Nussbaum v. Sutter Health CA1/2

CourtListener 10614444Calctapp20.06.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 6/20/25 Nussbaum v. Sutter Health CA1/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

THOMAS NUSSBAUM,
Plaintiff and Appellant,
A171050
v.
SUTTER HEALTH ET AL., (San Mateo County
Super. Ct. No. 22CIV05407)
Defendant and Respondent.

In late 2022, Nussbaum filed a lawsuit against a care facility alleging it
was responsible for the death of his mother, who had died almost three years
earlier. His amended complaint alleged five causes of action, to which
defendant filed a demurrer. The trial court sustained it without leave as to
four of the causes of action on statute of limitations grounds, granting leave
to amend as to the fifth. Nussbaum did not amend, and the trial court
dismissed the action. Nussbaum appeals. We affirm.
BACKGROUND1
On December 27, 2022, representing himself, Thomas Nussbaum filed a
complaint against Sutter Health and Sutter Bay Hospitals doing business as

1 The clerk’s transcript here is a total of 44 pages, 15 of which are
register of actions. The transcript contains a total of 10 items, most of which

1
Mills Peninsula (incorrectly sued as Sutter Health’s Mills Peninsula Center)
(collectively, Sutter). The complaint was based on the death of Nussbaum’s
mother, who died on January 2, 2020, and apparently alleged causes of action
for: (1) elder abuse; (2) willful neglect; and (3) wrongful death.
On February 28, 2023, Sutter filed a demurrer and motion to strike
based on the applicable statutes of limitations.
Nussbaum filed opposition, Sutter a reply and the motions came on for
hearing on September 11 before the Honorable Nicole Healy, who had issued
a tentative ruling. Nussbaum appeared, representing himself, Sutter
through counsel. Nussbaum attempted to argue about some claimed fraud,
which Judge Healy pointed out had not been alleged. On September 11,
Judge Healy issued an order sustaining the demurrer with leave to amend.2
On October 9, Nussbaum filed a first amended complaint that
apparently alleged five causes of action, for: (1) elder abuse; (2) willful
neglect; (3) wrongful death; (4) fraud; and (5) false imprisonment of elderly.
On October 12, Sutter filed a demurrer and motion to strike.
Nussbaum filed opposition and Sutter a reply, and on February 5, 2024, the
matters were continued to May 20.
On May 7, Nussbaum filed his second opposition, to which Sutter filed
objection.
The motions came on as rescheduled, before the Honorable Raymond
Swope, who had issued a tentative ruling. Both sides contested and
appeared, Nussbaum representing himself and Sutter through counsel.
Judge Swope heard argument, at the conclusion of which he adopted his

are minute orders, and not one of which is any pleading or motion filed below.
This background is derived largely from the register of actions.
2 The motion to strike was denied as moot.

2
tentative ruling, which was as follows: “Demurrer to Plaintiff’s First
Amended Complaint (‘FAC’) is SUSTAINED WITHOUT LEAVE TO AMEND
with respect to the First, Second, Third, and Fifth Causes of Action pursuant
to Cal. Code of Civil Procedure Sections 430.10(e), 335.1, 340.5, 340(c). The
Demurrer to the Fourth Cause of Action for Fraud is SUSTAINED WITH
LEAVE TO AMEND to allege a cause of action for fraud, because leave had
not been previously granted to add an additional cause of action.” (Italics
omitted.)3
Judge Swope’s order went on at length to support the basis of his
rulings, where among other things he noted as follows:
“Plaintiff has reasserted the same claims in his First Amended
Complaint, which alleges causes of action for (1) Elder Abuse, (2) Willful
Neglect, (3) Wrongful Death, (4) Fraud, and (5) False Imprisonment of
Elderly. Plaintiff contends that the Court’s prior order does not address the
applicable dates alleged in the original Complaint, and that the FAC is
timely because it was filed within three years from when the decedent was
moved to Mills Comfort Care on December 27, 2019. Opp., 2:9-10; FAC, 7:4-
18. However, Plaintiff’s argument does not analyze his allegations under the
applicable two- year statute of limitations. From the latest possible
applicable date in Plaintiff’s FAC, the date of the decedent’s death on
January 2, 2020, the two-year statute of limitations as to the First Cause of
Action for Elder Abuse and Second Cause of Action for Willful Neglect ran on
January 2, 2022. No facts relating to delayed discovery or other applicable
tolling have been pleaded. These claims are therefore time-barred on the face
of the pleading, and the demurrer is SUSTAINED WITHOUT LEAVE TO

