In re A.M. CA4/1

CourtListener 10586587Calctapp19.05.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 5/19/25 In re A.M. CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

In re A.M., a Person Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.

THE PEOPLE, D083816

Plaintiff and Respondent,
(Super. Ct. No. JJL000946)
v.

A.M.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Imperial County,
William D. Quan, Judge. Affirmed.
Laura Arnold, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General,
Steve Oetting and Evan Stele, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
A.M., a minor, appeals from a disposition order of the juvenile court
committing him to a secure youth treatment facility (SYTF) after he admitted
1
committing a robbery. On appeal, he contends the juvenile court abused its
discretion when it ordered him to be committed to a SYTF without giving due
consideration to an available less restrictive alternative, specifically formal
probation with electronic monitoring. We conclude the court’s ruling was not
an abuse of discretion. Accordingly, we affirm the judgment.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Robbery
In November 2023, 14-year-old A.M. stole two cases of beer from a
convenience store in Riverside County while on probation for a robbery
committed in February 2023. When confronted by the store owner, A.M.
allegedly pointed a chrome handgun at the victim before getting in a vehicle
and fleeing the scene. A.M. was arrested on December 5, 2023 and a Welfare

and Institutions Code section 6021 petition was filed the next day in
Riverside County Superior Court. The petition alleged A.M. committed
robbery (Pen. Code, § 211), theft (Pen. Code, § 487), and misdemeanor
shoplifting (Pen. Code, § 459.5).
In December 2023, A.M. admitted the November 2023 robbery. The
People dismissed the theft and misdemeanor shoplifting charges. The court
then granted A.M.’s request to transfer the case from Riverside County to
Imperial County.
B. Disposition Report
The juvenile court in Imperial County set a disposition hearing for
January 2024. Before the hearing, A.M.’s probation officer filed a disposition
report. The report included the following information about the current
offense: A.M. admitted to committing a “beer run,” denied having a firearm,

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions
Code unless otherwise specified.
2
did not display any guilt or remorse, attempted to shift the blame to the store
owner, and avoided answering questions about the incident. The report
further provided that A.M. was enrolled in independent studies, was not a
victim of abuse or general neglect, was behaving in the programs at the
Imperial County Juvenile Hall where he was being housed, and had initially
adjusted well to formal probation for the prior robbery. The probation officer
expressed concern, however, that the instant offense was a “repeat” of the
prior offense for which he was already on probation, indicating that he did
not take rehabilitation seriously and could be considered a threat to the
community. The probation officer also noted that he had made multiple
unsuccessful efforts to contact A.M.’s mother. When he finally reached her,
she said that A.M. was a “good kid” who was “negatively influenced by
negative older peers,” that “the entire incident was not his fault,” and that
“the incident was just a ‘beer run’ and not a robbery.”
The probation officer recommended A.M. be declared a ward of the
court under section 602 and placed in the SYTF located in Imperial County
Juvenile Hall. According to the report, the services A.M. needed were not
available near his home, and the unavailability of A.M.’s mother meant he
would not have reliable transportation to the necessary services. The officer
believed all these factors indicated A.M. would commit another related
offense.
C. Initial Disposition Hearing
At an initial disposition hearing, A.M. raised several concerns with the
disposition report. He argued, as relevant here, that there were possible due
process violations because the recommendation was based on A.M.’s area of
residence and there was no investigation into whether A.M. suffered from
any mental health issues. A.M. argued that a supplemental report was

