CourtListener 10597651•In re T.T. CA1/5
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 6/3/25 In re T.T. CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
In re T.T., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.
THE PEOPLE,
A169409 & A170438
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v. (Contra Costa County
Super. Ct. No. J22-00356)
T.T.,
Defendant and Appellant.
T.T. (Minor) argues the juvenile court abused its discretion in
committing him to a secure youth treatment facility (Welf. & Inst. Code,
§ 875)1, namely, the Secure Pathway of the Briones Youth Academy
(hereafter, Secure Pathway or Secure Track). We affirm.
BACKGROUND
Jurisdiction
Following a contested jurisdictional hearing, the juvenile court found
true allegations that Minor committed robbery and that a principal was
1 All undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
1
armed with a firearm during the commission of the offense. As relevant here,
the evidence presented at the jurisdictional hearing and summarized in the
probation report established that Minor and his cousin attempted to rob a
man at a mall on the afternoon of December 31, 2021. When another man
tried to stop the robbery, Minor’s cousin shot him. The shooting victim
subsequently died from his injuries.
Probation Report
A probation report submitted in advance of the October 2023
disposition hearing quoted Minor describing his cousin and co-responsible as
“ ‘like a brother.’ ” Minor characterized his family as supportive and loving.
Prior to entering juvenile hall, Minor had struggled with school attendance
and completing assignments. Minor was diagnosed with ADHD but
discontinued taking medication because of the side effects. Minor denied
drug or alcohol use.
In September 2019, a juvenile court had sustained allegations of
misdemeanor resisting a peace officer and possession of a stolen vehicle,
based on an armed carjacking Minor committed with his cousin and co-
responsible in the instant case. While on probation for the 2019 case, Minor
completed “Functional Family Therapy” with his family, wrote an apology
letter to the victims, and completed community service hours. In March
2020, Minor was arrested after being found with other juveniles in a vehicle
that contained three loaded firearms. A probation violation was filed but
later dismissed, and Minor successfully completed probation in January
2021.
At the time of the probation report, Minor had been in juvenile hall for
well over a year. While in juvenile hall, he had graduated high school and
was taking college classes. He performed well in his classes and had
2
excellent behavior for the vast majority of his time at juvenile hall. However,
there were notable exceptions in the months before the disposition hearing:
on two separate days in June 2023, Minor argued with juvenile hall staff and,
after he was admonished for arguing, yelled and cursed at staff members. On
one of these days, Minor also was involved in a physical fight with another
youth.
Regarding placement, the probation report stated: “In the instant
offense, [Minor] sustained a 707(b) offense for participating in a robbery that
resulted in a fatality. In what appears to have been a premeditated act,
[Minor] and his co-responsible entered a shopping mall on New Year’s Eve in
the middle of the day and put many innocent citizens at risk for injury and/or
loss of life. The serious nature of the instant offense indicates [Minor] needs
a high level of intervention. . . . [¶] A commitment to the BYA-Secure
Pathway will afford [Minor] the opportunity to participate in CORE Evidence
Based groups designed to address criminal behavior and distorted thinking,
in addition to intensive programming through Trauma Recovery Groups,
Free Your Mind, Life Skills, Choices, Interactive Journaling, and Victim
Empathy. Further, he will have the opportunity to continue his college
education and/or participate in the MC3 12-month vocational program,
creating a solid foundation for this 18-year-old to return to the community.”
The probation report provided additional information about the Briones
Youth Academy and Secure Pathway: “The objective of the BYA is to provide
individualized treatment, utilizing cognitive behavioral treatment, as well as
best practices, to help guide youth in their social-emotional development.
The BYA programming will utilize a holistic approach to create a
rehabilitative environment through collaboration with the community,
family, mental/behavioral health, and education, while offering the minor life
3
skills designed to promote vocational and educational success beyond the
term of commitment. The goal is to expose the root of delinquent behavior
through a variety of classes, activities and exercises offered with the
structure, guidance and support of Probation and the mental health team, in
a safe and secure environment, local to the minor and family. The BYA
consists of four progressive levels: Root, Forest, Mountain, and Peak Levels.
