In re R.D. CA2/1

CourtListener 10321058Calctapp27.01.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 1/27/25 In re R.D. CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

In re R.D., B338360

a Person Coming Under the (Los Angeles County
Juvenile Court Law. Super. Ct. No. 23CCJP01890)

LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DEPARTMENT OF CHILDREN
AND FAMILY SERVICES,

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

T.B.,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of Los
Angeles County, Pete R. Navarro, Judge Pro Tempore. Affirmed.
Gina Zaragoza, under appointment by the Court of Appeal,
for Defendant and Appellant.
Dawyn R. Harrison, County Counsel, Kim Nemoy,
Assistant County Counsel, and Veronica Randazzo, Deputy
County Counsel, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
_____________________

T.B. (Mother) challenges the juvenile court’s finding at the
six-month review hearing pursuant to Welfare and Institutions
Code1 section 366.21, subdivision (e) that the Los Angeles County
Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) provided
her with reasonable reunification services. Mother argues
services were inadequate because DCFS failed to facilitate a
minimum of nine hours per week of monitored visitation with her
daughter R.D. as ordered. R.D.’s presumed father D.D. (Father)
is not a party to this appeal.
We conclude substantial evidence supports the juvenile
court’s finding and thus affirm.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. Petition, Jurisdiction, Disposition, and Prior Appeal
We derive the following factual and procedural summary
from Mother’s prior appeal of the juvenile court’s disposition
order. (In re R.D. (Nov. 25, 2024, B333795) [nonpub. opn.].)
In May 2023, DCFS received a report that Mother had
engaged in domestic violence against Father in R.D.’s presence.
At the time, R.D. was less than one year old. R.D. was placed
with maternal grandmother and her teenage half-siblings, P.W.

1 All subsequent unspecified statutory references are to the
Welfare and Institutions Code.

2
and L.W., who had been in maternal grandmother’s care under a
plan of legal guardianship since 2015.
DCFS filed a section 300 petition alleging that, among
other things, Mother’s violence against Father created a
substantial risk that R.D. would suffer physical harm and that
Mother failed to protect R.D. from Father, who suffered from
substance abuse and mental health issues.
The court sustained all counts in the petition and, on
October 10, 2023, removed R.D. from her parents’ custody. It
ordered monitored visitation for Mother for a minimum of three
visits per week for three hours per visit. Maternal grandmother,
who had previously refused to host visits at her home due to
Mother’s lack of anger management, informed the court that she
was no longer willing to monitor Mother’s visits regardless of
where they occurred. The court ordered that DCFS facilitate the
visits or provide a referral for a human service aide (HSA) to act
as a monitor and granted DCFS discretion to liberalize visits.
Mother’s counsel requested a three-month progress report, and
the court scheduled a January 12, 2024 hearing for that purpose.
Mother appealed the removal order. We affirmed, stating,
“Mother had a history of losing her temper and becoming
physically violent beginning in 2012 up through 2023 . . . , and
the court had reason to believe that by the time of the disposition
hearing, Mother had not yet learned to adequately manage this
behavior such that returning R.D. to her custody would place
R.D. at substantial risk of harm.” (In re R.D., supra, B333795.)
Mother remained in a relationship with Father, who had not
adequately addressed his mental health and substance abuse
issues. Further, Mother continued to deny any domestic violence

