CourtListener 10382020•In re Mason M. CA2/2
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 4/21/25 In re Mason M. CA2/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION TWO
In re MASON M., a Person B335671
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No.
23CCJP01443A)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
V.C.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County. Stephen C. Marpet, Judge Pro Tempore.
Affirmed.
Elizabeth Klippi, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Veronica Randazzo, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
__________________________________________
In this juvenile dependency appeal, V.C. (mother)
challenges the juvenile court’s order continuing its jurisdiction
over her minor son, Mason M. (son). Mother argues the court
erred when it denied her request to terminate its jurisdiction at a
March 2024 review hearing. Mother claims substantial evidence
did not support the court’s order to keep the case open. We find
no error and affirm.
BACKGROUND
1. The Family and Previous Referrals
Mother and A.M. (father) are the parents of son. Although
mother and father lived together for approximately one year, they
are no longer in a relationship and father has had little contact
with son. Father is not a party to this appeal.
Prior to the underlying proceedings, the family had been
the subject of three earlier referrals to the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (Department). In
2017, soon after son was born, the Department filed a Welfare
and Institutions Code section 300 petition on behalf of son
alleging son was at risk due to mother and father’s domestic
violence and father’s substance abuse.1 Those proceedings
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2
resulted in a January 2018 custody order granting mother sole
legal and physical custody of son.
In September 2022, a referral was made alleging mother
behaved strangely, as if she was using drugs or had a mental
health issue, and hit and pushed son. Again, in late January
2023, a referral was made claiming mother physically abused
son. The Department closed both of those referrals as
inconclusive.
2. Events Preceding Petition
In early April 2023, two months after the latest referral,
the Department received a new referral alleging mother was
physically and verbally abusive toward son during a telehealth
session. The Department opened an investigation.
A Department social worker spoke with mother. Mother
insisted that son always be in her view, even when he was in
another room. Throughout the interview, mother tapped her
legs, looked back and forth to son and the social worker. Mother
told the social worker she disciplined son with warnings and time
outs. She said sometimes, but not often, she spanked him with
her hand on his buttocks. Any scratches were accidental. Mother
reported she was “super overprotective” of son and, although she
believed staff at his school was supportive, she feared for son’s
safety and admitted having a hard time leaving him at school.
Mother stated she was not perfect and was “strict” with son
because she wanted him “to be a good child.”
Mother stated she took medication both “for [posttraumatic
stress syndrome (PTSD)] due to her past relationship with . . .
father in which she was a victim of domestic violence” as well as
“for her thyroid.” She said she also had attention deficiency but
it was not clear if she took medication for that. Mother said she
3
had never done drugs and did not drink alcohol. At first, mother
said she was willing to drug test because she had nothing to hide,
but later declined to drug test because she did not want to expose
son to more strangers and “that type of environment.” Mother
reported she had been in therapy but was “taking a break.”
During an interview one week later, mother stated she had an
upcoming therapy session.
Mother believed her family was unsupportive, was mean to
her, and had “unstable behavior.” She said father’s family also
was not supportive. She noted her grandmother, son’s great
grandmother (great grandmother), lived in the “front house” on
the same property as her. Mother said great grandmother was
aggressive toward her and did not respect her privacy. Mother
stated she had no friends and no social life. She focused “solely
on caring for [son].” According to mother, her “only free time”
was when son was at school.
During her interview, mother became upset with the social
worker. Mother believed the social worker “was smirking,” “was
on drugs and was a bad person.” After the social worker
apologized for offending mother and stated she was on mother’s
team, mother again became extremely nice and complimented the
social worker.
Mother told the social worker she had married a few
months earlier in December 2022. Mother said she was not living
with her husband due to financial reasons, did not see him often,
and initially refused to provide any information about him.
Eventually, however, mother provided her husband’s name and
phone number.
4
The social worker tried to interview son the same day she
interviewed mother, but son refused to speak. One week later, a
social worker again unsuccessfully tried to interview son.
The Department social worker spoke with father, who had
not seen son for about five months. Father said he had no contact
with mother or son. Father told the social worker mother
behaved strangely, seemed paranoid, and was overprotective of
son. Father was not able to care for son at the time.
