In re Z.B. CA3

CourtListener 10292379Calctapp12.12.2024

Gesamter Gesetzestext

Filed 12/12/24 In re Z.B. CA3
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
THIRD APPELLATE DISTRICT
(Sacramento)
----

In re Z.B., a Person Coming Under the Juvenile Court C100558
Law.

THE PEOPLE, (Super. Ct. No. JV141572)

Plaintiff and Respondent,

v.

Z.B.,

Defendant and Appellant.

The juvenile court committed 16-year-old Z.B. to Valley Oak Youth Academy
(VOYA), a secure youth treatment facility (Welf. & Inst. Code, § 875, subd. (a)),1 setting

1 Undesignated statutory references are to the Welfare and Institutions Code.

1
a baseline term of confinement of three years and the maximum term of confinement of
16 years, with 315 days of custody credit.
Z.B. now contends the juvenile court abused its discretion in ordering a secure
youth treatment facility commitment. We conclude the juvenile court did not abuse its
discretion in committing Z.B. to VOYA and affirm the judgment.
I. BACKGROUND
In January 2022, the People filed a wardship petition alleging that Z.B. (then 14
years old) slapped L.V. on her buttocks after a high school class, and then later
approached her from behind, choked her until she could not breath, punched her in the
face and chest, and threatened L.V. and her family to keep them from reporting the
incident. The juvenile court placed Z.B. on electronic monitoring. In February 2022,
electronic monitoring was discontinued. In June 2022, Z.B. admitted felony assault and
misdemeanor sexual battery. Z.B. was adjudged a ward of the juvenile court and released
with an order to complete 24 hours of community service and sexual boundaries
counseling.
In November 2022, the People filed another wardship petition charging Z.B (now
15 years old) with felony grand theft after taking property (video game consoles) from
Target and fleeing the store. Z.B. was again released and placed on electronic
monitoring. In January 2023, the People filed a petition alleging Z.B. violated probation
when he stole from Target. Z.B. thereafter admitted misdemeanor grand theft as a
violation of probation. The juvenile court continued Z.B. as a ward of the juvenile court,
discontinued electronic monitoring, and released Z.B. to the custody of his mother.
In February 2023, the People filed a petition alleging three probation violations by
Z.B.: he failed to reside in Sacramento County and moved out of their jurisdiction
without probation’s permission, violated conditions of electronic monitoring, and failed
to complete sexual boundaries counseling. Z.B. was released to his mother’s care and

2
placed on electronic monitoring. Z.B. failed to appear for a March 2023 settlement
conference and a bench warrant was issued for his arrest.
In early April 2023, the People filed a wardship petition charging Z.B. with felony
vandalism for throwing a rock and damaging a car and resisting arrest, and a parallel
violation of probation petition. At the prosecution’s request, the wardship petition was
dismissed and the case proceeded on the February 2023 and April 2023 probation
violation petitions.
On April 12, 2023, the People filed a fourth wardship petition alleging four felony
counts and gun use enhancement allegations (Pen. Code, § 12022, subd. (a)(1)) arising
from a February 2023 home invasion robbery. Z.B. entered the backyard of the victims’
residence armed with a handgun and encountered one victim, whom he ordered into the
residence. Inside the residence, Z.B. encountered the victim’s daughter. Z.B. ordered the
victim and his daughter to sit on the bed. Z.B. ordered the daughter to hand over money
she was holding and then slapped her and threatened to shoot her when she refused. The
daughter gave Z.B. the money, and he left, taking a video game, a cell phone and other
items, as well as smashing another cell phone. The juvenile court ordered Z.B. detained
at juvenile hall.
In an amended wardship petition filed on April 17, 2023, the People added four
counts of child molestation arising from a December 2022 incident. Z.B. and the 11-
year-old victim were at a family member’s home when Z.B. put his hands in the victim’s
pants then pulled her pants down and inserted his penis in her vagina. The victim
attempted to push Z.B away but he brushed her hand off and continued. Z.B. also
penetrated the victim’s vagina with his fingers. Z.B. stopped when an adult entered the
room, but later in the day he forced the victim’s hand down his pants, made her touch his
penis, and forced her to orally copulate him. The same day Z.B. and the victim were
lying on a couch watching television in a different location. Z.B. pulled the victim’s
pants down and inserted his penis into her vagina, causing her pain and vaginal bleeding.