3
between them. Accordingly, we concluded substantial evidence
supported the court’s removal order.
B. Three-month Progress Review
In a last minute information (LMI) filed on January 11,
2024, DCFS reported that since the disposition hearing Mother
had completed seven therapeutic group sessions relating to
domestic violence and anger management. According to a
counselor, Mother made good progress in the program but had
not attended during the last few weeks. As to individual therapy,
Mother was assessed and received a recommendation for
treatment. However, she did not return to therapy. DCFS
reported a positive change in Mother’s behavior until she stopped
attending these programs in December 2023.
As to visitation, on September 27, 2023, a different DCFS
social worker was assigned to Mother’s case. The social worker
reported that prior to his involvement, Mother had visits on
Fridays and Saturdays. The social worker’s services log indicates
that he supervised a visit on October 28, 2023, but the record
does not specify the frequency of Mother’s visits with R.D.
between September 27 and October 31, 2023. Beginning in early
November 2023, DCFS reported that monitors were not available
for Mother’s visits with R.D., and there were no visits on
November 4 and 10, 2023. On November 11, 2023, the social
worker attempted to reschedule the visit for an earlier time
“[d]ue to the holiday weekend,” but maternal grandmother “was
unable to accommodate.”
On November 15, 2023, DCFS approved L.B., who Mother
had recommended, as a potential monitor. However, L.B. did not
have a car. On November 22, 2023, DCFS attempted to schedule
a visit monitored by L.B. that would have required maternal

4
grandmother to drive R.D. to a park. Both maternal
grandmother and Mother informed the social worker they would
not drive to the other’s neighborhood. As a result, DCFS was
unable to schedule a visit.
Maternal grandmother reportedly felt bad for Mother and,
on Thanksgiving Day, began monitoring visits between Mother
and R.D. at maternal grandmother’s home. The visits were for
nine or more hours and occurred mostly on weekends. On
December 18, 2023, maternal grandmother reported Mother was
doing well. On January 8, 2024, however, maternal grandmother
reported Mother “blew up” at her after maternal grandmother did
not pick Mother up for a visit on New Year’s Day because she
wanted to rest. As a result, maternal grandmother was no longer
willing to monitor visits. The social worker reported that he was
working on creating a new visitation schedule. According to the
social worker’s services log, on January 9, 2024, the social worker
texted Mother. The social worker did not receive a response from
Mother until February 11, 2024. DCFS recommended that
Mother’s visits with R.D. remain monitored.
At the hearing on January 12, 2024, Mother requested that
the court award her unmonitored visitation. She argued DCFS
had not provided visitation every week as ordered, and that
DCFS “failed to transport” R.D. to Mother for visits. Mother
requested that the court “order an assessment or best efforts for
an HSA available on the weekends” and provide transportation
assistance.
DCFS argued Mother’s request should be made via a
section 388 petition. It further argued the court could not order
DCFS to provide an HSA because that was a matter of internal
management for the agency and, thus, an executive function.

5
During the hearing, the court observed, “Mother looks like
she is trying to bully her way through to achieve her goals,” and
that maternal grandmother had agreed to monitor the visits until
Mother blew up at her.
Mother, speaking for herself, informed the court that
maternal grandmother’s assertions were false and asked for
proof. She advised the court she would sue DCFS for taking
away her rights and argued she had not had any visits (which as
explained above was not true). The court responded, “I can see
why Mother has burnt her bridges. She is hostile.” The court
ordered all prior orders remain in effect, including that visitation
be monitored.
C. Six-month Review
1. The Report
DCFS filed a six-month status review report on March 15,
2024. It described that on February 11, 2024, Mother texted the
social worker to request visits with R.D., and to inform DCFS
that Mother planned to sue DCFS for taking away her rights. On
February 14, 2024, the social worker asked Mother if L.B. was
still willing to act as a monitor. Mother did not answer the
question, and instead complained about the lack of visitation and
the social worker’s failure to correct it. The social worker
responded that he could arrange visits if Mother had a monitor;
otherwise, the social worker could clear someone to monitor the
visits.
On February 15, 2024, the social worker spoke with
maternal grandmother. Maternal grandmother agreed for visits
to occur on Saturdays but stated she would only release R.D. to
an approved monitor. The social worker informed Mother that
L.B. had to be present to pick up R.D. as well as to drop off the

