In re Nathan S. CA2/1

CourtListener 10675454Calctapp22.09.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 9/19/25 In re Nathan S. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

In re NATHAN S., B343540

a Person Coming Under the (Los Angeles County
Juvenile Court Law. Super. Ct. No. 22CCJP04881D)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

MARIO S.G.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Syna N. Dennis, Judge Pro Tempore. Reversed
in part, dismissed in part.
Paul Couenhoven, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Courtney Fisher, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_______________________

Mario S.G. (Father) appeals from the juvenile court’s
assertion of jurisdiction over his son Nathan S.S. (born 2021)
based on Father’s conduct, and from the related disposition order.
The court also based those jurisdiction and disposition orders on
the conduct of Nathan’s mother, N.S.S. (Mother), who is not a
party to this appeal.
Mother has an older daughter, T.E.S. (born 2011), who was
conceived with another man before Mother and T.E.S. emigrated
to the United States in 2016. Mother and Father met in 2020
and thereafter lived together; T.E.S. was part of their household.
Mother and Father struggled to control T.E.S.’s behavior, which
included skipping school, vaping marijuana, and drinking
alcohol. Mother and T.E.S. had numerous arguments over such
behavior, in which Father and Nathan were not involved, that
included physical violence. Nathan was never physically abused
by Mother or Father.
During a dispute over a cellphone on September 28, 2024,
Father hit T.E.S. when Nathan was also in the room. Nathan
was not touched during the incident. T.E.S. asserted she was
fearful of Mother and Father, but stated Mother and Father
treated Nathan differently and she was not worried they would
abuse him.

2
Father was not deemed a parent or guardian of T.E.S., and
the assertion of dependency jurisdiction over T.E.S. is not at
issue in this appeal. When asserting jurisdiction over T.E.S., the
juvenile court also asserted jurisdiction over Nathan. As to
Father, this assertion of jurisdiction was based on a finding that
Nathan was at substantial future risk of serious physical abuse
from Father because Nathan was present when Father struck
T.E.S. on September 28, 2024. We reverse, as no substantial
evidence supports this jurisdictional finding. As Father agrees
later developments have mooted his appeal of the disposition
order, we dismiss that portion of his appeal.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
We limit our summary of the factual and procedural
background to what is necessary to explain our disposition.
Although T.E.S. is not the subject of this appeal, and Mother is
not a party to it, we include facts from the proceedings involving
them where necessary for context.
A. Facts Leading to the Filing of the Dependency
Petition
1. Family Dependency History
On September 19, 2020, the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) received a
referral alleging emotional abuse of T.E.S. based on the child
witnessing Mother committing domestic violence on her
boyfriend.1 Criminal history records showed Mother was

1 The referral history indicates the boyfriend was likely
Father, as the parents were in a relationship in 2020 and T.E.S.

3
arrested for inflicting corporal injury on a spouse or cohabitant
that same day. On September 23, 2020, DCFS received another
referral regarding this same incident, as well as a new allegation
that Mother physically forced T.E.S. into a restroom by grabbing
her arm. DCFS closed both referrals as inconclusive.
On November 21, 2020, DCFS received a referral alleging
Mother neglected T.E.S. by leaving her at a babysitter’s home for
days. DCFS referred Mother to parenting services and domestic
violence classes, and closed the referral as inconclusive.
On August 23, 2021, DCFS received a referral that T.E.S.
was suffering emotional and physical abuse. When interviewed,
T.E.S. described an incident where she was in Father’s way, he
touched her shoulder, and Father was later arrested for reasons
T.E.S. did not understand. Criminal history records showed
Father was arrested for spousal battery on August 22, 2021, and
not anything involving a minor child. DCFS deemed the
allegations unfounded.
On December 2, 2021, DCFS made an unannounced visit to
meet with T.E.S. after learning she had called the police when
Mother and Father were arguing. Mother, Father, and T.E.S. all
agreed a verbal argument occurred but denied any physical
altercation. The matter was closed as inconclusive.
On November 9, 2022, DCFS received a referral alleging
that Mother hit T.E.S. with a wire on her arm and leg, and that
Nathan was at risk of abuse. DCFS substantiated the allegation,
promoted it to a family maintenance case, and filed a Welfare and

referred to the boyfriend as “Alexander,” which is Father’s middle
name and the name under which his criminal history appears.

