People v. Cosby CA4/1

CourtListener 10358145Calctapp19.03.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 3/19/25 P. v. Cosby CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

THE PEOPLE, D083014

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.
(Super. Ct. No. SCD288341)
TYLER PAULROBERT COSBY,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Joan P. Weber, Judge. Affirmed.
Jason L. Jones, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistant
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General,
Christopher P. Beesley and Namita Patel, Deputy Attorneys General, for
Plaintiff and Respondent.
Tyler Paulrobert Cosby was found guilty of first degree murder after a
trial in which he contended that he killed the victim in self-defense. Cosby
appeals the judgment, arguing that the court erred by excluding evidence of a
police-created flyer regarding the murder victim which he argues would show
the victim’s reputation for violence. As we discuss post, the trial court
properly excluded the flyer. Accordingly, we affirm.
I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Charges
Cosby was charged in an amended information with the murder of
Samuel Burkhalter and the personal use of a firearm and intentional and
personal discharge of a firearm, causing great bodily injury and death (count
1); possession for sale of fentanyl (count 3); possession for sale of
methamphetamine (count 4); and possession of methamphetamine while in
possession of a loaded, operable firearm (count 5). A codefendant, Selina
Elaina Singleton, was charged with being an accessory after the fact (count 2)
and with the drug possession charges (counts 3, 4 and 5).
Shortly before trial, Cosby pled guilty to counts 3, 4 and 5, and
proceeded to trial on count 1 as the sole defendant.
B. Motions in Limine
Prior to trial, Cosby moved in limine to introduce evidence of
Burkhalter’s prior specific bad acts “to confirm Mr. Cosby’s assertion that Mr.
Burkhalter was known to be armed with guns and was the aggressor.” The
motion noted that Cosby did not “dispute that [he] used a firearm and shot
Mr. Burkhalter.” Specifically, Cosby sought to introduce a one-page police

2
bulletin (flyer or police flyer)1 regarding Burkhalter that had been created by
the Carlsbad Police Department and circulated to law enforcement
approximately two months before the shooting. Cosby offered the police flyer
to show “how dangerous Mr. Burkhalter was” and to bolster Cosby’s “claim of
self-defense that Mr. Burkhalter was the aggressor.” At the hearing on the
motion, defense counsel explained, “It is our intent to introduce this flier [sic]
as evidence of Mr. Burkhalter’s prior access to firearms as part of the

[Evidence Code section] 11032 evidence, as well as Mr. Cosby’s testimony.
He did see Mr. Burkhalter with firearms.” Cosby argued that the flyer
proved that Burkhalter was known to carry firearms “and was also the

1 The flyer (sometimes inaccurately described as a “Be On The Lookout”
or “BOLO” flyer) was entitled “Officer Safety” with a subtitle “Status: Armed
Prohibited Due to Mental Health.” It contained a photograph above the
name Samuel John BURKHALTER, and stated a date of birth, weight, hair
and eye color, and a driver’s license number. It stated his last known address
in Carlsbad and stated “Transient – last arrest by LMPD 9/20/20.” It
contained the following text: “Sometime between 10/11/20 – 10/12/20,
Samuel BURKHALTER (9/17/83) entered his deceased parents’ residence at
1294 Cynthia Ln, Carlsbad and removed two rifles and a handgun.
Burkhalter is a transient and is possibly staying somewhere in Vista.
According to his sister and ex-wife, he is a drug abuser and has mental
health issues. He has an entry in the Armed Prohibited Persons System
(APPS) with an expiration of 5/10/25, citing mental health as the reason.
Burkhalter was last arrested in La Mesa on 9/20/20 for HS and he was
driving a rented U-Haul van which was impounded. If Burkhalter is
contacted in possession of the firearms, please notify CBPD Dispatch to have
an officer collect the firearms as evidence for 459 PC. This bulletin is for
officer safety information.” The flyer was attributed to the Carlsbad Police
Department Crime Analysis Unit and contained the name and contact
information for a Senior Crime Analyst.

2 Further statutory references are to the Evidence Code.

3
aggressor,” and the flyer “went to Cosby’s state of mind in fearing for his life
at the time of the shooting.”
The prosecutor explained that the police flyer was created after
Burkhalter removed guns from the home of his deceased parents.
The court denied the motion in limine, noting that the flyer was
“multiple layers of hearsay” and did not describe a violent act. “It does not
say that this man committed a violent attack against anyone. That’s the
issue, right?” The court concluded that Cosby could testify that he had seen
Burkhalter with firearms on earlier occasions, but the court refused to admit
the flyer. When defense counsel stated that she planned to call the officer
who created the flyer to explain why officers thought Burkhalter was armed
and dangerous, the court further noted an issue under section 352, i.e., that
the evidence would generate a “mini trial” on the circumstances of the
creation of the flyer.
During the trial, Cosby’s counsel revisited the issue of the flyer, telling
the court that it could be redacted to eliminate the reference to mental
health. The court stated, “You’re free to call ten witnesses if you wish that
say[ ], I was in his presence when he had guns, and he carried them. Your
client, he can testify to that, obviously can say that. I’m not prohibiting that.
I’m just saying a hearsay Be-On-The-Lookout flier without any other
information about it is too many levels of hearsay for this Court to allow it to
come in.”
C. Trial
At trial, Cosby testified that Burkhalter “typically was armed when I
would meet him . . . being in the drug-selling business,” and that Burkhalter
had told others that he planned to kill Cosby in retaliation for Cosby cutting
Burkhalter out of a drug deal. Cosby further testified that immediately

