In re M.F. CA1/4

CourtListener 10670134Calctapp11.09.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 9/11/25 In re M.F. CA1/4

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FOUR

In re M.F., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.

SAN FRANCISCO HUMAN
SERVICES AGENCY, A172662
Plaintiff and Respondent, (San Francisco City & County
v. Super. Ct. No. JD23-3004)

M.H.,
Defendant and Appellant.

M.H. (Father) appeals from a judgment terminating his parental rights
over M.F. (Minor) after a Welfare and Institutions Code section 366.26
hearing.1 Father argues the San Francisco Human Services Agency (Agency)
failed to comply with the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 (25 U.S.C. § 1901
et seq.; ICWA).2 We affirm.

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions

Code.
2 As ICWA and related California statutes use the term “Indian,” we

occasionally do the same for the sake of clarity and consistency while
acknowledging that other terms (such as “Native American” or “indigenous”)

1
I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
In January 2023, the Agency received a report that Father had hit,
bound and strangled A.F., Minor’s mother (Mother), while one-month-old
Minor was present. Mother was brought to the hospital where she was
incoherent, unable to properly hold Minor, and tested positive for cannabis
and benzodiazepines. A few days later, the Agency filed a section 300
dependency petition seeking to detain Minor. The petition alleged Minor
came within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court based on Father’s arrest for
domestic violence towards Mother, and Mother’s substance abuse and mental
health issues, among others. The petition also noted that a prior dependency
proceeding involving Minor’s half brother (Minor’s Brother) had previously
resulted in the termination of Father’s parental rights.
The section 300 petition also included an ICWA inquiry attachment
which stated the Agency had inquired with both parents and determined
there was no reason to believe Minor may be a Native American child. The
detention report filed by the Agency the following day stated that, when
asked, Father denied having any knowledge of Native American ancestry
while Mother acknowledged the possibility of having Native American
ancestry though she denied registration or knowledge of a specific tribe.
At the detention hearings, the juvenile court ordered Minor removed
from parents and detained in foster care. The court also voir dired both
parents regarding Native American ancestry and ordered the Agency to
follow up with them regarding the ICWA inquiry.
Later that month, the Agency filed an addendum report stating it had
requested that Mother ask the maternal grandmother about whether the

are preferable. (See In re A.A. (2023) 88 Cal.App.5th 393, 396, fn. 1.; In re
G.H. (2022) 84 Cal.App.5th 15, 27, fn. 2.)

2
family had Native American ancestry.3 The Agency also indicated it
attempted but was unable to reach the maternal grandmother, who shared a
cell phone with Mother. The Agency therefore concluded the initial ICWA
inquiry was incomplete and further inquiry was necessary.
Towards the end of January 2023, Father filed an ICWA-020 form
indicating that he may be a member of or eligible for membership in a
federally recognized Indian tribe. However, he did not list the names or
locations of any tribes. Shortly thereafter, Mother filed an ICWA-020 form
now indicating that she did not have any Native American ancestry.
One month later, the Agency filed a disposition report stating that in
early February 2023, Mother stated she identified as Native American but
did not know which tribe she would be affiliated with, was not involved with
a tribe, did not live on a reservation, and did not use any services provided to
Native Americans. Mother also indicated she was unaware of anyone in her
family who would have information regarding Native American ancestry.
The report stated that maternal grandfather was deceased, Mother had no
contact with his family, and Mother provided no contact information for
maternal relatives. Additionally, the disposition report stated that on
February 2 and February 14, 2023, the Agency had attempted to contact
Father, who was incarcerated and awaiting trial, but had not been able to
speak with him. The Agency also indicated that Minor had a half brother on
Father’s side whose whereabouts were unknown. The Agency concluded
there was no reason to believe or know that Minor was an Indian child.

3 The Agency also asked Mother about another man she was claiming

was Minor’s alleged father, but Mother had no contact information for that
man’s friends or relatives. We will not further discuss the Agency’s line of
inquiry relative to this other man because a paternity test later established
that Father was Minor’s biological father.

