CourtListener 10305576•Calleja v. Udewitz CA2/1
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 12/30/24 Calleja v. Udewitz CA2/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
DAISY CALLEJA, B319906
Plaintiff and Respondent, (Los Angeles County
Super. Ct. No. BC574549)
v.
JONATHAN UDEWITZ, as Special
Administrator, etc.,
Defendant and Appellant.
APPEAL from an order of the Superior Court of
Los Angeles County, Frederick C. Shaller, Judge. Affirmed.
Ford, Walker, Haggerty & Behar, Neil Tardiff and
Mark P. LaScola for Defendant and Appellant.
Singleton Schreiber, Benjamin I. Siminou; Simon Law
Group and Greyson M. Goody for Plaintiff and Respondent.
____________________________
See footnote 4, post.
This is an appeal from an award in a personal injury case
of expert fees and prejudgment interest pursuant to the penalty
provisions in Code of Civil Procedure1 section 998 and Civil Code
section 3291. To encourage pretrial settlement of litigation, the
Legislature enacted section 998, which authorizes a plaintiff to
seek an award of expert witness fees accruing after the date of
the plaintiff’s settlement offer if the defendant does not accept
that offer and the defendant fails to secure a more favorable
judgment or award. (See § 998, subds. (b) & (d).) If the offer is
made in a personal injury action and the plaintiff obtains a more
favorable judgment, then the plaintiff may also seek an award of
postoffer prejudgment interest.2 (See Civ. Code, § 3291.)
This appeal presents the following question: If (1) a
defendant does not accept a plaintiff’s section 998 offer, (2) the
defendant dies after the offer expired, and (3) the plaintiff
ultimately secures a judgment or award greater than the
settlement offer, then can the plaintiff obtain an award of
statutory penalties against the deceased defendant’s personal
representative?3 We answer that question in the affirmative.
1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Code of
Civil Procedure.
2 As a shorthand, we sometimes refer collectively to the
postoffer expert witness fees and prejudgment interest awardable
under Code of Civil Procedure section 998 and Civil Code
section 3291 as “section 998 penalties” or “statutory penalties.”
3 “ ‘ “The ‘personal representative’ is the person or firm
appointed by the probate court to administer the probate of a
decedent’s estate. [Citation.] The personal representative may
be the executor, who is the person named as such in the
decedent’s will, or it may be the successor to the executor, or an
2
Section 998 does not expressly address whether the
personal representative of the deceased recipient of the
section 998 offer may be held liable for statutory penalties by
virtue of the deceased’s failure to accept the opposing party’s
section 998 offer. Nor does Civil Code section 3291. Defendant
and appellant Donna Bogdanovich4 contends section 998 refers to
“the defendant” and we should interpret that term to refer to the
now deceased former defendant, because he, and not the personal
representative, received the offer. Plaintiff and respondent Daisy
administrator appointed by the court where the decedent died
without a will naming an executor. [Citation.]” ’ [Citation.] ‘It is
the duty of the personal representative to collect estate assets
and preserve them until distribution, to pay claims against the
estate including taxes and the charges of administration, and to
distribute the residue to those entitled.’ [Citations.]” (Estate of
Casserley (2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 824, 828, fn. 1, italics omitted.)
4 We note appellant’s briefing contains two different
spellings of Bogdanovich’s name. This discrepancy has no impact
on our resolution of this appeal.
We further note that on May 21, 2024, appellant’s counsel
informed this court that Bogdanovich had been removed from her
position as administrator of the Estate of Jose Chavez in
January 2024. On November 6, 2024, the probate court in case
no. 19STPB05495 appointed Jonathan Udewitz as “the Special
Administrator . . . for the sole purpose of representing the Estate”
in this appeal. We, sua sponte, take judicial notice of this probate
court order, which was attached to a status report filed by
appellant’s counsel on November 12, 2024. (Evid. Code, §§ 452,
subd. (d), 459.) Because Bogdanovich was the administrator of
Chavez’s estate during the events that are the subject of this
appeal, we refer to the administrator/appellant as “Bogdanovich”
throughout this opinion except where necessary for clarity.
3
Calleja argues the personal representative stands in the
deceased’s shoes such that statutory penalties may be imposed on
the personal representative even if he or she was not the
recipient of the section 998 offer. We conclude that because the
statutory language is reasonably susceptible to either
interpretation, Code of Civil Procedure section 998 and the
corresponding language in Civil Code section 3291 are
ambiguous. In the absence here of relevant legislative history,
we conclude that the purposes underlying both statutes are
better served by adopting Calleja’s interpretation.5
Our interpretation of Code of Civil Procedure section 998
and Civil Code section 3291 disposes of Bogdanovich’s principal
challenge to the trial court’s award of expert witness fees and
prejudgment interest to Calleja. We also reject Bogdanovich’s
contention that Calleja waived her right to seek section 998
penalties, and conclude that Bogdanovich forfeited the remaining
claims of error, including that the trial court erred in awarding
prejudgment interest on future damages. In sum, we affirm.
5 Probate Code section 1002 provides: “Unless it is
otherwise provided by this code or by rules adopted by the
Judicial Council, either the superior court or the court on appeal
may, in its discretion, order costs to be paid by any party to the
proceedings, or out of the assets of the estate, as justice may
require.” (Prob. Code, § 1002.) In their briefing, neither party
cites section 1002, and, consequently, they do not address
whether it has any relevance to the issues before us. We thus
express no opinion on that question.
4
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND6
We summarize only the procedural history relevant to this
appeal.
In March 2015, Calleja sued Jose Chavez for personal
injuries she allegedly suffered in a motor vehicle accident. On
February 25, 2016, Calleja served Chavez with a section 998 offer
to compromise in the amount of $750,000. Chavez allowed the
offer to lapse by failing to accept it within the 30-day statutory
deadline for doing so. (See Applicable Law, post [discussing §
998, subd. (b)(2)’s deadline to accept an offer].) Chavez died in
November 2018.
In December 2019, Calleja filed a Doe amendment naming
Bogdanovich, administrator of Chavez’s estate, in place of Doe 3.
Bogdanovich answered the complaint in January 2020. Calleja
did not serve an offer of compromise on Bogdanovich, and neither
party claims Bogdanovich had served an offer of compromise on
Calleja either. In July 2021, the trial court clerk dismissed
Chavez from the action without prejudice at Calleja’s request.7
In August 2021, a jury tried the case. The jury returned a
verdict in favor of Calleja and against Bogdanovich in the amount
6 We derive our Procedural Background in part from
undisputed findings in the trial court’s ruling, the parties’
admissions in their appellate briefing, and assertions by Calleja
that Bogdanovich does not dispute in the reply brief. (See
Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs v. County of
Los Angeles (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 764, 772, fn. 2, 773–774
(Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs) [employing this
approach].)