6
child. Mother requested that the social worker telephone L.B.
about this. The social worker left a message for L.B., but L.B. did
not return the call. Mother then recommended another monitor,
R.B., to supervise visits. Given the short notice, DCFS could not
approve R.B. in time for a visit on February 17, 2024.
On February 22, 2024, maternal grandmother reported
that Mother called to speak with P.W. and L.W., Mother’s older
daughters. Maternal grandmother heard Mother screaming at
them over the phone and intervened. Maternal grandmother
explained that Mother wanted P.W. and L.W. to spend time with
Father although he was not their father. Maternal grandmother
played a recording for the social worker with Mother “screaming
in a rage at the top of her lungs, ‘I’m going to kill you, you stupid
bitch,’ multiple times, referring to [maternal grandmother].”
On February 23, 2024, the social worker informed Mother
that R.B. had been cleared to monitor visits. On February 24,
2024, maternal grandmother reported that Mother did not
participate in her scheduled visit that day. Maternal
grandmother stated that “[M]other got into an altercation with
[Father]” and then received a ticket for driving under the
influence of alcohol (DUI). DCFS confirmed that on February 23,
2024, Mother received a DUI citation.
On February 28, 2024, a social worker made an
unannounced visit to Mother’s residence. Mother did not answer
the door, and the social worker left a business card. Mother
telephoned the social worker and told him he could not show up
unannounced at her home. The social worker asked what
happened with respect to her last scheduled visit with the minor.
Mother responded that the social worker knew what had occurred
because maternal grandmother had told him. Mother screamed

7
at the social worker. He asked her not to scream, and she
responded by asking if he wanted to hear her “actually scream.”
Mother demanded a new social worker and ended the call.
On March 1, 2024, maternal grandmother texted the social
worker to inform him that R.B. had stated she no longer wanted
anything to do with Mother.
On March 2, 2024, maternal grandmother reported that
Mother arrived at her home unannounced to see the children;
there is no record evidence that a monitor accompanied Mother,
meaning the visit would have violated the visitation order. When
maternal grandmother refused to let Mother in, Mother
attempted to kick in the front door and smashed the video
doorbell. Maternal grandmother called police, but Mother left
before they arrived. Maternal grandmother obtained a
temporary restraining order against Mother, and a hearing for a
permanent restraining order was scheduled for March 25, 2024.
The record does not reflect whether maternal grandmother
obtained a permanent restraining order.
On March 4, 2024, Mother asked the social worker to clear
A.S. as a monitor and stated that R.B. was “no good.” Mother
reported that because R.B. had “flaked,” Mother brought L.B. to
act as a monitor, but maternal grandmother would not let her
visit. The record does not state whether this was a scheduled
visit or when this occurred. The social worker inquired whether
Mother was available for visits on days other that Saturdays and
reported that Mother indicated “she now had Fridays available.”
The social worker was unable to clear A.S. for monitoring.
Mother then recommended K.F. as a monitor. In the meantime,
DCFS staff monitored a visit on March 8, 2024, at a DCFS office.

8
K.F. was thereafter cleared, and the social worker scheduled a
visit for March 16, 2024.
Mother’s neighbor informed the social worker that the
residents in Mother’s unit were “always fighting” and that the
neighbor often heard door slamming and yelling between
12:30 a.m. and 2:00 a.m. A police call log for Mother’s address
revealed that the police received a call for alleged domestic
violence on January 13, 2024, calls for “unknown trouble” on
February 14, 21, and 22, 2024, and a call for possible domestic
violence on March 8, 2024. DCFS reported Mother had confirmed
multiple times that she intended to continue her relationship
with Father.
DCFS confirmed Mother participated in a parenting class
through September 12, 2023. A representative from that
program stated that Mother actively participated and was a
pleasure to have in class. Further, prior to June 2023, Mother
had completed 10 anger management group therapy sessions,
and prior to December 2, 2023, had completed an additional
seven sessions. With respect to individual therapy, Mother
received three referrals, but she did not begin therapy sessions
with any of those providers. On March 12, 2024, Mother enrolled
in individual therapy, completed an assessment, and scheduled
an appointment for March 22, 2024.
DCFS reported Mother was in partial compliance with her
case plan, continued to have anger management issues, and
continued to deny that her relationship with Father created a
risk of harm to R.D. DCFS recommended that the court
terminate reunification services.

