CourtListener 10617014•In re J.A. CA4/3
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 6/25/25 In re J.A. CA4/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re J.A. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL
SERVICES AGENCY,
G064724
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 21DP0781,
v. 21DP0781A, 21DP0782,
21DP0782A
V.A. et al.,
ORDER MODIFYING OPINION
Defendants and Appellants. AND DENYING PETITION FOR
REHEARING; NO CHANGE IN
JUDGMENT
It is ORDERED that the opinion filed on May 27, 2025, be
modified as follows:
On page 22, second paragraph, add as footnote 4, at the end of
the following sentence: “Unless circumstances have materially changed, the
court should order guardianship as the permanent plan.” The footnote shall
read:
“In a petition for rehearing, SSA argued that our opinion takes
for granted that guardianship is an available option for the twins. Our review
of the record indicates that it is. If, however, it turns out not to be, this would
qualify as a material change of circumstances. 4”
The opinion is otherwise unchanged.
The petition for rehearing is DENIED.
The modification does not change the judgment.
SANCHEZ, ACTING P. J.
WE CONCUR:
DELANEY, J.
SCOTT, J.
2
Filed 5/29/25 In re J.A. CA4/3 (first modification)
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re J.A. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL
SERVICES AGENCY,
G064724
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 21DP0781,
v. 21DP0781A, 21DP0782,
21DP0782A)
V.A. et al.,
ORDER MODIFYING OPINION;
Defendants and Appellants.
NO CHANGE IN JUDGMENT
It is ordered that the opinion filed May 27, 2025, be modified as
follows:
The caption is MODIFIED to reflect that the correct superior
court case numbers are 21DP0781, 21DP0781A, 21DP0782, 21DP0782A.
There is no change in the judgment.
SANCHEZ, ACTING P. J.
WE CONCUR:
DELANEY, J.
SCOTT, J.
2
Filed 5/27/25 In re J.A. CA4/3 (unmodified opinion)
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION THREE
In re J.A. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law.
ORANGE COUNTY SOCIAL
SERVICES AGENCY,
G064724
Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. Nos. 21DP0781A,
v. 21DP0782A)
V.A. et al., OPINION
Defendants and Appellants.
Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Orange County,
Julie Anne Swain, Judge. Reversed.
Michelle D. Peña, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant father V.A.
Jack A. Love, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant mother V.A.
Leon J. Page, County Counsel, and Debbie Torrez and Chloe R.
Maksoudian, Deputy County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
* * *
V.A. (Father) and V.A. (Mother) have appealed from an order
made pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code section 366.26 (section
366.26) that terminated their parental rights regarding their twin daughters,
J.A. and V.A. They contend the order was in error because two exceptions
applied: the parental-benefit exception, and the sibling exception. They also
contend the court erred in finding that the Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978
(ICWA; 25 U.S.C. § 1901 et seq.) does not apply.
The principal issue in this appeal is the parental-benefit
exception. The parents contend the exception applies because their visitation
was extensive, consistent, and positive, and the children were old enough to
voice their love for their parents and indicated their desire to not be
separated from them. They contend the evidence pointed in only one
direction—that the minors would be harmed by terminating parental
rights—and that the court erred in not choosing guardianship as the
permanent plan. We agree and will reverse the judgment.
FACTS
I.
DETENTION, JURISDICTION, AND DISPOSITION
In July 2021, deputies of the Orange County Sheriff’s
Department were dispatched to Mother’s residence to evict her. When they
arrived, they were greeted by her oldest child, D.V., who informed them that
Mother was not home. D.V. (age 11) was watching two younger siblings, A.V.
(age 8) and J.A. (age 1, who, along with her twin sister, V.A., are the subjects
of this appeal). Deputies observed the residence to be disheveled and
2
unsanitary, including dog feces and dirty diapers on the floor; expired food in
the fridge; and, throughout the residence, clutter, trash, and leftover food.
About two hours later, Mother returned with her other two
children, E.V. (age 9) and V.A. Mother explained that she had been moving
her possessions out, and she could not fit all five children in her vehicle.
