Kavanaugh v. Klein CA2/5

CourtListener 10372373Calctapp03.04.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 4/3/25 Kavanaugh v. Klein CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION FIVE

RYAN KAVANAUGH, B327155

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No.
v. 21SMCV01868)

ETHAN KLEIN et al.,

Defendants and Appellants.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, H. Jay Ford III, Judge. Affirmed.
Heah Bar-Nissim and Rom Bar-Nissim for Defendants and
Appellants.
Novian & Novian, Farhad Novian and Lauren Woodland;
Meier Watkins Phillips Pusch, and Amy McCann Roller, for
Plaintiff and Respondent.
I. INTRODUCTION

Ryan Kavanaugh (Kavanaugh) brought an action against
Ethan Klein (Klein) and Ted Entertainment, Inc. (TEI)
(defendants) for defamation and defamation by implication
alleging they falsely accused him of running a Ponzi scheme.1
The trial court denied defendants’ anti-SLAPP2 motion to strike
Kavanaugh’s complaint. We affirm.

II. BACKGROUND

A. The Parties

Kavanaugh’s complaint alleges Kavanaugh is a film and
television producer, entertainment executive, and entrepreneur.

1 “‘A Ponzi scheme is a fraudulent investment scheme where
“[m]oney from the new investors is used directly to repay or pay
interest to old investors, [usually] without any operation or
revenue-producing activity other than the continual raising of
new funds.”’” (Peregrine Funding, Inc. v. Sheppard Mullin
Richter & Hampton LLP (2005) 133 Cal.App.4th 658, 666, fn. 1
(Peregrine Funding).)

2 “A ‘SLAPP’ is a ‘“strategic lawsuit against public
participation”’ [citation], and special motions to strike under
[Code of Civil Procedure] section 425.16 [(section 425.16)] are
commonly referred to as ‘[a]nti-SLAPP motions’ [citation].”
(Bonni v. St. Joseph Health System (2021) 11 Cal.5th 995, 1007,
fn. 1 (Bonni).) As we explain below, litigation of an anti-SLAPP
motion is a two-step process to determine if an action is meritless
and might chill the exercise of a defendant’s rights to speak and
petition on matters of public concern. (Id. at pp. 1008–1009.)

2
Kavanaugh’s media studio Proxima Media (Proxima) owns a
majority interest in Triller, Inc., a social media and
entertainment company that operates the video-sharing
application and social networking platform Triller. Triller, Inc. is
“affiliated” with Triller Fight Club II LLC (Triller Fight Club II),
a pay-per-view fight streaming service.
According to Kavanaugh’s complaint, Klein is a YouTube
content creator who produces and stars in videos. Through his
company TEI, Klein and his wife Hila Klein operate two YouTube
channels—“H3H3 Productions” and “H3 Podcast.” The videos
Klein produces and stars in air on those channels. In addition to
publishing Klein’s “various YouTube podcasts,” TEI also
publishes Klein’s “@h3h3productions” Twitter3 account.

B. The June 7, 2019, Variety Article

On June 7, 2019, Variety magazine published an article
entitled, “Ryan Kavanaugh Accused by Ex-Partner of Running a
Ponzi Scheme” (the Variety article.) The Variety article stated
Elon Spar filed a lawsuit against Kavanaugh in Los Angeles
Superior Court on June 6, 2019, alleging Kavanaugh persuaded
him to go into business with Kavanaugh under false pretenses.
Spar had developed an idea for a stock exchange in which buyers
could purchase equity in film projects. According to Spar’s
lawsuit, Kavanaugh falsely told Spar he had hundreds of millions
of dollars in commitments to finance films under Proxima.

3 Although Twitter has since been renamed “X,” we refer to
the platform as “Twitter,” the name of the platform at the time
this action was filed.

3
The Variety article quoted Spar’s complaint as alleging,
“‘Over time, as Kavanaugh withdrew and replaced one funding
proposal after another and each of his lies was exposed, it became
apparent to Spar that Kavanaugh was operating Proxima and its
related entities as essentially a Ponzi scheme, using meager new
investment capital to satisfy old debts, diverting corporate funds
for personal use (instead of paying his employees and
contractors), and manipulating the corporate books and records
to conceal his misrepresentations.’” The article attached a copy of
Spar’s verified complaint (the Spar complaint), which bore the
watermark, “UNFILED.”4
The Variety article stated Kavanaugh filed a lawsuit for
breach of contract against Spar after Spar filed his action.
Kavanaugh’s action alleged Proxima had invested $2 million into
the film stock exchange idea, but Spar wanted a bigger
commitment. That conflict led to a falling out between
Kavanaugh and Spar and Spar informed Kavanaugh he no longer
wanted to work with Kavanaugh on the project.
Within a day, Variety updated its article to inform its
readers that Kavanaugh’s representative sent Variety a

4 In support of their anti-SLAPP motion, defendants
submitted the declaration of Eriq Gardener, a journalist and
former employee of The Hollywood Reporter. In his declaration,
Gardner explained that the Los Angeles County Superior Court
has a media portal that enables members of the media to receive
instantaneous access to all court filings. Complaints accessed
through the portal that have been filed but are still being
processed have an “UNFILED” watermark on them. On or about
June 6, 2019, Gardner used the media portal to access the Spar
complaint and a complaint Kavanaugh filed against Spar. Spar’s
verified complaint had an “UNFILED” watermark on it.