3 Again, the motion to strike was denied as moot.

3
AMEND as to the First and Second Causes of Action in the FAC on this
basis.
“As to the Third Cause of Action for Wrongful Death, a shorter one-year
statute of limitations is applicable pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure
Section 340.5. No new facts have been pleaded that address this issue. It is
therefore time-barred, and the Demurrer is SUSTAINED WITHOUT LEAVE
TO AMEND as to the Third Cause of Action for Wrongful Death on that
basis.
“The Fifth Cause of Action for Wrongful Imprisonment is subject to a
one-year statute of limitations as well, pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure
Section 340(c), and is time-barred on the face of the FAC. The Demurrer is
therefore SUSTAINED WITHOUT LEAVE TO AMEND as to the Fifth Cause
of Action on that basis. [¶] . . . [¶]
“Cause of Action for Fraud
“When a demurrer is sustained with leave to amend, a plaintiff may
amend the complaint only as authorized by the order and may not add a
cause of action without having obtained permission to do so unless the cause
of action is within the scope of the order granting leave to amend. (Zakk v.
Diesel (2019) 33 Cal.App.5th 431, 456, citing Harris v. Wachovia Mortgage,
FSB (2010) 185 Cal.App.4th 1018, 1023.) Defendants contend that Plaintiff’s
cause of action for Fraud is not within the scope of the Court’s order granting
leave to amend the original Complaint upon the granting of Defendants’
demurrer to that pleading. Leave to amend was granted in that order
pursuant to the liberal policy favoring amendment. The discussion of fraud
in the order was with respect to a lack of factual allegations showing that a
departure from the applicable statutes of limitations was appropriate. Leave
to add an additional cause of action was not granted at that time. The cause

4
of action for fraud is also uncertain, as it is alleged in conjunction with the
other causes of action, and fails to allege each element of fraud with
specificity. Thus, the Fourth Cause of Action is SUSTAINED WITH LEAVE
TO AMEND to allege a cause of action for fraud.”
The order gave Nussbaum 10 days to file an amended pleading. On
May 31, the trial court served Nussbaum with a copy of Judge Swope’s order,
the effect of which was that Nussbaum had until June 10 to file an amended
complaint. No such complaint was forthcoming.
On July 2, Sutter filed an ex parte application pursuant to Code of Civil
Procedure section 581, subdivision (f)(2)4 seeking to have the action
dismissed. It appears that Nussbaum filed opposition, and according to
Sutter’s representation, an ex parte hearing was held on July 3, at which
Nussbaum personally appeared. That same day Judge Swope filed his order
dismissing the case and, on July 3, entered judgment for Sutter.
On July 26, Nussbaum filed his appeal.
DISCUSSION
Introduction
Still representing himself, Nussbaum has filed a 13-page opening brief,
some five pages of which is “Argument.” Specifically, the brief contains three
arguments, described by Nussbaum as follows: “6.1 The Trial Court Erred in
Sustaining the Demurrer Without Leave to Amend Elder Abuse and
Wrongful Death Causes of Action”; “6.2 The Trial Court’s Rulings Violated

4 Which section provides as follows: “The court may dismiss the
complaint as to [the] defendant when: [¶] . . . [¶] (2) Except where Section
597[, which authorizes a separate trial on special defenses not on the merits,]
applies, after a demurrer to the complaint is sustained with leave to amend,
the plaintiff fails to amend it within the time allowed by the court and either
party moves for dismissal.” (Code Civ. Proc. §581, subd. (f).)