Social workers interviewed Mother and the older children, all of whom
reported that their basic needs were being met, and in the home there was no
domestic violence, substance abuse, nor sexual abuse. The children reported
that the residence was not usually so filthy, but that it was so now because
they were in the process of moving out. They also reported that Mother does
not generally leave them home alone. The child V.A. had a scabbed-over burn
mark on her chest, which reportedly occurred when the child reached for a
portable stove that was being used for cooking while Mother was in the
bathroom.
The officers present did not arrest Mother but cited her for child
endangerment based on the filthy living conditions. The children were
detained and taken to Orangewood Children and Family Center where it was
observed that all five had lice. The children were subsequently placed with
family members.
At the time of the eviction, Father (who is husband to Mother,
but father to only J.A. and V.A.) had been in jail for about a month due to a
probation violation. Father had a criminal history that included forgery
(2012), receiving stolen property (2013), possession of a controlled substance
with intent to sell (2017, 2019), identity theft (2020), and various drug
offenses. He would ultimately be released approximately two weeks later.
The court ordered the children temporarily detained on July 20,
2021. The twins were placed with their paternal second cousin, Crystal C.,
3
where they would remain for the duration of these proceedings. Their three
older half siblings were placed with other relatives.
Mother was given 12 hours per week of supervised visitation.
From the outset, the twins’ caregiver reported that they would “have a
meltdown” for about five minutes when Mother left a visitation.
Among the various services Mother was initially referred to was
random drug testing. Mother tested positive for methamphetamine on
August 11, 13, and 14. Father was also referred to random drug testing, but
he no-showed on August 12, 17, and 24.
On August 27, 2021, Father was arrested for acts of domestic
violence against Mother and was sent back to jail. According to a police
report, Mother had visible marks on her when interviewed by police. Mother
and Father both denied any physical altercation had occurred. Father was
found with a drug pipe in his possession, and he admitted to relapsing on
methamphetamine.
The jurisdiction hearing was held on October 6, 2021, at which
the court found the allegations of an interlineated petition to be true. The
petition generally alleged that Mother had failed to provide a safe and
sanitary home environment, and Father has an unresolved substance abuse
problem. The court removed custody from the parents and approved a case
plan of family reunification services.
II.
FIRST REUNIFICATION PERIOD
Mother’s case plan called for her to participate in parenting
education, general counseling, substance abuse testing, and a substance
abuse outpatient program.
Mother completed a parenting class in September 2021.
4
Mother participated in individual counseling, which, according to
the counselor and Mother, was going well. The counselor reported observing
positive growth and progress.
As for substance abuse testing, Mother was a no-show for several
tests in November and December of 2021. Mother had a drug patch applied in
January of 2022, and it came back positive for methamphetamine and
cocaine. She also tested positive for cocaine in late January and early
February 2022. However, from March through June, Mother was present for
all tests, and all were negative.
Mother began an outpatient substance abuse program in January
2022. She provided proof of completion of her program in June 2022.
Mother’s case plan compliance for the first period was deemed
moderate.
Father was incarcerated for much of the first reunification
period. His case plan called for parenting education, general counseling,
substance abuse testing, and substance abuse treatment. Father participated
in counseling but otherwise did not engage further services due to his
incarceration.
Father’s case plan compliance was deemed to be none.
With regard to Mother’s visitation, the social worker provided the
following summary: “During the past period of supervision, the mother has
maintained a relationship with the children through supervised [visits];
however, it has also been common for the mother to cancel and/or refuse
visits. When the mother attends visits with the children, the mother is
attentive to the children’s needs, and they engage among each other in play,
sharing meals, and positive interaction. The visits have been reported to be
appropriate while the children engage in board games and tablet activities
5
with the mother. The family has been observed to share laughs while
snacking on the snacks provided by the mother. During the visits the
children and the mother watch movies, conversate and read books to each
other. The [half-brothers] have reported that they enjoy spending time with
their twin sisters during their visits.” One concern raised was that Mother
was consistently feeding the young twins unhealthy snacks, leading to
diarrhea and vomiting.
