People v. Patel CA4/1

CourtListener 10315201Calctapp16.01.2025

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 1/16/25 P. v. Patel CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION ONE

STATE OF CALIFORNIA

THE PEOPLE, D083132

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.
(Super. Ct. No. SCN441900)
SHAAF PATEL,

Defendant and Appellant.

APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Laura E. Duffy, Judge. Affirmed.
Thien Huong Tran, under appointment by the Court of Appeal, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief Assistance
Attorney General, Charles C. Ragland, Assistant Attorney General, Robin
Urbanski and Laura Baggett, Deputy Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and
Respondent.
A jury convicted Shaaf Patel of one count of receiving stolen property
(Pen. Code, § 496, subdivision (a)). Patel moved for a new trial, contending
that his counsel was ineffective. The court denied the motion.
Patel appeals, contending his trial counsel refused to let him testify at
his trial and therefore the court erred in denying his motion. We find the
court’s error was harmless and affirm.
STATEMENT OF FACTS
After a burglary at IQHQ, a commercial establishment that had been
undergoing renovations, law enforcement learned that Brandy Ruiz was
using a credit card that had been taken during the burglary. During a search
of Ruiz’s cell phone, officers discovered Patel’s cell phone number and a video
of Patel and Ruiz with items that had been taken during the burglary,
including laptops, monitors and televisions, and moving them from a
shipping container into Patel’s car. Ruiz inventoried the items in Patel’s car:
“So two Samsung, one Dell, two laptops, I mean, two keyboards, and seven
laptops. Cool.” Patel and Ruiz discussed that the laptops were worth “two
grand” and that Ruiz’s boyfriend, Dustin Greear, “wants to try to get at least
half.” Patel stated that Greear told Patel to “sell ‘em for half’ ” and then split
the proceeds with Greear. In the video, after loading the car, Patel and Ruiz
went inside the shipping container, which contained additional boxes of
electronics as well as bottles of liquor. Patel opened a box that contained
sports trading cards and commented on their value. Ruiz agreed and said
that she had told Greear, “Babe, good news, we can finally move!” Patel and
Ruiz also discussed that the cards were “worth about a thousand to two
thousand dollars, easily.” Ruiz explained that “[a]nd what’s funny, too, is we
didn’t even realize when we got these that that’s what it was . . . we thought
it was more laptops. Then we opened it.” When Patel asked Ruiz how
Greear found the “spot,” Ruiz explained that Greear went to “a construction
site” where “the door happened to be unlocked, and boom. He was like, ‘Ah!’ ”

2
Detectives located Patel and arrested him. He was interviewed after
the arrest. Excerpts of his interview were played for the jury. In the
interview, Patel stated that Greear had instructed Ruiz to take Patel to the
storage container to load up his vehicle. Patel stated that the items had been
stolen a day or two before he and Ruiz had loaded the items into his car. He
noted that Greear had gone to help an associate at a gas station that “was
right across the street from the place that they broke into.” Patel stated that
Greear would take “[a]nything that’s not bolted to the ground” and that
Greear and others would check the door on commercial buildings, go inside
and then take “whatever he can get.” Patel said that he had seen between
twenty and thirty laptops in the storage container, including “brand new ones
in the box,” and a stack of used laptops as well as “a lot of monitors” and
bottles of liquor. He acknowledged that he saw jackets and shirts with the
IQHQ logo on the sleeves. Patel agreed that he and Greear were going to
split the profits of what Patel sold. Patel told the detective that his intention
was to either sell the computers on Offer Up or to other local businessmen in
Riverside. He speculated that Greear asked him to sell the items because
he’s clean-cut and that he was “not in their scene” and therefore “off the
radar.” Patel commented that “even a grandma could sell” the “brand new in
the box laptops,” and that such items frequently sell for fifty percent of their
retail value. “Well, I mean, anything that’s being sold on the street [is] like
instantly half off. And then . . . if people don’t have money then you know,
whatever you can get for it.”
Patel was charged in an information with one count of violating Penal
Code section 496, subdivision (a)—receipt of stolen property with a value in
excess of $950. The jury convicted Patel of the offense and found true an
allegation that the value of the received property exceeded $950. Patel,