4
before the shooting, Burkhalter told him that he was going to kill Cosby.
Cosby testified that he shot Burkhalter because he was fearful for his life.
Burkhalter did not have a weapon with him when he was shot. After the
shooting, Cosby texted the message “It’s done” to two of his friends. Cosby’s
defense counsel did not call any other witnesses.
D. Verdict and Sentence
The jury found Cosby guilty of first degree murder and found true the
allegations that Cosby “intentionally and personally discharged . . . a
handgun, and proximately caused great bodily injury and death” to the victim
(Pen. Code, § 12022.53, subd. (d)) and personally used a handgun (Pen. Code,
§ 12022.5, subd. (d)). The trial court sentenced Cosby to state prison for
twenty-five years to life and ten additional years for the gun enhancement as
to the murder conviction, plus three years for counts 3, 4 and 5. Cosby timely
appealed.
II. DISCUSSION
Cosby argues that the trial court abused its discretion in excluding the
police flyer because the issue at trial was whether Cosby shot and killed
Burkhalter in actual or perceived self-defense, and the flyer would show that
the victim had a reputation for violence to buttress Cosby’s testimony that he
reasonably believed he was in imminent danger from Burkhalter.
We review evidentiary rulings involving character evidence for abuse of
discretion. (See People v. Doolin (2009) 45 Cal.4th 390, 437).
We note that the Cosby’s arguments regarding the purpose of the flyer
have changed over time. As noted above, during the trial, Cosby argued that
the flyer showed that Burkhalter was known to carry firearms so he could
have been armed and that he was the aggressor. On appeal, Cosby takes a
somewhat different tack, arguing that the flyer would show that Burkhalter

5
had a reputation for violence; that the flyer represented the police opinion
that Burkhalter was armed and dangerous; and that the flyer would show
“the reputation opinion of police that [Burkhalter] was armed and
dangerous.”
Section 1103 provides in relevant part that in a criminal case, evidence
of the victim’s character in the form of evidence of opinion or reputation or
evidence of specific instances of conduct may be admissible if offered by the
defendant to prove conduct of the victim in conformity with the character
trait.
Cosby is generally correct in his assertion that the character of the
victim is admissible in support of his claim of self-defense. (See, e.g. People
v. Sotelo-Urena (2016) 4 Cal.App.5th 732 [where defense is self-defense and
imperfect self-defense, evidence as to defendant’s actual belief in the need to
use lethal force to defend himself and the reasonableness of that belief was
relevant and admissible]; see also People v. Minifie (1996) 13 Cal.4th 1055,
1065 [in an effort to prove self-defense, the defendant may present evidence
to establish the reasonableness of his fear in order “ ‘to “prove his own frame
of mind” ’ ”].)
In this case, the trial court recognized the relevance of such evidence,
and the court repeatedly stated that the defense could present such evidence.
For example, in considering the motion in limine, the court stated, “We
already talked about your client testifying he had seen [Burkhalter] with
firearms. That’s fine, or any violent conduct between the two of them that he
can testify about, of course that all comes in.” When defense counsel raised
the issue of the flyer again during trial, the court stated, “You’re free to call
ten witnesses if you wish that say[ ], I was in his presence when he had guns,
and he carried them. Your client, he can testify to that, obviously can say

6
that. I’m not prohibiting that.” The court reiterated, “The defense could call
any witness you wish on this issue of defendant/victim’s reputation for
violence. If you wish to call, for example, victim’s sister to say he was violent
and carried guns around the house, anything of that nature would be
admissible, under the case law, as well.”
But the relevance of Burkhalter’s character does not mean that any
evidence offered by the defense as to Burkhalter was admissible. As noted by
the trial court, the flyer was problematic for many reasons.
First, as the defense implicitly conceded when it offered a redaction, the
flyer contained irrelevant details about Burkhalter’s mental health issues
and a reference to a firearms prohibition related to those mental health
issues. The flyer also stated that Burkhalter was a transient and a drug
abuser who had recently been arrested on drug charges. Those details did
not point to dangerousness and were therefore irrelevant to Cosby’s asserted
need to defend himself against Burkhalter.
Second, although the heading of the flyer is entitled “Officer Safety”
and the last statement in the flyer notes that “[t]his bulletin is for officer
safety information,” as the trial court aptly noted, the flyer nowhere states
that Burkhalter had acted violently or was known to be violent. It provided
no “evidence of specific instances of conduct” that might have been admissible
under section 1103 to prove his character for violence. Further, the flyer
contained no assertion that Burkhalter was considered to be “armed and
dangerous”, nor did it state that law enforcement believed him to be
dangerous. It states that he is transient; that he was recently arrested for
HS (presumably a drug offense); that he is a drug abuser; and that he has
mental health issues. The flyer notes that “[i]f Burkhalter is contacted in
possession of the firearms, please notify CBPD Dispatch to have an officer

