Parker v. Ainsworth CA5

CourtListener 10382836Calctapp23.04.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 4/23/25 Parker v. Ainsworth CA5

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

TIFFANY ANN PARKER,
F086739
Appellant,
(Super. Ct. No. BFL-18-003913)
v.

ROBERT HOWARD AINSWORTH, OPINION
Respondent;

KERN COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF CHILD
SUPPORT SERVICES,

Intervener and Respondent.

APPEAL from orders of the Superior Court of Kern County. Cynthia L. Loo,
Judge.
Tiffany A. Parker, in pro. per., for Appellant.
Robert H. Ainsworth, in pro. per., for Respondent.
No appearance for Intervener and Respondent.
-ooOoo-
This appeal involves a dispute by a mother and father over child support
payments. The family court filed an order modifying father’s child support payment
from $1,662.40 to $553.00 per month in December 2021. In June 2023, mother filed
both a request for order and a motion directed at setting aside the order modifying
support. The family court denied both the request and the motion, concluding they were
untimely. The mother appealed. We conclude she has not demonstrated reversible error.
The Family Code1 section 17432 motion to cancel (set aside) support order based
on presumed income was not filed within the one-year period established by section
17432, subdivision (f). That period begins to run when the first collection under the
modified support order occurred. The record shows such a collection occurred in April
2022, more than 14 months before the June 2023 motion was filed. Thus, the family
court correctly determined the section 17432 motion was untimely.
The mother’s request for order setting aside the order modifying support alleged
fraud and perjury. Her reliance of sections 2120, 2121 and 2122 is misplaced because
they address relief from judgments and the order modifying support is not a judgment.
As an order, it is subject to section 3691 and the six-month limitation period that begins
to run after the moving party discovered, or should have discovered, the alleged fraud or
perjury. (§ 3691, subds. (a), (b).) We conclude the delayed discovery provisions in
section 3691 do not extend the six-month filing period because the record before this
court does not establish any oral or written perjury or any fraud affected the December
2021 order modifying child support. Rather, the available evidence supports the family
court’s implied findings that no perjury or fraud occurred.
We therefore affirm the orders.

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Family Code.

2.
FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS
Respondent Robert Ainsworth (Father) was born in the State of Washington,
entered active duty with the Navy in February 2001, and retired 20 years and one month
later. He currently lives in Key West, Florida.
Appellant Tiffany Parker was born in Bakersfield, moved to Hawaii in 2013, and
met Father in 2016 while he was serving in the Navy. In June 2017, their son was born in
Honolulu. Legal proceedings addressing child support and custody have been filed in
Hawaii, California and Florida.
In January 2018, a Hawaii family court approved the parties’ stipulation
addressing custody, visitation, child support, and paternity. The stipulation gave Mother
legal and physical custody of their son, provided Father with reasonable visitation as
agreed by the parties, required Father to provide health insurance coverage, set child
support at $1,662.40 per month, and required Father to mail all payments to the Child
Support Enforcement Agency (Hawaii CSEA) at a post office box in Honolulu.
On August 30, 2018, Mother initiated Kern County Superior Court case No. BFL-
18-003913 by filing a Judicial Council form FL-580 (Registration of Out-of-State
Custody Order) that attached the stipulated custody and support order from the Hawaii
proceeding. Mother filed the form as a self-represented litigant and listed a Bakersfield
address.2

2 To explain why the support order from Hawaii was filed with a court in California,
Mother’s opening brief asserts, at that time, she “continued primarily residing in Hawaii”
and Father was residing at his duty station in San Diego and the order “was placed with
the Kern County Superior Court in the event of visitation issues due to poor
communications between the parties.”
Earlier, in a June 2022 document, Mother stated she gave a copy of the custody
order to the Kern County Superior Court because her brother was her next of kin, he was
a resident there, and if she passed away there would be documentation for him to gain
custody. She also stated Hawaii CSEA continued to enforce the support order, she and

3.
In January 2019, Mother received a letter from the Social Security Administration
stating that Hawaii would pay her Medicare premium beginning December 2018, her
monthly Social Security benefit would be $1,261 per month starting January 2019, and in
January 2020, the amount would increase to $1,282.
In October 2019, Mother filed a motion to modify child support with the Hawaii
family court. Mother asserted Father had rental income from properties located in
Washington and Florida along with pay raises that were not reflected in the stipulated
support order. Mother attended and represented herself at the July 15, 2020 hearing on
the motion. Father was represented by counsel and was not personally present. The
Hawaii family court denied the motion, stating the child support calculation had not
increased by 10 percent from the last ordered support, which had been in effect for less
than three years.
The following six paragraphs contain Kern DCSS’s description of its involvement
with Mother, Father and the Kern County family court matter initiated in August 2018 by
Mother’s registration of the Hawaii custody and support order.
On July 27, 2020 (12 days after the family court in Hawaii denied Mother’s
modification request), Mother submitted an application for services through Kern DCSS
using an address in Bakersfield that requested it to enforce and modify the Hawaii order.
On August 25, 2020, Mother sent Kern DCSS an income and expense declaration with a
Bakersfield address signed and dated by her. On September 8, 2020, a child support
specialist phoned Mother to conduct a case opening interview and left a voice message
asking Mother to return the call. The record contains billing records listing a Lake
Isabella address for Mother and showing the child received vaccinations at Kern Valley
Hospital in November 2020.

her son remained residents of Hawaii, and she did not give a copy of the order to the
Kern County Department of Child Support Services (Kern DCSS) to the Hawaii CSEA.