Youth progress to the next level based on their Individualized Rehabilitation
Plan (IRP) and completion of goals established in their IRP. On the Secure
Track, the services included in the IRP are expanded to address the more
intensive and sophisticated criminogenic treatment needs for youth who have
committed the most serious, violent, and dangerous felonies.
“The Root Level will be the minor’s orientation to BYA. In the Forest
Level, the minor will begin his core evidence-based treatment classes. In the
Mountain Level, the minor will participate in vocational classes and college
course work, while continuing evidence-based coursework. The Peak Level is
the final level in BYA, where the minor will continue to participate in
treatment, vocational, and educational classes, with a greater emphasis on
demonstration of learned concepts, and preparing the minor for successful
transition to the community. Upon reaching Peak Level on the Secure Track,
youth will earn more privileges, and have the opportunity to demonstrate
what they have learned on a transitional unit, where they will prepare for
successful reintegration into the community using a phased approach.”
The probation report concluded, “Indefinite Wardship with a
commitment to the BYA Secure Pathway is recommended, in order for the
youth to receive intensive treatment services. Should the youth be
committed to BYA, the youth will undergo an assessment period of 14 days,
during which time a variety of assessments and tools designed to
4
individualize treatment are completed. A multi-disciplinary team review will
further aid in the creation of a rehabilitation plan within the first 30 days of
commitment. [¶] Dependent on the outcome of these assessments, the
resulting rehabilitation plan could include an assortment of evidence-based
classes such as Trauma Recovery Groups, Free Your Mind, Life Skills,
Choices, Interactive Journaling. and Victim Empathy. Additionally, the
youth will be afforded the opportunity to continue his college education and
participate in the MC3-12 vocational program. [¶] In addition, youth on the
Secure Track of BYA would attend a hearing every six months, where the
Court will be updated on the minor’s progress and have the authority to
extend or reduce the youth’s baseline terms dependent on the youth’s
progress.”
Minor’s Evidence
Minor submitted two exhibits. The first was described by counsel as
“the Briones Youth Academy handbook,” authored, as identified on its cover,
by the Contra Costa County Probation Department.2 This handbook
explained, “The Court will order a youth to the Briones Youth Academy to
one of three pathways. The three pathways are the Secure Pathway,
Commitment Pathway, and Community Pathway.”3 The Secure Pathway
consists of four levels—Root, Forest, Mountain, and Peak—and “is governed
by Senate Bill 92.[4] The Court will determine a baseline term for a youth.
2 The People did not object to the handbook’s admission or contest its
authenticity.
3 The Community Pathway is not at issue in this appeal.
4 Senate Bill No. 92 (2021–2022 Reg. Sess.) (Stats. 2021, ch. 18, § 12)
added section 875, which established secure youth treatment facilities as the
most restrictive placement for juvenile wards.
5
Within 30 days of commitment, an Individualized Rehabilitation Plan will be
developed. [¶] Youth will attend a Court Review hearing every six months
where the Court will be updated on the youth’s progress. During reviews, the
Court has the authority to extend or reduce the baseline term by six months.”
The Commitment Pathway “is a three-level program [(Root, Forest, and
Mountain)] where youth will receive an Individualized Rehabilitation Plan.
The time spent within the Commitment Pathway is determined by the
youth’s successful completion of each level which can typically be
accomplished within a period of 10 to 12 months. In addition, while youth
successfully work through the levels of the program, they must demonstrate
an understanding of the skills and tools taught in the cognitive behavioral
treatment classes.” The handbook included descriptions of numerous
treatment programs that youth may be assigned, including many of the ones
identified in the probation report as relevant to Minor’s needs.
Minor’s second exhibit was a social history and assessment prepared at
Minor’s request by a social worker and former juvenile probation officer. The
report described Minor’s exposure to “a significant amount of loss and
trauma” during childhood, including, at seven years old, seeing his cousin
dead in the street after she was killed by crossfire, and, at 11 years old,
walking next to another cousin when she was hit by a car and killed. The
report discussed Minor’s ADHD diagnosis when he was six years old,
admission to a psychiatric hospital after threatening to kill himself when he
was ten years old, and multiple school suspensions for fighting and disruptive
behavior. The report opined that, although Minor’s relationship with his
family is strong, Minor did not receive the emotional and mental health
intervention needed during his childhood.
