Ko v. Choi CA2/3

CourtListener 10372988Calctapp04.04.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 4/4/25 Ko v. Choi CA2/3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

JOO MO KO et al., B328608

Plaintiffs, Cross-Defendants Los Angeles County
and Appellants, Super. Ct. No. 19STCV40062

v.

JONG SUK CHOI et al.,

Defendants, Cross-
Complainants and Respondents.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court
of Los Angeles County, Monica Bachner, Judge. Affirmed.

Park & Lim, S. Young Lim, Dennis McPhillips and
Jessie Y. Kim for Plaintiffs, Cross-Defendants and Appellants.

Steven C. Kim & Associates, Steven C. Kim and Gabriel
Colorado for Defendants, Cross-Complainants and Respondents.
_________________________
The parties to this appeal belong to separate factions
that are vying for control of a local Presbyterian church.
At the time the parties’ governance dispute arose, the church
belonged to a larger religious organization. The highest court
of that organization resolved the dispute in favor of respondents.
Nevertheless, appellants filed a complaint in the superior court
seeking a declaration that their faction represents the “true”
church. According to appellants, they are not bound by the
religious court’s determination because the church voted to
leave the larger organization before the religious court issued
its decision. Following an eight-day bench trial, the superior
court determined the church had not withdrawn from the
larger religious organization. The court entered judgment
for respondents and declared that they occupy leadership
positions within the church.
On appeal, appellants contend the trial court’s statement
of decision is inconsistent with a prior superior court order,
which they assert conclusively establishes that the church
left the larger religious organization. Appellants also argue
the trial court misinterpreted the church’s governing documents
and violated the United States Constitution by failing to defer
to them on matters of religious doctrine. We affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
This case concerns a dispute over control of the Korean
Western Presbyterian Church of Los Angeles (the Church).
The Church is a Korean-speaking Presbyterian church, and
it owns real property in Los Angeles that is worth as much
as $10 million.
In 2019, the Church members split into two factions,
both claiming to represent the true Church. The majority

2
of Church members—including the individual respondents—
belong to a faction led by Rev. Jong Suk Choi.1 A minority of
members—including the appellants—belong to a faction led by
Rev. Joo Mo Ko.2 Although the designations are not entirely
accurate, for the sake of simplicity, we refer to the appellants
and respondents as the “Ko Faction” and the “Choi Faction,”
respectively.
1. The Church history and structure
The Church was founded in 1972 as an independent
Presbyterian church. A few times over the years, the Church
has joined and withdrawn from larger religious organizations.
The parties disagree about whether the Church belonged
to any of those larger organizations in late 2019.
a. The World Korean Presbyterian Church
In 2014, the Church joined a larger religious organization
called the World Korean Presbyterian Church (WKPC). The
Choi Faction contends the Church has never left the WKPC,
while the Ko Faction contends the Church left the organization
in November 2019.
The WKPC is a hierarchical organization governed
by a constitutional document called the Book of Church Order
(BOCO). The WKPC’s hierarchy consists of three levels of
governing bodies, which are sometimes referred to as “courts.”

1 The respondents are Rev. Jong Suk Choi aka Olaf J. Choi,
Elder Nathanael Yun, Chang Rok Kim, Samuel Kim aka Seung
Gon Kim, the Western Presbytery of the Hapdong in USA, and
World Korean Presbyterian Church.
2 The appellants are Rev. Joo Mo Ko, Elder Bong Kyu Kim,
and Rev. Myung Chul Ra.

3
At the lowest level of the hierarchy, each local church
is governed by a “session,” which consists of the church’s pastor
and its ruling elders. The pastor of the church is the “moderator”
of the session, which is a position akin to the chair of a board
of directors.
At the next level of the hierarchy is the “presbytery.”
A presbytery has authority to resolve property disputes, appoint
interim pastors, and impose discipline on pastors, elders, and
members of the local churches under its jurisdiction. The
LA Presbytery and the California Presbytery are two WKPC
presbyteries that are relevant to this case.
The General Assembly is the highest body in the WKPC’s
hierarchy. A member who disagrees with a presbytery’s
resolution of a dispute may appeal the decision to the General
Assembly. The General Assembly’s decisions are final and
binding on all members.
As we discuss below, the Choi Faction contends the
Church has never left the WKPC, while the Ko Faction contends
the Church left the organization in November 2019.
b. The Western Presbytery of the Hapdong
In 2018, the Church joined another religious organization
called the Western Presbytery of the Hapdong (the Hapdong
Presbytery). The Hapdong Presbytery is the regional governing
body of a larger organization based in Korea called the
Presbyterian Church in Korea (PCK). The BOCO expressly
allows dual membership in the WKPC and the PCK.
The Choi Faction contends the Church has never left
the Hapdong Presbytery. The Ko Faction contends the Church
left the organization in March 2019.