4.
On December 28, 2020, Mother applied for public benefits through Kern County
reporting an address in Lake Isabella.3 During the application process, Mother provided
a copy of a lease for the Lake Isabella address for the period of September 2020 to
September 2021. Kern DCSS confirmed Mother received benefits between December
2020 and December 2021 and, specifically, that Mother used the benefits in transactions
occurring in Kern County every month from May 2021 to December 2021.
On June 15, 2021 (during the period benefits were used), a Kern DCSS review
showed it had not completed a case opening interview. As a result, one of its child
support specialists sent Mother an e-mail asking her to contact the specialist and provide
information about the support order from Hawaii. Mother sent a reply e-mail stating: “I
do not have a case with Kern County. Thank you.” The next day, the specialist sent an
e-mail stating: “There is an open case, but I will close it.”
In July 2021, Kern DCSS mailed both parties a notice of intent to close its case
that gave September 5, 2021, as the proposed closure date. On August 30, 2021, Father
submitted an online application to Kern DCSS requesting it to open a case. The next day,
Kern DCSS reopened its case and sent Mother an e-mail informing her of the service
request and that a child support specialist would call her to conduct a case opening
interview.
On September 2, 2021, Father spoke with Kern DCSS and asked for a
modification of support based on changes in income and custody. Kern DCSS initiated a
“Review and Adjustment” and requested financial information from the parties. The
review and adjustment packet was mailed to Mother at the Lake Isabella address.

3 Meanwhile, Father retired from the Navy in early 2021 and became a permanent
resident of Florida. The record contains a Florida driver’s license issued to Father in
August 2021 that lists an address on Shore Avenue in Key West, Florida.

5.
Kern DCSS’s Motion to Modify
On September 16, 2021, Kern DCSS filed a notice of motion (1) to intervene in
Kern County Superior Court case No. BFL-18-003913 and (2) to modify the child
support order made by the Hawaii family court. The motion was the first filing in the
court case since 2018, when Mother registered the order and had her court fee waiver
approved.
In the motion, Kern DCSS sought to change the January 2018 order of the Hawaii
family court directing Father to pay child support of $1,662.40 per month. As supporting
facts, Kern DCSS stated: “Motion filed at request of [Father] who asserts there has been
a change in custody with regard to the child in this case, as follows: the [son] is now
residing with [Father]. Additionally, [Father] asserts his income decreased.” Kern DCSS
served Father with a notice to appear at the hearing scheduled for November 8, 2021, and
requested he produce pay stubs for the last 12 months, income tax returns for the last two
years, and a completed income and expense declaration on Judicial Council form FL-150.
(Code Civ. Proc., § 1987.)
On November 3, 2021, Mother filed a response to Kern DCSS’s motion stating
she did not consent to the request to modify child support, Hawaii had jurisdiction over
custody and child support, four years of support had been paid through Hawaii, and the
court should dismiss the case. She asserted she did not request a hearing, Father had lied
to Kern DCSS to escape paying the child support balance owed in Hawaii, she and her
son were not residents of California, Father was a resident of Florida, and Father had
never requested physical custody of his son. To support her claim that Hawaii had
jurisdiction, Mother attached her Hawaii identification card issued in September 2019, a
copy of her son’s birth certificate, and several documents filed in the Hawaii family court
proceeding, including the January 2018 stipulated order regarding custody and support.
The response listed a post office box in Honolulu as Mother’s address.

6.
November 2021 Hearing
On November 8, 2021, the hearing on Kern DCSS’s motion was held. The minute
order for the hearing stated (1) an attorney for Kern DCSS appeared, Father appeared
remotely, and Mother was not present; (2) “[t]he court grants the motion for
modification”; (3) a calculation results summary was attached, incorporated, “and made a
part hereof”; (4) “Petitioner”—that is, Mother—“pays the sum of $553.00 per month for
the support of minor child(ren)”; and (5) “[c]hild support payments shall commence
10/1/2021.” The unsigned minute order included in the clerk’s transcript did not include
any attachment.
The record contains a letter from Kern DCSS to Mother describing telephone
conversations between its staff and Mother that occurred after the hearing. The letter
stated Mother called Kern DCSS on November 8, 2021, because she missed the hearing
and stated no one called her; when asked if she had registered at least one day before the
hearing, Mother stated she had not because she was unaware of the requirement. The
letter also stated Mother called the next day and asked why the support order was
modified without her being present at the hearing and why Kern DCSS believed Father
about custody of their son; Kern DCSS informed Mother that Father stated during the
hearing that he did not have custody and, as a result, the modified support order was
based on zero percent visitation for Father. Mother also asked why imputed income was
used for her when she received Social Security Disability Income and was told the
Family Code provides for the use of imputed income when a participant’s income is
unknown. Mother asked what she would need to do to change the order and was
informed she would need to file her own motion.
The letter also described a telephone call made by Mother on November 18, 2021,
to ask about the payment status because she had not received payments. The letter stated
Kern DCSS verified that it “did not have a valid mailing address for [Mother].”