6
The report noted that the family therapy program provided during
Minor’s prior probation inaccurately stated Minor and his family had no
history of trauma or mental illness. While “fragile progress” was made
during the program, no resources were provided after discharge in May 2020.
During the pandemic, Minor began spending more time on social media with
negative peers.
When Minor first began school in juvenile hall, his performance and
behavior were poor, but they significantly improved during his time there
and he earned a 4.0 grade point average during his last three quarters.
Minor had also recently begun regular therapy sessions.
The report concluded that Minor “has survived significant adversity
throughout his life and has demonstrated a potential for growth,
conscientious thinking and ultimately, rehabilitation. . . . [Minor’s] marked
response to his current rehabilitative programming not only indicates a
readiness for change but an amenability to services provided at The Briones
Youth Academy (BYA). The developmentally appropriate and evidence[]
based services offered through BYA appear to align with [Minor’s] current
needs and stage of development. These services include, but are not limited
to, a myriad of assessment tools, an assigned Multi-Disciplinary Team
(MDT), and family-centered and trauma informed therapeutic planning and
interventions. By affording [Minor] these services, he will have the
opportunity to continue on his established path toward rehabilitation.”
Disposition Hearing Arguments
The People agreed with the probation report’s recommendation of
Secure Pathway, and the probation department submitted on their report.
Minor’s counsel requested the court commit Minor to the Commitment
Pathway instead of the Secure Pathway. Counsel argued the handbook
7
reveals “the small differences between the Secure Track program and the
Commitment Track program in terms of programming offered and the depth
of treatment that is available to youth,” and noted that youth in the two
tracks “are housed on the same unit, they program together, and they
complete mostly the same programs.” The probation department had told
counsel Secure Pathway youth take both Thinking for a Change and
Aggression Replacement Therapy, while Commitment Pathway youth take
one or the other, but counsel represented that she had clients in Commitment
Pathway who had been ordered to take both. The probation department had
also told counsel there were two additional Secure Pathway programs—Free
Your Mind and Interactive Journaling—but counsel argued that if those
programs were needed to address Minor’s treatment needs, he could be
ordered to complete them in Commitment Pathway.
Decision
The juvenile court began by discussing Minor’s performance in juvenile
hall and finding his positive change and work there “significant.” The court
considered the severity of the offense and found that while Minor was not the
shooter, “[g]iven your close relationship with your cousin, I do find your role
in the incident significant as well. This was someone who seems more like an
equal partner to you, . . . and you both committed this crime, knowing that he
was armed and what that could mean, what the purpose of that was.” The
court considered Minor’s previous delinquency history and found “the
adequacy and success of previous [rehabilitative] attempts, was insufficient,
and so that weighs in favor of a Secure Track commitment.” The court also
found significant Minor’s “concerning behavior” in juvenile hall a few months
prior to the disposition hearing. The court concluded, “[M]y concern is that,
in the past, you have engaged in services, and I want to make sure that this
8
time, we are not just checking boxes and that you are really internalizing
what you need to internalize, not just when the pressure is on, but also when
no one is watching.”
The juvenile court committed Minor to Secure Pathway, with a
maximum term of four years or age 23, whichever occurred first, and a
baseline term of three years. Minor appeals from this order (case No.
A169409).5
DISCUSSION
“We review the [juvenile] court’s placement decision for an abuse of
discretion. [Citation.] We review the court’s findings for substantial
evidence, and ‘ “[a] trial court abuses its discretion when the factual findings
critical to its decision find no support in the evidence.” ’ ” (In re Nicole H.
(2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 1150, 1154.)
“Section 875 . . . governs the commitment of juvenile wards to the
secure youth treatment facilities that have replaced the Division of Juvenile
Justice (DJJ) as the most restrictive placement alternative.”6 (In re Tony R.