4
Institutions Code2 section 300 petition on behalf of T.E.S. and
Nathan on December 16, 2022. The juvenile court dismissed the
petition without prejudice on February 15, 2023.
2. August 29, 2024 Referral
On August 29, 2024, DCFS received a referral alleging that
T.E.S. had told the reporting party that Mother had hit her the
day before with a wooden back scratcher, leaving visible golf-ball-
sized bruises. The referral also said that T.E.S. had reported
Mother had hit her on August 27 with only Mother’s hands, and
that Father had laid T.E.S. on the couch and began to “ ‘choke
her,’ ” causing pressure in her chest and difficulty breathing.
When interviewed by DCFS, T.E.S. said Mother had hit her with
the back scratcher after learning that T.E.S. was drunk. Later
investigation indicated that T.E.S. had consumed a significant
amount of tequila and ended up being hospitalized for alcohol
intoxication. T.E.S. told DCFS that Father had not physically
disciplined her. When asked about the mention of choking in the
referral, T.E.S. said she saw Father “ ‘putting me down on the
couch but I don’t know [if the difficulty breathing] was
drunkenness[,]’ further stating she was intoxicated and isn’t
sure.” T.E.S. said Father encouraged Mother to use physical
discipline against T.E.S.
T.E.S. denied that Mother and Father treated Nathan the
way they treated her and denied any physical abuse of Nathan.
T.E.S. reported that Mother and Father often drank alcohol and
hit each other. One of Mother’s friends reported seeing visible
bruises on Mother’s legs, and the parents’ apartment manager

2 Unspecified statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.

5
reported Mother and Father drank on the weekends and argued.
Mother and Father denied any domestic violence.
DCFS found the allegations of physical abuse and general
neglect of T.E.S. and Nathan by Mother to be substantiated, and
the allegations of physical abuse by Father to be inconclusive.
3. September 28, 2024 Referral
On September 28, 2024, DCFS received another referral
alleging T.E.S. was a victim of general neglect by Mother and of
physical abuse by Mother and Father. The referral stated that
T.E.S. had called 9-1-1 after Father had slapped her face. Mother
and Father reportedly took Nathan and fled the home when they
learned T.E.S. had called 9-1-1, and T.E.S. was placed in
protective custody.
T.E.S. told the police that adults in the home had been
drinking beer. T.E.S. said she was watching videos on her cell
phone when Father grabbed the phone “without prompting” and
smashed it to the ground. T.E.S. said Father then slapped the
left side of her face with an open hand twice, grabbed her by the
forearms, and dragged her off the sofa where she was sitting.
Nathan was sitting nearby when this occurred. T.E.S. said
Mother joined in and began to pull her hair. T.E.S. said she had
“no idea” why the attack took place. T.E.S. then used another
phone to call 9-1-1. Police spoke to responding paramedics, who
examined T.E.S. and found no indications of physical trauma.
When DCFS interviewed T.E.S., she indicated Mother
pulled her hair and Father slapped her twice “for nothing.” She
reported past incidents involving abuse by Mother stemming
from issues such as T.E.S. drinking, vaping, dating, and having
behavioral problems at school. T.E.S. said she was afraid of
Mother and Father. T.E.S. denied ever seeing Nathan harmed

6
but was extremely concerned because of the unprovoked attack
on September 28, 2024 in his presence. DCFS observed Nathan
to be preverbal, ambulatory, friendly and playful, and to have no
marks or bruises indicative of abuse.
Mother told DCFS that T.E.S.’s behavior after she ended
the seventh grade in May 2024 had “become atrocious and
dangerous,” including vaping marijuana, consuming alcohol, and
not attending class. Mother said T.E.S. attacked Father and
broke his phone, after which both T.E.S. and Father were
“whaling” their arms at one another defensively. Mother
acknowledged using poor judgment by not engaging with law
enforcement after T.E.S. called 9-1-1, but said she was
exasperated by T.E.S.’s behavior and was worried she and Father
would get in trouble. Mother denied Nathan had ever been
harmed.
Father told DCFS that he did not slap T.E.S. but did use
his arms and hands to try blocking her unprovoked blows on him.
Father said T.E.S. broke his phone, threatened to send him to
jail, and then called 9-1-1. Like Mother, Father regretted the
decision not to interact with law enforcement. Father reported
that T.E.S.’s behavioral issues had escalated since May 2024,
when she began a relationship with a boyfriend. Father said this
led to numerous calls from the school related to attendance
issues, vaping, and alcohol consumption. Father believed T.E.S.’s
behavior had become dangerous, and that she required mental
health services. Father denied ever harming T.E.S. or Nathan.
B. Dependency Petition and Initial Hearings
On October 1, 2024, DCFS filed a section 300 petition on
behalf of T.E.S. and Nathan. The petition did not name Father
as an alleged or presumed father of T.E.S; he was identified only