4
statement that Kavanaugh and Spar had “‘satisfactorily resolved
all of their issues.’” According to Variety, the statement accused
Variety and The Hollywood Reporter of attempting to smear
Kavanaugh and Spar by quoting from their lawsuits against each
other. The statement claimed the dueling complaints “‘were
private documents’” that “‘went public’” by “‘mistake.’” Neither
complaint “‘was intended to be legally filed’”—they were
“submitted to the court by accident.”
The Variety update included a retraction from Spar.
According to Variety, “Spar apparently has some regrets . . . ,
saying that Kavanaugh is not really running a Ponzi scheme, as
he alleged in his suit . . . .” According to Spar, “‘[Kavanaugh] has
been funding the ESX operation himself . . . . To my knowledge
based on information provided to me, [Kavanaugh] has and is
investing heavily in this business and any reference to ESX or
any related business as a “Ponzi Scheme” is not accurate. He is a
visionary thinker and I wish him the best of luck in his future
endeavors. He and I have no remaining disputes.’”5

5 On appeal, defendants label the statement from
Kavanaugh’s representative and Spar’s retraction, as reflected in
the updated Variety article as the “Hearsay Statements.” They
contend the trial court improperly relied on these inadmissible
statements. In their trial court papers in support of their anti-
SLAPP motion and at oral argument, defendants characterized
the representative’s statement and Spar’s retraction as hearsay
but did not object to the admission of the updated Variety article
that included the statements. Accordingly, to the extent
defendants contend the court erred in admitting the updated
Variety article, defendants have forfeited their argument on
appeal. (Evid. Code, § 353, subd. (a) [“A verdict or finding shall
not be set aside, nor shall the judgment or decision based thereon
be reversed, by reason of the erroneous admission of evidence

5
C. Triller Fight Club II’s Copyright Action

On April 17, 2021, Triller Fight Club II broadcast a pay-
per-view fight and music event. On April 22, 2021, TEI used part
of the broadcast in a podcast episode. On April 29, 2021, Triller
Fight Club II brought an action against defendants (sued under
the names “H3H3 Productions” and “The H3 Podcast”) and others
for copyright infringement and other claims over the use of the
broadcast footage (the copyright action). Kavanaugh was not a
party to the copyright action, but Klein believed Kavanaugh was
“behind” and financing it.

D. The Alleged Defamatory Publications

Kavanaugh’s complaint alleges that beginning on June 11,
2021, Klein launched a campaign to harass and defame him in

unless: [¶] (a) There appears of record an objection to or a
motion to exclude or to strike the evidence that was timely made
and so stated as to make clear the specific ground of the objection
or motion”]; Duronslet v. Kamps (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 717, 725
[the failure to object to the admission of hearsay documents in
the trial court forfeits the issue on appeal]; In re Marriage of
Kerry (1984) 158 Cal.App.3d 456, 466 [the failure to object to the
admission of an affidavit as hearsay “waives the defect[ ], and the
affidavit becomes competent evidence”].)
In any event, defendants’ argument fails on the merits.
The trial court did not consider the updated Variety article for the
truth of the matters asserted, i.e., that the verified complaint was
filed by mistake and Kavanaugh was not running a Ponzi
scheme. Instead, the court referred to the statements in the
updated Variety article to show that Klein knew that “the factual
basis for his statements was both incorrect and incomplete.”

6
retaliation for Triller Fight Club II’s copyright action. Klein used
his YouTube channels and other social media platforms to
disseminate the defamatory accusation in the Variety article that
Kavanaugh ran a Ponzi scheme. Within hours of its publication
in Variety, that accusation had been retracted and the article had
been corrected. Klein knew of the retraction and correction but
repeatedly republished the false accusation over the following
months. Kavanaugh’s defamation and defamation by implication
causes of action are based on the following alleged podcast
statements and tweets identified in paragraphs 68 through 80 of
the complaint (the challenged statements)6:
“68. In a June 11, 2021 episode of H3 After Dark titled
‘And the Number of Babies Is . . .’ (#40), Klein said:
“a. ‘According to his ex-partner he runs a Ponzi scheme.
That sounds super illegal. Shady. That’s not who I’d want
running my business. Triller.’
“b. ‘And according to his ex-partner he was running a
Ponzi scheme. Like, come on bro. Imagine being Ryan
Kavanaugh, according to LA Magazine, I don’t want to be sued so
yeah. I’m not saying that.’
“69. In a July 1, 2021 episode of Off The Rails titled
‘Trisha’s Apology & Ace Family Scam’ (#3), Klein said:
“a. ‘Triller lies about their numbers. So who knows?
Allegedly, what do I know? I know this guy, Ryan Kavanaugh is
a piece of shit. I mean, he’s run a Ponzi scheme allegedly from
his partner. So of course the guy is capable of lying as we all are,
but he’s allegedly, according to his partner, Ryan Kavanaugh,
owner of Triller, Ryan Kavanaugh, look them up. Owner of