4
2. Events leading up to the litigation
a. Rev. Ko and Rev. Choi join the Church
In April 2018, LA Presbytery requested that the Hapdong
Presbytery remove the Church’s senior pastor, Rev. Gun Ho Seo.
The Hapdong Presbytery complied with the request, after which
the LA Presbytery appointed Rev. Ko as the Church’s interim
senior pastor.3
Upon Rev. Ko’s appointment as the Church’s senior pastor,
the Church’s session (the Session) consisted of Rev. Ko (as
moderator), Elder Kim, and Elder Yun. Rev. Ko and Elder Kim
belong to the Ko Faction. Elder Yun belongs to the Choi Faction.
About a month after Rev. Ko’s appointment as senior
pastor, Rev. Choi joined the Church as an associate pastor.
b. The Church considers a merger
For reasons not relevant to this case, the Church’s
membership decreased dramatically around the time Rev. Ko
and Rev. Choi joined the Church. In an attempt to resolve
the financial issues caused by the decline in membership,
Elder Yun spearheaded an effort to merge the Church with
another church called LA Open Door Presbyterian Church
(LA Open Door). At the time, both the Church and LA Open Door
were members of the WKPC. However, the Church was governed
by the LA Presbytery, while LA Open Door was governed by the
California Presbytery. Under the proposed terms of the merger,
the pastor of LA Open Door (Rev. Park) would become the senior
pastor of the merged church, effectively replacing Rev. Ko in
that position.

3 The parties seem to agree that the Hapdong Presbytery
had authority to remove Rev. Seo.

5
c. Elder Yun tries to replace Rev. Ko
The proposed merger stalled after a court entered a multi-
million dollar judgment against LA Open Door. Nevertheless,
Elder Yun remained determined to remove Rev. Ko from his
position as the Church’s senior pastor. Elder Yun sent letters
to the LA Presbytery requesting that it replace Rev. Ko with
Rev. Choi. After receiving no response, Elder Yun sent a letter
to the Hapdong Presbytery asking it to do the same. The
Hapdong Presbytery complied with Elder Yun’s request, and
on October 29, 2019, it passed a resolution appointing Rev. Choi
as interim senior pastor of the Church. Since that date, the
Choi Faction has claimed to represent the true Church.
d. Elder Kim and Elder Yun leave the Session
The Ko Faction refused to recognize the Hapdong
Presbytery’s appointment of Rev. Choi as the Church’s senior
pastor. On October 31, 2019, Rev. Ko and Elder Kim called
a special meeting of the Session. They did not provide notice
of the meeting to Elder Yun, despite the fact that he was a
member of the Session.
At the special meeting of the Session, Rev. Ko and
Elder Kim dismissed Rev. Choi from the Church. They also
dismissed Elder Yun from the Session for “illegally” petitioning
the Hapdong Presbytery to remove Rev. Ko.
After voting to remove Elder Yun, Elder Kim decided
to resign his position on the Session. Accordingly, the evening
of October 31, 2019, Elder Kim gave Rev. Ko his letter of
resignation.

6
e. The LA Presbytery Executive Committee appoints
new Session members
The next day—November 1, 2019—five members of
the Executive Officers Committee of the LA Presbytery met
to appoint new members to the Church’s Session. The majority
of the committee members who attended the meeting belong
to the Ko Faction: Rev. Ko, Rev. Ra, and Rev. Paul Choi.4
At that meeting, the committee expelled Rev. Choi from
the LA Presbytery. The committee also appointed Rev. Ra and
Rev. Paul Choi to fill the vacant seats in the Session that had
previously been filled by Elder Yun and Elder Kim.
f. The Choi Faction votes to join the California
Presbytery
On November 3, 2019, members of the Choi Faction and
LA Open Door physically blocked members of the Ko Faction
from entering the Church property to hold services. As we
discuss later in this opinion, the Ko Faction subsequently claimed
it dismissed and excommunicated the Church members who
participated in the blockade.
Two days later—on November 5, 2019—members of the
Choi Faction purported to hold a congregational meeting. At that
meeting, the members voted to leave the LA Presbytery and join
the California Presbytery. Rev. Choi sent the LA Presbytery
notice of the Church’s decision to withdraw from the
organization.

4 Rev. Choi and Rev. Paul Choi are different people and
belong to different factions.

7
3. The Ko Faction causes the Church to file a complaint
against the Choi Faction
The next day—November 6, 2019—the Ko Faction caused
the Church to file a complaint against the Choi Faction.5 The
complaint alleged the Choi Faction was attempting to make
LA Open Door the de facto owner of the Church’s property
and to use the Church as a shell for the purposes of avoiding
enforcement of the judgment against LA Open Door. According
to the complaint, the Choi Faction tried to take control of
the Church by falsely claiming the Church is a member of
the Hapdong Presbytery and that Rev. Choi is the Church’s
senior pastor. Among other forms of relief, the complaint sought
a declaration that the Church has the power to own, possess,
control, and manage the Church’s property in exclusion of
the Choi Faction.
4. The California Presbytery appoints Rev. Choi
as interim senior pastor of the Church
On November 8, 2019, the California Presbytery appointed
Rev. Choi as interim senior pastor of the Church, replacing
Rev. Ko in that position.
5. The court grants a temporary restraining order
and issues an order to show cause
On November 15, 2019, the trial court—the Hon. James C.
Chalfant—issued a temporary restraining order enjoining the
Choi Faction from interfering with the Church’s possession,
control, and management of the Church’s property. The court

5 The complaint named as defendants Rev. Choi, the
Hapdong Presbytery, LA Open Door, and LA Open Door’s pastor,
Rev. Park.