The social worker also spoke with great grandmother, who
lived in a separate house on the same property as mother and
son. Great grandmother was angry with the Department for not
having taken steps to help son earlier. She believed “something
dramatic needed to happen such as the child dying in order for
[the Department] to do something.” She heard son crying all the
time and had seen scratches and bruises on his body. She said
mother had no patience and threatened son “not to say anything.”
Great grandmother told the social worker mother did not allow
son to play outside and sometimes “gets in her moods.” Great
grandmother believed mother used drugs and might be bipolar.
One week later, great grandmother told a Department social
worker mother and son had not left the house for a few days. She
was worried for son and believed mother was “unwell.”
Maternal grandmother also spoke with the social worker.
Maternal grandmother believed mother had mental health
issues. Maternal grandmother stated mother was “special,”
“easily offended,” “gets mad fast,” and was “unable to hold a job.”
She said mother was not close to her family and did not want
their help. Maternal grandmother also believed mother used to,
and perhaps still did, take drugs, which caused her to
hallucinate. Maternal grandmother said mother had “a very
5
strong influence on” son, was protective of him, and coached him
on what to say. Maternal grandmother was worried about
mother and son, said she would “always be there to support”
mother, and was willing to care for son.
The social worker also spoke with a paternal aunt.
Paternal aunt believed son had “a weird attachment to” mother
and said mother “always talks over” son and “does not allow the
child to speak his mind.” Paternal aunt told the social worker
mother “goes through phases where she hates everyone and
disappears.” Paternal aunt said “the family” thought mother was
on drugs and was mentally unstable. Paternal aunt believed
mother loved son, treated him like a baby, verbally abused him,
and possibly told him what to say and do. According to paternal
aunt, mother did not allow son to interact with anyone unless she
was present. Paternal aunt did not spend time alone with son
because she feared mother would accuse her of harming him.
Paternal aunt stated mother’s family was very supportive and
wanted to help mother.
A Department social worker spoke with the principal of
son’s elementary school. The principal reported son was well
behaved at school. The principal was concerned about mother.
The principal stated mother came to the school “on a daily basis
and insists on going to the classroom to drop off [son’s] lunch, and
cupcakes, even when there is no special occasion.” The principal
had to alert school staff not to allow mother on campus. The
principal told the social worker mother talked over son when he
tried to speak and mother did “all the talking.” On one occasion,
mother parked in a crosswalk near school, parents complained,
and police were called. The responding officer told the principal
6
he believed “something is off with [mother].” The principal was
“glad” the Department was involved with the family.
The school attendance counselor told the Department social
worker that son had attended the school for 101 days and was
absent for 58 of those days. She noted, “[W]hen [son] is out, he is
out for weeks.” She also stated mother called and messaged
teachers “constantly” to ask if son is okay and if he needs
anything.
3. Petition
In April 2023, the Department filed a three-count section
300 petition on behalf of son, who was six years old at the time
(petition). Counts a-1 and b-1 both alleged mother physically
abused son and threatened to physically abuse him. Count b-2
alleged son was at risk of harm due to mother’s history of mental
and emotional issues, including PTSD, paranoia, and
hallucinations.
At the initial hearing on the petition held in May 2023, the
juvenile court detained son from father and ordered son placed
with mother under Department supervision. The court ordered,
among other things, unannounced home visits, random drug
testing for mother, and individual counseling. The court directed
mother to make son available for interviews with Department
social workers, without mother being present.
4. Continued Investigation
In June 2023, a Department social worker spoke with the
speech pathologist who had conducted the telehealth session that
resulted in the instant referral to the Department. The speech
pathologist recalled son refused to participate in the session.
Mother became angry and said to son, “ ‘Come over here or I am
going to punch you. Get the Fuck over here now.’ ” Son began to
7
cry. The speech pathologist said son and mother were sitting on
a bed when mother put her hand over son’s face and pushed him
backward onto the bed, causing son to cry louder. At another
point, mother had her arm behind son, when son spontaneously
said, “ ‘ouch’ ” and cried even more. The speech pathologist then
heard mother say, “ ‘That is what you get when you don’t
cooperate.’ ” Son was inconsolable and the speech pathologist
ended the session. The speech pathologist reported son “had a
delayed language pattern, was sometimes reluctant to engage,
and only communicated through the use of a few words.”