3
The juvenile court dismissed the April 12 petition, filed the April 17 petition, and ordered
Z.B. to remain detained at juvenile hall.
In June 2023, defense counsel asked that Z.B. be released on electronic
monitoring. The prosecutor opposed the request, pointing out that most of Z.B.’s
offenses had occurred while he was on electronic monitoring and confirming with the
probation department that Z.B. had collected 14 disciplinary reports in juvenile hall since
his last court date. The juvenile court denied Z.B.’s request. The court also denied Z.B.’s
counsel’s subsequent requests for release on electronic monitoring.
On August 31, 2023, the People filed a second amended wardship petition which
amended the gun use enhancement allegation in count two (Pen. Code, § 12022, subd.
(a)(1)) to allege personal use of a firearm (Pen. Code, § 12022.53, subd. (b)). The
juvenile court dismissed the April 17 amended petition as superseded.
At a hearing in September 2023, counsel for Z.B. argued for his release on
electronic monitoring because Z.B. had shown substantial improvement in juvenile hall,
to which the prosecutor responded that, since Z.B. has been at juvenile hall, “he has
consistently had behavior issues.” The juvenile court denied the request. The court
ordered a psychological evaluation under Penal Code section 288.1—required as a
condition of probation for a defendant convicted of a lewd and lascivious act on a child
under 14—and set the matter for trial.
On December 4, 2023, Z.B. admitted the charge of felony residential robbery in
concert (Pen. Code, § 212.5/213—count two) in the second amended wardship petition,
as well as the firearm enhancement (Pen. Code, § 12022.53, subd. (b)). The remaining
counts were “dismissed in the interest of justice in light of the plea with consideration.”2
The trial court set a contested disposition hearing.

2 “[T]he statutory scheme contemplates consideration of all available reliable, social and
behavioral evidence bearing upon the minor’s fitness in reaching the placement

4
Z.B.’s counsel filed a disposition memorandum. Counsel argued that prior to the
charged conduct Z.B. and his mother lacked a stable residence. Counsel noted that the
current offense was only Z.B.’s second incident of criminal behavior before the juvenile
court and claimed that Z.B. had a minimal number of conflict incidents while detained at
juvenile hall. Counsel contended that VOYA commitment, if recommended by the
probation department, would mean the juvenile court could not consider a less restrictive,
alternative disposition, which the defense proposed in the form of continued probation.
Moreover, defense counsel asserted, because a less restrictive, alternative disposition to
commitment had never been attempted, under section 875, subdivision (a)(3), the juvenile
court must not commit Z.B. to a secured youth treatment facility.
In a report submitted a week before the hearing, the probation department
recommended commitment to VOYA. The report summarized Z.B.’s offenses and noted
that at juvenile hall Z.B. had collected 31 incident reports since his detention on April 4,
2023. The report further noted that according to the psychological evaluation of Z.B.
conducted by two psychologists, Z.B. was at moderate to high risk to other children for
general and sexual offenses. The evaluation concluded that, while Z.B. did not need a
residential sex offender treatment program, he did need a formal sex offender treatment
program, with 24-hour supervision while Z.B. is in the community, due to his history of
absconding and noncompliance with previous sexual offender treatment.
Based on an interview of Z.B., the probation department assessed him as high risk
to reoffend. Z.B. reported that his adjustment to probation was good until he started to
experience housing issues in June 2022. Z.B. would stay in different hotels for a few

decision,” and “a minor can have no reasonable expectation the conduct underlying
dismissed allegations will not be looked to as a factor in deciding the appropriate
placement.” (In re Jimmy P. (1996) 50 Cal.App.4th 1679, 1681; see also In re T.C.
(2009) 173 Cal.App.4th 837, 842 [waiver under People v. Harvey (1979) 25 Cal.3d 754
“not required when using dismissed allegations in determining an appropriate juvenile
disposition”].)

