CourtListener 10283262•In re J.P. CA2/6
Gesamter Gesetzestext
Filed 11/25/24 In re J.P. CA2/6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION SIX
In re J.P., a Person Coming 2d Juv. Crim. B334423
Under the Juvenile Court Law. (Super. Ct. No. MJ23888)
(Los Angeles County)
THE PEOPLE,
Plaintiff and Respondent,
v.
J.P.,
Defendant and Appellant.
J.P. appeals an order transferring him from juvenile court
to a court of criminal jurisdiction. (Welf. & Inst. Code,1 § 707.)
We affirm.
1 All statutory references are to the Welfare and
Institutions Code.
FACTS
Underlying Offense
J.P. is a member of the South Los gang. He was in a dating
relationship with D.R. On May 24, 2021, J.P. and D.R. were at
D.R.’s home. Also there were two twin sisters who were friends
of D.R., along with two Playboy gang members. A conflict arose
between J.P. and the Playboy gang members. The sisters left.
Two days later the twin sisters were walking to a park. A
van driven by D.R. approached them at high speed. J.P. was in
the passenger seat. J.P. rolled down the window and yelled
“South Los” at the sisters. The van drove away and returned.
J.P. extended his arm out the window and fired multiple
gunshots at the sisters, striking and killing one of the sisters.
The surviving sister identified D.R. as the driver and J.P. as the
shooter. J.P. and D.R. were arrested three days later.
At the time of the shooting, J.P. was 17 years old, four
months from his 18th birthday. During the booking process, J.P.
told a detective he was not worried because he would be sent to a
juvenile camp and released when he turned 25 years old.
Juvenile Record Before the Underlying Offense
J.P. first came to the attention of the probation department
when he was 13 years old. The petition charged eight counts of
felony graffiti at three locations. At the time he was exhibiting
behavioral problems at school. In August 2017, J.P. admitted
five misdemeanors and was sent home on probation. He was
ordered to participate in substance abuse counseling, anger
management, and family therapy.
About two months later, probation filed a violation alleging
J.P. was arguing with his teacher, not reporting to probation, and
not participating in counseling. He was released on house arrest.
2
In December 2017, J.P. left home while on house arrest.
The juvenile court issued a bench warrant, and J.P. turned
himself in. He admitted a violation and was released on house
arrest about a week later. The next week J.P. left home again
and the court issued another bench warrant.
In March 2018, J.P. was placed in a program, but he left
the program without permission in April. J.P. was detained and
ordered to camp for five to seven months.
A camp progress report stated J.P. was participating in his
services but was also engaging in gang activities, including
fights. Another report stated J.P. initiated two gang-related
fights.
In November 2018, the court released J.P. from camp to his
mother. A month later J.P. ran away again and was again
detained.
While at Sylmar juvenile hall, J.P. joined with others in
doing extensive damage to the ceiling and walls by throwing
chairs and kicking doors. He also tried to assault other minors.
J.P. was six feet three inches tall, and the other minors were five
feet nine inches tall and under.
In April 2019, the juvenile court ordered that J.P. be placed
in a locked facility. While awaiting placement in the locked
facility, J.P. remained detained at juvenile hall. At juvenile hall,
J.P. caused disturbances, including an attempt to assault another
youth.
Later in April, J.P. was placed in a locked facility where he
received extensive services. J.P. continued to engage in
disturbances, including numerous instances where physical
intervention was necessary.
3
J.P. was released from the locked facility at the end of April
2020. He was again placed with his mother, but left home about
a week later. His mother stated that J.P. got physical with her
during an argument, and believed he was with his gang. J.P. was
again detained and ordered to camp.
While in camp, J.P. was charged with fighting, gang talk,
and stated he would “fuck the whole camp up.” He admitted the
violation and his camp placement was extended. He was released
from camp at the end of February 2021.