6 We omit plaintiff’s footnotes that provide web addresses for
the challenged statements.

7
Triller, scammer, allegedly peace and love. According to his
partner this guy’s suing me by the way, what was I talking
about?’
“b. ‘Ryan Kavanaugh, he’s the owner of Triller. He was
the CEO of like a big, uh, I forget the name of it, but he like, they
went bank, like super bankrupt. Super bankrupt. And then he
like got Triller involved and like he was accused of running a
Ponzi scheme. He’s got a really dark history. I read this online.
This is not me saying this. Right.’
“c. ‘The owner Ryan Kavanaugh is such a nasty piece of
shit . . . [his] business partner alleged he [ran] a Ponzi scheme if
you believe that.’
“d. ‘Ryan Kavanaugh accused by ex-partner of running a
Ponzi scheme. What a dude who runs a one-star app. Wow.’
“e. ‘Wow. Shady as fuck. And you know, I heard this
guy’s looking to go public with Triller. That’d be a horrible idea
for people to invest in Triller.’
“f. ‘Here he is. Ponzi scheme. I first read, he ran a
Ponzi scheme in [Variety] by his ex-partner. Yeah, here he is.
Ryan Kavanaugh.’
“g. ‘Serious guy. He’s a film and TV producer,
entrepreneur and Ponzi scheme enthusiast. Wait, no, sorry.
That was what his ex-partner said. No, it’s not alleged. His ex-
partner did say that. Well he made the allegation. Yeah. He
said he was running a Ponzi scheme. He was making an
allegation, but okay. You get the idea.’
“h. ‘The suit alleges. That’s literally what the Fyre
festival guy did.’
“70. In a July 2, 2021 episode of H3 After Dark titled
‘James Charles Returns & Baby Update’ (#43), Klein said:

8
“a. ‘Who allegedly runs a Ponzi scheme, according to his
ex-partner.’
“b. ‘This is Ryan Kavanaugh, uh, he’s like the, basically,
the owner of Triller and uh, his he’s been accused of by his
partner of running Zynga, Ponzi scam. And he bankrupted
Relativity. He’s just awesome because now he’s trying to build
Triller and he wants to go public. And it’s like, dude, you
bankrupted your last company. And you’ve been accused of
running a Ponzi scheme. It’s awesome. And this is the guy who’s
suing us.’
“c. ‘Ryan Kavanaugh, the owner of Triller. Who’s like,
who his partner says he’s like been involved in a Ponzi scam.’
“d. ‘This is really getting around at this guy. Ryan
Kavanaugh was accused of running a Ponzi scheme. It seems
like Ryan Kavanaugh was a really bad guy.’
“e. ‘Also, I heard that Ryan, Ryan Kavanaugh was
involved in a Ponzi scheme, according to his former business
partner.’
“f. ‘There’s the image of the, uh, Ryan Kavanaugh
accused by ex-partner of running a Ponzi scheme.’
“71. On July 8, 2021, Klein tweeted: ‘Every time I think
of Ryan Kavanaugh, I think of his business partner alleging he
was involved in a Ponzi scheme.’ Klein then re-tweeted his tweet
using the H3 Podcast Twitter account, which has more than
300,000 followers. [The complaint includes a screenshot of the
retweeted tweet which includes a photograph of the Variety
article headline, “Ryan Kavanaugh Accused by Ex-Partner of
Running a Ponzi Scheme,” with a photograph of Kavanaugh
beneath it.]

9
“72. On July 8, 2021 Klein tweeted: ‘I don’t know if [J]ake
[Paul] left because of Ryan Kavanaugh specifically but he
definitely thought showtime was a better opportunity than triller,
and I’m not surprised since the owner Ryan Kavanaugh was
accused by his ex-partner of running a Ponzi scheme as published
by variety[.]’ [The complaint includes a photograph of the tweet.]
“73. In a July 8, 2021 episode of Off The Rails titled ‘The
Biggest Scam in YouTube History’ (#4), Klein said:
“a. ‘Uh, this is the article that Variety published about
[Kavanaugh]. You can see, it says Variety here. It’s kind of like
a, it’s a, there’s a timestamp here. It’s kinda hard to see it. Or
like how would you call it? Watermark is right. But anyway, it
says Ryan Kavanaugh accused by ex-partner of running a Ponzi
scheme. So in open court . . . .’
“b. ‘Because allegedly, if it’s true, what his ex-business
partner said about him running a Ponzi scheme, it would mean
that he was comfortable deceiving people.’
“c. ‘Uh, Ryan accused by ex-partner of running a Ponzi
scheme, right? That was the Variety headline.’
“d. ‘Show the picture. Ryan Kavanaugh . . . He
apparently he’s bankrupted his previous companies and was
accused of creating a Ponzi scheme by his previous business
partner. How does he have investors? Are they just 20
something? Trust fund babies.’
“e. ‘Was that guy [a] scammer? I think he was just a,
maybe that wasn’t a scam it. Yeah. Oh, well maybe sort of like, I
don’t know what exactly Ryan Kavanaugh did, but he did
apparently according to his ex-partner written in Variety of
running a Ponzi scheme. Right?’