5
days with his mother or relatives, but family members did not want the probation
department at their homes. His mother would sometimes stay with him but also be absent
for days at a time. Z.B. attributed his positive drug tests to being around family who use
marijuana. Z.B. reported that he does not like counseling and does not believe he needs
it, but he will do what is necessary to get off probation. Regarding school, Z.B. did not
attend school from November 2022 to April 2023 due to absconding. Prior to
absconding, he was expelled from school for sexual battery and assault, and he was also
suspended for fighting and recording fights. Z.B. stated that his accomplice in the
robbery was a friend from school, but Z.B. denied entering the victim’s home.
Finally, the probation department described the intake assessment process and
treatment programs available at VOYA that would benefit Z.B., including behavior
treatment interventions, cognitive behavioral interventions for substance abuse, mental
health treatment, sexual behavior treatment, post-secondary education opportunities,
vocational programs, and reentry.
At the contested disposition hearing, Z.B.’s counsel argued the probation report
was slanted, and, along the lines of her brief, that a less restrictive alternative to
commitment to a secure youth treatment facility was appropriate, adding that Z.B. had
engaged in many rehabilitative programs at juvenile hall. The People disagreed,
contending that VOYA commitment was appropriate given, among other things, Z.B.’s
offenses and his behavior at juvenile hall. The People also argued that a VOYA
commitment would best meet Z.B.’s needs, as well the goals of rehabilitation and
community safety.
The trial court agreed with the People and committed Z.B. to VOYA. Addressing
Z.B., the court concluded: “[I]n considering all of the factors that the law requires, the
severity of the offenses, the previous delinquent history, whether the programming in
VOYA, which is different, and which I think can be tailored to the needs that you have,
and to where you’re at in terms of moving through this programming. I think that

6
[defense counsel] makes very compelling arguments, and the law does require that I
consider whether there are less restrictive alternatives, but I think our experience in the
community, even now with some of the additional programs that may be available, I
don’t think that in light of everything that I have a duty to consider [a less restrictive
alternative] would be appropriate. [¶] So the Court will adopt the findings and
recommendations of the Probation Department.”
The findings of the probation department included that Z.B.’s parent is not capable
of or neglected to provide maintenance and training of Z.B., probation and custody of his
parent has been tried and Z.B. failed to reform, and the juvenile court has considered all
relevant and material evidence including the recommendations of the probation
department, counsel, and individuals designated to advise the court. The probation
department’s findings also stated that the juvenile court has considered all the disposition
criteria set forth in section 875, subdivision (a)(3)(A)-(E), including “[w]hether the goals
of rehabilitation and community safety can be met by assigning the ward to an
alternative, less restrictive disposition that is available to the court.”
The juvenile court set Z.B.’s baseline term of confinement (§ 875, subd. (b)) at
three years and the maximum term of confinement (§ 875, subd. (c)) at 16 years, with
315 days custody credit.
Z.B. filed a timely appeal.
II. DISCUSSION
Z.B. asserts the juvenile court abused its discretion in ordering a VOYA
commitment, because his offense, while serious, occurred during a five-month period of
family and housing instability, and his behavior improved dramatically in the structured
environment of juvenile hall. Z.B. further claims there was insufficient evidence to
support a VOYA commitment as appropriate to Z.B.’s needs, and the goals of
rehabilitation and community safety could have been achieved in a less restrictive