7.
On December 15, 2021, the commissioner signed and filed the order after hearing
on Judicial Council form FL-687 that had been prepared by Kern DCSS’s counsel.
Correcting the minute order, the order stated the respondent (i.e., Father) was the parent
ordered to pay support and attached a “Guideline Calculation Results Summary” stating:
“ROBERT AINSWORTH is required to pay TIFFANY A PARKER $553.00 in
CURRENT SUPPORT.” The attachment listed the “Average % Time with NCP” (i.e.,
Father) as zero. The order directed the payments be made to Mother beginning October
1, 2021.
In December 2021, Kern DCSS contacted Hawaii CSEA and determined both
agencies were enforcing a child support order for the period beginning September 1,
2021. Kern DCSS also determined its involvement should end as both parties had moved
out of California. Later that day, Kern DCSS attempted to contact Mother by telephone,
was unable to leave a message, and mailed her a letter explaining it would be closing its
case.
On January 31, 2022, Kern DCSS telephoned Mother and informed her that (1) it
needed to review its case further to determine whether the funds on hold for support
could be disbursed to Mother; (2) it was aware Hawaii CSEA was also collecting and
distributing child support payments for the time Kern DCSS case had been open; and (3)
it would be closing its case and allowing Hawaii CSEA to continue to provide
enforcement.
On February 28, 2022, Mother obtained a Florida driver’s license that listed an
address in Key Largo, Florida. During that month, Hawaii CSEA mailed information
about the account balance to her at a post office box in Key West, Florida. One report
showed Hawaii CSEA received a payment of $1,093.42 in September 2021, the next
payment was in the same amount and was received in December 2021, and Hawaii CSEA
believed the obligation owed was about $5,600.

8.
In February and March 2022, Mother telephoned Kern DCSS to ask the status of
payment and each time was informed the agency was still reviewing the case to
determine if the funds on hold could be disbursed to her. Kern DCSS contacted Hawaii
CSEA to ask for a payment record to ensure against overpayment. Kern DCSS was
informed Hawaii CSEA was enforcing the original Hawaii support order and that agency
was unsure if the California order setting support at $553 per month was valid. Kern
DCSS asserted its position that California has continuous exclusive jurisdiction to modify
the Hawaii order because the parties no longer resided in Hawaii.
A few days later, a staff attorney for Hawaii CSEA telephoned Kern DCSS and
said that Hawaii would not honor the California order. The agencies exchanged further
information and Kern DCSS asked for a proposed calculation of arrears as if Hawaii had
been enforcing the California modification order instead of the Hawaii order. Kern
DCSS placed a hold on funds to keep the money from being disbursed until a court
determined the arrears.
On March 28, 2022, Mother again telephoned Kern DCSS about the funds on hold
and was informed the case was being reviewed by the agency’s legal department. The
next day, Kern DCSS informed Mother it would file a motion to determine jurisdiction.
Mother again asked why a case was opened in Kern County when she was not a resident
there and she was told she had registered the Hawaii order in Kern County in 2018 in the
event Father had tried to violate the custody provisions during a visit made while he was
stationed in San Diego. The agency also stated all it could do was wait for a decision on
its motion to determine which state had jurisdiction.
Kern DCSS’s Motion
In May 2022, about five months after it obtained the modification order, Kern
DCSS filed a notice of motion requesting the family court to determine the validity of the
California order, determine the arrearage balance, and set a reasonable payment schedule
for the arrears. Addressing the dispute with Mother as to where she resided when the

9.
modification order was made, Kern DCSS’s moving papers asserted that in March 2022,
it “received additional confirmation that [Mother] did in fact reside at the Lake Isabella
address in 2021.” Addressing the amount of arrears, Kern DCSS prepared and attached
two calculations containing Father’s payment history and how those payments applied to
the support obligation in the Hawaii order and the California order. The calculations
showed that under the California order, Father had an overpayment of about $52. In
comparison Father owed a balance of about $7,714 if the Hawaii order remained in
effect.
On June 17, 2022, Mother filed a response (form FL-685) to Kern DCSS’s motion.
Mother acknowledged that in 2018 she had registered the Hawaii order in Kern County,
had taken her son to visit Father in San Diego, but she and her son remained residents of
Hawaii during the time they were travelling. Addressing the dispute about where she
resided in 2021 when the Kern DCSS filed its motion to modify support, Mother attached
a copy of (1) a residential rental agreement listing her and a man as the tenants of a three-
bedroom condominium in Honolulu for a term running from December 2020 through the
end of December 2021, and (2) letters dated 2021 from the State of Hawaii sent to her
post office box in Honolulu.
Hearing and Order
On June 28, 2022, a hearing was held on Kern DCSS’s motion to determine the
validity of the order modifying support and to determine arrears. Mother and Father
appeared remotely. An attorney for DCSS appeared. There was no court reporter at the
hearing. The court found its order modifying support valid and enforceable and Father
had an overpayment of $52. The order after hearing prepared by Kern DCSS’s counsel
was signed and filed by the commissioner on August 4, 2022.4