A Department social worker also interviewed mother and
son at their home. As the social worker arrived for the interview,
he heard mother and great grandmother arguing loudly about
mother’s mail, which mother accused great grandmother of
stealing. Great grandmother denied taking mother’s mail. She
said mother had lost multiple keys to the mailbox.
During mother’s interview with the social worker, mother
stated son sometimes was “aggressive, defiant, and disrespectful”
and occasionally threw objects and had outbursts. Although son
mostly appeared comfortable, happy, and loving toward mother,
at one point he pushed mother aggressively. While the social
worker was inside the home with both mother and son, the social
worker attempted to engage with son, but son refused.
Eventually, the social worker encouraged son to color outside.
Once son was outside and alone with the social worker, son spoke
with the social worker, albeit reluctantly. When asked about
“sad moments” with mother, son told the social worker mother
“ ‘hits me when I don’t listen. She yells at me’ ” and “ ‘I cry.’ ”
In a virtual interview with mother a couple of weeks later,
mother “adamantly denied” physically abusing or mistreating
8
son. Regarding the telehealth incident that resulted in the
referral to the Department, mother stated she proactively had
scheduled speech therapy for son. She said, on that day, son was
not behaving or listening to her and she may have pulled his
shirt to get him to listen and participate. She did not remember
shoving son or placing her hand on his face. She said she did not
intentionally harm son. She remembered son was crying during
the incident, but she told the social worker son often cried when
he did not want to do something. Mother also stated there may
have been times when she pulled son into her car “because
unknown persons were walking on the street or there was traffic
speeding by.” Mother noted when son was defiant, disrespectful,
or pushing boundaries, she spanked him as a form of discipline.
She did not do that often. She believed the allegations in the
petition were false and Department intervention was intrusive
and unnecessary.
She told the social worker “part of her issues were related
to the trauma and violence that she had suffered from the
father,” which caused her PTSD. She said she was being treated
for PTSD and social anxiety and had been diagnosed with ADHD.
She took medications as prescribed.2 Mother believed great
grandmother and maternal grandmother were “dismissive” of her
and “meddled” in her “personal affairs and parenting.” She said
her family was at times “ ‘toxic’ ” and criticized her.
The social worker also spoke with great grandmother and
maternal grandmother separately. Both reiterated they loved
mother and son, wanted the best for them, and were willing and
able to help. Both noted mother was distrustful and never left
2 It appears one of mother’s medications resulted in a June
2023 positive drug test (positive for amphetamines).
9
son alone or with other people. Maternal grandmother said
mother became agitated and verbally aggressive if anyone tried
to talk to son apart from mother. Great grandmother similarly
reported mother did not allow anyone to talk to or question son.
It seemed to great grandmother that mother coached or
controlled son. Maternal grandmother noted son appeared
“uncertain around his mother” and often looked to “mother prior
to responding to the maternal relatives.” Maternal grandmother
limited her contact with mother because mother was angry with
and resentful toward maternal grandmother and blamed
maternal grandmother for her problems. Maternal grandmother
described some of mother’s bizarre behaviors, including leaving
home with son for days and not answering her phone, calling to
say she had bugs on her arm, and needing a ride home in the
middle of the night after becoming “stranded” with son away
from home. Great grandmother said mother was “astute” and
“able to convince others that she was fine.”
Before the Department’s involvement, both great
grandmother and maternal grandmother had seen marks on son’s
face. Great grandmother believed mother was responsible. Great
grandmother also recalled a time son was crying while walking to
school and he seemed to indicate mother had hit him. Maternal
grandmother believed mother loved son but also believed
“something [was] wrong with the mother and the mother needs
assistance to help safely care for her child.”
The social worker spoke with a maternal great aunt, who
echoed the concerns voiced by maternal grandmother and great
grandmother.