3
After the jurisdiction and disposition hearing was continued from
February 2023 to March 2023, the Agency filed two addendum reports. In
the first addendum report, the Agency stated that Mother once again
identified as Native American but could not name a tribe, had never used
services, lived on a reservation, or attended cultural activities on a
reservation. The Agency also stated that on February 24, Father declined to
respond to the Agency’s ICWA inquiries. The Agency therefore requested
that the juvenile court order Mother to provide contact information for
maternal relatives and Father to provide ICWA information.
In the second addendum report, the Agency stated that Father did not
respond to texts or phone calls from February 24, 2023, to March 7, 2023, and
that on March 7, he declined to respond to the Agency’s ICWA inquiries.
Based on the foregoing, the Agency concluded there was no reason to know
Minor was an Indian child, and recommended that the juvenile court find an
adequate further inquiry was conducted and ICWA did not apply. The
Agency also filed a request for judicial notice of court records from a prior
dependency proceeding involving Minor’s Brother, now an adult, wherein the
juvenile court found that ICWA did not apply.
At the jurisdiction hearing, the juvenile court sustained the section 300
petition, granted Mother’s request for a three-year restraining order against
Father, and set the matter for disposition. The court also indicated that the
ICWA status would be addressed at the disposition hearing.
In advance of the disposition hearing, the Agency filed an addendum
report stating that Mother continued to identify as Native American, without
any further details to support this representation. As for Father, the Agency
stated he continued to decline to respond to ICWA inquiries and “ha[d] not
engaged with the Agency during the investigation.”

4
After the disposition was continued due to a change in Father’s counsel,
the Agency filed another addendum report before the continued hearing date.
In this report, the Agency stated that Father had declined to answer
questions relating to ICWA on two occasions, but it had spoken with Father
on April 19, 2023, and Father stated he did not know if he had Native
American ancestry. Father also indicated he had never used services for
Native Americans, resided on a reservation, or attended cultural events on a
reservation. The Agency noted that Father had been “very difficult to engage
throughout the investigation,” would decline to respond to questions, or
would become upset with or speak over the social worker. The Agency once
again concluded there was no reason to know Minor was an Indian child, and
recommended that the juvenile court find an adequate further inquiry was
conducted and ICWA did not apply.
At the disposition hearing held in May 2023, the juvenile court declared
Minor a dependent of the court and ordered reunification services for Mother.
The court set a later hearing to address the issue of reunification services for
Father.
Before the June 2023 hearing, the Agency filed an addendum report
wherein it stated that Mother continued to identify as Native American,
without further supporting this representation. The Agency was also able to
meet in person with Father who stated he did not have any Native American
ancestry, had never lived on a reservation, and had never participated in
reservation activities. Further, the Agency noted it had contacted Minor’s
Brother, who stated that Father was supported by Father’s sister who also
lived in the Bay Area. Father also informed the Agency that he was
requesting reunification services as he and his brother were in foster care
during their childhood, and he did not want the same for Minor. The Agency

5
concluded there was no reason to know Minor was an Indian child, and
requested that the juvenile court find ICWA did not apply.
The juvenile court held hearings on the issue of Father’s request for
reunification services in June 2023, August 2023 and September 2023.
Before the August 2023 hearing, the Agency filed an addendum report
stating it had spoken further with Mother regarding her claims of Native
American ancestry, and Mother had stated she believed she had Native
American ancestry as “she ha[d] read several books because she enjoy[ed]
history.” Mother could not further explain what other information led her to
believe she was Native American. The Agency also indicated it had spoken
again with Father, who again stated he did not have Native American
ancestry; Father also stated he did not have any relatives the Agency could
contact to discuss the issue. The Agency further stated maternal
grandmother had not responded to three separate attempts to contact her,
and Minor’s Brother stated on two occasions that he was unaware of Native
American ancestry and did not have contact with paternal relatives. Based
on the foregoing, the Agency concluded there was no reason to know Minor
was an Indian child and requested that the juvenile court find a proper and
adequate further inquiry had been conducted by the Agency.
At the August 2023 hearing, the juvenile court renewed Minor’s
dependency status and stated it would not order visitation for Father at that
time. At the September 2023 hearing, the court renewed Minor’s dependency
status, found that visitation by Father would be detrimental to Minor’s
physical and emotional well-being, and denied Father’s request for
reunification services. The court also set a six-month review hearing for
October 2023.
Before the October 2023 hearing, the Agency filed a status review