10
“f. ‘But if I would say running a Ponzi scheme based on
his ex-partner’s allegations and open court in Variety, that’s off
the rails.’
“74. Klein filmed the July 8 episode of Off The Rails in
front of a photograph of Mr. Kavanaugh with a caption that
repeats the false and defamatory Ponzi scheme claim. Klein
appears to have altered the font size of the Variety article
headline in the image hanging behind him to de-emphasize the
words, ‘Accused by Ex-Partner.’ [The complaint includes a
screenshot of the podcast including a photograph of the allegedly
altered Variety article headline with a photograph of Kavanaugh
beneath it.]
“75. On July 11, 2021, Klein posted an Instagram story
purporting to depict the Variety article beneath a headline
asking: ‘DO YOU GUYS KNOW THAT RYAN KAVANAUGH
WAS ACCUSED BY EX-PARTNER OF RUNNING A PONZI
SCHEME?’
“76. In a July 15, 2021 episode of Off The Rails titled ‘im
sorry hila’ (#5), Klein said:
“a. ‘Welcome back everybody, uh, to the, the Ryan
Kavanaugh accused by ex-partner of running a Ponzi scheme
podcast.’
“b. ‘Ryan’s this one from the Variety article over here in
there, accused by ex-partner of running a Ponzi scheme, which
we’ve now clarified was under oath.’
“77. A July 29, episode of H3 After Dark titled ‘Hila Is
Back . . . And She’s Being Sued’ (#45), featured the following
exchange:
“a. Hila Klein: ‘You may have heard of Ryan.’
“Ethan Klein: ‘And his bankruptcy.’

11
“Hila Klein: ‘And he doesn’t always pay people.’
“Ethan Klein: ‘There’s like a thousand debtors from
the bankruptcy. I don’t know if you heard but Ryan Kavanaugh,
this man here, is accused by his Ex- Partner of running a Ponzi
scheme.’
“Podcast Manager: ‘That was reported in Variety.’
“78. During these remarks, a producer held up this photo
in the background: [The complaint includes a screenshot of the
podcast and appears to include the same photograph of
Kavanaugh beneath the allegedly altered Variety article headline
that was included in paragraph 74 of the complaint.]
“79. Klein began selling t-shirts to fans that appear to
depict Mr. Kavanaugh as a criminal defendant, doubling down on
his defamatory suggestion that Mr. Kavanagh runs a criminal
enterprise: [The complaint includes a depiction of the t-shirt
which shows a person sitting at a table apparently in front of a
judge.]
“80. Klein’s statements were intended to and did falsely
convey that Mr. Kavanaugh engaged in criminal conduct by
running a Ponzi scheme. Further, circumstances show that
Mr. Klein intended this t-shirt to imply that Mr. Kavanaugh was
guilty of financial crimes because during a September 3 episode
of H3 After Dark, Klein proposed various t-shirt ideas and asked
fans to vote on them, including a t-shirt featuring Mr.
Kavanagh’s likeness with the word ‘SCAM’ written above it. This
was the design that received the most votes.”

12
E. Defendants’ Anti-SLAPP Motion

Defendants moved to dismiss Kavanaugh’s action “in its
entirety” as a SLAPP suit. Defendants contended that “(a) each
and every cause of action in the Complaint arises from protected
activity as defined by . . . Section 425.16 (e); and (b) Kavanaugh
cannot meet his burden to demonstrate a probability of prevailing
as to any cause of action in the Complaint.”
The trial court denied defendants’ anti-SLAPP motion. As
to the first prong of defendants’ motion, the court found
Kavanaugh’s action arose from activity protected by section
425.16, subdivisions (e)(3) and (e)(4). Defendants established
Kavanaugh and his business dealings, including those with Spar,
were issues of widespread public interest and the challenged
statements were made on public forums—YouTube channels and
Twitter.
As to the second prong of defendants’ motion, the trial court
found Kavanaugh met his burden to show sufficient facts to
sustain a favorable judgment on his defamation and defamation
by implication claims. Kavanaugh presented evidence of a prima
facie case that the challenged statements were false assertions of
fact and defendants’ evidence failed to establish the statements’
truth as a matter of law. Further, Kavanaugh presented prima
facie evidence of actual malice and defendants’ evidence failed to
establish the absence of malice as a matter of law. Finally, the
court found defendants failed to meet their burden to show the
challenged statements were fair and true reports of judicial
proceedings privileged under Civil Code section 47, subdivision
(d) (section 47(d)).

13
III. DISCUSSION

Defendants assert and Kavanaugh does not dispute the
trial court properly found defendants’ challenged statements
were protected activity under section 425.16, subdivisions (e)(3)
and (e)(4) of the anti-SLAPP statute—i.e., that defendants
satisfied the first step of the two-step litigation process of an anti-
SLAPP motion. Accordingly, this appeal concerns the court’s
finding on the second step of the anti-SLAPP process.
Defendants contend the court erred in finding Kavanaugh
satisfied the second step because his action against them does not
have even minimal merit as he cannot show the challenged
statements were (1) assertions of fact, (2) false, or (3) made with
actual malice. Defendants further contend the challenged
statements were protected under the fair and true report
privilege in section 47(d).

A. Legal Principles

1. Defamation

The elements of a defamation cause of action are: (1) a
publication that is (2) false, (3) defamatory, and (4) unprivileged,
and (5) has a natural tendency to injure or that causes special
damage. (Taus v. Loftus (2007) 40 Cal.4th 683, 720.) When the
defamation plaintiff is a public figure, the plaintiff also must
prove the defendant made the defamatory statement with actual
malice. (Reader’s Digest Assn. v. Superior Court (1984) 37 Cal.3d
244, 256 (Reader’s Digest).)

