CourtListener 10352202•In re Mason L. CA2/5
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 3/7/25 In re Mason L. CA2/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not
certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been
certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
In re MASON L., a Person B335252
Coming Under the Juvenile (Los Angeles County
Court Law. Super. Ct. No.
23CCJP04243A)
LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF
CHILDREN AND FAMILY
SERVICES,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
P.G.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court Los Angeles
County, Pete R. Navarro, Judge Pro Tempore. Reversed.
Nicole Kronberg, under appointment by the Court of
Appeal, for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel and Jessica Buckelew, Deputy County
Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
________________________________
P.G. (mother) challenges the juvenile court’s order
declaring Mason L. (minor) a dependent under Welfare and
Institutions Code section 300, subdivision (a).1 Respondent Los
Angeles County Department of Children and Family Services
(Department) contends the appealed jurisdictional finding is
supported by substantial evidence. We reverse.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
Consistent with our standard of review, we state the facts
in the light most favorable to the juvenile court’s findings,
resolving all conflicts and drawing all reasonable inferences to
uphold the court’s order, if possible. (In re R.T. (2017) 3 Cal.5th
622, 633.)
Mother and father knew each other as teenagers, and
became involved after father was living in Minnesota in 2021.
Minor was born in Minnesota in December 2022. Mother and
minor moved to Los Angeles in May 2023, with father following
1 All statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code, unless stated otherwise.
2
shortly thereafter. Mother and father did not have a place of
their own.
Law enforcement was called to maternal grandmother’s
home in September 2023, after mother disagreed with how father
was holding minor while changing minor’s diaper. According to
the summary of the call to law enforcement, “father grabbed his
belongings and he attempted to leave their home with [minor].
Mother stated there was a struggle between her and the father,
while [minor] was held on the left side of the father’s arm. As
mother and father continued to argue, they threw items at each
other.” Father later reported that mother threw a shoe at him.
The Department investigated, and closed the matter as
inconclusive because the parents appeared knowledgeable about
child development and protective of minor, they had the support
of extended relatives, and they were open to services to provide
them communication and parenting tools.
A second incident occurred on October 20, 2023. According
to a police report of the incident, mother and father got into an
argument as mother was leaving father’s home with minor.
Father punched mother in the face and left arm, and he pulled
mother’s hair. Mother was holding minor for part of the
altercation, until paternal aunt came to mother’s aid and took
minor to paternal aunt’s apartment and called 911. Father left
the home before law enforcement arrived. Mother had bruising
on the left side of her forehead and on her left arm.
On October 31, 2023, a social worker interviewed paternal
aunt by phone about the incident. Paternal aunt stated she
called law enforcement after mother fled to paternal aunt’s
apartment because father started hitting her and took her car
keys and cell phone. According to paternal aunt, mother just
3
wanted father to return her belongings so she could leave, but
paternal aunt contacted law enforcement to protect her nephew
from the violence. Paternal aunt denied any knowledge of prior
physical violence between mother and father; they would argue
and yell, but had not gotten physical.
On November 2, 2023, father told an investigating social
worker that he and mother were in counseling. On November 3,
2023, the social worker interviewed paternal grandmother
(PGM), who said she was not present during the incident, but
mother told her that father pushed mother, hit her with closed
fists and was kicking her, but that minor was not hurt. Mother
also acknowledged hitting father and apologized to PGM for
fighting in her home. When PGM asked father what happened,
he told her “it is our issue, we fought, and that’s it.” PGM told
father he needed to respect PGM’s home or he would need to
leave. Father cared for minor Sunday through Thursday, from
7:00 a.m. until 6:00 p.m., while mother was at work. Mother and
father had verbal arguments, but PGM had never seen them get
physically abusive.
