)
180 Cal.App.4th 1517, 1528, disapproved of on other grounds by
Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989.) Thus, the question
before us is whether the juvenile court was compelled, as a
matter of law, to sustain the petition as originally alleged under
section 300(b)(1) and (d).

19
We find it was not.
When Father was interviewed by the CSW on December 4,
2023, he denied any incident where he laid on top of Ryan with
an erection. Father said “nothing like that ever happened” and
that he did “not recall anything like that at all.” Father chalked
up the incidents as rough-housing or goofing around. He
admitted to having been “abused as a child” by his own father
and reported he would “never do anything like that to his child.”
Father admitted to tickling Ryan near his upper thigh, where
Ryan “is ticklish,” but that it was while goofing around. Mr.
Peraza, the therapist from Aurora Charter Oak, also opined that
what triggered Ryan “may have been from playing around.”
Ryan’s forensic interview conducted on November 21, 2023
also contained notable inconsistencies. When Ryan first
described the 2022 incident, he stated that Father was “just
laying still on” Ryan for about two minutes until he got off and
went outside to smoke. However, when the forensic interviewer
asked clarifying questions, Ryan then said that Father’s legs
“were moving” and “shifting around” and that Father was
“breathing heavily.” As for the second incident, Ryan stated it
took place sometime in December 2022 or January 2023, and
later stated it took place “definitely right after Spring.” He
admitted it started off when Ryan was “messing” around with
Father and “being annoying as a child does” when Father
“plopped on top” of Ryan. When asked what Father did when he
was on top of Ryan, Ryan answered, “He didn’t really do
anything.” But a few minutes later, Ryan said Father’s legs were
“moving more than the last time” and “were shifting around a
lot.” Ryan didn’t “know if it was just [Father’s] pants or

20
something cause he had jeans on . . . but there was like
something poking” him.
The juvenile court stated on the record that it “consider[ed]
all of the factors and the people involved and the statements that
were made by Ryan . . . through the forensic interview,” which
the juvenile court watched via DVD. The court found Ryan was
very bonded and devoted to his Mother and “internalizes a lot of
the mother’s emotions and feelings with regards to the father.”
The court found “a lot of it stems from the gender dysphoria and
lack of knowledge and information, and I think that the intensely
emotional experience that Ryan has undergone because of the
custody disputes and all of it has sort of blended together.” The
court did not “believe, even by a preponderance of the evidence,
that any of the behaviors that Ryan attributes to the father were
done for sexual gratification such that the elements in . . . Penal
Code. . . section 11165.1 [are met].” The court did not think “that
even the description of the potential erection that was discussed
even meets that level.” We defer to the trial court’s credibility
assessments based, as they are, on firsthand observations
unavailable to us on appeal. (People v. Williams (2015)
61 Cal.4th 1244, 1262.)
Father’s behavior towards Ryan was concerning. The
crossing of certain boundaries was an appropriate basis for
jurisdiction over Ryan under section 300, subdivision (b)(1).
However, the evidence presented does not compel a finding of
sexual abuse as a matter of law, in part because it does not
support a finding that Father had the requisite sexual intent.
Mother’s and DCFS’s evidence (i.e., that Ryan felt Father’s
erection during the incidents) was not uncontradicted and

21
unimpeached so as to compel a finding that Father sexually
abused Ryan.
Mother contends the juvenile court’s finding that the
crossing of boundaries did not amount to sexual abuse is
contradicted by another finding by the juvenile court that Ryan
was credible in his recounting of the two incidents (which would
include Ryan’s allegation that he felt Father’s erect penis). We
agree that the juvenile court’s statements were contradictory at
times, but confusing statements do not meet the high appellate
burden applicable here. If Ryan’s statements were the only
evidence before the court, and his version of events was
uncontradicted and unimpeached, a different result might be
warranted. But because Father’s interview contradicted Ryan’s
account, we cannot find that the evidence compelled, as a matter
of law, a finding of jurisdiction under the petition as originally
phrased.
Applying these principles, we conclude that the evidence,
“view[ed] . . . in the light most favorable to the juvenile court’s
determinations” (In re Yolanda L. (2017) 7 Cal.App.5th 987, 992),
is sufficient to support the finding that Father did not act with
the requisite sexual intent set forth in Penal Code sections
11165.1, subdivision (b)(4), 288, subdivision (a), and 647.6,
subdivision (a)(1). The juvenile court here could properly
conclude that while Father did not recognize appropriate
boundaries with Ryan, he did not act with the requisite sexual
intent. We therefore decline Mother’s and DCFS’s request to
reverse the findings and remand the cause and we affirm the
juvenile court.

22
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s findings and order made March 28,
2024 are affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

STRATTON, P. J.

We concur:

WILEY, J.

VIRAMONTES, J.

23

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.