Orange County Social Services Agency’s (SSA) initial six-month
status review report contained an unusual discrepancy: on the first page the
“Summary Recommendation” stated “Terminate reunification
services . . . schedule . . . Selection and Implementation hearing.” However, in
the “Assessment/Evaluation” section, it stated, “Based on the aforementioned
information, the Social Services Agency respectfully requests additional
Family Reunification services for the parents. Further, it is respectfully
recommended that the Court continue dependency and that a Twelve-Month
Review Hearing be scheduled.” But then in the “Recommendation” section, it
stated, “It is further recommended . . . that reunification services to the
parents be terminated, and the matter be scheduled for a Permanency
hearing pursuant to Section 366.26 . . . .” A little over a month later, still
prior to the review hearing, SSA “changed” its recommendation in an
addendum report to “[c]ontinue reunification services . . . schedule Twelve-
Month Permanency Review hearing.”
The six-month review hearing was continued multiple times and
eventually became a combined six- and 12-month review hearing, scheduled
for August 2022.
6
III.
SECOND REUNIFICATION PERIOD
In its 12-month status review report, SSA determined that
reunification was likely and recommended continuing services and
scheduling an 18-month review hearing.
Following Father’s release from jail in May 2022, through August
2022, there were no further criminal charges, both parents were receiving
regular income, and they had stable housing that was assessed to be safe.
In August 2022, Mother attended a doctor visit for the twins to
address issues of vomiting and diarrhea.
Two days later, Mother gave birth to her sixth child.
For the 12-month review hearing, SSA deemed both Mother’s and
Father’s compliance with their case plans to be moderate.
Mother continued to test sober through August 2022.
Father completed a parenting education course in June 2022.
Father was participating in individual counseling. He completed an anger
management course and substance abuse treatment while incarcerated.
Between June and August 2022, Father consistently tested negative on
random drug tests.
Mother continued visiting consistently, the visits were positive,
and no new concerns were noted. After Mother fed V.A. a meal at one visit
(which had been approved in advance), V.A. returned to the caretaker and
once again began vomiting. This resulted in another doctor visit, which
Mother attended. Although the twins’ caregiver suggested that Mother was
7
feeding them unhealthy food, the foods and portions were screened by Olive
Crest Visitation supervisors who verified that they were appropriate.1
After his release from jail, Father consistently attended his
allotted four hours of weekly visitation concurrent with one of Mother’s visits.
The visits were appropriate, with the only comment being that the Olive
Crest Visitation supervisors would like to see Father take the lead more often
on parenting activities, which were mostly being performed by Mother.
At the 12-month review hearing, the court found that both
Mother and Father had made substantial progress toward mitigating the
causes necessitating placement. The court ordered an 18-month review
hearing and approved a case plan that continued reunification services. The
court also permitted unsupervised visits to commence.
III.
THE THIRD REUNIFICATION PERIOD
Almost immediately, a portion of the parents’ visitation was
liberalized to unsupervised. On October 21, 2022, this progressed to a 60-day
in-home trial visit where the twins moved back in with their parents. In a
status review report filed in advance of the January 10, 2023, hearing, the
social worker observed, “Throughout the 60-day trial visit, the parents have
met the children, [J.A. and V.A.’s] basic needs and maintained medical and
dental appointments up to date, additionally following up with medical
referrals as needed. During the monthly compliance contacts, the children
have presented to be well and free from marks/bruises indicative of abuse.
1 Later, the social worker would observe, “It is also noted that
throughout this dependency case, the caregiver of the children [J.A. and V.A.]
has continuously reported concerns of which have not been substantiated.”
8
The children have been observed comfortable and happy in the home and
there has been no suspicion of abuse and/or neglect to the children.” The
older children reported that, during unsupervised visits, the parents
sometimes yelled and cussed at each other, but this concern did not warrant
ending the 60-day visit.
SSA deemed the case plan progress of both Mother and Father to
be substantial. Mother had 90 days of consistent negative drug tests on the
patch, which enabled her to transition to random drug testing instead of a
patch. Father continued with individual counseling, and his counselor
reported the sessions had been successful, with Father improving his skills in
communication, problem solving, coping, and overall parenting. Father’s drug
tests were mostly negative, though on November 9 and 11, 2022, he tested
positive for opiates. The lab reported there was some possibility this was a
false positive due to cold medication Father had taken, though unlikely. He
tested negative thereafter through the reporting period.
