In re J.M. CA2/5

CourtListener 10462688Calctapp02.05.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 5/2/25 In re J.M. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule
8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

In re J.M. et al., Persons Coming
Under the Juvenile Court Law. B333283

LOS ANGELES COUNTY (Los Angeles County
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN Super. Ct. No.
AND FAMILY SERVICES, 19CCJP07502E-H)

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

A.W.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Gabriela H. Shapiro, Judge Pro Tempore.
Affirmed.
Cristina Gabrielidis, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Veronica Randazzo, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Without holding a hearing, the juvenile court denied A.W.’s
(Mother’s) changed circumstances petition to reinstate
reunification services for her four children: J.N.M., J.M.M., N.M.,
and L.R. (collectively, Minors). We are asked to decide whether
this was error because Mother made a prima facie showing as to
both requirements for the order she sought: that the
circumstances had changed and that ordering additional services
would be in Minors’ best interest.

I. BACKGROUND
J.N.M. was born in 2012, J.M.M. was born in 2013, N.M.
was born in 2015, and L.R. was born in 2019. The proceedings
giving rise to this appeal began in September 2021 and have
continued for an extended period due to delays in obtaining
documents pertinent to the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) and
related California law.1

1
At the outset of the Department of Children and Family
Service’s (the Department’s) investigation, Mother disclosed
Minors may have Cherokee or other Indian ancestry. The
Department sent notice of the proceedings to several tribes, and
the Cherokee Nation responded the children were eligible for
enrollment through a maternal great grandmother but had not
been enrolled and “were not considered ‘Indian children’ per
federal law.” The juvenile court ordered the Department to enroll
Mother and Minors in the Cherokee Nation, but delays ensued
and the record does not reveal whether that had yet been
accomplished at the time this appeal was taken.

2
A. Investigation and Assumption of Dependency
Jurisdiction
The Department received several referrals concerning the
family between 2012 and 2019. In February 2020, the juvenile
court assumed dependency jurisdiction over Minors based on a
finding that Mother left them home alone without adult
supervision. The juvenile court terminated jurisdiction in August
2021, finding the concerns that brought Minors to the
Department’s attention no longer existed.
Less than one month later, the Department learned
Mother’s neighbors called the police because she was threatening
to fight people, she was incoherent when the police arrived, and
she kicked a police officer. J.M.M. and L.R. were with Mother at
the time of the incident, and J.N.M. and N.M. were at a park
across the street from the home, unsupervised. Mother told Fire
Department personnel she “[did not] give a fuck about [Minors]”
and police officers heard her say she wanted to kill three of the
four children. J.N.M. also told a social worker Mother physically
abused him.
The Department filed a juvenile dependency petition
alleging Minors faced a substantial risk of serious physical harm
based on Mother’s physical abuse of J.N.M.; her use of drugs,
including while Minors were under her supervision; her mental
and emotional problems, “including a diagnosis of Schizophrenia,
auditory hallucinations, homicidal ideations and violent and
assaultive behaviors”; her failure to supervise Minors; and
unsanitary conditions in the home.
Minors were detained from Mother in September 2021.
The two oldest children, J.N.M. and J.M.M., were placed with
their paternal grandparents. The two younger children, N.M.

3
and L.R., were placed with Mother’s biological aunt and her
sister by adoption, D.W. Mother had unmonitored virtual visits
with Minors until October 2021, when she made threats against
Minors’ caregivers and their families. The juvenile court then
restricted her to monitored virtual visits until she showed she
was participating in appropriate mental health services.
When the Department interviewed Minors concerning the
allegations in the juvenile dependency petition, J.N.M. reported
Mother hit him with her fists and a belt, and his siblings also
sometimes received “whoopings.” The two other children old
enough to offer a statement, J.M.M. and N.M., denied Mother
physically abused them or J.N.M. J.M.M. acknowledged Mother
sometimes spanked her with a belt, but she said it did not hurt.
With respect to drug use, J.N.M. said Mother smoked “green
stuff” “all the time,” but J.M.M. said Mother only took medication
prescribed to treat Crohn’s disease. Mother said she only took
medication prescribed to treat schizophrenia. L.R.’s father, M.R.,
described Mother as an “addict.” Regarding the allegation that
Minors did not receive appropriate supervision, J.N.M. and
J.M.M. reported they went to a nearby park when Mother slept.
J.N.M. also stated Mother sometimes left him to supervise his
younger siblings.
Mother insisted she did not hit Minors and said she
disciplined them by taking away a tablet. With respect to mental
health, Mother told a Department social worker in November
2021 that she suffers from schizophrenia. The following month,
Mother confirmed she was not receiving treatment or taking any
medication for her mental health issues and refused a referral for
services. Mother claimed Minors were “never alone” and
unsupervised.