The social worker also spoke with paternal aunt. Paternal
aunt reported mother rarely allowed visits with son and when
10
she did, mother was always present. Paternal aunt stated during
one visit mother told son to tell mother that he loved her and, if
he did not, mother would leave him. Son began to cry. Mother
then told son he had to tell mother he only wanted to be with
mother. Paternal aunt said mother sometimes called for help
with bizarre situations. One time mother called paternal aunt
and said she “felt like she had worms coming out of her mouth.”
Another time, mother asked paternal aunt to pick up mother and
son from an industrial building on the side of a freeway.
Paternal aunt never saw marks on son, but she was concerned for
him because of mother’s behaviors.
Finally, the social worker spoke with two of mother’s
friends, neither of whom had any concerns about mother or son.
The social worker called mother’s husband, but he could not fully
understand English and required an interpreter.
In July 2023, the Department reported mother had enrolled
in a parenting program, attended one session, and did not return.
Mother also had signed up for individual therapy, but had
rescheduled her first appointment several times and, by mid-July
2023, had not met with her therapist. During an unannounced
home visit, a Department social worker found mother’s home to
be “messy and cluttered.” The social worker asked about son’s
summer school, to which mother replied son had not been
attending because he had a cough and was not feeling well. Each
time mother mentioned the cough, son immediately coughed.
Mother also indicated she had stopped taking her anxiety
medication but was planning to refill her prescription.
The Department believed son was at risk of abuse and
neglect “due to the mother’s likely physical abuse of [son] and the
mother’s behaviors possibly associated with a mental health
11
disorder.” The Department reported, “[I]t appears probable and
likely that [son] has lived in a periodically volatile, and neglectful
environment while with his mother” and “the incidents of the
mother’s inability to handle stressful situations or manage [son’s]
behaviors without resorting to a physical reactions [sic] do not
appear to be isolated or an aberration.” The Department further
believed mother’s mental health issues could be “contributory
factors in [her] behaviors and responses to stressful situations.”
The Department was concerned that mother seemed to isolate
herself and son, was not consistently taking her prescribed
medication, and potentially suffered from an undiagnosed or
untreated mental health condition, all of which could impact her
ability to parent son and handle his own challenging behaviors.
The day before the adjudication hearing, mother called the
Department social worker to note her disagreement with the
Department’s recommendations. Mother believed her rights were
being violated and she was being discriminated against. She
requested a new social worker be assigned to the case and the
case be closed.
5. Adjudication and Disposition
A combined jurisdiction and disposition hearing was held in
July 2023. At the hearing, mother pleaded no contest to the
petition as amended. The juvenile court sustained the b-1 count,
which concerned mother’s physical abuse of son. The court
dismissed the identically worded a-1 count and the b-2 count
concerning mother’s alleged history of mental and emotional
problems.
The court declared son a dependent of the court under
subdivision (b) of section 300 and ordered him to remain released
to mother under Department supervision. The court ordered
12
mother to submit to eight random and on demand drug tests as
well as to a psychological assessment and psychiatric evaluation.
The court also ordered mother to participate in parenting classes,
individual counseling, and conjoint counseling with son if
recommended by son’s therapist, and to take all her prescribed
medications. The juvenile court also ordered that son participate
in individual counseling and “all age-appropriate services.”
6. Review Period
In October 2023, three months after disposition, the
Department reported son had one individual counseling session.
Son’s therapist stated that, at son’s request, mother was present
for son’s session. The therapist stated mother “distracted and
influenced [son] during the session” and made “it difficult for
[son] to concentrate and speak freely.” According to the
therapist, “[T]here was a notable attachment issue with” mother.
The therapist said son could not express himself verbally but did
so through play therapy. Son was “aggressive and rough in his
play.” Mother told the therapist she was married but had not
seen her husband since the beginning of the year. She said her
husband and son did not get along. Mother said she was “ ‘not
sure if he [husband] touched him or something happened’ ” and
said one time son “asked her to take off her clothes.”
The Department also reported son was doing well at school,
but mother’s behavior continued to raise concerns and son
continued to miss a lot of school time.