(2023) 98 Cal.App.5th 395, 406.) The provision authorizes such placements
if, among other findings, “[t]he court has made a finding on the record that a
5 Minor filed a second appeal from an order issued following an April
2024 six-month review hearing (case No. A170438). We granted Minor’s
unopposed motion to consolidate the two appeals for briefing, oral argument,
and decision. Because Minor’s briefs raise no challenges to the six-month
review order, we omit background facts relating solely to that order.
6 A secure youth treatment facility “shall be a secure facility that is
operated, utilized, or accessed by the county of commitment,” and “may be a
stand-alone facility, . . . or may be a unit or portion of an existing county
juvenile facility, including a juvenile hall or probation camp, that is
configured and programmed to serve” the targeted population. (§ 875,
subd. (g)(1)–(2).)
9
less restrictive, alternative disposition for the ward is unsuitable.” (§ 875,
subd. (a)(3).) The statute sets forth criteria to be used in making this finding:
“(A) The severity of the offense or offenses for which the ward has been most
recently adjudicated, including the ward’s role in the offense, the ward’s
behavior, and harm done to victims. [¶] (B) The ward’s previous delinquent
history, including the adequacy and success of previous attempts by the
juvenile court to rehabilitate the ward. [¶] (C) Whether the programming,
treatment, and education offered and provided in a secure youth treatment
facility is appropriate to meet the treatment and security needs of the ward.
[¶] (D) Whether the goals of rehabilitation and community safety can be met
by assigning the ward to an alternative, less restrictive disposition that is
available to the court. [¶] (E) The ward’s age, developmental maturity,
mental and emotional health, sexual orientation, gender identity and
expression, and any disabilities or special needs affecting the safety or
suitability of committing the ward to a term of confinement in a secure youth
treatment facility.” (§ 875, subd. (a)(3).)
Minor argues the juvenile court abused its discretion in finding Secure
Pathway the least restrictive placement. Minor first contends the severity of
the offense does not warrant the placement because Minor was not the
shooter and there was no evidence he possessed a weapon. There was
evidence that Minor characterized the shooter as like a brother and the two
had previously committed crimes together. The juvenile court could
reasonably infer that Minor knew the shooter had a firearm when they
committed the robbery and further knew the shooter might use it. That a
different inference could have been drawn is immaterial. (Rupf v. Yan (2000)
85 Cal.App.4th 411, 429, fn. 5 [“ ‘So long as there is “substantial evidence,”
the appellate court must affirm . . . even if the reviewing justices personally
10
would have ruled differently had they presided over the proceedings below,
and even if other substantial evidence would have supported a different
result’ ”].) The juvenile court did not abuse its discretion in finding this
factor weighed in favor of Secure Pathway.
Minor next contends his overall progress in juvenile hall and the
inadequacy of the services he received in his prior delinquency case should
outweigh his recent incidents of arguing and cursing at juvenile hall staff.
The court considered all of these factors and Minor fails to establish any
abuse of discretion in how the court weighed them.
Finally, Minor contends there is no evidence that Secure Pathway is
the least restrictive placement because essentially the same programming is
offered to youths in Commitment Pathway.7 The record demonstrates that
both offer programming that would address Minor’s needs, but the Secure
Pathway programming is more intensive and longer, including a fourth level
to assist youth in transitioning back to the community. The juvenile court
could reasonably find that the less intensive Commitment Pathway would not
be sufficient in light of the relevant factors, most notably the seriousness of
the offense and Minor’s delinquency and rehabilitation history. In re Carlos
J. (2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 1, relied on by Minor, is easily distinguishable
because in that case, there was “no specific information in the record
regarding the programs” in the most restrictive placement (id. at p. 4, italics
added).
DISPOSITION
The orders are affirmed.
7 Both parties assume Commitment Pathway is a less restrictive
alternative to Secure Pathway. For purposes of this appeal, we will do so as
well.
11
SIMONS, J.
We concur.
JACKSON, P. J.
BURNS, J.
(A169409 & A170438)
12
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.