8
issued an order to show cause and set a hearing to consider
issuing a preliminary injunction.
6. Factions vie for control of the LA Presbytery
At the same time the Ko Faction and Choi Faction were
vying for control of the Church, two competing factions were
vying for control of the LA Presbytery.
On November 18, 2019, one of those factions—led by
Rev. Ko—held a special meeting of the LA Presbytery. At that
meeting, the faction expelled the moderator of the LA Presbytery
and appointed Rev. Ko in his place. The faction also ratified
the Executive Committee’s November 1 resolutions expelling
Rev. Choi from the LA Presbytery and expelling Elder Yun
from the Church Session.
The other faction of the LA Presbytery held a meeting
five days later, on November 23, 2019. At that meeting, the
faction expelled Rev. Ko and Rev. Ra from the LA Presbytery
and disciplined several other members of the Ko Faction. The
faction found Rev. Ko and Rev. Ra had filed a lawsuit to try to
take control of the Church’s property, submitted false documents
to the court, and held an illegal meeting on November 18, 2019.
7. Members of the Ko Faction submit declarations
in support of the request for a preliminary injunction
On December 5, 2019, the Ko Faction caused the Church
to file a brief in support of its request for a preliminary
injunction. Rev. Ko and Elder Kim submitted declarations in
support of the request, which they signed under penalty of
perjury on December 4, 2019. In those declarations, Rev. Ko and
Elder Kim each asserted that “since November 1, 2019 to date,
the session consists of Ko, Ra, and [Paul] Choi.” (Original italics
and underscoring.) As we discuss below, Rev. Ko and Elder Kim

9
later contradicted their sworn declarations by claiming the
Session had been dissolved on November 17, 2019.
8. The court grants the Church’s request for a
preliminary injunction
On January 16, 2020, the trial court—Judge Chalfant—
issued a preliminary injunction enjoining the Choi Faction
from interfering with the Church’s possession, control, and
management of its property. The court stated the case turned
on whether the Hapdong Presbytery had authority to appoint
Rev. Choi as the Church’s interim pastor. The court determined
the evidence “shows that [the] Church is governed by the
LA Presbytery and is not a member of the [Hapdong Presbytery].
Consequently, no action by or on behalf of the [Hapdong
Presbytery] has any bearing on the control and management
of Church Property.” The court also found the Church had
demonstrated the November 5, 2019 congregational meeting—
at which members of the Choi Faction voted to leave the
LA Presbytery and join the California Presbytery—“was not
properly noticed and convened as required by [the] BOCO.”
9. The Ko Faction causes the Church to file for
bankruptcy
On February 14, 2020, the Ko Faction caused the Church
to file a petition for bankruptcy in the Central District of
California. The filing of the bankruptcy petition automatically
stayed the Church’s lawsuit in the superior court.
Over the Ko Faction’s objection, the bankruptcy court
granted the Choi Faction’s motion to lift the automatic stay
to allow the superior court to resolve the parties’ governance
dispute. The court found the Ko Faction had filed the bankruptcy
case in bad faith and had “engaged in very questionable tactics.”

10
It noted the Ko Faction had been pressing for the immediate
sale of the Church’s property, apparently to fund its litigation
and “disrupt the Choi Faction’s ability to conduct services . . .
and obtain collections from worshipers.” The court appointed
a neutral trustee to control the Church’s property while the
parties litigated the governance dispute in the superior court.
10. The General Assembly resolves the dispute in favor
of the Choi Faction
In June 2020, the WKPC General Assembly held its
annual meeting. At that meeting, the General Assembly sided
with the Choi Faction and made the following resolutions:
(1) the LA Presbytery properly removed and expelled Rev. Ko
and Rev. Ra on November 23, 2019 for attempting to steal
the Church’s property; (2) the meetings of the LA Presbytery
on November 1, 7, and 18, 2019—at which it purported to expel
Rev. Choi and Elder Yun and appoint members of the Ko Faction
to the Session—were illegal and any resolutions reached at
the meetings are void; (3) the Church legally withdrew from
the LA Presbytery and joined the California Presbytery; (4) the
California Presbytery properly appointed Rev. Choi as interim
senior pastor; and (5) Elder Yun remains a member of the
Session. The General Assembly also requested that the Church
dismiss this lawsuit against the Choi Faction as soon as possible.
11. The Ko Faction files the first amended complaint
Instead of complying with the General Assembly’s request
to dismiss this lawsuit, on August 6, 2020, the Ko Faction caused
the Church to file the operative first amended complaint (FAC).
While the original complaint was concerned primarily with
a property dispute, the FAC was concerned primarily with