9
2. April 3, 2024 LMI
In an LMI filed on April 3, 2024, DCFS reported Mother
contacted the social worker to discuss DCFS’s recommendation
that the court terminate reunification services. The social worker
explained that although Mother had participated in programs,
DCFS did not consider Mother’s behavior to have changed.
Mother stated she had done everything DCFS had asked, and
that maternal grandmother was manipulating the social worker.
Mother denied any domestic violence or anger issues and claimed
DCFS wrongly removed R.D. from her. Mother stated the social
worker had not provided her with nine hours of visitation per
week. The social worker explained that Mother had requested to
have monitors known to her, but that visits were difficult to
arrange when the monitors canceled. Mother cursed at the social
worker, including calling him a “mutha f***” and an “ugly a**
Asian n***a[],” and threatening “I’m going to come after you” and
“You think that [I] can’t get you[?].” Due to Mother’s behavior,
the social worker moved two upcoming visits to an office where
security was present.
The LMI also indicated Mother provided DCFS with a
February 5, 2024 certificate of completion for a 12-week anger
management course.
3. Concurrent Planning Assessment
In a concurrent planning assessment filed on March 15,
2024, DCFS reported Mother and R.D. had had 20 visits in the
last six months.
4. The Hearing
At the April 4, 2024 six-month review hearing, Mother
argued she had moderately complied with the case plan and
requested that the court provide further family reunification

10
services. As to visitation, Mother acknowledged she proposed
monitors who “flaked.” However, Mother argued she participated
in her case plan, visited with R.D., and that six additional
months of reunification services would be beneficial. Minor’s
counsel supported additional reunification services for Mother.
DCFS argued R.D. was under the age of three. Mother had
more than six months of reunification services, “hasn’t learned a
thing with regards to domestic violence and anger management,”
required maternal grandmother to seek a permanent restraining
order as late as March 2024, and made threats and cursed at
people. Further, Mother and Father continued to have contact.
The court stated it was “too early to throw in the towel. I
think Mother should be given the opportunity to show that she is
interested in having this child in her care.” Mother apologized to
the court for her past outbursts, noted she was in therapy, and
said that she wanted to participate in more reunification services
to become a better parent and get R.D. back. The court explained
it would give her “one final opportunity to complete the case
plan.” The court then inquired when Mother and R.D. had last
visited. Mother responded the social worker had not scheduled
visits for two months. The court observed that it did not blame
the monitors because Mother “scares people off.” Mother
responded that she “t[ook] full responsibility” and was “working
on it.”
The court found DCFS made reasonable efforts to provide
reunification services, that Mother partially complied with the
case plan, and that returning R.D. to Mother’s custody would
create a substantial risk to R.D.’s well-being. Over DCFS’s
objection, the court ordered further reunification services for
Mother, ordered that DCFS assess an HSA for Mother’s visits,

11
and scheduled a combined 12- and 18-month review hearing for
October 2, 2024.
DISCUSSION
A. General Legal Principles Relating to Family
Reunification Services
“The purpose of California’s dependency law is ‘to provide
maximum safety and protection for children who are currently
being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being
neglected, or being exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection,
and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk
of that harm.’ [Citation.] In its effort to achieve this overarching
goal, the law balances a number of vital interests: children’s
interests in safe and stable homes; parents’ interests in raising
their children; families’ shared interests in each other’s
companionship; and the state’s interest in protecting society’s
most vulnerable members. [Citations.]” (Michael G. v. Superior
Court (2023) 14 Cal.5th 609, 623-624.) “To balance the interest
in family preservation with the child’s interest in the prompt
resolution of her custody status and long-term placement, the
dependency law establishes a detailed timeline for reunification.
For qualifying parents, the minimum length of reunification
services depends on the age of the child at the time of removal.
(. . . § 361.5, subd. (a)(1).) Parents of children under three are
presumptively eligible for at least six months of reunification
services. (See id., subd. (a)(1)(B).)” (Id. at p. 625, fn. omitted.)
For such children, reunification services should be provided “no
longer than 12 months from the date the child entered foster
care.” (§ 361.5, subd. (a)(1)(B).) However, “court-ordered services
may be extended up to a maximum time period not to exceed 18
months after the date the child was originally removed from