On May 18, 2021, a progress report stated that J.P. was
doing well, and recommended termination of jurisdiction. J.P.
did not appear in juvenile court that day and a bench warrant
was issued for his arrest. J.P. murdered a young girl two days
later.
Juvenile Record After Arrest for the Underlying Offense
In the 14 months between May 29, 2021, and July 28, 2022,
J.P. was involved in 117 incidents in juvenile hall. The incidents
included 12 physical altercations, gang activity, participating in
unit disturbances, threats to staff, and refusing to follow
instructions. Of the 12 fights J.P. was involved in, he was the
aggressor in 11 of them. Most, if not all of the fights, were gang
related.
The final incident in juvenile hall occurred on July 24,
2022. J.P. participated in a riot. He picked up a trash can and
hit a probation officer in the head with it. Then he joined others
in punching the officer. J.P. punched the officer in the head or
face at least once. He later pled no contest to battery against a
custodial officer and was sentenced to 16 months. Due to the
incident, J.P. was transferred to county jail.
4
Time in County Jail
J.P. made a number of telephone calls from county jail.
The calls were recorded from July 2023 to the time of the transfer
proceedings. During the calls J.P. talked about buying drugs. He
asked his sister to relay messages so that he could “keep in
contact with the hood.” Among the messages J.P. asked his sister
to relay was to tell “little Swifty” to get Serio “cause he’s a
snitch.” He told his sister to tell a contact to “Los up and stay
dangerous.” J.P. asked his sister to send him a picture of a “K-
Swiss” gang logo so he could have it tattooed on the back of his
neck. J.P. told his mother the logo stood for, “Kill a [Hoover gang
member].”
In another call, J.P. told his mother, “All the homies from
my hood are scared of me.”
J.P. told an unknown female that he got into a fight with
someone from Temple Street because he “got down with Sleepy.”
In a call with an unknown male, J.P. spoke about the gang
tattoos he got. He got an “S” on the side of his face, “South Los”
on his jaw line, and an “S” and an “L” on his legs. He said he got
a K-Swiss tattoo and a “verkillamut” tattoo. J.P. said he got
caught selling “spice.” J.P. said, “I’m a gangster fool, I had to pay
off a big ass debt.”
At times during the calls, J.P. referred to himself as
“shooter.”
A gang expert testified the calls are significant because
they show that J.P. is still committed to staying connected to the
gang. The expert said “verkillamut” is a reference to Vermont,
South Los’s main corridor. It means if the gang saw an enemy on
the gang’s turf, that person would be killed.
J.P. was found in possession of a shank in the county jail.
5
Personal History
J.P.’s aunt took custody of him from his birth mother when
he was a few days old. She formally adopted him about five years
later. He did not know he was adopted until he turned 18 years
old. J.P. refers to his aunt as his mother. J.P. has a sister who is
16 months older. He is very close to his sister.
J.P. had a normal childhood until he was eight years old
when his grandmother died. His grandmother’s death greatly
affected his mother. His mother became more focused on men
and J.P.’s relationship with his mother became strained. J.P.
describes his mother as “difficult” and “drama.”
J.P. would run away from his mother’s home and spend
time with his uncle. His uncle was a gang member and would
take drugs and get tattoos with his fellow gang members. J.P.’s
uncle did not push gangs and drugs on him, but J.P. decided he
wanted to join a gang. He did not want to join his uncle’s gang
because he wanted to make his own reputation. J.P. joined a
different gang at age 12.
Defense
Francis Guzman is an attorney and director of the National
Center of Youth Law. He has been recognized as an expert in
adolescent rehabilitation. He met with J.P. on three different
occasions.
Guzman testified that J.P. is very insightful into his
background, the issues he needs to work on, the harms he caused,
and the factors that led to his behavior. Based on J.P.’s insight,
Guzman testified that J.P. could be rehabilitated within the
juvenile court’s jurisdiction.
Monica Lujan is a licensed clinical social worker. She also
met with J.P. three times. Lujan opined that J.P. can be
6
rehabilitated before the age 25 years old because he has shown
the capacity to do well when his mental health and emotional
needs are met, and he is in a structured, safe environment.