3
required to address these issues, and he requested a continuance. The People
did not oppose the continuance and agreed that a supplemental report was
necessary.
The court continued the disposition hearing and ordered a
supplemental report from probation that focused on any childhood trauma,
mental health issues, learning disabilities, and any other factors that may
mitigate A.M.’s actions.
D. First Supplemental Report
A.M.’s probation officer filed a supplemental report before the
continued disposition hearing, again recommending that A.M. be committed
to a SYTF. A.M. and his mother both indicated there was no childhood
trauma, learning disability, or abuse; neither believed A.M. required
behavioral health services but were open to the idea; and the staff of A.M.’s
high school described him as “bright and intelligent.” A.M.’s mother reported
she was a farm laborer, which is why she had been unavailable, but she
promised to try to keep A.M. under control. A.M.’s mother also mentioned
she hired an attorney to get A.M. readmitted to his school and planned to file
a restraining order against the others involved in the instant offense should
A.M. be released from custody. At the continued disposition hearing, the
court noted that while it was in receipt of the supplemental report, it had not
received an additional memo A.M.’s probation officer had filed the previous
day. A.M.’s counsel had also not received the memo. As a result, A.M.
requested another continuance and indicated he expected the disposition to
become a contested matter.
E. Contested Disposition Hearing
The court held the contested disposition hearing in March 2024. The
probation officer testified that A.M.’s mother told him she was unavailable

4
because she works in the fields and her phone had been disconnected or
changed approximately four times since the initiation of the case. According
to the probation officer, A.M. was known to have a gang affiliation from a
previous case. While A.M. had been in juvenile hall, there were incident
reports about him and a rival gang member tagging and making graffiti
threats against each other. In a recorded conversation with a person named
Fargo, A.M. said the “whip” (meaning firearm) was with his mother and he
would be able to retrieve it when he was released. The officer did not
investigate any other alternatives to the SYTF commitment, including
electronic monitoring.
A.M.’s mother testified that she attempted to communicate with the
probation officer on ten separate occasions since December of 2023 and only
reached him once. She indicated she was willing to move to an area with
more readily available services, but she was unable to do so at that time.
A.M. testified that he would comply with all required terms of
probation or other services if offered. A.M. said he was never a gang member,
but he associated with people in a gang on one occasion. A.M. stated that
despite the negative influences in his life, he would focus on school and try to
graduate. He explained that he had been on electronic monitoring for a
month, but he was not on electronic monitoring at the time of the most recent
offense. On cross-examination, he denied using a gun during the robbery and
admitted having a nickname given to him by friend who was associated with
a gang.
During closing arguments, counsel for A.M. argued that he had an
uncle and grandparent at home who could supervise him, and that he had
successfully completed electronic monitoring during his prior probation

5
period. Despite this, the probation officer failed to explore electronic
monitoring as an option for the current offense.
The court acknowledged that the probation officer did not provide
further information regarding alternatives to confinement to the SYTF. The
court continued the disposition hearing again, ordering that the probation
officer submit a second supplemental report that provided information on
alternatives to confinement.
F. Second Supplemental Report
The probation officer stated in his second supplemental report that
A.M. had expressed remorse for committing the instant offense because he
recently learned the victim was his aunt’s ex-boyfriend. A.M. requested that
the court consider electronic monitoring, emphasizing that he did not want to
spend a large portion of his teenage years in custody and that his priority
was to graduate from high school and find employment afterwards.
The probation officer also interviewed A.M.’s mother. She stated that
although she works, there was always some form of adult supervision for
A.M. at home. A.M.’s mother promised to “do ‘anything and everything in her
power’ ” to raise A.M. appropriately. “Regarding the instant offense, she
advised that the minor is heavily influenced by negative adult peers who she
believes ‘put him up to it.’ She advised that she cannot stop him from
associating with three adults and advised that at least two of them are
known gang members.” She was “at a loss as to how to change the minor’s
criminal behavior patterns and gang associations.”
The probation officer’s report explored pre-placement services, relative
placement, group home placement, and Short-Term Residential Therapeutic
Programs (STRTP) as alternatives to confinement. He found that pre-
placement services were not feasible because the closest facilities were