6
report setting out its ICWA inquiry efforts to date. In addition to recounting
the outcome of its prior inquiries, the Agency stated it interviewed Mother
about her purported Native American ancestry and was told Mother had an
“ ‘Aunt Pearl’ ” or a “ ‘Nance Farin Jones’ ” (relationship to Mother unknown),
who might have relevant information. Mother did not have contact
information for either individual. Mother also said she thought she may have
relatives from a tribe or reservation somewhere north of California but could
not say why she thought this. Mother also did not know of any relatives who
lived on a reservation, attended boarding school, or attended a Native
American health center for medical or dental work. The Agency attempted to
contact maternal grandmother once more but the phone number provided
was out of service. The Agency concluded there was no reason to know Minor
was an Indian child and requested that the juvenile court find a proper and
adequate further inquiry had been conducted.
The six-month review hearing was continued to January 24, 2024 for a
contested hearing. The Agency filed an addendum report beforehand in
which it stated it had made one more attempt to contact maternal
grandmother, but the number provided could not accept calls. The Agency
also spoke with a maternal grand-aunt who said she was not aware of any
Native American ancestry or of any relatives who lived on a reservation.
Based on the foregoing, the Agency concluded there was no reason to know
Minor was an Indian child and recommended that the juvenile court find that
a proper and adequate further inquiry was conducted. It also recommended
termination of Mother’s services based on the fact Mother continued to miss
visits with Minor and had not participated in services to address her
substance abuse and mental health issues, among others.
At the January 2024 contested hearing, the juvenile court renewed

7
Minor’s dependency, continued reunification services, ordered Mother to
participate in a psychological evaluation, and set a 12-month review hearing.
The court also checked a box on the ICWA Findings attachment stating that
it had found that there was reason to know Minor was an Indian child;
checked a box indicating that notice had been provided to the applicable
tribes and the Agency had exercised due diligence to work with all tribes the
child could be a member of to verify the child’s eligibility or membership
status; and checked the box stating that ICWA did not apply.4
Before the 12-month review hearing, the Agency filed a couple of
additional reports in which it noted the juvenile court had previously found
ICWA did not apply. It also continued to recommend termination of Mother’s
reunification services due to her lack of participation.
At the 12-month review hearing held in June 2024, the juvenile court
terminated Mother’s reunification services, denied a section 388 petition
Father filed requesting custody of Minor and reunification services, and set a
section 366.26 implementation hearing. The Agency filed a couple of
additional reports before the section 366.26 hearing that eventually took
place in January 2025; these reports contained no additional ICWA
information and merely noted the court previously found that ICWA did not
apply. At the section 366.26 hearing, the court terminated Father’s parental
rights and found by clear and convincing evidence that Minor would likely be
adopted.

4 There appears to be a clerical error on the ICWA Attachment as the

record does not indicate there were any tribes to notify nor does it indicate
there was any notice provided to such tribes. Father attempts to latch onto
this error in his reply, arguing the juvenile court expressly found there was
reason to know Minor was an Indian child and such knowledge triggered the
formal notice requirements under ICWA. There is no merit to this contention
for the reasons set forth below.

8
This appeal by Father followed.
II. DISCUSSION
Father contends on appeal that the Agency failed to adequately inquire
as to Minor’s Native American heritage. Thus, he requests that the order
terminating his parental rights be conditionally affirmed and the matter
remanded for the Agency to comply with ICWA.
A. Applicable Legal Principles and Standard of Review
Congress enacted ICWA in 1978 in response to “ ‘abusive child welfare
practices that resulted in the separation of large numbers of Indian children
from their families and tribes through adoption or foster care placement,
usually in non-Indian homes.’ ” (In re Dezi C. (2024) 16 Cal.5th 1112, 1128
(Dezi).) This separation of Indian children “ ‘contributed to a number of
problems, including the erosion of a generation of Indians from Tribal
communities, loss of Indian traditions and culture, and long-term emotional
effects on Indian children caused by loss of their Indian identity.’ ” (Ibid.)
ICWA sought to redress these practices, in part, by “establish[ing] minimum
standards for state courts to follow before removing Indian children from
their families and placing them in foster care or adoptive homes,” and
allowing an Indian child’s tribe to “ ‘intervene at any point’ ” in a proceeding
involving the removal of an Indian child from their family. (Dezi, at p. 1129.)
Whether ICWA applies in a dependency proceeding turns on whether
an “Indian child” is involved.5 (In re A.A., supra, 88 Cal.App.5th 393, 399.)

5 An “Indian child” is defined as “[a]ny unmarried person who is under

18 years of age” who is either “(A) [a] member or citizen of an Indian tribe” or
“(B) [e]ligible for membership or citizenship in an Indian tribe and is a
biological child of a member or citizen of an Indian tribe.” (§ 224.1,
subd. (b)(1)(A)−(B).)