4
At a February 2022 jurisdiction hearing, the juvenile court
sustained the dependency petition and ordered Minors removed
from Mother’s custody. Mother was granted monitored visitation
and ordered to participate in drug testing, parenting classes, and
individual counseling; to undergo a psychological assessment and
psychiatric evaluation; and to take all prescribed medication.

B. Reunification Period
During the initial months of the reunification period,
Mother missed drug tests and did not comply with her case plan
other than completing a parenting class. In June 2022, the
juvenile court ordered Mother to complete a drug treatment
program with testing. Mother enrolled in an inpatient program
in August 2022. She mostly tested negative for drugs while in
this program, but the Department reported the program’s testing
methods did not meet Department standards.
After she completed the inpatient program in November
2022, Mother moved into a sober living facility. Mother started
taking drug tests acceptable to the Department in January 2023,
and she tested negative for all substances between January and
March 2023. She also participated in individual therapy, though
she did not discuss case issues with her therapist.
Mother told the Department she was not taking any
psychotropic medication in April 2022, but she claimed she was
taking all prescribed medication before she entered the inpatient
drug program in August 2022. Mother reported she stopped
taking psychotropic medication when she completed the inpatient
drug program in November 2022, but she resumed taking the
medication after undergoing a psychiatric evaluation in January
2023. She enrolled in the San Pedro Mental Health Center in

5
January 2023 and attended monthly psychiatric appointments
and twice-monthly individual therapy.
Mother visited the children inconsistently during the
reunification period. She had little contact with the children
between September 2021 and August 2022. Mother’s
inconsistency in visiting left J.M.M. “tearful” and caused her to
act aggressively and “create[ ] a narrative as to why [M]other
cannot visit more often.” N.M. and L.R. “exhibit[ed] insecurity
when [Mother] [wa]s not present and often ask[ed] for her.” A
social worker terminated a visit in April 2022 when Mother
responded to J.N.M.’s discussion of physical abuse by telling him
she would not seek to regain custody of him. When the social
worker told Mother this comment was not appropriate, Mother
suggested J.N.M. could handle it because he was 14 years old;
she “appeared surprised” when the social worker reminded her
J.N.M. was only nine.
Apart from a phone call with N.M. and L.R., Mother had no
contact with the children between August 2022 and November
2022 when she was in the inpatient drug program. Between
November 2022 and April 2023, Mother had nine visits (some
virtual) with N.M. and L.R; at the first in-person visit, N.M. and
L.R. appeared not to recognize Mother. Mother had six virtual
visits with J.M.M. during this period and declined the
Department’s offers to facilitate in-person visits or longer virtual
visits. Mother and J.M.M. also participated in counseling
together between December 2022 and February 2023.
Minors’ responses to visits with Mother were mixed.
J.N.M. refused additional contact with Mother after only a
handful of visits, and as of October 2022, J.N.M. “[did] not want
to hear her name.” J.M.M.’s visits with Mother were generally