11
a governance dispute between the Ko Faction and the Choi
Faction.6
The FAC alleged the General Assembly’s June 2020
resolutions were not binding because the Church had withdrawn
from the WKPC several months earlier. According to the
FAC, on November 9, 2019, the Session called for a special
congregational meeting on November 17, 2019. The Session
announced the meeting to the congregation in the November 10th
weekly worship bulletin. At the November 17th meeting, nine of
the Church’s 10 regular members were present. Those members
voted to withdraw from the WKPC, appoint Rev. Ko as senior
pastor of the Church, and operate the Church as an independent
Presbyterian church.
12. The Ko Faction files a motion under Corporations
Code section 9418
In January 2021, the Ko Faction caused the Church to file
a motion under Corporations Code section 9418, asking the court
to determine “the validity of the Church’s Board of Directors
consisting of Plaintiffs [Rev.] Ko, [Elder] Kim, and [Rev.] Ra in
conformity with its Articles of Incorporation . . . and its Bylaws.”
According to the motion, since withdrawing from the WKPC on
November 17, 2019, the Church has been governed by a Board
of Directors (the Board), rather than the Session. The motion
asserted Rev. Ko and Elder Kim were the original members of
the Board. On November 17, 2019, they held a special meeting
at which they appointed Rev. Ra to join them on the Board.

6 The Ko Faction later dismissed LA Open Door and
Rev. Park as defendants.

12
The Choi Faction opposed the motion, asserting it
improperly asked the court to determine which faction represents
the true Church. According to the Choi Faction, the General
Assembly had resolved that issue in favor of the Choi Faction
at its June 2020 annual meeting, and the court is bound by
the General Assembly’s decision.
The Choi Faction asserted the Ko Faction had fabricated
the November 17, 2019 congregational meeting after it
became clear the General Assembly would rule in favor of the
Choi Faction. The Choi Faction pointed out that none of the
declarations the Ko Faction filed in December 2019 mentioned
the November 17, 2019 congregational meeting or the fact that
the Church had withdrawn from the WKPC. The Choi Faction
also submitted declarations from 31 Church members stating
they did not receive notice of the November 17, 2019
congregational meeting.
On April 8, 2021, the trial court issued a 16-page decision
concluding, “[Rev.] Ko, Elder Kim, and [Rev.] Ra were duly
elected or appointed to the Board (Session).” We refer to that
decision as the section 9418 order. The court cautioned that
its decision was extremely limited. According to the court,
the decision did not address whether the Church withdrew
from the WKPC or which faction represents the true Church.
As we discuss later in this opinion, the section 9418 order
has been the source of considerable confusion in this case.
13. The Choi Faction files a cross-complaint
In May 2021, the Choi Faction filed a cross-complaint
against the Ko Faction. The cross-complaint alleged the
trial court is bound by the General Assembly’s June 2020
determination that members of the Choi Faction are the

13
legitimate leaders of the Church. Among other forms of relief,
the cross-complaint sought declarations that, since October 2019,
Rev. Choi has been the true senior pastor of the Church and
the Session has been comprised of members of the Choi Faction.
14. The trial
The parties tried their claims before the court—the Hon.
Monica Bachner—over the course of eight days in August 2022.
The Ko Faction presented testimony from Rev. Ko, Rev. Ra,
Elder Kim, and Elder Yun. The Choi Faction did not call
any witnesses.7
Rev. Ko and Elder Kim testified that, on November 3, 2019,
members of the Choi Faction blocked members of the Ko Faction
from conducting services on Church property. In response,
the Session held a special meeting later that day. At the time,
Rev. Ko and Elder Kim were the only two members of the
Session.8 At the special meeting, the Session dismissed
and expelled 16 members of the Church for interfering with
the Church services earlier that day.
The Ko Faction entered into evidence a document
purporting to be the minutes of the November 3 Session meeting.
The document states the Session “has resolved to dismiss and
expel the church members, who interrupted the services of this

7 Because the record of trial is voluminous, we summarize
only the evidence directly relevant to the issues in this appeal.
8 Rev. Ko and Elder Kim acknowledged that Elder Kim
submitted a letter of resignation from the Session on October 31,
2019. However, they claimed he rescinded his resignation the
next day, shortly after the LA Presbytery Executive Committee
appointed Rev. Ra and Rev. Paul Choi to the Session.

14
church . . . pursuant to Chapter 8 (Session), Article 5 (Duties of
Session), Item 2 (Admission and withdrawal as church member)
and Item 6 (Discipline) of the [BOCO], as of November 3, 2019.”
The document lists 16 people who were dismissed and expelled
from the Church, and 10 people who remained members of
the Church.
Rev. Ko admitted he did not try to summon any members
to the Session before expelling them. He explained that the
Session had authority to dismiss and excommunicate those
members summarily because, under the BOCO, “if someone
interferes with service or tries to separate, one can take
immediate action.”
Rev. Ko testified that the Session held another special
meeting on November 9, 2019. At that meeting, the Session
resolved to convene a special congregational meeting on
November 17, 2019 to withdraw from the WKPC.
Rev. Ko testified that he provided notice of the special
congregational meeting to Church members in the Church
bulletins on November 10 and 17, 2019. He also announced
the meeting during the service on November 10. Rev. Ko
admitted he did not give notice of the congregational meeting
to the members of the Church who were following Rev. Choi.
According to Rev. Ko and Elder Kim, nine of the
10 members of the Church attended the November 17
congregational meeting. All nine members voted to leave
the WKPC.
15. The court enters judgment for the Choi Faction
In January 2023, the court issued a final statement of
decision finding in favor of the Choi Faction. The court concluded
the Ko Faction failed to meet its burden of proving the Church