7
as Nathan’s father. The petition alleged that Mother had
physically abused T.E.S. and that this abuse placed Nathan at
risk of serious physical harm (counts a-1, b-1, and b-2). As to
Father, the petition asserted he struck T.E.S. on September 28,
2024, and that this physical abuse placed Nathan at risk of
serious physical harm (count b-2).3
At the initial hearing on October 2, 2024, counsel for
Father and Mother, along with minors’ counsel, all requested
Nathan be released to Mother and Father.4 Counsel for the
minors stated that “all parties have been consistent about
Nathan’s safety with his parents. [DCFS] has made observations
of him multiple times and has consistently reported no injuries or
concerns. There is a prior referral history of physical abuse and
potential [domestic violence] between [Mother] and [Father], but
none of those referrals have included Nathan. The parents have
made it clear in the reports that they have struggled to parent
and discipline [T.E.S.], but Nathan is differently situated . . . .
Even [T.E.S.] said in the report that her brother has not been
injured because they treat him differently. I did speak with
[T.E.S.] today, and she confirmed that she believes Nathan would
be safe with his parents and that . . . she would hope her brother
can return home.”
DCFS recommended Nathan be detained, and the court
agreed. However, the juvenile court scheduled a prerelease

3 The petition contained further allegations which the court
later struck because DCFS did not sustain its burden of proof.
We accordingly omit discussion of them.
4 Minors’ counsel requested the court detain T.E.S. from
Mother and Father.

8
investigation (PRI) to consider releasing Nathan to the parents’
custody with a safety plan in place. On October 15, 2024, the
juvenile court held the PRI hearing. Over DCFS’s objection, the
court released Nathan to his parents’ custody with a safety plan
in place.
D. Additional Investigation Before the Adjudication
and Disposition Hearing
DCFS conducted further investigation as memorialized in a
jurisdiction/disposition report. T.E.S. and Mother both told
DCFS that Nathan was in the room during the altercation on
September 28, 2024. The report contained further information
about prior physical abuse involving only T.E.S., and stated that
her foster mother was having issues with T.E.S. skipping classes
and not following rules. DCFS made an unannounced visit to the
parents’ home, and found Nathan to be clean, appropriately
dressed, and with no visible marks or bruises. Nathan appeared
to have a possible speech delay, and DCFS referred him to the
Regional Center. DCFS observed Nathan to be fearful of the
social worker assigned to provide services to the family. Both
Mother and Father thought this might be because Nathan was
afraid the social worker was there to take Nathan away.
DCFS believed the court should exercise jurisdiction over
Nathan because he was at risk due to the parents not “chang[ing]
and address[ing] the underlying causes of their abusive behavior”
and not participating in recommended services from the prior
referral investigations.

9
E. The Adjudication and Disposition Hearing
The court held a combined adjudication and disposition
hearing on December 2, 2024.5 The court sustained counts a-1, b-
1, and b-2 as alleged against Mother and count b-2 as alleged
against Father, and dismissed all other counts. As the sustained
counts centered on physical abuse of T.E.S., the court initially
believed that its dismissal of the remaining counts meant
“Nathan is no longer a part of this petition.” After DCFS pointed
out that sustained counts also alleged Nathan was at risk, the
court corrected itself and noted that Nathan was not dismissed.
With regard to disposition for Nathan, the court ordered
him released to the parents’ home. Father was ordered to
participate in family preservation services, counseling, and other
services as part of his case plan.
F. Post-adjudication and Disposition Hearing Events
Father filed a timely notice of appeal from the jurisdiction
and disposition orders on January 15, 2025.6 On July 30, 2025,
the juvenile court terminated jurisdiction over Nathan, granting
Mother and Father joint legal and physical custody of the minor.