4 On July 11, 2022, Kern DCSS closed its case. A November 28, 2022 letter from
Kern DCSS to Mother at her Frostproof address stated: “Per review of the case

10.
Florida Proceedings
On June 29, 2022, the day after the hearing on Kern DCSS’s motion, Mother filed
a petition to domesticate and enforce out-of-state custody decree in case No. 2022DR-
005397 before the court in Polk County, Florida. On June 30, 2022, Mother filed a
petition for protection against domestic violence against Father; that proceeding was
assigned case No. 22-DR-005445. In July 2022, in the first Florida case, Mother filed a
supplemental petition to modify parental responsibility regarding visitation, timesharing,
or a parenting plan.
On August 1, 2022, in the first Florida case, Father filed a petition to establish
parental responsibility, timesharing, child support, and other related relief. The petition
alleged (1) Mother had dropped their son off at Father’s residence on July 16, 2022,
pounded on the door, and was speeding away when Father opened the door; (2) the child
was presently residing with Father; (3) the previous day, Mother had not attended a
hearing on her domestic violence petition; and (4) the child was unsafe in the
unsupervised care of Mother.5
On October 6, 2022, a mediation involving Mother, Father, and his counsel was
held. Mother and Father’s counsel signed a mediated settlement agreement that stated the
parties agreed “to reserve on child support for final determination by the Court,” and
agreed to Father having 165 overnights with the child. A parenting plan was attached. A
Frostproof, Florida address was listed for Mother and a Key West, Florida address for

financials, it appears no child support payments were ever issued to you through our
office.”
5 On August 11, 2022, Mother taken into custody by the Polk County Sheriff’s
Office at her son’s elementary school based on a warrant issued in Monroe County,
Florida. The Monroe County case charged her with cyberstalking Father. When the
Department of Children and Families telephoned Father, he stated he was not coming to
pick up the child. In January 2023, an assistant state attorney filed a nolle prosequi in the
Monroe County case stating admissible evidence did not allow for a conviction.

11.
Father. Father did not sign the settlement agreement or the parenting plan. A week later,
the Florida court granted the motion to withdraw filed by Father’s counsel.
On October 20, 2022, Father contacted the police and expressed his concern about
having heard Mother was driving on a suspended license with their son in the car. On
November 12, 2022, Father contacted the police with questions about a temporary
injunction he had obtained against Mother but had yet to be served. The temporary
injunction was served later that day. On November 14, 2022, Father called the police
with questions about catching Mother driving with their son in the car while her license
was suspended and said he had pictures of her driving. He was informed a police officer
needed to see Mother driving before action could be taken.
At a January 11, 2023 status conference before the Florida court, Father withdrew
his petition regarding timesharing, child support, and other relief. The court’s order
noted that Mother’s petitions filed in June and July of 2022 remained pending and a final
hearing would be scheduled on those petitions.
On March 15, 2023, Father appeared in Monroe County, Florida case No. 2022-
DR-627-K. He had obtained a temporary injunction for protection against domestic
violence in that case and requested the action be voluntarily dismissed. The court
dismissed the case without prejudice.
Father’s Disability Benefits
Kern DCSS’s September 2021 motion to modify child support was based on
Father having taxable income of $2,378 per month and Mother having earned income,
based on California’s minimum wage, of $2,253 per month. Father’s figure reflected his
retirement pay without disability benefits.
In September 2022, Father filed a family law financial affidavit in the Florida
custody and support case stating his monthly retirement pay was $2,513 and his monthly
disability benefit was $2,116.85. In February 2023, he updated this information by filing

12.
an affidavit stating his monthly retirement pay was $2,731 and his month disability
benefit was $4,317.
These monthly figures were supported by a February 17, 2023 retiree account
statement provided to Father indicating his retirement pay was $2,731 per month and by a
March 2, 2023 letter from the Department of Veteran Affairs (VA) summarizing his
benefits from the VA. The letter stated (1) the character of Father’s service was
honorable; he had a service-connected disability that caused him to be considered totally
and permanently disabled; he was being paid monthly at the 100 percent rate because he
was unemployable due to the disabilities; and the effective date of the last change in his
current award was December 1, 2022. The letter also stated the effective date of Father’s
total and permanent disability was March 9, 2022, and his current monthly benefit was
$4,317.79.
On May 24, 2023, Mother sent Father an e-mail asking “[w]hen was the first time
you began receiving any sort of disability income?” Father responded: “I received my
first disability payment at a low rate (I can’t see it) on November 1st 2021. I didn’t
receive payment until later. [¶] I received retirement pay before that which was filed in
the CA court.” This exchange of e-mails figures prominently in Mother’s claim that
Father committed fraud and perjury in connection with the November 8, 2021 hearing in
the Kern County proceeding.
Mother’s Motions for Relief
On June 7, 2023, Mother filed a request for order (Judicial Council form FL-300)
seeking to vacate the order modifying child support made at the November 8, 2021
hearing. Mother asserted Kern DCSS failed to discover both parties’ real income, stating
Farther was receiving disability benefits at the time and she had no earned wages, only
Social Security Disability Insurance payments as income. Mother alleged Father
committed perjury to obtain the modification hearing.