3
acting on his own, filed a motion for a new trial, raising a number of issues
regarding his trial counsel’s performance at trial. Among the various
arguments in the motion, Patel asserted that “[my attorney] also refused to
allow me to take the stand. I was following his directions, which I later
learned from speaking with other attorneys is incorrect.” Other than this
statement, which he made under penalty of perjury, he provided no evidence
to support this assertion, and at the hearing, he submitted the matter
without offering any evidence. After discussing several of the issues raised in
the motion, the court found Patel had failed to meet his burden to show
ineffective assistance of counsel and denied his new trial motion. The court
sentenced Patel to two years formal probation and 90 days incarceration.
Patel timely appeals.
DISCUSSION
Patel contends on appeal that his counsel refused to let him testify and
that the court erred in failing to inquire of defense counsel as to this issue.
1. Legal Principles
Under the Sixth Amendment, a defendant in a criminal case is entitled
to the effective assistance of counsel. The defendant bears the burden to
prove the performance of counsel fell below the appropriate level of
competence and that such failure caused the defendant prejudice.
(Strickland v. Washington (1984) 466 U.S. 668, 686, 688.)
Where, as here, the court denies a motion for new trial that is based
upon a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel, we uphold the trial court’s
factual findings if they are supported by substantial evidence. (People
v. Taylor (1984) 162 Cal.App.3d 720, 724 [“The trial court’s factual findings,
express or implied, will be upheld if they are supported by substantial

4
evidence”].) We independently review whether the appellant received
ineffective assistance. (Id. at p. 725.)
A defendant has the right to decide whether to testify at trial in his
own defense. (People v. Winn (2020) 44 Cal.App.5th 859, 871 (Winn) [trial
court erred by failing to inquire into Winn’s claim that his counsel deprived
him of the right to testify].) The denial of a defendant’s right to testify is
subject to harmless error analysis under Chapman v. California (1967)
386 U.S. 18, i.e., whether the error was harmless beyond a reasonable doubt.
(People v. Allen (2008) 44 Cal.4th 843, 871; see also Winn, at p. 871.)
2. Analysis
Here, the trial court made no findings regarding Patel’s assertion in his
motion that his attorney “refused to allow [him] to take the stand.” Other
than this statement, made under penalty of perjury, there is nothing in the
record regarding the issue, which presumably would have occurred in a
private conversation between Patel and his counsel. There was no contrary
evidence before the court that would support even an implied finding as to
the issue, and therefore there is no substantial evidence that would support
the court’s denial of the new trial motion as to this issue. (See Winn, supra,
44 Cal.App.5th at p. 871.)
However, as in Winn, the error here was harmless beyond a reasonable
doubt. The only issue at trial was whether Patel knew the items were stolen
at the time he received them. As recounted above, the video recording of
Patel loading numerous boxes of electronics into his vehicle, his discussion
with Ruiz about where the items in the storage unit had come from, and his
postarrest statements to the detectives established his culpability beyond a
reasonable doubt.

5
Patel argues that the evidence of his knowledge was insufficiently
proven at trial. If he had testified, he would have asserted that he did not
know the goods were stolen when he received them, and “the outcome could
have been different.” Patel asserts that his question to Ruiz about how they
found the “spot” only occurred after he had loaded the items in his car, and
therefore when he was loading the items, “it is conceivable he had no idea the
goods were stolen.”
A person’s knowledge as to the character of stolen property “may be,
and almost always must be, presented by circumstantial evidence.” (People
v. Rodriguez (1986) 177 Cal.App.3d 174, 179–180) [circumstantial evidence of
knowledge strongly supported conviction for receiving stolen property; court’s
error in allowing impeachment was harmless].) None of the evidence
presented at trial raised any doubt as to Patel’s knowledge of the stolen
nature of the property he took in his vehicle; instead, all the evidence,
including Patel’s own statements to Ruiz and to the detectives proved
circumstantially that Patel was well aware of the stolen nature of the
property in his car. Even without Patel’s testimony denying knowledge,
Patel’s attorney argued to the jury that there was no evidence that Patel
knew the items were stolen. The jury disagreed and found Patel guilty
beyond a reasonable doubt. Similarly, we conclude that the omission of
Patel’s testimony denying knowledge was harmless beyond a reasonable
doubt.

6
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

KELETY, J.

WE CONCUR:

BUCHANAN, Acting P. J.

RUBIN, J.

7

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.