15
is not subject to the control and authority of the WKPC. Instead,
the preponderance of the evidence supports the Choi Faction’s
contention that the Church “did not sever its relationship with
WKPC in November 2019 or at any time thereafter and [the
Church] is still a member of WKPC.”
The court noted Judge Chalfant made a “binding
determination that, as of November 17, 2019, the Board consisted
of Plaintiffs [Rev.] Ko, [Rev.] Ra, and [Elder] Kim.” Nevertheless,
the court determined the November 17, 2019 congregational
meeting—at which the Church purportedly withdrew from
the WKPC—was not “valid as it did not include members of
the congregation that had been excommunicated on November 3,
2019, without following the procedures set forth in the [BOCO].
[Citation.] The [BOCO] does not include a summary
excommunication procedure, but rather required the session
to summon the offender and witnesses. [Citations.] Accordingly,
the Ko faction did not give notice of the November 17, 2019
Congregational meeting to the improperly expelled members.
[Citation.] Accordingly, assuming the 10 members of the
Ko faction were present, there was not a quorum. The Court
finds that the November 17, 2019 congregational meeting was
not properly called, noticed and convened in compliance with
the [BOCO]. Accordingly, the November 17, 2019 resolutions
ceasing the affiliation with WKPC, calling Rev. Ko as Senior
Pastor, and establishing [the Church] as an independent
Presbyterian church were not valid.”
The court entered judgment against the Ko Faction on
the FAC and in favor of the Choi Faction on the cross-complaint.
The judgment declares the following: (1) the Church is a
member of the WKPC and subject to its control and authority;

16
(2) Rev. Choi replaced Rev. Ko as senior pastor of the Church
on October 29, 2019; and (3) Rev. Choi and Elder Yun are
the only members of the Session.
The Ko Faction appealed.
DISCUSSION
The Ko Faction challenges the trial court’s determination
that the Church did not withdraw from the WKPC on
November 17, 2019. According to the Ko Faction, the court’s
determination is inconsistent with Judge Chalfant’s section
9418 order, which conclusively establishes the November 17,
2019 congregational meeting was valid and the Church withdrew
from the WKPC at that meeting. The Ko Faction also argues
the trial court erred in finding the congregational meeting was
not called, noticed, and convened in compliance with the BOCO.
1. The statement of decision is not inconsistent with
the section 9418 order
Corporations Code section 9418 provides, in relevant part,
“[u]pon the filing of an action therefor by any director or member
[of a corporation], . . . the superior court of the proper county
shall determine the validity of any election or appointment of
any director of any corporation.” (Corp. Code, § 9418, subd. (a).)
The court must set an expedited hearing to consider the issue
(id., subd. (b)), and it “may determine the person entitled to
the office of director or may order a new election to be held or
appointment to be made, . . . and may direct such other relief
as may be just and proper” (id., subd. (c)).
Before trial, the Ko Faction filed a motion under
Corporations Code section 9418 asking the court to determine
“the validity of the Church’s Board of Directors consisting of
Plaintiffs [Rev.] Ko, [Elder] Kim, and [Rev.] Ra in conformity

17
with its Articles of Incorporation . . . and its Bylaws.” The court
ultimately granted the motion, concluding, “[Rev.] Ko, Elder Kim,
and [Rev.] Ra were duly elected or appointed to the Board
(Session).”
According to the Ko Faction, the court’s conclusions
in the section 9418 order can be true only if the Church
withdrew from the WKPC on November 17, 2019. Therefore,
the court must have implicitly found the November 17, 2019
congregational meeting was valid and the Church withdrew
from the WKPC on that date. The Ko Faction contends those
implicit findings are conclusive, and it urges us to reject the
statement of decision to the extent it is inconsistent with them.
Although the section 9418 order purports to be a limited
decision on a narrow issue, it has been the source of a great deal
of confusion in this case. Much of that confusion stems from
the fact that the order does not clearly indicate when the court
is making factual findings, and when it is merely summarizing
the evidence and arguments presented to it. Adding to the
confusion, the order seems to use the terms “Board” and “Session”
interchangeably, without regard for the significant legal
implications of the court’s choice of terms. This imprecision
makes it difficult to ascertain precisely what legal and
factual findings the court intended to make.
That being said, we agree with the Ko Faction that some
of the court’s conclusions—particularly those related to Rev. Ra
—seem to imply that the Church withdrew from the WKPC.
For example, the Ko Faction’s motion asserted Rev. Ko and
Elder Kim appointed Rev. Ra to the Board during a special
Board meeting on November 17, 2019. In granting the motion,
it seems the court must have accepted the Ko Faction’s