In October 2023, the Department also reported on mother’s
court-ordered services. Mother’s individual therapist reported
mother was doing well in therapy. The therapist had no concerns
for mother at the time. Mother also had been participating in
parenting classes. Her parenting instructor, who also met with
13
mother individually on a weekly basis, stated mother had two
classes left and had been doing well in the program. Mother’s
psychiatrist was treating mother for ADHD and PTSD. Mother
said she was taking her prescribed medications. Mother had
tested negative for drugs four times and was a “No Show” for her
most recent drug test. A family preservation worker reported
mother participated in weekly sessions at mother’s home, but son
refused to participate and often screamed and cried when the
family preservation worker arrived. The family preservation
worker believed son needed to learn more independence.
Although by October 2023, mother was in compliance with
most of her court orders, the Department social worker assigned
to the family remained concerned. The social worker had mostly
been unable to interview son separate from mother. On one
occasion, the social worker spoke with son at school, where he
spoke openly and engaged in conversation. The social worker
tried again to interview son at school, but mother denied access
to son and said she did not agree with the social worker speaking
with him at school. Any time the social worker tried to speak
with son at his home, he would not allow mother to leave the area
and would not answer questions or speak freely.
At an October 2023 hearing, the court ordered son to
continue his counseling sessions “by himself” and mother to allow
son to be interviewed “by himself when it’s arranged.” The court
explained to mother the importance that son be allowed to attend
therapy sessions as well as interviews on his own, without her
present. Mother indicated she understood.
In a January 2024 status report, the Department reported
son was bonded with mother but there appeared “to be a
boundary issue with both,” son struggled “to detach from
14
[mother],” and son had “some aggressive behaviors.” The
Department noted son only struggled with these behaviors when
he was under mother’s supervision. The Department suspected
mother was coaching son. Son was doing well in school, although
he had experienced some bullying and continued to have
attendance issues. Son stated “he feels good and bad with
[mother] but did not know how to describe his feelings.”
According to the Department, son was “reluctant to share his
true feelings unless he is in a completely private environment
free from [mother’s] influence.”
The Department also reported that although in late
October 2023, son began attending counseling sessions
individually, issues remained regarding son’s attendance and
mother’s disruptive behaviors. Son’s therapist, Ms. Nevarez,
reported son struggled with aggression toward mother and doing
things independently. In November 2023, mother canceled an
appointment with Ms. Nevarez at the last minute and requested
a new therapist. Mother believed “Ms. Nevarez was too
intimidating for [son] based on eyes and height.” Ms. Nevarez
had not noticed son to be uncomfortable during sessions. Mother
was informed she could not change son’s therapist “on a whim”
and Ms. Nevarez remained his therapist. Ms. Nevarez told a
Department social worker son came to one session 30 minutes
late and with a cell phone. Mother and son called each other
during the session. Mother asked son if he needed water, if he
was okay, and how much time was left for his therapy session.
Ms. Nevarez wondered if the phone was intended for recording
the session. Another time, mother wanted son to enter a session
with a backpack and a phone. Ms. Nevarez refused to allow the
backpack and son refused the phone. At some point, mother
15
again asked for a different therapist for son. Mother told Ms.
Nevarez she did not plan to continue therapy once the
dependency case closed. Ms. Nevarez told mother she needed to
continue therapy.
In its January 2024 report, the Department stated mother
had completed her parenting classes and her individual therapy
goals. Neither her therapist nor parenting class facilitator had
any concerns. Mother reported she was taking her medications
as prescribed. Nonetheless, the Department continued to work
with mother on parenting skills, in particular teaching son
independence and creating boundaries. The Department was
concerned with mother and son’s relationship and son’s potential
underlying behavioral issues. Although mother “care[d] deeply”
for son, the Department believed mother lacked boundaries with
son, had “an unhealthy attachment” to him, and had been a
“barrier” to son receiving therapy services. Mother continued to
request a new therapist for son and wanted family therapy over
individual therapy. The Department worried mother would end
son’s therapy if it was not court ordered. In its report, the
Department noted, “The Department suspects that mother tries
to change the child’s therapist constantly because she is possibly
concerned of what the child will disclose. The Department sees
this as a red flag for the child’s safety. The child already appears
coached not to say much and now that he is gaining rapport with
his therapist, mother wants to change it and has stated that once
the case closes she will not keep the child in therapy.”