On November 3, 2023, mother spoke to a social worker and
gave a description of the domestic violence incident that occurred
on October 20, 2023. Mother explained that she went to pick
minor up from father, and while she was holding minor in her
arms, father blocked her from leaving, pushed her towards the
couch, and accused her of being a bad mother and of wanting to
leave so she could cheat on him. Mother put minor down in an
attempt to leave by herself and de-escalate the situation, but
father started hitting her arms, legs, and face. She picked minor
up and tried to leave again, but father took her car keys and cell
phone. Minor was crying throughout the incident, but was not
4
hurt. Mother took minor to paternal aunt’s apartment, and
paternal aunt called law enforcement. Father did not return
until four hours later, after law enforcement had left, but mother
was unable to leave because father had her car keys and minor’s
car seat was in her car. Mother told the social worker that she
and father separated for the sake of minor’s safety, she and
father agreed to engage in individual counseling, and if their
relationship worked out they would do couples counseling. Her
only contact with father was to exchange minor because father
watches minor while mother is at work. Mother has a close
relationship with PGM and considers her a best friend. She also
seeks advice from paternal aunt, who has four children of her
own.
On December 7, 2023, the Department obtained
authorization to remove minor from father’s custody only, and
advised mother of the removal order. On December 11, 2023, the
Department filed a petition alleging, under section 300,
subdivision (a), that mother and father “engaged in a violent
physical altercation in the presence of the child. The father
forcibly pushed the mother and repeatedly struck the mother
with the father’s hands, while the mother was holding the child.
The father forcibly pushed the mother towards a couch and
blocked the door of the home. The father pushed the mother to
the ground and repeatedly kicked the mother. The father struck
the mother’s face and arms with the father’s fists. The father
pulled the mother’s hair. The father took the mother’s cellular
telephone and keys to prevent the mother from leaving and
contacting law enforcement. The mother struck the father with
the mother’s hands. The mother sustained bruising to the
mother’s face, arms and legs as a result of the physical
5
altercation. Such violent conduct by the mother and father
endangers the child’s physical and emotional health and safety
and places the child at risk of serious physical harm, damage and
danger.” The petition also included an allegation under section
300, subdivision (b)(1), with nearly identical language, but also
alleging that mother failed to protect minor “by allowing the
father to have unlimited access to the child.”
In an interview at her home on January 4, 2024, mother
did not deny the allegations. Instead, mother explained that she
was hitting father to make him stop hitting her. Mother agreed
that minor was traumatized by the incident, and she had noticed
he was more sensitive to loud noises, was more easily scared, and
was crying more. Father agreed that he and mother had an
altercation, but disagreed that mother had failed to protect
minor. In January 2024, mother, father, and PGM all reported
that mother and father were not seeing each other, and father
was not visiting minor. Mother did not want to reconcile with
father because he did not support himself, and she did not want
him to hold her back from moving forward with her life.
By January 11, 2024, mother’s therapist reported mother
had completed five of six sessions. The therapist observed that
mother had demonstrated capacity to protect minor because
mother had been keeping her distance from father.
The Department recommended the court declare minor a
dependent, sustain the petition allegations, and order family
maintenance services for mother and enhancement services for
father. The recommended services for mother were domestic
violence education classes for victims, parenting classes,
individual therapy, and family preservation services. Father’s
recommended services included a psychiatric assessment
6
pursuant to Evidence Code 730, mental health treatment,
domestic violence classes for perpetrators and individual therapy,
along with drug testing if there was any suspicion of drug use.
At the jurisdiction and disposition hearing on February 8,
2024, mother asked the court to dismiss her from the petition
entirely, arguing that her actions during the October 2023
domestic violence incident were protective, as she was holding
minor when father started hitting her, and she hit father back in
self defense. After the juvenile court made a tentative ruling that
it was inclined to dismiss the petition for lack of a current risk,
minor’s counsel asked the court to sustain the petition, including
the failure to protect allegation against mother, because this was
not a one-time incident. Minor’s counsel pointed to the prior
referral from the September 2023 incident, and statements by
paternal aunt about parents’ previously arguing and yelling at
each other. In addition, mother reported that minor was easily
scared, crying more and sensitive to loud noises, evidence that
minor’s exposure to the domestic violence had traumatized him.
Minor’s counsel asked the court to order age-appropriate therapy.
The court asked whether there was any dispute that the
incidents occurred while parents were living together, and that
they were no longer cohabitating. Minor’s counsel responded that
the parents were not living together when the October 2023
incident occurred, because after the couple moved to Los Angeles
from Minnesota, maternal grandmother had kicked father out of
the home. Minor’s counsel also pointed to conflicting statements
about whether parents wanted to continue their relationship.