6
positive, but J.M.M. cried when Mother brought up painful
memories. J.M.M. told a social worker in April 2023 she worried
about the prospect of unmonitored visits with Mother because
“you never know what [Mother] will say or do.” For example,
“she could do things then ask us to keep a secret and not tell
anyone what she does at home and I have to keep her secrets.”
N.M. also expressed a need to keep secrets for Mother.2 Mother
was affectionate with N.M. and L.R., but after visits “both
children regress[ed] in their behaviors and exhibit[ed] anxious
behavior, bed-wetting, aggression towards each other and
insomnia.”
Although some of the children exhibited behavioral issues,
they were generally doing well in the homes of their respective
caregivers. J.N.M. and J.M.M. were attending school and
participating in extracurricular activities following “chronic
absenteeism or no school enrollment for significant periods” in
Mother’s care. The caregivers, who initially expressed a desire to
serve as legal guardians, had reconsidered and were committed
to adopting Minors. J.N.M. and J.M.M. both told a social worker
they wanted to be adopted by their caregivers. J.M.M. said her
paternal grandparents’ home was the “only place she feels
protected.” J.M.M. told a social worker she did not reciprocate
when Mother said “I love you” because she “[did not] talk about
[her] feelings like that,” but she acknowledged she told her
caregivers “I love you every night before bed.” N.M. (seven years
old in April 2023) and L.R. (four years old in April 2023) were not

2
J.N.M. told a social worker that Mother coached him and
his siblings to deny abuse “during the years of [Department]
investigations.”

7
formally asked about their preferences. However, N.M. “ha[d]
expressed that he [did] not want to live with his mother and
want[ed] to live with his current caregiver, who he call[ed] mom
or Auntie D[.]”
The juvenile court terminated family reunification services
in May 2023.

C. The Post-Reunification Period and Mother’s Changed
Circumstances Petition
In August 2023, in advance of a scheduled hearing to
determine whether to terminate Mother’s parental rights or to
select another permanent plan, the Department reported Minors
continued to do well in the homes of their caregivers. J.N.M. said
he wanted his grandparents to adopt him “because he knows that
they love him.” J.M.M. said she loves her grandparents “very
much” and “she understands that being adopted means that you
have a ‘forever home’ and she wants to be adopted by her
grandparents.” L.R. said she liked living with her aunt D.W. and
she “appeared to be very comfortable in the home.” N.M. said he
was “doing ‘good’” living with D.W. and “he [was] ‘fine’ with
staying with [her] if he [could not] return to his mom.” D.W.
reported N.M. sometimes “display[ed] vindictive behaviors” after
visits and “repeatedly state[d] he want[ed] to go live with his
mother.” D.W., however, believed Mother was “coaching” the
children and she wanted to stop the visits “because she [did] not
believe they [were] helping the children and [were] instead
causing the children to act out emotionally.”3

3
D.W. told a social worker that a monitor ended a visit
between Mother and N.M. when the monitor heard “grown up

8
A September 2023 hearing on whether to terminate
Mother’s parental rights was continued to January 2024. Later
that September, Mother filed the first of two petitions under
Welfare and Institutions Code section 388 to reinstate family
reunification services based on changed circumstances.4 The
juvenile court denied this petition without a hearing, finding
Mother showed neither a change of circumstances nor that
resuming reunification services would promote Minors’ best
interest.
In October 2023, the Department reported that J.N.M. and
J.M.M. were refusing to visit Mother. J.N.M. and J.M.M.
“reportedly ha[d] experienced bed-wetting, misbehaving at school,
and decreased appetite after face to face visits with [M]other.”
J.N.M.’s academic and social skills had improved, but he
“continued to struggle with insomnia, nightmares and being
easily triggered/anxious when past incidents regarding
[M]other . . . [were] discussed.” J.M.M. was enjoying school and
had “improved coping, improved temperament, [and] reduced
deceptive behaviors . . . .” Although N.M. was doing well in
school, he bullied his sister L.R. and said he wanted to leave
home when D.W. disciplined him. A social worker who observed
one of Mother’s visits with N.M. and L.R. remarked that they
“appear[ed] bonded” to her.
In November 2023, Mother filed a second petition asking
the juvenile court to reinstate family reunification services.

talk.” The record does not include any additional details
concerning this incident.
4
Undesignated statutory references that follow are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.