7 We describe this dismissal in greater detail in our
Discussion, part D, post.
5
of $1,176,992.60, which consists of $221,392.60 in past economic
loss, $150,000 in past noneconomic damages, $705,600 in future
economic loss, and $100,000 in future noneconomic damages.8 In
September 2021, in accordance with the jury’s verdict, the trial
court entered judgment in favor of Calleja and against
Bogdanovich in her capacity as administrator of Chavez’s estate.
The original judgment contained a blank space for the trial court
to later insert an award of costs in favor of Calleja and against
Bogdanovich in her capacity as the administrator of Chavez’s
estate.
Calleja filed a memorandum of costs seeking $834,163.24
against Bogdanovich, including $89,969.49 in expert witness fees
and $657,173.48 in prejudgment interest. Bogdanovich moved to
tax costs, arguing, among other things, that Calleja was not
entitled to section 998 penalties because she never served a
statutory offer on Bogdanovich. On December 16, 2021, the trial
court rejected Bogdanovich’s argument against awarding
section 998 penalties and awarded Calleja $81,789.759 in expert
witness fees and $683,945.56 in prejudgment interest.10
Concurrent with its order on Bogdanovich’s motion to tax, the
8 At one point, the judgment’s recitation of the jury’s
verdict suggests that the $100,000 award corresponds to Calleja’s
past—rather than future—noneconomic damages. This apparent
typographical error does not impact our resolution of this appeal.
9 The trial court granted in part Bogdanovich’s motion by
taxing $8,179.74 of the expert witness fees, $1,209 in deposition
costs, and $2,400 in interpreter fees that Calleja had requested.
10 Calleja had requested $657,173.48. The trial court
awarded a higher amount—$683,945.56—to account for interest
accruing after Calleja filed her memorandum of costs.
6
trial court issued an amended judgment that included its award
of costs to Calleja.
On February 25, 2022, Bogdanovich appealed the
December 16, 2021 order. During the pendency of this appeal, in
an unpublished opinion, we affirmed the original judgment that
awarded Calleja the damages found by the jury. (Calleja v.
Bogdanovich (Aug. 17, 2023, B317024) [nonpub. opn.].)11
APPLICABLE LAW
“As a general matter, a party prevailing at trial may not
recover the fees of experts who are not ordered by the court.
[Citations.] Such fees are recoverable, however, when a
judgment following the nonacceptance of a pretrial settlement
offer triggers operation of section 998.” (Martinez v. Brownco
Construction Co. (2013) 56 Cal.4th 1014, 1018–1019 (Martinez).)
Section 998 delineates procedures governing the service
and expiration of settlement offers subject to its terms. “Not less
than 10 days prior to commencement of trial or arbitration (as
provided in Section 1281 or 1295) of a dispute to be resolved by
arbitration, any party may serve an offer in writing upon any
other party to the action to allow judgment to be taken or an
award to be entered in accordance with the terms and conditions
stated at that time.” (§ 998, subd. (b).) “If the offer is accepted,
the offer with proof of acceptance shall be filed and the clerk or
the judge shall enter judgment accordingly.” (Id., subd. (b)(1).)
“Any judgment or award entered pursuant to . . . section [998]
shall be deemed to be a compromise settlement.” (Id., subd. (f).)
“If the offer is not accepted prior to trial or arbitration or within
11We, sua sponte, take judicial notice of our prior
unpublished opinion. (Evid. Code, §§ 452, subd. (d), 459.)
7
30 days after it is made, whichever occurs first, it shall be
deemed withdrawn, and cannot be given in evidence upon the
trial or arbitration.” (Id., subd. (b)(2).)
The statute also prescribes the consequences of failing to
accept such a settlement offer. Regarding a defendant’s
settlement offer: “If an offer made by a defendant is not accepted
and the plaintiff fails to obtain a more favorable judgment or
award, the plaintiff shall not recover his or her postoffer costs
and shall pay the defendant’s costs from the time of the offer. In
addition, in any action or proceeding other than an eminent
domain action, the court or arbitrator, in its discretion, may
require the plaintiff to pay a reasonable sum to cover postoffer
costs of the services of expert witnesses, who are not regular
employees of any party, actually incurred and reasonably
necessary in either, or both, preparation for trial or arbitration,
or during trial or arbitration, of the case by the defendant.”
(§ 998, subd. (c)(1).)
Regarding settlements offered by a plaintiff, the statute
provides: “If an offer made by a plaintiff is not accepted and the
defendant fails to obtain a more favorable judgment or award in
any action or proceeding other than an eminent domain action,
the court or arbitrator, in its discretion, may require the
defendant to pay a reasonable sum to cover postoffer costs of the
services of expert witnesses, who are not regular employees of
any party, actually incurred and reasonably necessary in either,
or both, preparation for trial or arbitration, or during trial or
arbitration, of the case by the plaintiff, in addition to plaintiff’s
costs.” (§ 998, subd. (d).)
A correlating provision appears in Civil Code section 3291,
which “provides for prejudgment interest as a recoverable cost
8
when a plaintiff prevails on a . . . section 998 offer in personal-
injury actions.” (See Glassman v. Safeco Ins. Co. of America
(2023) 90 Cal.App.5th 1281, 1293, 1301 & fn. 1 (Glassman).)
Specifically, “[i]f the plaintiff makes an offer pursuant to
Section 998 of the Code of Civil Procedure which the defendant
does not accept prior to trial or within 30 days, whichever occurs
first, and the plaintiff obtains a more favorable judgment, the
judgment shall bear interest at the legal rate of 10 percent per
annum calculated from the date of the plaintiff’s first offer
pursuant to Section 998 of the Code of Civil Procedure which is
exceeded by the judgment, and interest shall accrue until the
satisfaction of judgment.” (Civ. Code, § 3291.)
The “fee-shifting rules of section 998” turn on whether “the
section 998 offer was valid, reasonable, and made in good faith.”
(See Smalley v. Subaru of America, Inc. (2022) 87 Cal.App.5th
450, 453.) In analyzing whether the offeror discharged his or her
burden of establishing the validity of a section 998 offer, a court
determines whether the offer complies with the statute and is
sufficiently specific to permit the offeree to determine whether to
accept it. (See Glassman, supra, 90 Cal.App.5th at p. 1313.) If
the offeror discharges that burden, then the offeree must
“demonstrate the offer was unreasonable or was not made in good
faith” to avoid statutory penalties. (See Smalley, at pp. 455, 458.)
DISCUSSION
A. Bogdanovich’s Appeal of the Trial Court’s Order Is
Timely
Calleja does not contest the timeliness of Bogdanovich’s
appeal. We, however, “ ‘are dutybound to consider [this question]
on our own motion’ [citation]” because “ ‘[c]ompliance with the
9
time for filing a notice of appeal is mandatory and jurisdictional.