13.
On June 23, 2023, Mother filed a notice and motion to cancel (set aside) support
order based on presumed income (Judicial Council form FL-640). Mother asserted her
monthly disability income in 2021 was $1,298 and she had no other income, and she
estimated Father’s monthly income in 2021 at $6,416. Both the request for order and the
motion listed a Frostproof, Florida address for Mother.
Father filed a responsive declaration to request for order (Judicial Council form
FL-320) stating he did not consent to the order requested. The declaration stated Father
was making a special appearance to challenge jurisdiction and asserted Florida had
exclusive jurisdiction over child support because Mother and the child had been residing
in Florida since February 2022 and he had been a permanent resident of Florida since
January 2021. The declaration also included the case number of the Polk County, Florida
case Mother initiated in June 2022 to enforce child support.
Kern DCSS also filed a responsive declaration to request for order (Judicial
Council form FL-320) stating it did not consent to the order requested. It asserted the
request and motion should be denied because of res judicata and the time to rehear or
appeal the order made on November 8, 2021, had lapsed. Kern DCSS argued the validity
of that order was the subject of it notice motion, which was heard on June 28, 2022, and
attended by Mother, Father and Kern DCSS.
Order and Appeal
On July 20, 2023, the hearing on Mother’s motions was held. The minute order
for the hearing stated (1) an attorney for Kern DCSS was present and Father and Mother
appeared by telephone; (2) no court reporter was present; and (3) the motions were
denied with prejudice.
On July 31, 2023, the commissioner signed and filed an order after hearing
(Judicial Council form FL-687) prepared by counsel for Kern DCSS. The order stated
Mother’s motions filed June 7, 2023, and June 23, 2023, were denied with prejudice and
“[t]he court finds the requests to set aside were untimely under the applicable statutes.”

14.
Mother filed a timely appeal on August 18, 2023, that listed an address in Frostproof,
Florida.
Because there was no court reporter at the July 2023 hearing, Mother filed a
proposed settled statement with the superior court. The family court determined
corrections were required and ordered Mother to prepare, serve, and file a modified
settled statement. On November 1, 2023, Kern DCSS filed a proposed settled statement
summarizing the proceedings at the July 2023 hearing. In March 2024, Mother filed an
amended settled statement, attachments and exhibits totaling 321 pages. Kern DCSS
filed a response requesting changes and asserting the amended proposed settled statement
did not comply with applicable rules. The family court again ordered corrections and
directed Mother to comply with its earlier order.
In May 2024, the family court issued an order stating Mother did not file a second
amended proposed settled statement and, therefore, the record of oral proceedings would
be Kern DCSS’s proposed settled statement filed November 1, 2023.
Mother’s amended proposed settled statement included a copy of an order closing
case filed in Polk County, Florida case No. 2022DR-005397 in March 2024. The order
stated Father testified that Mother and the child had moved to California, the Florida
court had no jurisdiction to order the California court to do anything, the action would be
dismissed with prejudice, and the clerk of court was directed to close the matter.
DISCUSSION
I. BASIC PRINCIPLES OF APPELLATE REVIEW
In Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, the California Supreme Court stated “it
is a fundamental principle of appellate procedure that a trial court judgment is ordinarily
presumed to be correct and the burden is on an appellant to demonstrate, on the basis of
the record presented to the appellate court, that the trial court committed an error that
justifies reversal of the judgment. [Citations.] ‘This is not only a general principle of

15.
appellate practice but an ingredient of the constitutional doctrine of reversible error.’ ”
(Id. at pp. 608–609; see Cal. Const., art. VI, § 13; Code Civ. Proc., § 475 [“There shall be
no presumption that error is prejudicial”].)
Pursuant to the presumption of correctness, the reviewing court must indulge all
intendments and presumptions that support the trial court’s order. (Denham v. Superior
Court (1970) 2 Cal.3d 557, 564.) Thus, when an order is silent on a particular question,
the reviewing court presumes the trial court decided the matter in a way that supports the
order. (Ibid.) When there are disputed issues of fact, the reviewing court interprets the
trial court’s decision to include implied findings of fact that are favorable to the order,
provided such findings are supported by substantial evidence. (In re Marriage of
Arceneaux (1990) 51 Cal.3d 1130, 1133; see Fladeboe v. American Isuzu Motors Inc.
(2007) 150 Cal.App.4th 42, 58.)
We apply the abuse of discretion standard of appellate review when considering a
family court’s ruling under section 2122 or 3691. (In re Marriage of Rosevear (1998) 65
Cal.App.4th 673, 682 [§ 2122]; In re Marriage of Zimmerman (2010) 183 Cal.App.4th
900, 906 [§ 3691] (Zimmerman).) “The abuse of discretion standard is not a unified
standard; the deference it calls for varies according to the aspect of a trial court’s ruling
under review. The trial court’s findings of fact are reviewed for substantial evidence, its
conclusions of law are reviewed de novo, and its application of the law to the facts is
reversible only if arbitrary and capricious.” (Haraguchi v. Superior Court (2008) 43
Cal.4th 706, 711–712, fns. omitted; see In re Marriage of Hein (2020) 52 Cal.App.5th
519, 529; County of Kern v. T.C.E.F., Inc. (2016) 246 Cal.App.4th 301, 316 [abuse of
discretion standard does not allow trial courts to apply incorrect rule of law or make
factual findings that are not supported by substantial evidence].)