7
collect the firearms as evidence for 459 PC [burglary].” Nowhere does it state
that the Carlsbad Police Department considered Burkhalter to be both armed
and dangerous.
Thus, fairly read, the sole relevance of the flyer was the information
that Burkhalter was in possession of two rifles and a handgun. This
information was relevant, because it would have reinforced Cosby’s testimony
that Burkhalter could have been armed and that Cosby’s fear of him was
reasonable. As argued by Cosby’s counsel in seeking its admission, “We’re
seeking to introduce [that] Mr. Burkhalter was known to carry weapons,
which bolsters Mr. Cosby’s belief that on the day in question, Burkhalter
could have been armed and his life was in imminent danger.”
The source of the information that Burkhalter was in possession of
weapons cannot be discerned from the flyer, but from its context, it appears
the police department received the information from Burkhalter’s sister or
his ex-wife, both of whom were named in the flyer. Thus, the information
was hearsay, as the trial court correctly noted.
Cosby counters that section 1324 provides that the hearsay rule does
not preclude admission of a person’s general reputation. However, the fact
that Burkhalter was said to have weapons available to him is different from
whether he had a reputation for possessing weapons.
Cosby further argues that the flyer was admissible under an exception

to the hearsay rule, namely section 12803, as an official record. However,

3 Section 1280 provides: “Evidence of a writing made as a record of an
act, condition, or event is not made inadmissible by the hearsay rule when
offered in any civil or criminal proceeding to prove the act, condition, or event
if all of the following applies: [¶] (a) The writing was made by and within the
scope of duty of a public employee. [¶] (b) The writing was made at or near
the time of the act, condition, or event. [¶] (c) The sources of information and
method and time of preparation were such as to indicate its trustworthiness.”

8
where the source of the hearsay statement is not a public employee, the
trustworthiness element of section 1280 cannot be met. (See, e.g., People
v. Baeske (1976) 58 Cal.App.3d 775, 779–781 [police report of a telephone call
from victim’s neighbor was untrustworthy and therefore inadmissible under
section 1280 where the relevant information was provided by a private
citizen, not a public employee who had a duty to observe correctly or report
accurately]; Alvarez v. Jacmar Pacific Pizza Corp. (2002) 100 Cal.App.4th
1190, 1206 [police records of 911 calls were not admissible as official records
because the people who made the calls to 911 “had no duty to correctly
observe and report facts”].) Thus, the trial court did not abuse its discretion
in finding that the flyer did not constitute evidence of specific acts of violence
that could support a claim that Burkhalter was the aggressor in the shooting,
nor in finding that the flyer constituted hearsay as to the information that
Burkhalter was in possession of weapons.
On appeal, Cosby now argues that the flyer should have been admitted
as “opinion of reputation” evidence. Specifically, he contends that the flyer
represented the police’s opinion that the victim was armed and dangerous or,
put another way, the flyer would show “the reputation opinion of police that
he was armed and dangerous.”
We reject this contention. As discussed above, the flyer nowhere states
that Burkhalter is considered to be “armed and dangerous.” The flyer in no
way establishes that Burkhalter had a “reputation” within the Carlsbad
Police Department or that the department had formed an “opinion” that
Burkhalter was dangerous. Even if we were to consider that a police
department could constitute the kind of “community” contemplated in the
context of reputation testimony, Cosby failed to provide a foundation to
establish that the police had any view about Burkhalter’s reputation in the

9
community beyond the information that had been received from the sister
and the ex-wife. (See, e.g., Khan v. Zemansky (1922) 59 Cal.App. 324, 329
[court does not abuse its discretion in excluding reputation testimony where
no foundation is laid to show “the opportunities” for the witness to form “a
correct estimate of the character” of the subject of the reputation evidence].)
Accordingly, the trial court did not abuse its discretion in excluding the

flyer.4
III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

KELETY, J.
WE CONCUR:

DATO, Acting P. J.

CASTILLO, J.

4 Because we conclude that the flyer was inadmissible hearsay, we do not
reach the trial court’s further concerns as to section 352.

10

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.