[Citations.] . . . .’ [Citations.]” (See Nguyen v. Calhoun (2003)
105 Cal.App.4th 428, 436; Ellis v. Ellis (2015) 235 Cal.App.4th
837, 842 (Ellis).)
“California Rules of Court, rule 8.104(a)(1),[12] contains the
applicable time period for filing a notice of appeal.” (Ellis, supra,
235 Cal.App.4th at p. 842.) Rule 8.104(a)(1) provides in pertinent
part: “[A] notice of appeal must be filed on or before the earliest
of: [¶] (A) 60 days after the superior court clerk serves on the
party filing the notice of appeal a document entitled ‘Notice of
Entry’ of judgment or a filed-endorsed copy of the judgment,
showing the date either was served; [¶] (B) 60 days after the
party filing the notice of appeal serves or is served by a party
with a document entitled ‘Notice of Entry’ of judgment or a filed-
endorsed copy of the judgment, accompanied by proof of service;
or [¶] (C) 180 days after entry of judgment.” (Rule 8.104(a)(1).)
“As used in [rule 8.104](a)[,] . . . ‘judgment’ includes an
appealable order if the appeal is from an appealable order.”
(Rule 8.104(e).)
On December 16, 2021, the trial court issued its minute
order granting in part and denying in part Bogdanovich’s motion
to tax costs.13 On February 25, 2022, Bogdanovich appealed the
12 All unspecified rule references are to the California
Rules of Court.
13 A postjudgment ruling on a motion to tax costs is
appealable pursuant to section 904.1, subdivision (a)(2). (See
§ 904.1, subd. (a)(2) [“An appeal . . . may be taken from any of the
following: [¶] . . . [¶] [A]n order made after a judgment . . . .”];
LNSU #1, LLC v. Alta Del Mar Coastal Collection Community
Assn. (2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 1050, 1081 [noting that “ ‘[a]
10
December 16, 2021 order. Bogdanovich asserts in her opening
brief that she filed the notice of appeal on February 14, 2022.
Although Bogdanovich’s trial counsel apparently inserted
“2/14/2022” above the signature line on the notice of appeal, the
trial court clerk’s electronic stamp at the top of the document
shows the notice was filed on February 25, 2022. Accordingly,
Bogdanovich filed her notice of appeal 71 days after issuance of
the December 16, 2021 order.14 Bogdanovich’s appeal is
nonetheless timely.
First, rule 8.104(a)(1)(A)’s 60-day deadline is inapplicable.
We acknowledge that a certificate of mailing filed on
December 16, 2021 indicates the trial court clerk served the order
on Bogdanovich’s counsel on that date. There is no indication,
however, that the trial court clerk served a “Notice of Entry” of
that order or a filed-endorsed copy of the ruling upon
Bogdanovich.15 (See Alan v. American Honda Motor Co., Inc.
(2007) 40 Cal.4th 894, 902 [“ ‘Because the time limits for filing a
notice of appeal are jurisdictional, we must apply
postjudgment order which awards or denies costs[,]’ ” including
an “order denying [a] motion to tax costs,” “ ‘is separately
appealable’ ” pursuant to § 904.1, subd. (a)(2)].)
14 We, sua sponte, take judicial notice of the fact that
February 25, 2022 is 71 days after December 16, 2021. (Evid.
Code, §§ 452, subd. (h), 459.)
15 We, sua sponte, take judicial notice of the certificate of
mailing and the December 16, 2021 order from the trial court’s
docket, neither of which indicate the court clerk served a “Notice
of Entry” of the order or a filed-endorsed version of the order on
the parties. (Evid. Code, §§ 452, subd. (d), 459.)
11
[rule 8.104(a)(1)] . . . strictly and literally according to its
terms . . . .”].)
Next, our record is devoid of evidence or a representation in
briefing that either party had served the other with a copy of the
December 16, 2021 order. Thus, rule 8.104(a)(1)(B)’s 60-day
deadline is also inapplicable.
In sum, because Bogdanovich filed her notice of appeal
within 180 days of entry of the December 16, 2021 order, her
appeal is timely under rule 8.104(a)(1)(C).
B. Interpreting Code of Civil Procedure Section 998 and
Civil Code Section 3291 To Authorize Statutory
Penalties Against a Personal Representative of a
Defendant Who Failed To Accept a Plaintiff’s
Settlement Offer Best Effectuates the Statutes’
Purposes, Including Promotion of Early Settlement
1. Principles of statutory interpretation and standard of
review
The principles of statutory interpretation are well known.
We start with the language of the statute. (Dignity Health v.
Local Initiative Health Care Authority of Los Angeles County
(2020) 44 Cal.App.5th 144, 154 (Dignity Health).) If the language
is ambiguous, that is, it “allows for more than one reasonable
interpretation,” then we consult legislative history and other
extrinsic evidence of legislative intent. (See ibid.) In addition,
we may consider public policies served by the parties’ opposing
statutory interpretations. (See People v. Manzo (2012) 53 Cal.4th
880, 885–886 (Manzo).)
In applying these interpretive rules, we are mindful that
“ ‘[t]he fundamental rule is to ascertain the Legislature’s intent
12
in order to give effect to the purpose of the law.’ [Citation.]”
(Dignity Health, supra, 44 Cal.App.5th at p. 154.) “ ‘ “We must
select the construction that comports most closely with the
apparent intent of the Legislature, with a view to promoting
rather than defeating the general purpose of the statute, and
avoid an interpretation that would lead to absurd consequences.”
[Citation.]’ [Citation.]” (People v. Lofchie (2014) 229 Cal.App.4th
240, 251 (Lofchie).)
To recap, the principal issue before us is whether a plaintiff
may recover section 998 penalties from the personal
representative of a now deceased defendant when the section 998
offer was made only to the deceased, and not the personal
representative, and the offer had expired before that defendant
died. “Because this is a question of statutory interpretation, our
review is de novo.” (Moofly Productions, LLC v. Favila (2018)
24 Cal.App.5th 993, 997.)
“ ‘Even when our review on appeal “is de novo, it is limited
to issues which have been adequately raised and supported in
[the appellant’s opening] brief. [Citations.] . . . ” ’ [Citation.]”
(Golden Door Properties, LLC v. County of San Diego (2020)
50 Cal.App.5th 467, 554–555.) This rule is a corollary to “ ‘ “[t]he
most fundamental rule of appellate review . . . that an appealed
judgment or order is presumed to be correct.” [Citation.] It is the
appellant who bears the burden of overcoming that presumption.’
[Citation.]” (See id. at p. 555.) To overcome the presumption of
correctness, the appellant must “ ‘ “ ‘supply[ ] the reviewing court
with some cogent argument supported by legal analysis and
citation to the record.’ ” [Citation.]’ [Citation.]” (See Association
for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, supra, 94 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 776–777.)