At the conclusion of its report filed for the January 10, 2023,
hearing, SSA requested a 60-day continuance. This was to address lingering
concerns about the parents cussing and yelling in front of the children, and to
ensure Father remained sober. The court granted the continuance.
During the following 60 days, SSA continued to conduct
unannounced compliance visits at the parents’ home. No safety concerns were
identified. The twins (and now also D.V., who began his own 60-day trial
visit) were observed to be “clean, well-groomed and free from marks/bruises
indicative of abuse. The children have presented happy and comfortable in
the home.”
9
During this period, mother attended all her random drug tests,
all of which were negative. It was the same for Father: 100 percent
compliance, all negative.
During this period, E.V. began unsupervised visitation with
Mother and Father (his stepfather), which went well. A.V. continued to refuse
visitation, explaining, with tears in his eyes, that he feared not being able to
see his caregivers anymore.
As of SSA’s addendum report for the March 9, 2023, hearing, SSA
recommended returning custody of the twins to their parents (and also
custody of their brothers to their mother). The court agreed, finding foster
care was no longer necessary or appropriate. The court ordered the twins
returned to their parents as the permanent plan. However, it found that
continued supervision was necessary and ordered a six-month review
hearing.
About three months later, it all unraveled.
IV.
THE CHILDREN ARE REMOVED AGAIN; PARENTAL RIGHTS ARE TERMINATED
On May 23, 2023, Father tested positive for methamphetamine.
Between then and early July, he refused multiple “on-demand” tests,
contending he was working as a tow truck driver out of the county and
unable to test. Starting May 30, 2023, Mother became inconsistent with her
drug tests, citing various medical reasons (including Covid-19, which she
provided a positive test for, and a viral infection resulting in a fever of 103
degrees, which was verified with a doctor’s note). The biggest concern was a
test deemed refused on July 5, 2023. The test administrator observed what
appeared to be Mother attempting to manipulate the test with a balloon full
of liquid.
10
Despite these issues occurring behind the scenes, the children
reported that everything was going fine in the home. They did not have any
concerns.
On July 7, 2023, the court signed an emergency protective
custody warrant. Social workers arrived at the residence together with police
officers. The social workers explained the reason for the removal to mother:
“inconsistency in her drug tests, the incident at the testing site on July 5,
2023, the father’s positive drug test result on May 23, 2023, as well as the
neglect of the children’s medical and dental care.” (The medical care referred
to overdue well-child checkups, and E.V. had an unspecified tooth issue that
required dental treatment, though E.V. said he “likes how it looks” and was
apparently in no pain.)
Mother stepped out of the house, told the children to call their
dad, saying, “they are going to take you away,” and shut the door behind her.
She initially refused to let the social workers and officers in, sitting in the
doorway to block their path. One of the children opened the door to hand
Mother her phone, at which point the twins both clung to Mother’s back and
neck. E.V. and A.V. were crying while standing near mother; D.V. was nearby
punching the wall. Eventually, Mother relented and helped the children pack
their belongings. The children were returned to their previous caregivers.
SSA filed a supplemental dependency petition. The petition
alleged that Mother and Father had ongoing substance abuse problems.
At the new detention hearing, the court ordered SSA to provide
reunification services and authorized visitation of 12 hours per week for
Mother and eight hours per week for Father. At the same hearing, E.V.
disclosed that, in connection with her manipulated drug test, Mother had
asked him to provide urine for her.
11
In anticipation of the August 14, 2023, jurisdiction/disposition
hearing, SSA filed a report on August 7, 2023, in which it recommended that
Mother be given reunification services, but not Father.
Mother tested positive for amphetamine and methamphetamine
on July 21, 2023. She was a no-show at two subsequent tests. Father tested
positive on July 27. Additionally, the brothers reported that incidents of
domestic violence had been occurring in the home, including Father pushing
Mother to the floor, the two hitting each other, and arguing. They reported
that mother sometimes yelled at the children, threw things at them, and even
broke a bedroom door running after E.V. There were times when Mother
refused to feed the children because she was mad at Father. Further, they
reported Mother and Father would sometimes spend hours together in the
garage, leaving D.V. to care for and feed the other children. Since being
returned to the parents’ care, the children had as many as 18 unexcused
absences from school.