9
Mother argued circumstances had changed because “[s]he
completed an outpatient treatment program, [completed a]
parenting class in May 2022 . . . , continue[d] to participate in
mental health treatment services[,] . . . is in a sober living
program where she is randomly drug tested[,5] . . . [and] [s]he
attends Narcotics Anonymous . . . .” She argued additional
reunification services would be in Minors’ best interest because
she “learned from her services and loves her children. She is
bonded to her children and has not stopped implementing what
she has learned. She works closely with her therapist and
eagerly awaits visits and contact with her kids. Her goal is to be
granted additional reunification and a renewed and narrowly
tailored case plan for her to follow and become a better mother
for her children.” She asked for “more visitation as she’s
struggled with transportation and monitors” and emphasized she
was “permitted to have children live with her in her current
living situation.”
A few days after Mother filed her petition, the Department
notified the juvenile court that J.N.M.’s caregivers hoped to avoid
bringing him to court because “the last time [he] saw [M]other in
[c]ourt, his behaviors and nocturnal bed-wetting increased and
did not subside for [two] months.”

5
Mother submitted a letter from the clinical director of the
sober living program indicating she enrolled in its “self-paid sober
living housing program on May 22, 2023” and, though she did not
receive drug and alcohol treatment services, was still subject to
random drug testing.

10
The juvenile court denied Mother’s second section 388
petition without a hearing on November 9, 2023.6

II. DISCUSSION
The juvenile court did not err in denying Mother’s petition
to reinstate family reunification services. Assuming the evidence
of Mother’s continued sobriety and participation in mental health
treatment amounted to a prima facie showing of changed
circumstances, the court did not abuse its discretion in finding
Mother still failed to show additional reunification services would
be in Minors’ best interest. Minors were doing well in the care of
relatives with whom they had been placed for more than two
years, they had sporadic contact with Mother during this time,
the two oldest children no longer wanted to visit Mother, and the
behavior of the two younger children worsened after visits.
Under the umbrella of Minors’ best interests (i.e., not presented
as a freestanding contention of error), Mother additionally argues
it was in Minors’ best interests to be enrolled in the Cherokee
Nation and had the Department facilitated that earlier, “the case
plan and support for Mother and [Minors] would have been
different and more tailored to this family’s needs.” The argument
is impermissibly speculative and in any event does not
undermine the juvenile court’s discretionary determination of
what is in Minors’ best interests now.7

6
The juvenile court reinstated reunification services for
L.R.’s father, M.R., on the same date.
7
By virtue of the manner in which the argument is raised in
this appeal, nothing we say in this opinion expresses a view on
the merit, if any, of a direct Cal-ICWA challenge to any

11
A. Legal Framework
Section 388 “accords a parent the right to petition the
juvenile court for modification of any of its orders based upon
changed circumstances or new evidence. [Citations.] To obtain
the requested modification, the parent must demonstrate both a
change of circumstance or new evidence, and that the proposed
change is in the best interests of the child. [Citations.]” (In re
Alayah J. (2017) 9 Cal.App.5th 469, 478.) Where, as here,
reunification services have been terminated, “the parents’
interest in the care, custody and companionship of the child are
no longer paramount” and a court considering a child’s best
interest in the context of a section 388 petition “must recognize
this shift of focus . . . .” (In re Stephanie M. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 295,
317; accord Alayah J., supra, at 478; In re K.L. (2016) 248
Cal.App.4th 52, 62.)
The juvenile court may deny a petition under section 388
without holding a hearing if the petitioner fails to make a prima
facie showing as to either element. (In re Christopher L. (2022)
12 Cal.5th 1063, 1080; In re R.F. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 718, 728.)
In deciding whether a prima facie showing has been made, “we
may consider the entire factual and procedural history of the
case.” (In re Daniel F. (2021) 64 Cal.App.5th 701, 711.) Our
review of the juvenile court’s ruling is for abuse of discretion.
(Ibid.; In re R.F., supra, at 728; In re C.J.W. (2007) 157
Cal.App.4th 1075, 1079.)

subsequent orders the juvenile court may have made subsequent
to the order at issue in this appeal.