7
placement. We conclude the juvenile court did not abuse its discretion, as its
determination was supported by substantial evidence.
“ ‘ “We review a juvenile court’s commitment decision for abuse of discretion,
indulging all reasonable inferences to support its decision.” [Citation.] “ ‘[D]iscretion is
abused whenever the court exceeds the bounds of all reason, all of the circumstances
being considered.’ ” [Citation.] We will not disturb the juvenile court’s findings when
there is substantial evidence to support them. [Citation.] “ ‘In determining whether there
was substantial evidence to support the commitment, we must examine the record
presented at the disposition hearing in light of the purposes of the Juvenile Court
Law.’ ” ’ [Citation.] ‘A trial court abuses its discretion when the factual findings critical
to its decision find no support in the evidence.’ ” (In re Khalid B. (2015)
233 Cal.App.4th 1285, 1288.) “The purpose of the juvenile court is to protect both the
minor under its jurisdiction and the public, and to preserve and strengthen the minor’s
family ties whenever possible. [Citations.] Central to the juvenile court’s mission are the
care, treatment, guidance, and rehabilitation of the delinquent juvenile.” (In re Walter P.
(2009) 170 Ca.App.4th 95, 99; see § 202, subds. (a) & (b).)
A juvenile court may order that a minor be committed to a secure youth treatment
facility for a period of confinement if, among other things, the “court has made a finding
on the record that a less restrictive, alternative disposition for the ward is unsuitable.”
(§ 875, subd. (a)(3).) In making such a commitment determination, the juvenile court
must consider: “(A) The severity of the offense or offenses for which the ward has been
most recently adjudicated, including the ward’s role in the offense, the ward’s behavior,
and harm done to victims. [¶] (B) The ward’s previous delinquent history, including the
adequacy and success of previous attempts by the juvenile court to rehabilitate the ward.
[¶] (C) Whether the programming, treatment, and education offered and provided in a
secure youth treatment facility is appropriate to meet the treatment and security needs of
the ward. [¶] (D) Whether the goals of rehabilitation and community safety can be met

8
by assigning the ward to an alternative, less restrictive disposition that is available to the
court. [¶] (E) The ward’s age, developmental maturity, mental and emotional health,
sexual orientation, gender identity and expression, and any disabilities or special needs
affecting the safety or suitability of committing the ward to a term of confinement in a
secure youth treatment facility.” (§ 875, subd. (a)(3)(A)-(E).)
Consistent with the statute, the juvenile court considered the first factor, the
severity of the current offense. (§ 875, subd. (a)(3)(A).) Z.B. acknowledges that his
offense of first degree robbery was indeed severe. As summarized in the probation
report, the victim saw Z.B. walk up to the house and heard him climb the backyard fence.
The victim went out to check the backyard and saw Z.B pointing a handgun at him. Z.B.
ordered the victim inside the house. The victim’s daughter was inside. The victim
reported that Z.B. pointed a firearm at his daughter’s head, demanded money, hit her on
the side of the face, and told her she had five seconds to give him her money. According
to the victim’s daughter, Z.B. ordered the victim and his daughter to sit on the bed in her
bedroom and not move. When she refused, Z.B. slapped her in the face and threatened to
shoot her in five seconds if she did not listen. The daughter gave Z.B. $2,000 in cash.
Z.B. continued to aim the gun at the victims while he stole the daughter’s video game
console, a True Religion belt, and other items that Z.B. placed in a backpack. Z.B. also
stole the victim’s cell phone, destroyed his daughter’s cell phone, and fled the home.
Z.B. committed the robbery while wearing electronic monitoring equipment. The
victim’s daughter’s mother reported Z.B.’s actions were “brazen,” having occurred in the
middle of the day. She further reported that her daughter “has suffered the most and feels
vulnerable and exposed” and may seek counseling in the future.
The juvenile court also considered Z.B.’s previous delinquent history. (§ 875,
subd. (a)(3)(B).) This history included the December 2022 incident where Z.B. inserted
his penis in the vagina of an 11-year-old, learning-disabled girl and later made her orally
copulate him. As described in the probation report, other children were in the room at the