Kurtis Miller is a probation officer and consultant for the
Secure Youth Treatment Facility (SYTF). Miller testified about
the programs available at SYTF, including a mentorship program
with formerly incarcerated persons, culinary classes, college
classes, substance abuse program, mental health, anger
management, conflict resolution, tattoo removal and gang
intervention. Miller said of SYTF, “We’re still in our infant
stages.” He was unable to say how many in the program
reoffended. The program had only been going for about six
months. They have no statistics to show how effective the
program is.
DISCUSSION
I. Section 707
Section 707, subdivision (a)(1) authorizes the district
attorney to make a motion to transfer to a court of criminal
jurisdiction a minor who is alleged to have committed an offense
listed in subdivision (b) when the minor was 16 years of age or
older. Section 707, subdivision (b)(1) lists the offense of murder.
In order to transfer the minor, the juvenile court must find
by clear and convincing evidence that the minor is not amenable
to rehabilitation while under its jurisdiction. (§ 707, subd. (a)(3).)
In making its decision the court must consider the criteria
specified in subparagraphs (A) to (E) inclusive. (Ibid.) Those
criteria are:
“(A)(i) The degree of criminal sophistication exhibited by
the minor. [¶] . . . [¶] (B)(i) Whether the minor can be
rehabilitated prior to the expiration of the juvenile court’s
7
jurisdiction. [¶] . . . [¶] (C)(i) The minor’s previous delinquent
history. [¶] . . . [¶] (D)(i) The success of previous attempts by the
juvenile court to rehabilitate the minor. [¶] . . . [¶] (E)(i) The
circumstances and gravity of the offense alleged to have been
committed by the minor.”
If the juvenile court orders a transfer of jurisdiction, the
court must recite the basis for its decision in an order entered
upon the minutes. (§ 707, subd. (a)(3).)
II. Basis of Decision Entered onto the Minutes
J.P. contends the juvenile court’s minutes do not properly
recite the basis for the court’s decision.
J.P. points out that section 707, subdivision (a)(3) requires
that if the juvenile court orders transfer of jurisdiction, the court
must recite the basis for its decision “in an order entered upon
the minutes.” J.P. does not contest that the court made a
thorough analysis of the criteria required as a basis for its
decision orally on the record. J.P.’s only complaint appears to be
that the court’s oral analysis was not reflected in the minutes.
We decline to remand the matter to the juvenile court so
that it can perform the administrative task of transferring its
oral statements into the minutes. The reason for the
requirement that the minutes reflect the basis for the decision is
to permit meaningful review. (C.S. v. Superior Court (2018) 29
Cal.App.5th 1009, 1028.) We are entirely capable of reviewing
the basis for the juvenile court’s decision from the reporter’s
transcript even if it is not reflected in the minutes. The error was
harmless by any standard.
III. Substantial Evidence
J.P. contends the juvenile court’s decision is not supported
by substantial evidence.
8
In Conservatorship of O.B. (2020) 9 Cal.5th 989, our
Supreme Court stated the standard of review for sufficiency of
the evidence is where the burden of proof is by clear and
convincing evidence. We review the record in a light most
favorable to the prevailing party. (Id. at p. 1011.) We give
deference to how the trier of fact may have evaluated the
credibility of witnesses, resolved conflicts in the evidence, and
drawn reasonable inferences from the evidence. (Id. at pp. 1011-
1012.) We must determine whether the record as a whole
contains substantial evidence from which a reasonable finder of
fact could have found it highly probable that the fact or facts
were true. (Id. at p. 1011.)
(a) Criminal Sophistication
J.P. argues that extending his arm outside a moving van
and firing multiple shots does not show criminal sophistication.