9
To effectuate timely determinations under ICWA and the California Indian
Child Welfare Act (Cal-ICWA)—ICWA’s state analogue—courts and child
welfare agencies are charged with an “affirmative and continuing duty to
inquire whether a child . . . is or may be an Indian child.” (§ 224.2, subd. (a).)
This duty of inquiry by the social services agency begins when it is first
contacted regarding a child and includes an obligation to ask “each family
member, including extended family members” whether the child is or may be
an Indian child. (Id., subd. (b)(1).) A similar duty of initial inquiry exists for
the court presiding over a juvenile proceeding that could result in placement
of a child with someone other than a parent. (Id., subd. (c).)
The quality of information obtained by the initial inquiry dictates the
subsequent obligations imposed by Cal-ICWA, if any, on the juvenile court
and the social services agency. Where the inquiry produces a “reason to
know” a child is an Indian child, the party seeking foster care placement with
someone other than a parent or Indian custodian must provide formal notices
to the tribe concerning court proceedings. (§§ 224.2, subds. (d), (f), 224.3.)
If, on the other hand, the initial inquiry does not provide a reason to
know, but instead presents a “reason to believe” the child is an Indian child,
then the court and the social services agency are responsible for promptly
pursuing further inquiry regarding the possible Indian status of the child.
(§ 224.2, subd. (e).) Further inquiry includes but is not limited to
interviewing the “parents, Indian custodian, and extended family members”
to gather information required under section 224.3, subdivision (a) for
purposes of providing a tribe with the names, addresses and birth dates of
the child’s biological parents, grandparents, and great-grandparents;
contacting the Bureau of Indian Affairs and State Department of Social
Services for assistance in identifying the names and contact information of

10
tribes in which the child may be a member or citizen; and “[c]ontacting the
tribe or tribes and any other person that may reasonably be expected to have
information regarding the child’s membership, citizenship status, or
eligibility.” (Id., subd. (e)(2)(C).) The juvenile court “has a responsibility to
ascertain that the agency has conducted an adequate investigation.” (In re
K.R. (2018) 20 Cal.App.5th 701, 709.)
There is reason to know a child is an Indian child if: (1) a person with
an interest in the child, such as an officer of the court, a tribe, an Indian
organization, a public or private agency, or a member of the child’s extended
family, informs the court the child is an Indian child; (2) the residence or
domicile of the child, child’s parents, or Indian custodian is on a reservation
or in an Alaska Native village; (3) a participant in the proceeding, officer of
the court, Indian tribe, Indian organization, or agency informs the court it
has discovered information indicating the child is an Indian child; (4) the
child gives the court reason to know the child is an Indian child; (5) the court
is informed the child is or has been a ward of a tribal court; and (6) the court
is informed that either the parent or the child possess an identification card
indicating membership or citizenship in an Indian tribe. (§ 224.2, subd. (d).)
There is reason to believe a child is an Indian child if there is information
suggesting that either the parent or child is a member or citizen, or may be
eligible for membership or citizenship, in an Indian tribe. (Id. at subd. (e)(1).)
Information suggesting membership or citizenship, or potential membership
or citizenship in a tribe, includes information that indicates the existence of
one or more of the reasons to know enumerated above. (Ibid.)
When a juvenile court finds that ICWA does not apply to a child,
“ ‘ “[t]he finding implies that . . . social workers and the court did not know or
have a reason to know the children were Indian children and that social

11
workers had fulfilled their duty of inquiry.” ’ ” (In re Josiah T. (2021)
71 Cal.App.5th 388, 401 (Josiah T.).) We review a juvenile court’s ICWA
findings for substantial evidence, which requires us to determine if
“ ‘ “reasonable, credible evidence of solid value supports the court’s order.” ’ ”
(Ibid.; see also In re S.H. (2022) 82 Cal.App.5th 166, 175.)
B. Adequacy of the Agency’s Inquiry
Father argues that the Agency failed to adequately inquire as to
Minor’s Native American heritage when it failed to document any inquiry of
the paternal aunt and uncle, did not acknowledge in its reports that Father
had completed an ICWA-020 form indicating he might be eligible for
membership in a federally recognized tribe, and made no effort to contact
tribes regarding Minor’s possible Native American ancestry. We disagree.
The record indicates the Agency went to great lengths to inquire as to
whether either of Minor’s parents had Native American ancestry. With
respect to Mother, the Agency continued to seek out ICWA-related
information, notwithstanding the fact Mother filed an ICWA-020 form
initially indicating she did not have Native American ancestry. The Agency
spoke with Mother multiple times to try and discern the basis of her claims of
Native American ancestry, asked Mother to ask maternal grandmother about
the issue, unsuccessfully attempted on multiple occasions to speak with
maternal grandmother, and spoke with a maternal grand-aunt who denied
any knowledge of Native American ancestry in the family. After all of these
conversations, Mother could say no more than that she believed she was
Native American because “she ha[d] read several history books.” Further,
despite representing that she might have relatives from a tribe or reservation
somewhere north of California, she could not explain the basis for her belief.
Mother also did not provide any contact information for “ ‘Aunt Pearl’ ” or a