14
2. Defamation by Implication

If a defendant “juxtaposes [a] series of facts so as to imply a
defamatory connection between them, or [otherwise] creates a
defamatory implication . . . he may be held responsible for the
defamatory implication, . . . even though the particular facts are
correct. [Citation.]” (Issa v. Applegate (2019) 31 Cal.App.5th 689,
703, internal quotations omitted (Issa).) “In a case in which a
plaintiff seeks to maintain an action for defamation by
implication, the plaintiff must demonstrate that (1) his or her
interpretation of the statement is reasonable; (2) the implication
or implications to be drawn convey defamatory facts, not
opinions; (3) the challenged implications are not ‘“substantially
true”’; and (4) the identified reasonable implications could also be
reasonably deemed defamatory. [Citation.]” (Id. at p. 707.)

3. Anti-SLAPP

“The anti-SLAPP statute is ‘designed to protect defendants
from meritless lawsuits that might chill the exercise of their
rights to speak and petition on matters of public concern.
[Citations.] To that end, the statute authorizes a special motion
to strike a claim “arising from any act of that person in
furtherance of the person’s right of petition or free speech under
the United States Constitution or the California Constitution in
connection with a public issue.” (§ 425.16, subd. (b)(1).)’ (Wilson
[v. Cable News Network, Inc. (2019)] 7 Cal.5th [871,] 883–884.)
“Litigation of an anti-SLAPP motion involves a two-step
process. First, ‘the moving defendant bears the burden of
establishing that the challenged allegations or claims “aris[e]

15
from” protected activity in which the defendant has engaged.’
(Park [v. Board of Trustees of California State University (2017)]
2 Cal.5th [1057,] 1061 [(Park)].) Second, for each claim that does
arise from protected activity, the plaintiff must show the claim
has ‘at least “minimal merit.”’ (Ibid.) If the plaintiff cannot
make this showing, the court will strike the claim.” (Bonni,
supra, 11 Cal.5th at pp. 1008–1009.)
“[A]t the second anti-SLAPP step, ‘“a plaintiff responding to
an anti-SLAPP motion must ‘“state[ ] and substantiate[ ] a legally
sufficient claim.”’ [Citation.] Put another way, the plaintiff ‘must
demonstrate that the complaint is both legally sufficient and
supported by a sufficient prima facie showing of facts to sustain a
favorable judgment if the evidence submitted by the plaintiff is
credited.’” [Citation.] “. . . However, we neither ‘weigh credibility
[nor] compare the weight of the evidence. Rather, [we] accept as
true the evidence favorable to the plaintiff [citation] and evaluate
the defendant’s evidence only to determine if it has defeated that
submitted by the plaintiff as a matter of law.’”’ [Citation.]”
(Monster Energy Co. v. Schechter (2019) 7 Cal.5th 781, 791–792.)
“[A] plaintiff’s burden at the second anti-SLAPP step is a low one,
requiring only a showing that a cause of action has at least
‘minimal merit within the meaning of the anti-SLAPP statute.’
[Citation.]” (Id. at p. 793.) “Only a cause of action that lacks
‘even minimal merit’ constitutes a SLAPP.” (Overstock.com, Inc.
v. Gradient Analytics, Inc. (2007) 151 Cal.App.4th 688, 700.)
We review the grant or denial of an anti-SLAPP motion de
novo. (Park, supra, 2 Cal.5th at p. 1067.)

16
B. Analysis

1. Assertions of Fact

“‘The sine qua non of recovery for defamation . . . is the
existence of falsehood.’ [Citation.] Because the statement must
contain a provable falsehood, courts distinguish between
statements of fact and statements of opinion for purposes of
defamation liability. Although statements of fact may be
actionable as libel, statements of opinion [generally] are
constitutionally protected. [Citation.]” (McGarry v. University of
San Diego (2007) 154 Cal.App.4th 97, 112; Taus v. Loftus, supra,
40 Cal.4th at p. 720; Issa, supra, 31 Cal.App.5th at p. 702.)
“[I]n ascertaining whether the statement in question is
sufficiently communicative of provable falsity or actual fact to
subject the defendant to liability, courts . . . consider the ‘“totality
of the circumstances. . . . First, the language of the statement is
examined. For words to be defamatory, they must be understood
in a defamatory sense. . . . [¶] Next, the context in which the
statement was made must be considered. . . . [¶] This contextual
analysis demands that the courts look at the nature and full
content of the communication and to the knowledge and
understanding of the audience to whom the publication was
directed.”’ [Citations.]” (Kahn v. Bower (1991) 232 Cal.App.3d
1599, 1608; Issa, supra, 31 Cal.App.5th at p. 703.)
“[C]onstitutional protection has been accorded ‘“rhetorical
hyperbole,” “vigorous epithet[s],” “lusty and imaginative
expression[s] of . . . contempt,” and language used “in a loose,
figurative sense”’ [citations] . . . .” (Wilbanks v. Wolk (2004) 121
Cal.App.4th 883, 902.) However, “such communications may be