16.
II. MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM SUPPORT BASED ON PRESUMED INCOME
Section 17432 authorizes relief from the part of a judgment or order concerning
the amount of child support when that amount is based upon presumed income.
(§ 17432, subds. (a), (b).) The statute’s timeliness provision states: “A motion for relief
under this section shall be filed within one year of the first collection of money by the
local child support agency or the obligee. The one-year time period shall run from the
date that the local child support agency receives the first collection.” (§ 17432, subd. (f).)
Mother’s section 17432 motion using Judicial Council form FL-640 was filed on
June 23, 2023. Consequently, if the local child support agency received the first
collection of the modified support payment of $553 more than one year earlier (i.e.,
before June 23, 2022), Mother’s motion would have been filed too late.
The clerk’s transcript contains a month-to-month transaction summary showing a
$553 support payment was received by Hawaii CSEA in April 2022. The summary was
attached as an exhibit to Kern DCSS’s May 2022 motion to determine the validity of the
November 8, 2021 order modifying support. The summary constitutes substantial
evidence supporting the family court’s implied factual finding that the motion was not
brought within one year of the date the first modified support payment was received.
Therefore, we conclude the family court did not commit factual err when it determined
Mother’s section 17432 motion to set aside support based on presumed income was
untimely.
Next, we consider whether the family court committed legal error by
misinterpreting the statute. Mother’s opening brief asserts that, in a letter dated
November 28, 2022, Kern DCSS conceded no payment ever circulated through
California. This assertion implies that Hawaii CSEA is not “the local child support
agency” for purposes of section 17432, subdivision (f) and, therefore, any collection
received by it is irrelevant to application of the statute. Stated another way, Mother
implies that only Kern DCSS qualifies as the local child support agency. Mother,

17.
however, has not presented any argument or cited any legal authority to support this
interpretation of the statute. Consequently, she has failed to affirmatively demonstrate
the family court erred when it interpreted the statute more broadly. (See Jameson v.
Desta, supra, 5 Cal.5th at p. 609 [appellant has the burden of demonstrating “the trial
court committed an error that justifies reversal”].)
Moreover, we conclude interpreting the phrase “the local child support agency”
(§ 17432, subd. (f)) to include Hawaii CSEA is consistent with the principle that courts
must give statutes a reasonable and commonsense interpretation. (In re Reeves (2005) 35
Cal.4th 765, 771, fn. 9.) At a minimum, Mother had notice of Hawaii CSEA had
received the modified amount of support by May 2022 when she was served with a copy
of Kern DCSS’s motion to determine the validity of the support modification order.
After service of Kern DCSS’s motion, Mother waited approximately 13 months before
filing her section 17432 motion. Interpreting the statute to exclude the agency of another
state receiving the modified payment when the moving party is aware of that collection
activity would mean the filing period is open ended in those circumstances and allow the
moving party to unreasonably delay seeking relief. (See § 17432, subd. (f).) Therefore,
we conclude the family court did not misinterpret section 17432 when it implied
determined Hawaii CSEA qualified as the “the local child support agency” (§ 17432,
subd. (f)) and, as a result, Mother’s motion to set aside support based on presumed
income was untimely.
III. REQUEST TO SET ASIDE MODIFICATION OF SUPPORT ORDER
Mother also contends the family court erred when it denied as untimely her June 7,
2023 request for order to set aside or vacate the family court’s order modifying child
support. The modification order was made orally at the November 8, 2021 hearing,
included in the minute order for the hearing, and formalized in the Judicial Council form
FL-687 filed on December 15, 2021.

18.
A. Code of Civil Procedure Section 473
On appeal, Mother cites sections 2120, 2122, and 3691 and does not argue she is
entitled to relief under the discretionary provision in Code of Civil Procedure section 473,
subdivision (b). Nonetheless, because her moving papers, section 2121, subdivision (a),
and section 3690, subdivision (a) refer to Code of Civil Procedure section 473, we briefly
explain why relief is not available under Code of Civil Procedure section 473,
subdivision (b) to provide context for our discussion of the Family Code provisions for
relief.
Code of Civil Procedure section 473, subdivision (b) provides that a “court may,
upon any terms as may be just, relieve a party or his or her legal representative from a
judgment, dismissal, order, or other proceeding taken against him or her through his or
her mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable neglect.” (See Zamora v. Clayborn
Contracting Group, Inc. (2002) 28 Cal.4th 249, 257 [statute grants discretionary
authority to the trial court].) To obtain relief, the application must “be made within a
reasonable time, in no case exceeding six months, after the … order … was taken.”
(§ 473, subd. (b).)
Here, Mother’s June 7, 2023 request to set aside the modification order was filed
more than one year and five months after the order was filed on December 15, 2021.
Consequently, the request was made outside the statute’s six-month period when Mother
was no longer eligible for relief under Code of Civil Procedure section 473, subdivision
(b).
B. Sections 2121 and 2122 and Relief from a Judgment
Mother’s opening brief quotes the legislative findings and declarations in section
2120 and along with parts of section 2122.
In section 2120, subdivision (a), the Legislature declared that “California has a
strong policy … of providing for fair and sufficient child … support awards” and that
policy goal could only be implemented through full disclosure of financial information in