12
“ ‘Nance Farin Jones,’ ” who Mother stated might have more information.
As for Father, beginning in February 2023, the Agency attempted to
speak with him multiple times and, when it was finally able to reach him, he
refused to respond to the ICWA inquiries. From the end of February 2023 to
the beginning of March 2023, Father failed to respond to the Agency’s texts
and phone calls, and continued to decline to respond. In April 2023, Father
began responding to the Agency and indicated he did not know if he had
Native American ancestry, but had never used services for Native Americans,
resided on a reservation, or attended cultural events on a reservation.
However, the Agency noted that Father continued to be “very difficult to
engage throughout the investigation,” would decline to respond to questions,
or would become upset with or speak over the social worker.
It is true that at some point in the investigation, Father mentioned
having a brother who was in foster care with him and Minor’s Brother
mentioned Father’s sister who also lived in the Bay Area. However, neither
Father nor Minor’s Brother provided any names or contact information of
these individuals, and in July 2023, Father specifically indicated that he had
no relatives he or the Agency would be able to contact to discuss the ICWA
issue. In later conversations with Father, he also stated that he did not have
Native American ancestry. Minor’s Brother also reported on two occasions
that he was unaware of any Native American ancestry.
The foregoing constitutes substantial evidence in support of the
juvenile court’s finding that the Agency fulfilled its duty of inquiry. (See
Josiah T., supra, 71 Cal.App.5th at p. 401.) Notwithstanding both parents’
vague and inconsistent representations as to whether they had Native
American ancestry, the Agency repeatedly attempted to obtain contact
information of relatives who could potentially provide more information

13
regarding the ICWA issue and repeatedly attempted to contact and speak
with relatives for whom the Agency did have contact information, including
Minor’s Brother and a maternal grand-aunt. Each of their attempts,
however, came up empty.
Further, neither Mother nor Father provided the Agency with the
contact information necessary to further advance the ICWA inquiry. Under
these circumstances, the Agency was not required to inquire any further.
(See, e.g., In re Q.M. (2022) 79 Cal.App.5th 1068, 1082 [where parent largely
fails to cooperate with agency or to provide names and contact information
for extended family members, agency’s ability to conduct exhaustive ICWA
inquiry is necessarily constrained]; In re K.M. (2009) 172 Cal.App.4th 115,
119 [agency “did all that can or should be reasonably expected of it to meet its
obligation” when record indicated it “attempted on several occasions to elicit
further information from the child’s family, but was unsuccessful due to the
family’s hostility”].) Though it is true the Agency has a duty to develop
information bearing on whether a child is a Native American child, “in most
cases the court and [agency] cannot satisfy this duty without the
participation of the parents.” (Q.M., at p. 1082.) Thus, though it is
reasonable in many cases to follow up on leads provided by the parents, “we
cannot ask the agency to intuit the names of unidentified family members or
to interview individuals for whom no contact information has been provided.”
(Ibid.)
As for Father’s other arguments regarding the purported inadequacy of
the Agency’s ICWA inquiry, they also have no merit. Father takes issue with
the Agency’s failure to acknowledge in its reports that Father had completed
an ICWA-020 form indicating he might be eligible for membership in a
federally recognized tribe. However, this fact has nothing to do with the

14
adequacy of the Agency’s ICWA inquiry. Further, as stated, the record
clearly indicates that even if the Agency did not acknowledge Father’s filing
of this form, it did continue to pursue the ICWA inquiry despite Father
reporting on at least three occasions subsequent to completing the ICWA-020
form that he did not have Native American ancestry.
As for Father’s contention the Agency made no effort to contact tribes
regarding Minor’s possible Native American ancestry based on Mother’s
belief she might have relatives located in a tribe north of California, he does
not further elaborate. As such, we deem this contention waived. (See In re
Marriage of Falcone & Fyke (2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 814, 830 [“The absence of
cogent legal argument or citation to authority allows this court to treat the
contentions as waived”].) In any event, the Agency’s duty to provide formal
notices was not triggered by Mother’s unsubstantiated and vague references
to potential membership in a tribe or reservation somewhere north of
California as they did not provide reason to know Minor was an Indian child.
(See §§ 224.2, subds. (d), (f), 224.3.)
III. DISPOSITION
The order terminating parental rights is affirmed, and no remand for ICWA
and Cal-ICWA compliance is necessary.

CLAY, J. *

WE CONCUR:

BROWN, P. J.
STREETER, J.

*Judge of the Alameda Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice

pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.
15

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.