13
2. Code of Civil Procedure section 998 and Civil Code
section 3291 are ambiguous, and there is no
legislative history or judicial decision resolving the
issue before us
Section 998 does not expressly address whether a trial
court may award statutory penalties against the personal
representative of a deceased defendant who failed to accept a
plaintiff’s section 998 offer: “If an offer made by a plaintiff is not
accepted and the defendant fails to obtain a more favorable
judgment or award[,] . . . the court or arbitrator, in its discretion,
may require the defendant to pay a reasonable sum to cover
postoffer costs of the services of expert witnesses . . . .” (See
§ 998, subd. (d).) Civil Code section 3291 does not expressly
address that circumstance either; it merely prescribes the
consequences when “the defendant” does not accept the plaintiff’s
Code of Civil Procedure section 998 offer.16 (See Civil Code,
§ 3291.)
Bogdanovich argues that Code of Civil Procedure
section 998, subdivision (d)’s reference to “the defendant,” and,
presumably, Civil Code section 3291’s use of that term, should be
read narrowly, that is, statutory penalties can be awarded
16 Civil Code section 3291, however, exempts public
entities and employees acting within the scope of their
employment from its penalty provisions. (See Civ. Code, § 3291
[“This section shall not apply to a public entity, or to a public
employee for an act or omission within the scope of employment,
and neither the public entity nor the public employee shall be
liable, directly or indirectly, to any person for any interest
imposed by this section.”].)
14
against only the actual recipient of the plaintiff’s offer.17 Calleja
counters that a personal representative stands in the shoes of the
deceased former defendant, who received and failed to accept the
plaintiff’s section 998 offer.
The statutory text is reasonably susceptible to Calleja’s and
Bogdanovich’s interpretations. The statute is thus ambiguous.
(See Dignity Health, supra, 44 Cal.App.5th at p. 154 [“ ‘If the
statutory language is clear, we should not change it to accomplish
a purpose that does not appear on the face of the statute or from
its legislative history.’ [Citation.] If, however, the language
allows for more than one reasonable interpretation[, it] . . . is
ambiguous . . . .”].)
The term “the defendant” in Code of Civil Procedure
section 998, subdivision (d) and Civil Code section 3291, could
simply refer to the “other party to the action” upon whom “any
party” served the offer, as the quoted terms are referenced in
subdivision (b) of section 998. (See § 998, subd. (b).)18 On the
other hand, the Code of Civil Procedure generally defines “the
defendant” to a civil action as the party “adverse” to the plaintiff
(see §§ 307–308), and a provision in that code states, “[A] cause of
action against a decedent that survives may be asserted against
17 Although Bogdanovich does not discuss specifically the
text of Civil Code section 3291 in connection with this argument,
Bogdanovich does argue the trial court’s award of “expert witness
fees and post-settlement offer prejudgment interest” was
erroneous because statutory penalties cannot be awarded
“against the administrator of a defendant’s estate who was never
served with the [Code of Civil Procedure section] 998 offer . . . .”
(Italics added.)
18 (See Applicable Law, ante.)
15
the decedent’s personal representative” (see § 377.40).19 If Code
of Civil Procedure section 998, subdivision (d) and Civil Code
section 3291 were read in conjunction with these other
provisions, one could infer that the term “the defendant” includes
the personal representative of the deceased-offeree defendant.
(See Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, supra,
94 Cal.App.5th at p. 789, fn. 21 [noting that under “the
interpretive doctrine of ‘in pari materia[,]’ ” “ ‘related statutes
[can be] construed together’ ”].)
Neither Bogdanovich nor Calleja asserts there is evidence
of legislative intent resolving this ambiguity, and our own
research has not located any legislative history or judicial
decisions resolving the interpretive issue before us. We thus turn
to the purposes underlying Code of Civil Procedure section 998
and Civil Code section 3291 for guidance in selecting the
appropriate construction of “the defendant.” (See Manzo, supra,
53 Cal.4th at p. 886 [noting that “[w]e may . . . consider extrinsic
aids such as the ostensible objects to be achieved, the evils to be
remedied, and public policy” if a statute is ambiguous]; cf.
Martinez, supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 1017 [observing that “the terms
of section 998 . . . are silent as to the effect of a party’s multiple
19 We acknowledge section 377.40 provides that the right
to assert a cause of action against a decedent’s personal
representative is “[s]ubject to Part 4 (commencing with
Section 9000) of Division 7 of the Probate Code governing creditor
claims . . . .” (See § 377.40.) We explain in Discussion, part C,
post, that Bogdanovich forfeited her argument that the trial
court’s award of statutory penalties violates a provision in part 4
of division 7 of the Probate Code, to wit, Probate Code
section 9370. (See Prob. Code, § 9370 [codified in part 4 of div. 7
of the Prob. Code].)
16
[settlement] offers,” and thereafter adopting a construction that
is “consistent with section 998’s language and best promotes the
statutory purpose”].)
3. The statutory purposes, as evidenced by our high
court’s description of those purposes, are best served
by adopting Calleja’s interpretation
In Martinez, our high court described the statutory
purposes underlying section 998. There, a plaintiff served two
pretrial statutory offers on the defendant, neither of which was
accepted. (See Martinez, supra, 56 Cal.4th at pp. 1017–1018.)
After trial, the plaintiff obtained a judgment that was in the
same amount as her first statutory offer and greater than her
second offer. (See id. at p. 1018.) The Supreme Court rejected
the defendant’s argument that the plaintiff was not entitled to
the expert fees she incurred after her first settlement offer but
before her second offer. (See id. at pp. 1017–1018, 1027.)
Martinez held, “Where . . . a plaintiff serves two statutory offers
to compromise, and the defendant fails to obtain a judgment more
favorable than either offer, recoverability of expert fees incurred
from the date of the first offer is consistent with section 998’s
language and best promotes the statutory purpose to encourage
the settlement of lawsuits before trial.” (Martinez, at p. 1027.)
In arriving at this conclusion, Martinez observed that
section 998 “was enacted to encourage the settlement of lawsuits
prior to trial,” and that “[t]he statute accomplishes this purpose
by providing” “ ‘a strong financial disincentive to a party—
whether it be a plaintiff or a defendant—who fails to achieve a
better result than that party could have achieved by accepting his
or her opponent’s settlement offer.’ [Citation.]” (See Martinez,
supra, 56 Cal.4th at pp. 1017, 1019.) The Martinez court further
17
explained that “the potential for statutory recovery of expert
witness fees and other costs provides parties ‘a financial incentive
to make reasonable settlement offers[,]’ [citation]” and that
“[s]ection 998 aims to avoid the time delays and economic waste
associated with trials and to reduce the number of meritless
lawsuits.” (Martinez, at p. 1019.) Our high court also observed
the statute “serves the public policy of compensating the injured
party.” (See id. at p. 1021.) Martinez noted this policy is
“accomplished by allowing a plaintiff who made an early
settlement offer to ‘either propose a new offer in light of . . . newly
discovered evidence or proceed to trial and present all the
evidence in an attempt to be compensated fairly by the trier of
fact’s decision’ [citation] without having to forfeit the statutory
benefits flowing from the early offer.” (See id. at p. 1026, italics
added.)