17
actionable if they convey false and defamatory information.”
(Ibid.)
The evidence shows defendants intended the challenged
statements to be viewed as assertions of fact by their audience.
They emphasized that Kavanaugh’s “ex-partner” Spar alleged
Kavanaugh ran a Ponzi scheme. A person viewing defendants’
podcasts or tweets reasonably would assume that Spar, who
worked with Kavanaugh on the ESX project, was in a position to
know if Kavanaugh was running a Ponzi scheme.
Defendants also sought to bolster the veracity of the
challenged statements by stating they were published in Variety.
In the June 11, 2021, podcast, after directing his viewers to
Variety’s website where they could find the Variety article, Klein
said, “That’s written—that was written by Variety, which is like
a pretty—that’s like a reputable, you know . . . .” Later, during
the July 1, 2021, podcast, Klein again directed his viewers to the
Variety’s website and a podcast member stated, “Why, Variety,
that’s one of the two major trade papers in the entertainment
industry. They’re very reputable.”
Defendants do not avoid liability for their factual assertions
that Kavanaugh ran a Ponzi scheme because they relied on
Spar’s allegation in his complaint or the Variety article’s initial
report (but not the updated article) on that allegation. (Gilman v.
McClatchy (1896) 111 Cal. 606, 612 [“If A says B is a thief, and C
publishes the statement that A said B was a thief, in a certain
sense this would be the truth, but not in the sense that the law
means. It would constitute no defense to C, for it would be but a
repetition by him of a slanderous charge. His defense must
consist in showing that in fact B is a thief”]; (Ringler Associates
Inc. v. Maryland Casualty Co. (2000) 80 Cal.App.4th 1165, 1180

18
[“when a person repeats a slanderous charge, even though
identifying the source . . . , this constitutes republication and has
the same effect as the original publication of the slander”]; Ray v.
Citizen-News Co. (1936) 14 Cal.App.2d 6, 8–9 [“A false statement
is not less libelous because it is the repetition of rumor or gossip
or of statements or allegations that others have made concerning
the matter”].)
The challenged statements’ context also supports a finding
that defendants intended the challenged statements to be viewed
as assertions of fact by their audience. Defendants’ campaign
against Kavanaugh was based on their belief he was behind and
financing Triller Fight Club’s copyright action against them.
Defendants used the Ponzi scheme allegation to undermine in the
minds of their audience the credibility of the person they believed
was behind the copyright action.
Defendants’ contention that the “audience interpreted
[defendants’] statements as a meme,”7 even if true, is unavailing.
(Polygram Records, Inc. v. Superior Court (1985) 170 Cal.App.3d
543, 552, fn. 11 [acknowledging that it is often true that “‘humor
typically is understood to be humor and to convey no serious
factual allegations about its object,’ [citation]” but explaining that
“‘humor . . . can give rise to causes of action for defamation’
[citation] and that humor is actionable where ‘it is used to make a

7 A “meme” is “an amusing or interesting item (such as a
captioned picture or video) or genre of items that is spread widely
online especially through social media.” (Merriam-Webster
Online Dict. <https://www.merriam-
webster.com/dictionary/meme> [as of Mar. 28, 2025], archived at
<https://perma.cc/Z48H-DEKY>.) The length of the broadcasts
and statements suggest that the audience did not interpret the
statements as a “meme.”

19
defamatory point.’ [Citation.] In short, . . . ‘“‘The principle is
clear that a person shall not be allowed to murder another’s
reputation in jest’”’ and that ‘“‘[if] a man in jest conveys a serious
imputation, he jests at his peril.’”’ [Citations.]”].)
Accordingly, Kavanaugh presented sufficient evidence to
establish a prima facie case that the challenged statements were
assertions of fact, and defendants do not identify sufficient
evidence that disproves the challenged statements are assertions
of fact as a matter of law.

2. Falsity

“A public figure . . . who seeks to recover damages for a
defamatory statement bears the burden of proving that the
challenged statement was false. [Citation.] The plaintiff cannot
be said to have carried this burden so long as the statement
appears substantially true. To bar liability, ‘“it is sufficient if the
substance of the charge be proved true, irrespective of slight
inaccuracy in the details.” [Citations.] . . . [Citation.] . . . Minor
inaccuracies do not amount to falsity so long as “the substance,
the gist, the sting, of the libelous charge be justified.” [Citations.]
Put another way, the statement is not considered false unless it
“would have a different effect on the mind of the reader from that
which the pleaded truth would have produced.” [Citations.]’
[Citation.]” (Vogel v. Felice (2005) 127 Cal.App.4th 1006, 1021,
fn. omitted.)
“[M]ere assertions that a statement is ‘false,’ even in sworn
declarations, do not satisfy a plaintiff’s burden to demonstrate
falsity. . . . [T]he ‘simple negation of the challenged statement
fails to fairly meet its substance.’ [Citation.]” (Industrial Waste

20
& Debris Box Service, Inc. v. Murphy (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 1135,
1159 (Industrial Waste).)
In his opposition to defendants’ anti-SLAPP motion,
Kavanaugh contended defendants’ claim he was running a Ponzi
scheme was false. Kavanaugh supported this contention with his
July 9, 2019, and March 25, 2022, declarations and a declaration
from Michael Lambert, his partner in Proxima. In his July 9,
2019, declaration, Kavanaugh stated he was not running a Ponzi
scheme and he and Lambert fully funded Proxima during the
time he and Spar were working together to launch ESX. As of
July 8, 2019, Kavanaugh bought Lambert’s interest in Proxima
using only his own capital. In his March 25, 2022, declaration,
Kavanaugh stated he was not running and had never run a Ponzi
scheme. He and Lambert fully funded Proxima which funded
ESX and he eventually purchased Lambert’s interest in Proxima
using only his own capital. Lambert stated in his March 25,
2022, declaration that prior to July 8, 2019, he was an investor in
Proxima and/or related entities that owned ESX. Lambert and
Kavanaugh and entities Lambert controlled fully funded Proxima
without any additional investors. As of July 8, 2019, Kavanaugh
“bought out” Lambert’s “interest in Proxima, after which
[Kavanaugh] was the sole investor.”
Kavanaugh’s declarations alone were sufficient to meet his
prima facie showing that the challenged statements are false.
(Burrill v. Nair (2013) 217 Cal.App.4th 357, 389 [in an anti-
SLAPP case, the plaintiff’s declaration denying a claim of perjury
was “a sufficient prima facie showing that the accusations [were]
false”]; see Briganti v. Chow (2019) 42 Cal.App.5th 504, 509–510,
fn. omitted [the plaintiff’s declaration that she “has never been
convicted of, or indicted for, any crime, and she has not stolen