After the removal, Mother and Father consistently visited the
children.
SSA filed an addendum report prior to the August 21, 2023,
hearing in which it changed its recommendation to no reunification services
for either parent.
It was subsequently reported that Mother had no-showed or
failed to produce a specimen for four of her five required tests in August and
September 2023. It was later reported she continued to fail testing in late
September and October. Father tested positive for methamphetamine on
August 8, 2023.
On October 17, 2023, Father was arrested on felony charges of
second degree vehicle burglary. It was alleged that he broke into a locked
12
vehicle with the intent to commit larceny. He was also charged with felony
counts of being a felon in possession of ammunition and possession of
fentanyl and methamphetamine for sale, and a misdemeanor count of
vandalism.
For all that, Mother continued to consistently attend her visits
with the children, and the visits were going well.
At the jurisdictional hearing, the court found the petition to be
true, and it found that reunification services need not be provided. The court
scheduled a permanency hearing pursuant to section 366.26 (.26 hearing).
The court also accepted the negotiated settlement reached by Mother, Father,
and SSA. SSA agreed to provide funding for services through the date of the
.26 hearing. Mother and Father agreed to continue drug testing, with the
condition that any positive or missed test would nullify SSA’s obligations
under the agreement.
In the runup to the .26 hearing, Mother continued visiting her
children consistently, missing hardly any visits, and the visits were reported
to be enjoyable and free of any significant concerns. In January 2024, the
social worker observed a visit between Mother and her children. “The
children all appeared happy to visit with the mother as they all smiled and
laughed throughout the visit. The younger children were observed to hug the
mother. [V.A.] spent time sitting on mother’s lap and close by her side.”
During that same period, mother continued drug testing,
resulting in 12 negative tests, two refused tests (unable to provide a urine
sample), and seven missed tests. Father had two negative tests, 15 missed
tests, and one test positive for cannabinoids.
Leading up to the .26 hearing, SSA also took steps to remove the
twins from their caregiver, Crystal, to potentially be placed with a maternal
13
aunt in New Hampshire. In October 2023, the social worker reported on a
concern about the number of children in Crystal’s home: “The undersigned
would like to formally notify the Court that there is concern as to placement
for the [twins and their infant brother]. It has come to the attention of the
Agency that the caregiver for the [twins and their infant brother] has a total
of ten children in her care; four biological children, three other children who
are Dependents, and the [twins and their infant brother]. The Agency is
currently working and addressing the concern as to the number of children in
her care.” In a February 2024 report, a social worker noted: “Presently, the
[twins] share a bedroom with the other four dependent children, (3 males and
1 female) who range in age between a 1 year old and 12-year-old.” A month
later, Crystal added an additional bedroom to her home so that the twins and
their infant brother had their own room.
After multiple continuances, the .26 hearing finally took place
beginning August 12, 2024.
The parties stipulated that if called to testify, J.A. would testify
as follows: “She said she misses her parents and wants to go home with them.
She likes to see them.” “It makes her feel bad when she has to leave them
[after visits] because she misses them.” “She said it’s good with Crystal, but
she misses her parents and wants to live with them.” She wished she could
live with her parents and wished she had more visitation with them. When
asked whether she loves her parents, J.A. replied, “[T]o love something is
with all your heart” and said she “feels that way about mommy and daddy.”
She said she does not want to be adopted. If she never saw her parents again,
she would be “sad and would miss them so much.” V.A. offered similar
stipulated testimony.
14
Consistent with their testimony, both Mother and D.V. testified
that the twins would become emotional at the end of visits, not wanting to
leave.
The social worker, upon questioning from the court, testified that
the twins would benefit by continuing their contact with their parents. The
social worker also testified that it would have been beneficial to have a
consortium referral, but acknowledged that it never happened.2 The referral
would have been beneficial so that visitation between the twins and their
parents could have been set. Unofficially, the social worker had discussed the
matter with Crystal, who expressed willingness to facilitate postadoption
visitation with Mother and Father. However, the social worker also
acknowledged, as is evident from the record, that Mother and Crystal do not
get along.