Although Martinez construed only Code of Civil Procedure
section 998 (see Martinez, supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 1017), we
conclude that this statute and Civil Code section 3291 were both
designed to effectuate the same purposes. Civil Code
section 3291 “expressly incorporates the provisions of Code of
Civil Procedure section 998, adding interest from the date of the
offer as a recoverable item . . . .” (See Glassman, supra,
90 Cal.App.5th at p. 1293.) Thus, the interpretive doctrine of
in pari materia counsels in favor of reading the statutes together.
(See Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, supra,
94 Cal.App.5th at p. 789, fn. 21.) The parties do not contend
otherwise.
Additionally, the Martinez court recognized that Civil Code
section 3291’s legislative history “plainly reflects a legislative
policy choice to encourage early settlement of personal injury
18
actions,” which is Code of Civil Procedure section 998’s objective
as well. (See Martinez, supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 1024, fn. 8; see
also Ray v. Goodman (2006) 142 Cal.App.4th 83, 91 (Ray)
[observing that both statutes are designed to “encourage the
parties to make reasonable settlement offers as early as possible
in personal injury litigation”].) It is also apparent that much like
Code of Civil Procedure section 998, Civil Code section 3291
serves the public policy of compensating the injured party.
Specifically, we agree with Bogdanovich that Civil Code
section 3291 is aimed at “compensating [a p]laintiff for loss of use
of money during the prejudgment period.” (See also Lakin v.
Watkins Associated Industries (1993) 6 Cal.4th 644, 664 [“In
enacting [Civil Code] section 3291, the Legislature provided a
means of compensating personal injury plaintiffs for loss of use of
money during the prejudgment period.”].)
Construing “the defendant” in Code of Civil Procedure
section 998, subdivision (d) and Civil Code section 3291 to include
a decedent-offeree’s personal representative would best effectuate
the statutory purposes our high court identified in Martinez.
Under Calleja’s interpretation of the two statutes, the specter of
section 998 penalties imposed on account of the deceased’s failure
to accept the original offer within the statutory deadline would
incentivize the personal representative to engage in further
settlement discussions with the plaintiff. (See Code Civ. Proc.,
§ 998, subd. (b)(2) [prescribing the deadline for acceptance of a
§ 998 offer]; Martinez, supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 1017 [noting that
§ 998’s penalties apply “when the judgment is not more favorable
than the plaintiff’s settlement offer” to the defendant]; Civ. Code,
§ 3291 [authorizing prejudgment interest if the plaintiff obtains a
judgment more favorable than the settlement offer].)
19
Including the decedent’s personal representative in the
scope of the term “the defendant” would also effectuate the
statutory objective of compensating injured parties. Under
Calleja’s interpretation, a plaintiff could make a reasonable
settlement offer to the decedent during his or her lifetime and, if
the jury returns a verdict after the decedent’s passing that is
more favorable to the plaintiff than the offer, then the plaintiff
would be compensated for the “time delays and economic waste
associated with [a] trial” that could have been avoided if the
decedent had accepted the offer. (See Martinez, supra, 56 Cal.4th
at p. 1019 [noting that § 998 is designed to avoid such delays and
waste].)
Conversely, if the personal representative were not bound
by the decedent-offeree’s failure to accept a section 998 offer, then
there would be no risk to the personal representative of incurring
statutory penalties resulting from that failure. Also, if the
plaintiff were to make a second section 998 offer, then the
personal representative could accept the second offer with no
liability to the plaintiff for any expert witness fees or
prejudgment interest incurred after the first offer. The plaintiff’s
financial interests would thus be jeopardized by a possibility
completely beyond that party’s control, to wit, the original
defendant’s death before trial. Because we must avoid an
“ ‘interpretation [of the statute] that would lead to [such an]
absurd consequence’ ” (see Lofchie, supra, 229 Cal.App.4th at
p. 251), we reject Bogdanovich’s interpretation. Indeed, if, as the
Martinez court held, “parties should not be penalized for making
more than one reasonable settlement offer” under section 998
(see Martinez, supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 1026), we see no reason
20
why a plaintiff who made a reasonable unaccepted settlement
offer should be penalized for the death of the original defendant.
Bogdanovich argues that holding her liable for Chavez’s
failure to accept Calleja’s section 998 offer would be unfair
because Bogdanovich “did not have any involvement in and
therefore no control over the litigation process . . . until after . . .
Chavez died,” and “[t]he dynamics of trial drastically change
when one of the parties to the lawsuit dies and cannot appear or
testify at trial.” Bogdanovich further claims Estate of Watts
(1984) 162 Cal.App.3d 1160 (Watts) supports her position that
“she should not be penalized for the decedent defendant allowing
the offer to be withdrawn” “by operation of law pursuant to
section 998[, subdivision ](b)(2).” Additionally, Bogdanovich’s
counsel suggested at oral argument that the Court of Appeal’s
decision in Ray demonstrates that Calleja could not recover
section 998 penalties because she did not serve a statutory offer
to compromise on Bogdanovich. These arguments do not
undermine our interpretation of “the defendant” in Code of Civil
Procedure section 998, subdivision (d) and Civil Code
section 3291.
First, Bogdanovich seems to argue that because she was
unable to control the litigation until after Chavez’s death, “the
statutory purpose of encouraging settlements is not promoted by
awarding section 998 [penalties] against” her. We disagree.
Section 377.41 provides in pertinent part: “On motion, the
court shall allow a pending action or proceeding against the
decedent that does not abate to be continued against the
decedent’s personal representative . . . .” (§ 377.41.) Bogdanovich
concedes this statute codifies prior case law holding that a
“personal representative was bound by the trial court’s findings”
21
rendered at trial against the decedent-defendant before he or she
had passed. Our interpretation of Code of Civil Procedure
section 998 and Civil Code section 3291 is consistent with the
legislative determination that in at least some cases, the personal
representative should bear the consequences of prior decisions
the decedent had made during the litigation.
We find unpersuasive Bogdanovich’s argument that
Calleja’s interpretation of Code of Civil Procedure section 998 and
Civil Code section 3291 is unfair because Chavez’s death
hindered Bogdanovich’s defense at trial. Any number of events
can occur after expiration of a section 998 offer that may impede
a party’s defense. For instance, a key witness may die or
otherwise become unavailable on the eve of trial.