Son reported he loved mother but at times she disciplined
him by hitting or pinching him when she was upset. However,
son did not indicate mother had done that recently. A
Department social worker reported son was physically aggressive
16
with mother, noting he hit and pushed her when he was upset.
Mother told the social worker she no longer used corporal
punishment to discipline son but instead used time outs.
In January 2024, the juvenile court ordered mother not to
participate or intervene in son’s therapy sessions and not to
record or photograph those sessions. That same month, the
Department received a referral alleging mother sexually abused
son. The Department investigated and found those allegations
unfounded.
In February 2024, the Department reported that, at
mother’s request, son had been assigned to a new therapist, Ms.
Rodriguez. Mother then said she wanted son to return to Ms.
Nevarez. Eventually, son began individual counseling with Ms.
Rodriguez. By early March 2024, son had seen Ms. Rodriguez
five times and was doing well with her. Ms. Rodriguez had
concerns and believed son would benefit from continued therapy.
She reported mother had not tried to intervene in son’s sessions.
The Department recommended that court-ordered services
continue for an additional three months.
7. Review Hearing
On March 6, 2024, the juvenile court held a section 364
review hearing. At the hearing, counsel for mother asked the
juvenile court to terminate jurisdiction and grant mother sole
legal and physical custody of son. Counsel noted mother had
completed her services and the issue on which the court based
jurisdiction—improper discipline of son—no longer existed.
Counsel argued mother had gained the necessary insight.
Counsel for son, on the other hand, urged the court to keep
the case open. Counsel noted son’s therapy had begun with
mother attending his sessions, then mother sent son to sessions
17
with a phone and made requests for a new therapist. Counsel
further noted son only recently had begun individual sessions
with a new therapist and without mother’s interference. Counsel
wanted to be satisfied “the issues that brought the case to court
have been resolved. And I’m not confident that that is
happening.”
After hearing argument, the juvenile court found mother
was in “partial compliance” with her services. The court noted it
was “a good thing” mother no longer was interfering with son’s
individual counseling. The court continued its jurisdiction for
three months and ordered son to remain consistent with
counseling sessions and mother not to interfere with those
sessions.
8. Appeal and Postappeal Events
Mother appealed the court’s March 6, 2024 order
continuing its jurisdiction.
The following month, the Department filed both a
subsequent petition and a supplemental petition on behalf of son,
alleging mother physically abused son and failed to comply with
juvenile court orders. The juvenile court detained son from
mother. On June 5, 2024, the juvenile court sustained the
subsequent and supplemental petitions, removed son from
mother, and ordered family reunification services. Mother did
not appeal the juvenile court’s June 5, 2024 findings and orders.
The Department filed a motion to dismiss the instant
appeal. In a January 24, 2025 order, we denied the Department’s
motion to dismiss.
18
DISCUSSION
1. Applicable Law and Standard of Review
The parties agree the relevant statute is section 364, which
applies to review hearings in the juvenile court when a child,
such as son here, has not been removed from a parent. At a
section 364 review hearing, the juvenile court “shall determine
whether continued supervision is necessary. The court shall
terminate its jurisdiction unless the [Department] establishes by
a preponderance of evidence that the conditions still exist which
would justify initial assumption of jurisdiction under Section 300,
or that those conditions are likely to exist if supervision is
withdrawn.” (§ 364, subd. (c).)3 Section 364 also provides,
“Failure of the parent or guardian to participate regularly in any
court ordered treatment program shall constitute prima facie
evidence that the conditions which justified initial assumption of
jurisdiction still exist and that continued supervision is
necessary.” (Ibid.)
“When proceeding under section 364, because the child is in
placement with a parent, the court is not concerned with
reunification, but with determining whether continued
3 Courts are split on whether the phrase “conditions still
exist which would justify initial assumption of jurisdiction” as
used in section 364 refers to the same conditions that justified
the juvenile court’s initial exercise of jurisdiction in the case, or to
any condition that would justify dependency jurisdiction at the
time of the section 364 review hearing. (See In re N.O. (2019) 31
Cal.App.5th 899, 923; In re D.B. (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 1073,
1085; In re J.F. (2014) 228 Cal.App.4th 202, 210.) We need not
address this apparent split of authority, however, because as
discussed below the juvenile court could have continued its
jurisdiction under either interpretation of section 364.