5
Appellant’s Due Process Rights”; and “6.3 Accrual of Claims Should Be Tolled
Under the Delayed Discovery Rule and Public Policy Related to Homicide
Cases.”5 (Boldface omitted.)
We begin our discussion by noting that Nussbaum’s brief violates many
principles of appellate review, a criticism we make against the background
that he has chosen to represent himself, as is his right. Doing so, however, he
is held to the same standard as an attorney. (Rappleyea v. Campbell (1994) 8
Cal.4th 975, 984–985.) Self-representation is not a ground for lenient
treatment and, as is the case with attorneys, a person who represents herself
“must follow correct rules of procedure.” (Nwosu v. Uba (2004) 122
Cal.App.4th 1229, 1247.) Nussbaum’s brief here falls far short.
To begin with, a judgment or order of the trial court is presumed to be
correct, and the appellant has the burden of overcoming this presumption.
(Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 608–609.) Inherent in this burden is
the obligation to present an appellate record sufficient to enable
determination of the issues. (Maria P. v. Riles (1987) 43 Cal.3d 1281, 1295.)
Here, Nussbaum seeks reversal of the order sustaining Sutter’s demurrer to
the first amended complaint and the subsequent order dismissing this action.
However, as mentioned above, Nussbaum has failed to include in the record
the operative complaint, the documents in support of or opposing the

5 Nussbaum’s brief has a section entitled, “Issues Presented” that lists
four issues: “Whether the trial court erred in sustaining the demurrer
without leave to amend on elder abuse and wrongful death causes of action”;
“Whether the trial court violated Appellant’s procedural due process rights by
limiting oral arguments and refusing to consider critical filings”; “Whether
the court’s striking of Appellant’s responses violated Code of Civ..[sic] Proc.
§ 435(b)(2) and Cal. R. Ct. 3.1113”]; and “Whether the discovery rule and
public policy toll the statute of limitations due to allegations of homicide and
delayed discovery of fraud.”

6
demurrer and motion to strike, and the documents filed in connection with
Sutter’s ex parte application to dismiss the action. Nussbaum’s failure to
provide an adequate record on the challenged proceedings by itself requires
that his claims on appeal be resolved against him. (Hernandez v. California
Hospital Medical Center (2000) 78 Cal.App.4th 498, 502, citing Maria P. v.
Riles, supra, 43 Cal.3d at pp. 1295–1296; see, e.g., Bains v. Moores (2009) 172
Cal.App.4th 445, 478 [“[P]laintiffs have failed to include in the record either
the operative complaint or the demurrers, thus making it impossible for this
court to review the complaint de novo to determine whether it states a cause
of action. On that basis alone, we must reject plaintiffs’ claim”].)
Additionally, California Rules of Court, rule 8.204(a)(2)(C) provides
that an appellant’s opening brief shall “[p]rovide a summary of the significant
facts . . . .” And the leading California appellate practice guide instructs
about this: “Before addressing the legal issues, your brief should accurately
and fairly state the critical facts (including the evidence), free of bias; and
likewise as to the applicable law. [Citation.] [¶] Misstatements,
misrepresentations, and/or material omissions of the relevant facts or law
can instantly ‘undo’ and otherwise effective brief, waiving issues and
arguments; it will certainly cast doubt on your credibility, may draw
sanctions [citation], and may well cause you to lose the case.” (Eisenberg et
al., Cal. Practice Guide: Civil Appeals and Writs (The Rutter Group 2023) ¶
9:27, italics omitted.) Such summary is missing here.
Nussbaum’s brief violates other principles of appellate advocacy and
Rules of Court. For example, rule 8.204(a)(1)(C) requires that any reference
to a matter in the record, whether factual or procedural, be supported by a
citation to the volume and page number of the record where the matter
appears. (Professional Collection Consultants v. Lauron (2017) 8 Cal.App.5th