Notwithstanding the possibility of such contingencies, a court
assesses the reasonableness of a section 998 offer by reviewing
“ ‘the information available to the parties as of the date the offer
was served’ ” and not at some later point in time. (See Whatley-
Miller v. Cooper (2013) 212 Cal.App.4th 1103, 1112, italics
added.) Given that Code of Civil Procedure section 998 and
Civil Code section 3291 require offeree-defendants to bear such
postoffer risks, we see no reason why these statutes would treat
the subsequent death of the offeree-defendant any differently.
Also, allowing a personal representative to invoke prejudice as a
basis for avoiding liability for statutory penalties would
improperly “inject[ ] uncertainty into the section 998 process.”
(See Martinez, supra, 56 Cal.4th at p. 1021; ibid. [holding that a
court should reject a proposed interpretation of section 998 if it
“would encourage gamesmanship or spawn disputes over the
operation of section 998,” and observing that “courts have
22
adopted bright-line rules [in this context] in order to avoid
confusion”].)
Furthermore, our interpretation would not unfairly
prejudice Bogdanovich’s personal interests. Under Code of Civil
Procedure section 998 and Civil Code section 3291, postoffer
expert witness fees and prejudgment interest constitute
“recoverable costs . . . .” (See Glassman, supra, 90 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 1293–1294, 1313–1314.) Although Code of Civil Procedure
section 1026 provides that costs are recoverable “in an action . . .
defended by a personal representative,” those costs are
“chargeable only upon the estate . . . represented, unless the
court directs the costs to be paid by the fiduciary personally for
mismanagement or bad faith in the action or defense.”20 (See
§ 1026, subds. (a)–(b).)
Next, Watts did not consider the scope of the term “the
defendant” in Code of Civil Procedure section 998, subdivision (d)
or Civil Code section 3291, but instead employed “general
contract law principles” to determine whether a defendant’s
settlement offer had been “ ‘accepted’ ” for the purpose of
section 998. (See Watts, supra, 162 Cal.App.3d at p. 1162 &
20 We acknowledge that the financial interests of a
personal representative could be affected by our interpretation of
Code of Civil Procedure section 998 and Civil Code section 3291 if
that individual were also a beneficiary of the decedent’s estate.
An award of statutory penalties against the estate could arguably
reduce the amount of funds available for distribution to the
personal representative. That concern is not implicated here.
Neither Bogdanovich nor Udewitz has claimed to be a beneficiary
of Chavez’s estate. Additionally, the trial court observed, and
Bogdanovich does not dispute, “[t]here is no evidence that . . .
Chavez had or that his estate has any assets.”
23
fn. 1.) There, the plaintiff sued the defendant for “personal
injuries arising out of a slip and fall accident on [the defendant’s]
property.” (Id. at p. 1162.) Two events occurred within 30 days
of the defendant’s having served upon the plaintiff the section
998 offer to compromise the action for $25,000—(1) the plaintiff
“died of apparently unrelated causes,” and (2) the administrators
of the plaintiff’s estate “purported” to accept the defendant’s offer.
(See Watts, at pp. 1162–1163, 1165.) The administrators
thereafter successfully moved for judgment in the amount of
$25,000 pursuant to the section 998 offer. (Watts, at p. 1163.)
On appeal, the Watts court held, “[I]n the context of a
personal injury action, a statutory offer of compromise by a
defendant pursuant to section 998 is terminated by the death of
the plaintiff offeree prior to its acceptance . . . .” (See Watts,
supra, 162 Cal.App.3d at p. 1162.) Watts explained that “general
contract law principles govern the process of offer and acceptance
under section 998 unless such principles conflict with the statute
or defeat the statutory purpose of encouraging pretrial
settlement.” (See Watts, at p. 1163.) Applying the “well-
established principle of contract law that death of an offeree
terminates a revocable offer,” the Court of Appeal found that “the
purported acceptance of [the defendant’s] statutory offer by the
administrators of [the plaintiff’s] estate [within the 30-day
statutory period for the plaintiff to consider the offer] had no
legal effect.” (See id. at pp. 1162–1163 & fn. 1.)
We agree with Bogdanovich’s statement in her opening
brief that “after [a section 998 offer] is withdrawn by operation of
law” and the plaintiff secures a “verdict [that] exceeds [the
p]laintiff’s offer[,] . . . ‘statutory penalties’ come into play, not
contract law.” (See § 998, subd. (d) [authorizing “postoffer costs
24
of the services of expert witnesses” “[i]f an offer made by a
plaintiff is not accepted and the defendant fails to obtain a more
favorable judgment”]; Civ. Code, § 3291 [authorizing prejudgment
interest if “the plaintiff obtains a more favorable judgment”].)
Accordingly, Watts’s discussion of common law contract principles
on acceptance of a pending offer is not instructive on the meaning
of the statutory text at issue here.
Lastly, Ray is of no assistance to Bogdanovich. There, a
plaintiff sued two defendants for injuries the plaintiff sustained
when he fell on a stairway attached to property owned by the
defendants. (Ray, supra, 142 Cal.App.4th at pp. 85–86.) Before
trial, the plaintiff served the two defendants with a statutory
offer to settle the case for $400,000 from each defendant; the
defendants allowed this offer to lapse. (Id. at p. 86.) After one of
the two defendants died, the plaintiff substituted the estate of
that defendant for the deceased individual, and thereafter served
upon the newly-added estate and the other defendant a statutory
offer to settle for a total amount of $400,000.21 (Ray, at p. 86.)
Neither defendant accepted this second offer, and the plaintiff
later secured a verdict awarding him $919,102. (Ibid.) The trial
court subsequently awarded the plaintiff prejudgment interest
pursuant to Civil Code section 3291 accruing from the date of the
plaintiff’s second offer, rather than from his first offer. (See id. at
p. 85.)
21 Although Bogdanovich asserts in her reply brief that the
deceased defendant’s “personal representative was substituted in
the case for the decedent,” the Ray court stated that the plaintiff
“substitut[ed] the [e]state of [the deceased] as a defendant in lieu
of” that individual.” (See Ray, supra, 142 Cal.App.4th at p. 86.)
This discrepancy has no impact on our analysis.
25
The Court of Appeal reversed the trial court’s decision and
held that the plaintiff was entitled to prejudgment interest
accruing from the date of the plaintiff’s first offer. (See Ray,
supra, 142 Cal.App.4th at pp. 85, 92.) The Ray court reasoned,
“The question of the date from which . . . interest should be
computed when a personal injury plaintiff makes multiple
section 998 offers is answered by reference to the clear language
of [Civil Code] section 3291: from ‘plaintiff’s first offer pursuant
to Section 998 of the Code of Civil Procedure.’ [Citation.]” (Ray,
at p. 91.) The Court of Appeal further explained that the
statutory policy of “encouragement of the settlement of litigation”
supported this interpretation of Civil Code section 3291 because,
“[i]f prejudgment interest on behalf of a successful personal
injury plaintiff were to run only from that party’s last section 998
offer, it would necessarily discourage that party from making
successive, and lower, section 998 offers, thus significantly
reducing the chances of pretrial settlement.” (See Ray, at pp. 91–
92.)