In the end, however, the court found the twins to be adoptable,
terminated parental rights, and ordered adoption as the permanent plan.
With regard to the parental-benefit and sibling relationship exception, the
court simply stated: “Parents have not met their burden as to either of those
exceptions, so the Court finds those exceptions do not apply.” The court did
not explain its reasoning or make any specific factual findings in support of
its ruling.
Both parents appealed.
2 A consortium referral is a referral to Consortium for Children,
which helps create and implement postpermanency plans for continued
contact between minors and biological family members. (See Cal. Dept. of
Social Services, All County Information Notice No. I-45-04 (June 30, 2004)
p. 8 <https://www.cdss.ca.gov/lettersnotices/entres/getinfo/acin04/pdf/
I-45_04.pdf> [as of May 27, 2025], archived at <https://perma.cc/
9ULV-DSGQ>.)
15
DISCUSSION
The principal issue raised by the parents is that the evidence
compelled a finding that the parental-benefit exception to adoption applied.
Although such an argument is an uphill battle given the deferential standard
of review we must apply, we are convinced they are correct.
Section 366.26 governs the procedures applicable once the efforts
to reunify the parent and child have failed. The goal at the .26 hearing is “‘to
select and implement a permanent plan for the child.’” (In re Caden C. (2021)
11 Cal.5th 614, 630 (Caden C.).) Section 366.26, subdivision (b) sets forth the
available options for a permanent plan “in . . . order of preference.” The first,
and thus most highly preferred option, is to terminate parental rights and
order that the child be placed for adoption. (§ 366.26, subd. (b)(1).) “‘Adoption
is the Legislature’s first choice because it gives the child the best chance at [a
full] emotional commitment from a responsible caretaker.’” (In re Celine R.
(2003) 31 Cal.4th 45, 53.) The other options, in order of preference, are to
appoint a legal guardian for the child, to place the child with a fit and willing
relative, or to place the child in long-term foster care. (§ 366.26, subd.
(b)(5)–(7); In re Fernando M. (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 529, 534.)
In selecting a permanent plan, “the court must first determine by
clear and convincing evidence whether the child is likely to be adopted. (See
§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1).) If so, and if the court finds that there has been a
previous determination that reunification services be terminated, then the
court shall terminate parental rights to allow for adoption. [Citation.] But if
the parent shows that termination would be detrimental to the child for at
least one specifically enumerated reason, the court should decline to
terminate parental rights and select another permanent plan. (See § 366.26,
subd. (c)(1)(B)(i)–(vi), (4)(A).) As we have previously explained, ‘[t]he
16
statutory exceptions merely permit the court, in exceptional circumstances
[citation], to choose an option other than the norm, which remains adoption.’”
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at pp. 630–631.)
The relevant exception to adoption here is the parental-benefit
exception. To find that this exception applies, the court must find “a
compelling reason for determining that termination would be detrimental to
the child due to . . . the following circumstance[ ]: [¶] (i) The parents have
maintained regular visitation and contact with the child and the child would
benefit from continuing the relationship.” (§ 366.26, subd. (c)(1)(B)(i).) “From
the statute, we readily discern three elements the parent must prove to
establish the exception: (1) regular visitation and contact, and (2) a
relationship, the continuation of which would benefit the child such that
(3) the termination of parental rights would be detrimental to the child.”
(Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 631.) In deciding whether termination of
parental rights would be detrimental, “the trial court must decide whether
the harm from severing the child’s relationship with the parent outweighs
the benefit to the child of placement in a new adoptive home. [Citation.] By
making this decision, the trial court determines whether terminating
parental rights serves the child’s best interests.” (Id. at p. 632.) “Because
terminating parental rights eliminates any legal basis for the parent or child
to maintain the relationship, courts must assume that terminating parental
rights terminates the relationship. [Citations.] What courts need to
determine, therefore, is how the child would be affected by losing the
parental relationship—in effect, what life would be like for the child in an
adoptive home without the parent in the child’s life.” (Id. at p. 633.) “When
the relationship with a parent is so important to the child that the security
and stability of a new home wouldn’t outweigh its loss, termination would be
17
‘detrimental to the child due to’ the child’s beneficial relationship with a
parent.” (Id. at pp. 633–634.)