18
assertions, as there was no evidence that Rev. Ra had been
appointed at some other time. As the Ko Faction points out,
had the Church not withdrawn from the WKPC on November 17,
2019, it would have been governed by the Session, not the Board.
Therefore, the court’s conclusion that Rev. Ra had been duly
appointed to the Board seems to imply that the Church validly
withdrew from the WKPC.
The court’s conclusions related to Rev. Ra also seem
to imply that the Ko Faction controlled the Church as of
November 17, 2019. Had the Choi Faction controlled the
Church on that date, Rev. Ko would not have been a member
of the Board or the Session. Therefore, he would not have
had the authority to call a special meeting or appoint Rev. Ra
to any leadership position within the Church. Thus, it would
seem Rev. Ra’s appointment is valid only if the Ko Faction
represented the true Church as of November 17, 2019.
Although the Ko Faction’s contentions have some logical
and textual support, we are confident the court did not intend
to resolve the governance dispute or decide whether the Church
validly withdrew from the WKPC. In a section of the order
entitled “Scope of the Section 9418 Trial,” the court plainly stated
it would not resolve “the validity of the Church’s November 17,
2019 withdrawal from WKPC or the WKPC General Assembly’s
June 2020 ratification of the removal and expulsion of Ko and Ra,
and of Choi’s installation as Church’s pastor.” In another section
of the order, the court reiterated that it would not address the
existence of the November 17, 2019 congregational meeting, the
validity of its notice, or whether the General Assembly removed
Rev. Ko, Elder Kim, and Rev. Ra from their leadership positions.

19
The court stated those issues are “hotly disputed and must be
addressed in the main trial.”
It is very difficult to square the court’s explicit statements
regarding the order’s limited scope with the broad implications
of its conclusions. On the one hand, the court explicitly stated
it would not address whether the Church left the WKPC or
which faction controls it. On the other hand, the court confirmed
the validity of Rev. Ra’s appointment to the Board, which would
seem to be true only if the Church validly withdrew from the
WKPC under the Ko Faction’s governance.
We see no obvious way to resolve the conflict between the
court’s explicit statements and its implied findings. Of the two,
we have more confidence in our understanding of the court’s
explicit statements regarding the limited scope of its order.
Indeed, given the order’s ambiguity, it is possible we have
fundamentally misunderstood the court’s findings and
conclusions. Therefore, to the extent the court’s explicit
statements conflict with its implicit findings, we will follow
the explicit statements. Accordingly, we reject the Ko Faction’s
contention that the section 9418 order conclusively establishes
that the Church withdrew from the WKPC on November 17,
2019. We also reject any suggestion that the order resolves
the parties’ underlying governance dispute.
2. The trial court did not prejudicially err in finding
the November 17, 2019 congregational meeting
was not properly called, noticed, and convened
In its statement of decision, the trial court concluded
the preponderance of the evidence shows the Church did not
leave the WKPC on November 17, 2019 because the purported
congregational meeting was not properly called, noticed, and

20
convened. The court reasoned that, a few weeks before the
congregational meeting, the Ko Faction purported to dismiss
and excommunicate 16 members of the Church, who made up
a majority of the congregation at the time. The court found the
Ko Faction failed to summon the members before dismissing
and excommunicating them, as required under BOCO Chapter 8,
Article 5, Item 6 (BOCO Item 6).9 The court explained that,
because the 16 members were not properly excommunicated and
dismissed, they were entitled to participate in the November 17,
2019 congregational meeting. The Ko Faction, however, did not
give those members notice of the meeting, nor did they attend it.
Therefore, the court concluded, the Ko Faction did not properly
call, notice, or convene the November 17, 2019 congregational
meeting, rendering invalid any decisions made at that meeting.
The Ko Faction argues the trial court erred to the extent
it found the congregational meeting was not properly called,
noticed, or convened. The Ko Faction asserts its failure to comply
with BOCO Item 6 is irrelevant because it had independent
authority to dismiss Church members under BOCO Chapter 8,
Article 5, Item 2 (BOCO Item 2). BOCO Item 2 states, in
relevant part, the “session shall examine people for communicant
membership, urge communicant parents to present their children
for baptism, examine baptized children to see if they are ready

9 BOCO Item 6 provides, in relevant part, the “session shall
summon the offender[s] and the witness[es] among the church
members for investigation . . . . Where there is clear evidence
of the offense, the session should rebuke, reprimand, suspend,
keep from the communion table, dismiss from the church roll,
or excommunicate the unrepentant, as appropriate, and lift
discipline on the penitent.”