19
supervision is necessary in the family home.” (In re Gabriel L.
(2009) 172 Cal.App.4th 644, 650.) Section 364 “ ‘establishes a
statutory presumption in favor of terminating jurisdiction and
returning the children to the parents’ care without further court
supervision.’ ” (In re N.O., supra, 31 Cal.App.5th at p. 923.) The
juvenile court makes its section 364 determination “based on the
totality of the evidence before it.” (Id. at p. 922.)
We review the juvenile court’s order under section 364 for
substantial evidence. (In re Aurora P. (2015) 241 Cal.App.4th
1142, 1156; In re J.F., supra, 228 Cal.App.4th at p. 209.) “Under
the substantial evidence standard of review, the appellate court
does not reweigh the evidence, evaluate the credibility of
witnesses, or draw inferences contrary to the findings of the trial
court. [Citation.] The appellate court ‘accept[s] the evidence
most favorable to the order as true and discard[s] the unfavorable
evidence as not having sufficient verity to be accepted by the trier
of fact.’ [Citation.] For evidence to be sufficient to support a trial
court’s finding, it must be reasonable, credible, and of solid
value.” (In re J.F., supra, 228 Cal.App.4th at p. 209.)
2. Substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s
order continuing jurisdiction.
Mother argues substantial evidence does not support the
juvenile court’s finding that, at the time of the section 364 review
hearing, conditions still existed justifying jurisdiction. Mother
asserts the conditions that prompted jurisdiction—mother’s
physical abuse of son—had been eliminated as there were no
reports of such abuse following the adjudication and disposition
hearing. Further, mother notes she had completed her court-
ordered services. We disagree with mother’s analysis.
20
Although by the time of the section 364 review hearing
mother had completed her court-ordered services, she had only
recently begun to cooperate in satisfying the court-ordered
counseling for son. The record includes ample evidence of both
son’s problematic behaviors and mother’s frustration with those
behaviors. Indeed, toward the start of the underlying
proceedings mother conceded she sometimes responded to son’s
behaviors with physical discipline. Despite knowing son’s
behaviors were problematic, mother repeatedly impeded his
court-ordered counseling. At the time of the section 364 review
hearing, son had been seeing his new therapist for only one
month. Moreover, mother had stated she would discontinue son’s
counseling when the dependency case ended, thus thwarting
attempts to address son’s behaviors.
Additionally, it is undisputed mother fostered an
unhealthy relationship with son. Although mother loves son, she
exerted an unusual amount of control over him. The record
reveals that almost everyone who was involved below—social
workers, relatives, school personnel, son’s therapist—was
concerned that mother not only was coaching son but also at
times did not want him to speak to anyone outside of her
presence for fear of what he might say. For example, mother
denied the Department access to son at school, where he was
more forthcoming. Similarly, when son finally began to form a
relationship with his first therapist, mother switched him to a
new therapist. Mother’s control over and coaching of son were
concrete issues throughout the underlying proceedings. It was
clear son was not fully expressing himself. Without consistent
counseling as ordered by the court, son’s behaviors (which
21
prompted physical discipline from mother) and unhealthy
attachment to mother had not fully been addressed.
Less than two months before the section 364 review
hearing, the Department reported son said “he feels good and bad
with [mother] but did not know how to describe his feelings.” Son
continued to experience a level of discomfort with mother that
had not been satisfactorily resolved or understood by the time of
the section 364 hearing. Given the record before us, we conclude
substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s determination
that the conditions initially justifying jurisdiction still existed or
likely would exist if court supervision were withdrawn.
Finally, we are not persuaded by the cases on which mother
relies because they are factually distinct.
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s March 6, 2024 order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
LUI, P. J.
We concur:
CHAVEZ, J.
RICHARDSON, J.
22
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.