19.
accordance with sections 2100 through 2113. The Legislature also found and declared
that “[i]t occasionally happens that … the award of support, whether made as a result of
agreement or trial, is inequitable when made due to the nondisclosure or other
misconduct of one of the parties.” (§ 2120, subd. (b).)
Relief from certain support awards is authorized by section 2121, subdivision (a),
which provides in full:

“In proceedings for dissolution of marriage, for nullity of marriage, or for
legal separation of the parties, the court may, on any terms that may be just,
relieve a spouse from a judgment, or any part or parts thereof, adjudicating
support or division of property, after the six-month time limit of Section
473 of the Code of Civil Procedure has run, based on the grounds, and
within the time limits, provided in this chapter.” (Italics added.)
Section 2122 sets forth “[t]he grounds and time limits for a motion to set aside a
judgment, or any part or parts thereof.” (Italics added.) The grounds include actual
fraud, perjury, duress, mental incapacity, and a failure to comply with statutory disclosure
requirements. (§ 2122, subds. (a), (b), (c), (d), (f).) The limitations period for motions
based on actual fraud or perjury are “one year after the date on which the complaining
party either did discover, or should have discovered,” the fraud or perjury. (§ 2122, subd.
(a), (b).)
The first issue we consider involves the phrase “a judgment, or any parts thereof”
that appears in both section 2121, subdivision (a) and section 2122 and how that phrase
applies to the facts of this case. Specifically, we consider whether Mother is seeking
relief from or “judgment” or any part of a judgment.
This question was addressed in Zimmerman, supra, 183 Cal.App.4th 900, when
the petitioner argued that the one-year limitations period in section 2122 applied to her
request to set aside child support orders allegedly obtained by fraud. (Id. at p. 905.) The
appellate court rejected the argument because section 2122 applies to a motion to set
aside a judgment and the petitioner’s motion sought to set aside a support order. As a

20.
result, the court concluded the motion was governed by section 3691, subdivision (b) and
its six-month limitations period. (Zimmerman, supra, at p. 910.)
Based on Zimmerman and the plain meaning of the word “judgment” used in
sections 2121 and 2122, we conclude Mother’s request for relief from the order
modifying child support is not governed by sections 2121 and 2122 and the one-year
limitations period. Instead, the timeliness of the request must be determined under
section 3691 and its shorter limitations period. (Zimmerman, supra, 183 Cal.App.4th at
p. 910.)
C. Relief from a Support Order under Section 3691
1. Relevant Statutory Text
In the Child Support Enforcement Fairness Act of 2000, the Legislature declared,
“[t]he efficient and fair enforcement of child support orders is essential to ensuring
compliance with those orders and respect for the administration of justice.” (Stats. 1999,
ch. 653, §§ 1, subds. (a), (b)(1).) Among other things, the act addressed relief from
certain support orders by adding sections 3690 through 3693 to the Family Code. (Stats.
1999, ch. 653, § 6.)
Section 3690, subdivision (a) provides that the family “court may, on any terms
that may be just, relieve a party from a support order, or any part or parts thereof, after
the six-month time limit of Section 473 of the Code of Civil Procedure has run, based on
the grounds, and within the time limits, provided in this article.” Section 3691 provides
in part:

“The grounds and time limits for an action or motion to set aside a support
order, or part thereof, are governed by this section and shall be one of the
following:

“(a) Actual fraud. Where the defrauded party was kept in ignorance or in
some other manner, other than through the party’s own lack of care or
attention, was fraudulently prevented from fully participating in the
proceeding. An action or motion based on fraud shall be brought within six

21.
months after the date on which the complaining party discovered or
reasonably should have discovered the fraud.

“(b) Perjury. An action or motion based on perjury shall be brought within
six months after the date on which the complaining party discovered or
reasonably should have discovered the perjury.”
Subdivision (c) of section 3691 addresses a lack of notice that results in a default
or default judgment and, thus, is not applicable to the modification order challenged in
this appeal. Mother bases her claim for relief under section 3691 on both fraud and
perjury.
2. Perjury Has Not Been Established
California’s definition of perjury provides that “every person who testifies,
declares, deposes, or certifies under penalty of perjury in any of the cases in which the
testimony, declarations, depositions, or certification is permitted by law of the State of
California under penalty of perjury and willfully states as true any material matter which
he or she knows to be false, is guilty of perjury.” (Pen. Code, § 118, subd. (a).) Penal
Code section 124 states: “The making of a ... certificate is deemed to be complete ... from
the time when it is delivered by the accused to any other person, with the intent that it be
uttered or published as true.”
Our analysis of Mother’s perjury claim is divided into two parts. The first
addresses perjured testimony—that is, a false oral statement given under oath. The
second addresses false written statements given in a declaration or certificate.
Mother has not established perjured testimony was presented at the November 8,
2021 hearing. The minute order from the hearing does not state any person was sworn or
testified. No court reporter was present at the hearing and, as a result, there is no
reporter’s transcript showing any testimony was given at the hearing. Also, there is no
agreed statement or settled statement of the oral proceedings that occurred at the hearing.
(See Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.134 [agreed statement], 8.137 [settled statement].)
Because the appellate record does not contain any testimony presented at the hearing, it is