When the court stated it would sustain the petition
allegations under section 300, subdivisions (a) and (b) as pled,
mother’s counsel reiterated that mother had been trying to
7
protect minor from being struck by father, and paternal aunt’s
account was consistent. Counsel argued that “to sustain the
[subdivision] (a) count against the mother would only further
victimize her for keeping her and her son safe in an emergency
situation.” Counsel also argued that there was no evidence of
any ongoing risk of harm posed by domestic violence under the
subdivision (b) count, as there was only one incident of actual
physical violence, and it would be unreasonable to consider an
earlier verbal argument as part of any ongoing pattern. The
court stated “I am striking the mother from the (b) count. She is
not accused of failure to protect in the (a) count.” When mother’s
counsel pointed out that the count under section 300, subdivision
(a), was pled as mutual domestic violence, the court responded it
was “just going to leave it as it is pled.” The minute order and
the interlineated petition show that the court sustained the
subdivision (a) count as pled, and sustained an amended count
under subdivision (b), striking the allegation that mother failed
to protect minor. The court declined to declare minor a
dependent, instead ordering parents under section 360,
subdivision (b) to comply with services for a period consistent
with a voluntary contract under section 301. The court noted its
section 360, subdivision (b) order was over the objection of all
parties.
Mother appealed.
8
DISCUSSION
Mother contends the juvenile court erred in sustaining a
jurisdictional finding against her under section 300, subdivision
(a), based on a single incident of domestic violence. She argues
there was no substantial evidence to support a finding that minor
remained at risk of any harm, because there was only one
incident of domestic violence, she had acted to protect minor
during that incident, and the parents had separated. We agree
with mother that there was insufficient evidence that minor was
at risk of harm due to domestic violence at the time of the
February 2024 hearing, and we reverse the jurisdictional finding
against mother only.
A. Appealability of order for informal supervision
Section 360, subdivision (b), provides: “If the court finds
that the child is a person described by [s]ection 300, it may,
without adjudicating the child a dependent child of the court,
order that services be provided to keep the family together and
place the child and the child’s parent or guardian under the
supervision of the social worker for a time period consistent with
[s]ection 301.” “ ‘If the court agrees to or orders a program of
informal supervision, it does not dismiss the dependency petition
or otherwise set it aside. The true finding of jurisdiction remains.
It is only the dispositional alternative of declaring the child a
dependent that is not made.’ ” (In re Adam D. (2010) 183
Cal.App.4th 1250, 1260.) The order is tantamount to a
9
disposition and therefore sufficient for a parent to appeal the
underlying jurisdictional finding. (Id. at pp. 1260-1261.)
B. Justiciability of mother’s appeal
“An important requirement for justiciability is the
availability of ‘effective’ relief—that is, the prospect of a remedy
that can have a practical, tangible impact on the parties’ conduct
or legal status.” (In re I.A. (2011) 201 Cal.App.4th 1484, 1490
(I.A.).) As a general rule, a jurisdictional finding as to one parent
is good as to both. (In re Briana V. (2015) 236 Cal.App.4th 297,
308.) It is well settled that juvenile court jurisdiction attaches to
children, not their parents. (In re I.A., supra, at p. 1491.) Here,
the juvenile court sustained one allegation under section 300,
subdivision (a), concerning the risk of harm posed by parents
engaging in a violent physical altercation in minor’s presence,
and a separate allegation against father only under section 300,
subdivision (b). Father has not appealed either finding, so
regardless of the outcome of mother’s appeal, the court’s exercise
of jurisdiction will remain.
This court retains discretion to address the merits of a
challenge to a jurisdictional finding, even if overturning that
finding will have no immediate effect on the assertion of
jurisdiction. (I.A., supra, 201 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1494–1495.)
Although “no single factor is necessarily dispositive of whether a
court should exercise discretionary review of a moot appeal,” (In
re D.P. (2023) 14 Cal.5th 266, 287 (D.P.)) appellate courts
exercise discretion to reach the merits when a juvenile court’s
jurisdictional findings could have consequences for the appellant
beyond jurisdiction, or when a challenged finding “is based on
10
particularly pernicious or stigmatizing conduct.” (Id. at pp. 285–
286.)