7
958, 970; Myers v. Trendwest Resorts, Inc. (2009) 178 Cal.App.4th 735, 745.)
Nussbaum does not do that here.
On top of all that, as best we can tell Nussbaum’s briefing does nothing
more than rehash—and very briefly, and in conclusory terms—his position
below, which disregards the admonition from Division One of this court that
he is not to merely reargue or “merely reassert [his] position” below.
(Conderback, Inc. v. Standard Oil Co. (1966) 239 Cal.App.2d 664, 687.)
In any event, Nussbaum’s arguments have no merit.
The Trial Court Properly Dismissed the Action
Nussbaum’s first argument is that “The Trial Court Erred in
Sustaining the Demurrer Without Leave to Amend Elder Abuse and
Wrongful Death Causes of Action.” The brief’s two-page discussion refers to
cases that Nussbaum describes as holding that “[s]imilar allegations have
been deemed sufficient to state a claim for elder abuse in California courts.”
But utterly lacking is any reference to the applicable statutes of limitations,
which, as noted, were the bases for Judge Swope’s holding.
Nussbaum’s second argument is that the rulings violated his “Due
Process Rights,” and proceeds to list, without discussion or argument, some
seven claimed things he asserts denied him “a meaningful opportunity to be
heard.” The claims are not supported legally. Judge Swope expressly stated
he “read and considered the moving paper and the opposition” and
“entertained the arguments of counsel and Mr. Nussbaum.” Indeed, our
review of the reporter’s transcript for both the hearing before Judge Healy as
well as before Judge Swope demonstrates that Nussbaum had every

8
opportunity to make his case.6
Nussbaum’s third argument is that “Accrual of Claims Should Be
Tolled Under the Delayed Discovery Rule and Public Policy Related to
Homicide Cases.” Utterly ignoring that he addressed the issue with both
Judge Healy and Judge Swope, and ignoring Judge Swope’s specific reference
to delayed discovery, Nussbaum ends his argument, without further
explanation, with this: “Appellant argues the accrual date for wrongful death
and elder abuse claims should be tolled until January 29, 2024, when
Defendants admitted material facts. . . . [¶] Moreover, public policy disfavors
allowing perpetrators of homicide to benefit from procedural time bars[.]
Perez v. Roe 1 (2006) 146 Cal.App.4th 171, 180.” (Italics added.)
Lastly, as to any claim that Nussbaum was not allowed to amend, we
note that the general rule is that an order dismissing an action pursuant to
Code of Civil Procedure, section 581, subdivision (f)(2) is reviewed for abuse of
discretion. (Nuño v. California State University, Bakersfield (2020) 47
Cal.App.5th 799, 807; Gitmed v. General Motors Corp. (1994) 26 Cal.App.4th
824, 827 [“The decision to dismiss an action under [Code of Civil Procedure]
section 581, subdivision (f)(2) rests in the sound discretion of the trial court
and a reviewing court will not disturb the ruling unless the trial court has
abused its discretion”], citing Harding v. Collazo (1986) 177 Cal.App.3d 1044,
1054; Haidet v. Del Mar Woods Homeowners Assn. (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th
530, 535 [same, citing Gitmed].)
As to what such showing of such abuse requires, it has been described
in terms of a decision that “exceeds the bounds of reason” (People v. Beames

6 To the extent Judge Swope did not consider Nussbaum’s second
opposition, which the Judge called a sur-reply, he was correct, as no such
pleading is provided for.

9
(2007) 40 Cal.4th 907, 920), or one that is arbitrary, capricious, patently
absurd, or even whimsical. (See, e.g., People v. Bryant, Smith and Wheeler
(2014) 60 Cal.4th 335, 390.) In its observation on the subject in a leading
case, our Supreme Court said that “[a] ruling that constitutes an abuse of
discretion has been described as one that is ‘so irrational or arbitrary that no
reasonable person could agree with it.’ ” (Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v.
University of Southern California (2012) 55 Cal.4th 747, 773.) Nussbaum has
made no such showing here.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

10
RICHMAN, J.

We concur.

STEWART, P. J.

MILLER, J.

(A171050N)

11

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.