5 The hearing was originally scheduled for November 19,
2024, but had to be postponed because T.E.S. was refusing to
return to her placement, and DCFS needed to assess emergency
placement options for her.
6 The notice of appeal erroneously states that Father is
appealing jurisdictional findings and orders made on
December 10, 2024, as opposed to December 2, 2024. As this
error has not prejudiced either party in arguing the issues before
the court, we disregard it.

10
DISCUSSION
Father acknowledges that, in light of the exit order, any
challenge to the dispositional order is moot. As Father does not
argue we should address the now moot dispositional order, we
dismiss his appeal from that order. (Parkford Owners for a Better
Community v. County of Placer (2020) 54 Cal.App.5th 714, 722
[“ ‘When events render a case moot, the court . . . should
generally dismiss it’ ”].)
As for jurisdiction, Father does not seek to challenge the
juvenile court’s assertion of jurisdiction over T.E.S., who is not
his child. Father challenges only the jurisdictional finding
against him involving Nathan.
A. Father’s Appeal of the Jurisdiction Order is Not
Moot
The juvenile court asserted jurisdiction over Nathan based
on conduct by both Mother and Father, and Mother has not
appealed. Accordingly, the juvenile court’s assertion of
jurisdiction over Nathan was proper regardless of the outcome of
this appeal (In re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 283), and in any
event the juvenile court is no longer asserting jurisdiction.
Father asserts his appeal is not moot because it will differentiate
between him being an offending or nonoffending parent. DCFS
does not oppose us reaching the merits of Father’s appeal because
the sustained allegation against him involves physical abuse.
The Penal Code requires that DCFS forward substantiated
reports of child abuse to the California Department of Justice for
inclusion in the Child Abuse Central Index (CACI). (Pen. Code,
§ 11169, subd. (a).) The allegations here involve child abuse, and
if DCFS was to forward the information, the juvenile court’s
finding would estop Father from challenging his inclusion in

11
CACI. (Id., subd. (e).)7 Because of the likelihood our disposition
will impact Father’s legal status going forward, Father’s
jurisdictional challenge is not moot and is justiciable.
B. Relevant Law and Standard of Review
The sole sustained allegation in the petition against Father
(count b-2) was made pursuant to section 300, subdivision
(b)(1)(A).8 To pass muster, this required evidence that Nathan
was at substantial risk of suffering serious physical harm due to
Father’s failure to supervise or adequately protect Nathan.
(Ibid.) “A jurisdictional finding under section 300, subdivision

7 This case is accordingly distinguishable from In re D.P.,
where the father failed to show the allegations against him were
reportable to CACI. (In re D.P., supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 281-
282.) We recognize the ultimate resolution of this issue is
currently pending before our Supreme Court. (In re S.R.
(Aug. 21, 2024, B326812), review granted Sept. 11, 2024, S285759
[granting review to decide: “(1) When a juvenile court’s
jurisdictional findings establish that a parent committed an
offense that the law requires be reported to [CACI], should an
appellate court presume, on an otherwise silent record, the
offense has been or will be reported to CACI? (2) If unrebutted, is
this presumption sufficient to avoid dismissal for mootness?”].)
DCFS does not state whether it has reported Father, but pending
further guidance from our high court we presume on the facts
before us that DCFS will report the offense to CACI and that this
is sufficient to avoid dismissal of the appeal for mootness.
8 The b-2 count, which was alleged against both Mother
and Father, also included an allegation pursuant to section 300,
subdivision (b)(1)(B) that Mother failed to protect T.E.S. from
Father’s conduct. The failure to protect allegation was made only
against Mother; there was no allegation that Father failed to
protect Nathan from Mother.