6
approximately 40 minutes from A.M.’s residence. Relative placement was not
an option because it appeared that A.M.’s only stable and permanent
residence placement option was with his mother. A.M. did not qualify for
group home placement, nor did he meet the criteria for an STRTP.
The probation officer reaffirmed his initial recommendation for A.M. to
be committed to a SYTF. The report stated that A.M.’s role as the sole actor
in the commission of the instant offense and the harm done to the victims
qualified him for commitment. Further, although A.M. denied any gang
affiliation, it had been established in the prior robbery case and he had also
“inadvertently admitted his gang affiliation to the Deputy District Attorney
during his cross-examination” in this matter. The probation officer
considered A.M. a threat to the community.
G. Final Hearing and Disposition
At the final contested disposition hearing, the juvenile court declared
A.M. a ward of the court. The court considered the probation officer’s report,
the supplemental reports, and all evidence presented. The court focused on
the fact that the current offense occurred while A.M. was on probation for a
previous robbery. The court expressed concern that A.M. was susceptible to
peer pressure and that his mother was at a loss as to how to change A.M.’s
behavior and associations. The court did not find credible the testimony from
A.M.’s mother that she was able to supervise A.M. and that she was unable to
reach the probation officer throughout the entire probation period. The court
found the probation officer’s testimony credible regarding his contact
attempts. The court stated that it had considered alternatives to
confinement and did not believe electronic monitoring would have prevented
A.M. from committing the present offense. It noted that even after being on

7
electronic monitoring for the prior robbery, A.M. “willfully and intentionally
went out and committed the second robbery, period.”
In sum, the court made the following statement and findings: “The
Court did consider the five factors as follows: the severity of the offense,
including the youth’s role in the offense, the youth’s behavior and the harm
done to the victims. [¶] The Court has also considered the youth’s previous
delinquent history, including adequacy and successful previous attempts to
rehabilitate the youth, whether the program and treatment and education
offered and provided in a secure youth treatment facility is appropriate to
meet the needs of the minor child, and whether the goals of rehabilitation
and community safety can be met by assigning the youth to an alternative,
less restrictive disposition available to the Court, the youth’s age,
developmental maturity, mental and emotional health, sexual orientation,
gender identity and expression, and any disabilities or special needs that may
have been brought forward affecting the safety or suitability of committing
the youth to a term of confinement in a secure youth treatment facility. [¶]
Having considered all that, the Court will find that a less restrictive
alternative is unsuitable.” The court further found under section 726 that an
award of custody to A.M.’s parent or legal guardian was not appropriate,
because he had tried and failed to reform while on probation, and the return
of A.M. to his home would be contrary to his welfare.
The court sentenced A.M. to a baseline term of two years at the SYTF,
with a maximum confinement time of five years.
DISCUSSION
A.M. contends the court abused its discretion when it ordered him
committed to a SYTF instead of sentencing him to a less restrictive

8
alternative—specifically, formal probation with electronic monitoring. We
disagree.
We review a juvenile court’s decision to commit a minor to confinement
for abuse of discretion. (In re Miguel C. (2021) 69 Cal.App.5th 899, 908.) An
abuse of discretion occurs when the court’s factual findings critical to its
decision find no support in the evidence. (Ibid.) The appellate court
therefore considers whether substantial evidence—meaning evidence
reasonable in nature, credible, and of solid value—supports the juvenile
court’s commitment order in light of the purpose of the juvenile court law.
(Ibid.; § 202, subd. (b) [a minor “in need of protective services shall receive
care, treatment, and guidance consistent with their best interest and the best
interest of the public”].) We must indulge all reasonable inferences to
support the juvenile court’s decision. (In re A.R. (2018) 24 Cal.App.5th 1076,
1080.)
A court determining the appropriate disposition of a section 602 case
shall consider, in addition to other relevant and material evidence, (1) the age
of the minor, (2) the circumstances and gravity of the offense, and (3) the
minor’s previous delinquent history. (§ 725.5.) If the minor is adjudged a
ward under section 602, “the court may make any reasonable orders for the
care, supervision, custody, conduct, maintenance, and support of the minor.”
(§ 727, subd. (a)(1).) The court has the discretion to place the ward at home,
on probation, with or without electronic monitoring, or to order various forms
of commitment. (§§ 727, subd. (a)(2)–(3), 730, subd. (a).)
The court also has the discretion to order a juvenile who is 14 years of
age or older to be committed to a secure youth treatment facility for a period
of confinement if certain criteria are met, including a finding on the record
that a less restrictive, alternative disposition for the minor is unsuitable.