Mother contends that review is warranted in this case
because the section 300, subdivision (a) finding against her could
impact her in future dependency investigations or proceedings, or
could have consequences “related to employment and other areas
as a result of being placed on the Child Abuse Central Index
(‘CACI’).” The Department acknowledges this court’s discretion
and does not offer any argument against an exercise of that
discretion.
Considering the court’s statements at the adjudication
hearing, mother’s compliance with services and court orders, and
in light of the potential consequences for mother beyond
jurisdiction, we exercise our discretion to reach the merits of her
appeal.
C. The jurisdictional finding against mother
“ ‘In reviewing the jurisdictional findings and the
disposition, we look to see if substantial evidence, contradicted or
uncontradicted, supports them. [Citation.] In making this
determination, we draw all reasonable inferences from the
evidence to support the findings and orders of the dependency
court; we review the record in the light most favorable to the
court's determinations; and we note that issues of fact and
credibility are the province of the trial court.’ ” (In re R.T., supra,
3 Cal.5th at p. 633.) “We do not reweigh the evidence, evaluate
the credibility of witnesses, or resolve evidentiary conflicts.” (In
re Dakota H. (2005) 132 Cal.App.4th 212, 228.) “Substantial
evidence must be of ponderable legal significance. It is not
11
synonymous with ‘any’ evidence. [Citation.] The evidence must
be reasonable in nature, credible, and of solid value. [Citation.]
The appellant has the burden of showing there is no evidence of a
sufficiently substantial nature to support the finding or order.”
(Ibid.) “ ‘ “The ultimate test is whether it is reasonable for a trier
of fact to make the ruling in question in light of the whole
record.” ’ ” (In re Yolanda L. (2017) 7 Cal.App.5th 987, 992.)
“[I]ncidents of domestic violence between a child’s parents,
if they occur in the child's immediate presence, may support a
jurisdiction finding under section 300, subdivision (a).” (In re
Cole L. (2021) 70 Cal.App.5th 591, 603; In re M.M. (2015) 240
Cal.App.4th 703, 720–721.) “ ‘While evidence of past conduct
may be probative of current conditions, the question under
section 300 is whether circumstances at the time of the hearing
subject the minor to the defined risk of harm.’ ” (In re Ma.V.
(2021) 64 Cal.App.5th 11, 23.)
If we view the evidence most favorable to the court’s
decision to sustain the count alleged under section 300,
subdivision (a), against mother as well as father, there may have
been sufficient evidence at the time of the October 2023 incident
to support jurisdiction. During their September 2023 verbal
disagreement, father reported mother threw a shoe at him, and
the police report also noted parents threw items at each other
while father was holding minor. There is also uncontroverted
evidence that mother and father engaged in a physical
altercation in October 2023, with minor present.
However, there is no evidence to support a reasonable
inference that minor remained at risk of any physical harm at
the time of the February 8, 2024 hearing. More than three
months had passed between the October incident and the
12
February hearing, and while mother previously relied on father
to provide child care while she worked, she no longer permitted
father to contact her or have contact with minor. Mother had
engaged in services and also expressed she had no interest in
reconciling with father. There was no evidence that mother was
being untruthful in her statement, and the court made no
indication that it found mother to lack credibility.
Rather, it appears that after it struck language alleging
mother failed to protect minor from the allegation under section
300, subdivision (b), the juvenile court simply misunderstood the
nature of the subdivision (a) allegation and failed to consider the
sufficiency of the evidence against mother. The court’s
statements underscore our conclusion. The court announced: “I
am striking the mother from the (b) count. She is not accused of
failure to protect in the (a) count.” When mother’s counsel tried
to alert the court that the subdivision (a) count involved mutual
domestic violence, not just allegations against father, the court
simply responded “I am just going to leave it as it is pled.”
Based on the record evidence, we find insufficient evidence
to support the court’s decision to sustain the jurisdictional
allegation against mother under section 300, subdivision (a).
However, because father has not appealed the court’s exercise of
jurisdiction over minor, the finding against him remains.
13
DISPOSITION
The court’s jurisdictional finding against mother under
Welfare and Institutions Code section 300, subdivision (a), is
reversed.
MOOR, J.
We concur:
HOFFSTADT, P. J.
KIM (D.), J.
14
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.