12
physical custody of the child’s parent” under certain
circumstances. (Id., subd. (a)(3)(A).)
“During the reunification stage, the juvenile court must
hold periodic review hearings to evaluate the status of
reunification efforts and appropriate next steps. (. . . § 366.21.)
These review hearings ordinarily take place at six-month
intervals. At each review hearing, a court evaluates, among
other things, the adequacy of the reunification services offered or
provided and the extent of the parent’s progress. If, at the six- or
12-month status review hearing, the court finds that there is a
substantial probability the child may be returned to her parent
within six months, or that reasonable services were not provided
to the parent, the court extends reunification services for an
additional six months rather than proceed to the final stage of
dependency proceedings, permanency planning. (. . . §§ 361.5,
366.21, subd[]. (e)(3) [for children under three] . . . .) The court
may schedule the section 366.26 permanency planning hearing
‘only if’ it finds ‘there is clear and convincing evidence that
reasonable services have been provided or offered to the parents
or legal guardians.’ (. . . § 366.21, subd. (g)(4).) In other words, at
the six- and 12-month status hearings, the court must find that
the parent has been provided or offered reasonable reunification
services before the court can proceed to set a hearing to decide
whether to terminate parental rights and select a permanent
plan for the child.” (Michael G. v. Superior Court, supra, 14
Cal.5th at p. 625, fn. omitted.)
To support a finding that reasonable services were offered
or provided, the record should show that DCFS identified the
problems leading to the loss of custody, offered services designed
to remedy those problems, maintained reasonable contact with

13
the parent during the reunification period, and made reasonable
efforts to assist the parent in areas where compliance proved
difficult. (Kevin R. v. Superior Court (2010) 191 Cal.App.4th 676,
691.) “The standard is not whether the services provided were
the best that might be provided in an ideal world, but whether
the services were reasonable under the circumstances.” (In re
Misako R. (1991) 2 Cal.App.4th 538, 547.)
We review a reasonable services finding for substantial
evidence based on that clear and convincing standard. (In re
M.F. (2019) 32 Cal.App.5th 1, 14, disapproved on another ground
by Michael G. v. Superior Court, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 631,
fn. 8.) In determining whether substantial evidence supports the
court’s reasonable services finding, we review the record in the
light most favorable to the finding and draw all reasonable
inferences from the evidence to support it. (In re M.F., supra, at
p. 14.) We do not reweigh the evidence or exercise independent
judgment, and the burden is on the appellant to show that the
evidence is insufficient to support the court’s findings. (Ibid.)
B. DCFS Provided Reasonable Reunification Services
Under the Circumstances
No party takes issue on appeal with Mother receiving
further reunification services. Mother’s sole argument is that
DCFS failed to provide her with reasonable services during the
first six months of the dependency proceedings because it did not
facilitate regular visits between her and R.D.2 DCFS argues that

2 Although the court here extended reunification services
for another six months, “a parent . . . can [be] aggrieved by a
reasonable services finding at the time of the six-month review
hearing if it is not supported by substantial evidence. Such a

14
Mother forfeited this argument because she did not raise it in the
juvenile court. We disagree. Mother complained during the six-
month review hearing that DCFS failed to provide adequate
visitation. Even if she had not done so, a party’s failure to raise a
substantial evidence challenge in the juvenile court does not
forfeit the issue for purposes of appeal. (See In re Javier G.
(2006) 137 Cal.App.4th 453, 464.)
Visitation is a critical component of a reunification plan.
(In re Alvin R. (2003) 108 Cal.App.4th 962, 972.) “In order to
maintain ties between the parent . . . and the child, and to
provide information relevant to deciding if, and when, to return a
child to the custody of his or her parent . . . , any order placing a
child in foster care, and ordering reunification services, shall
provide . . . [¶] . . . for visitation between the parent . . . and the
child. Visitation shall be as frequent as possible . . . .” (§ 362.1,
subd. (a).)
The law requires that DCFS provide reasonable
reunification services under the circumstances of the case before
it. (See In re Misako R., supra, 2 Cal.App.4th at p. 547.) Here,
during the six months prior to March 15, 2024, Mother had 20
visits with R.D., and the chronology makes clear the social
worker made repeated efforts to facilitate additional visits,
including timely efforts to clear persons suggested by Mother to
act as monitors. The fact those additional visits did not occur
was not due to a lack of reasonable effort by DCFS. It was