9
(§ 875, subd. (a).) The court must base its determination for a less restrictive
alternative disposition on the following criteria: “(A) The severity of the
offense or offenses for which the ward has been most recently adjudicated,
including the ward’s role in the offense, the ward’s behavior, and harm done
to victims. [¶] (B) The ward’s previous delinquent history, including the
adequacy and success of previous attempts by the juvenile court to
rehabilitate the ward. [¶] (C) Whether the programming, treatment, and
education offered and provided in a secure youth treatment facility is
appropriate to meet the treatment and security needs of the ward. [¶]
(D) Whether the goals of rehabilitation and community safety can be met by
assigning the ward to an alternative, less restrictive disposition that is
available to the court. [¶] (E) The ward’s age, developmental maturity,
mental and emotional health, sexual orientation, gender identity and
expression, and any disabilities or special needs affecting the safety or
suitability of committing the ward to a term of confinement in a secure youth
treatment facility.” (§ 875, subd. (a)(3)(A)-(E).)
A.M. argues the court abused its discretion in declining to sentence him
to formal probation with electronic monitoring because (1) A.M. was only 14
years old, (2) the current robbery offense was not particularly serious,
(3) A.M.’s criminal history did not support a secure commitment, and (4) the
goal of rehabilitation and community safety could be met through probation
with electronic monitoring. Additionally, A.M. argues the court dismissed his
request for probation based on pure speculation that A.M. would have
committed the present offense even if he had been on house arrest with
electronic monitoring for his prior offense.
We discern no abuse of discretion. The court paid close attention to the
possibility of less restrictive available alternatives, and even continued the

10
disposition hearing for a supplemental report on the subject. The court was
aware of its duty to consider a less restrictive available alternative and
reasonably concluded that such alternatives, including electronic monitoring,
were not suitable for A.M. The court expressly stated that it considered the
probation report and supplemental reports, the evidence presented by A.M.’s
counsel, and the required factors under section 875, subdivision (a)(3)(A)
through (E), in reaching its conclusion. When making a finding that a less
restrictive alternative disposition is not suitable, the court is not required to
first attempt a less restrictive placement before ordering commitment to one
that is more restrictive. (See In re Nicole H. (2016) 244 Cal.App.4th 1150,
1159.)
Despite his young age, this was not A.M.’s first interaction with the
juvenile justice system—he was already on probation for a similar robbery.
A.M. denied any gang affiliation, but his gang affiliation was previously
established in a separate case and his mother confirmed his association with
older gang members and her inability to do anything about it. A.M. was not
deterred by his previous punishment, which included probation with
electronic monitoring. Instead, A.M. committed a second robbery while on
probation for the first. According to the probation officer, he also showed no
remorse for committing the offense and minimized it as a “beer run.”
A.M. argues the robbery was not a serious crime, but his actions do
suggest a troubling pattern of serious criminality and gang influence at a
young and impressionable age. The probation officer thus deemed A.M. a
“threat to the community.”
The court further took into consideration whether probation with
electronic monitoring could achieve the goals of rehabilitation and community
safety, and it concluded that it would not. The court specifically found that

11
awarding custody to his mother would be detrimental to A.M. because he was
previously placed on probation with electronic monitoring and failed to
reform. The court did not find A.M.’s mother’s testimony entirely credible,
including her assertion that she would be able to supervise A.M. at home.
Her statement to the probation officer made it clear that she was unable to
control A.M.’s behavior or stop him from associating with gang members or
others who had a negative influence on him. The court reasonably concluded
that returning A.M. to his home would be contrary to his welfare and
community safety.
We therefore conclude that the juvenile court based its decision to
commit A.M. on the required statutory factors, substantial evidence
supported its factual findings, and it did not abuse its discretion in
committing A.M. to a SYTF.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

BUCHANAN, J.

WE CONCUR:

DATO, Acting P. J.

DO, J.

12

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.