In re B.T. CA4/2

CourtListener 10362763Calctapp24.03.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 3/24/25 In re B.T. CA4/2
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION TWO

In re B.T. et al., Persons Coming Under
the Juvenile Court Law.

SAN BERNARDINO COUNTY
CHILDREN AND FAMILY SERVICES, E083839

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. Nos. J291595, J291596)

v. OPINION

P.F.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from the Superior Court of San Bernardino County. Cara D. Hutson,

Judge. Affirmed.

Pamela Rae Tripp, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for Defendant and

Appellant.

Tom Bunton, County Counsel, and Dawn M. Martin, Deputy County Counsel, for

Plaintiff and Respondent.

1
I.

INTRODUCTION

Defendant and appellant, P.F.-B., the maternal grandmother (MGM) of B.T. and

Bo.T., appeals the juvenile court’s order removing the children from her care. We find no

error and affirm.

II.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

The children came to the attention of plaintiff and respondent, the San Bernardino

County Child and Family Services (CFS) in December 2021, due to concerns about

domestic violence between the parents (who are not parties to this appeal). MGM told an

investigating social worker that, although the parents argued and had “normal

relationship issues,” she had “never been concerned about domestic violence” between

the parents. The social worker had learned, however, that a police report stated that

MGM called the police in May 2020 due to a domestic violence incident between the

parents, but MGM denied that she ever called the police. MGM also denied knowing

who the biological father of the children was.

CFS ruled out MGM for placement of the children “due to her lack of protective

capacity for the children and her deception” of CFS. CFS did not believe MGM’s

statements that the parents had not engaged in domestic violence, she had never called

the police to report domestic violence between them, and she did not know who the

children’s biological father was. CFS also was concerned that, even though MGM had

2
called the police, she “never attempted to get guardianship of the children, never called

CFS, and when questioned about the concerns, minimized the domestic violence in favor

of the mother.” Because the children were not placed with her, MGM applied to be a

resource parent through a foster family agency (FFA).

CFS later filed a petition on the children’s behalf under Welfare & Institutions
1
Code section 300, subdivision (b), alleging that the parents’ domestic violence and

substance abuse placed the children at risk. The juvenile court sustained the petition and

ordered the children removed from the parents’ care, although they were eventually

returned to the parents’ care.

However, due to the father’s arrest, the children were detained and placed in

MGM’s “FFA home” in January 2024. CFS then requested an emergency home

clearance for MGM, which led to CFS discovering 12 domestic violence referrals

involving MGM and her then-husband between 2005 and 2015, which CFS had

overlooked. When reviewing MGM’s home study that the FFA performed, CFS noted

that MGM did not disclose any Child Welfare Services/Case Management System history
2
although she had her own history with CFS. MGM nonetheless denied any domestic

violence history and minimized the reasons she separated from her ex-husband, stating

1 Unless otherwise noted, all further statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
2
This is a statewide case information system used by child welfare services
agencies to manage their cases and provide statewide access to information about
children receiving services. (See §§ 16501.5-16501.7.)

3
that it was due to his “‘drinking and his lifestyle choices’” instead of his serious domestic

violence. MGM’s failure to disclose these issues concerned CFS because FFA applicants

are told to be forthcoming about any relevant criminal or CFS history since FFAs do not

have access to this information. CFS thus obtained a detention warrant and removed the

children from MGM’s care.

In February 2024, CFS filed a section 387 supplemental petition to change the

children’s placement from MGM’s home to foster care. CFS alleged that placement with

MGM was “no longer appropriate as [MGM] has demonstrated a lack of good moral

character and a lack of protective capacity, in that, she was aware of the concerns of

domestic violence between the parents at the initial removal [in December 2021], and did

not act on them or report them and was not forthcoming in her FFA home study, denying

her own CFS history that included Domestic Violence in her home,” which placed the

children at risk.

In March 2024, CFS asked MGM about the petition’s allegations, and she said

some were true while others were false. She took accountability for not reporting

concerns about the parents to CFS sooner because “she should have been more protective

of her grandchildren.” Although she claimed she did not know of the extent of the

domestic violence between the parents or their substance abuse issues, she acknowledged

that she called the police when the parents were fighting and the mother broke the

father’s car windows. MGM also acknowledged “there are numerous police reports and

4
CFS history” concerning her ex-husband’s domestic violence because she repeatedly

called the police to report him.

In May 2024, CFS filed an addendum report recommending that the children

remain in foster care and not return to MGM’s care, even though she and the children had

a strong bond, because CFS remained concerned about MGM’s contradicting statements,

which she chalked up to a language barrier/translation issue; her “ongoing evasive

behavior” with CFS and misrepresentations to the FFA; and her minimization of her CFS

history and her ex-husband’s domestic violence. CFS also doubted MGM’s claimed

ignorance about the extent of the parents’ domestic violence given how close she is to the

mother and children. Because CFS had significant and ongoing concerns that MGM was

not being truthful, CFS concluded that leaving the children in MGM’s care put them at

imminent risk.

The juvenile court sustained the section 387 petition and removed the children

from MGM’s care. MGM timely appealed.

III.