21
thousands of innocent victims’ identities” was sufficient to
support a prima facie case of defamation in anti-SLAPP
proceeding].) Not only did Kavanaugh’s declarations deny the
general charge that he ran a Ponzi scheme, they also explained
why the charge was false—he and Lambert fully funded Proxima
and he alone purchased Lambert’s interest in Proxima.
Accordingly, there was no money from new Proxima investors
that could be used to repay or to pay interest to old Proxima
investors as part of a Ponzi scheme. (See Peregrine Funding,
supra, 133 Cal.App.4th at p. 666, fn. 1.) Thus, Kavanaugh’s
denials that he was running or ever ran a Ponzi scheme were not
the sort of “mere assertions” or “simple negations” Industrial
Waste rejected. (Industrial Waste, supra, 4 Cal.App.5th at
p. 1159.)
Moreover, apart from Kavanaugh’s declarations, Lambert’s
declaration concerning the funding of Proxima and ESX supports
a prima facie case that the claim Kavanaugh ran a Ponzi scheme
was false. Lambert stated that Kavanaugh and entities Lambert
controlled fully funded Proxima without any additional investors,
he was an investor in Proxima and/or related entities that owned
ESX, and Kavanaugh “bought out” Lambert’s “interest in
Proxima, after which [Kavanaugh] was the sole investor.”
Defendants do not identify sufficient evidence that
disproves the falsity of the challenged statements as a matter of
law.

3. Actual Malice

To prove a defendant made a defamatory statement with
“actual malice” a plaintiff must show the defendant knew the

22
statement was false or made the statement with reckless
disregard of whether it was false or not. (Reader’s Digest, supra,
37 Cal.3d at p. 256.)8 A defendant acts with reckless disregard if
the defendant “‘made the false publication with a “high degree of
awareness of . . . probable falsity,” [citation], or . . . “entertained
serious doubts as to the truth of his publication,” [citation].’”
(Young, supra, 212 Cal.App.4th at pp. 562–563.)
In assessing actual malice, we apply a “subjective test,
under which the defendant’s actual belief concerning the
truthfulness of the publication is the crucial issue. [Citation.]
This test directs attention to the ‘defendant’s attitude toward the
truth or falsity of the material published . . . [not] the defendant’s
attitude toward the plaintiff.’ [Citation.]” (Reader’s Digest,
supra, 37 Cal.3d at p. 257.) “Although the ultimate issue is thus
the good faith of the publisher, . . . a defendant cannot
‘automatically insure a favorable verdict by testifying that he
published with a belief that the statements were true. The finder
of fact must determine whether the publication was indeed made
in good faith.” (Ibid.)
Actual malice may be proved by circumstantial evidence.
(Reader’s Digest, supra, 37 Cal.3d at p. 257.) “‘[Evidence] of
negligence, of motive and of intent may be adduced for the

8 “In opposing an anti-SLAPP motion, a defamation plaintiff
need not establish malice by clear and convincing evidence, the
standard applicable at trial. Rather, the plaintiff must meet [his]
minimal burden by introducing sufficient facts to establish a
prima facie case of actual malice; in other words, [he] must
establish a reasonable probability that [he] can produce clear and
convincing evidence showing that the statements were made with
actual malice. [Citation.]” (Young v. CBS Broadcasting, Inc.
(2012) 212 Cal.App.4th 551, 563 (Young).)

23
purpose of establishing, by cumulation and by appropriate
inferences, the fact of a defendant’s recklessness or of his
knowledge of falsity.’ [Citations.]” (Ibid.) Evidence of a
defendant’s “failure to investigate,” “anger and hostility toward
the plaintiff,” and “reliance upon sources known to be . . . biased
against the plaintiff” may, “in an appropriate case, indicate that
the publisher himself had serious doubts regarding the truth of
his publication.” (Id. at p. 258, fn. omitted.) “[S]uch evidence is
relevant only to the extent that it reflects on the subjective
attitude of the publisher.” (Ibid.)
A publisher acts with reckless disregard of whether a
statement is true or false when it is aware of true, crucial facts
but decides to leave them out of its statement and thereby creates
a false impression. (Montandon v. Triangle Publications, Inc.
(1975) 45 Cal.App.3d 938, 944, 949 (Montandon).) Such evidence
“is proof of convincing clarity” and supports a finding that the
statement was “published not in good faith, but with actual
malice.” (Id. at p. 944; Fisher v. Larsen (1982) 138 Cal.App.3d
627, 642 (Fisher) [triable issue of fact on summary judgment as to
actual malice when, “Although [the defendant] says she relied on
media accounts, including the false report in [another defendant
reporter’s] article detailing [the plaintiff’s] march with the
[illegally] striking teachers . . . , she ignores [the plaintiff’s]
published, repeated denials of support for teachers’ strikes and
the editorial apology for the [reporter defendant’s]
misstatements”].)
Kavanaugh presented sufficient evidence to establish a
prima facie case of actual malice. The Variety article, including
the update with the statement from Kavanaugh’s representative
and Spar’s retraction, was published in June 2019. Two years