finding can put the interests of parents and children in
reunification at a significant procedural disadvantage.” (In re
T.G. (2010) 188 Cal.App.4th 687, 695.)

15
primarily because of Mother’s actions and those of her own
proposed monitors.
Mother argues that DCFS did not provide reasonable
reunification services because she did not have visits with R.D. in
November until Thanksgiving Day, and then, after January 1,
2024, she did not have any visits until March 8, 2024. In
November 2023, the social worker attempted to schedule four
visits. Mother wanted monitors known to her—in other words,
friends instead of someone from DCFS. Monitors were not
available on two occasions and maternal grandmother could not
accommodate the third proposed date. For the fourth attempted
visit, Mother’s monitor L.B. did not have a car, and Mother could
not agree with maternal grandmother on a visitation location.
Thereafter, maternal grandmother agreed to act as a
monitor, and Mother had visits with R.D. between Thanksgiving
and mid-to-late December. That stopped not because of DCFS
but because Mother lost her temper and blew up at maternal
grandmother. After maternal grandmother refused to monitor
visits due to Mother’s actions, the social worker texted Mother on
January 9, 2024, but Mother did not respond until over a month
later on February 11, 2024. Between February 14 and 17, the
social worker attempted to arrange a visit with L.B. as a monitor,
but L.B. did not return the social worker’s call. The record
indicates that Mother made an 11th-hour proposal of R.B. as a
monitor, but the social worker could not clear R.B. in time for the
February 17 visit. Soon after, the social worker was able to clear
R.B. and scheduled her to monitor a February 24 visit. However,
that visit did not occur because Mother was arrested for driving
under the influence and did not appear for the visit.

16
On March 1, 2024, the social worker learned that R.B. no
longer want to serve as a monitor. The social worker then set to
determine whether A.S. and K.F., two other potential monitors
proposed by Mother, could be cleared. In the meantime, the
social worker arranged a March 8, 2024 visit for Mother and R.D.
to be monitored by DCFS staff.
Based on the court’s statement that Mother was hostile,
Mother argues her behavior should not have deterred DCFS from
providing staff to act as a monitor because DCFS specially trains
its staff to deal with difficult personalities such as hers. Mother’s
argument presumes DCFS did not assign its staff to monitor her
visits because of her behavior. Nothing supports this contention.
Instead, Mother expressed a preference for monitors that she
knew, and it was those monitors (such as maternal grandmother
and R.B.) that chose not to participate as a result of Mother’s
aggressiveness. Indeed, even after Mother threatened the DCFS
social worker, he continued to facilitate visits, scheduling them at
a location with security.
Accordingly, we conclude substantial evidence
demonstrates DCFS provided reasonable reunification services
under the circumstances.3

3 Mother argues in a conclusory fashion that at the
January 12, 2024 hearing, the court should have ordered DCFS
to assess an HSA to serve as a monitor. The court previously
made such an order on October 10, 2023, and reiterated it on
April 4, 2024; it never modified or retracted that order between
those two dates. To the extent Mother nevertheless believes she
was aggrieved by what occurred at the January 12, 2024 hearing,
her notice of appeal does not list that hearing and in any event
was filed well after 60 days from the court’s January 12, 2024

17
DISPOSITION
The juvenile court’s April 4, 2024 order is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED

WEINGART, J.

We concur:

BENDIX, Acting P. J.

M. KIM, J.

order. We therefore lack jurisdiction to consider her claim. (In re
Cynthia C. (1997) 58 Cal.App.4th 1479, 1488.)

18

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.