12
B. The Juvenile Court Did Not Abuse Its Discretion in
Denying Mother’s Section 388 Petition
Although some of the purported changes cited in Mother’s
November 2023 petition pre-date the juvenile court’s May 2023
order terminating family reunification services, we shall assume
for the sake of argument that Mother’s continued sobriety and
participation in mental health services reflect a change in
circumstances. We hold, however, that Mother did not make a
prima facie showing that reinstating family reunification services
would be in Minors’ best interest.
The two older children, J.N.M. and J.M.M., were strongly
bonded with their paternal grandparents after two years of living
with them, they wanted to be adopted, and they no longer wanted
contact with Mother. J.N.M. had refused visits with Mother
since 2022—when Mother told him she would not seek to regain
custody of him—and J.M.M.’s relationship with Mother
deteriorated over time. Mother cites an August 2022 status
review report mentioning, among other things, that she and
J.M.M. enjoyed positive visits and J.M.M. did not feel “normal”
outside her care, but more recent reports detail J.M.M.’s adverse
response to visits with Mother and J.M.M.’s concern that “you
never know what [Mother] will say or do.”8 Mother and J.M.M.

8
Mother also references an observation in the August 2022
report that J.M.M. acted out when J.N.M. discussed his
treatment in Mother’s care. Viewing this evidence in the context
of “the entire factual and procedural history of the case” (In re
Daniel F., supra, 64 Cal.App.5th at 711), J.M.M.’s behavior in
2022 is consistent with her worry in 2023 that Mother expected
her to keep secrets. The point, if anything, therefore appears to

13
had already participated in conjoint counseling, with J.M.M.
reporting that Mother failed to listen to her. There is no evidence
that additional reunification services would benefit J.N.M. and
J.M.M., and ample evidence to the contrary.
The fact that the two younger siblings, N.M. and L.R., had
a more positive relationship and some apparent bond with
Mother does not show that additional reunification services
would be in their best interests. Notwithstanding visits in which
Mother appeared to behave appropriately, there was evidence
that the children’s behavior worsened after visits. But even if the
children’s visits with Mother were unambiguously beneficial, “a
parent’s petition for . . . an order . . . reopening reunification
efforts must establish how such a change will advance the child’s
need for permanency and stability.” (In re J.C. (2014) 226
Cal.App.4th 503, 527.) Mother made no such showing. N.M. and
L.R. had lived with their maternal aunt for more than two
years—since N.M. was five years old and L.R. was two years old.
There were extended periods during which Mother had no contact
with N.M. and L.R.—to the point where, at one visit, the
Department reported N.M. and L.R. did not recognize her.
Further, as of September 2023, L.R. said “she likes living with
her aunt” and N.M. said he was “doing ‘good’” and “‘fine’ staying
with his aunt if he [could not] return to [Mother].” N.M.’s
statements that he wanted to live with Mother were also
disclosed (by his caregiver) in the context of her concerns about
Mother coaching the children.

undermine Mother’s argument that reinstating reunification
services would be in J.M.M.’s best interest.

14
Mother’s related argument that Minors’ eligibility for
membership in the Cherokee Nation shows additional
reunification services would be in their best interest also lacks
merit. Even assuming Mother did not forfeit the point because
she did not raise it in her section 388 petition, her counterfactual
claim that the nature of services provided would have been
different “if [the Department] had done its job and assisted
Mother and the children’s [tribal] enrollment, as ordered, at the
inception of this case” is too speculative; we have no way to know
how services provided after an earlier tribal enrollment would
have changed (if at all) or how the changes might have affected
the children. Even more to the point, the juvenile court was
required to evaluate what was in Minors’ best interests at the
time it ruled (not in the past or at some indefinite point in the
future), and Mother has identified no evidence suggesting a delay
in provision of “culturally appropriate services” contributed to her
inability to make a prima facie showing that providing more
reunification services—which would necessarily put off
permanency planning—would be in Minors’ best interests.

15
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s order is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

BAKER, J.

We concur:

HOFFSTADT, P. J.

KIM (D.), J.

16

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.