A.D. v. B.G. CA2/6

CourtListener 10321064Calctapp27.01.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 1/27/25 A.D. v. B.G. CA2/6

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION SIX

A.D., 2d Civ. No. B335061
(Super. Ct. No. D376245)
Respondent, (Santa Barbara County)

v.

B.G.,

Appellant.

B.G. (Mother) appeals an order giving A.D. (Father) sole
legal and physical custody of their minor daughter, A.D. She
contends the family court erred by: (1) failing to apply Family
Code1 section 3044’s presumption against awarding custody to a
parent found to have perpetrated domestic violence; and (2)
modifying the parties’ existing custody order without sufficient
evidence of changed circumstances. We will affirm.

1 Further unspecified statutory references are to the Family

Code.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A.D. was born in 2015. Father filed this parentage case in
May of 2016 after his relationship with Mother ended. They
never married. A.D. resided with Mother in Lancaster and would
visit Father, who lived in Oak Park. They stipulated to joint
legal and physical custody in September of 2016.
The Los Angeles Department of Children and Family
Services (DCFS) detained A.D. in 2018 following allegations of
physical abuse by Father’s then-girlfriend (the DCFS case).2 The
juvenile court in Los Angeles entered a “Custody Order-Juvenile-
Final Judgment” in February 2019 awarding Mother sole
physical custody and ordering Father to attend parenting
classes.3 They continued to share legal custody. Father moved to
Colorado in March of 2021 and visited A.D. monthly.
A.D. began first grade in August of 2021. She struggled
with attendance. Mother and Father agreed to move A.D. from
Lancaster to Oak Park in February of 2022 so she could live with
Father’s parents. She finished first grade at Brookside
Elementary School. Father returned from Colorado in August of
2022 and moved into his parents’ house with A.D.
A.D. began second grade at Brookside. Mother withdrew
her mid-year from school and relocated her to Lancaster. A.D.
again struggled. She returned to live with Father and his

2 In re A.D. (Super. Ct. L.A. County, 2018, No. 18LJJP

00554A).

3 We grant Mother’s March 13, 2024 request for judicial

notice of the “Custody Order-Juvenile-Final Judgment” dated
February 16, 2019 in the DCFS case. We otherwise deny the
request.

2
parents a few weeks later. A.D. reenrolled at Brookside and
finished second grade.
In September of 2023, Father sought emergency orders in
the parentage action giving him sole legal and physical custody of
A.D. Father alleged mother’s visits with A.D. had become less
frequent over the past year. He suspected Mother was smoking
methamphetamine and allowing her abusive boyfriend, R.C., a
registered sex offender from Texas, to live in her house. Father
alleged that during a recent visit Mother told A.D. to remain in
the back room in case anyone started shooting at the house. The
family court denied the request for emergency orders but ordered
the parties to mediate. Mother removed A.D. from Brookside
after receiving father’s request for orders and began
homeschooling her in Lancaster.
A court-appointed custody counselor separately interviewed
Mother, Father, and A.D. in November of 2023. The counselor
previously mediated their case in 2016. She recommended the
family court award Father physical custody during the school
year and a “two weeks on / two weeks off” schedule during
summer break. The court adopted the recommendations as its
temporary order and scheduled an evidentiary hearing for
December 13, 2023.
The custody counselor testified at the evidentiary hearing
about her interviews. Mother testified as well. She denied
allegations of drug and alcohol abuse. She stated she was no
longer in a relationship with R.C. and there was “no more
domestic violence.” At the hearing’s end, the family court made
its temporary order permanent (December 13 order). Mother
appealed.

3
There is no reporter’s transcript of the evidentiary hearing.
Appellant elected to use a settled statement as the oral record on
appeal and filed a proposed statement with the family court.
(Cal. Rules of Court, rule 8.137.) Father filed a response and
requested a resolution hearing. The family court certified
Father’s response “as an accurate summary of testimony [and]
other relevant evidence” presented on December 13.
DISCUSSION
Appealability
Father argues we must dismiss the appeal because the
December 13 order is only an “interim custody order.” We denied
his earlier motion to dismiss on identical grounds.4 His second
effort is no more persuasive than the first.
Father sought to permanently modify custody and
visitation rights. He stated as follows in the declaration
supporting his request for orders: “PERMANENT ORDERS
SOUGHT [¶] b. Sole physical custody of [A.D.] to father; [¶]
i. Monitored visitation with mother keeping in mind [A.D.’s]
school and other needs. Visitations to occur in Oak Park area.
Monitor to be paid by the Respondent. R.C. not to be around
[A.D.]. [¶] c. Sole legal custody of [A.D.] to Father . . . .”
The family court granted Father’s request. The minute
order from the December 13 hearing states: “The Court finds the
[mediator’s] recommendation is in the best interest of the minor
child and makes the temporary order the permanent order of the
court.” (Italics added.) Father’s responsive settled statement—
which the family court adopted as the settled statement on
appeal—summarized the findings similarly: “The Court made a
finding that [Mother] was not credible and that the Court found