22.
not possible for this court to conclude any testimony was tainted by perjury. In short,
Mother has not carried her burden as the appellant of affirmatively demonstrating
perjured testimony was a basis for the family court’s order modifying support. (See
Jameson v. Desta, supra, 5 Cal.5th at p. 609 [appellant’s burden].)
In addition, Mother has not established that a declaration or certificate affecting
the modification order contained a false statement that qualifies as perjury. Mother’s
opening brief refers to “Father’s application for services and income/address information
provided [to Kern DCSS] under perjury in 2021 which prompted” Kern DCSS to move
for modification of child support. She contends an attorney for Kern DCSS “admitted to
obstruction of justice by the agency destroying” that application and information. She
supports this contention by referring to the position statement served by Kern DCSS on
January 17, 2024, which stated:

“On August 31, 2021, KCDCSS reopened the case at the request of
[Father]. The [Mother] was notified by phone call of the case reopening.
KCDCSS’s staff member was having difficulty in uploading [Father’s]
application for services into CSE and it was inadvertently not saved.
However, the information was set forth in a contemporaneous business note
entry (ALE) in the KCDCSS case management system (CSE).”
The position statement asserted Father’s application listed Mother’s Lake Isabella
address, not the Bakersfield post office box she had provided Kern DCSS, and listed a
Key West address for himself.
Without a document signed by Father under penalty of perjury, we cannot
determine whether Father made a false statement of fact that was both material to the
proceedings and was known by him to be false. Furthermore, assuming the position
statement accurately described the information Father gave Kern DCSS about his address
and Mother’s address, the record supports Father having a Key West address at that time.
Father’s July 2023 declaration states he has been a permanent resident of Florida since
January 2021. Also, the record contains a photocopy of a Florida driver’s license issued

23.
to Father in August 2021, which lists an address in Key West. Thus, it appears Father
gave Kern DCSS accurate information about his address. As to Mother’s address at that
time, the record contains conflicting information, which prevents us from concluding the
Lake Isabella address was wrong and, moreover, was known by Father to be an incorrect
address. Similarly, on the issues of custody and income, without a document signed by
Father, it is not possible to conclude he committed perjury on those matters in a
declaration or certificate.
To summarize, Mother has not shown the order modifying support should have
been set aside due to perjured testimony or a perjured declaration. (§ 3691, subd. (b).)
3. Actual Fraud
Mother’s theory of fraud and the timeliness of her request for relief under section
3691 asserts Kern DCSS and Father were in sole possession of information about his VA
disability award and the dates of payment; Father did not disclose proof of the VA
disability award until March 2023; and in a May 24, 2023 e-mail, Father admitted he
received his first disability payment on November 1, 2021, which was before the
modification hearing on November 8, 2021. Mother claims these facts establish Father
engaged in fraud to obtain the order modifying support.
According to the settled statement approved by the family court, at the July 20,
2023 hearing, Father denied he had engaged in fraud and stated he had provided all his
income information to Kern DCSS before the November 8, 2022 hearing. Father’s
respondent’s brief asserts the dates given in his e-mail were estimates; he provided
Mother with a copy of a November 15, 2021 letter from the VA indicating he was
eligible for back pay; and the VA then paid him for his months of eligibility that preceded
the letter. In sum, Father contends his initial disability benefit from the VA was paid
retroactively after the November 8, 2022 hearing.

24.
The parties’ arguments required the family court to interpret the e-mails
exchanged on May 24, 2023. Father’s e-mail stated in part:

“I received my first disability payment at a low rate (I can’t see it) on
November 1st, 2021. I didn’t receive payment until later. [¶] I received
retirement pay before that[,] which was filed with the CA court.”
The first two sentence of Father’s e-mail are ambiguous about the date he
“received” payment of his first disability payment. The first says the payment was
received on November 1, 2021. The second says the payment was not received until
later. As a result, the family court had to resolve this contradiction. Based on the
presumption of correctness and the related doctrine of implied findings, we must
conclude the court found the first disability payment was attributed to an earlier period
and that payment was made retroactively. In other words, the court found Father did not
gain possession of the first payment of a disability benefit until after the November 8,
2021 hearing.
Because the evidence in the appellate record does not compel a finding that Father
actually received disability benefits before the November 8, 2021 hearing, we are
required by the rules of appellate procedure to accept the family court’s implied
interpretation of the ambiguous email. (See Denham v. Superior Court, supra, 2 Cal.3d
at p. 564; Fladeboe v. American Isuzu Motors Inc., supra, 150 Cal.App.4th at p. 58.) As
a result, Mother has not demonstrated Father committed fraud that would delay in the
start of the six-month period specified in section 3691, subdivision (a). It follows that the
family court correctly determined Mother’s June 2023 request for relief from the
December 2021 order modifying support was untimely.
DISPOSITION
The orders denying appellant’s request for order and her section 17432 motion are
affirmed. Respondent shall recover his costs on appeal.

25.
FRANSON, J.
WE CONCUR:

LEVY, Acting P. J.

SNAUFFER, J.

26.

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.