9
time of the oral copulation, and Z.B. was holding his infant sister. According to the
victim’s mother, although the victim is in the fifth grade, she is at the second-grade level
intellectually speaking. Z.B. was on an ankle monitor at the time of the offenses. Z.B.’s
history also includes numerous probation violations while Z.B. was on electronic
monitoring, such as an incident in April 2023 where Z.B. was in a group of juveniles
assaulting an elderly person, and he threw a rock breaking the car window of someone
who photographed the assault.
As to attempts to rehabilitate Z.B., the probation department reported that the
juvenile court ordered Z.B. to complete sexual boundaries training, which he did not do,
and stated that he does not like counseling, does not believe he needs it, and participates
only to satisfy the juvenile court. In addition, Z.B.’s adjustment to probation was
generally extremely poor given his recidivism and failure to complete community
service. Z.B. also submitted two drug tests that were positive for marijuana. His mother
reported that Z.B.’s behavior at home “is horrible”—he becomes physically aggressive
and leaves home without her knowledge and against her wishes. Attempts to hold Z.B.
accountable with intermediate sanctions were unsuccessful as he repeatedly violated
electronic monitoring.
Z.B., however, characterizes his delinquent behavior as an aberration and
escalation that occurred in the context of family and housing instability from December
2022 to April 2023. Z.B. argues his behavior improved substantially when he was
incarcerated in the “stable, therapeutic environment” of juvenile hall. The record does
not support this argument. The probation department reported that as of October 10,
2023, Z.B. had approximately 31 incident reports at juvenile hall for staff disrespect and
behavior “uncharacteristic of an Honor level.”3 Z.B.’s negative behaviors included “staff

3 Z.B.’s counsel emphasized at the hearing that he was at the “Honor” level in juvenile
hall since July 9, 2023. As a court officer explained to the juvenile court, Z.B. “failed to

10
disrespect, creating an unsafe environment, threatening staff, disruptive school behavior,
peer agitation, excessive point loss, horseplaying, constant disruption, failure to follow
instructions, non-compliant behavior, distributing an inappropriate image, and school
suspension,” with the “most egregious behaviors” also involving “destruction of school
property, inappropriate comments to peers, yelling, arguing with staff, touching other
residents, and aggressive and agitated behavior towards staff.” Contrary to Z.B.’s claim,
his conduct in juvenile hall appears consistent with his delinquent behavior when
released.
The juvenile court also considered whether the VOYA programming, different
from what Z.B. was receiving in juvenile hall, could be “tailored” to his needs, as well as
his stage in programming participation. (§ 875, subd. (a)(3)(C).) The probation report
contained pages-long discussions of the VOYA secure youth treatment facility. These
discussions included an overview and a discussion of the ward’s probable benefit,
including subsections addressing mental health treatment programs, sexual behavior
treatment program, academics, vocational matters, and reentry.
The juvenile court acknowledged that “the law does require that I consider
whether there are less restrictive alternatives,” but observed that “experience” with Z.B.’s
conduct in the community, even with available programs, indicated a less restrictive
alternative would not be appropriate. (§ 875, subd. (a)(3)(D).) As mentioned, the
probation report stated Z.B. had not completed sexual boundaries counseling and showed
little indication that he would in the future. According to two psychologists, Z.B. was not
in need of a residential sex offender treatment program, but he did need a treatment
program and must be supervised 24 hours a day while in the community due to his
history of absconding and noncompliance with sex offender treatment. The juvenile

earn points on almost a daily basis” at juvenile hall, but this would not cause him to lose
honor status, which would require greater misconduct, such as a fight.