But J.P. ignores the context. The murder was not an
unthoughtful act. J.P. saw the two sisters, left the scene, armed
himself, and returned to shoot at them multiple times. It was a
willful, deliberate and premeditated murder. J.P. did not act
under the influence of drugs or alcohol. He did not suffer from
mental illness or low intelligence. He did not act under adult or
peer pressure. J.P. was entirely self-motivated. He did not show
remorse for the murder. In fact, J.P. appeared proud of what he
did, adopting the moniker “shooter” and bragging that people in
his neighborhood were afraid of him.
(b) Previous Delinquent History
J.P. has an extensive delinquent history, beginning when
he was 13 years old. It began with felony vandalism, but it
quickly escalated to violence. He initiated almost all of the
numerous fights he was involved in. The violence was against
9
minors much smaller than he was. In addition, J.P. threatened
staff, escaped, and intentionally damaged the juvenile facilities
where he was housed. Finally, J.P. committed a battery on a
peace officer. The authorities determined he was too violent to be
housed in a juvenile hall and transferred him to county jail.
The juvenile court carefully considered J.P.’s family and
community environments, and reasonably concluded his juvenile
delinquent history supported the transfer to criminal court.
(c) Previous Attempts to Rehabilitate
J.P. has received years of services, including those
addressing mental health and substance abuse. He failed to
respond positively to the extensive provision of services. If
anything, he has gotten worse. J.P. proved too violent to remain
in juvenile hall. Nothing in J.P.’s behavior indicates that the
provision of even more services will rehabilitate him within the
jurisdiction of the juvenile court.
(d) Circumstances of the Gravity of the Offense
Here the offense was an unprovoked, willful, deliberate,
and premeditated murder of an unarmed girl. Not only did J.P.
take a girl’s life, but he also placed her sister in mortal danger.
The residual effects are severe. The victim’s sister must live with
the life-long trauma of seeing her sister murdered in her
presence. The victim’s family and friends must live with a
devastating loss.
(e) Rehabilitation Prior to the Expiration of the
Juvenile Court’s Jurisdiction
The ultimate question is whether the minor is amenable to
rehabilitation while under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court.
Overwhelming evidence leads to the conclusion that he is not
amenable. He has shown no remorse or resolve to reform. To the
10
contrary, he appears proud of the murder, identifying himself as
“shooter.” He added tattoos to his body that show his willingness,
if not his eagerness, to kill again. He boasted that people in his
neighborhood are afraid of him. Juvenile authorities determined
that he is too violent to be held in juvenile hall. County jail
authorities found J.P. in possession of a shiv.
J.P.’s telephone calls from county jail show he is still deeply
involved with his gang. He shows no desire to stop or even
diminish his involvement. In fact, the name of his gang was
tattooed on his face.
Years of services have done nothing to improve J.P.’s
behavior. In fact, it has grown worse despite the services. There
is nothing to suggest that more services will be effective.
The trial court’s thorough order transferring J.P. from
juvenile court to a court of criminal jurisdiction is well supported
by clear and convincing evidence.
DISPOSITION
The judgment (order) is affirmed.
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED.
GILBERT, P. J.
We concur:
YEGAN, J.
BALTODANO, J.
11
Susan Ser, Judge
Superior Court County of Los Angeles
______________________________
Law Office of Christine M. Aros and Christine M. Aros, for
Defendant and Appellant.
Rob Bonta, Attorney General, Lance E. Winters, Chief
Assistant Attorney General, Susan Sullivan Pithey, Assistant
Attorney General, Scott A. Taryle and David E. Madeo, Deputy
Attorneys General, for Plaintiff and Respondent.
Was bedeutet dieser Text für Ihre Situation?
Kostenlose und unverbindliche Beratung
Schildern Sie uns Ihre Situation. Unser Team meldet sich per E-Mail bei Ihnen für Ihre Beratung.
Setzen Sie Ihre Recherche in ChatGPT oder Claude fort
Verbinden Sie Omnilex, um den Rechtskorpus über Ihren KI-Assistenten zu durchsuchen.