21
to receive communion, receive and issue letters of transfer
for those who have moved . . . , and even dismiss members.”
According to the Ko Faction, the phrase “even dismiss members”
granted the Session the authority to dismiss summarily any
Church member for any reason.
The Ko Faction further contends the trial court was
required to defer to the Session’s decision to dismiss members
under BOCO Item 2. According to the Ko Faction, the Session’s
authority to dismiss members under that provision is a “purely
ecclesiastical matter” that requires an extensive inquiry into
religious law, governance, and administration of the Church.
Moreover, the question of who should be a communicant member
of the Church is a question of religious law and administration.
Therefore, the United States Constitution precluded the trial
court from second guessing the Session’s decision to dismiss
members under BOCO Item 2. Thus, the Ko Faction contends,
the trial court erred to the extent it relied on the improper
dismissal of members to conclude the November 17, 2019
congregational meeting was invalid.
We will assume, for the sake of argument, that the
trial court erred to the extent it found the Ko Faction failed
to comply with the BOCO when it dismissed the 16 Church
members. Nevertheless, reversal is not required, because
the Ko Faction has not met its burden to show the error was
prejudicial. (See Cal. Const., art. VI, § 13 [a judgment cannot
be set aside unless “the error complained of has resulted in a
miscarriage of justice”]; Waller v. TJD, Inc. (1993) 12 Cal.App.4th
830, 833 [“Prejudice is not presumed, and the burden is on the
appealing party to demonstrate that a miscarriage of justice
has occurred.”].)

22
As the Ko Faction correctly points out, the First and
Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution
limit a state court’s authority to decide matters of religious law.
In Serbian Eastern Orthodox Diocese, etc. v. Milivojevich (1976)
426 U.S. 696, for example, the United States Supreme Court
reversed a state court decision setting aside a church’s defrocking
of a bishop. The state court held the defrocking was arbitrary
and invalid because the church did not comply with its internal
regulations. (Id. at p. 698.) In reversing the state court’s
decision, the United States Supreme Court explained the
“fallacy fatal to the judgment of the [state court] is that it rests
upon an impermissible rejection of the decisions of the highest
ecclesiastical tribunals of this hierarchical church upon the issues
in dispute, and impermissibly substitutes its own inquiry into
church polity and resolutions based thereon of those disputes. . . .
For where resolution of the disputes cannot be made without
extensive inquiry by civil courts into religious law and polity,
the First and Fourteenth Amendments mandate that civil courts
shall not disturb the decisions of the highest ecclesiastical
tribunal within a church of hierarchical polity, but must accept
such decisions as binding on them, in their application to the
religious issues of doctrine or polity before them.” (Id. at
pp. 708–709.)
California courts also have held civil courts must not
“entangle themselves in disputes over church doctrine or infringe
on the right to free exercise of religion.” (Episcopal Church Cases
(2009) 45 Cal.4th 467, 478.) Instead, civil courts must “defer
to the position of the highest ecclesiastical authority that has
decided the point.” (Id. at p. 485.) “Ecclesiastical matters”
subject to deference “include not only issues of religious doctrine

23
per se, but also issues of membership, clergy credentials and
discipline, and church polity and administration.” (New v.
Kroeger (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 800, 824 (Kroeger).) Moreover,
the “question of which faction represents the ‘true’ church
entitled to [church] property is an ecclesiastical matter in which
civil courts may not meddle.” (Metropolitan Philip v. Steiger
(2000) 82 Cal.App.4th 923, 925 (Metropolitan Philip); see
Huber v. Jackson (2009) 175 Cal.App.4th 663, 678 (Huber)
[pronouncement that some group of individuals is the true church
is an ecclesiastical matter].)
There are limited exceptions to the rule of judicial
deference on ecclesiastical matters. For example, state courts
may apply neutral principles of law to resolve internal church
disputes over ownership of church property. (Episcopal Church
Cases, supra, 45 Cal.4th at p. 485.) In doing so, “[t]he court
should consider sources such as the deeds to the property in
dispute, the local church’s articles of incorporation, the general
church’s constitution, canons, and rules, and relevant statutes.”
(Ibid.) However, “if resolution of a property dispute involves a
point of [religious] doctrine, the court must defer to the position
of the highest ecclesiastical authority that has decided the point.”
(Ibid.; see Kroeger, supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p. 817 [“if
resolution of a religious dispute determines the control or
possession of the property at issue, the sectarian authority’s
decision is not subject to judicial review”].)
Kim v. The True Church Members of Holy Hill Community
Church (2015) 236 Cal.App.4th 1435 (Kim) is instructive, and
its facts are remarkably similar to this case. Kim involved
a dispute between two factions vying for control of a Korean-
speaking Presbyterian church that owned valuable real estate

24
in Los Angeles. The church’s presbytery—the Western California
Presbytery (WCP)—appointed the appellants to leadership
positions within the church. However, the WCP later removed
the appellants from those positions and replaced them with the
respondents. The appellants reacted by calling a congregational
meeting at which they purported to withdraw the church from
the WCP. The WCP, in turn, excommunicated the appellants
and determined the congregational meeting was illegal. The
parties filed civil claims against each other, and the trial court
eventually entered judgment in favor of the respondents.
(See id., at pp. 1441–1444.)
On appeal, the appellants argued the trial court erred by
deferring to the WCP’s decisions. (Kim, supra, 236 Cal.App.4th
at p. 1448.) The appellants asserted the trial court should
have found the WCP lacked authority over them because they
had validly seceded from the organization. (Id. at p. 1449.)
The Court of Appeal rejected the appellants’ arguments and
affirmed the judgment. (Id. at p. 1441.) The court noted that,
“[w]hen a property dispute between two religious groups is
susceptible to the application of neutral principles of law, it is
proper for the civil courts to apply those principles to the dispute,
rather than deferring to the adjudicatory bodies of the relevant
ecclesiastical organizations.” (Id. at p. 1446.) However, that
exception to the general rule of ecclesiastical deference did not
apply because the parties’ disputes concerned church governance,
not church property. (See id. at p. 1448.) The court concluded
“the ecclesiastical rule of judicial deference to the highest
authority within a hierarchical church on questions of church
governance and church membership requires that we defer to
the WCP’s decision that appellants’ vote to secede did not comply