As Bogdanovich acknowledges in the reply brief, “[N]o
argument in Ray was ever made that the offers [the plaintiff
had made] were to two different parties.” (See Ray, supra,
142 Cal.App.4th at pp. 87–92 [instead addressing other issues].)
Therefore, the Ray decision does not establish that to obtain
section 998 penalties from Bogdanovich, Calleja had to serve
Bogdanovich with a second statutory offer. (See’s Candies, Inc. v.
Superior Court (2021) 73 Cal.App.5th 66, 92 [“ ‘ “[C]ases are not
authority for propositions that are not considered.” ’ ”].)
In sum, we hold that a personal representative of a
defendant-decedent is bound by the decedent’s failure to accept a
plaintiff’s section 998 offer within the statutory deadline for
26
doing so. We thus do not reach Bogdanovich’s argument that the
trial court erred in concluding the estate should be liable for the
statutory penalties because Chavez’s insurance carrier
purportedly controlled the defense throughout the proceedings.
(Estate of Sapp (2019) 36 Cal.App.5th 86, 104 [“ ‘If the decision of
a lower court is correct on any theory of law applicable to the
case, the judgment or order will be affirmed regardless of the
correctness of the grounds upon which the lower court reached its
conclusion.’ ”].)
C. Bogdanovich Forfeited Her Argument That Calleja
Failed To Substitute Bogdanovich for Chavez Under
Probate Code Section 9370
Probate Code section 9370 provides:
“(a) An action or proceeding pending against the decedent
at the time of death may not be continued against the decedent’s
personal representative unless all of the following conditions are
satisfied: [¶] (1) A claim is first filed as provided in this part. [¶]
(2) The claim is rejected in whole or in part. [¶] (3) Within three
months after the notice of rejection is given, the plaintiff applies
to the court in which the action or proceeding is pending for an
order to substitute the personal representative in the action or
proceeding. This paragraph applies only if the notice of rejection
contains a statement that the plaintiff has three months within
which to apply for an order for substitution. [¶] (b) No recovery
shall be allowed in the action against property in the decedent’s
estate unless proof is made of compliance with this section.”
(Prob. Code, § 9370.)
In her opening brief, Bogdanovich argues, “Nowhere in the
record does it show that [Calleja] complied with . . . Probate Code
27
[section 9370] to properly substitute [Bogdanovich].”22
Bogdanovich asserts Calleja “never brought a motion as required
by the Probate Code and never received an order from the trial
court allowing [Bogdanovich] to be substituted in place and
instead of . . . Chavez.” Bogdanovich argues that in lieu of a
motion under Probate Code section 9370, Calleja “filed a Doe
Amendment amending the Complaint to add a different
defendant by substituting [Bogdanovich for] Defendant Doe 3.”
According to Bogdanovich, because Calleja failed to comply with
Probate Code section 9370, “the section 998 penalties should not
be imposed against” Bogdanovich. (Boldface & capitalization
omitted.)
Calleja contends Bogdanovich forfeited her argument that
Probate Code section 9370 precludes an award of section 998
penalties against Bogdanovich because Bogdanovich never made
that argument below.
In her reply, Bogdanovich does not claim to have argued
below that Probate Code section 9370 precludes the award of
statutory penalties. Instead, Bogdanovich maintains,
“[Bogdanovich] asserted below that section 998 penalties
should not be awarded against [her] as . . . Chavez’s personal
representative because she is a different party, she was not
served with the statutory offer, Defendant Chavez was dismissed
from the case by way of a Request for Dismissal, [Bogdanovich]
was not ‘added’ as a new party until more than 3 years after the
offer to . . . Chavez, and the judgment was against [Bogdanovich],
22 Although Bogdanovich cited Probate Code section 9700
in her opening brief, Bogdanovich acknowledges in her reply she
had “[i]nadvertently referenced” that provision and intended to
refer us to section 9370 of the Probate Code.
28
not . . . Chavez.” Bogdanovich also appears to contend she could
not have forfeited reliance on Probate Code section 9370 because
“the issue is probably one of jurisdiction.” (Italics added.)
“ ‘Ordinarily the failure to preserve a point below
constitutes a [forfeiture] of the point. [Citation.]’ ” (Meridian
Financial Services, Inc. v. Phan (2021) 67 Cal.App.5th 657, 698
(Meridian Financial Services, Inc.).) To preserve an argument for
appeal, an appellant must provide the trial court and the
opposing party with “sufficient notice of the issue” to afford them
an opportunity to address it. (See Simplon Ballpark, LLC v.
Scull (2015) 235 Cal.App.4th 660, 668–670; see also Meridian
Financial Services, Inc., at p. 698 [“ ‘ “ ‘In the hurry of the trial
many things may be, and are, overlooked which could readily
have been rectified had attention been called to them. The law
casts upon the party the duty of looking after his legal rights and
of calling the judge’s attention to any infringement of
them.’ ” ’ ”].)
By failing to dispute Calleja’s assertion in her appellate
briefing that Bogdanovich failed to raise below noncompliance
with Probate Code section 9370, Bogdanovich tacitly concedes she
in fact did not raise that issue in the trial court. (See Association
for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, supra, 94 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 773–774 [holding that the appellants “tacitly concede[d]” a
point raised in the respondent’s brief by “failing to dispute it in
their reply”].) Even assuming arguendo Bogdanovich correctly
identifies in her reply brief the contentions she raised in support
of her motion to tax costs, her vague allusions to improper
substitution fell short of affording the trial court and Calleja with
sufficient notice that her argument was premised on Probate
Code section 9370.
29
We acknowledge, “[T]he parties to a case cannot confer
fundamental jurisdiction upon a court by waiver, estoppel,
consent, or forfeiture,” and “[d]efects in fundamental jurisdiction
therefore ‘may be raised at any point in a proceeding, including
for the first time on appeal[.]’ ” (See Quigley v. Garden Valley
Fire Protection Dist. (2019) 7 Cal.5th 798, 807 (Quigley).) There
exists, however, a “presumption that statutes do not limit the
courts’ fundamental jurisdiction absent a clear indication of
legislative intent to do so.” (See id. at p. 808.)