12
(b)(1), requires DCFS to demonstrate . . . three elements by a
preponderance of the evidence: (1) neglectful conduct, failure, or
inability by the parent; (2) causation; and (3) serious physical
harm or illness or a substantial risk of serious physical harm or
illness.” (In re L.W. (2019) 32 Cal.App.5th 840, 848.) Domestic
violence involving someone other than the child at issue can
constitute neglectful conduct because of “the substantial risk [to
the child] of encountering the violence and suffering serious
physical harm or illness from it.” (In re Heather A. (1996) 52
Cal.App.4th 183, 194.) For an assertion of jurisdiction to stand,
“a significant risk to the child must exist ‘ “at the time of the
jurisdiction hearing.” ’ ” (In re J.N. (2021) 62 Cal.App.5th 767,
775.)
We review jurisdictional findings for substantial evidence
in light of the entire record. (In re I.C. (2018) 4 Cal.5th 869, 892.)
“ ‘To be substantial, the evidence must be of ponderable legal
significance and must be reasonable in nature, credible, and of
solid value.’ ” (In re Cole L. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 591, 602.) “We
do not evaluate the credibility of witnesses, reweigh the evidence,
or resolve evidentiary conflicts.” (In re L.Y.L. (2002) 101
Cal.App.4th 942, 947.) “[W]e draw all reasonable inferences in
support of the findings, consider the record most favorably to the
juvenile court’s order, and affirm if the order is supported by
substantial evidence even if other evidence supports a contrary
conclusion.” (Ibid.)
C. Substantial Evidence Does Not Support the
Jurisdictional Finding Against Father
To assert jurisdiction over Nathan based on count b-2 as
alleged against Father, there had to be substantial evidence
establishing all three of the following: (1) Father physically

13
abused his partner’s daughter T.E.S. when Nathan was present;
(2) there was a substantial risk that Father would abuse T.E.S.
in the future; and (3) this substantial risk of future abuse of
T.E.S. by Father created a concomitant risk that Nathan would
suffer serious physical harm.
Father does not contest that substantial evidence supports
the court’s conclusion that he physically abused T.E.S. on
September 28, 2024, and that Nathan was present when the
abuse occurred. He instead argues there was insufficient
evidence to support a conclusion that he would abuse T.E.S. in
the future in a way that put Nathan at substantial risk of serious
physical harm from Father. We agree.
There is no evidence Nathan was ever physically abused by
either parent. There is no evidence that Father struck T.E.S. on
any occasion when Nathan was present other than September 28,
2024. Indeed, the only other time where it was claimed Father
had struck T.E.S. occurred on August 29, 2024; the party making
a referral to DCFS said T.E.S. reported Father had possibly sat
on T.E.S. and choked her, but when asked directly T.E.S. did not
confirm this had happened even though she was certain that
Mother had hit her. Even if we assume Father harmed T.E.S. on
August 29, there is no evidence Nathan was present. T.E.S. also
stated that Father treated Nathan differently than her, and that
Nathan was not at risk of harm. Although T.E.S. did state she
was “extremely concerned” after the September 28 incident took
place in Nathan’s presence, she later re-confirmed through her
counsel that she did not believe Nathan was at risk.
DCFS seeks to bolster its showing that Father posed a
future risk of harm to Nathan by asserting other evidence
demonstrated domestic violence occurred between the parents.

14
First, the petition alleged no such conduct. Accordingly, Father
had no notice or opportunity to defend against it, and it would be
improper to sustain the petition based on such unalleged conduct.
(See, e.g., In re Andrew S. (2016) 2 Cal.App.5th 536, 544; In re
Wilford J. (2005) 131 Cal.App.4th 742, 751.) Second, even if it
was proper to consider that unalleged conduct, DCFS points to no
evidence that Nathan was ever present during any such domestic
violence. Any risk of physical danger to Nathan for purposes of
section 300, subdivision (b)(1) was therefore minimal. (In re Cole
L., supra, 70 Cal.App.5th at p. 606.)
DCFS contends that Mother and Father were struggling to
address T.E.S.’s behavioral issues, that Mother’s frequent
physically abusive reactions to that behavior were escalating, and
that Mother’s escalations posed risk to Nathan. We do not
quarrel with these claims, but they show only that substantial
evidence supported the court’s assertion of jurisdiction over
Nathan based on Mother’s conduct. This appeal concerns Father,
not Mother. There is no substantial evidence that Father’s
conduct was escalating or that his actions against T.E.S. (an
older and rebellious teenager very differently situated than
Nathan) on one day in September 2024, when Nathan was
present (or what occurred on August 29, 2024, when Nathan was
not present), posed a substantial risk of serious future harm to
Nathan. Accordingly, on this record, Nathan’s presence during
one incident between Father and T.E.S., in which T.E.S. suffered
no visible physical injury, was insufficient to support a
jurisdictional finding that Father posed a substantial risk of
future serious harm to Nathan.

15
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order asserting jurisdiction over
Nathan as against Father is reversed. The appeal of the
disposition order is dismissed as moot.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

WEINGART, J.

We concur:

BENDIX, Acting P. J.

M. KIM, J.

16

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.