25
with BOCO, and that the WCP had authority to intervene.”
(Id. at p. 1449.)
Here, the Ko Faction’s appeal focuses on the validity of the
November 17, 2019 congregational meeting and the Church’s
purported withdrawal from the WKPC. Those issues, however,
can be traced back to a fundamental dispute over Church
governance. The undisputed evidence shows that dispute arose
on October 29, 2019, when the Hapdong Presbytery purported
to appoint Rev. Choi as senior pastor of the Church, replacing
Rev. Ko. The California Presbytery followed suit on November 8,
2019. Since then, the Ko Faction and the Choi Faction each
claim to represent the true Church.
The Ko Faction does not contest that the ecclesiastical rule
of judicial deference applies to the parties’ governance dispute.
Nor could it, as the dispute concerns issues of church governance
and membership, and its resolution requires inquiry into
religious law and polity. Accordingly, we must defer to the
highest authority within the Church’s hierarchy to have resolved
the dispute. (See Episcopal Church Cases, supra, 45 Cal.4th
at p. 485; Kim, supra, 236 Cal.App.4th at p. 1449; Kroeger,
supra, 167 Cal.App.4th at p. 824; Metropolitan Philip, supra,
82 Cal.App.4th at p. 925; Huber, supra, 175 Cal.App.4th
at p. 678.)
On that issue, the undisputed evidence shows the
Church was a member of the WKPC from 2014 until at least
November 17, 2019. Accordingly, there is no question the
Church was a member of the WKPC when the parties’
governance dispute arose. Nor is there any question that
the WKPC is a hierarchical religious organization and the
General Assembly is the highest authority within that hierarchy.

26
Therefore, to the extent the General Assembly resolved the
parties’ governance dispute, we must defer to its decision.
The Choi Faction maintains the General Assembly resolved
the parties’ dispute by confirming the Hapdong Presbytery’s
October 29, 2019 appointment of Rev. Choi as the Church’s
senior pastor. Although the Ko Faction does not directly contest
that point, the record on the issue is not entirely clear.
Nevertheless, there is no question that the General
Assembly determined at its June 2020 annual meeting that
the California Presbytery properly appointed Rev. Choi as the
Church’s interim senior pastor. That appointment occurred
on November 8, 2019. Under Chapter 8, Article 3 of the BOCO,
“[t]he pastor of the local church, by virtue of his office, is the
moderator of the session.” Therefore, under the General
Assembly’s decision, Rev. Choi became senior pastor of the
Church and moderator of the Session no later than November 8,
2019.
The Ko Faction does not meaningfully contest that the
General Assembly resolved the parties’ governance dispute at
its June 2020 annual meeting. Instead, it suggests the decision
is not binding because the Church withdrew from the WKPC
on November 17, 2019. However, the Ko Faction provides no
authority—civil or religious—to support its implicit assertion
that it could escape the General Assembly’s jurisdiction by
leaving the WKPC after the parties’ dispute had already arisen.
Absent such authority, we must defer to the General Assembly’s
determination that Rev. Choi became the Church’s senior pastor
and moderator of the Session no later than November 8, 2019.
That determination conclusively resolves the parties’ governance
dispute in favor of the Choi Faction.

27
The General Assembly’s decision also defeats the
Ko Faction’s arguments related to the November 17, 2019
congregational meeting. We are bound by the General
Assembly’s determination that Rev. Choi became Session
moderator no later than November 8, 2019, and it is undisputed
that there can be only one moderator of a session at a given time.
Therefore, we are compelled to conclude that any actions Rev. Ko
purported to take as moderator of the Session after November 8,
2019—including calling the November 9, 2019 special Session
meeting and the November 17, 2019 congregational meeting—
are ineffectual. Thus, we must conclude the Church did not
withdraw from the WKPC, regardless of whether the Ko Faction
complied with the BOCO when it dismissed the 16 Church
members on November 3, 2019. Accordingly, to the extent the
trial court erred in determining the Ko Faction failed to comply
with BOCO Item 6, the error is harmless and does not require
reversal of the judgment.10

10 To the extent the Ko Faction makes other arguments
related to the statement of decision, they fail for the same reason.

28
DISPOSITION
We affirm the judgment. Respondents are awarded
their costs on appeal.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

EGERTON, J.

We concur:

EDMON, P. J.

HANASONO, J.


Judge of the Los Angeles Superior Court, assigned by the
Chief Justice pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California
Constitution.

29

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.