4 See Order dated April 26, 2024.

4
it unlikely that the minor child made false reports to the
mediator. The Court further found that based on the
recommendations and testimony of the mediator and on the
declarations received by the court, there was a significant change
of circumstances and found that the recommendation is in the
best interest of the minor child and makes the temporary order
the permanent order of the court.” (Italics added.)
Despite requesting and receiving permanent relief, Father
argues the December 13 order is not appealable because the court
has not entered final judgment. (See Enrique M. v. Angelina V.
(2004) 121 Cal.App.4th 1371, 1377 [“the right to appeal a child
custody determination is generally limited to final judgments and
orders made after final judgments”].) This is misleading. Father
sought to modify a final judgment entered in Los Angeles in
February of 2019. He chose Ventura as the venue for his
modification request. The resulting order is an order made after
judgment. (Code Civ. Proc., § 904.1, subd. (a)(2).) He cannot
immunize the order from appeal by crossing county lines and
filing his request in a separate case.
We now turn to the merits of Mother’s appeal.
Family Code Section 3044
Mother contends the family court erred because it failed to
apply section 3044’s rebuttable presumption against awarding
custody to a parent found to have perpetrated domestic violence.
(See Celia S. v. Hugo H. (2016) 3 Cal.App.5th 655, 661 [“section
3044 establishes a rebuttable presumption that awarding
physical or legal custody to a parent who has committed domestic
violence is detrimental to a child’s best interest . . .”].) The
presumption does not apply here. The DCFS case against Father
and his then-girlfriend was filed in August of 2018. He requested

5
the appealed orders in September of 2023 and the court granted
them in December of 2023. The presumption applies to domestic
violence perpetrated “within the previous five years.” (§ 3044,
subd. (a).) Mother presented no evidence of domestic violence
perpetrated by Father within this period.
Custody Order
Mother next contends the family court “improperly
modified prior juvenile court orders without sufficient evidence of
changed circumstances since their issuance.” We review the
December 13 order, as Mother acknowledges, for substantial
evidence. (In re Marriage of Fajota (2014) 230 Cal.App.4th 1487,
1497 [factual findings underlying custody and visitation orders
reviewed for substantial evidence].)
“When issuing custody and visitation orders, a trial court’s
paramount concern is the best interests of the child.” (In re
Marriage of C.D. & G.D. (2023) 95 Cal.App.5th 378, 380; § 3020,
subd. (a).) The court must consider many factors when
determining these interests, including, among other things, “[t]he
health, safety, and welfare of the child” and “[t]he habitual or
continual illegal use of controlled substances . . . by either
parent.” (§ 3011, subd. (a)(1)&(4).)
Mother and Father filed lengthy declarations accusing each
other of endangering and manipulating A.D. Mother, for
example, cited the DCFS case as evidence of Father’s past abuse
and described how A.D. regularly suffered minor injuries while in
his care. She described how Father repeatedly violated existing
custody orders and purposefully limited her contact with A.D.
after they agreed to place her with Father’ parents she moved to
Oak Park. Father described Mother as a drug user who lived in a

6
violent neighborhood with a boyfriend who was previously
convicted of sexually assaulting a 14-year-old girl.
The family court considered these declarations along with
testimony from the mediator and Mother at the evidentiary
hearing. It found the mediator’s testimony credible and Mother’s
testimony not credible. We decline to second guess the family
court’s weighing of the evidence, particularly those findings based
on witness credibility. (In re Marriage of Winternitz (2015) 235
Cal.App.4th 644, 653.)
DISPOSITION
The December 13 order is affirmed. Respondent shall
recover his costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.

CODY, J.

We concur:

YEGAN, Acting P. J.

BALTODANO, J.

7
Hon. Michael S. Lief, Judge
Superior Court County of Ventura
______________________________

B.G., in pro per, for Appellant.
Lozoya & Lozoya, Robin J. Lozoya, for Respondent.

8

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.