24
later, defendants, who admitted in their broadcast to being angry
with Kavanaugh about Triller Fight Club II’s copyright action
against them, began their retaliatory campaign against
Kavanaugh which included their allegations that he ran a Ponzi
scheme. Defendants’ campaign, however, omitted, in almost all
instances,9 the true and crucial facts that Variety updated its
article to reflect that according to Kavanaugh’s representative,
neither Kavanaugh nor Spar intended their complaints to be
“legally filed” and Spar retracted his allegation. Defendants’
omission “is proof of convincing clarity” that supports a finding
defendants’ Ponzi scheme statements were not published in good
faith but with actual malice. (Montandon, supra, 45 Cal.App.3d
at p. 944; Fisher, supra, 138 Cal.App.3d at p. 642.)
Defendants do not identify sufficient evidence that shows a
lack of actual malice as a matter of law.

4. Fair and True Report Privilege

“Under section 47[(d)][10], the fair and true reporting
privilege protects a ‘fair and true report in, or a communication
to, a public journal, of . . . a judicial . . . proceeding, or . . . [of]
anything said in the course thereof.’ It . . . is an absolute
privilege—that is, it applies regardless of the defendants’ motive

9 Defendants concede that in “most instances” they did not
discuss Spar’s retraction.

10 Section 47(d) provides that “[a] privileged publication or
broadcast is one made: [¶] . . . [¶] (1) By a fair and true report
in . . . a public journal, of (A) a judicial . . . proceeding, or (D) of
anything said in the course thereof . . . .”

25
for making the report—and forecloses a plaintiff from showing a
probability of prevailing on the merits. [Citation.]” (Argentieri v.
Zuckerberg (2017) 8 Cal.App.5th 768, 787 (Argentieri).)
“To be fair and true, the report must [capture] the
substance, the gist or sting, of the subject proceedings as
measured by considering the natural and probable effect [of the
report] on the mind of the average reader. [Citation.] The
defendant is entitled to a certain degree of flexibility/literary
license in this regard, such that the privilege will apply even if
there is a slight inaccuracy in details—one that does not lead the
reader to be affected differently by the report than he or she
would be by the actual truth. [Citation.]” (Argentieri, supra, 8
Cal.App.5th at pp. 787–788, internal quotations omitted.)
“California courts have construed the phrase, ‘judicial
proceeding,’ broadly to include the filing of a complaint.
[Citations.] Thus, fair and true communications to the news
media about allegations in a complaint are covered by the
privilege. [Citation.]” (Healthsmart Pacific, Inc. v. Kabateck
(2016) 7 Cal.App.5th 416, 432.)
Assuming without deciding the Spar complaint was part of
a judicial proceeding and the challenged statements were made
in public journals, we nevertheless hold the fair and true report
privilege does not apply to the statements quoted in the
complaint that are alleged to be defamatory.11 Defendants’

11 “There is some dispute in the case law as to which party
bears the burden of proof on an affirmative defense in the context
of an anti-SLAPP motion. Some cases state that ‘although
section 425.16 places on the plaintiff the burden of substantiating
its claims, a defendant that advances an affirmative defense to
such claims properly bears the burden of proof on the defense.

26
statements that Kavanaugh’s partner accused him of running a
Ponzi scheme were not fair and true because, as they concede,
they omitted, in almost all instances, the context that Variety
published an updated article stating that neither Kavanaugh nor
Spar intended their complaints to be “legally filed” and Spar
retracted his allegation. Spar had explained, “‘[Kavanaugh] has
been funding the ESX operation himself . . . . To my knowledge
based on information provided to me, [Kavanaugh] has and is
investing heavily in this business and any reference to ESX or
any related business as a “Ponzi Scheme” is not accurate.’”
Without Spar’s retraction, defendants’ reports led the listener “to
be affected differently by the report[s] than he or she would be by
the actual truth.” (Argentieri, supra, 8 Cal.App.5th at p. 788.)
Thus, the fair and true report privilege does not apply to the
complained of statements.

[Citation.]’ ([E.g., ]Peregrine Funding, [supra,] 133 Cal.App.4th
[at p.] 676.) Others suggest that the litigation privilege presents
‘“a substantive defense a plaintiff must overcome to demonstrate
a probability of prevailing. [Citations.]” [Citation.]’ (Feldman v.
1100 Park Lane Associates (2008) 160 Cal.App.4th 1467, 1485.)”
(Dickinson v. Cosby (2017) 17 Cal.App.5th 655, 683.) Based on
the evidence presented, we need not resolve this dispute as the
evidence shows the privilege does not apply regardless of which
party has the burden of proof.

27
IV. DISPOSITION

The order is affirmed. Kavanaugh is entitled to his costs on
appeal.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS

KIM (D.), J.

We concur:

BAKER, Acting P. J.

MOOR, J.

28

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.