“A hybrid standard governs our review. [Citation.] The first two
elements involve factual determinations to which the substantial evidence
standard of review applies. [Citation.] The final step, determining whether
termination of parental rights would be detrimental to the child, is reviewed
for abuse of discretion.” (In re G.H. (2022) 84 Cal.App.5th 15, 26.)
Here, there is no dispute about the first element. Mother
consistently visited her children; indeed, she was extremely consistent. And
having 12 to 15 hours per week of visitation, plus holidays and birthdays,
meant this was a significant commitment of time every week, which she
fulfilled almost without fail. Father was also highly consistent when he was
out of custody.
With regard to the second element, although SSA argues on
appeal that continuing the parental relationship would not benefit the child,
the evidence at trial was largely undisputed. While the assigned social
worker was on the stand, the court asked her point blank: “Is it your opinion
that [V.A.] and [J.A.] would benefit by continuing visitation or contact with
the parents?” Answer: “Yes.”
What this case really comes down to is the third element of the
Caden C. test: whether the balance of harms favors adoption. As Caden C.
counsels, we will assume that, if adopted, J.A. and V.A. would be completely
cut off from their biological parents. The court was called upon to decide
whether this severing would “outweigh[ ] the benefit to the child of placement
in a new adoptive home.” (Caden C., supra, 11 Cal.5th at p. 632.)
Because each case is fact specific, the Caden C. framework does
not specify precisely what alternatives the court must weigh. It tells us to
18
assess whether the benefit of a permanent adoptive home outweighs the
harm of severing the parent-child relationship—but compared to what
permanency plan for the children? Here, the parties presented only two
options: adoption or guardianship. Accordingly, the question before the court
was to what extent adoption offers a meaningful advantage over
guardianship, and whether that advantage justifies the complete termination
of J.A. and V.A.’s legal and personal connection to their parents.
We begin with the comparative advantage of adoption over
guardianship. Fortunately, this is a topic that has been rigorously studied in
the social sciences. In one study commissioned by the State of Illinois, only
3.5 percent of children subject to a guardianship exited the guardianship
prematurely. (Testa et al., Illinois Subsidized Guardianship Waiver
Demonstration, Final Evaluation Report (2003) p. 3 <https://cfrc.illinois.edu/
pubs/rp_20030701_IllinoisSubsidizedGuardianshipWaiverDemonstrationFin
alEvaluationReport.pdf> [as of May 23, 2025], archived at
<https://perma.cc/GMR8-BQW4>.) In another study that specifically
compared guardianship to adoption, incidences of discontinuity were 11
percent in guardianships versus 6 percent in adoptions. (Rolock & White,
Continuity for Children After Guardianship Versus Adoption with Kin:
Approximating the Right Counterfactual (2017) 72 Child Abuse & Neglect
32.) In another study analyzing data collected by four different states, one
researcher summarized the results of choosing guardianship over adoption
as: “there is no evidence of any adverse impact on the long-term stability of
the living arrangement.” (Testa, Subsidized Guardianship: Testing the
Effectiveness of an Idea Whose Time Has Finally Come (2008) p. 25
<https://spaulding.org/wp-content/uploads/archive-pdf/Subsidized-
Guardianship-Testing-Effectiveness-Testa-2008.pdf> [as of May 27, 2025],
19
archived at <https://perma.cc/9ZNZ-V4GK>.) Similarly, a synthesis of several
state studies prepared for the Federal government found that children in a
guardianship relationship “experienced comparable rates of placement
stability as children in other placement arrangements.” (Admin. for Children
and Families, Admin. on Children, Youth and Families, Children’s Bureau,
U.S. Dep’t Health & Human Services, Synthesis of Findings: Subsidized
Guardianship Child Welfare Waiver Demonstrations (2011) p. 18
<https://acf.gov/sites/default/files/documents/cb/subsidized.pdf> [as of May 27,
2025], archived at <https://perma.cc/RH4B-Z3CX>.) However, as pointed out
by retired Judge Leonard Edwards, a noted subject matter expert, there are
advantages to adoption beyond permanency, such as that the legal
relationship persists beyond age 18 and enables the adoptee to inherit from
the adoptive parents. (Judge Leonard Edwards (ret.), Comments on
“Confronting Indeterminacy and Bias in Child Protection Law” by Josh
Gupta-Kagan, 33 Stan. L. & Pol’y Rev. Online (2022) p. 5.) What emerges
from the literature is that there is some advantage to adoption over kinship
guardianship, but the advantage is modest.3
In citing this data, we emphasize that we are not seeking to
displace the Legislature’s stated preference for adoption, which we have
neither the authority nor the desire to do. However, because the Legislature
has codified exceptions to the adoption preference, courts must engage in a
comparative analysis—and in doing so, we believe it is appropriate to
consider relevant and broadly accepted research findings.