DISCUSSION

Section 387 permits a juvenile court to change a placement order when the

existing placement has not been effective in protecting the child or the relative placement

is no longer appropriate under the non-exhaustive list of criteria in section 361.3. (§ 387,

subds. (a), (b).) “Thus, the test for granting a section 387 petition has two alternative

prongs—(1) the previous disposition has not been effective, or (2) a placement with a

5
relative is not appropriate under section 361.3. If the trial court sustains the petition

based on the second prong, then it is effectively denying the relative’s request for

placement under section 361.3. However, even if it sustains the petition based on the first

prong, it is making a ‘new placement,’ and therefore it is required under section 361.3 to

‘consider[]’ the relative for placement and to evaluate the factors listed in section 361.3.”

(In re K.T. (2019) 42 Cal.App.5th 15, 20.)

These factors include “[t]he best interest of the child,” “[t]he good moral character

of the relative and any other adult living in the home, including whether any individual

residing in the home has a prior history of violent criminal acts or has been responsible

for acts of child abuse or neglect,” “the ability of the relative to . . . [p]rotect the child

from their parents,” and “[t]he safety of the relative’s home.” (§ 361.3, subd. (a)(1), (5),

(7)(d), (8)(A).)

We review the juvenile court’s findings and orders on a section 387 petition for

substantial evidence. (In re A.O. (2004) 120 Cal.App.4th 1054, 1061.) In doing so, we

do not reweigh the evidence, evaluate the credibility of witnesses, or resolve evidentiary

conflicts. (In re S.C. (2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 396, 415.) The appellant thus bears the

burden of showing there is no substantial evidence to support the court’s findings and

orders. (In re L.Y.L. (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th 942, 947.)

MGM has not met that burden. During the initial removal and on subsequent

occasions, MGM’s statements suggested she was withholding information from the

juvenile court to protect the parents. She denied any domestic violence between the

6
parents, but police records revealed that she called the police because of their domestic

violence. And when asked about their domestic violence, she minimized what happened.

She also denied knowing about the parents’ substance abuse issues. In general, CFS did

not find MGM’s purported ignorance of the parents’ domestic violence and substance

abuse issues credible given her close relationship with the mother and the children.

MGM had other credibility issues. When MGM applied to be a FFA home, she

denied having experienced domestic violence, despite having suffered extensive, serious

domestic violence herself that she repeatedly reported to the police. MGM also failed to

disclose CFS’s resulting involvement from her calls to the police. MGM omitted this

information even though she was told to be forthcoming about any relevant CFS history

or domestic violence in her past.

On this record, the juvenile court could reasonably conclude that the MGM was

not a credible witness and had not been forthright with the juvenile court in an effort to

protect the parents. It was thus reasonable for the juvenile court to infer that the MGM

could not be trusted to voluntarily disclose information to social workers or to the

juvenile court in order to protect the children’s interests in the future if those interests

possibly conflicted with the interests of the parents. In other words, the juvenile court

could reasonably find that MGM could not (or would not) protect the children from their

parents or provide a safe, secure, and stable environment for the children. (§ 361.3, subd.

(a)(7)(A), (D).)

7
As a result, substantial evidence supports the juvenile court’s decision to sustain

the section 387 petition and remove the children from MGM’s care.

For the first time on appeal, MGM argues the juvenile court erroneously failed to

consider section 16001.9, subdivision (a)(4) and (5), and section 16010.7. MGM

forfeited the argument by failing to assert it below, but it fails in any event. (In re D.P.

(2023) 92 Cal.App.5th 1282, 1293.)

Section 16001.9 outlines various rights that foster children have. Subdivision

(a)(4) provides that foster children have the right “[t]o be placed in the least restrict

setting possible . . . unless a court orders otherwise,” and subdivision (a)(5) provides that

foster children have the right “[t]o be placed with a relative or nonrelative extended

family member if an appropriate and willing individual is available.” (Italics added.)

These provisions thus state that foster children have a right to be placed in a relative’s

home if the juvenile court finds that the relative’s home is appropriate. The juvenile court

here did not violate either subdivision because it properly found that placing the children

with MGM was not appropriate.

MGM contends that section 16010.7 “requires that significant efforts be put into

preserving placement, especially with a relative.” MGM is correct that section 16010.7

outlines the “placement preservation strategy” procedures that a social services agency

usually must follow before changing a foster youth’s placement. (See generally

§ 16010.7, subdivisions (b)-(c), (e).) MGM is also correct that the procedures are in

place to prevent a foster child’s “unnecessary or abrupt” change in placement. (Id., subd.

8
(a).) The agency need not develop a placement preservation strategy, however, “[i]f it is

determined that remaining in the existing foster care placement or providing prior written

notice of that foster care placement change poses an imminent risk to the health or safety

of the child.” (§ 16010.7, subd. (h).) Because CFS concluded leaving the children in

MGM’s care put them at imminent risk, CFS had no obligation under section 16010.7 to

employ a placement preservation strategy to maintain their placement with MGM.

IV.

DISPOSITION

The juvenile court’s order granting CFS’s section 387 petition is affirmed.

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

CODRINGTON
J.

We concur:

MILLER
Acting P. J.

MENETREZ
J.

9

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.