Bogdanovich does not direct us to any evidence the
Legislature intended Probate Code section 9370 to limit trial
courts’ fundamental jurisdiction to hear cases. Also, California
appellate courts do not “blindly” apply provisions barring the
entry of judgment “against a personal representative of a
decedent’s estate[ ] until the representative has been made a
party by substitution,” but instead require a showing of
“prejudice to the parties because of lack of notice, lack of proper
representation, or some other disadvantage.” (See Sacks v. FSR
Brokerage, Inc. (1992) 7 Cal.App.4th 950, 956–960 & fn. 4
[collecting cases and citing, inter alia, Prob. Code, § 9370].) That
guidance strongly suggests Probate Code section 9370 does not
restrict courts’ fundamental jurisdiction. At least one leading
secondary source has opined that the statutory restrictions on
claims against the estate imposed by part 4 of division 7 of the
Probate Code, e.g., Probate Code section 9370, are “not
jurisdictional.” (See Haning, et al., Cal. Prac. Guide: Personal
Injury (The Rutter Group 2023) ¶¶ 5:74–5:75, citing, inter alia,
Prob. Code, § 9002, subd. (b) [providing that the statutes codified
“in this part” restrict a plaintiff’s right to assert claims against a
30
personal representative]; see also fn. 19, ante [observing that
Prob. Code, § 9370 is in part 4 of div. 7 of the Prob. Code].)
We thus conclude that Bogdanovich has not rebutted the
interpretive presumption the Supreme Court recognized in
Quigley—that the Legislature did not intend Probate Code
section 9370 to deprive the trial court of fundamental
jurisdiction. (See Quigley, supra, 7 Cal.5th at p. 808.) In sum,
we conclude that Bogdanovich forfeited this claim of error by
failing to raise it below.
D. Calleja Did Not Waive Her Right to Seek Section 998
Penalties from Bogdanovich
On July 22, 2021, Calleja filed a request for dismissal of
five defendants without prejudice: “Jose Chavez; Jeffrey Wong;
Dan Kerr Trucking Inc.; Cougar Service Inc[.]; and Active
Logistics Solutions Inc.” (Some capitalization omitted.) Directly
adjacent to the list of defendants in the request is the following
text: “Each Party to bear their own costs and fees.” The trial
court clerk entered the requested dismissal on July 29, 2021.23
Bogdanovich contends Calleja “waived her rights to
section 998 penalties” against Bogdanovich by filing the request
for dismissal of Chavez with the aforesaid notation, “Each Party
to bear their own costs and fees.” As a preliminary matter, we
observe that Bogdanovich does not identify explicitly the
standard of review applicable to her claim of waiver. For the
reasons set forth below, we reject Bogdanovich’s waiver claim
even under the de novo standard of review.
23 Calleja and Bogdanovich are the only parties to this
appeal.
31
“Waiver means ‘the intentional relinquishment or
abandonment of a known right.’ [Citations.] And whether there
has been waiver is a question of fact. [Citation.] Waiver
‘ “always rests upon intent.” ’ [Citation.] The intention may be
express, based on the waiving party’s words, or implied, based on
conduct that is ‘ “so inconsistent with an intent to enforce the
right as to induce a reasonable belief that such right has been
relinquished.” ’ [Citations.]” (California-American Water Co. v.
Marina Coast Water Dist. (2022) 86 Cal.App.5th 1272, 1292.)
“ ‘ “The burden . . . is on the party claiming a waiver of a right to
prove it by clear and convincing evidence that does not leave the
matter to speculation, and ‘doubtful cases will be decided against
a waiver’ [citation].” ’ [Citation.] ‘Whether a waiver has occurred
depends solely on the intention of the waiving party.’ [Citation.]”
(In re Marriage of Turkanis & Price (2013) 213 Cal.App.4th 332,
352.)
Assuming arguendo Bogdanovich’s claim of waiver is
subject to our independent review, that claim fails because
Bogdanovich has not discharged her burden of establishing
waiver by clear and convincing evidence. By the time Calleja
requested Chavez’s dismissal in July 2021, Chavez was deceased
and Calleja had already joined Bogdanovich to the action in
Bogdanovich’s capacity as the administrator of Chavez’s estate.
We infer from these facts that Calleja requested the dismissal of
Chavez simply because Bogdanovich’s joinder had rendered
Chavez’s being a party defendant unnecessary. (See § 377.41
[providing in relevant part that “a pending action or proceeding
against the decedent that does not abate [may] be continued
against the decedent’s personal representative”].)
32
Calleja correctly notes that if she instead filed this request
for dismissal for the purpose of relinquishing or abandoning any
of her rights against Chavez’s estate, then this document “would
have served to terminate the case in its entirety” by dismissing
her claim for damages against the estate, “and there would have
been no need for trial.” Clearly common sense informs us that
this was not Calleja’s intention. We thus conclude that, by
stating in the request for dismissal that each party would bear
that party’s own costs and fees, Calleja expressed her intention to
waive those rights against only the other four defendants
identified in the dismissal, to wit, Jeffrey Wong; Dan Kerr
Trucking Inc.; Cougar Service Inc.; and Active Logistics Solutions
Inc.
E. Bogdanovich Forfeited Her Challenge to the Trial
Court’s Award of Prejudgment Interest on Future
Damages
Bogdanovich contends that even “if section 998 penalties
are allowed to be imposed on the personal representative of the
decedent,” the trial court nonetheless erred in awarding
prejudgment interest on Calleja’s future damages. (Boldface &
capitalization omitted.) Although she acknowledges that Civil
Code section 3291 “provides for interest on the ‘judgment,’
[Bogdanovich argues] the word ‘judgment’ in the statute is vague
and should be interpreted narrowly.” According to Bogdanovich,
“[p]roviding some 5 years of prejudgment interest” on “future
economic and non-economic damages[,] which by definition are
those damages to be incurred after the date of trial,” would be
“a windfall for” Calleja.
In response to Calleja’s contention that Bogdanovich
forfeited this claim of error by failing to raise it below,
33
Bogdanovich “concedes she did not make this argument at the
trial level.” Bogdanovich nonetheless “contends the issue is one
of law on undisputed facts and thus not forfeited on appeal or
requests this Court to exercise its discretion to address the issue.”
“ ‘[M]erely because an issue is one of law[ ] does not give a
party license to raise it for the first time on appeal . . . . Whether
an appellate court will entertain a belatedly raised legal issue
always rests within the court’s discretion.’ [Citations.]”
(Meridian Financial Services, Inc., supra, 67 Cal.App.5th at
pp. 699–700.) Although Bogdanovich asserts “there is no case
addressing this issue,” Bogdanovich does not respond to the
arguments Calleja raises in support of her position that Civil
Code section 3291 authorizes an “award[ of] prejudgment interest
on future damages.” Because “[w]e do not serve as ‘backup
appellate counsel,’ or make the parties’ arguments for them”
(Inyo Citizens for Better Planning v. Inyo County Bd. of
Supervisors (2009) 180 Cal.App.4th 1, 14), we decline to exercise
our discretion to excuse Bogdanovich’s forfeiture.
DISPOSITION
The December 16, 2021 order granting in part and denying
in part appellant’s motion to tax costs is affirmed. Respondent is
awarded her costs on appeal.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
BENDIX, J.
We concur:
ROTHSCHILD, P. J. WEINGART, J.
34
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.