3 Most of the studies on guardianship involved kinship
guardianship (i.e. guardianship by a relative). Since the two potential
guardians in this case are both kin of the minors, these studies are relevant
and applicable. There is less data available on non-kinship guardianship.
20
Next, we must assess the harm that would ensue to J.A. and V.A.
if their relationship with their parents were completely severed. On this
issue, the evidence pointed consistently toward harm. The twins, who were
five years old at the time of the hearing, both testified that they love their
parents dearly and did not want to lose them. Both twins referred to their
biological parents as “Mom” and “Dad,” not their caretakers. The reports from
observers of visitation consistently noted the loving interaction between the
parents and children. The twins spent significant amounts of time with the
parents (especially Mother). Mother visited between 12 and 15 hours per
week (which, when one considers work and school schedules, is a significant
fraction of one’s free time). And the twins lived with the parents for five
months when they transitioned to Family Maintenance. The evidence showed
that the twins were consistently sad when having to leave visitation. When
they were taken from Mother’s care, there was the tragic scene of the twins
clinging to Mother’s neck and back. SSA ultimately found it would be
detrimental to sever the parental relationship with the twins’ half siblings
E.V. and D.V. And the social worker testified that the twins would benefit by
continuing their relationship with their parents.
When we conclude that the parental-benefit exception does not
apply, we often characterize the evidence as showing the biological parents
filled the role of “‘friendly visitor’” or friendly aunt, or that they enjoyed
merely “‘pleasant visits.’” (In re Katherine J. (2022) 75 Cal.App.5th 303, 319;
In re J.C. (2014) 226 Cal.App.4th 503, 529; In re Angel B. (2002) 97
Cal.App.4th 454, 468; In re Autumn H. (1994) 27 Cal.App.4th 567, 576.)
There is no way to characterize the evidence that way in this case. Mother
and Father are the twins’ parents, both biologically and relationally. There is
a loving, committed relationship between the twins and their parents.
21
Completely severing that relationship would undoubtedly harm the twins.
(See In re S.B. (2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 289, 300–301 [“The record shows S.B.
loved her father, wanted their relationship to continue and derived some
measure of benefit from his visits. Based on this record, the only reasonable
inference is that S.B. would be greatly harmed by the loss of her significant,
positive relationship with [her father].”].)
In light of the modest benefits to be gained through adoption over
guardianship in this case, and also the evidence of harm that would ensue
from terminating the parental relationship, it was an abuse of discretion to
weigh those factors in favor of adoption. Accordingly, we will reverse the
judgment selecting adoption as the permanent plan. On remand, the court
should conduct a new .26 hearing. Unless circumstances have materially
changed, the court should order guardianship as the permanent plan.
Because we conclude the parental-benefit to adoption applies, we
need not address the parents’ argument concerning whether the sibling
relationship exception required guardianship. Nor need we address ICWA
issues, which can be addressed below on remand.
22
DISPOSITION
The judgment is reversed.
SANCHEZ, ACTING P. J.
WE CONCUR:
DELANEY, J.
SCOTT, J.
23
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.