11
court and probation department plainly were not able to supervise Z.B., let alone for 24
hours a day. Indeed, Z.B. committed multiple additional offenses since becoming a ward
of the juvenile court, two while he was on electronic monitoring. Z.B.’s mother proposed
that he be returned to her custody with electronic monitoring and that she would
supervise him since he would reside with her. However, Z.B.’s mother and relatives with
whom Z.B. had been staying were not able to supervise him and electronic monitoring
had little to no effect on his delinquent behavior. Substantial evidence supported the
juvenile court’s determination that a less restrictive alternative than VOYA would not be
appropriate.
Lastly, with regard to addressing Z.B.’s “age, developmental maturity, [and]
mental and emotional health . . . affecting the safety or suitability of committing the ward
to a term of confinement in a secure youth treatment facility” (§ 875, subd. (a)(3)(E)), the
probation report indicated Z.B. had reached the point in his developmental maturity
where a term of commitment in VOYA was the most suitable solution. As the probation
report stated, Z.B.’s “prior and current delinquent behavior demonstrates criminal
sophistication.” Z.B. attempted to persuade the 11-year-old victim and her family not to
report the December 2022 incident, reflecting his understanding of the consequences of a
sexual offense after his adjudication for sexual battery in June 2022. The current offense
for first degree burglary was not only a brazen, midday home invasion by Z.B. with an
accomplice, but Z.B. appeared to have prior knowledge of the victims’ home or
valuables, since he seemed to know exactly what he wanted to take, which suggested
planning. Nothing in the probation report indicated that Z.B. suffered from trauma that
made him unsuitable for a VOYA commitment. While the probation report documented
his need for and resistance to sex offender treatment, this did not negatively affect the
suitability of a VOYA commitment. To the contrary, sex offender treatment at VOYA
was more likely to be effective since Z.B. could not abscond or otherwise fail to comply
with a treatment program in that structured environment.

12
Nonetheless, Z.B. asserts that juvenile hall was meeting his treatment and security
needs and moving him to a secure youth treatment facility would traumatize him in this
“harsh and restrictive reformatory environment” where he would be exposed to “older,
more sophisticated, juveniles and ultimately impair his prospects for rehabilitation.” Z.B.
ignores the probation department’s conclusion that his current and prior crimes already
demonstrated “criminal sophistication.” Z.B. further disregards his own statements to
probation rejecting the counseling he received from December 2022 until October 2023,
which includes time when he was detained at juvenile hall. Z.B. also expressed to the
probation department that “he does not want to return to Juvenile Hall.” In short, we find
nothing in the record that indicates Z.B. would be traumatized simply by moving from
juvenile hall to VOYA or that his rehabilitation would be impaired thereby.
We find In re Carlos J. (2018) 22 Cal.App.5th 1 and In re Calvin S. (2016)
5 Cal.App.5th 522, on which Z.B. relies, inapposite. In Carlos J., the record contained
no evidence of programs available to benefit the minor in the Division of Juvenile
Justice.4 (In re Carlos J., supra, at pp. 10-12.) Here, the probation department
enumerated the programs at VOYA that would benefit Z.B. by addressing, inter alia, his
mental health, sexual behavior, academic, vocational, and reentry needs. No similar
evidence was presented in Carlos J. (Ibid.) Likewise, we are not persuaded by Z.B.’s
argument, relying on Calvin S., that the record lacks sufficient support for the juvenile
court’s determination that less restrictive alternatives would be ineffective and
inappropriate. In Calvin S., the only information in the record to support the juvenile
court’s rejection of a juvenile hall placement for the minor was “the court’s statement that

4 Division of Juvenile Justice was formerly “the state’s most restrictive placement for its
most severe juvenile offenders.” (In re Miguel C. (2021) 69 Cal.App.5th 899, 902.) The
county-level equivalent of Division of Juvenile Justice is a secure youth treatment
facility. (§§ 875, 875.5.)

13
juvenile hall is ‘not a treatment center,’ but ‘a detention center.’ ” (Calvin S., supra, at
pp. 528-529.) The appellate court concluded this was not substantial evidence to support
a finding that keeping the minor confined in juvenile hall would be ineffective or
inappropriate. (Id. at p. 528.) The circumstances here are not like those in Calvin S.
Z.B.’s record of disciplinary incidents at juvenile hall and his rejection of counseling he
was receiving in the period during which he was detained there demonstrated that
juvenile hall was not a workable alternative to the treatment and programs at VOYA.
Substantial evidence discussed above supports the court’s commitment of Z.B. to a
secure youth treatment facility. Accordingly, the juvenile court did not abuse its
discretion.
III. DISPOSITION
The disposition order is affirmed.

/S/

RENNER, J.

We concur:

/S/

EARL, P. J.

/S/

KRAUSE, J.

14

Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort

Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.